Morphologic characteristics of p16INK4a-positive cells in cervical cytology samples

OBJECTIVE: Overexpression of p16INK4a has been proposed as a biomarker helpful for the identification of dysplastic cervical epithelial cells on histologic slides as well as in cervical smears. Since a few nontransformed cells in the genital tract in some instances may also express p16INK4a, we evaluated whether applying established morphologic criteria for cervical dysplasia allows a distinction of dysplastic from nondysplastic p16INK4a-stained cells in cytologic samples. STUDY DESIGN: Liquid-based cytology samples were obtained from a screening population (n=50), and from patients attending a dysplasia clinic (n=40). Slides prepared from these samples were stained with the conventional Papanicolaou stain procedure. From each specimen, a second slide was prepared in parallel and immunostained for p16INK4a. Cytologic diagnoses for most patients attending the dysplasia clinic could be compared to the reported histologic diagnoses on punch biopsy samples taken from the patients at the time of colposcopy. This allowed a comparison of the cytology and p16INK4a immunostaining results with subsequent hematoxylin and eosin-based histologic diagnoses. RESULTS: Overall, in 10% of slides obtained from patients with nonsuspicious smears, few p16INK4a-positive cells were found. Using established morphologic criteria and applying these criteria on cells showing any p16INK4a immunoreactivity, p16INK4a-positive normal or metaplastic cells could be discriminated from p16INK4a-expressing dysplastic cells. In 21 of 22 cases (95%) of high grade lesions (cervical intraepithelial neoplasia 2 or higher in follow-up histology), easily recognizable p16INK4a-positive dysplastic cells could be detected, with the remaining case lacking dysplastic cells in the thin-layer slide used for p16INK4a immunostaining. CONCLUSION: Established morphologic criteria for cervical dysplasia can be readily applied to p16INK4a-immunostained cytologic specimens. Thus, p16INK4a immunostaining may help to avoid ambiguities in the interpretation of cervical cytology samples and facilitate more rapid diagnosis and possibly even automated screening of cytologic slides.     

Comparison of three different methods for automated classification of cervical cells.

Over 4600 exfoliated squamous cervical cells taken from appropriate Papanicolaou samples were classified as normal, mildly dysplastic, moderately dysplastic and severely dysplastic by an experienced cytopathologist. The slides were de-stained and subsequently re-stained with Feulgen Thionin-SO2 stain. Images of the nuclei were then captured, recorded and processed employing an image cytometry device. Automated classification of the cells was carried out using three different methods--discriminant function analysis, a decision tree classifier and a neutral network classifier. The discriminant function analysis method, which combined all dysplastic cells into an abnormal group, achieved a combined error rate of less than 0.4% for moderate and severe dysplastic cells, and less than 40% for mildly dysplastic cells. All three methods yielded comparable results, which approached those of human performance.     

Flow cytometric DNA analyses of epithelial dysplasia of the esophagus

OBJECTIVE: To investigate, with flow cytometry, DNA aneuploidy as a marker of early carcinogenesis in dysplastic esophageal lesions. STUDY DESIGN: DNA content of exfoliated cells from 789 cases of esophageal dysplasia (including mild dysplasia, 195 cases; moderate dysplasia, 383 cases; and severe dysplasia, 211 cases) was determined with a FACS 420 flow cytometer. RESULTS: Cellular DNA content was closely related to the severity of dysplasia. The carcinogenesis rate in patients with dysplasia showed that DNA aneuploidy was significantly higher than in patients showing DNA diploidy. CONCLUSION: DNA aneuploidy in dysplastic lesions is a very important early signal of carcinogenesis. Patients with dysplastic lesions showing DNA aneuploidy should be treated and closely followed.     

