Integration of Deoxyribonuclease-Treated DNA in Bacillus subtilis Transformation

Normal preparations of B. subtilis DNA have weight average native molecular weights of 10 to 30 x 10⁶. For any given preparation the upper and lower 95% size limits may differ by a factor of ten or more. Single-stranded molecular weights indicate an average of 1 to 4 breaks per single strand of the native DNA. The reduction in transforming activity and viscosity following DNAase I digestion can be accounted for by a direct relationship between the transforming activity of a DNA and its single-stranded molecular weight. Uptake studies with DNAase I treated heavy (²H¹⁵N ³H) DNA show that single strand breaks inhibit integration less than transformation. A provisional estimate of the size of the integrated region based on correlating the single strand size of the donor-recipient complex with the donor-recipient density differences following alkali denaturation came to 1530 nucleotides. Using a competent, nonleaky thymine-requiring strain of B. subtilis grown in 5-BU medium before and after transformation, it was shown that (a) No detectable amount of DNA synthesis is necessary for the initial stages of integration, (b) Cells which have recently been replicating DNA are not competent. (c) Cells containing donor DNA show a lag in DNA replication following transformation, (d) When donor DNA is replicated it initially appears in a density region between light and hybrid. This indicates that it includes the transition point formed at the time of reinitiation of DNA synthesis in the presence of 5-BU following transformation. A model is proposed in which donor DNA is integrated at the stationary growing point of the competent cell, which is in a state of suspended DNA synthesis.     

Integration of donor DNA in bacterial conjugation

Conjugation between ¹³C¹⁵N- and ³H-labelled hybrid donors and ¹³C¹⁵N-labelled hybrid recipients of Escherichia coli gives rise to recombinant radioactive DNA of density greater than labelled hybrid. The donor radioactivity is present, in these molecules, in discrete heavy segments covalently attached to the light strand. When light radioactive Hfr cells are mated to heavy F^? cells in light medium, the donor label appears, in DNA extracted from the F^? cells, in labelled hybrid molecules. The radioactivity in these molecules is exclusively in the light strand. The insertion of donor material is thus restricted to a single newly formed strand of the recipient DNA and double-strand integrations do not occur. A temperature-sensitive recipient containing the dna B mutation ts₄₃ accumulates single-stranded Hfr DNA if mating is carried out at the nonpermissive temperature. The formation of a complementary strand in the recipient does not, therefore, appear to be necessary for continued transfer of Hfr DNA.     

The integration of donor and recipient deoxyribonucleic acid during transformation of Bacillus subtilis

1. DNA labelled with 5-bromo[(3)H]uracil was used to transform auxotrophic strains of Bacillus subtilis. 2. After various times of incubation, DNA was extracted from the transformed culture and subjected to equilibrium sedimentation in caesium chloride gradients. 3. In addition to heavy donor DNA and light recipient DNA, a component with an intermediate density was found and is believed to consist of a biological hybrid of donor and recipient. 4. The component of intermediate density was isolated and found to possess activity in transformation derived from both donor and recipient strains. 5. Denaturation of the component of intermediate density followed by centrifugation gave only one component, indicating that integration had occurred in both strands of the recipient DNA. 6. No integrated band was observed after uptake by competent cells of B. subtilis of heavy DNA prepared from Escherichia coli.     

Competence Mutant of Haemophilus influenzae with Abnormal Ratios of Marker Efficiencies in Transformation

