The Syngens of Paramecium bursaria: New Mating Types and Intersyngenic Mating Reactions

SYNOPSIS. Three syngens of Paramecium bursaria have been identified amongst stocks collected in Scotland. These syngens probably correspond to the previously-described syngens 4, 5 and 6; they have been so named. In all 3 syngens 8 mating types have been found. An extensive series of intersyngenic mating reactions has been discovered between stocks of syngens 4 and 5, and between stocks of syngen 2 and syngens 4 and 5.     

Enzyme Variation in Paramecium caudatum

Stocks of four “syngens” (syngens 1, 3, 12, 13) of Paramecium caudatum could not be distinguished on the basis of isozymic variations of six enzymes. Using the most common enzyme form as the standard for the syngen, we found a higher coefficient of identity between syngens (>90%) than within syngens (73%). These observations, combined with evidence for fertile matings among the groups, suggest that the groups do not warrant the status of syngens. True syngenic variation in P. caudatum is, however, clearly established on the basis of isozymic and breeding studies of wild stocks collected from various places. Some stocks from England have a close affinity with those from Japan, but stocks from Scotland and California must be placed in separate syngenic sets. Thus, P. caudatum is indeed a species complex, within which evolutionarily distinct groups (species = syngens) are identifiable. The definition of syngens on the basis of initial agglutination response is, however, unjustified.     

Comparative Corticotype Analyses in Tetrahymena*

SYNOPSIS. Strains of Tetrahymena pyriformis, including amicronucleate strain GL and representatives of 9 syngens, have been examined to determine the patterns whereby cortical features vary with numbers of ciliary meridians. The characteristics scored were the positions of the contractile vacuole pores (CVP's), the extent of the area within which CVP's develop, the incidence of supernumerary CVP's, and the number of postoral meridians. Intrasyngenic comparisons were possible in 6 syngens and permitted an assessment of intrasyngenic variation for these characteristics. Only the CVP positions appear to be reasonably constant within syngens in the strains examined. On the basis of this criterion the syngens can be arrayed in an approximate order of 1, 3, 7, 6, 8, 9, 2, 5, GL and 4; the angle formed between the central axis, the stomatogenic meridian and the CVP's is most acute in syngen 1.     

SEXUAL AND GENETIC ISOLATION IN THE COSMOPOLITAN ALGAL SPECIES PANDORINA MORUM

In an effort to analyze the nature of a taxonomic species in the microalgae, the major biological characters of various isolates of Pandorina morum have been studied. Seventy heterothallic clones from 31 collecting sites on three continents were found to represent 20 reproductively isolated groups, based on their ability to form zygotes when paired in all possible combinations. Successful germination of the zygotes and demonstrated fertility of their products suggest that each reproductively isolated group represents a syngen—a group of organisms sharing a common gene pool. A further indication of the close relationship of members of the same syngen is that its representatives all share a common chromosome number, time of division, and zygote distribution pattern, characters which vary between syngens. The known range of 18 of the syngens is less than 500 km. The other two syngens may have a world-wide distribution; they both have a haploid chromosome number of 5. Crosses between geographically isolated clones in these two syngens and one other give evidence of both pre- and postzygotic partial isolation within a syngen. Analysis of collections from two revisited sites demonstrated that representatives of a syngen can be recovered after 19 years have elapsed, and that a single pond may contain as many as four syngens. The results obtained for P. morum are compared with the information available on other microalgae with a similar breeding system, and the possible causes and consequences of the species structure are discussed.     

