Monophyly and generic relationships of polemoniaceae based on matK Sequences

Polemoniaceae are often considered a model family for studying evolutionary processes, yet a reliable phylogeny for the family is only now beginning to emerge. To test the monophyly of this family and to elucidate intergeneric relationships, we employed comparative sequencing of the chloroplast gene matK. Parsimony analysis of matK sequences representing 18 genera of Polemoniaceae and nine families from Asteridae sensu lato places Polemoniaceae apart from Solanaceae near Fouquieriaceae, Ericaceae, Sarraceniaceae, and Diapensiaceae. Both this and a subsequent analysis of 59 species of Polemoniaceae indicate that Cobaea is derived from within Polemoniaceae, rather than being the sister to Polemoniaceae as suggested by some authors. The tropical genera Bonplandia, Cantua, and Cobaea form a clade, and the remaining, primarily temperate genera, excluding Acanthogilia, form a second monophyletic group. Acanthogilia is placed ambiguously as sister to either the tropical or temperate groups depending on the location of the root for Polemoniaceae. Within the temperate lineage, Polemonium is sister to three large clades: a well-supported clade comprising Phlox, Gymnosteris, Linanthus, Leptodactylon, and Gilia filiformis; a moderately well-supported clade comprising Allophyllum, Collomia, Navarretia, and several species of Gilia; and a weakly supported clade comprising Eriastrum, Ipomopsis, Langloisia, Loeseliastrum, Loeselia, and several species of Gilia. In addition to revealing the extreme polyphyly of Gilia, this analysis suggests that Ipomopsis and Linanthus are also polyphyletic.     

Polemoniaceae phylogeny and classification: implications of sequence data from the chloroplast gene ndhF

The chloroplast gene ndhF was used to study phylogenetic relationships of the Polemoniaceae at two levels: among members of the Ericales and among genera of the family. Sequence data for interfamilial analyses consisted of 2266 bp for 14 members of the Ericales, including four species of the Polemoniaceae, plus three outgroup taxa. The Polemoniaceae were found to be related to Diospyros, Fouquieria, the Primulales, Rhododendron, and Impatiens, but relationships among taxa were generally not well supported. The precise position of the Polemoniaceae within the Ericales remains obscure. Data for intrafamilial analyses consisted of 1031 bp for 27 species of the Polemoniaceae, including at least one species from most genera of the family, plus five outgroup taxa. A single most parsimonious tree was identified. The analyses suggested that subfamily Cobaeoideae, excluding Loeselia, is monophyletic and that Huthia is sister to Cantua. Acanthogilia was sister to the remainder of subfamily Cobaeoideae. Subfamily Polemonioideae plus Loeselia formed four subclades that were strongly supported as monophyletic and represent the major lineages of the subfamily.     

Pollen Morphology of Polemoniaceae in Relation to Systematics and Pollination Systems: Scanning Electron Microscopy

Representative pollen grains of each genus and section of the family Polemoniaceae were examined with scanning electron microscopy. Exine pattern diversity within the family is discussed in relation to pollination biology. Pollen data support some previously recognized relationships within the family; in other instances the use of pollen morphology suggests the institution of new associations. The value of pollen morphology as an index to possible phylogenetic interpretations within the Polemoniaceae is discussed.     

Nuclear and cpDNA sequences combined provide strong inference of higher phylogenetic relationships in the phlox family (Polemoniaceae)

Members of the phlox family (Polemoniaceae) serve as useful models for studying various evolutionary and biological processes. Despite its biological importance, no family-wide phylogenetic estimate based on multiple DNA regions with complete generic sampling is available. Here, we analyze one nuclear and five chloroplast DNA sequence regions (nuclear ITS, chloroplast matK, trnL intron plus trnL-trnF intergeneric spacer, and the trnS-trnG, trnD-trnT, and psbM-trnD intergenic spacers) using parsimony and Bayesian methods, as well as assessments of congruence and long branch attraction, to explore phylogenetic relationships among 84 ingroup species representing all currently recognized Polemoniaceae genera. Relationships inferred from the ITS and concatenated chloroplast regions are similar overall. A combined analysis provides strong support for the monophyly of Polemoniaceae and subfamilies Acanthogilioideae, Cobaeoideae, and Polemonioideae. Relationships among subfamilies, and thus for the precise root of Polemoniaceae, remain poorly supported. Within the largest subfamily, Polemonioideae, four clades corresponding to tribes Polemonieae, Phlocideae, Gilieae, and Loeselieae receive strong support. The monogeneric Polemonieae appears sister to Phlocideae. Relationships within Polemonieae, Phlocideae, and Gilieae are mostly consistent between analyses and data permutations. Many relationships within Loeselieae remain uncertain. Overall, inferred phylogenetic relationships support a higher-level classification for Polemoniaceae proposed in 2000.     

