Aminoglycoside binding to human and bacterial A-Site rRNA decoding region constructs

The 16S bacterial ribosomal A-site decoding rRNA region is thought to be the pharmacological target for the aminoglycoside antibiotics. The clinical utility of aminoglycosides could possibly depend on the preferential binding of these drugs to the prokaryotic A-site versus the corresponding A-site from eukaryotes. However, quantitative aminoglycoside binding experiments reported here on prokaryotic and eukaryotic A-site RNA constructs show that there is little in the way of differential binding affinities of aminoglycosides for the two targets. The largest difference in affinity is 4-fold in the case of neomycin, with the prokaryotic A-site construct exhibiting the higher binding affinity. Mutational studies revealed that decoding region constructs retaining elements of non-Watson-Crick (WC) base pairing, specifically bound aminoglycosides with affinities in the muM range. These studies are consistent with the idea that aminoglycoside antibiotics can specifically bind to RNA molecules as long as the latter have non-A form structural elements allowing access of aminoglycosides to the narrow major groove.     

Structural origins of aminoglycoside specificity for prokaryotic ribosomes

Aminoglycoside antibiotics, including paromomycin, neomycin and gentamicin, target a region of highly conserved nucleotides in the decoding region aminoacyl-tRNA site (A site) of 16 S rRNA on the 30 S subunit. Change of a single nucleotide, A1408 to G, reduces the affinity of many aminoglycosides for the ribosome; G1408 distinguishes between prokaryotic and eukaryotic ribosomes. The structures of a prokaryotic decoding region A-site oligonucleotide free in solution and bound to the aminoglycosides paromomycin and gentamicin C1a were determined previously. Here, the structure of a eukaryotic decoding region A-site oligonucleotide bound to paromomycin has been determined using NMR spectroscopy and compared to the prokaryotic A-site-paromomycin structure. A conformational change in three adenosine residues of an internal loop, critical for high-affinity antibiotic binding, was observed in the prokaryotic RNA-paromomycin complex in comparison to its free form. This conformational change is not observed in the eukaryotic RNA-paromomycin complex, disrupting the binding pocket for ring I of the antibiotic. The lack of the conformational change supports footprinting and titration calorimetry data that demonstrate approximately 25-50-fold weaker binding of paromomycin to the eukaryotic decoding-site oligonucleotide. Neomycin, which is much less active against Escherichia coli ribosomes with an A1408G mutation, binds non-specifically to the oligonucleotide. These results suggest that eukaryotic ribosomal RNA has a shallow binding pocket for aminoglycosides, which accommodates only certain antibiotics.     

Sequence-specific recognition of the major groove of RNA by deoxystreptamine

Aminoglycoside antibiotics specifically interact with a variety of RNA sequences, and in particular with the decoding region of 16S ribosomal RNA in the aminoacyl tRNA acceptor site (A-site). Ring II of aminoglycosides (2-deoxystreptamine) is the most conserved element among aminoglycoside antibiotics that bind to the A-site. NMR structures of aminoglycoside-A-site RNA complexes suggested that the 2-deoxystreptamine core of aminoglycosides specifically recognizes (5')G-U(3') and potentially (5')G-G(3') or (5')U-G(3') steps in the major groove of RNA. Here, we show that isolated deoxystreptamine specifically interacts with G-U steps within the major groove of the A-site RNA. The bulge residue of A-site RNA is required to open the major groove for accommodation of deoxystreptamine. The chemical groups of deoxystreptamine presented to the RNA by the framework of the 6-carbon ring modulate RNA recognition.     

Structure of a eukaryotic decoding region A-site RNA

The aminoglycoside antibiotics target a region of highly conserved nucleotides in the aminoacyl-tRNA site (A site) of 16 S RNA on the 30 S subunit. The structures of a prokaryotic decoding region A-site oligonucleotide free in solution and bound to the aminoglycosides paromomycin and gentamicin C1A have been determined. Here, the structure of a eukaryotic decoding region A-site oligonucleotide has been determined using homonuclear and heteronuclear NMR spectroscopy, and compared to the unbound prokaryotic rRNA structure. The two structures are similar, with a U1406-U1495 base-pair, a C1407-G1494 Watson-Crick base-pair, and a G1408-A1493 base-pair instead of the A1408-A1493 base-pair of the prokaryotic structure. The two structures differ in the orientation of the 1408 position with respect to A1493; G1408 is rotated toward the major groove, which is the binding pocket for aminoglycosides. The structures also differ in the stacking geometry of G1494 on A1493, which could have slight long-range conformational effects.     

