Effective production of marker-free transgenic strawberry plants using inducible site-specific recombination and a bifunctional selectable marker gene

Public concerns about the issue of the environmental safety of genetically modified plants have led to a demand for technologies allowing the production of transgenic plants without selectable (antibiotic resistance) markers. We describe the development of an effective transformation system for generating such marker-free transgenic plants, without the need for repeated transformation or sexual crossing. This system combines an inducible site-specific recombinase for the precise elimination of undesired, introduced DNA sequences with a bifunctional selectable marker gene used for the initial positive selection of transgenic tissue and subsequent negative selection for fully marker-free plants. The described system can be generally applied to existing transformation protocols, and was tested in strawberry using a model vector in which site-specific recombination leads to a functional combination of a cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter and a GUS encoding sequence, thereby enabling the histochemical monitoring of recombination events. Fully marker-free transgenic strawberry plants were obtained following two different selection/regeneration strategies.     

Methods to produce marker-free transgenic plants

Selectable marker genes (SMGs) have been extraordinarily useful in enabling plant transformation because of the low efficiency of transgene integration. The most used SMGs encode proteins resistant to antibiotics or herbicides and use negative selection, i.e., by killing nontransgenic tissue. However, there are perceived risks in wide-scale deployment of SMG-transgenic plants, and therefore research has recently been performed to develop marker-free systems. In this review, transformation using markers not based on antibiotic or herbicide resistance genes, as well as different systems of marker gene deletion, are discussed.     

Production of selectable marker-free transgenic tobacco plants using a non-selection approach: chimerism or escape,transgene inheritance,and efficiency

Public concern and metabolic drain were the main driving forces for the development of a selectable marker-free transformation system. We demonstrated here the production of transgenic tobacco plants using a non-selection approach by Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated transformation. A. tumefaciens-infected leaf explants were allowed to produce shoots on a shoot induction medium (SIM) containing no selective compounds. Up to 35.1% of the A. tumefaciens-infected leaf explants produced histochemically GUS⁺ shoots, 3.1% of regenerated shoots were GUS⁺, and 72% of the GUS⁺ shoots were stably transformed by producing GUS⁺ T1 seedlings. When polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was used to screen the regenerated shoots, 4% of the shoots were found to be PCR⁺ for the transgene and 65% of the PCR⁺ shoots were stable transformants. Also, generation of PCR⁺ escapes decreased linearly as the number of subculture increased from one to three on SIM containing the antibiotic that kills the Agrobacterium. Twenty-five to 75% of the transformants were able to transmit transgene activity to the T1 generation in a Mendelian 3:1 ratio, and a transformation efficiency of 2.2–2.8% was achieved for the most effective binary vector. These results indicated that majority of the GUS⁺ or PCR⁺ shoots recovered under no selection were stable transformants, and only one-third of them were chimeric or escapes. Transgenes in these transgenic plants were able to transmit the transgene into progeny in a similar fashion as those recovered under selection.     

Evaluation of a morphological marker selection and excision system to generate marker-free transgenic cassava plants

The efficacy of the ipt-type Multi-Auto-Transformation (MAT) vector system to transform the extensively grown cassava cultivar “KU50” was evaluated. This system utilizes the isopentenyltransferase (ipt) gene as morphological marker for visual selection of transgenic lines. The extreme shooty phenotype (ESP) of transgenic lines is lost due to the removal of ipt gene mediated by the yeast Rint/RS system. As a result, phenotypically normal shoots, considered marker-free transgenic plants, could be obtained. When transforming KU50 cassava cultivar with two different ipt-type MAT vectors, transformation frequency at 19–21% was observed. Among the total number of ESP explants, 32–38% regained normal extended shoot phenotype and 88–96% of which were confirmed to represent the marker-free transgenic plants. This is the first demonstration of the efficacy of Rint/RS system in promoting excision of ipt marker gene in cassava specie, with the consequent rapid production of marker-free transgenic plants. The high efficiency of this system should facilitate pyramiding a number of transgenes by repeated transformation without having to undergo through laborious, expensive and time-consuming processes of sexual crossing and seed production. The generation of marker-free, thus environmentally safe, genetically modified cassava clones should also ease the public concerns regarding the use of transgenic cassava in both food and nonfood industries.     