Oxidative stress in HPV-driven viral carcinogenesis: redox proteomics analysis of HPV-16 dysplastic and neoplastic tissues

Genital infection by high risk Human Papillomavirus (HR-HPV), although recognized as the main etio-pathogenetic factor of cervical cancer, is not per se sufficient to induce tumour development. Oxidative stress (OS) represents an interesting and under-explored candidate as a promoting factor in HPV-initiated carcinogenesis. To gain insight into the role of OS in cervical cancer, HPV-16 positive tissues were collected from patients with invasive squamous cervical carcinoma, from patients with High Grade dysplastic HPV lesions and from patients with no clinical evidence of HPV lesions. After virological characterization, modulation of proteins involved in the redox status regulation was investigated. ERp57 and GST were sharply elevated in dysplastic and neoplastic tissues. TrxR2 peaked in dysplastic samples while iNOS was progressively reduced in dysplastic and neoplastic samples. By redox proteomic approach, five proteins were found to have increased levels of carbonyls in dysplastic samples respect to controls namely: cytokeratin 6, actin, cornulin, retinal dehydrogenase and GAPDH. In carcinoma samples the peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerase A, ERp57, serpin B3, Annexin 2 and GAPDH were found less oxidized than in dysplastic tissues. HPV16 neoplastic progression seems associated with increased oxidant environment. In dysplastic tissues the oxidative modification of DNA and proteins involved in cell morphogenesis and terminal differentiation may provide the conditions for the neoplastic progression. Conversely cancer tissues seem to attain an improved control on oxidative damage as shown by the selective reduction of carbonyl adducts on key detoxifying/pro-survival proteins.     

Proteomic analysis of high-grade dysplastic cervical cells obtained from ThinPrep slides using laser capture microdissection and mass spectrometry

The purpose of this discovery phase study was to identify candidate protein biomarkers for high-grade dysplastic cervical cells using mass spectrometry. Laser Capture Microdissection (LCM) was utilized to isolate high-grade dysplastic and normal cells from ThinPrep slides prepared from cervical cytological specimens. Following cell capture, samples were solubilized and proteins separated by gel electrophoresis in preparation for enzymatic digestion and liquid chromatography mass spectrometry analysis (LC-MS). Processed samples were subsequently analyzed using a linear ion trap coupled with a Fourier transform mass spectrometer (LTQ-FT MS). It was determined that both PreservCyt Solution and ThinPrep Pap Stain (Cytyc Corporation) were compatible with the sample processing and LC-MS analysis. In total, from 9 normal and 9 abnormal cervical cytological specimens, more than 1000 unique proteins were identified with high confidence, based on approximately 12,000 captured cells per specimen. Quantitative protein differences between HSIL (High-Grade Squamous Intraepithelial Lesion) and NILM (Negative for Intraepithelial Lesions or Malignancy) samples were determined by comparing the intensities of the representative (label-free) peptide ions. More than 200 proteins were found to exhibit a 3-fold difference in protein level. Interestingly, significant up-regulation of nuclear and mitochondrial proteins in HSIL specimens was noted. In several cases, the increased protein abundance observed in high-grade cells, as determined by quantitative LC-MS, was validated by immunocytochemical methods using ThinPrep cervical specimens. With the study of additional clinical specimens, the differential abundance of proteins in high-grade dysplastic cells versus morphologically normal cervical cells may lead to validated novel biomarkers for cervical disease.     

Combined analysis of HPV DNA and p16INK4a expression to predict prognosis in ASCUS and LSIL pap smears

Human papillomavirus (HPV) is known to play an important etiological role in the genesis of cervical cancer, but only a very small proportion of infected women develop invasive cervical cancer. The purpose of cervical cancer prevention is early diagnosis of its precursors. The molecular detection of HPV DNA as a diagnostic test to cervical carcinogenesis gave a low positive predictive value as compared to the use of biomarkers. p16INK4a has been proposed as putative surrogate biomarkers that would allow identification of dysplastic cervical epithelia. Serial consecutive cervical smears were test for high-risk HPV stained with immunocytochemistry for p16INK4a and followed-up for 36 months. The aim of the study was to evaluate the immunohistochemical expression of pl6INK4a as a marker of progression risk in low-grade dysplastic lesions of the cervix uteri. In the present series, significant pl6 overexpression was observed in the group that progressed from low to high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion when compared with the group that did not progress. In conclusion, overexpression of p16INK4a acts as potential biomarkers for cervical cancer progression from premalignant lesions.     