A molecular dynamics simulation study of an aminoglycoside/A-site RNA complex: conformational and hydration patterns

Aminoglycoside antibiotics interfere with the translation mechanism by binding to the tRNA decoding site of the 16S ribosomal RNA. Crystallographic structures of aminoglycosides bound to A-site systems clarified many static aspects of RNA-ligand interactions. To gain some insight on the dynamic aspects of recognition phenomena, we conducted molecular dynamics simulations of the aminoglycoside paromomycin bound to a eubacterial ribosomal decoding A-site oligonucleotide. Results from 25 ns of simulation time revealed that: (i) the neamine part of the antibiotic represents the main anchor for binding, (ii) additional sugar rings provide limited and fragile contacts, (iii) long-resident water molecules present at the drug/RNA interface are involved in the recognition phenomena. The combination of MD simulations together with systematic structural information offers striking insights into the molecular recognition processes underlying RNA/aminoglycoside binding. Important methodological considerations related to the use of medium resolution starting structures and associated sampling problems are thoroughly discussed.     

Specific binding of Hoechst 33258 to site 1 thymidylate synthase mRNA

The translational initiator codon in thymidylate synthetase (TS) mRNA is located in a stem–loop structure with a CC bubble. TS is an important target for anticancer drugs. Aminoglycoside antibiotics have been shown to specifically bind to TS mRNA site 1 constructs and, furthermore, specific binding requires the non-duplex CC bubble region. It is shown here that DNA intercalating agents and DNA minor groove-binding drugs also bind to a TS mRNA site 1 construct. This binding is competitive with aminoglycosides, suggesting that the binding sites overlap. Hoechst 33258 binds with a dissociation constant of 60 nM, a value significantly lower than the ~1 µM values found for aminoglycosides. Footprinting and direct binding studies show that the CC bubble is important for binding of the Hoechst compound. However, the exact structure of the bubble is unimportant. Interestingly, mutations in regions adjacent to the bulge also affect binding. These studies point to the important role of non-duplex RNA structures in binding of the DNA minor groove binder Hoechst 33258.     

Decoding region bubble size and aminoglycoside antibiotic binding

Aminoglycoside antibiotics promiscuously bind to structurally diverse RNA molecules containing internal bubbles and bulges with affinities in the microM range. An interesting exception is found in the human 12S mitochondrial decoding region where aminoglycoside binding, unlike in the case of its bacterial and human cytoplasmic counterparts, is absent. Mutations that reduce the size of the bubble in the 12S decoding region immediately restore aminoglycoside binding, giving the system chemical switch like behavior.     

Enhanced binding of aminoglycoside dimers to a "dimerized" A-site 16S rRNA construct

In this work, we investigated the binding of a series of dimeric aminoglycoside molecules to (i) a 27 nt A-site 16S rRNA construct, and (ii) an artificially grafted 46 nt 'dimerized' A-site 16S rRNA construct. It was observed that the dissociation constants of dimeric aminoglycosides to the dimerized A-site 16S rRNA construct can achieve up to approximately 19-fold enhancement compared to the monomeric aminoglycoside molecules.     

Genetic reconstruction of protozoan rRNA decoding sites provides a rationale for paromomycin activity against Leishmania and Trypanosoma

Aminoglycoside antibiotics target the ribosomal decoding A-site and are active against a broad spectrum of bacteria. These compounds bind to a highly conserved stem-loop-stem structure in helix 44 of bacterial 16S rRNA. One particular aminoglycoside, paromomycin, also shows potent antiprotozoal activity and is used for the treatment of parasitic infections, e.g. by Leishmania spp. The precise drug target is, however, unclear; in particular whether aminoglycoside antibiotics target the cytosolic and/or the mitochondrial protozoan ribosome. To establish an experimental model for the study of protozoan decoding-site function, we constructed bacterial chimeric ribosomes where the central part of bacterial 16S rRNA helix 44 has been replaced by the corresponding Leishmania and Trypanosoma rRNA sequences. Relating the results from in-vitro ribosomal assays to that of in-vivo aminoglycoside activity against Trypanosoma brucei, as assessed in cell cultures and in a mouse model of infection, we conclude that aminoglycosides affect cytosolic translation while the mitochondrial ribosome of trypanosomes is not a target for aminoglycoside antibiotics.     