MOLECULAR DELINEATION OF SPECIES AND SYNGENS IN VOLVOCACEAN GREEN ALGAE (CHLOROPHYTA)1

Two species of the colonial green flagellate family Volvocaceae are worldwide in distribution yet exhibit contrasting species structure. Geographically disparate isolates of Gonium pectorale Mueller can interbreed while isolates of Pandorina morum Bory behave quite differently. More than 20 sexually isolated subpopulations occur within this species; these have been termed “syngens” (sensu Sonneborn). Because prezygotic barriers to mating cause intersyngen pairings to fail, breeding analyses cannot be used to estimate genetic relatedness among the syngens of P. morum. DNA comparisons provide an alternative method of assessing genetic relatedness. We compared the nucleotide sequence of the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) region of the nuclear ribosomal repeat among clones of P. morum and of G. pectorale. Members of syngens of P. morum with distribution restricted to one small geographical area show great similarity. Likewise, members of any syngen of worldwide distribution show near uniformity, even those from different continents. However, the ITS sequence of each syngen differs from that of other syngens. In contrast, G. pectorale, which has an ITS region that is remarkably uniform throughout the world, appears to consist of a single syngen within North America and Europe by mating tests. The molecular data are in complete conformity with previous syngen assignment. Because the latter is based on mating affinity, with two complementary mating types per syngen, the evolution of new mating type pairs appears to be the basis of microevolution in these algae. We infer that either P. morum is a more ancient species than G. pectorale or that P. morum has a less stable genome. In either case, the biogeographic distribution of certain syngens may reflect climatological changes of the past.     

A SIMPLIFIED,RAPID METHOD FOR IDENTIFYING MATING TYPE IN ALGAE: RESULTS WITH THE PANDORINA MORUM (CHLOROPHYCEAE) SPECIES COMPLEX1

As a collection expands, increasing numbers of test crosses are required to identify new isolates in algal species containing numerous pairs of mating types. A short-cut is described that utilizes a reduced number of preliminary test crosses. The method was used successfully with the colonial green flagellate, Pandorina morum Bory de St. Vincent, to identify a new pair of milling types (syngen) from Japan and five new isolates from China of a previously known syngen. When tested on the 20 previously described syngens, it revealed one unexpected multi-clone effect on mating. The method should be valuable for identifying newly collected clones, examining potential, interactions among incompatible mating types, and for screening other highly specific inter-organism interactions such as host-parasite infections.     

The Purification of DNA from the Genomes of Paramecium aurelia and Tetrahymena pyriformis1

SYNOPSIS. Methods are described for the recovery of highly purified DNA from Paramecium aurelia and Tetrahymena pyriformis in high yields. Our DNA is only slightly contaminated with RNA and carbohydrate, and little or no protein can be detected. We could not reduce the RNA (orcinol-positive material) by further treatment (sephadex or hydroxyapatite chromatography and preparative CsCl gradients). At the extreme our DNA is contaminated with 15–20% RNA but the real value is most likely considerably lower than this. The DNA we have prepared from Paramecium and Tetrahymena shows all the properties of double-stranded, high molecular weight DNA when characterized by temperature melting, CsCl density gradient centrifugation and hydroxyapatite and sephadex chromatography. When denatured, it absorbs to nitrocellulose filters. The 2 major results of importance from our work reported here are: (1) There is similarity in base composition of DNA from different syngens of Paramecium (28% G+C for syngens 1, 2, 4, 5, and 9 and 29–30% G+C for syngen 8) while there is variation between the syngens of Tetrahymena (24–31% G+C for syngens 1, 4, 7, 10, 11, and 12); (2) the density of any Paramecium DNA varies depending upon whether the cells are grown in the presence of bacteria or in axenic medium. Our results are compatible with observations previously reported for Tetrahymena but contradict those made for Paramecium. The earlier reports of differences in base composition between syngens of Paramecium are probably due in large part to the use of stocks grown on bacteria.     