Characterization of microsatellite loci in Ipomopsis (Polemoniaceae) wildflowers

Members of the Ipomopsis aggregata species complex in the phlox family (Polemoniaceae) often hybridize when they occur in sympatry, and thus have been extensively studied to examine processes involved in plant speciation. I developed 12 microsatellite loci in I. aggregata that are also polymorphic in closely related Ipomopsis tenuituba, producing an average of eight alleles per locus in test populations of 12 individuals per species. Several of these markers also successfully amplified in other Ipomopsis species and more distant members of the Polemoniaceae, suggesting they should prove useful for a broad range of evolutionary studies in this widely distributed system.     

CONTRIBUTION OF POLLEN MORPHOLOGY TO SYSTEMATICS OF COLLOMIA (POLEMONIACEAE)

Pollen morphology of 14 species of Collomia (Polemoniaceae) was examined by light microscopy, and by both scanning and transmission electron microscopy. Four distinct pollen types were observed which are based principally upon 1) shape, number and distribution of apertures, and 2) surface sculpturing: Type 1—zonocolporate with striate ridges; Type 2—zonocolporate with striato-reticulate ridges; Type 3—pantoporate with radiate ridges; Type 4—pantoporate with irregularly reticulate ridges. Evaluation of pollen morphology reveals considerable discrepancy with respect to presently accepted sectional classification. Collomia grandiflora of sect. Collomia has a pollen type similar to that of members of sect. Collomiastrum and is now interpreted as representing an independent evolutionary line derived from the latter section. Collomia diversifolia of sect. Courtoisia has a pollen morphology similar to that of sect. Collomia. whereas C. heterophylla of the same section possesses pollen unique within the genus. This last pollen type shows close similarity to the pollen of members of Polemonium, Gilia, Leptodactylon, and Ipomopsis. Pollen of C. tinctoria and C. tracyi of sect. Collomia are anomalous within Polemoniaceae. No significant difference in exine stratification was discernible among the four pollen types.     

Oviposition choices by a pre-dispersal seed predator (Hylemya sp.)

Summary Pre-dispersal seed predators must choose proper hosts and flowers on those hosts that have a high probability of setting seed. In this study, I documented that flowers of Ipomopsis aggregata (Polemoniaceae) chosen by a pre-dispersal seed predator (Anthomyiidae: Hylemya sp.) had a higher probability of seed set than flowers the fly did not choose. I experimentally tested the hypothesis that Hylemya uses a post-fertilization cue in making oviposition choices. I found no evidence for this hypothesis.     

Phenotypic plasticity in Phlox

Summary Three species of Phlox (Polemoniaceae) were grown in 6 greenhouse treatments. A variety of traits were recorded and the correlations among them were computed for each treatment. The phenotypic correlations between characters are significantly altered when plants are grown under different environmental conditions. These changes in correlation structure result from the differential phenotypic plasticity of traits. Partial correlations between flower production and other traits are also environment-dependent. Such changes can alter the intensity of, and possibly the response to, selection on traits correlated with fitness in natural plant populations.     

Molecular phylogeny and biogeography of Linanthus (Polemoniaceae)

To better understand the evolutionary history of Linanthus (Polemoniaceae) and its relatives, molecular phylogenies based on DNA sequence data from the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) region of nrDNA and the chloroplast gene matK were estimated using several methods. Our data suggest two separate and well-supported lineages of Linanthus in close association with two other genera-Leptodactylon and Phlox. These results agree with previous molecular systematic work on the Polemoniaceae, but do not support the traditional classification of the genus as a natural group, nor do they support the sectional classification within the genus. With a distribution centered primarily in western North America and a high degree of endemism in the California Floristic Province, it has been suggested by Raven and Axelrod that the origin and diversification of Linanthus and its relatives were tied to the development of a summer-dry climate in western North America, which began around 13-15 million years ago (mya). Increased drying during the Pliocene (1.2-5 mya) has also been hypothesized by Axelrod to have led to an increase in plant speciation in California and adjacent areas. Divergence times within the Linanthus lineages were estimated from the ITS and matK gene trees. A log-likelihood ratio test could not reject clock-like evolution for the matK data; however, the clock was strongly rejected for the ITS data set. Although ITS molecular evolution was not clock-like, the estimated times of divergence were similar to those of the matK data set. Within both lineages of Linanthus there seems to have been considerable diversification that has occurred since the Pliocene.     

