Protease Inhibitors: Part 4. Synthesis of Weakly Basic Thrombin Inhibitors Incorporating Pyridinium-Sulfanilylaminoguanidine Moieties

Three series of derivatives have been prepared by reaction of sulfanilylaminoguanidine with pyrylium salts, with the pyridinium derivatives of glycine and with the pyridinium derivatives of β-alanine, respectively. The new compounds were assayed as inhibitors of two serine proteases, thrombin and trypsin. The study showed that in contrast to the leads, possessing K₁'s around 100–300nM against thrombin, and 450–1420nM against trypsin, respectively, the new derivdtives showed inhibition constants in the range of 15–50nM against thrombin, whereas their affinity for trypsin remained relatively low. Derivatives of β-alanine were more active than the corresponding glycine derivatives, which in turn were more inhibitory than the pyridinium derivatives of sulfanilylaminoguanidine possessing the same substitution pattern at the pyridinium ring. Thus, the present study proposes two novel approaches for the preparation of high affinity, specific thrombin inhibitors: a novel S1 anchoring moiety in the already large family of arginine/amidine-based inhibitors, i.e., the SO₂NHNHC(=NH)NH₂ group, and novel non-peptidomimetic scaffolds obtained by incorporating alkyl-/aryl-substituted-pyridinium moieties in the hydrophobic binding site(s). The first one is important for obtaining bioavailable thrombin inhibitors, devoid of the high basicity of the commonly used arginine/amidine-based inhibitors, whereas the second one may lead to improved water solubility of such compounds.     

Development of substrate analogue inhibitors for the human airway trypsin-like protease HAT

A series of substrate analogue inhibitors of the serine protease HAT, containing a 4-amidinobenzylamide moiety as the P1 residue, was prepared. The most potent compounds possess a basic amino acid in the d-configuration as P3 residue. Whereas inhibitor 4 (K_i 13 nM) containing proline as the P2 residue completely lacks selectivity, incorporation of norvaline leads to a potent inhibitor (15, K_i 15 nM) with improved selectivity for HAT in comparison to the coagulation proteases thrombin and factor Xa or the fibrinolytic plasmin. Selected inhibitors were able to suppress influenza virus replication in a HAT-expressing MDCK cell model.     

Design and synthesis of highly constrained factor Xa inhibitors: amidine-substituted bis(benzoyl)--diazepan-2-ones and bis(benzylidene)-bis(gem-dimethyl)cycloketones

Two conformationally constrained templates have been designed to provide selective inhibitors of the coagulation cascade serine protease, Factor Xa (FXa). The most active inhibitor, 2,7-bis[(Z)-p-amidinobenzylidene)]-3,3,6,6-tetramethylcycloheptanone, exhibits a K(i) of 42 nM against FXa, with strong selectivity against thrombin (1000-fold), trypsin (300-fold) and plasmin (900-fold). With only two freely rotatable bonds, molecular modeling suggests that one amidine group is positioned into the S1 pocket, forming hydrogen bonds with the side chain of Asp189, similar to other amidine-based inhibitors, with the second benzamidine positioned into the S4 pocket in a position to form strong cation-pi bonding with the S4 aryl cage. We suggest that this interaction plays an important role in the specificity of these inhibitors against other serine proteases.     

Nonbenzamidine tetrazole derivatives as factor Xa inhibitors

Factor Xa (fXa) is an important serine protease that holds the central position linking the intrinsic and extrinsic activation mechanisms in the blood coagulation cascade. Therefore, inhibition of fXa has potential therapeutic applications in the treatments of both arterial and venous thrombosis. Herein we describe a series of tetrazole fXa inhibitors containing benzamidine mimics as the P(1) substrate, of which the aminobenzisoxazole moiety was found to be the most potent benzamidine mimic. SR374 (12) inhibits fXa with a K(i) value of 0.35 nM and is very selective for fXa over thrombin and trypsin.     