Correlation of immunochemical detection of HPV L1 capsid protein in pap smears with regression of high-risk HPV positive mild/moderate dysplasia

OBJECTIVE: To immunostain Pap smears of high-risk (hr) HPV DNA-positive early squamous lesions for detecting HPV L1 protein. STUDY DESIGN: Routinely stained archival slides from 84 mild and moderate hrHPV DNA-positive dysplasias were immunostained using a panreactive HPV L1 antibody. Follow-up smears were taken from women with remission for a mean period of 22.8 months (range, 6-46). Conization was done in patients with persistence or progression (3 and 48 patients, respectively) after a mean time of 12 months (range, 9-48). RESULTS: Twenty-nine of 84 smears (34.5%) had positively stained squamous epithelial cell nuclei. In 9 of 29 (31%) women progressive disease occurred (2 cervical intraepithelial neoplasia [CIN] 2 and 7 CIN 3 lesions on conization) 20 (69%) had remission. Of the 55 L1-negative cases, 13 (23.6%) had remission, 42 (76.4%) progressed (3 CIN 2, 38 CIN 3, 1 microinvasive carcinoma). The difference in follow-up between L1 positive and negative cases was statistically significant (chi2 test, p< or =0.001). CONCLUSION: Low and moderate dysplastic squamous lesions without immunochemically detectable HPV L1 protein are significantly more likely to progress than are L1-positive cases. Immunochemical L1 capsid detection in routine Pap smears thus offers prognostic information about early dysplastic lesions.     

Analysis of nuclear chromatin distribution in cervical glandular abnormalities

OBJECTIVE: To measure the intensity of hematoxylin staining for the analysis of chromatin distribution and to define a clear set of standards. STUDY DESIGN: Cervical smears obtained from 12 patients with glandular lesions, 5 with squamous lesions and 3 without cervical lesions were used for NIH image analysis (public domain NIH image program developed at the U.S. National Institute of Health, available through the Internet by anonymous ftp from zippy.nimh.nih.gov or on floppy disk from the National Technical Information Service, Springfield, Virginia). In addition, the same cervical smears were restained with propidium iodide, and the DNA content in the nuclei was compared with that with hematoxylin staining. RESULTS: Chromatin distribution was categorized into 3 patterns. Pattern A was that for which the highest staining density was localized in the periphery of the nucleus, while in pattern C it was localized in the center of the nucleus. Pattern B was the intermediate type between patterns A and C. In patients with adenocarcinoma, pattern B was predominant; pattern C was also relatively frequent in this group. In atypical glandular cells observed in patients with squamous lesions, patterns A and B were predominant and pattern C rarely seen. Analysis of DNA content in the nucleus revealed that nuclei showing pattern B contained significantly higher quantities of DNA than those showing pattern A. CONCLUSION: Nuclear chromatin distribution seems to correlate well with DNA content, and analysis of the chromatin distribution pattern is helpful for the diagnosis of cervical glandular neoplasia.     

Proliferating activity in oral dysplastic leasions and squamous cell carcinomas

The aim of the study was the quantitative analysis of AgNORs in oral squamous cell carcinomas as well as in dysplastic epithelial changes accompanied and not accompanied by oral squamous cell carcinomas. AgNOR proteins were visualized in histological slides using silver impregnation technique according to D. Ploton. In each sample 100 cell nuclei were assessed. The study used 54 cases of proliferating oral epithelial changes divided into 3 groups: group I consisting of 13 cases of dysplastic lesions not accompanied by oral squamous cell carcinomas; group II (a total of 18 cases) containing dysplastic lesions situated in the vicinity of oral carcinomas and group III (23 cases) with oral squamous cell carcinomas. Statistically significant differences were found between groups with mild dysplasia and groups with severe dysplasia as well as squamous cell carcinomas. Statistical analysis did not show any differences in the number of AgNORs between squamous cell carcinomas and epithelial lesions with severe dysplasia. Our results demonstrate that the analysis of AgNORs expression can serve only as an additional parameter to evaluate the potential of malignant transformation.     