The conserved nature and taxonomic utility of pollen morphology in Cantua (Polemoniaceae)

Pollen exine morphology of nine of the ten species of Cantua (Polemoniaceae) is examined using light and scanning electron microscopy. A total of 28 specimens of C. bicolor, C. buxifolia, C. candelilla, C. cuzcoensis, C. flexuosa, C. pyrifolia, C. quercifolia, C. volcanica, and an as yet undescribed species (Cantua sp. nov.) are examined using either fresh or herbarium material. Pollen grains are found to be spheroidal, pantoporate, and quite large; mean diameter varies from 62 to 87?μm. Mean number of pores varies from 4.5 to 21.2 and mean pore size varies from 4.86 to 12.40?μm. Pollen grains of all species have insulate semitectate sexines. This feature distinguishes the pollen of Cantua species from the remainder of the Polemoniaceae. Insulae are evenly distributed over the surface of the pollen grain, with the exception of C. flexuosa and occasionally C. buxifolia, where insulae are more sparsely and haphazardly distributed. The majority of the species examined have irregularly shaped tectal insulae, with the exception of the large rounded insulae in C. quercifolia and the elongated narrow insulae in C. volcanica. Cantua quercifolia and C. volcanica have supratectal verrucae, a possible synapomorphy. In comparison to close relatives, the pollen grains of Cantua are evolutionarily conserved, and show little variation among species.     

DEVELOPMENT OF STRIATE EXINE IN IPOMOPSIS RUBURA (POLEMONIACEAE)

Exine formation in Ipomopsis rubura (L.) Wherry (Polemoniaceae) was traced with transmission and scanning electron microscopy. At the early tetrad stage, plasma membranes of microspores invaginate and form a punctate pattern within the callose wall. Protectum is then deposited, taking a punctate pattern corresponding to the plasma membrane. After dissolution of the callose wall, the punctate pattern develops into a striate sculpture by partial thickening of tectum. The mature tectum is thus composed of two layers, the inner punctate and outer striate layers. With the plasma membrane determining the initial tectum pattern within the tetrad, additional sculptural elements are later formed above this pattern during the free microspore stage.     

Correlations between anthocyanin chemistry and pollination ecology in the polemoniaceae

A study of the anthocyanins in a representative sample (34 species from 14 genera) of Polemoniaceae has shown that the pigment type in the flowers is broadly correlated with pollination ecology. Thus, hummingbird pollinated species such as Ipomopsis aggregata generally contain pelargonidin sometimes with cyanidin, while bee and beefly pollinated species (e.g. Gilia latiflora) contain mainly delphinidin. On the other hand, lepidopteran species such as Leptodactylon californicum have cyanidin or mixtures of cyanidin with delphinidin. The above three anthocyanidins occur usually as the 3-glucoside, 3,5-diglucoside, $\text{3-(p-}\text{coumarylglucoside}\text{)}$ and $\text{3-(p-}\text{coumarylglucoside}\text{)-5-}\text{glucoside}$, although other types are occasionally found. The distribution of glycosidic types and of acylation, unlike that of the anthocyanidins, is more closely correlated with systematic position than with pollinating vectors. In autogamous species where animal pollination is absent or unimportant, anthocyanin pigmentation in the flowers retains the complexity present in related animal-pollinated taxa. Anthocyanins were also identified in hummingbird pollinated plants from two related families and pelargonidin derivatives were detected. In Fouquieria splendens (Fouquieriaceae), the glycosidic pattern was different from that in Polemoniaceae in being 3-galactoside. In Penstemon (Scrophulariaceae) a study of flower anthocyanins was consistent with Straw's hypothesis that the wasp-pollinated P. spectabilis originated by hybridization between the hummingbird-pollinated P. centranthifolius and the bee-pollinated P. grinnellii.     