Protease Inhibitors. Part 2. Weakly Basic Thrombin Inhibitors Incorporating Sulfonyl-Aminoguanidine Moieties as S1 Anchoring Groups: Synthesis and Structure-Activity Correlations

Abstract

Two series of derivatives have been prepared and assayed as inhibitors of two physiologically relevant serine proteases, human thrombin and human trypsin. The first series includes alkyl-/ aralkyl-/aryl- and hetarylsulfonyl-aminoguanidines. It was thus observed that sulfanilyl-aminoguanidine possesses moderate but intrinsically selective thrombin inhibitory properties, with K_i values around 90 and 1400 nM against thrombin and trypsin respectively. Further elaboration of this molecule afforded compounds that inhibited thrombin with K_i values in the range 10–50 nM, whereas affinity for trypsin remained relatively low. Such compounds were obtained either by attaching benzyloxycarbonyl- or 4-toluenesulfonylureido-protected amino acids (such as D-Phe, L-Pro) or dipeptides (such as Phe-Pro, Gly-His, β-Ala-His or Pro-Gly) to the N-4 atom of the lead molecule, sulfanilyl-aminoguanidine, or by attaching substituted-pyridinium-propylcarboxamido moieties to this lead. Thus, this study brings novel insights regarding a novel non-basic S1 anchoring moiety (i, e., SO₂NHNHC(=NH)NH₂), and new types of peptidomimetic scaffolds obtained by incorporating tosylureido-amino acids/pyridinium-substituted-GABA moieties in the hydrophobic binding site(s). Structure-activity correlations of the new serine protease inhibitors are also discussed based on a QSAR model described previously for a large series of structurally-related derivatives (Supuran et al. (1999) J. Med. Chem., in press).     

Heterocyclic core analogs of a direct thrombin inhibitor

Thrombin is a serine protease that plays a key role in blood clotting. Pyrrolidine 1 is a potent thrombin inhibitor discovered at Merck several years ago. Seven analogs (2–8) of 1 in which the pyrrolidine core was replaced with various heterocycles were prepared and evaluated for activity against thrombin, clotting factors VIIa, IXa, Xa, and XIIa, and trypsin. The thiomorpholine analog 6 was the most active, essentially matching the thrombin inhibitory activity of 1 with slightly improved selectivity over trypsin.     

Expression and characterization of Flavikunin: A Kunitz‐type serine protease inhibitor identified in the venom gland cDNA library of Bungarus flaviceps

Trancriptomic analysis of the venom gland cDNA library of Bungarus flaviceps revealed Kunitz‐type serine protease inhibitor as one of the major venom protein families with three groups A, B, C. One of the group B isoforms named Flavikunin, which lacked an extra cysteine residue involved in disulfide bond formation in β‐bungarotoxin, was synthesized, cloned, and overexpressed in Escherichia coli. To decipher the structure‐function relationship, the P1 residue of Flavikunin, histidine, was mutated to alanine and arginine. Purified wild‐type and mutant Flavikunins were screened against serine proteases‐thrombin, factor Xa, trypsin, chymotrypsin, plasmin, and elastase. The wild‐type and mutant Flavikunin (H?R) inhibited plasmin with an IC ₅₀ of 0.48 and 0.35 µM, respectively. The in‐silico study showed that P1 residue of wild‐type and mutant (H?R) Flavikunin interacted with S1′ and S1 site of plasmin, respectively. Thus, histidine at the P1 position was found to be involved in plasmin inhibition with mild anticoagulant activity.     

Design,parallel synthesis,and crystal structures of biphenyl antithrombotics as selective inhibitors of tissue factor FVIIa complex. Part 1: Exploration of S2 pocket pharmacophores

Factor VIIa (FVIIa), a serine protease enzyme, coupled with tissue factor (TF) plays an important role in a number of thrombosis-related disorders. Inhibition of TF·FVIIa occurs early in the coagulation cascade and might provide some safety advantages over other related enzymes. We report here a novel series of substituted biphenyl derivatives that are highly potent and selective TF·FVIIa inhibitors. Parallel synthesis coupled with structure-based drug design allowed us to explore the S2 pocket of the enzyme active site. A number of compounds with IC₅₀ value of <10 nM were synthesized. The X-ray crystal structures of some of these compounds complexed with TF·FVIIa were determined and results were applied to design the next round of inhibitors. All the potent inhibitors were tested for inhibition against a panel of related enzymes and selectivity of 17,600 over thrombin, 450 over trypsin, 685 over FXa, and 76 over plasmin was achieved. Two groups, vinyl 36b and 2-furan 36ab, were identified as the optimum binding substituents on the phenyl ring in the S2 pocket. Compounds with these two substituents are the most potent compounds in this series with good selectivity over related serine proteases. These compounds will be further explored for structure–activity relationship.     