In studies of competence-deficient mutants of Haemophilus influenzae which absorb deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) but fail to produce transformants, it was observed that in some mutants the residual transforming activity for different markers varied widely, i.e., produced a ratio effect. One of these mutants, com⁻⁵⁶, was studied intensively to determine the cause of the residual efficiency of transformation and the reason for the ratio effect. The residual frequency of transformation was higher for markers considered single-site mutations (like naladixic acid resistance), whereas the least efficient markers tested were those conferring resistance to high levels of streptomycin or novobiocin which are more complex than single-site mutations. Measurement of frequencies of cotransformation indicated that overall genetic linkage was reduced. Transfection was fairly efficient with phage S2 DNA, but not prophage DNA. Donor marker activity could be detected in transformed cell lysates, but not linked to recipient markers in recombinant molecules. Sucrose gradient analysis of such lysates revealed that donor material was associated with recipient DNA in at least normal quantities, but lacked detectable genetic activity. Material from donor DNA labeled with heavy isotopes was incorporated into recipient chromosomal fragments having a density indistinguishable from normal density, unlike the hybrid density recombinant material found in normal cells. No excessive solubilization or nicking of unincorporated donor was detected. It is postulated that this strain contains a hyperactive nuclease, which reduces the effective size of the input DNA during the integration process.     

An unstable donor-recipient DNA complex in transformation of Bacillus subtilis.

Summary In re-extracted DNA obtained shortly after uptake of transforming DNA by Bacillus subtilis, increased amounts of donor DNA radioactivity banding at the position of donor-recipient DNA complex (DRC) are observed in CsCl gradients, if the cells are irradiated with high doses of UV prior to reextraction of the DNA. Qualitatively, the same phenomenon is observed if lysates of transforming cells are irradiated. UV-irradiation of lysates of competent cells to which single-stranded DNA is added after lysis, does not result in linkage of this DNA to the chromosomal DNA. Two observations argue in favour of the formation of a specific labile complex between donor and resident DNA during transformation. Firstly, heterologous donor DNA from Escherichia coli, although being processed to single-stranded DNA in competent B. subtilis, does not seem to be linked to the recipient chromosome upon UV-irradiation, and secondly, the labile complex of donor and recipient DNA can be stabilized by means of treatment of the lysates of transforming cells with 4, 5¹, 8-trimethylpsoralen in conjuction with long-wave ultra violet light irradiation. This indicates that base-pairing is involved in the formation of the complex. On the basis of these results we assume that the unstable complex of donor and recipient DNA is an early intermediate in genetic recombination during transformation.     

Plasmid marker rescue transformation proceeds by breakage-reunion in Bacillus subtilis.

Bacillus subtilis carrying a plasmid which replicates with a copy number of about 1 was transformed with linearized homologous plasmid DNA labeled with the heavy isotopes 2H and 15N, in the presence of 32Pi and 6-(p-hydroxyphenylazo)-uracil to inhibit DNA replication. Plasmid DNA was isolated from the transformed culture and fractionated in cesium chloride density gradients. The distribution of total and donor plasmid DNA was examined, using specific hybridization probes. The synthesis of new DNA, associated with the integration of donor moiety, was also monitored. Donor-specific sequences were present at a density intermediate between that of light and hybrid DNA. This recombinant DNA represented 1.4% of total plasmid DNA. The latter value corresponded well with the transforming activity (1.7%) obtained for the donor marker. Newly synthesized material associated with plasmid DNA at the recombinant density amounted to a minor portion of the recombinant plasmid DNA. These data suggest that, like chromosomal transformation, plasmid marker rescue transformation does not require replication for the integration of donor markers and, also like chromosomal transformation, proceeds by a breakage-reunion mechanism. The extent of donor DNA replacement of recipient DNA per plasmid molecule of 54 kilobases (27 kilobase pairs) was estimated as 16 kilobases.     

