Foreword to ‘Multiscale structural biology: biophysical principles and mechanisms underlying the action of bio-nanomachines’, a special issue in Honour of Fumio Arisaka’s 70th birthday

This issue of Biophysical Reviews, titled ‘Multiscale structural biology: biophysical principles and mechanisms underlying the action of bio-nanomachines’, is a collection of articles dedicated in honour of Professor Fumio Arisaka’s 70th birthday. Initially, working in the fields of haemocyanin and actin filament assembly, Fumio went on to publish important work on the elucidation of structural and functional aspects of T4 phage biology. As his career has transitioned levels of complexity from proteins (hemocyanin) to large protein complexes (actin) to even more massive bio-nanomachinery (phage), it is fitting that the subject of this special issue is similarly reflective of his multiscale approach to structural biology. This festschrift contains articles spanning biophysical structure and function from the bio-molecular through to the bio-nanomachine level.     

Bacteriophage T4 baseplate components. III. Location and properties of the bacteriophage structural thymidylate synthetase.

Two T4D thymidylate synthetase (td) temperature-sensitive mutants have been isolated and characterized. Both mutants produce heat-labile phage particles. This observation supports the view that this viral-induced protein is a phage structural component. Further, antiserum to td has been shown to block a specific step in tail plate morphogenesis. The results indicated that the td protein is largely covered by the T4D tail plate gene 11 protein. Since the phageinduced dihydrofolate reductase (dfr) also is partially covered by the gene 11 protein, it appears that td was adjacent to the tail plate dfr. This location has been confirmed by constructing a T4D mutant which is dfrtstdts and showing that these two tail plate constituents interact and give altered physical properties to the phage particles produced. A structural relationship for the tail plate folate, dfr, and td has been reported.     

Bacteriophage T4 baseplate components. II. Binding and location of bacteriophage-induced dihydrofolate reductase.

The location of T4D phage-induced dihydrofolate reductase (dfr) has been determined in intact and incomplete phage particles. It has been found that phage mutants inducing a temperature-sensitive dfr (dfrts) procude heat-labile phage particles. The structural dfr produced by these ts mutants was shown to assume different configurations depending on the temperature at which the phage is assembled. Morphogenesis of incomplete phage particles lacking the gene 11 protein on their baseplates was found to be inhibited by reagents binding to dfr, such as antibodies to dfr. Further, cofactor molecules for dfr, such as reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate and reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide, also inhibited the step in morphogenesis involving the addition of gene 11 product. On the other hand, inhibitors of dfr, such as adenosine dephosphoribose, stimulated the addition of the gene 11 protein. It has been concluded that the phage-induced dfr is a baseplate component which is partially covered by the gene 11 protein. The properties of phage particles produced after infection of the nonpermissive host with the one known T4D mutant containing a nonsense mutation in its dfr gene suggested that these progeny particles contained a partial polypeptide, which was large enough to serve as a structural element.     

An open reading frame in the Escherichia coli bacteriophage lambda genome encodes a protein that functions in assembly of the long tail fibers of bacteriophage T4.

Assembly of the long tail fibers of the Escherichia coli bacteriophage T4 requires the catalytic action of two auxiliary proteins. It was found that a gene of the entirely unrelated phage lambda codes for a protein which can substitute for one of these T4 polypeptides, protein 38. The lambda gene was designated tfa (tail fiber assembly). Protein 38 consists of 183 residues, and the Tfa protein consists of 194 residues; the two polypeptides are about 40% homologous. Although the tfa gene is dispensable for the growth of phage lambda, these results indicate that it may have a function in lambda morphogenesis.     