Basis for prokaryotic specificity of action of aminoglycoside antibiotics.

The aminoglycosides, a group of structurally related antibiotics, bind to rRNA in the small subunit of the prokaryotic ribosome. Most aminoglycosides are inactive or weakly active against eukaryotic ribosomes. A major difference in the binding site for these antibiotics between prokaryotic and eukaryotic ribosomes is the identity of the nucleotide at position 1408 (Escherichia coli numbering), which is an adenosine in prokaryotic ribosomes and a guanosine in eukaryotic ribosomes. Expression in E.coli of plasmid-encoded 16S rRNA containing an A1408 to G substitution confers resistance to a subclass of the aminoglycoside antibiotics that contain a 6' amino group on ring I. Chemical footprinting experiments indicate that resistance arises from the lower affinity of the drug for the eukaryotic rRNA sequence. The 1408G ribosomes are resistant to the same subclass of aminoglycosides as previously observed both for eukaryotic ribosomes and bacterial ribosomes containing a methylation at the N1 position of A1408. The results indicate that the identity of the nucleotide at position 1408 is a major determinant of specificity of aminoglycoside action, and agree with prior structural studies of aminoglycoside-rRNA complexes.     

Monitoring aminoglycoside-induced conformational changes in 16S rRNA through acrylamide quenching

Fluorescence of 2-aminopurine (2AP)-substituted A-site and acrylamide quenching were used to study the interactions of paromomycin and neamine with the decoding region of 16S rRNA. The results reveal that paromomycin binding to the A-site RNA leads to increased exposure of residue A1492. In contrast, neamine has little effect on the solvent accessibility of A1492. Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry was used to compare the affinity of paromomycin with the A-site and 2-AP-substituted A-site RNAs.     

A structure-based strategy to identify new molecular scaffolds targeting the bacterial ribosomal A-site

The need for novel antibiotics is widely recognized. A well validated target of antibiotics is the bacterial ribosome. Recent X-ray structures of the ribosome bound to antibiotics have shed new light on the binding sites of these antibiotics, providing fresh impetus for structure-based strategies aiming at identifying new ribosomal ligands. In that respect, the ribosomal decoding region of the aminoacyl-tRNA acceptor site (A-site) is of particular interest because oligonucleotide model systems of this site are available for crystallography, NMR and compound binding assays. This work presents how these different resources can be combined in a hierarchical screening strategy which has led to the identification of new A-site ligands. The approach exploits an X-ray structure of the A-site against which large and diverse libraries of compounds were computationally docked. The complementarity of the compounds to the A-site was assessed using a scoring function specifically calibrated for RNA targets. Starting from approximately 1 million compounds, the computational selection of candidate ligands allowed us to focus the experimental work on 129 compounds, 34 of which showed affinity for the A-site in a FRET-based binding assay. NMR experiments confirmed binding to the A-site for some compounds. For the most potent compound in the FRET assay, a tentative binding mode is suggested, which is compatible with the NMR data and the limited SAR in this series. Overall, the results validate the screening strategy.     

RNA aptamers that specifically bind to a 16S ribosomal RNA decoding region construct

RNA–RNA recognition is a critical process in controlling many key biological events, such as translation and ribozyme functions. The recognition process governing RNA–RNA interactions can involve complementary Watson–Crick (WC) base pair binding, or can involve binding through tertiary structural interaction. Hence, it is of interest to determine which of the RNA–RNA binding events might emerge through an in vitro selection process. The A-site of the 16S rRNA decoding region was chosen as the target, both because it possesses several different RNA structural motifs, and because it is the rRNA site where codon/anticodon recognition occurs requiring recognition of both mRNA and tRNA. It is shown here that a single family of RNA molecules can be readily selected from two different sizes of RNA library. The tightest binding aptamer to the A-site 16S rRNA construct, 109.2-3, has its consensus sequences confined to a stem–loop region, which contains three nucleotides complementary to three of the four nucleotides in the stem–loop region of the A-site 16S rRNA. Point mutations on each of the three nucleotides on the stem–loop of the aptamer abolish its binding capacity. These studies suggest that the RNA aptamer 109.2-3 interacts with the simple 27 nt A-site decoding region of 16S rRNA through their respective stem–loops. The most probable mode of interaction is through complementary WC base pairing, commonly referred to as a loop–loop ‘kissing’ motif. High affinity binding to the other structural motifs in the decoding region were not observed.     

