Efficient hit-finding approaches for histone methyltransferases: the key parameters

For many novel epigenetics targets the chemical ligand space and structural information were limited until recently and are still largely unknown for some targets. Hit-finding campaigns are therefore dependent on large and chemically diverse libraries. In the specific case of the histone methyltransferase G9a, the authors have been able to apply an efficient process of intelligent selection of compounds for primary screening, rather than screening the full diverse deck of 900 000 compounds to identify hit compounds. A number of different virtual screening methods have been applied for the compound selection, and the results have been analyzed in the context of their individual success rates. For the primary screening of 2112 compounds, a FlashPlate assay format and full-length histone H3.1 substrate were employed. Validation of hit compounds was performed using the orthogonal fluorescence lifetime technology. Rated by purity and IC(50) value, 18 compounds (0.9% of compound screening deck) were finally considered validated primary G9a hits. The hit-finding approach has led to novel chemotypes being identified, which can facilitate hit-to-lead projects. This study demonstrates the power of virtual screening technologies for novel, therapeutically relevant epigenetics protein targets.     

The effect of freeze/thaw cycles on the stability of compounds in DMSO

A diverse set of 320 compounds from the Procter & Gamble Pharmaceuticals organic compound repository was prepared as 20-mM DMSO solutions and stored at 4 degrees C under argon in pressurized canisters to simulate a low-humidity environment. The plates were subjected to 25 freeze/thaw cycles while being exposed to ambient atmospheric conditions after each thaw to simulate the time and manner by which compound plates are exposed to the atmosphere during typical liquid-handling and high-throughput screening processes. High-performance liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry with evaporative light-scattering detection was used to quantitate the amount of compound remaining after every 5th freeze/thaw cycle. Control plates were stored either at room temperature under argon or at 4 degrees C under argon without freeze/thaw cycling and were evaluated at the midpoint and the endpoint of the study. The study was conducted over a short time period (i.e., 7 weeks) to minimize the effect of compound degradation over time due to the exposure of the compounds to DMSO. The results from this study will be used to determine the maximum number of freeze/thaw cycles that can be achieved while maintaining acceptable compound integrity.     

Ultra-high throughput screen of two-million-member combinatorial compound collection in a miniaturized, 1536-well assay format

Results of a complete survey of the more than 2-million-member Pharmacopeia compound collection in a 1536-well microvolume screening assay format are reported. A complete technology platform, enabling the performance of ultra-high throughput screening in a miniaturized 1536-well assay format, has been assembled and utilized. The platform consists of tools for performing microvolume assays, including assay plates, liquid handlers, optical imagers, and data management software. A fluorogenic screening assay for inhibition of a protease enzyme target was designed and developed using this platform. The assay was used to perform a survey screen of the Pharmacopeia compound collection for active inhibitors of the target enzyme. The results from the survey demonstrate the successful implementation of the ultra-high throughout platform for routine screening purposes. Performance of the assay in the miniaturized format is equivalent to that of a standard 96-well assay, showing the same dependence on kinetic parameters and ability to measure enzyme inhibition. The survey screen identified an active class of compounds within the Pharmacopeia compound collection. These results were confirmed using a standard 96-well assay.     

Screening library evolution through automation of solution preparation

The quality of the compound library is a critical success factor in every high-throughput screening campaign. Screening solutions have to be prepared with a high level of process control to ensure the correct identity and initial concentration of each compound. However, even under optimized storage conditions, a certain level of degradation in solution cannot be avoided. Therefore, regular quality control and eventual removal of solutions from the screening deck is necessary. Because solution preparation, especially the weighing of compounds, is a tedious and often manual task, a regular resolubilization of compounds is difficult to achieve. By complete automation of the solution preparation, the authors have laid the foundation for a life cycle management of screening solutions. They demonstrate how a combination of quality and process control leads to a continuous improvement of the screening library. In presenting an automation concept, they show how a series of innovative process optimizations led to a high-performance system that achieves full industrialization of solution preparation.     

RNA-based drug screening using automated RNA purification and real-time RT-PCR1

A new system has been developed for RNA-based drug screening, and the feasibility of this approach has been demonstrated by the identification of new immunomodulating compounds. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells were chosen as the cellular assay system. Cells were either stimulated by TPA/ionomycin to produce T cell cytokines as asthma targets or stimulated by lipopolysaccharide to produce proinflammatory cytokines as targets for chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). The authors developed a new fully automated system for RNA purification from cells grown in 96-well plates. Gene expression was determined in 384-well plates using real-time quantitative one-tube RT-PCR. Small interdonor variation could be demonstrated. The assay system was validated with known immunosuppressants cyclosporine and dexamethasone. Screening of 800 compounds resulted in 9.5% compounds inhibiting the induction of at least 1 T cell derived cytokine and 6.8% compounds inhibiting at least 1 cytokine relevant for COPD. All these compounds were retested by analyzing remaining RNA from the 1st round of screening. The reproducibility of hits was between 56% and 74% for different cytokines. One compound selectively inhibited TNF, which was confirmed by IC(50) determination. Analyzing its effect on cells from different donors revealed little interdonor variation. In conclusion, the authors established fully automated RNA isolation and precise gene expression profiling using real-time RT-PCR for drug screening.     