Excision of selectable marker gene from transgenic tobacco using the GM-gene-deletor system regulated by a heat-inducible promoter

To excise a selectable marker gene from transgenic plants, a new binary expression vector based on the 'genetically modified (GM)-gene-deletor' system was constructed. In this vector, the gene coding for FLP site-specific recombinase under the control of a heat shock-inducible promoter HSP18.2 from Arabidopsis thaliana and isopentenyltransferase gene (ipt), as a selectable marker gene under the control of the cauliflower mosaic virus 35S (CaMV 35S) promoter, were flanked by two loxP/FRT fusion sequences as recombination sites in direct orientation. Histochemical staining for GUS activity showed that, upon induction by heat shock, all exogenous DNA, including the selectable marker gene ipt, beta-glucuronidase (gusA) gene and the FLP recombinase gene, between two loxP/FRT sites was eliminated efficiently from primary transgenic tobacco plants. Molecular analysis further confirmed that excision of the marker gene (ipt) was heritable and stable. Our approach provides a reliable strategy for auto-excising a selectable marker gene from calli, shoots or other tissues of transgenic plants after transformation and producing marker-free transgenic plants.     

Production of marker-free transgenic Nierembergia caerulea using MAT vector system

Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain EHA105 harboring an ipt-type MAT vector, pNPI132, was used to produce morphologically normal transgenic Nierembergia caerulea cv. Mont Blanc employing ipt gene as the selectable marker gene. β-glucuronidase (GUS) gene was used as model gene of interest. The MAT vector system is a positive selection system that gives the advantage of regeneration to the transgenic cells without killing the non-transgenic cells. Infected explants were cultured on hormone- and antibiotic-free MS medium, and 65% of the regenerated shoots developed ipt shooty phenotype-morphologically abnormal shoots, within approximately 3 months after co-cultivation. Twenty morphologically normal shoots were produced from 12 transgenic ipt shoots 7 months after co-cultivation. The normal shoots rooted well on hormone-free MS medium. Ninety percent of the normal shoots were ipt ⁻, GUS⁺ and excision⁺ as determined by PCR and Southern blot analyses. These results indicate that ipt-type MAT vector system can be used successfully in Nierembergia to produce marker-free transgenic plants without using phytohormones and selective chemical agents.     

Site-specific excisional recombination strategies for elimination of undesirable transgenes from crop plants

A major limitation of crop biotechnology and breeding is the lack of efficient molecular technologies for precise engineering of target genomic loci. While transformation procedures have become routine for a growing number of plant species, the random introduction of complex transgenenic DNA into the plant genome by current methods generates unpredictable effects on both transgene and homologous native gene expression. The risk of transgene transfer into related plant species and consumers is another concern associated with the conventional transformation technologies. Various approaches to avoid or eliminate undesirable transgenes, most notably selectable marker genes used in plant transformation, have recently been developed. These approaches include cotransformation with two independent T-DNAs or plasmid DNAs followed by their subsequent segregation, transposon-mediated DNA elimination, and most recently, attempts to replace bacterial T-DNA borders and selectable marker genes with functional equivalents of plant origin. The use of site-specific recombination to remove undesired DNA from the plant genome and concomitantly, via excision-mediated DNA rearrangement, switch-activate by choice transgenes of agronomical, food or feed quality traits provides a versatile “transgene maintenance and control” strategy that can significantly contribute to the transfer of transgenic laboratory developments into farming practice. This review focuses on recent reports demonstrating the elimination of undesirable transgenes (essentially selectable marker and recombinase genes) from the plant genome and concomitant activation of a silent transgene (e.g., a reporter gene) mediated by different site-specific recombinases driven by constitutive or chemically, environmentally or developmentally regulated promoters. These reports indicate major progress in excision strategies which extends application of the technology from annual, sexually propagated plants towards perennial, woody and vegetatively propagated plants. Current trends and future prospects for optimization of excision-activation machinery and its practical implementation for the generation of transgenic plants and plant products free of undesired genes are discussed.     