Single-stranded conjugation in Escherichia coli K-12

Summary The mutation BT43 in the gene dnaB leads to the inhibition of vegetative and conjugational DNA synthesis at 42°. The consequences in case of conjugation are very unusual. The fragment of donor DNA tramsmitted to the recipient cell remains single-stranded and is integrated as such into the recipient chromosome similar to the main events during transformation. We call this process single-stranded (SS) conjugation.The evidence for this statement comes from the measurement of the time of expression of the gene tsx, containing the genetic information for the receptor of phage T6. The gene tsx is introduced into a dnaBT43 recipient cell alternatively by two different donors Hfr H and Hfr C, which are characterized by opposite directions of transfer. Therefore both donors introduce into the recipient cell alternatively the informational or noninformational DNA strand. If conjugation is performed at a nonpermissive temperature, the transferred DNA piece remains single-stranded and is integrated as such into the recipient chromosome. If it is the informational strand (case of Hfr H), it is transcribed very fast and yields the protein in question in about 20 min. If the noninformational strand is integrated (Hfr C) about 40 min additional time is required to effect cell division.SS-conjugation is very sensitive to the action of exonucleases Exo I and Exo V and is much enhanced in the absence of both nucleases in the recipient.The exogenous DNA pieces are integrated as short insertions, this leads to the disjoining of linked markers and to a very short scale of the genetic map. Because the donor DNA undergoes recombination in the single-stranded state heteroduplex regions originate which are subsequently corrected by the enzymes of the recipient cell. The situation leads to a very special but predictable heterogeneity of the progeny of transconjugants.The fact of the existence of this special process, SS-conjugation, drastically different from common conjugation in many respects, suggests that common conjugation leads to the integration of double-stranded DNA pieces into the recipient chromosome.     

Deoxyribonucleate Binding and Transformation in Rhizobium japonicum

Rhizobium japonicum, capable of binding high-molecular-weight donor (32)P-labeled deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) during late log phase in a competence medium, was transformed for streptomycin resistance with a frequency of transformation ranging between 0.02 and 0.08%. Eight to 10% of the homologous native (32)P-labeled input DNA was bound irreversibly in a temperature-dependent manner. Homologous denatured (32)P-labeled DNA was incapable of binding to the recipient under similar conditions. CsCl density gradient banding of the donor and recipient DNA indicated homology. The low frequency of transformation could be due to one or more steps that occur between DNA uptake and integration.     

Heterospecific transformation of Pneumococcus and Streptococcus

Summary Transformations of two linked ribosomal loci (str and ery) were carried out between the SIII-1 strain of pneumococcus and the Challis and SBE strains of group H streptococcus. Transfer of markers between the Challis and SBE strains is as efficient as in the corresponding intrastrain transformations. Transfer between either of these strains and the pneumococcus, however, is less efficient than in the corresponding intrastrain transformation, and is referred to as heterospecific transformation. The inefficiency of the heterospecific transformation is due neither to specific lethality nor reduced uptake of heterologous DNA.When DNA was extracted from the hybrid resulting from a heterospecific cross and used to transform the original donor and recipient species, we found: (a) no donor material in the hybrid DNA responsible for the markedly low efficiency of integration into the recipient species; (b) donor material, in addition to the transforming marker itself, detectable by the higher efficiency with which hybrid DNA transforms the original donor species than does DNA from the original recipient species.DNA was extracted from each of 36 independently derived, doubly marked transformants resulting from the cross: Challis str-s ery-sxSIII-1 str-r53 ery-r2 DNA. Variability was observed between the different hybrid DNAs when the integration efficiency of the str marker in each DNA was compared with that of the ery marker. Variability of as great a magnitude was not observed when the same hybrid DNA was tested in repeated experiments, or when different DNA preparations were extracted from the same hybrid strain, or when several DNA preparations were obtained from a number of independent homospecific transformants. It is concluded that different kinds of donor material are present in the various hybrids, and that the nature of this extra-marker material affects the integration of the marker.Linkage of the str and ery markers was reduced in heterospecific transformations. The kind of donor DNA in the hybrid genome did not affect the linkage reduction observed when the str and ery markers were transferred back to the donor species in which they originated. Indeed, this linkage reduction was the same as that observed when the markers were originally transferred from the SIII-1 to the Challis strain. Specific factors reducing linkage in heterologous crosses must, therefore, be distinct from other factors which affect integration efficiency. The former, however, may be primarily responsible for the inefficiency of heterospecific transformation.One of the hybrid DNAs was used to obtain a second generation of hybrids by passing it through each of the original parental strains. Tests of the DNAs extracted from 24 independently produced, second-generation hybrids showed that hybrid DNA is subject to further alteration by a second integration involving some heterologous confrontation. The probability of such alteration appears to be increased if the second integration is accompanied by linkage reduction.Supported by NIH grant AI-00917.     

