Characterization of Helicobacter pylori factors that control transformation frequency and integration length during inter-strain DNA recombination

Helicobacter pylori is a genetically diverse bacterial species, owing in part to its natural competence for DNA uptake that facilitates recombination between strains. Inter-strain DNA recombination occurs during human infection and the H. pylori genome is in linkage equilibrium worldwide. Despite this high propensity for DNA exchange, little is known about the factors that limit the extent of recombination during natural transformation. Here, we identify restriction-modification (R-M) systems as a barrier to transformation with homeologous DNA and find that R-M systems and several components of the recombination machinery control integration length. Type II R-M systems, the nuclease nucT and resolvase ruvC reduced integration length whereas the helicase recG increased it. In addition, we characterized a new factor that promotes natural transformation in H. pylori, dprB. Although free recombination has been widely observed in H. pylori, our study suggests that this bacterium uses multiple systems to limit inter-strain recombination.     

Helicobacter pylori interstrain restriction-modification diversity prevents genome subversion by chromosomal DNA from competing strains

Helicobacter pylori, bacteria that colonize the human gastric mucosa, possess a large number of genes for restriction-modification (R-M) systems, and essentially, every strain possesses a unique complement of functional and partial R-M systems. Nearly half of the H.pylori strains studied possess an active type IIs R-M system, HpyII, with the recognition sequence GAAGA. Recombination between direct repeats that flank the R-M cassette allows for its deletion whereas strains lacking hpyIIRM can acquire this cassette through natural transformation. We asked whether strains lacking HpyII R-M activity can acquire an active hpyIIRM cassette [containing a 1.4 kb kanamycin resistance (aphA) marker], whether such acquisition is DNase sensitive or resistant and whether restriction barriers limit acquisition of chromosomal DNA. Our results indicate that natural transformation and conjugation-like mechanisms may contribute to the transfer of large (4.8 kb) insertions of chromosomal DNA between H.pylori strains, that inactive or partial R-M systems can be reactivated upon recombination with a functional allele, consistent with their being contingency genes, and that H.pylori R-M diversity limits acquisition of chromosomal DNA fragments of ≥1 kb.     

Isolation and characterization of a HpyC1I restriction-modification system in Helicobacter pylori

Using transposon shuttle mutagenesis, we identified six Helicobacter pylori mutants from the NTUH-C1 strain that exhibited decreased adherence and cell elongation. Inverse polymerase chain reaction and DNA sequencing revealed that the same locus was interrupted in these six mutants. Nucleotide and amino acid sequences showed no homologies with H. pylori 26695 and J99 strains. This novel open reading frame contained 1617 base pairs. The amino acid sequence shared 24% identity with a putative nicking enzyme in Bacillus halodurans and 23 and 20% identity with type IIS restriction endonucleases PleI and MlyI, respectively. The purified protein, HpyC1I, showed endonuclease activity with the recognition and cleavage site 5'-CCATC(4/5)-3'. Two open reading frames were located upstream of the gene encoding HpyC1I. Together, HpyC1I and these two putative methyltransferases (M1.HpyC1I and M2.HpyC1I) function as a restriction-modification (R-M) system. The HpyC1I R-M genes were found in 9 of the 15 H. pylori strains tested. When compared with the full genome, significantly lower G + C content of HpyC1I R-M genes implied that these genes might have been acquired by horizontal gene transfer. Plasmid DNA transformation efficiencies and chromosomal DNA digestion assays demonstrated protection from HpyC1I digestion by the R-M system. In conclusion, we have identified a novel R-M system present in approximately 60% of H. pylori strains. Disruption of this R-M system results in cell elongation and susceptibility to HpyC1I digestion.     