Generation of selectable marker-free sheath blight resistant transgenic rice plants by efficient co-transformation of a cointegrate vector T-DNA and a binary vector T-DNA in one Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain

Co-transformation of Oryza sativa L. var. Pusa Basmati1 was done using an Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain harbouring a single-copy cointegrate vector and a multi-copy binary vector in the same cell. The T-DNA of the cointegrate vector pGV2260::pSSJ1 carried the hygromycin phosphotransferase (hph) and beta-glucuronidase (gus) genes. The binary vector pCam-chi11, without a plant selectable marker gene, harboured the rice chitinase (chi11) gene under maize ubiquitin promoter. Co-transformation of the gene of interest (chi11) with the selectable marker gene (hph) occurred in 4 out of 20 T(0) plants (20%). Segregation of hph from chi11 was accomplished in two (CoT6 and CoT23) of the four co-transformed plants in the T(1) generation. The selectable marker-free (SMF) lines CoT6 and CoT23 harboured single copies of chi11. Homozygous SMF T(2) plants were established in the lines CoT6 and CoT23. Northern and Western blot analysis of the homozygous SMF lines showed high level of transgene expression. In comparison to untransformed controls, chitinase specific activity was 66- and 22-fold higher in the homozygous SMF T(2) plants of lines CoT6 and CoT23, respectively. The lines CoT6 and CoT23 exhibited 38 and 40% reduction in sheath blight disease, respectively.     

利用竞争性PCR筛选无标记Xa21转基因水稻

PCR是一种简单、迅速、灵敏的检测方法,但假阳性与假阴性却影响了它在常规应用中的准确性。本研究利用竞争性PCR解决无标记Xa21转基因水稻PCR检测中的假阳性与假阴性问题。标记基因潮霉素基因(Hygromycin phosphotransferase,hpt)的竞争模板是外加的日本晴hpt转基因植株基因组DNA,抗白叶枯病基因Xa21的竞争模板是待测水稻内源的位于第11染色体上的Xa21同源基因序列。利用这一方法对双右边界T-DNA载体转化产生的转基因T1代植株进行分析,可以有效地减少或排除假阳性或假阴性样品,选出真正的转基因阳性植株。与常规PCR相比竞争性PCR提高了无标记Xa21转基因植株筛选的准确性。对获得的无标记Xa21转基因植株进行白叶枯抗病鉴定与潮霉素抗性鉴定证实了该方法的可靠性。     

Effective selection system for generating marker-free transgenic plants independent of sexual crossing

 In a previous report, a novel selection protocol termed "the MAT-vector system" for generating marker-free transgenic plants (MFTPs) was presented. The first stage of the system is visual selection of morphologically abnormal transgenic shoots, ipt-shooty, that have lost apical dominance and rooting ability. The second stage involves elimination of the ipt gene and the appearance of MFTPs free of ipt gene influence. The present report describes a practical MAT-vector in which removal of the ipt gene is efficiently mediated by the site-specific recombination system R/RS from Zygosaccharomyces rouxii, in place of the maize transposable element Ac, used previously. This improved MAT-vector produced MFTPs from 39% of moderate ipt-shooty and 70% of extreme ipt-shooty lines. These results are superior to the previous MAT-vector which produced MFTPs from only 5% of ipt-shooty lines. The present novel system also induced direct development of MFTPs from adventitious buds without production of ipt-shooty intermediates. The presence of β-glucuronidase (GUS) and neomycin phosphotransferase (NPTII) genes of interest, and the absence of the ipt gene were verified by a GUS histochemical assay, NPTII assay, and molecular analysis. Received: 19 June 1998 / Revision received: 4 December 1998 / Accepted: 18 December 1998     

Auto-excision of selectable marker genes from transgenic tobacco via a stress inducible FLP/FRT site-specific recombination system

Antibiotic resistance marker genes are powerful selection tools for use in plant transformation processes. However, once transformation is accomplished, the presence of these resistance genes is no longer necessary and can even be undesirable. We herein describe the successful excision of antibiotic resistance genes from transgenic plants via the use of an oxidative stress-inducible FLP gene. FLP encodes a recombinase that can eliminate FLP and hpt selection genes flanked by two FRT sites. During a transformation procedure in tobacco, transformants were obtained by selection on hygromycin media. Regenerants of the initial transformants were screened for selective marker excision in hydrogen peroxide supplemented media and both the FLP and hpt genes were found to have been eliminated. About 13–41% of regenerated shoots on hydrogen peroxide media were marker-free. This auto-excision system, mediated by the oxidative stress-inducible FLP/FRT system to eliminate a selectable marker gene can be very readily adopted and used to efficiently generate marker-free transgenic plants.     

