The fate of low affinity tumor-specific CD8+ T cells in tumor-bearing mice

A major challenge in tumor immunology is how best to activate the relatively low avidity self-specific and tumor-specific T cells that are available in the self-tolerant repertoire. To address this issue, we produced a TCR transgenic mouse expressing a class I-restricted hemagglutinin (HA)-specific TCR (clone 1 TCR) derived from a mouse that expressed HA as a self-Ag in the insulin-producing beta cells of the pancreatic islets (InsHA) mice. Upon transfer of clone 1 TCR CD8(+) T cells into InsHA mice, very few cells were activated by cross-presented HA, indicating that the cells were retained in InsHA mice because they ignored the presence of Ag, and not because they were functionally inactivated by anergy or tuning. Upon transfer into recipient mice in which HA is expressed at high concentrations as a tumor-associated Ag in spontaneously arising insulinomas (RIP-Tag2-HA mice), a high proportion of clone 1 cells were activated when they encountered cross-presented tumor Ag in the pancreatic lymph nodes. However, the activated cells exhibited very weak effector function and were soon tolerized. The few activated cells that did migrate to the tumor were unable to delay tumor progression. However, when HA-specific CD4 helper cells were cotransferred with clone 1 cells into RIP-Tag2-HA recipients and the mice were vaccinated with influenza, clone 1 cells were found to exert a significant level of effector function and could delay tumor growth. This tumor model should prove of great value in identifying protocols that can optimize the function of low avidity tumor-specific T cells.     

Characterization of CD8+ T lymphocytes that persist after peripheral tolerance to a self antigen expressed in the pancreas

As a result of expression of the influenza hemagglutinin (HA) in the pancreatic islets, the repertoire of HA-specific CD8+ T lymphocytes in InsHA transgenic mice (D2 mice expressing the HA transgene under control of the rat insulin promoter) is comprised of cells that are less responsive to cognate Ag than are HA-specific CD8+ T lymphocytes from conventional mice. Previous studies of tolerance induction involving TCR transgenic T lymphocytes suggested that a variety of different mechanisms can reduce avidity for Ag, including altered cell surface expression of molecules involved in Ag recognition and a deficiency in signaling through the TCR complex. To determine which, if any, of these mechanisms pertain to CD8+ T lymphocytes within a conventional repertoire, HA-specific CD8+ T lymphocytes from B10.D2 mice and B10.D2 InsHA transgenic mice were compared with respect to expression of cell surface molecules, TCR gene utilization, binding of tetrameric KdHA complexes, lytic mechanisms, and diabetogenic potential. No evidence was found for reduced expression of TCR or CD8 by InsHA-derived CTL, nor was there evidence for a defect in triggering lytic activity. However, avidity differences between CD8+ clones correlated with their ability to bind KdHA tetramers. These results argue that most of the KdHA-specific T lymphocytes in InsHA mice are not intrinsically different from KdHA-specific T lymphocytes isolated from conventional animals. They simply express TCRs that are less avid in their binding to KdHA.     

Defective CD8+ T cell peripheral tolerance in nonobese diabetic mice.

Nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice develop spontaneous autoimmune diabetes that involves participation of both CD4+ and CD8+ T cells. Previous studies have demonstrated spontaneous reactivity to self-Ags within the CD4+ T cell compartment in this strain. Whether CD8+ T cells in NOD mice achieve and maintain tolerance to self-Ags has not previously been evaluated. To investigate this issue, we have assessed the extent of tolerance to a model pancreatic Ag, the hemagglutinin (HA) molecule of influenza virus, that is transgenically expressed by pancreatic islet beta cells in InsHA mice. Previous studies have demonstrated that BALB/c and B10.D2 mice that express this transgene exhibit tolerance of HA and retain only low-avidity CD8+ T cells specific for the dominant peptide epitope of HA. In this study, we present data that demonstrate a deficiency in peripheral tolerance within the CD8+ T cell repertoire of NOD-InsHA mice. CD8+ T cells can be obtained from NOD-InsHA mice that exhibit high avidity for HA, as measured by tetramer (K(d)HA) binding and dose titration analysis. Significantly, these autoreactive CD8+ T cells can cause diabetes very rapidly upon adoptive transfer into NOD-InsHA recipient mice. The data presented demonstrate a retention in the repertoire of CD8+ T cells with high avidity for islet Ags that could contribute to autoimmune diabetes in NOD mice.     