Identification of a small molecule that induces mitotic arrest using a simplified high-content screening assay and data analysis method

High-content screening has emerged as a new and powerful technique for identifying small-molecule modulators of mammalian cell biology. The authors describe the development and execution of a high-content screen to identify small molecules that induce mitotic arrest in mammalian cancer cells. Many widely used chemotherapeutics, such as Taxol and vinblastine, induce mitotic arrest, and the creation of new drugs that also induce mitotic arrest may have tremendous therapeutic value. In their screen, the authors employed a simple DNA stain (DAPI) and a sensitive nonparametric statistical test to identify compounds from an internal collection of approximately 13,000 high-quality lead-like small molecules. Subsequent analysis of 1 active compound indicated that it induces mitotic arrest, assessed using a high-content phosphohistone H3 detection assay, and caused cell proliferation defects in multiple cancer cell lines. The active compound, a quinazolinone originating from a natural product-like subset of the screened compounds, is active in cells at approximately 500 nM and appears to act by inhibiting the polymerization of tubulin.     

A method for screening bacteria: Aerobically degrading chlorinated short-chain hydrocarbons

A method for screening of short-chain chlorinated-hydrocarbon-degrading bacteria is described. It uses as a criterium for selection the liberation of protons and change in color of a pH indicator rather than growth on the compound as sole carbon source. The usefulness of indicator plates is demonstrated with several bacteria, known to degrade certain chlorinated hydrocarbons. Bacteria-degrading volatile compounds can be isolated with a medium containing a second carbon source. A correlation between proton liberation and liberation of chloride or disappearance of 2-chloroethanol from the medium is demonstrated as an example. The method should be useful in isolating bacteria for the decontamination of respective commodities.     

Compound transfer efficiency from polystyrene surfaces: application to microarrayed compound screening

In microarrayed compound screening (microARCS), compounds are spotted and dried onto a polystyrene sheet (ChemCard)ata high density and introduced into the assay by contacting with agarose gels that contain reagents for the assay. The authors have conducted studies to characterize the compound transfer process using 59 compounds of diverse properties. The amount of compounds remaining on the ChemCard was determined by liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry after incubation with agarose gels for predetermined time periods. The results showed good correlation with kinetics of compound transfer to phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) buffer, but only moderate correlation with equilibrium solubility of compounds in PBS buffer. These observations indicate that the major factor determining compound transfer efficiency is the kinetics of dissolution of compounds, rather than equilibrium solubility and diffusion of compounds in the gel. Compounds of lower ClogP showed a higher rate of transfer to agarose gels and vice versa. Other compound properties such as molecular weight, size, acid-base, and H-bonding properties did not significantly affect compound transfer. Importantly, the majority of the compounds studied show greater than 20% transfer after a 10-min incubation with agarose gels, providing sufficient amounts of compounds for screening purposes.     

Development and application of a GFP-FRET intracellular caspase assay for drug screening

Apoptosis is a crucial biological process, and activation of caspase endoproteases is essential for proper regulation and execution of apoptosis. Because caspases also appear to be central players in several pathological states, there is a practical need within the biopharmaceutical research community for facile, noninvasive cellular assays for the discovery of compounds that modulate caspase activity. Tandem molecules of green fluorescent protein (GFP) stably expressed within cells can serve as a genetically encoded sensor of protease activity. Using this technology, we have developed a stable cellular system for the screening of agents that modulate activation of the caspase cascade. This assay technology allows for the real-time monitoring of apoptosis in situ, using conventional fluorescent plate reader detection. By applying this assay system to an actual compound screen, small-molecule inducers of cell apoptosis were reliably identified. Follow-up pharmacology confirmed that the rank-order potency of primary hits using the intracellular GFP assay corresponded to that found using a conventional, cell lysis-based assay method.     

Practical approaches to efficient screening: information-rich screening protocol

The past approach of high-throughput screening of everything in the corporate collection has been shown to be very expensive in terms of reagents cost, disposal cost, and compound collection depletion. It is well known that screening campaigns produce several hits, of which only 50% confirm on average. More efficient ways of screening can provide an informative structure-activity relationship (SAR), which in turn can be used to build mathematical models for further probing the activity space and directing chemical synthesis. The authors report new methods and insights to extract the maximum possible information from a screening experiment and find most of the possible hits in the corporate collection while screening as few compounds as possible.     