The ribosomal A-site as an inspiration for the design of RNA binders

The specific binding of aminoglycoside antibiotics to the bacterial ribosomal decoding site (A-site) has inspired the study of RNA-small molecules interactions and the search for novel RNA binders. Among the numerous RNA targets studied so far, the A-site holds a unique place. It is among the few truly validated RNA targets for which naturally occurring ligands have been discovered as "cognate" binders. In addition, due to its encapsulating architecture, the A-site is a more discriminating RNA target when compared to other RNA sequences. Previous observations and current challenges for the designers of potent and specific RNA binders are discussed.     

Rigid spiroethers targeting the decoding center of the bacterial ribosome

Continuing our efforts towards understanding the principles governing ribosomal recognition and function, we have synthesized and evaluated a series of diversely functionalized 5,6-, 6,6- and 7,6-spiroethers. These compounds successfully mimic natural aminoglycosides regarding their binding to the decoding center of the bacterial ribosome. Their potential to inhibit prokaryotic protein production in vitro along with their antibacterial potencies have also been examined.     

Defining the basis for the specificity of aminoglycoside-rRNA recognition: a comparative study of drug binding to the A sites of Escherichia coli and human rRNA

2-Deoxystreptamine (2-DOS) aminoglycoside antibiotics exert their antimicrobial activities by targeting the decoding region A site of the rRNA and inhibiting protein synthesis. A prokaryotic specificity of action is critical to therapeutic utility of 2-DOS aminoglycosides as antibiotics. Here, isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) and fluorescence studies are presented that provide insight into the molecular basis for this prokaryotic specificity of action. Specifically, the rRNA binding properties of the 2-DOS aminoglycosides paromomycin and G418 (geneticin) are compared, using both human and Escherichia coli rRNA A site model oligonucleotides as drug targets. Paromomycin and G418 differ with respect to their specificities of action, with only paromomycin exhibiting a specificity for prokaryotic versus human ribosomes. G418 binds to both the human and E. coli rRNA A sites with a markedly lower affinity than paromomycin, with the affinities of both drugs for the human rRNA A site being lower than those they exhibit for the E. coli rRNA A site. Paromomycin induces the destacking of the base at position 1492 (by E. coli numbering) upon binding to the E. coli rRNA A site, but not the human rRNA A site. By contrast, the binding of G418 induces the destacking of base 1492 when either rRNA A site serves as the drug target. In the aggregate, these results suggest that binding-induced base destacking at the rRNA A site is a critical factor in determining the prokaryotic specificity of aminoglycoside action, with binding affinity for the A site being of secondary importance.     

Aminoglycosides versus bacteria – a description of the action, resistance mechanism, and nosocomial battleground

Since 1944, we have come a long way using aminoglycosides as antibiotics. Bacteria also have got them selected with hardier resistance mechanisms. Aminoglycosides are aminocyclitols that kill bacteria by inhibiting protein synthesis as they bind to the 16S rRNA and by disrupting the integrity of bacterial cell membrane. Aminoglycoside resistance mechanisms include: (a) the deactivation of aminoglycosides by N-acetylation, adenylylation or O-phosphorylation, (b) the reduction of the intracellular concentration of aminoglycosides by changes in outer membrane permeability, decreased inner membrane transport, active efflux, and drug trapping, (c) the alteration of the 30S ribosomal subunit target by mutation, and (d) methylation of the aminoglycoside binding site. There is an alarming increase in resistance outbreaks in hospital setting. Our review explores the molecular understanding of aminoglycoside action and resistance with an aim to minimize the spread of resistance.     

Thermodynamics of aminoglycoside-rRNA recognition: the binding of neomycin-class aminoglycosides to the A site of 16S rRNA