Factors predicting successful DNA recovery from archival cervical smear samples

Polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based DNA testing of archival cervical smear slides is a useful method of retrospectively establishing the presence of the human papillomavirus (HPV) in cervical cells. A cellular DNA recovery test is performed in parallel to HPV DNA testing to ensure that sufficient cells are present and purification of sample DNA has been successfully performed. Previous studies have not comprehensively assessed DNA recovery rates in slides older than 13 years. We undertook a study to determine the factors impacting DNA recovery in 436 UK slides dating from 11 to 33 years prior to testing. Overall, a low cellular DNA recovery success rate of 29% was obtained but a strong trend was observed with increasing recovery rates the older the slides (P < 0.001). Recovery rates increased from 22% in the most recent slides collected from 1988 to 1992, to 61% in the oldest slides, collected in 1970-72. It is likely that fixation compounds incorporating acetic acid, introduced in the UK through the 1980s, have compromised subsequent attempts at PCR amplification. These findings emphasize the importance of the original fixation method in the success of DNA recovery from archival smear samples.     

Comparing the accuracy of ThinPrep Pap tests and conventional Papanicolaou smears on the basis of the histologic diagnosis: a clinical study of women with cervical abnormalities

OBJECTIVE: To confirm that the ThinPrep Pap test (TP) is as effective as or more effective than the conventional Papanicolaou smear (CS) in detecting epithelial cell abnormalities in a population with cervical abnormalities. STUDY DESIGN: In a blinded, split-sample, matched-pair study, a CS was prepared using a cytobrush, and then TP slides were prepared from the remainder of the sample. All slides were evaluated as defined and classified by the Bethesda System. The results of the two cytologic tests were compared in 483 women relative to the histologic diagnoses of subsequent colposcopically directed cervical biopsies in 158 cases. RESULTS: The cytologic diagnoses from the two methods agreed exactly in 91.4% of cases. The comparison between the two cytologic diagnoses with reference to the histologic diagnosis of subsequent colposcopically directed cervical biopsies showed that TP was significantly more specific for diagnosing lesions than was CS. The sensitivity of the two methods was equivalent. CONCLUSION: In a population with cervical abnormalities, TP is more specific than and as effective as CS in detecting cervical epithelial cell abnormalities. TP improved the specificity of disease detection by reducing the atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance category and/or false positive cases.     

Progression of abnormal MIB-1 staining patterns of reserve cells in cervical smears from women ultimately developing high grade squamous intraepithelial lesions

OBJECTIVE: To assess, in a longitudinal study in women diagnosed with high grade squamous epithelial lesion (HSIL), the progression over time of proliferative activity in reserve cells using population screening cervical cytology specimens. STUDY DESIGN: Twenty consecutive, unselected patients with HSIL lesions were part of the national cervical screening program. From the archives, for each patient, the last prior normal population screening smear was included in the study. Concurrent sets of cervical smears from 80 age-matched women without pathology formed the controls. The original slides were stained using MIB-1 monoclonal antibody. The fraction of MIB-1-positive reserve cells was assessed using systematic random sampling and running progressive means assessment to ensure a sufficient sample size. RESULTS: The proliferation fraction in reserve cells of HSIL patients was significantly raised (mean, 65.0%; range, 53.5-94.1%; p < 0.01) as compared with that in concurrent controls (mean, 12.8%; range, 1.9-45.4%). Prior smears from HSIL patients, although without morphologic abnormalities, had abnormally high proliferation fractions (mean, 59.1%; range, 1.0-94.7%), significantly raised over those from concurrent controls (mean, 9.4%; range CONCLUSION: In population-based cervical smear screening, HSIL patients already have abnormally raised proliferation fractions of reserve cells, even without morphologic changes in squamous cells, 1-5 (mean, 3.6) years prior to diagnosis.     