NMR Structure of a Monomeric Intermediate on the Evolutionarily Optimized Assembly Pathway of a Small Trimerization Domain

Efficient formation of specific intermolecular interactions is essential for self-assembly of biological structures. The foldon domain is an evolutionarily optimized trimerization module required for assembly of the large, trimeric structural protein fibritin from phage T4. Monomers consisting of the 27 amino acids comprising a single foldon domain subunit spontaneously form a natively folded trimer. During assembly of the foldon domain, a monomeric intermediate is formed on the submillisecond time scale, which provides the basis for two consecutive very fast association reactions. Mutation of an intermolecular salt bridge leads to a monomeric protein that resembles the kinetic intermediate in its spectroscopic properties. NMR spectroscopy revealed essentially native topology of the monomeric intermediate with defined hydrogen bonds and side-chain interactions but largely reduced stability compared to the native trimer. This structural preorganization leads to an asymmetric charge distribution on the surface that can direct rapid subunit recognition. The low stability of the intermediate allows a large free-energy gain upon trimerization, which serves as driving force for rapid assembly. These results indicate different free-energy landscapes for folding of small oligomeric proteins compared to monomeric proteins, which typically avoid the transient population of intermediates.     

The solution structure of the bacteriophage lambda head-tail joining protein,gpFII

The bacteriophage lambda FII protein (gpFII) is a 117 residue structural protein found in the phage particle that is required for the joining of phage heads and tails at the last step of morphogenesis. We have performed biophysical experiments to show that gpFII is stable, monomeric, and reversibly folded. We have also determined the atomic resolution structure of gpFII using NMR spectroscopy. gpFII is shown to possess a novel fold consisting of seven beta-strands and a short alpha-helix. It also displays two large unstructured regions at the N terminus (residues 1-24) and in a large loop near the middle of the protein (residues 46-62). We speculate that these unstructured regions become structured when gpFII assembles into the phage particle, and that these conformational changes play an important role in regulating the assembly pathway. Alignment of the gpFII sequence with those of homologues from other lambdoid phages has allowed us to putatively identify distinct surfaces on the gpFII structure that mediate binding to the phage head and tail.     

1H, 15N and 13C resonance assignments of PpdD,a type IV pilin from enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli

Bacterial type 4 pili (T4P) are long flexible fibers involved in adhesion, DNA uptake, phage transduction, aggregation and a flagella-independent movement called “twitching motility”. T4P comprise thousands of copies of the major pilin subunit, which is initially inserted in the plasma membrane, processed and assembled into dynamic helical filaments. T4P are crucial for host colonization and virulence of many Gram-negative bacteria. In enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli the T4P, called hemorrhagic coli pili (HCP) promote cell adhesion, motility, biofilm formation and signaling. To understand the mechanism of HCP assembly and function, we analyzed the structure of the major subunit prepilin peptidase-dependent protein D (PpdD) (also called HcpA), a 15 kDa pilin with two potential disulfide bonds. Here we present the ¹H, ¹⁵N and ¹³C backbone and side chain resonance assignments of the C-terminal globular domain of PpdD as a first step to its structural determination.     

Bacteriophage T5 structure reveals similarities with HK97 and T4 suggesting evolutionary relationships

Evolutionary relationships between viruses may be obscure by protein sequence but unmasked by structure. Analysis of bacteriophage T5 by cryo-electron microscopy and protein sequence analysis reveals analogies with HK97 and T4 that suggest a mosaic of such connections. The T5 capsid is consistent with the HK97 capsid protein fold but has a different geometry, incorporating three additional hexamers on each icosahedral facet. Similarly to HK97, the T5 major capsid protein has an N-terminal extension, or Delta-domain that is missing in the mature capsid, and by analogy with HK97, may function as an assembly or scaffold domain. This Delta-domain is predicted to be largely coiled-coil, as for that of HK97, but is approximately 70% longer correlating with the larger capsid. Thus, capsid architecture appears likely to be specified by the Delta-domain. Unlike HK97, the T5 capsid binds a decoration protein in the center of each hexamer similarly to the "hoc" protein of phage T4, suggesting a common role for these molecules. The tail-tube has unusual trimeric symmetry that may aid in the unique two-stage DNA-ejection process, and joins the tail-tip at a disk where tail fibers attach. This intriguing mix of characteristics embodied by phage T5 offers insights into virus assembly, subunit function, and the evolutionary connections between related viruses.     