Functional and Structural Characterization of Vibrio cholerae Extracellular Serine Protease B,VesB

The chymotrypsin subfamily A of serine proteases consists primarily of eukaryotic proteases, including only a few proteases of bacterial origin. VesB, a newly identified serine protease that is secreted by the type II secretion system in Vibrio cholerae, belongs to this subfamily. VesB is likely produced as a zymogen because sequence alignment with trypsinogen identified a putative cleavage site for activation and a catalytic triad, His-Asp-Ser. Using synthetic peptides, VesB efficiently cleaved a trypsin substrate, but not chymotrypsin and elastase substrates. The reversible serine protease inhibitor, benzamidine, inhibited VesB and served as an immobilized ligand for VesB affinity purification, further indicating its relationship with trypsin-like enzymes. Consistent with this family of serine proteases, N-terminal sequencing implied that the propeptide is removed in the secreted form of VesB. Separate mutagenesis of the activation site and catalytic serine rendered VesB inactive, confirming the importance of these features for activity, but not for secretion. Similar to trypsin but, in contrast to thrombin and other coagulation factors, Na⁺ did not stimulate the activity of VesB, despite containing the Tyr²⁵⁰ signature. The crystal structure of catalytically inactive pro-VesB revealed that the protease domain is structurally similar to trypsinogen. The C-terminal domain of VesB was found to adopt an immunoglobulin (Ig)-fold that is structurally homologous to Ig-folds of other extracellular Vibrio proteins. Possible roles of the Ig-fold domain in stability, substrate specificity, cell surface association, and type II secretion of VesB, the first bacterial multidomain trypsin-like protease with known structure, are discussed.     

Preparation of l-proline based aeruginosin 298-A analogs: Optimization of the P1-moiety

Aeruginosins are a family of naturally occurring oligopeptides that share a common bicyclic amino acid core structure. Many compounds in the family are inhibitors of serine proteases, such as thrombin and trypsin. Thrombin is an important enzyme in the blood coagulation cascade, and is a promising target for anticoagulant drug development. In order to understand the structure–activity relationship (SAR) and to find selective thrombin inhibitors, we synthesized a series of aeruginosin 298-A analogs, in which the P₂ bicyclic amino acid was replaced by a l-proline residue. The structure optimization was focused on modification of the P₁ position. In choosing the P₁ group, an effort was made to avoid using the highly basic guanidine groups present in nearly all naturally occurring aeruginosins. The synthesis and enzyme assays of these aeruginosin analogs against thrombin and trypsin are reported. We found that several compounds with neutral P₁ groups exhibit excellent selectivity over trypsin and good potency against thrombin. The SAR data of the P₁ groups obtained here can be used in preparing other thrombin inhibitors with better selectivity against trypsin.     

Protease inhibitors: Part 4. Synthesis of weakly basic thrombin inhibitors incorporating pyridinium-sulfanilylaminoguanidine moieties

Three series of derivatives have been prepared by reaction of sulfanilylaminoguanidine with pyrylium salts, with the pyridinium derivatives of glycine and with the pyridinium derivatives of beta-alanine, respectively. The new compounds were assayed as inhibitors of two serine proteases, thrombin and trypsin. The study showed that in contrast to the leads, possessing KI's around 100-300 nM against thrombin, and 450-1420 nM against trypsin, respectively, the new derivatives showed inhibition constants in the range of 15-50 nM against thrombin, whereas their affinity for trypsin remained relatively low. Derivatives of beta-alanine were more active than the corresponding glycine derivatives, which in turn were more inhibitory than the pyridinium derivatives of sulfanilylaminoguanidine possessing the same substitution pattern at the pyridinium ring. Thus, the present study proposes two novel approaches for the preparation of high affinity, specific thrombin inhibitors: a novel S1 anchoring moiety in the already large family of arginine/amidine-based inhibitors, i.e., the SO2NHNHC(=NH)NH2 group, and novel non-peptidomimetic scaffolds obtained by incorporating alkyl-/aryl-substituted-pyridinium moieties in the hydrophobic binding site(s). The first one is important for obtaining bioavailable thrombin inhibitors, devoid of the high basicity of the commonly used arginine/amidine-based inhibitors, whereas the second one may lead to improved water solubility of such compounds.     