Wind pollination and reproductive assurance in Linanthus parviflorus (Polemoniaceae), a self-incompatible annual

Wind pollination was experimentally demonstrated in Linanthus parviflorus (Polemoniaceae), a predominantly beefly-pollinated, self-incompatible annual. Seed set in plants enclosed in mesh tents that excluded pollinators but allowed airborne pollen flow provided evidence for wind pollination, and the extent of seed set due to wind pollination was compared to that in open-pollinated controls and pollen-supplemented treatments. Additional controls were included to test for possible confounding effects of the mesh tent. Mean seed number in open-pollinated plants was 72.8–81.1% of that in pollen-supplemented plants, while wind pollination alone produced 49.5–52.2%, a smaller but substantial proportion of seed set with pollen supplementation. Further evidence for wind pollination was found in a comparison of sites differing in the extent of wind exposure in two populations of L. parviflorus. Airborne pollen counts were higher in exposed sites than in protected sites, and the difference was marginally significant. Seed set was significantly pollen limited in protected sites, but not in exposed sites. Taken together, the data suggest that wind pollination provides some reproductive assurance in this obligately outcrossing species. Wind pollination is hypothesized to represent an alternative to selfing as an evolutionary solution to the problem of temporal or spatial variation in pollination visitation.     

Development of microsatellite markers for Polemonium kiushianum (Polemoniaceae), a critically endangered grassland plant species in Japan

Eight microsatellite loci were isolated and characterized for Polemonium kiushianum (Polemoniaceae), an endangered perennial herb endemic to the Kyushu region in Japan. The number of individuals of this species is presumed to be about 400 individuals. The loci showed polymorphisms with two to ten alleles per locus. The expected and observed heterozygositis ranged from 0.039 to 0.744 and 0.039 to 0.784, respectively. Although significant deviations (P < 0.05) from Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium were detected for one locus, no significant deviations were detected for other seven loci. There was no evidence of significant linkage disequilibrium between any two of the loci. The markers described here will be useful to establish conservation programs based on genetic traits of P. kiushianum.     

Early floral development and androecium organization in Fouquieriaceae (Ericales)

Early floral development with focus on the androecium was studied with the help of scanning electron microscopy and serial microtome sectioning in Fouquieria columnaris and F. splendens. Perianth organs appear in a spiral pattern on the floral apex. The spiral may be a clockwise or anti-clockwise. The androecium is best interpreted as two-whorled with all the stamens arranged in a single series. In F. splendens, two or more of the five epipetalous stamen positions are doubled, i.e. they are occupied by stamen pairs. Unusual features in the floral development of Fouquieriaceae include (1) a strong spiral component even in whorled organ categories and (2) a pronouncedly asymmetric floral apex during an early phase of floral development. From a phylogenetic point of view, it seems plausible that the common ancestor of Fouquieriaceae and its sister family Polemoniaceae was characterized by two alternating, pentamerous stamen-whorls.     

Allotetraploids in Patagonia with Affinities to Western North American Diploids: Did Dispersal or Genome Doubling Occur First?

Amphitropical disjunct distributions between western North America and western South America have intrigued botanists for over a century. Here, specific examples of migration and speciation are investigated using herbaceous species from the phlox family (Polemoniaceae) as a model for considering the timing of dispersal relative to speciation. Comparative DNA sequencing reveals that, in Collomia and Navarretia, the South American species are allopolyploids, suggesting either two dispersals prior to the allopolyploidization event for each species with subsequent extirpation of the diploid progenitors from South America, or allopolyploid formation prior to dispersal with extirpation of these polyploids from North America. Divergence time estimates support a Pliestocene dispersal hypothesis and sequence data indicate that, at least in Collomia, hybridization of the diploid progenitors occurred in South America.     