Intersyngenic variations in the esterases of bacterized Paramecium aurelia

The esterase isozymes were surveyed in bacterized stocks representative of all 14 syngens of Paramecium aurelia by starch gel electrophoresis. The properties of substrate specificity and independent variation of particular isozymes permit the ordering of the differences observed among stocks. Differences can arise from several sources: bacterial variation, intrasyngenic variation, and intersyngenic variation. Bacterial esterases tend to be found in certain zonal areas (see Rowe et al., 1971) and produce minor stock differences, which are erratic in their distribution. Unlike the situation found in Tetrahymena pyriformis, major intrasyngenic variations are rare in P. aurelia except in syngen 2. This lack of intrasyngenic variation is significant in view of the wide differences in geographic origin and micronuclear chromosome numbers among stocks within a syngen. It suggests that certain esterase genotypes must be under stringent selection within a syngen. The lack of intrasyngenic variation permits assessment of intersyngenic relationships. Syngens differ in a complex way from each other, suggesting that several gene differences may be involved. The syngens can be classified on the basis of their esterases. Syngens which have been shown to be more closely related in terms of cross-mating, breeding systems, and other criteria tend to be more similar in their esterase isozymes. The isozyme technique confirms relationships previously suggested among syngens and offers the promise of eventual assessment of evolutionary distances among syngens. However, establishment of these relationships will be clearer in the absence of bacteria.Supported by a Research Grant, GM-15879, from the National Institute of General Medical Sciences, U.S. Public Health Service     

Cortical Patterns in Two Syngens of Glaucoma*

SYNOPSIS. Strains of 2 syngens of Glaucoma (16) were found to have different cortical characteristics. All clones of a particular strain had approximately the same range of corticotypes, approximately the same means and high and very similar variances. The chief differences between the syngens was the corticotypic range. The patterns of variation of cortical elements of syngen 2 appeared to be primarily extensions of the patterns of syngen 1. The range of meridian numbers of different species of Glaucoma overlapped with each other and could not be distinguished by this criterion alone.     

Enzyme variation between syngens in Paramecium aurelia

Five enzymes (succinic dehydrogenase isocitrate dehydrogenase, glutamate dehydrogenase, -hydroxybutyrate dehydrogenase, and fumarase) in the ciliate Paramecium aurelia have been examined by starch gel electrophoresis. Relatively few variants were found among stocks belonging to a given syngen and only in two out of the five enzymes studied. Comparison of stocks belonging to different syngens, however, revealed many enzyme differences, which did not resemble intrasyngen variants. By studying the electrophoretic patterns of the enzymes of the 14 described syngens of Paramecium aurelia, it was found that only two syngens (Nos. 1 and 5) were indistinguishable. It is concluded that the use of starch gel electrophoresis of suitable enzymes provides a method of assigning a stock of paramecia to its syngen. Such a method may, in some cases, be less laborious than the standard one of making test matings and would, of course, be available for organisms which show no mating reaction.This work was carried out during the tenure of an M.R.C. Postgraduate Research Scholarship, and forms part of the material for a Ph.D. thesis at the University of Edinburgh.     

Cortical Characteristics of Strains of Syngens 10, 11 and 12 of Tetrahymena pyriformis*

SYNOPSIS. The patterns of correlation among cortical structures have been examined in strains of 3 additional breeding groups (syngens) of Tetrahymena pyriformis. As in previous studies, many cytogeometric properties were found to vary within a syngen. Surprisingly, one strain of syngen 12 differed from 3 others in the one property previously found to be constant—the pattern of variation of the position of the contractile vacuole pores. This strain may, however, be a sexually cross-reacting representative of still another syngen. This interpretation would preserve the diagnostic value of CVP position, and permit an ordering of syngens in terms of the distance of the CVP's from meridian #1: 1, 3, 7, 6, 8, 11, 12, 9, 2, 5, 4, 10.     

The Axenic Culture of Strains of the Various Syngens of Paramecium aurelia*

SYNOPSIS Strains of the various syngens of Paramecium aurelia respond differently to the culture media developed for Strain 299 of syngen 8. Not only is there a variety of response between the syngens, but strains belonging to the same syngen respond differently to the 3 growth media.     

Esterase Variations between the 14 Syngens of PARAMECIUM AURELIA under Axenic Growth

Under axenic growth all 14 syngens of Paramecium aurelia have 4 types of esterases. The three major types (A, B and cathodal C) vary independently in electrophoretic mobility among the syngens. Using these three esterases, stocks can be keyed to a syngen, except for the groupings 1-3-5 and 7-13. Using 5 other enzymes only syngens 1 and 5 cannot be distinguished. Most syngens differ from each other in 6 out of the 8 enzymes. An axenically-grown stock of Paramecium multimicronucleatum collected in Costa Rica has the same types of esterases as P. aurelia. Two of the types (A and C) are similar in mobility to those found in syngens 7 and 13, but its B esterase differs in mobility from all the known syngens of P. aurelia.     