Restriction-modification system differences in Helicobacter pylori are a barrier to interstrain plasmid transfer

Helicobacter pylori cells are naturally competent for the uptake of both plasmid and chromosomal DNA. However, we demonstrate that there are strong barriers to transformation of H. pylori strains by plasmids derived from unrelated strains. We sought to determine the molecular mechanisms underlying these barriers. Transformation efficiency was assessed using pHP1, an Escherichia coli-H. pylori shuttle vector conferring kanamycin resistance. Transformation of 33 H. pylori strains was attempted with pHP1 purified from either E. coli or H. pylori, and was successfully introduced into only 11 strains. Digestion of H. pylori chromosomes with different restriction endonucleases (REs) showed that DNA methylation patterns vary substantially among strains. The strain most easily transformed, JP26, was found to have extremely low endogenous RE activity and to lack a restriction-modification (R-M) system, homologous to MboI, which is highly conserved among H. pylori strains. When we introduced this system to JP26, pHP1 from MboI.M+ JP26, but not from wild-type JP26, transformed MboI R-M+ JP26 and heterologous MboI R-M+ wild-type H. pylori strains. Parallel studies with pHP1 from dam+ and dam- E. coli strains confirmed these findings. These data indicate that the endogenous REs of H. pylori strains represent a critical barrier to interstrain plasmid transfer among H. pylori.     

BstNI同功酶限制—修饰系统基因的表达检测和定位分析

鉴定了Ｅ．ｃｏｌｉ ＨＢ１０１和ＪＭ１１０的部分遗传标记,作为受体菌分别用于ＢｓｔＮＩ同功酶限制－修饰系统中限制性内切酶（Ｒ）基因和甲基化酶（Ｍ）基因表达的检测。用外切酶Ⅲ单向删切含Ｒ－Ｍ基因的ＤＮＡ片段,获得２３个缺失突变亚克隆。通过检测各亚克隆表达的Ｒ酶和Ｍ酶活性,将Ｒ和Ｍ基因分别定位在距克隆位点ＰｓｔＩ和０．２→１．４ｋｂ和１．５→３．３ｋｂ范围内。分析表明：该系统属于Ⅱ类限制－修饰系统,两     

Natural transformation of an engineered Helicobacter pylori strain deficient in type II restriction endonucleases

Restriction-modification (RM) systems are important for bacteria to limit foreign DNA invasion. The naturally competent bacterium Helicobacter pylori has highly diverse strain-specific type II systems. To evaluate the roles of strain-specific restriction in H. pylori natural transformation, a markerless type II restriction endonuclease-deficient (REd) mutant was constructed. We deleted the genes encoding all four active type II restriction endonucleases in H. pylori strain 26695 using sacB-mediated counterselection. Transformation by donor DNA with exogenous cassettes methylated by Escherichia coli was substantially (1.7 and 2.0 log(10) for cat and aphA, respectively) increased in the REd strain. There also was significantly increased transformation of the REd strain by donor DNA from other H. pylori strains, to an extent corresponding to their shared type II R-M system strain specificity with 26695. Comparison of the REd and wild-type strains indicates that restriction did not affect the length of DNA fragment integration during natural transformation. There also were no differentials in cell growth or susceptibility to DNA damage. In total, the data indicate that the type II REd mutant has enhanced competence with no loss of growth or repair facility compared to the wild type, facilitating H. pylori mutant construction and other genetic engineering.     

Context-dependent conservation of DNA methyltransferases in bacteria

DNA methytransferases (MTs) in bacteria are best understood in the context of restriction-modification (R-M) systems, which act as bacterial immune systems against incoming DNA including phages, but have also been described as selfish elements. But several orphan MTs, which are not associated with any restriction enzyme, have also been characterized and may protect against parasitism by R-M systems. The occurrence of MTs in these two contexts, namely as part of R-M systems or as orphans, is poorly understood. Here we report the results of a comparative genomic survey of DNA MTs across ～1000 bacterial genomes. We show that orphan MTs overwhelm R-M systems in their occurrence. In general, R-M MTs are poorly conserved, whereas orphans are nearly as conserved within a genus as any average gene. However, oligonucleotide usage and conservation patterns across genera suggest that both forms of MTs might have been horizontally acquired. We suggest that many orphan MTs might be 'degradation' products of R-M systems, based on the properties of orphan MTs encoded adjacent to highly diverged REs. In addition, several fully degraded R-M systems exist in which both the MT and the RE are highly divergent from their corresponding reference R-M pair. Despite their sporadic occurrence, conserved R-M systems are present in strength in two highly transformable genera, in which they may contribute to selection against integration of foreign DNA.     