Comparative molecular modeling analysis of­5‐amidinoindole and benzamidine binding to thrombin and trypsin: specific H‐bond formation contributes to high 5‐amidinoindole potency and selectivity for thrombin and factor Xa

The coagulation cascade enzymes thrombin and factor Xa are known to have specificity pockets very similar to those of trypsin and plasmin. However, comparative molecular modeling analysis of the crystal structures of benzamidine–thrombin and benzamidine–trypsin, in conjunction with a docking analysis of 5‐amidinoindole and related inhibitors in both enzymes reveals subtle differences between the specificity sites of the two types of enzymes. Specifically, thrombin and factor Xa, which have an alanine residue at position 190, exhibit increased activities for the rigid and more bulky bicyclic derivatives of benzamidine (e.g. amidinobenzofuran, amidinothiophene and amidinoindole), because of additional hydrophobic and H‐bond interactions between the inhibitors and the specificity sites, whereas enzymes with a serine residue at position 190, like trypsin and plasmin, exhibit little difference in activity among the same set of compounds because of the orientational restriction imposed on the inhibitors by Ser190, which forms an additional H‐bond with the amidino group of the inhibitors. Enzymes of both groups show similar responses to the flexible aminobenzamidine since the smaller size and the rotatable anilino group of the inhibitor would allow the inhibitor to achieve favorable electrostatic interactions with both groups of enzymes. 5‐Amidinoindole is the most dramatic example of the rigid bicyclic type inhibitor. Based on our docking analysis, we propose that a selective H‐bond with the hydroxyl group of the catalytic Ser195 and the subtle differences in steric fit imposed by Ala/Ser at position 190 explain the high potency and selectivity of 5‐amidinoindole for thrombin and factor Xa. Copyright © 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Design of weakly basic thrombin inhibitors incorporating novel P1 binding functions: molecular and X-ray crystallographic studies

To prepare weakly basic thrombin inhibitors with modified S1 anchoring groups, two series of compounds were synthesized by reaction of guanidine or aminoguanidine with acyl halides and N,N-disubstituted carbamoyl chlorides. pK(a) measurements of these acylated guanidines/aminoguanidines showed a reduced basicity, with pK(a) values in the range of 8.4-8.7. These molecules typically showed inhibition constants in the range of 150-425 nM against thrombin and 360-965 nM against trypsin, even though some bulky derivatives, such as N,N-diphenylcarbamoylguanidine/aminoguanidine and their congeners, showed much stronger thrombin inhibitory activity, with inhibition constants in the range of 24-42 nM. Unexpectedly, very long incubation times with both proteases revealed that aminoguanidine derivatives behaved as irreversible inhibitors. To assess the molecular basis responsible for the high affinity observed for these molecules toward thrombin, the crystal structure of the thrombin-hirugen-N,N-diphenylcarbamoylaminoguanidine complex has been solved at 1.90 A resolution. The structural analysis of the complex revealed an unexpected interaction mode with the protease, resulting in an N,N-diphenylcarbamoyl intermediate covalently bound to the catalytic serine as a consequence of its hydrolysis together with the release of the aminoguanidine moiety. Surprisingly, in this covalent adduct a phenyl group was found in the S1 specificity pocket, which usually recognizes positively charged residues. These findings provide new insights in the design of low basicity serine protease inhibitors.     