CD8+ T cell tolerance in nonobese diabetic mice is restored by insulin-dependent diabetes resistance alleles

Although candidate genes controlling autoimmune disease can now be identified, a major challenge that remains is defining the resulting cellular events mediated by each locus. In the current study we have used NOD-InsHA transgenic mice that express the influenza hemagglutinin (HA) as an islet Ag to compare the fate of HA-specific CD8+ T cells in diabetes susceptible NOD-InsHA mice with that observed in diabetes-resistant congenic mice having protective alleles at insulin-dependent diabetes (Idd) 3, Idd5.1, and Idd5.2 (Idd3/5 strain) or at Idd9.1, Idd9.2, and Idd9.3 (Idd9 strain). We demonstrate that protection from diabetes in each case is correlated with functional tolerance of endogenous islet-specific CD8+ T cells. However, by following the fate of naive, CFSE-labeled, islet Ag-specific CD8+ (HA-specific clone-4) or CD4+ (BDC2.5) T cells, we observed that tolerance is achieved differently in each protected strain. In Idd3/5 mice, tolerance occurs during the initial activation of islet Ag-specific CD8+ and CD4+ T cells in the pancreatic lymph nodes where CD25+ regulatory T cells (Tregs) effectively prevent their accumulation. In contrast, resistance alleles in Idd9 mice do not prevent the accumulation of islet Ag-specific CD8+ and CD4+ T cells in the pancreatic lymph nodes, indicating that tolerance occurs at a later checkpoint. These results underscore the variety of ways that autoimmunity can be prevented and identify the elimination of islet-specific CD8+ T cells as a common indicator of high-level protection.     

Tc17 CD8+ T Cells Potentiate Th1-Mediated Autoimmune Diabetes in a Mouse Model

An increase in IL-17-producing CD8(+) T (Tc17) cells has been reported in the peripheral blood of children with recent onset type 1 diabetes (T1D), but their contribution to disease pathogenesis is still unknown. To directly study the pathogenic potential of β cell-specific Tc17 cells, we used an experimental model of T1D based on the expression of the neo-self Ag hemagglutinin (HA) in the β cells of the pancreas. When transferred alone, the IL-17-producing HA-specific CD8(+) T cells homed to the pancreatic lymph nodes without causing any pancreatic infiltration or tissue destruction. When transferred together with small numbers of diabetogenic HA-specific CD4(+) T cells, a strikingly different phenotype developed. Under these conditions, Tc17 cells sustained disease progression, driving the destruction of β-islet cells, causing hyperglycemia and ultimately death. Disease progression did not correlate with functional or numerical alterations among the HA-specific CD4(+) T cells. Rather, the transferred CD8(+) T cells accumulated in the pancreatic islets and a considerable fraction converted, under the control of IL-12, to an IFN-γ-producing phenotype. Our data indicate that Tc17 cells are not diabetogenic but can potentiate a Th1-mediated disease. Plasticity of the Tc17 lineage is associated with transition to overt disease in this experimental model of T1D.     