Overcoming the restriction barrier to plasmid transformation of Helicobacter pylori

Helicobacter pylori strains demonstrate substantial variability in the efficiency of transformation by plasmids from Escherichia coli, and many strains are completely resistant to transformation. Among the barriers to transformation are numerous strain-specific restriction-modification systems in H. pylori. We have developed a method to protect plasmid DNA from restriction by in vitro site-specific methylation using cell-free extracts of H. pylori before transformation. In two cases, plasmid DNA treated with cell-free extracts in vitro acquired the restriction pattern characteristic of genomic DNA from the source strain. Among three strains examined in detail, the transformation frequency by treated plasmid shuttle and suicide vectors was significantly increased compared with mock-treated plasmid DNA. The results indicate that the restriction barrier in H. pylori can be largely overcome by specific DNA methylation in vitro. The approach described should significantly enhance the ability to manipulate gene function in H. pylori and other organisms that have substantial restriction barriers to transformation.     

Haemophilus influenzae phasevarions have evolved from type III DNA restriction systems into epigenetic regulators of gene expression

Phase variably expressed (randomly switching) methyltransferases associated with type III restriction-modification (R-M) systems have been identified in a variety of pathogenic bacteria. We have previously shown that a phase variable methyltransferase (Mod) associated with a type III R-M system in Haemophilus influenzae strain Rd coordinates the random switching of expression of multiple genes, and constitutes a phase variable regulon—‘phasevarion’. We have now identified the recognition site for the Mod methyltransferase in H. influenzae strain Rd as 5′-CGAAT-3′. This is the same recognition site as the previously described HinfIII system. A survey of 59 H. influenzae strains indicated significant sequence heterogeneity in the central, variable region of the mod gene associated with target site recognition. Intra- and inter-strain transformation experiments using Mod methylated or non-methylated plasmids, and a methylation site assay demonstrated that the sequence heterogeneity seen in the region encoding target site specificity does correlate to distinct target sites. Mutations were identified within the res gene in several strains surveyed indicating that Res is not functional. These data suggest that evolution of this type III R-M system into an epigenetic mechanism for controlling gene expression has, in some strains, resulted in loss of the DNA restriction function.     

Genomic methylation: a tool for typing Helicobacter pylori isolates

The genome sequences of three Helicobacter pylori strains revealed an abundant number of putative restriction and modification (R-M) systems within a small genome (1.60 to 1.67 Mb). Each R-M system includes an endonuclease that cleaves a specific DNA sequence and a DNA methyltransferase that methylates either adenosine or cytosine within the same DNA sequence. These are believed to be a defense mechanism, protecting bacteria from foreign DNA. They have been classified as selfish genetic elements; in some instances it has been shown that they are not easily lost from their host cell. Possibly because of this phenomenon, the H. pylori genome is very rich in R-M systems, with considerable variation in potential recognition sequences. For this reason the protective aspect of the methyltransferase gene has been proposed as a tool for typing H. pylori isolates. We studied the expression of H. pylori methyltransferases by digesting the genomic DNAs of 50 strains with 31 restriction endonucleases. We conclude that methyltransferase diversity is sufficiently high to enable the use of the genomic methylation status as a typing tool. The stability of methyltransferase expression was assessed by comparing the methylation status of genomic DNAs from strains that were isolated either from the same patient at different times or from different stomach locations (antrum and corpus). We found a group of five methyltransferases common to all tested strains. These five may be characteristic of the genetic pool analyzed, and their biological role may be important in the host/bacterium interaction.     