Bacteriophage Tail Components: II. Dihydrofolate Reductase in T4D Bacteriophage

The protein component of the T-even bacteriophage coat which binds the phage-specific dihydropteroyl polyglutamate has been identified as the phage-induced dihydrofolate reductase. Dihydrofolate reductase activity has been found in highly purified preparations of T-even phage ghosts and phage substructures after partial denaturation. The highest specific enzymatic activity was found in purified tail plate preparations, and it was concluded that this enzyme was a structural component of the phage tail plate. Phage viability was directly correlated with the enzymological properties of the phage tail plate dihydrofolate reductase. All reactions catalyzed by this enzyme which changed the oxidation state of the phage dihydrofolate also inactivated the phage. Properties of two T4D dihydrofolate reductase-negative mutants, wh1 and wh11, have been examined. Various lines of evidence support the view that the product of the wh locus of the phage genome is normally incorporated into the phage tail structure. The effects of various dihydrofolate reductase inhibitors on phage assembly in in vitro complementation experiments with various extracts of conditional lethal T4D mutants have been examined. These inhibitors were found to specifically block complementation when added to extracts which did not contain preformed tail plates. If tail plates were present, inhibitors such as aminopterin, did not affect further phage assembly. This specific inhibition of tail plate formation in vitro confirms the analytical and genetic evidence that this phage-induced "early" enzyme is a component of the phage coat.     

Common components in the assembly of type 4 fimbriae, DNA transfer systems, filamentous phage and protein-secretion apparatus: a general system for the formation of surface-associated protein complexes

The Pseudomonas aeruginosa genes pilB-D and pilQ are necessary for the assembly of type 4 fimbriae. Homologues of these genes and of the subunit (pilin) gene have been described in various different bacterial species, but not always in association with type 4 fimbrial biosynthesis and function. Pil-like proteins are also involved in protein secretion, DNA transfer by conjugation and transformation, and morphogenesis of filamentous bacteriophages. It seems likely that the Pil homologues function in the processing and export of proteins resembling type 4 fimbrial sub-units, and in their organization into fimbrial-like structures. These may either be true type 4 fimbriae, or components of protein complexes which act in the transport of macromolecules (DNA or protein) into or out of the cell. Some PilB-like and PilQ-like proteins are apparently also involved in the assembly of non-type 4 polymeric structures (filamentous phage virions and conjugative pili). The diverse studies summarized in this review are providing insight into an extensive infrastructural system which appears to be utilized in the formation of a variety of cell surface-associated complexes.     

Large Terminase Conformational Change Induced by Connector Binding in Bacteriophage T7

During bacteriophage morphogenesis DNA is translocated into a preformed prohead by the complex formed by the portal protein, or connector, plus the terminase, which are located at an especial prohead vertex. The terminase is a powerful motor that converts ATP hydrolysis into mechanical movement of the DNA. Here, we have determined the structure of the T7 large terminase by electron microscopy. The five terminase subunits assemble in a toroid that encloses a channel wide enough to accommodate dsDNA. The structure of the complete connector-terminase complex is also reported, revealing the coupling between the terminase and the connector forming a continuous channel. The structure of the terminase assembled into the complex showed a different conformation when compared with the isolated terminase pentamer. To understand in molecular terms the terminase morphological change, we generated the terminase atomic model based on the crystallographic structure of its phage T4 counterpart. The docking of the threaded model in both terminase conformations showed that the transition between the two states can be achieved by rigid body subunit rotation in the pentameric assembly. The existence of two terminase conformations and its possible relation to the sequential DNA translocation may shed light into the molecular bases of the packaging mechanism of bacteriophage T7.     

Bacteriophage-coded thymidylate synthetase. Evidence that the T4 enzyme is a capsid protein

It has previously been shown that T4 bacteriophage-coded dihydrofolate reductase is a capsid protein, specifically an element of the tail plate. This paper presents evidence that thymidylate synthetase is also a structural protein. Antiserum prepared against purified T4 thymidylate synthetase neutralizes T4 infectivity. Evidence is presented that structural thymidylate synthetase is the target of the antiphage component of the serum.The td gene in T4 codes for thymidylate synthetase. We have crossed the td gene from phage T6 into T4 and eliminated other T6 genetic material from the hybrid phage by extensive backcrossing. The hybrid phage, T4td^T6, is inactivated at 60 °C significantly more rapidly than the parent phage, T4D. Thus, the td gene is a determinant of a physical property of the virion, providing direct confirmation that thymidylate synthetase is a capsid protein. At present the role of the virion-bound enzyme is unknown.     