Human papillomavirus DNA and liquid-based cervical cytology cotesting in screening and follow-up patient groups

OBJECTIVE: To compare the use of human papillomavirus (HPV) DNA and cervical cytology cotesting in screening and follow-up of patients with previous cervical abnormalities and to assess the significance of a positive HPV DNA test result in re-screening of cytologically normal cases. STUDY DESIGN: Cellular samples collected in liquid-based fixative were used for both cervical cytology and HPV DNA testing. The cervical cytology slides were manually screened by cytotechnologists followed by rapid re-screening by pathologists. The HPV DNA tests were performed using hybrid capture test kits. Statistical analyses of cervical cytology results and HPV DNA tests for high- and low-risk HPV from both patient groups were carried out. RESULTS: The prevalence of HPV DNA-positive cases was higher in younger patients. There was a poor correlation between cervical cytology results and HPV DNA tests for the screening group (kappa = 0.23), but a fair to good correlation was obtained for the follow-up group (kappa = 0.51). The false negative fraction of cytology negative/HPV DNA positive cases (0.1317), as compared with cytology negative/HPV DNA negative cases (0.0056), was statistically significant (p = 0.000001). CONCLUSION: The prevalence of HPV DNA decreased with increasing age in both the screening and follow-up patient groups. Virus clearance was delayed in the follow-up group as compared with the screening group. There was a poor correlation between cervical cytology and HPV DNA tests in the screening group but a fair to good correlation in the follow-up patient group. Cotesting of HPV DNA and cervical cytology increases the sensitivity and decreases the false negative fraction, suggesting that cotesting could be used to increase the interval of screening.     

Computer grading of cervical intraepithelial neoplastic lesions. I. Cytologic indices

In an attempt to derive a computer-assisted grading for cervical intraepithelial neoplastic (CIN) lesions, apparent discrepancies with the visual diagnostic evaluation could be explained from the data structure of the objective assessment. The 40 cases of dysplasia in this study appeared to fall into two subgroups having different curves of progression. A smaller subgroup, visually graded as milder, less-severe CIN, exhibited dysplastic cells with unexpectedly high abnormality indices. A larger subgroup showed dysplastic cells with abnormality indices in agreement with the tissue assessment.     

Quantitative cytology of the positive region in flow sorted vaginal smears.

Fifty-one gynecologic specimens were collected from three women's hospitals and mailed in a prefixed status to our laboratory. The specimens were classified into a negative, a suspicious, a postradiation, and a positive group. After single cell dispersion the samples were stained for DNA and protein, analyzed, and sorted in the dual laser equipped Heidelberg flow analyzer sorter (HEIFAS). Particles with elevated DNA values (beyond 3.5 ploidy) and with intermediate protein values were sorted as the positive fraction directly on microscopic slides. After restaining according to Papanicolaou, they were re-evaluated cytologically and identified as tumor cells, dysplastic cells and false alarms. The latter consist of doublets and aggregates of more than two cells, binucleated cells, sperm aggregates and epithelial cells contaminated with bacteria. The different groups showed significant differences regarding the total rate of aggregates to single cells. In general, false alarms were very frequent in the positive region and impeded the statistical classification of the sample. The reduction of false alarms is a prerequisite for prescreening with flow instrumentation.     

Relation of quantitative features of visually normal intermediate cells in cervical intraepithelial neoplasia I and II smears to progression or nonprogression of the lesion

The relationship between the quantitative features extracted from digitized images of visually normal intermediate cells in cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) I and II smears and the subsequent follow-up diagnosis was studied. Using the ISPAHAN interactive system of pattern recognition, the average rate of correct classification of progressive or nonprogressive lesions was 80% at the specimen level. It is concluded that additional diagnostic information regarding the probability of progression of CIN I and II lesions may be obtained by studying the microphotometric features of visually normal intermediate cells in the cervical smears. Significant differences were found between intermediate cells close to obviously dysplastic cells and those at a distance. The implication of this finding and the problems involved in the selection of the cells are briefly discussed.     

Genome-wide methylation profiling identifies hypermethylated biomarkers in high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia

Epigenetic modifications, such as aberrant DNA promoter methylation, are frequently observed in cervical cancer. Identification of hypermethylated regions allowing discrimination between normal cervical epithelium and high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN2/3), or worse, may improve current cervical cancer population-based screening programs. In this study, the DNA methylome of high-grade CIN lesions was studied using genome-wide DNA methylation screening to identify potential biomarkers for early diagnosis of cervical neoplasia. Methylated DNA Immunoprecipitation (MeDIP) combined with DNA microarray was used to compare DNA methylation profiles of epithelial cells derived from high-grade CIN lesions with normal cervical epithelium. Hypermethylated differentially methylated regions (DMRs) were identified. Validation of nine selected DMRs using BSP and MSP in cervical tissue revealed methylation in 63.2–94.7% high-grade CIN and in 59.3–100% cervical carcinomas. QMSP for the two most significant high-grade CIN-specific methylation markers was conducted exploring test performance in a large series of cervical scrapings. Frequency and relative level of methylation were significantly different between normal and cancer samples. Clinical validation of both markers in cervical scrapings from patients with an abnormal cervical smear confirmed that frequency and relative level of methylation were related with increasing severity of the underlying CIN lesion and that ROC analysis was discriminative. These markers represent the COL25A1 and KATNAL2 and their observed increased methylation upon progression could intimate the regulatory role in carcinogenesis. In conclusion, our newly identified hypermethylated DMRs represent specific DNA methylation patterns in high-grade CIN lesions and are candidate biomarkers for early detection.     

Genome-wide methylation profiling identifies hypermethylated biomarkers in high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia

Epigenetic modifications, such as aberrant DNA promoter methylation, are frequently observed in cervical cancer. Identification of hypermethylated regions allowing discrimination between normal cervical epithelium and high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN2/3), or worse, may improve current cervical cancer population-based screening programs. In this study, the DNA methylome of high-grade CIN lesions was studied using genome-wide DNA methylation screening to identify potential biomarkers for early diagnosis of cervical neoplasia. Methylated DNA Immunoprecipitation (MeDIP) combined with DNA microarray was used to compare DNA methylation profiles of epithelial cells derived from high-grade CIN lesions with normal cervical epithelium. Hypermethylated differentially methylated regions (DMRs) were identified. Validation of nine selected DMRs using BSP and MSP in cervical tissue revealed methylation in 63.2–94.7% high-grade CIN and in 59.3–100% cervical carcinomas. QMSP for the two most significant high-grade CIN-specific methylation markers was conducted exploring test performance in a large series of cervical scrapings. Frequency and relative level of methylation were significantly different between normal and cancer samples. Clinical validation of both markers in cervical scrapings from patients with an abnormal cervical smear confirmed that frequency and relative level of methylation were related with increasing severity of the underlying CIN lesion and that ROC analysis was discriminative. These markers represent the COL25A1 and KATNAL2 and their observed increased methylation upon progression could intimate the regulatory role in carcinogenesis. In conclusion, our newly identified hypermethylated DMRs represent specific DNA methylation patterns in high-grade CIN lesions and are candidate biomarkers for early detection.     

P-9A COMPARISON OF THE REPORTING MORPHOLOGICAL FEATURES OF GLANDULAR NEOPLASIA FOR CONVENTIONAL AND LIQUID BASED CYTOLOGY FOR CERVICAL SAMPLES

Cervical cancer accounts for approximately 15% of cancer diagnosed in women worldwide with up to 190 000 deaths per annum. One of the major causes of cervical cancer is the infection of human papillomavirus (HPV), a DNA virus. This virus is epidermotropic; there are over 75 subtypes and subtypes 16, 18, 31 and 33 are associated with cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) and carcinomas. Since the start of the cervical screening in mid 1960s, the cervical cancer rate has decreased. There are two techniques used for slide preparation and staining: conventional cytology and liquid based cytology (LBC). Due to the differences in sample collection and preparation, certain aspects of cell morphology, architecture and patterns will present differently from each other on the slide. The study was conducted in a County Hospital. Twenty conventional slides and eight LBC slides already reported as ? Glandular neoplasia were reviewed and assessed with regards to their morphological features. Moreover, conventional slides were compared with LBC slides to determine the differences in their cell morphology, sensitivity and specificity. Furthermore, a semi-quantitative method was used and also true-positive and false-positive rates were evaluated using positive predictive value (PPV). The findings indicated that despite the differences in cell morphology there are many similarities between the two techniques. The study also showed that it was difficult to distinguish between abnormal glandular cells and abnormal squamous cells, which may end in a false positive result and over reporting of glandular neoplasia. Finally, it showed that LBC slides were easier to screen and also had a higher positive predictive value (PPV) resulting in higher sensitivity and specificity. In conclusion, the LBC technique is more accurate and conversion to this technique is the positive step in the screening program.