Connection between foreign DNA replication and induced expression of the restriction-modification system inStreptomyces aureofaciens

Tetracycline-producing strains ofStreptomyces aureofaciens expressedSauLPI restriction-modification (R-M) system, which recognized specific DNA sequence 5′-GCCGGC-3′ (isoschizomerNaeI). The activation of the second R-M systemSauLPII (5′-GAGCTC-3′, isoschizomer ofXhoI), which was silent during the growth cycle, after a foreign DNA transfer into this strain was observed. This phenomenon was tentatively explained as a response of the cells against the exogenous DNA entering the cells. The involvement of a SOS-like response in induction of R-M system genes inS. aureofaciens strains has been considered.     

DNA restriction-modification systems in the ethanologen, Zymomonas mobilis ZM4

To better understand the DNA restriction-modification (R-M) systems for more amenable strain development of the alternative industrial ethanologen, Zymomonas mobilis, three gene knockout mutants were constructed. The gene knockout mutants were tested for their DNA restriction activities by the determination of transformation efficiency using methylated and unmethylated foreign plasmid DNAs. Inactivation of a putative mrr gene encoded by ZMO0028 (zmrr) resulted in a 60-fold increase in the transformation efficiency when unmethylated plasmid DNA was used. This indicated that the putative mrr gene may serve as a type IV restriction-modification system in Z. mobilis ZM4. To assign the function of a putative type I DNA methyltransferase encoded by ZMO1933 (putative S subunit) and ZMO1934 (putative M subunit), the putative S subunit was inactivated. The gene inactivation of ZMO1933 resulted in a 30-fold increase in the transformation efficiency when methylated plasmid DNA was introduced, indicating that the putative S subunit possibly serves as a part of functional type I R-M system(s). Growth studies performed on the mutant strains indicate inactivation of the type I S subunit resulted in a lower maximum specific glucose consumption rate and biomass yield, while inactivation of the type IV Zmrr had the opposite effect, with an increase in the maximum specific growth rate and biomass yield.     

M.SpyI, a DNA methyltransferase encoded on a mefA chimeric element, modifies the genome of Streptococcus pyogenes

While screening the clonality of Streptococcus pyogenes isolates from an outbreak of erythromycin-resistant pharyngitis in Pittsburgh, PA, we found a correlation between the presence of the chimeric element Phi10394.4 (carrying the macrolide efflux gene, mefA) and genomic DNA being resistant to cleavage by SmaI restriction endonuclease. A search of the open reading frames in Phi10394.4 identified a putative type II restriction-modification (R-M) cassette containing a cytosine methyltransferase gene (spyIM). Heterologous expression of the cloned spyIM gene, as well as allelic-replacement experiments, showed that the action of this methyltransferase (M.SpyI) was responsible for the inhibition of SmaI digestion of genomic DNA in the Phi10394.4-containing isolates. Analysis of the methylation patterns of streptococcal genomic DNA from spyIM-positive strains, a spyIM deletion mutant, and a spyIM-negative strain determined that M.SpyI specifically recognized and methylated the DNA sequence to generate 5'-C(m)CNGG. To our knowledge, this is the first methyltransferase gene from S. pyogenes to be cloned and to have its activity characterized. These results reveal why pulsed field gel electrophoresis analysis of SmaI-digested genomic DNA cannot be used to analyze the clonality of some streptococci containing Phi10394.4 and may explain the inability of previous epidemiological studies to use SmaI to analyze DNAs from macrolide-resistant streptococci. The presence of the SpyI R-M cassette in Phi10394.4 could impart a selective advantage to host strain survival and may provide another explanation for the observed increase in macrolide-resistant streptococci.     

New restriction enzymes discovered from Escherichia coli clinical strains using a plasmid transformation method