Marker-free site-specific integration plants

Recently, site-specific recombination methods in plants have been developed to delete selection markers to produce marker-free transgenic plants or to integrate the transgene into a pre-determined genomic location to produce site-specific transgenic plants. However, these methods have been developed independently, and although the strategies of producing marker-free site-specific integration plants have been discussed, the concept has not been demonstrated. In the present study, we combined two approaches to site-specific recombination and demonstrated the concepts for removing the marker after site-specific integration for producing marker-free site-specific transgenic plants.     

Transgene stacking in plants in the absence of sexual crossing

A transgene stacking system is a prerequisite for the introduction of multiple genes and for the modification of complex metabolic pathways in plants. We demonstrate here that the MAT-vector system previously used for generating marker-free transgenic plants is also an efficient and reliable transformation system for the repeated introduction of multiple transgenes independent of sexual crossing. We previously reported that the GST-MAT vector system, in which excision of the yeast site-specific recombination R/RS system is regulated by the maize GST-II-27 promoter, could generate marker-free transgenic plants containing a single transgene with high frequency. Here we show that the GST-MAT vector can be used successfully to introduce a second transgene (GFP) into a marker-free transgenic tobacco line containing single copies of the first transgenes (nptII and uidA genes). The transgene-stacked marker-free transgenic tobacco plants were generated from ca. 20% of excision-positive ipt-shooty explants within 5 months of Agrobacterium infection. The presence of uidA, nptII, GFP genes and the absence of the ipt gene were verified by PCR analyses. Furthermore, Southern blot analysis showed that no chromosomal rearrangements were introduced between the first and second transformations.     

Generation of selectable marker-free transgenic tomato resistant to drought, cold and oxidative stress using the Cre/loxP DNA excision system

The aim of this research was to generate selectable marker-free transgenic tomato plants with improved tolerance to abiotic stress. An estradiol-induced site-specific DNA excision of a selectable marker gene using the Cre/loxP DNA recombination system was employed to develop transgenic tomato constitutively expressing AtIpk2β, an inositol polyphosphate 6-/3-kinase gene from Arabidopsis thaliana. Transgenic tomato plants containing a selectable marker were also produced as controls. The expression of AtIpk2β conferred improved resistance to drought, cold and oxidative stress in both sets of transgenic tomato plants. These results demonstrate the feasibility of using this Cre/loxP-based marker elimination strategy to generate marker-free transgenic crops with improved stress tolerance.     

Development of selection marker-free transgenic potato plants with enhanced tolerance to oxidative stress

A binary vector devoid of a plant selection-marker gene (designated as pSSA-F) was constructed to overcome bio-safety concerns about genetically modified plants. This vector carried chloroplast-targeted superoxide dismutase (SOD) and ascorbate peroxidase (APX) genes under the control of an oxidative stress-inducible(SWPA2) promoter, and was utilized to transform potato (Solanum tuberosum L.). Integration of these foreign genes into transgenic plants was primarily performed via PCR with genomic DNA. Twelve marker-free transgenic lines were obtained by inoculating stem explants. The maximum transformation efficiency was 6.25% and averaged 2.2%. Successful integration of the SOD and APX genes rendered transgenic plants tolerant to methyl viologen-mediated oxidative stress at the leaf-disc and whole-plant levels. Our findings suggest that this technique for developing selection marker-free transgenic plants is feasible and can be employed with other crop species.     