A system for performing high throughput assays of synaptic function

Unbiased, high-throughput screening has proven invaluable for dissecting complex biological processes. Application of this general approach to synaptic function would have a major impact on neuroscience research and drug discovery. However, existing techniques for studying synaptic physiology are labor intensive and low-throughput. Here, we describe a new high-throughput technology for performing assays of synaptic function in primary neurons cultured in microtiter plates. We show that this system can perform 96 synaptic vesicle cycling assays in parallel with high sensitivity, precision, uniformity, and reproducibility and can detect modulators of presynaptic function. By screening libraries of pharmacologically defined compounds on rat forebrain cultures, we have used this system to identify novel effects of compounds on specific aspects of presynaptic function. As a system for unbiased compound as well as genomic screening, this technology has significant applications for basic neuroscience research and for the discovery of novel, mechanism-based treatments for central nervous system disorders.     

Just-in-time purification: an effective solution for cherry-picking and purifying active compounds from large legacy libraries

Many companies possess a compound collection consisting of purified compounds and of unpurified products from combinatorial libraries. Using commercial and proprietary compounds as examples, this report provides clear examples of the significant impact purification can have on the activity observed for a compound and highlights the need to retest the purified compounds prior to creating structure-activity relationships. Crude mixtures made with commercial compounds led to an increase in the number of false positives in the SXR-GAL4 assay as compared with their pure and purified counterparts. An examination of proprietary compounds in an HIV assay resulted in the purification of 61 active crude synthetic mixtures. Of these 61 compounds, 32 were 5-fold less active and 2 were 5-fold more active after purification. This report details a semiautomated process developed and implemented for cherry-picking, tracking, and selectively purifying compounds found active in high-throughput screening campaigns.     

High-throughput screening for antimicrobial compounds using a 96-well format bacterial motility absorbance assay

There is a pressing need to develop new antimicrobial drugs because of the increasing resistance of pathogenic bacteria to existing antibiotics. The preliminary development and validation of a novel methodology for the high-throughput screening of antimicrobial compounds and inhibitors of bacterial motility is described. This method uses a bacterial motility swarming agar assay, combined with the use of offset inoculation of the wells in a standard, clear, 96-well plate, to enable rapid screening of compounds for potential antibiotic and antimotility properties with a standard absorbance microplate reader. Thus, the methodology should be compatible with 96-well laboratory automation technology used in drug discovery and chemical biology studies. To validate the screening method, the Genesis Plus structurally diverse library of 960 biologically active compounds was screened against a motile strain of the gram-negative bacterial pathogen Salmonella typhimurium. The average Z' value for the positive and negative motility controls on all 12 compound plates was 0.67 +/- 0.14, and the signal-to-baseline ratio calculated from the positive and negative controls was 5.9 +/- 1.1. A collection of 70 compounds with well-known antimicrobial properties was successfully identified using this assay.     

Application of a homogenous membrane potential assay to assess mitochondrial function

Decreases in mitochondrial membrane potential (MMP) have been associated with mitochondrial dysfunction that could lead to cell death. The MMP is generated by an electrochemical gradient via the mitochondrial electron transport chain coupled to a series of redox reactions. Measuring the MMP in living cells is commonly used to assess the effect of chemicals on mitochondrial function; decreases in MMP can be detected using lipophilic cationic fluorescent dyes. To identify an optimal dye for use in a high-throughput screening (HTS) format, we compared the ability of mitochondrial membrane potential sensor (Mito-MPS), 5,5',6,6'-tetrachloro-1,1',3,3' tetraethylbenzimidazolylcarbocyanine iodide, rhodamine 123, and tetramethylrhodamine to quantify a decrease in MMP in chemically exposed HepG2 cells cultured in 1,536-well plates. Under the conditions used, the optimal dye for this purpose is Mito-MPS. Next, we developed and optimized a homogenous cell-based Mito-MPS assay for use in 1,536-well plate format and demonstrated the utility of this assay by screening 1,280 compounds in the library of pharmacologically active compounds in HepG2 cells using a quantitative high-throughput screening platform. From the screening, we identified 14 compounds that disrupted the MMP, with half-maximal potencies ranging from 0.15 to 18 μM; among these, compound clusters that contained tyrphostin and 3'-substituted indolone analogs exhibited a structure-activity relationship. Our results demonstrate that this homogenous cell-based Mito-MPS assay can be used to evaluate the ability of large numbers of chemicals to decrease mitochondrial function.     