Location of the ss--mutation of bacteriophage T7 in genes 10, the structural gene for the major capsid protein.

T7+ phage are unable to plate on a strain of Shigella sonnei D2 371-48. Spontaneous phage mutants arise (ss--mutants) that are able to plate on this strain of Shigella. We have shown by complementation studies and genetic crosses that the ss--mutation maps in gene 10, the structural gene for the major protein of the capsid. This finding implies that the gene 10 protein may interact with a host protein during phage development and that the abortive infection of T7 observed in S. sonnei D2 371-48 with T7+ phage may be a defect in head morphogenesis. Our studies also reveal that various T7 strains commonly contain deletions in nonessential regions. T7 ss--mutants selected after growth of T7+ on Shigella D2 371-48 often acquire a deletion in the 0.7 gene that is not necessary for the ss--phenotype. Finally, we have found a new nonessential region of the T7 chromosome that is located between 33 and 35.5% of the T7 genome length.     

Use of phage display and high-density screening for the isolation of an antibody against the 51-kDa subunit of complex I

Monoclonal antibodies play an increasingly important role in structural biology. In this report, we develop the use of phage display technology for the isolation of an antibody that binds to a specific subunit of a macromolecular assembly. Antibodies that bind to the intact complex are selected from a phage display library and screened with a high-density Western blot to identify a subunit-specific binder. Conventional Western blotting and competition ELISA are then used to confirm the identity of the target subunit and that the antibody binds to the native protein complex and not to an epitope that is only revealed when the antibody is immobilized for phage selection. Using this technique, monoclonal scFv and Fab fragments have been produced that bind to the 51-kDa subunit of bovine complex I, a large integral membrane protein complex from mitochondria.     

Membrane-associated assembly of a phage T4 DNA entrance vertex structure studied with expression vectors

The DNA entrance vertex of the phage head is critical for prohead assembly and DNA packaging. A single structural protein comprises this dodecameric ring substructure of the prohead. Assembly of the phage T4 prohead occurs on the cytoplasmic membrane through a specific attachment at or near the gp20 DNA entrance vertex. An auxiliary head assembly gene product, gp40, was hypothesized to be involved in assembling the gp20 substructure. T4 genes 20, 40 and 20 + 40 were cloned into expression vectors under lambda pL promoter control. The corresponding T4 gene products were synthesized in high yield and were active as judged by their ability to complement the corresponding infecting T4 mutants in vivo. The cloned T4 gene 20 and gene 40 products were inserted into the cytoplasmic membrane as integral membrane proteins; however, gp20 was inserted into the membrane only when gp40 was also synthesized, whereas gp40 was inserted in the presence or absence of gp20. The gp20 insertion required a membrane potential, was not dependent upon the Escherichia coli groE gene, and assumed a defined membrane-spanning conformation, as judged by specific protease fragments protected by the membrane. The inserted gp20 structure could be probed by antibody binding and protein A-gold immunoelectron microscopy. The data suggest that a specific gp20-gp40-membrane insertion structure constitutes the T4 prohead assembly initiation complex.     

Valyl-tRNA synthetase modification-dependent restriction of bacteriophage T4

A strain of Escherichia coli, CP 790302, severely restricts the growth of wild-type bacteriophage T4. In broth culture, most infections of single cells are abortive, although a few infected cells exhibit reduced burst sizes. In contrast, bacteriophage T4 mutants impaired in the ability to modify valyl-tRNA synthetase develop normally on this strain. Biochemical evidence indicates that the phage-modified valyl-tRNA synthetase in CP 790302 is different from that previously described. Although the enzyme is able to support normal protein synthesis, a disproportionate amount of phage structural protein (serum blocking power) fails to mature into particles of the appropriate density. The results with host strain CP 790302 are consistent with either a gratuitous inhibition of phage assembly by faulty modification or abrogation of an unknown role that valyl-tRNA synthetase might normally play in viral assembly.     

gpwac of the T4-type bacteriophages: structure, function, and evolution of a segmented coiled-coil protein that controls viral infectivity