Diversity and evolution of floral structure among early diverging lineages in the Ericales

This is a combination of review and original data on floral structure and diversity in the two earliest diverging lineages of the Ericales, i.e. the balsaminoids, comprising Balsaminaceae, Marcgraviaceae and Tetrameristaceae, and the polemonioids, comprising Fouquieriaceae and Polemoniaceae. Each clade is strongly supported in molecular studies, while structural synapomorphies have largely been lacking. For the balsaminoid families, we compare floral morphology, anatomy and histology among selected taxa and find that the entire clade is strongly supported by the shared presence of nectariferous tissue in the floral periphery, thread-like structures on anthers, truncate stigmas, secretion in the ovary, as well as mucilage cells, raphides and tannins in floral tissues. A possible sister group relationship between Balsaminaceae and Tetrameristaceae is supported by the shared presence of post-genital fusion of filaments and ovary and a star-shaped stylar canal. For polemonioids, we document unexpected diversity of floral features in Polemoniaceae, partly providing structural links to Fouquieriaceae. Features include cochlear and quincuncial corolla aestivation, connective protrusions, ventrifixed anthers and nectariferous tissue in the base of the ovary. In addition, we outline future directions for research on floral structure in the Ericales and briefly discuss the general importance of structural studies for our understanding of plant phylogeny and evolution.     

ADAPTIVE SIGNIFICANCE OF IPOMOPSIS AGGREGATA NECTAR PRODUCTION: OBSERVATION AND EXPERIMENT IN THE FIELD

Production of floral nectar is generally thought to be an adaptation that increases plant fitness by altering pollinator behavior, and therefore pollination success. To test this hypothesis, I investigated the effects of floral nectar production rate on pollination success of the hermaphroditic plant Ipomopsis aggregata (Polemoniaceae). Success through male function (estimated by the export of fluorescent dyes) was significantly greater for plants with naturally high nectar production rates than for nearby plants with low nectar production rates, whereas success through female function (receipt of fluorescent dye) was unrelated to nectar production rate. Experimental addition of artificial nectar also produced a significant increase in male function success and no increase in several estimates of female function success. Observations confirmed that hummingbirds probed a larger proportion of flowers on plants that received supplemental nectar, as they do in response to natural variation in nectar production. The concordance of results across these observational and experimental studies indicates that nectar production acts primarily to increase pollination success through male function for this species.     

Reproductive biology of the Red List species Polemonium caeruleum (Polemoniaceae)

The majority of flowering plants, including many rare and threatened species, are pollinated by animals, but little is known of pollination and breeding systems of many endangered species. Polemonium caeruleum (Polemoniaceae) is a red‐listed species and is regarded as dichogamous, self‐compatible and bee pollinated. However, some studies show that it is visited by a vast assemblage of anthophilous insects from many taxonomic orders and that breeding systems vary greatly between closely related taxa of this genus. Over a period of 3 years we investigated breeding system, dichogamy, nectar secretion and composition, insect visitations and pollen loads in flowers of P. caeruleum in north‐eastern Poland to determine whether the reproductive biology of the plant explains its rarity. Contrary to published data, our study plants were self‐incompatible and showed a high degree of outcrossing. Our experimental work confirmed the occurrence of protandry in this species, revealed that nectar is sucrose‐dominant and proline‐rich and, for the first time for Polemoniaceae, that nectar secretion and nectar sugar concentration in flowers of P. caeruleum is female‐biased. Although flowers were visited by at least 39 species of insects from five taxonomic orders, overall the plant exhibited many characters associated with bee pollination, and analysis of insect performance showed that bumblebees and honeybees are the key pollinators; occasionally hoverflies and butterflies may also be involved. We conclude that, in terms of pollination system, P. caeruleum demonstrates high apparent generalization, but low realized generalization, and is a functional specialist, as most pollinators belong to a single functional group (guild). Its conservation status, at least in our study population, cannot be explained in terms of the biological properties of its breeding or pollination systems; rather, the present decline of the species is caused by habitat loss. However, if this process and bumblebee decline in Europe continue, P. caeruleum populations may diminish in numbers and density and, owing to the self‐incompatibility of the species, quickly become severely pollen‐limited, thereby accelerating further local extinctions. © 2013 The Linnean Society of London, Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society, 2013, 173 , 92–107.     

Development, characterization and transferability of microsatellite markers for the plant genus Phlox (Polemoniaceae)

In order to study diversification and microevolution in Phlox, we developed nine polymorphic microsatellite loci. In 20 individuals of Phlox pilosa from a single population, the average number of alleles per locus was 10.0 ± 5.1, and average observed and expected heterozygosities were 0.611 ± 0.234 and 0.769 ± 0.170, respectively. Most of these markers amplified successfully in 11 additional species of Phlox, representing a broad diversity of the genus, and some also amplified in more distantly related members of the Polemoniaceae. These microsatellite markers will be valuable for investigation of evolutionary processes in this important study system.