High-throughput receptor-binding methods for somatostatin receptor 2

Three high-throughput screening methods for quantitating 125I-SS14 binding to human somatostatin receptor 2 (hSST2) have been developed. Microplate-based separation assays were performed in Packard Unifilter and Millipore Multiscreen plates. A homogeneous ligand-binding assay was developed by employing wheat germ agglutinin (WGA)-coated Flashplates. Apparent dissociation constants for 125I-SS14 binding to hSST2 were obtained with each method. IC(50) values were determined for 12 compounds using each of the methods. Similar IC(50) values were obtained for each compound with all of the methods. The WGA-Flashplate is suitable for fully automated high-throughput screening whereas the Unifilter and Multiscreen methods are more suitable for semiautomated and manual screening applications.     

Dissimilarity-based approaches to compound acquisition

The concept of molecular diversity has been integrated in drug discovery efforts for many years. Applications of molecular diversity have been used to identify compounds for screening and to select compounds to augment proprietary collections. These early efforts were crude and suffered from a number of faults, but their evolution has, over the years, led to an improvement in the computational procedures used to identify new commercial compounds for acquisition. Although not much has recently been written about modern methods for augmenting compound collections, this activity is still a very relevant and important task to those involved with the development of compound collections. This review focuses on the process and software used to identify compounds deemed worthy of acquisition.     

Hole filling and library optimization: Application to commercially available fragment libraries

Compound libraries comprise an integral component of drug discovery in the pharmaceutical and biotechnology industries. While in-house libraries often contain millions of molecules, this number pales in comparison to the accessible space of drug-like molecules. Therefore, care must be taken when adding new compounds to an existing library in order to ensure that unexplored regions in the chemical space are filled efficiently while not needlessly increasing the library size. In this work, we present an automated method to fill holes in an existing library using compounds from an external source and apply it to commercially available fragment libraries. The method, called Canvas HF, uses distances computed from 2D chemical fingerprints and selects compounds that fill vacuous regions while not suffering from the problem of selecting only compounds at the edge of the chemical space. We show that the method is robust with respect to different databases and the number of requested compounds to retrieve. We also present an extension of the method where chemical properties can be considered simultaneously with the selection process to bias the compounds toward a desired property space without imposing hard property cutoffs. We compare the results of Canvas HF to those obtained with a standard sphere exclusion method and with random compound selection and find that Canvas HF performs favorably. Overall, the method presented here offers an efficient and effective hole-filling strategy to augment compound libraries with compounds from external sources. The method does not have any fit parameters and therefore it should be applicable in most hole-filling applications.     

Rapid Screening of Antimicrobial Synthetic Peptides

Increasing resistance to conventional antibiotics among microorganisms is one of the leading problems of medicine nowadays. Antimicrobial peptides are compounds exhibiting both antibacterial and antifungal activities. However, it is difficult to predict whether a designed new compound would exhibit any biological activity. Moreover, purification of the peptides is one of the most time-consuming and expensive steps of the synthesis that sometimes leads to unnecessary loss of solvents and reagents. In our study we have developed a thin-layer chromatography (TLC) direct bioautography technique for rapid determination of antimicrobial activity of peptides without the necessity of high-performance liquid chromatography purification. In this assay, crude peptides were applied and separated on a TLC plate. Then, pre-prepared plates were dipped into microbial suspension and incubated under optimum conditions for bacteria and fungi as well. The activity of the tested compounds was visualized by spraying the TLC plates with a cell viability reagent, resazurin (7-hydroxy-3H-phenoxazin-3-one 10-oxide). Effectiveness of this assay was compared with minimal inhibitory concentration results obtained by broth microdilution assay. Interestingly, so far such a screening method has not been applied for this group of compounds.     

Affinity ligand selection from a library of small molecules: assay development, screening, and application

A facile and cost-effective process for screening synthetic libraries for an affinity ligand is described. A high throughput 96-well plate filtration method was designed to screen both discrete compounds and mixtures of compounds attached to a solid support. Human serum albumin (HSA) was used as a target protein to demonstrate the proof of concept. Detection and quantitation by fluorescence was accomplished with the use of fluorescamine to conjugate the protein in the filtrate. It is found that mixtures demonstrating low average binding reflect an overall lower hit rate of the components, whereas deconvolution of mixtures with high protein binding consistently provides a high hit rate. This differs from many of the previous experiences screening solid-phase mixtures in which high false positive rates are noted to occur. A total of 100K compounds were tested: 25K as discrete samples and 75K as mixtures. An overall hit rate of 8% was observed. Secondary screening of compounds measured specificity, recovery, and dynamic binding capacity. The effectiveness of the method is illustrated using an affinity column made with a representative lead compound. A similar purity was achieved in a single-step purification of HSA from serum as compared to that obtained by two steps of ion-exchange chromatography. The process for primary screening of a large number of compounds is simple, inexpensive, and applicable to any soluble target protein of known or unknown function from crude mixtures and may have additional utility as a generic chemical affinity tool for the functional characterization of novel proteins emerging from proteomics work.