Mechanism of transformation in B. subtilis

Summary Transformation in B. subtilis is achieved by the uptake of donor DNA into recipient cells and the integration of part of this donor DNA into the host chromosome. The evidence presented in this report is interpreted to indicate that donor double helical DNA, on entry into host cells is rapidly membrane bound and can remain in this state for a consicerable time, perhaps even until integration. This bound DNA consists of molecules which have been reduced in size and degraded on uptake, and appear as partially single-stranded molecules. It is suggested that the donor DNA initially forms single strands which rapidly assume a partially single stranded nature by association with the host DNA or by reannealing.Host cells, by virtue of the competent state, possess temporarily, and prior to the addition of donor DNA, chromosomes with single-stranded gaps. It is likely that such gaps are larger than the single-stranded segments of donor DNA which are to be integrated. Results are described which are best explained if integration is achieved by an initial annealing between the single-stranded donor and host segments followed by their covalent linkage.     

On the Mechanism of Integration of Transforming Deoxyribonucleate

The characteristics of the intermediates in the reaction, between DNA and pneumococcus, that results in genetic transformation are described in so far as they have been characterized. Transformation with DNA isolated from bacteria carrying in addition to genetic markers ³²P as a radioactive label and ²H and ¹⁵N as density labels has permitted the characterization of the product of recombination between the newly introduced DNA and the DNA of a recipient bacterium. The evidence for a single strand displacement mechanism producing a hybrid structure in the DNA of the recipient bacteria is presented. Progeny of single transformants have been examined. The results of these segregation studies permit the further characterization of this hybrid product of transformation as a genetically heterozygous structure.     

Molecular Fate of Heterologous Bacterial DNA in Competent BACILLUS SUBTILIS. I. Processing of B. PUMILUS and B. LICHENIFORMIS DNA in B. SUBTILIS

Competent Bacillus subtilis cells were exposed to radioactive and density labeled donor DNA extracted from B. pumilus and B. licheniformis. The DNA from these strains hybridized with B. subtilis DNA in vitro at a rate of 24% and 11%, respectively. After entry the vast majority of heterologous DNA was found at the single-strand DNA position in CsCl gradients, and was gradually degraded during incubation. Much less donor DNA than expected from the hybridization values participated in the formation of the donorrecipient complex (DRC). By subjecting the heterologous DRC to sonication and alkaline CsCl gradient centrifugation, it was established that the DRC consisted of three components: (1) recipient DNA in which breakdown products of donor DNA were incorporated through DNA synthesis, (2) recipient DNA in which donor DNA was covalently integrated and (3) recipient DNA in which the donor moiety was not covalently integrated.     

Characteristics of a complex formed by a nonintegrated fraction of transforming DNA and Bacillus subtilis recipient cell constituents.

Summary Nonintegrated transforming DNA was isolated from recipient cell lysates as a complex with cellular constituents (natural complex) and separated from free proteins on CsCl density gradients. Sensitivity of DNA in this complex to digestion with endonuclease S₁, liberation of denatured donor molecules by treatment of the cell lysates with phenol, as well as previously described liberation of single-stranded donor DNA by heating with detergents, pointed to the single-stranded nature of the donor DNA in the complex. About 1% of radioactive leucine or phenylalamine incorporated to cellular proteins were detected in the natural complex, with two associated enzymatic activities: one autolytic, the other endonucleolytic. The autolytic activity, known to be localized mainly in the cell wall and the endonucleolytic one, similar to the enzyme localized in cell membrane and periplasmic space of B. subtilis, suggest that donor DNA is complexed with a cell wall and/or a cell membrane fragment. Consideration of several characteristics of the natural complex: its density, protein content, and partial resistance of its DNA to DNase I, point to partial shielding of donor DNA in the cell fragment structure, and existence of a portion in a free uncovered form. Considerations on the possible role of the two enzymatic activities were based on the fact that they were not found in the complex formed by denatured DNA added to cells before lysis (reconstruction complex), and on hypotheses of their possible physioligical role.Part of the above results was presented in preliminary form at the Third European Meeting on Bacterial Transformation and Transfection, Granada, Spain, August 31–September 3, 1976     