Protease inhibitors. Part 2. Weakly basic thrombin inhibitors incorporating sulfonyl-aminoguanidine moieties as S1 anchoring groups: synthesis and structure-activity correlations

Two series of derivatives have been prepared and assayed as inhibitors of two physiologically relevant serine proteases, human thrombin and human trypsin. The first series includes alkyl-/ aralkyl-/aryl- and hetarylsulfonyl-aminoguanidines. It was thus observed that sulfanilyl-aminoguanidine possesses moderate but intrinsically selective thrombin inhibitory properties, with KI values around 90 and 1400 nM against thrombin and trypsin respectively. Further elaboration of this molecule afforded compounds that inhibited thrombin with KI values in the range 10-50 nM, whereas affinity for trypsin remained relatively low. Such compounds were obtained either by attaching benzyloxycarbonyl- or 4-toluenesulfonylureido-protected amino acids (such as D-Phe, L-Pro) or dipeptides (such as Phe-Pro, Gly His, beta-Ala-His or Pro-Gly) to the N-4 atom of the lead molecule, sulfanilyl-aminoguanidine, or by attaching substituted-pyridinium propylcarboxamido moieties to this lead. Thus, this study brings novel insights regarding a novel non-basic S1 anchoring moiety (i.e., SO2NHNHC(=NH)NH2), and new types of peptidomimetic scaffolds obtained by incorporating tosylureido-amino acids/pyridinium-substituted-GABA moieties in the hydrophobic binding site(s). Structure-activity correlations of the new serine protease inhibitors are also discussed based on a QSAR model described previously for a large series of structurally-related derivatives (Supuran et al. (1999) J. Med. Chem., in press).     

Effect of inhibitory activity of mutation at reaction site P4 of the Streptomyces subtilisin inhibitor, SSI

The protein Streptomyces subtilisin inhibitor, SSI, efficiently inhibits a bacterial serine protease, subtilisin BPN'. We recently demonstrated that functional change in SSI was possible simply by replacing the amino acid residue at the reactive P1 site (methionine 73) of SSI. The present paper reports the additional effect of replacing methionine 70 at the P4 site of SSI (Lys73) on inhibitory activity toward two types of serine proteases, trypsin (or lysyl endopeptidase) and subtilisin BPN'. Conversion of methionine 70 at the P4 site of SSI(Lys73) to glycine or alanine resulted in increased inhibitory activity toward trypsin and lysyl endopeptidase, while replacement with phenylalanine weakened the inhibitory activity toward trypsin. This suggests that steric hindrance at the P4 site of SSI(Lys73) is an obstacle for its binding with trypsin. In contrast, the same P4 replacements had hardly any effect on inhibitory activity toward subtilisin BPN'. Thus the subsite structure of subtilisin BPN' is tolerant to these replacements. This contrast in the effect of P4 substitution might be due to the differences in the S4 subsite structures between the trypsin-like and the subtilisin-like proteases. These findings demonstrate the importance of considering structural complementarity, not only at the main reactive site but also at subsites of a protease, when designing stronger inhibitors.     

Mechanism-based isocoumarin inhibitors for serine proteases: use of active site structure and substrate specificity in inhibitor design

Isocoumarins are potent mechanism-based heterocyclic irreversible inhibitors for a variety of serine proteases. Most serine proteases are inhibited by the general serine protease inhibitor 3,4-dichloroisocoumarin, whereas isocoumarins containing hydrophobic 7-acylamino groups are potent inhibitors for human leukocyte elastase and those containing 7-alkylureidogroups are inhibitors for procine pancreatic elastase. Isocoumarins containing basic side chains that resemble arginine are potent inhibitors for trypsin-like enzymes. A number of 3-alkoxy-4-chloro-7-guanidinoisocoumarins are potent inhibitors of bovine thrombin, human factor Xa, human factor XIa, human factor XIIa, human plasma kallikrein, porcine pancreatic kallikrein, and bovine trypsin. Another cathionic derivative, 4-chloro-3-(2-isothiureidoethoxy) isocoumarin, is less reactive toward many of these enzymes but is an extremely potent inhibitor of human plasma kallikrein. Several guanidinoisocoumarins have been tested as anticoagulants in human plasma and are effective at prolonging the prothrombin time. The mechanism of inhibition by this class of heterocyclic inactivators involves formation of an acyl enzyme by reaction of the active site serine with the isocoumarin carbonyl group. Isocoumarins with 7-amino or 7-guanidino groups will then decompose further to quinone imine methide intermediates, which react further with an active site residue (probably His-57) to form stable inhibited enzyme derivatives. Isocoumarins should be useful in further investigations of the physiological function of serine proteases and may have future therapeutic utility for the treatment of emphysema and coagulation disorders.     