Induction of tumor cell apoptosis in vivo increases tumor antigen cross-presentation,cross-priming rather than cross-tolerizing host tumor-specific CD8 T cells

Cross-presentation of cell-bound Ags from established, solid tumors to CD8 cells is efficient and likely to have a role in determining host response to tumor. A number of investigators have predicted that when tumor Ags are derived from apoptotic cells either no response, due to Ag "sequestration," or CD8 cross-tolerance would ensue. Because the crucial issue of whether this happens in vivo has never been addressed, we induced apoptosis of established hemagglutinin (HA)-transfected AB1 tumors in BALB/c mice using the apoptosis-inducing reagent gemcitabine. This shrank the tumor by approximately 80%. This induction of apoptosis increased cross-presentation of HA to CD8 cells yet neither gross deletion nor functional tolerance of HA-specific CD8 cells were observed, based on tetramer analysis, proliferation of specific CD8 T cells, and in vivo CTL activity. Interestingly, apoptosis primed the host for a strong antitumor response to a second, virus-generated HA-specific signal in that administration of an HA-expressing virus after gemcitabine administration markedly decreased tumor growth compared with viral administration without gemcitabine. Thus tumor cell apoptosis in vivo neither sequesters tumor Ags nor cross-tolerizes tumor-specific CD8 cells. This observation has fundamental consequences for the development of tumor immunotherapy protocols and for understanding T cell reactivity to tumors and the in vivo immune responses to apoptotic cells.     

Regulatory T cells control uveoretinitis induced by pathogenic Th1 cells reacting to a specific retinal neoantigen

In many clinical cases, uveitis develops secondary to an infection. This could result from peripheral activation followed by ocular penetration and reactivation of T cells specific for microbial Ags expressed in the retina. To gain insights into the pathophysiology of uveitis, we developed a new mouse model based on stable retinal expression of influenza virus hemagglutinin (HA) neoantigen by adeno-associated virus-mediated gene transfer. One month thereafter, we adoptively transferred HA-specific T cells, which were activated in vitro or in vivo. Intraocular inflammation was clinically and histologically observed in all animals within 15 days. The ocular infiltrate was composed mostly of macrophages and HA-specific T cells with a proinflammatory cytokine profile. Depletion of CD4(+)CD25(+) regulatory T cells exacerbated the disease, whereas HA-specific CD4(+)CD25(+) T cells given i.v. controlled the disease. This novel model should allow to better study the pathophysiology and therapeutic of uveitis.     

In vivo CD4+ T cell tolerance induction versus priming is independent of the rate and number of cell divisions

In vitro studies have suggested that tolerance induction (i.e., anergy) is associated with an inability of T cells to proliferate vigorously upon Ag recognition. In vivo, the relationship between T cell proliferation and tolerance induction is less clear. To clarify this issue, we have been studying a model system in which naive CD4+ T cells specific for the model Ag hemagluttinin (HA) are adoptively transferred into different transgenic founder lines of mice expressing HA as a peripheral self-Ag. When transferred into two lines whose HA expression differs by at least 1000-fold, HA-specific T cells undergo multiple rounds of cell division before reaching a nonresponsive (i.e., tolerant) state. While the proliferative response is more rapid in mice expressing higher levels of HA, the T cells become tolerant regardless of the level of peripheral HA expression. When the T cells encounter HA expressed as a viral Ag, they proliferate at a similar rate and undergo the same number of divisions as with self-HA, but they do not become tolerant. These results indicate that a tolerizing stimulus can induce similar T cell mitotic rates as a priming stimulus. Therefore, CD4+ T cell tolerance induction in vivo is not the result of an insufficient proliferative response elicited upon TCR engagement.     

In a transgenic model of spontaneous autoimmune diabetes, expression of a protective class II MHC molecule results in thymic deletion of diabetogenic CD8+ T cells

H-2(d) mice expressing both the influenza virus hemagglutinin (HA) as a transgene-encoded protein on pancreatic islet beta cells (InsHA), as well as the Clone 4 TCR specific for the dominant H-2K(d)-restricted HA epitope, can be protected from the development of spontaneous autoimmune diabetes by expression of the H-2(b) haplotype. Protection occurs due to the deletion of K(d)HA-specific CD8+ T cells. This was unexpected as neither the presence of the InsHA transgene nor H-2(b), individually, resulted in thymic deletion. Further analyses revealed that thymic deletion required both a hybrid MHC class II molecule, Ebeta(b) Ealpha(d), and the K(d) molecule presenting the HA epitope, which together synergize to effect deletion of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes. This surprising example of protection from autoimmunity that maps to a class II MHC molecule, yet effects an alteration in the CD8+ T cell repertoire, suggests that selective events in the thymus represent the integrated strength of signal delivered to each cell through recognition of a variety of different MHC-peptide ligands.     