Novel recA-Independent Horizontal Gene Transfer in Escherichia coli K-12

In bacteria, mechanisms that incorporate DNA into a genome without strand-transfer proteins such as RecA play a major role in generating novelty by horizontal gene transfer. We describe a new illegitimate recombination event in Escherichia coli K-12: RecA-independent homologous replacements, with very large (megabase-length) donor patches replacing recipient DNA. A previously uncharacterized gene (yjiP) increases the frequency of RecA-independent replacement recombination. To show this, we used conjugal DNA transfer, combining a classical conjugation donor, HfrH, with modern genome engineering methods and whole genome sequencing analysis to enable interrogation of genetic dependence of integration mechanisms and characterization of recombination products. As in classical experiments, genomic DNA transfer begins at a unique position in the donor, entering the recipient via conjugation; antibiotic resistance markers are then used to select recombinant progeny. Different configurations of this system were used to compare known mechanisms for stable DNA incorporation, including homologous recombination, F’-plasmid formation, and genome duplication. A genome island of interest known as the immigration control region was specifically replaced in a minority of recombinants, at a frequency of 3 X 10^-12 CFU/recipient per hour.     

A competence specific inducible protein promotes in vivo recombination in Streptococcus sanguis

Summary We describe the first example of a recombination-specific protein induced during the development of competence for transformation in Streptococcus sanguis. Elaborated in response to stimulation by competence-protein, the 51,000 Molecular Weight (MW) polypeptide is one of at least 10 new polypeptides transiently induced during the competence phase. Biochemical and genetic analyses of the parental, cipA⁺ (competence specific inducible polypeptide A), and mutant, cipA, strains have shown that the 51,000 MW polypeptide has two roles: its low level constitutive synthesis is required for repair of damage to DNA due to UV light and methylmethane sulfonate; its induced synthesis (3–6x10⁴ copies/cell) during the competence phase is essential for promoting recombination between donor single-stranded DNA and the recipient chromosome. Also, ccc plasmid donor DNA transformation, which occurs as a decreasing probability of the increasing donor plasmid MW, requires the inducible function specified by the 51,000 MW polypeptide. The MW independent low level transformation with ccc plasmids, the inheritance of plasmids by conjugation, and the stable maintenance of plasmids introduced by transformation and conjugation, respectively, are independent of the function specified by the 51,000 MW polypeptide.     

Transforming activity of phage T4r+ DNA, treated with ultraviolet light, nitrous acid, hydroxylamine and visible light in the presence of methylene blue]

The efficiency of phages T4rIIB-638v+ and T4rIIB-638v- transformation by native and denatured DNA treated with UV, nitrous acid, hydroxylamine and visible light in the presence of methylene blue is studied. A greater transformation efficiency of UV-irradiated T4r+ phage native and denatured DNA was observed in the v+ recipient as compared with v- recipients. Denatured donor DNA treated with nitrous acid has higher transformation activity in spheroplasts infected with T4v+ phage than in those infected with T4v- phage. Native donor DNA, treated with methylene blue and visible light-irradiated, developed a decrease of the transformation activity in T4v- phage-infected spheroplasts as compared with T4v+ phage-infected spheroplasts. Hydroxylamine treatment of native and denatured donor DNA did not reveal any differences in the transforming activity for v+ and v- recipients. Denatured donor DNA was more resistant to the effect of hydroxylamine than native DNA.     