Comparison of the Esterases and Acid Phosphatases in Paramecium multimicronucleatum,Syngens 1–5, P. jenningsi,P. caudatum,and the P. aurelia Complex1

ABSTRACT. Forty-eight stocks in Paramecium jenningsi, syngens 1–5 of P. multimicronucleatum, P. caudatum, P. primaurelia, P. biaurelia, and P. tetraurelia were grown axenically and tested for their esterases and acid phosphatases using starch gel electrophoresis. The five esterases and the acid phosphatases previously characterized in species of the P. aurelia complex were also found in P. jenningsi, and three to four of the esterases and the acid phosphatases were found in the P. multimicronucleatum species complex and in P. caudatum. Additional subtypes were observed for each of the enzyme phenotypes in these new (though here unnamed) species of Paramecium. Two of the new acid phosphatase subtypes, which depart radically in mobility and in pattern, were found in syngen 3 of P. multimicronucleatum and in P. caudatum. Except for syngens 1 and 5 in P. multimicronucleatum, the degree of similarity between syngens 1, 5 and 2, 3, and 4 appears to be very low—perhaps even lower than that seen for species in the aurelia complex. More realistically, the syngens of P. multimicronucleatum should be considered as separate species although they are not here given separate taxonomic names. Limited sharing of subtypes occurred between species in different species complexes. This observation suggests that the molecular distances between species complexes may be even greater than between species within a complex.     

Genetic control of lactate dehydrogenase isozymes in Paramecium caudatum

The LDH isozymes were surveyed in bacterized cultures of syngens 1, 3, 12, and 13 of Paramecium caudatum by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. All the examined stocks of different syngens except one stock in syngen 3 had a single common LDH isozyme, and intra- and intersyngenic variation was not observed except for the one stock in syngen 3. Breeding data using the exceptional stock indicated that the LDH isozymes of P. caudatum are controlled by two codominant alleles at a single locus whose products aggregate randomly, forming a dimer.     

Intersyngenic variations in the esterases of axenic stocks of Paramecium aurelia

The esterase isozymes were surveyed in axenic stocks of syngens 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, and 8 of Paramecium aurelia by starch gel electrophoresis. In paramecia there appear to be four types of esterases which are clearer in axenic than in bacterized stocks. Each type differs in its substrate specificity and/or its response to the inhibitor eserine sulfate. Minor variations in type D esterases sometimes occur in different extracts of the same stock and may result from changes in the temperature of growth of the cells or growth cycle differences. Differences in the mobility of the A, B, or C (cathodal) types of esterases may occur in different syngens. They also occur for the A and B types among stocks within a syngen, but the frequency is low, except in the case of syngen 2. Since each of the types of esterases varies independently, at least four and possibly more genes appear to specify the esterases in the species complex. Some pairs of syngens vary in their electrophoretic positions for all types of esterases. Other pairs have identical zymograms. This observation suggests that some syngens may differ from each other by as many as four esterase genes, while others may not differ at all. The difference between P. aurelia and Tetrahymena pyriformis in the degree of intrasyngenic variation observed for enzymes is discussed in relation to other types of characters, the organization of the genetic material in the macronucleus, the presence of symbionts, and their breeding systems. It is suggested that enzyme variation is achieved by the action of different selective forces in these two groups of ciliated protozoa.Supported by research grants from the National Institute of General Medical Sciences (GM-15879), U.S. Public Health Service, and from the British Medical Research Council.     