The wac gene product (gpwac) or fibritin of bacteriophage T4 forms the six fibers that radiate from the phage neck. During phage morphogenesis these whiskers bind the long tail fibers (LTFs) and facilitate their attachment to the phage baseplate. After the cell lysis, the gpwac fibers function as part of an environmental sensing device that retains the LTFs in a retracted configuration and thus prevents phage adsorption in unfavorable conditions. A comparative analysis of the sequences of 5 wac gene orthologs from various T4-type phages reveals that the approximately 50-amino-acid N-terminal domain is the only highly conserved segment of the protein. This sequence conservation is probably a direct consequence of the domain's strong and specific interactions with the neck proteins. The sequence of the central fibrous region of gpwac is highly plastic, with only the heptad periodicity of the coiled-coil structure being conserved. In the various gpwac sequences, the small C-terminal domain essential for initiation of the folding of T4 gpwac is replaced by unrelated sequences of unknown origin. When a distant T4-type phage has a novel C-terminal gpwac sequence, the phage's gp36 sequence that is located at the knee joint of the LTF invariably has a novel domain in its C terminus as well. The covariance of these two sequences is compatible with genetic data suggesting that the C termini of gpwac and gp36 engage in a protein-protein interaction that controls phage infectivity. These results add to the limited evidence for domain swapping in the evolution of phage structural proteins.     

Identification of bacteriophage T4D gene products 26 and 51 as baseplate hub structural components

Products of two bacteriophage T4D genes, 26 and 51, both known to be essential for the formation of the central hub of the phage tail baseplate, have been partially characterized chemically, and their biological role has been examined. The gene 26 product was found to be a protein with a molecular size of 41,000 daltons and the gene 51 product a protein of 16,500 daltons. The earlier proposal (L. M. Kozloff and J. Zorzopulos, J. Virol. 40:635-644), from observations of a 40,000-dalton protein in labeled hubs, that the gene 26 product is a structural component of the baseplate, has been confirmed. The gene 51 product, not yet detected in phage particles, appears from indirect evidence also to be a structural component of the baseplate hub. These current conclusions about the gene 26 and 51 products are based on properties of T4 mutant particles containing altered gene 26 or 51 products and include (i) changes in heat lability, (ii) changes in adsorption rates, and (iii) changes in plating efficiencies on different hosts, and with the results of previous isotope incorporation experiments indicate that T4 particles contain three copies of the gene 26 product and possibly one or at most two copies of the gene 51 product. Properties of these mutant particles indicate that the gene 26 product, together with the other hub components such as the gene 28 product, plays a critical role in phage DNA injection into the host cell, whereas the 51 product seems essential in initiating baseplate hub assembly.     

The Baseplate Wedges of Bacteriophage T4 Spontaneously Assemble into Hubless Baseplate-Like Structure In Vitro

The baseplate of phage T4 is an important model system in viral supramolecular assembly. The baseplate consists of six wedges surrounding the central hub. We report the first successful attempt at complete wedge assembly using an in vitro approach based on recombinant proteins. The cells expressing the individual wedge proteins were mixed in a combinatorial manner and then lysed. Using this approach, we could both reliably isolate the complete wedge along with a series of intermediate complexes as well as determine the exact sequence of assembly. The individual proteins and intermediate complexes at each step of the wedge assembly were successfully purified and characterized by sedimentation velocity and electron microscopy. Although our results mostly confirmed the hypothesized sequential wedge assembly pathway as established using phage mutants, interestingly, we also detected some protein interactions not following the specified order. It was found that association of gene product 53 to the immediate precursor complex induces spontaneous association of the wedges to form a six-fold star-shaped baseplate-like structure in the absence of the hub. The formation of the baseplate-like structure was facilitated by the addition of gene product 25. The complete wedge in the star-shaped supramolecular complex has a structure similar to the baseplate in the expanded “star” conformation found after infection. Based on the results of the present and previous studies, we assume that the strict order of wedge assembly is due to the induced conformational change caused by every new binding event. The significance of a 40-S star-shaped baseplate structure, which was previously reported and was also found in this study, is discussed in the light of a new paradigm for T4 baseplate assembly involving the star-shaped wedge ring and the central hub. Importantly, the methods described in this article suggest a novel methodology for future structural characterization of supramolecular protein assemblies.