The presence of restriction enzymes in bacterial cells has been predicted by either classical phage restriction-modification (R-M) tests, direct in vitro enzyme assays or more recently from bacterial genome sequence analysis. We have applied phage R-M test principles to the transformation of plasmid DNA and established a plasmid R-M test. To validate this test, six plasmids that contain BamHI fragments of phage lambda DNA were constructed and transformed into Escherichia coli strains containing known R-M systems including: type I (EcoBI, EcoAI, Eco124I), type II (HindIII) and type III (EcoP1I). Plasmid DNA with a single recognition site showed a reduction of relative efficiency of transformation (EOT = 10(-1)-10(-2)). When multiple recognition sites were present, greater reductions in EOT values were observed. Once established in the cell, the plasmids were subjected to modification (EOT = 1.0). We applied this test to screen E.coli clinical strains and detected the presence of restriction enzymes in 93% (14/15) of cells. Using additional subclones and the computer program, RM Search, we identified four new restriction enzymes, Eco377I, Eco585I, Eco646I and Eco777I, along with their recognition sequences, GGA(8N)ATGC, GCC(6N)TGCG, CCA(7N)CTTC, and GGA(6N)TATC, respectively. Eco1158I, an isoschizomer of EcoBI, was also found in this study.     

Differential distribution of novel restriction-modification systems in clonal lineages of Neisseria meningitidis

Using representational difference analysis, we isolated novel meningococcal restriction-modification (R-M) systems. NmeBI, which is a homologue of the R-M system HgaI of Pasteurella volantium, was present in meningococci of the ET-5 complex and of lineage III. NmeAI was found in serogroup A, ET-37 complex, and cluster A4 meningococci. NmeDI was harbored by meningococci of the ET-37 complex and of cluster A4, but not by serogroup A meningococci. Two of the R-M systems, NmeBI and NmeDI, were located at homologous positions between the phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase genes pheS and pheT, which appeared to be a preferential target for the insertion of foreign DNA in meningococci. The distribution of the three R-M systems was tested with 103 meningococcal strains comprising 49 sequence types. The vast majority of the strains had either NmeBI, NmeAI, or both NmeAI and NmeDI. Using cocultivation experiments, we could demonstrate that NmeBI, which was present in ET-5 complex meningococci, was responsible for a partial restriction of DNA transfer from meningococci of the ET-37 complex to meningococci of the ET-5 complex.     

Restriction of DNA encoding selectable markers decreases the transformation efficiency of Helicobacter pylori

Helicobacter pylori populations recovered from the human stomach display extensive recombination and quasispecies development, and this suggests frequent exchange of DNA between different strains in vivo. In vitro, however, most H. pylori strains display restriction to the uptake of non-self DNA, as measured using selectable markers, regardless of their competency for transformation with self DNA. We have examined the effect of different selectable markers on double-crossover recombination efficiencies in three reference strains (1061, 26695 & SS1) and one clinical isolate (CHP1) of H. pylori. All strains were efficiently transformable to kanamycin or chloramphenicol resistance by using self-genomic DNA from isogenic mutants bearing the aphA3 or cat cassettes, respectively. However, strains 26695 and CHP1 showed a 3-5-log reduction in transformation efficiency by non-self recombinant DNA containing aphA3, when compared to cat. Strain 1061 readily accepted either cassette, and strain SS1 was poorly tolerant of any non-self DNA. Genome-wide random mutagenesis of these strains was only achievable with a selectable marker that allowed high transformation efficiency. Digestion of 32P-labelled cassettes by H. pylori lysates mirrored the transformation results and indicated that in some strains these cassettes are the targets of enzymatic restriction.     

Different restriction and modification phenotypes in ruminal lactate-utilizing bacteria

Analysis of restriction and modification activities in lactate-utilizing bacteria belonging to the Megasphaera elsdenii and Mitsuokella multiacida species revealed the presence of GATC-specific, MboI isospecific, restriction-modification (R-M) systems in all strains tested. While restriction endonucleases isolated from M. elsdenii strains were found to be sensitive to Dam methylation, enzymes from M. multiacida cleaved DNA irrespective of Dam methylation. The comparison of type II R-M systems specificities in three closely related lactate-utilizing ruminal bacterial species indicated complete lack of restriction and/or modification enzymes previously characterized from Selenomonas ruminantium in tested M. elsdenii and M. multiacida strains. R-M systems are believed to represent the main defense tool against phage infection. Based on the results of our experiments it could be assumed that M. elsdenii and M. multiacida use the different strategy for bacteriophage protection compared to S. ruminantium.