Fate of transforming DNA following uptake by competent Bacillus subtilis

Summary During transformation in Bacillus subtilis, donor and recipient DNA are initially associated by non-covalent bonds. The donor and recipient moieties later become covalently joined. The molecular weight of the donor component, when freed from the noncovalent complex by sucrose gradient sedimentation under alkaline conditions, ranges from 1 to 5×10⁶, with an average of about 2.5 to 3.0×10⁶. The latter values are in good agreement with previous measurements of the size of the integrated donor fragment.     

Genetic Studies of Recombining DNA in Pneumococcal Transformation

The results of genetic fine structure experiments, performed on the amiA locus of Pneumococcus are summarized. The peculiar feature of transformation genetics is that a given donor marker mutation transforms with an efficiency characteristic of the mutated site. In spite of this difficulty, mapping procedures have been devised and quantitative recombination studies performed. It is concluded from these studies that transformation, in this locus, is the consequence of frequent, and essentially random exchanges occurring between donor DNA and the chromosomal DNA of the recipient cell. The average length of uninterrupted donor DNA polynucleotide strand which could be inserted into the chromosome of a transformed cell is estimated, from genetic data, to be probably not greater than 3·10⁵ daltons (for a double-stranded insertion). It is proposed, on the basis of genetic evidence, that following essentially random exchanges between donor DNA and recipient chromosome, a revision process, specific for certain types of mutated sites, occurs. The revision process appears to remove preferentially donor DNA sequences from the primary recombinant structure, and allow repair along the chromosomal template, leading to low efficiency in the genetic integration of these sites. A mechanism for this "destruction-choice" process is presented, and evidence in support of this mechanism discussed.     

The Size and Continuity of DNA Segments Integrated in Bacillus Transformation

We investigated the size and continuity of DNA segments integrated in Bacillus subtilis transformation. We transformed B. subtilis strain 1A2 toward rifampicin resistance (coded by rpoB) with genomic DNA and with a PCR-amplified 3.4-kb segment of the rpoB gene from several donors. Restriction analysis showed that smaller lengths of donor DNA integrated into the chromosome with transformation by PCR-amplified DNA than by genomic DNA. Nevertheless, integration of very short segments (<2 kb) from large, genomic donor molecules was not a rare event. With PCR-amplified segments as donor DNA, smaller fragments were integrated when there was greater sequence divergence between donor and recipient. There was a large stochastic component to the pattern of recombination. We detected discontinuity in the integration of donor segments within the rpoB gene, probably due to multiple integration events involving a single donor molecule. The transfer of adaptations across Bacillus species may be facilitated by the small sizes of DNA segments integrated in transformation.     

Superhelical DNA in Streptococcus sanguis: role in recombination in vivo.

Summary Competent Streptococcus sanguis treated with non-lethal doses of coumermycin Al immediately before or after uptake of radioactive transforming DNA were reduced in their capacity to yield transformants. This treatment did not alter bacterial ability to bind DNA in DNase I-resistant form, nor did it prevent the single-stranded donor DNA-recipient protein complexes formed upon uptake at the surface of the bacteria from translocating to chromosomal sites. Inhibition of transformation by heterospecific DNA was greater than that by homospecific DNA. The reduction in transformant yield was not accompanied by any loss of donor counts incorporated into the recipient chromosome, but rather by a loss of genetic activity of incorporated donor material indicating a failure of genetic integration and degradation of donor DNA as a consequence of coumermycin treatment. The inhibitory effect of coumermycin on transformation was associated with in vivo loss of chromosomal DNA superhelicity. The chromosomal DNA remained intact, however, indicative of inhibition of a gyrase-like enzyme responsible for the maintenance of negative supercoiling of the S. sanguis chromosome. Upon treatment with the drug, a coumermycin-resistant mutant strain showed neither loss of chromosomal superhelicity nor any inhibitory effect on genetic integration of donor DNA. The evidence supports the idea that chromosomal superhelicity promotes genetic recombination in vivo.