We use spectroscopic and calorimetric techniques to characterize the binding of the aminoglycoside antibiotics neomycin, paromomycin, and ribostamycin to a RNA oligonucleotide that models the A-site of Escherichia coli 16S rRNA. Our results reveal the following significant features: (i) Aminoglycoside binding enhances the thermal stability of the A-site RNA duplex, with the extent of this thermal enhancement decreasing with increasing pH and/or Na(+) concentration. (ii) The RNA binding enthalpies of the aminoglycosides become more exothermic (favorable) with increasing pH, an observation consistent with binding-linked protonation of one or more drug amino groups. (iii) Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) studies conducted as a function of buffer reveal that aminoglycoside binding to the host RNA is linked to the uptake of protons, with the number of linked protons being dependent on pH. Specifically, increasing the pH results in a corresponding increase in the number of linked protons. (iv) ITC studies conducted at 25 and 37 degrees C reveal that aminoglycoside-RNA complexation is associated with a negative heat capacity change (Delta C(p)), the magnitude of which becomes greater with increasing pH. (v) The observed RNA binding affinities of the aminoglycosides decrease with increasing pH and/or Na(+) concentration. In addition, the thermodynamic forces underlying these RNA binding affinities also change as a function of pH. Specifically, with increasing pH, the enthalpic contribution to the observed RNA binding affinity increases, while the corresponding entropic contribution to binding decreases. (vi) The affinities of the aminoglycosides for the host RNA follow the hierarchy neomycin > paromomycin > ribostamycin. The enhanced affinity of neomycin relative to either paromomycin or ribostamycin is primarily, if not entirely, enthalpic in origin. (vii) The salt dependencies of the RNA binding affinities of neomycin and paromomycin are consistent with at least three drug NH(3)(+) groups participating in electrostatic interactions with the host RNA. In the aggregate, our results reveal the impact of specific alterations in aminoglycoside structure on the thermodynamics of binding to an A-site model RNA oligonucleotide. Such systematic comparative studies are critical first steps toward establishing the thermodynamic database required for enhancing our understanding of the molecular forces that dictate and control aminoglycoside recognition of RNA.     

Universal dissymmetry and the origin of biomolecular chirality

Handed systems are distributed over four general domains. These span the fundamental particles, the molecular enantiomers, the crystal enantiomorphs, and the spiral galaxies. The characterisation of the molecular enantiomers followed from the identification of the crystal enantiomorphs and revealed a chiral homogeneity in the biomolecules of the organic world. The origin of the homogeneity has been variously ascribed to a universal dissymmetric force, from Pasteur, or to a chance choice of the initial enantiomer perpetuated by the stereoselection of diastereomer production with recycling, from Fischer's "key and lock" hypothesis. The classical chiral fields identified by Curie require a particular time or location on the Earth's surface for a determinate molecular enantioselection, as do the weak charged current agencies of the non-classical weak interaction. The weak neutral current of the electroweak interaction provides a constant and uniform chiral agency which favours both the L-series of amino acids and polypeptides and the parent aldotriose of the D-series of sugars. The enantiomeric bias of the electroweak interaction is small at the molecular level: it may become significant either as a trigger-perturbation guiding the transition from a metastable autocatalytic racemic process to one of the two constituent enantiomeric reaction channels, or by cumulative amplification in a large chirally-homogeneous aggregate of enantiomer units.     

Substrate specificities and structure-activity relationships for the nucleotidylation of antibiotics catalyzed by aminoglycoside nucleotidyltransferase 2'-I

Aminoglycoside nucleotidyltransferase 2'-I (formerly gentamicin adenylyltransferase) conveys antibiotic resistance to Gram-negative bacteria by transfer of AMP to the 2'-hydroxyl group of 4,6-substituted deoxystreptamine-containing aminoglycosides. The kinetics constants of thirteen aminoglycoside antibiotics and the magnesium chelates of eight nucleotide triphosphates were determined with purified enzyme. Eleven of the antibiotics exhibit substrate inhibition attributed to secondary binding of the aminoglycoside to an enzyme-AMP-aminoglycoside complex. Maximal velocities vary by only 4-fold, versus variation of values of Vmax/Km for the aminoglycosides of nearly 4000-fold, consistent with a Theorell-Chance kinetic mechanism as proposed for this enzyme [Gates, C. A., & Northrop, D. B. (1988) Biochemistry (second of three papers in this issue)] with the added specification that the binding of aminoglycosides is in rapid equilibrium. Under these conditions, Vmax/Km becomes kcat/Kd, where kcat is the net rate constant for catalysis (but not turnover) and Kd is the dissociation constant of aminoglycosides from a complex with enzyme and nucleotide. Values of kcat fall closely together into three distinct sets, with the 3',4'-dideoxygentamicins greater than gentamicins greater than kanamycins. These sets reflect unusual structure-activity correlations which are specific for catalysis but have nothing to do with the maximal velocity of this enzyme.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)