First signature of islet beta-cell-derived naturally processed peptides selected by diabetogenic class II MHC molecules

The diversity of Ags targeted by T cells in autoimmune diabetes is unknown. In this study, we identify and characterize a limited number of naturally processed peptides from pancreatic islet beta-cells selected by diabetogenic I-A(g7) molecules of NOD mice. We used insulinomas transfected with the CIITA transactivator, which resulted in their expression of class II histocompatibility molecules and activation of diabetogenic CD4 T cells. Peptides bound to I-A(g7) were isolated and examined by mass spectrometry: some peptides derived from proteins present in secretory granules of endocrine cells, and a number were shared with cells of neuronal lineage. All proteins to which peptides were identified were expressed in beta cells from normal islets. Peptides bound to I-A(g7) molecules contained the favorable binding motif characterized by acidic amino acids at the P9 position. The draining pancreatic lymph nodes of prediabetic NOD mice contained CD4 T cells that recognized three different natural peptides. Furthermore, four different peptides elicited CD4 T cells, substantiating the presence of such self-reactive T cells. The overall strategy of identifying natural peptides from islet beta-cells opens up new avenues to evaluate the repertoire of self-reactive T cells and its role in onset of diabetes.     

Tumor antigens are constitutively presented in the draining lymph nodes

Tumor growth is rarely associated with a strong specific CTL response, suggesting that the immune system is ignorant of the presence of tumor because the Ags are not readily available to or are sequestered from potential effector cells. We studied the in vivo activation of naive TCR transgenic hemagglutinin (HA)-specific CD8+ T cells adoptively transferred into mice bearing HA-expressing tumor using 5,6-carboxy-succinimidyl-fluorescein-ester labeling, which allows the identification of proliferating HA-specific T cells. We demonstrate that tumor Ags are constitutively presented in the lymph nodes draining tumors and are powerfully mitogenic for responding T cells despite the absence of anti-tumor CTL responses. Importantly, this proliferative signal occurs throughout tumor growth and is still detectable 6 mo after tumor inoculation when tumor is not palpable. These results provide the first evidence that there is constitutive presentation of tumor Ags in draining lymph nodes.     

Cutting Edge: Programmed death (PD) ligand-1/PD-1 interaction is required for CD8+ T cell tolerance to tissue antigens

Constitutive presentation of tissue Ags by dendritic cells results in tolerance of autoreactive CD8+ T cells; however, the underlying molecular mechanisms are not well understood. In this study we show that programmed death (PD)-1, an inhibitory receptor of the CD28 family, is required for tolerance induction of autoreactive CD8+ T cells. An antagonistic Ab against PD-1 provoked destructive autoimmune diabetes in RIP-mOVA mice expressing chicken OVA in the pancreatic islet cells, which received naive OVA-specific CD8+ OT-I cells. This effect was mediated by the PD ligand (PD-L) PD-L1 but not by PD-L2. An increased number of effector OT-I cells recovered from the pancreatic lymph nodes of anti-PD-L1-treated mice showed down-regulation of PD-1. Furthermore, the blockade of PD-1/PD-L1 interaction during the priming phase did not significantly affect OT-I cell division but enhanced its granzyme B, IFN-gamma, and IL-2 production. Thus, during the presentation of tissue Ags to CD8+ T cells, PD-1/PD-L1 interaction crucially controls the effector differentiation of autoreactive T cells to maintain self-tolerance.     