Isolation and characterization of Perkinsus marinus proteases using bacitracin–sepharose affinity chromatography

Extracellular proteases were isolated from the cell-free culture supernatant of the oyster-pathogenic protozoan, Perkinsus marinus, by bacitracin–sepharose affinity chromatography. The purified protease fractions contained >75% of the protease activity initially loaded onto the column with very high specific activity that corresponded to 8–11-fold level of protease enrichment. The isolated proteases hydrolysed a variety of protein substrates including oyster plasma. All of the isolated P. marinus proteases belonged to the serine class of proteases. Inhibitor studies involving spectrophotometric assay and gelatin gel electrophoresis showed high levels of inhibition in the presence of the serine protease inhibitors PMSF, benzamidine and chymostatin, whereas inhibitors of cysteine, aspartic, and metalloproteases showed little or no inhibition. Spectrophotometric assays involving serine-specific peptide substrates further revealed that the isolated proteases belong to the class of chymotrypsin-like serine proteases. A 41.7 kDa monomeric, N-glycosylated, serine protease (designated Perkinsin) has been identified as the major P. marinus extracellular protease.     

Human rhinovirus 3C protease: a cysteine protease showing the trypsin(ogen)-like fold

Viral-encoded proteases cleave precursor polyprotein(s) leading to maturation of infectious virions. Strikingly, human rhinovirus 3C protease shows the trypsin(ogen)-like serine protease fold based on two topologically equivalent six-stranded β-barrels, but displays residue Cys147 as the active site nucleophile. By contrast, papain, which is representative of most cysteine proteases, does not display the trypsin(ogen)-like fold. Remarkably, in human rhinovirus 3C cysteine protease, the catalytic residues Cys147, His40 and Glu71 are positioned as Ser195, His57 and Asp102, respectively, building up the catalytic triad of serine proteases in the chymotrypsin–trypsin–elastase family. However, as compared to trypsin-like serine proteases and their zymogens, residue His40 and the oxyanion hole of human rhinovirus 3C cysteine protease, both key structural components of the active site, are located closer to the protein core. Human rhinovirus 3C cysteine protease cleaves preferentially GlnGly peptide bonds or, less commonly, the GlnSer, GlnAla, GluSer or GluGly pairs. Finally, human rhinovirus 3C cysteine protease and the 3CD cysteine protease–polymerase covalent complex bind the 5′ non-coding region of rhinovirus genomic RNA, an essential function for replication of the viral genome.     

1,2,5-Thiadiazolidin-3-one 1,1-dioxide-based heterocyclic sulfides are potent inhibitors of human tryptase

We describe herein the design, synthesis, and in vitro biochemical evaluation of a series of potent, time-dependent inhibitors of the mast cell-derived serine protease tryptase. The inhibitors were readily obtained by attaching various heterocyclic thiols, as well as a basic primary specificity residue P₁, to the 1,2,5-thiadiazolidin-3-one 1,1-dioxide scaffold. The inhibitors were found to be devoid of any inhibitory activity toward a neutral (elastase) or cysteine (papain) protease, however they were also fairly efficient inhibitors of bovine trypsin. The differential inhibition observed with trypsin suggests that enzyme selectivity can be optimized by exploiting differences in the S′ subsites of the two enzymes. The results described herein demonstrate the versatility of the heterocyclic scaffold in fashioning mechanism-based inhibitors of neutral, basic, and acidic (chymo)trypsin-like serine proteases.     

1-Aminoisoquinoline as benzamidine isoster in the design and synthesis of orally active thrombin inhibitors

Replacement of the highly basic benzamidine moiety of NAPAP by the moderately basic 1-aminoisoquinoline moiety resulted in thrombin inhibitors with improved selectivity towards trypsin and enhanced Caco-2 cell permeability.