去除转基因植物标记基因的研究进展

得到转基因植物以后 ,标记基因就失去了筛选的作用。但它的存在引起公众对转基因植物的安全性以及环境效应的担心 ,所以在目的基因转入后 ,要去除标记基因。该文主要就利用共转化、转座子、同源重组、位点特异重组酶等去除标记基因的方法进行了总结 ,并对各种方法的优缺点进行了比较 ,对该技术未来的发展趋势也进行了展望。     

Excision of a selectable marker in transgenic rice (Oryza sativa L.) using a chemically regulated Cre/loxP system

Removal of a selectable marker gene from genetically modified (GM) crops alleviates the risk of its release into the environment and hastens the public acceptance of GM crops. Here we report the production of marker-free transgenic rice by using a chemically regulated, Cre/loxP-mediated site-specific DNA recombination in a single transformation. Among 86 independent transgenic lines, ten were found to be marker-free in the T₀ generation and an additional 17 lines segregated marker-free transgenic plants in the T₁ generation. Molecular and genetic analyses indicated that the DNA recombination and excision in transgenic rice were precise and the marker-free recombinant T-DNA was stable and heritable.The first two authors contributed equally to the work     

Basta tolerance as a selectable and screening marker for transgenic plants of Norway spruce

The bar gene conferring resistance to the herbicide Basta (containing phosphinothricin) was transferred to embryogenic cultures of Picea abies by particle bombardment and transformants were selected on Basta medium. In total, 83 9-month-old transgenic plants of Picea abies from six transformed sublines were analysed for continued tolerance to Basta. PCR analysis showed that the bar gene was present in all transformed plants but not in the control plants. Northern blot analysis showed differences in expression level among plants from the same subline as well as among sublines. A simple biotest for screening for Basta tolerance based on the colour change of detached needles induced by Basta was developed. The tolerance to Basta varied among the plants from different sublines. Needles from four of the sublines were resistant to 100 mg l⁻¹ phosphinothricin, a concentration inducing yellowing in control needles, while plants from the other two sublines were on average two to four times as resistant as untransformed control plants. The biotest enables rapid semi-quantitative monitoring for continued transgene expression in long-lived tree species. Received: 21 October 1999 / Revision received: 24 January 2000 / Accepted: 24 January 2000     

Efficient production of transgenic citrus plants using isopentenyl transferase positive selection and removal of the marker gene by site-specific recombination

The presence of marker genes conferring antibiotic resistance in transgenic plants represents a serious obstacle for their public acceptance and future commercialization. In citrus, selection using the selectable marker gene nptII, that confers resistance to the antibiotic kanamycin, is in general very effective. An attractive alternative is offered by the MAT system (Multi-Auto-Transformation), which combines the ipt gene for positive selection with the recombinase system R/RS for removal of marker genes from transgenic cells after transformation. Transformation with a MAT vector has been attempted in two citrus genotypes, Pineapple sweet orange (Citrus sinensis L. Osb.) and Carrizo citrange (C. sinensis L. Osb. × Poncirus trifoliata L. Raf.). Results indicated that the IPT phenotype was clearly distinguishable in sweet orange but not in citrange, and that excision was not always efficient and precise. Nevertheless, the easy visual detection of the IPT phenotype combined with the higher transformation efficiency achieved in sweet orange using this system open interesting perspectives for the generation of marker-free transgenic citrus plants.     

Isopentenyl transferase gene expression offers the positive selection of marker-free transgenic plant of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Kalanchoe blossfeldiana</Emphasis>

The technologies allowing the production of transgenic plants without selectable marker genes, is of great interest in public and environmental safety. For generating such marker-free transgenic plants, possibility has been offered by Multi-Auto-Transformation [MAT] vector system, which combines positive selection, using the isopentenyl transferase (ipt) gene, with a site-specific recombination that generates marker-free plants. In this study Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain EHA105 harboring an ipt-type MAT vector, pMAT21, containing lacZ, gus genes and the removable cassette in the T-DNA region was used to produce marker-free transgenic Kalanchoe blossfeldiana Poelln., employing ipt gene as the selectable marker gene. Co-cultivated explants were cultured on hormone- and selective agent-free MS medium, and 85% of the regenerated shoots showed ipt-shooty phenotype with GUS expression. Forty-one morphologically normal shoots were produced during the subculture. More than ninety percent of the normal shoots were ipt ⁻, gus ⁻ but lacZ ⁺ as determined by PCR analyses. These results indicate that the ipt phenotype was clearly distinguishable from non-transgenic as well as transgenic marker-free shoots. This study opens interesting perspective for the generation of marker-free transgenic K. blossfeldiana with objective useful transgene.