A bone marrow-derived APC in the gut-associated lymphoid tissue captures oral antigens and presents them to both CD4+ and CD8+ T cells

We have previously reported that feeding OVA to C57BL/6 mice can lead to a weak CTL response that is dependent on CD4+ T cell help and is capable of causing autoimmunity. In this study, we investigated the basis of the class I and class II-restricted Ag presentation required for such CTL induction. Two days after feeding OVA, Ag-specific CD4+ and CD8+ T cells were seen to proliferate in the Peyer's patches and mesenteric lymph nodes. Little proliferation was evident in other lymphoid tissues, except at high Ags doses, in which case some dividing CD4+ T cells were observed in the spleen and peripheral lymph nodes. Using chimeric mice, the APC responsible for presenting orally derived Ags was shown to be derived from the bone marrow. Examination of the Ag dose required to activate either CD4+ or CD8+ T cells indicated that a single dose of 6 mg OVA was the minimum dose that consistently stimulated either T cell subset. These data indicate that oral Ags can be transported from the gut into the gut-associated lymphoid tissue, where they are captured by a bone marrow-derived APC and presented to both CD4+ and CD8+ T cells.     

Cutting edge: CD25+ regulatory T cells prevent expansion and induce apoptosis of B cells specific for tissue autoantigens

To study the role of CD25(+) regulatory T cells (T(regs)) in peripheral B cell tolerance, we generated transgenic rat insulin promoter RIP-OVA/HEL mice expressing the model Ags OVA and HEL in pancreatic islet beta cells (where RIP is rat insulin promoter and HEL is hen egg lysozyme). Adoptively transferred transgenic OVA-specific CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells proliferated only in the autoantigen-draining pancreatic lymph node (PLN), demonstrating pancreas-specific Ag expression. Transferred HEL-specific transgenic B cells (IgHEL cells) disappeared within 3 wk from transgenic but not from nontransgenic mice immunized with autoantigen. Depletion of CD25(+) FoxP3(+) cells completely restored IgHEL cell numbers. T(reg) exerted an analogous suppressive effect on endogenous HEL-specific autoreactive B cells. T(regs) acted by inhibiting the proliferation of IgHEL cells in the spleen and PLN and by systemic induction of their apoptosis. Furthermore, they reduced BCR and MHC II surface expression on IgHEL cells in the PLN. These findings demonstrate that autoreactive B cells specific for a nonlymphoid tissue autoantigen are controlled by T(regs).     

Murine Peyer's patches favor development of an IL-10-secreting,regulatory T cell population

Peyer's patches (PP) are believed to be the principal sites for induction of tolerance to Ags from food and commensal flora, yet the phenotype of T cells activated within the PP is largely unexplored. We hypothesize that exposure to Ags within the PP promotes differentiation of T cells with immunoregulatory functions. Cytokine production and cell surface marker expression of murine PP mononuclear cells (MC) are compared with those from mesenteric lymph nodes and peripheral lymph nodes (PLN). In response to stimulation through the TCR/CD3 complex, PP MC exhibit vigorous proliferation, modest production of IL-2, and significantly elevated synthesis of IL-10. Exogenous IL-12 enhances both IL-10 and IFN-gamma secretion by activated PP MC. Cell surface marker analysis reveals that PP T cells consist of activated and memory subpopulations compared with the predominantly naive T cells identified in the PLN and mesenteric lymph nodes. Upon stimulation, only CD45RB(low)CD4(+) PP T cells produce IL-10, whereas secretion of IL-2, IL-4, and IFN-gamma was not detected. Furthermore, PP MC, but not PLN MC, stimulated through the TCR/CD3 complex suppress proliferation of purified PLN T cells in vitro, evidence for a regulatory function among PP lymphocytes. We conclude that PP favor differentiation of an IL-10-producing, regulatory CD45RB(low)CD4(+) T cell population and that inhibition of T cell proliferation by activated PP MC may reflect regulatory activity consistent with T regulatory cells.     