The linear 20 kb mitochondrial genome of Pandorina morum (Volvocaceae,Chlorophyta)

A physical restriction map of the mitochondrial genome from one clone (TCC 854) of the sexually isolated populations (syngens) of the morphologically uniform species Pandorina morum Bory has been constructed using restriction endonucleases Ava I, Bam HI, Bgl II, Eco RI, Kpn I, and Pst I. The 20 kb linear genome can easily be separated from plastid DNA, nuclear satellite rDNA, and main band (nuclear) DNA on a Hoechst/CsCl buoyant density gradient. The Pandorina mitochondrial DNA shows sufficient similarity to the 16 kb mitochondrial genome of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii to cross-hybridize, and also hybridizes with a probe containing maize mitochondrial 18S rRNA genes. Double digests, self-probing, and Bal31 exonuclease experiments suggest that 1.8 to 3.3 kb of sequence is repeated at each end of the genome as an inverted repeat. Mitochondrial genome sizes of other P. morum syngens were found to range from ca. 20 to ca. 38 kb. The mitochondrial genome should be valuable for taxonomic studies; it can be used for comparative organellar studies; and it should be of interest to compare with that of other plant and animal mitochondrial genomes.     

Analysis of natural diversity of symbiotic relationships in the Paramecium bursaria--Holospora curviuscula system

Bacteria of the genus Holospora belong to obligatory endonucleobionts of ciliates of the genus Paramecium. The bacteria show specificity towards the particular host species and the types of nuclei they infect: macro- or micronuclei. During a long-term screening of P. bursaria clones, belonging to three different syngens, Holospora inhibited cells of two syngens only. Using the number of host clones and symbiont isolates, it was shown that H. curviuscula was unable to pass successfully through the syngen barrier even under experimental infection. Considering the species level of specificity in Holospora associations of P. caudatum we suggest the existence of a greater evolutionary divergence in P. bursaria syngens than in syngens of P. caudatum. We have revealed that in incompatible combinations "host clone--symbionts isolate" the complicated bacterial life cycle may be blocked at definite stages depending on genetic features of both partners. Thus, the recognition of the full block spectrum could break the continuous infection process down to independently controlled steps. The block spectrum revealed in the system of P. bursaria--H. curviuscula demonstrates its significant similarity to block spectra of other systems within the Holospora--Paramecium complex. A block of transverse binding formation has been first revealed in Holospora dividing in the nucleus.     

Intersyngenic variations in the esterases and acid phosphatases of Tetrahymena pyriformis

The esterase and acid phosphatase isozymes were surveyed in strains of syngens 2–12 under conditions found to be optimal for syngen 1. Both intersyngenic and intrasyngenic variations were found. Comparisons of the esterases suggest that homologous enzymes are present in certain syngens and that some ordering of the variations with respect to syngen differences is possible. The acid phosphatases are highly polymorphic in different strains even within a syngen, and the variations cannot be ordered with respect to syngen differences. These results are discussed in terms of other types of studies directed at assessing syngen relationships and in terms of the sources of variation. It was concluded that only characters less vulnerable to intraclonal variation will be capable of revealing syngen relationships.Supported by a Research Grant, GM-15879, from the National Institute of General Medical Sciences, U.S. Public Health Service.     

Identification of Paramecium bursaria syngens through molecular markers--comparative analysis of three loci in the nuclear and mitochondrial DNA

This is the first attempt to resolve the phylogenetic relationship between different syngens of Paramecium bursaria and to investigate at a molecular level the intraspecific differentiation of strains originating from very distant geographical locations. Herein we introduce a new collection of five P. bursaria syngens maintained at St Petersburg State University, as the international collection of syngens was lost in the 1960s. To analyze the degree of speciation within Paramecium bursaria, we examined 26 strains belonging to five different syngens from distant and geographically isolated localities using rDNA (ITS1-5.8S-ITS2-5'LSU) fragments, mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI), and H4 gene fragments. It was shown that P. bursaria strains of the same syngens cluster together in all three inferred molecular phylogenies. The genetic diversity among the studied P. bursaria strains based on rDNA sequences was rather low. The COI divergence of Paramecium bursaria was also definitely lower than that observed in the Paramecium aurelia complex. The nucleotide sequences of the H4 gene analyzed in the present study indicate the extent of genetic differences between the syngens of Paramecium bursaria. Our study demonstrates the diagnostic value of molecular markers, which are important tools in the identification of Paramecium bursaria syngens.