Bystander central memory but not effector memory CD8+ T cells suppress allograft rejection

Memory T cells respond faster and more vigorously than their naive counterparts and are critical for adaptive immunity. However, it is unknown whether and how memory T cells react in the face of irrelevant Ags. It is generally accepted that bystander memory T cells are neutral in immune responsiveness. In this study, we present the first evidence that bystander central memory (TCM), but not effector memory (TEM), CD8+ T cells suppress allograft rejection as well as T cell proliferation in the draining lymph nodes (DLN) of recipient mice. Both bystander TCM and naive T cells, but fewer TEM cells, migrated to DLN, whereas TCM cells exhibited faster turnover than their naive counterparts, suggesting that bystander TCM cells have an advantage over their naive counterparts in suppression. However, bystander TEM cells migrated to inflammatory graft sites, but not DLN, and yet failed to exert their suppression. These findings indicate that bystander memory T cells need to migrate to lymph nodes to exert their suppression by inhibiting responder T cell activation or homeostatic proliferation. Moreover, the suppression mediated by bystander TCM cells was largely dependent on IL-15, as IL-15 was required for their homeostatic proliferation and TCM-mediated suppression of allograft rejection. This suppression also required the presence of TGFbeta1, as TCM cells expressed TGFbeta1 while neutralizing TGFbeta1 abolished their suppression. Thus, bystander TCM, but not TEM, CD8+ T cells are potent suppressors rather than bystanders. This new finding will have an impact on cellular immunology and may have clinic implications for tolerance induction.     

Cross-priming of diabetogenic T cells dissociated from CTL-induced shedding of beta cell autoantigens

Cross-presentation of self Ags by APCs is key to the initiation of organ-specific autoimmunity. As MHC class I molecules are essential for the initiation of diabetes in nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice, we sought to determine whether the initial insult that allows cross-presentation of beta cell autoantigens in diabetes is caused by cognate interactions between naive CD8(+) T cells and beta cells. Naive splenic CD8(+) T cells from transgenic NOD mice expressing a diabetogenic TCR killed peptide-pulsed targets in the absence of APCs. To ascertain the role of CD8(+) T cell-induced beta cell lysis in the initiation of diabetes, we expressed a rat insulin promoter (RIP)-driven adenovirus E19 transgene in NOD mice. RIP-E19 expression inhibited MHC class I transport exclusively in beta cells and rendered these cells resistant to lysis by CD8(+) (but not CD4(+)) T cells, both in vitro and in vivo. Surprisingly, RIP-E19 expression impaired the accumulation of CD8(+) T cells in islets and delayed the onset of islet inflammation, without affecting the timing or magnitude of T cell cross-priming in the pancreatic lymph nodes, which is the earliest known event in diabetogenesis. These results suggest that access of beta cell autoantigens to the cross-presentation pathway in diabetes is T cell independent, and reveal a previously unrecognized function of MHC class I molecules on target cells in autoimmunity: local retention of disease-initiating clonotypes.     

CD4+ T cells recognizing a single self-peptide expressed by APCs induce spontaneous autoimmune arthritis

We have examined processes leading to the spontaneous development of autoimmune inflammatory arthritis in transgenic mice containing CD4+ T cells targeted to a nominal Ag (hemagglutinin (HA)) and coexpressing HA driven by a MHC class II promoter. Despite being subjected to multiple tolerance mechanisms, autoreactive CD4+ T cells accumulate in the periphery of these mice and promote systemic proinflammatory cytokine production. The majority of mice spontaneously develop inflammatory arthritis, which is accompanied by an enhanced regional immune response in lymph nodes draining major joints. Arthritis development is accompanied by systemic B cell activation; however, neither B cells nor Ab is required for arthritis development, since disease develops in a B cell-deficient background. Moreover, arthritis also develops in a recombinase activating gene-deficient background, indicating that the disease process is driven by CD4+ T cells recognizing the neo-self HA Ag. These findings show that autoreactive CD4+ T cells recognizing a single self-Ag, expressed by systemically distributed APCs, can induce arthritis via a mechanism that is independent of their ability to provide help for autoantibody production.