Molecular genetics of puroindolines and related genes: allelic diversity in wheat and other grasses

The hardness or texture of cereal grains is a primary determinant of their technological and processing quality. Among members of the Triticeae, most notably wheat, much of the variation in texture is controlled by a single locus comprised of the Puroindoline a, Puroindoline b and Grain Softness Protein-1 (Gsp-1) genes. Puroindolines confer the three major texture classes of soft and hard common wheat and the very hard durum wheat. The protein products of these genes interact with lipids and are associated with the surface of isolated starch (as a protein fraction known as ‘friabilin’). During the past ten years a great diversity of alleles of both Puroindoline genes have been discovered and significant advances made in understanding the relationship between the gene presence/absence, sequence polymorphism and texture of cereal grains. Efforts have also focussed on Puroindoline and Gsp-1 genes in diploid progenitors, other Triticeae grasses and synthetic wheats in order to understand the evolution of this gene family and find potentially useful variants. The puroindoline homologues in other cereals such as rye and barley are also receiving attention. This work summarises new developments in molecular genetics of puroindolines in wheat and related Triticeae grasses, and the related genes in other cereals.     

The determinants of grain texture in cereals

Kernel hardness is an important agronomic trait that influences end-product properties. In wheat cultivars, this trait is determined by thePuroindoline a (Pina) andPuroindoline b (Pinb) genes, located in theHardness locus (Ha) on chromosome 5DS of the D genome. Wild type alleles code puroindoline a (PINA) and puroindoline b (PINB) proteins, which form a 15-kDa friabilin present on the surface of water-washed starch granules. Both the proteins are accumulated in the starch endosperm cells and aleurone of the mature kernels.Puroindoline-like genes coding puroindoline-like proteins in the starch endosperm occur in some of the genomes of Triticeae and Aveneae cereals. Orthologs are present in barley, rye and oats. However, some genomes of these diploid and polyploid cereals, like that ofTriticum turgidum var.durum (AABB) lack thepuroindoline genes, having a very hard kernel texture. The two wild type alleles in opposition (dominant loci) control the soft pheno-type. Mutation either inPina orPinb or in both leads to a medium-hard or hard kernel texture. The most frequent types ofPin mutations are point mutations within the coding sequence resulting in the substitution of a single amino acid or a null allele. The latter is the result of a frame shift determined by base deletion or insertion or a one-point mutation to the stop codon. The lipid-binding properties of the puroindolines affect not only the dough quality but also the plants’ resistance to pathogens. Genetic modification of cereals withPuroindoline genes and/or their promoters enable more detailed functional analyses and the production of plants with the desired characteristics.     

Two Plant Puroindolines Colocalize in Wheat Seed and <Emphasis Type="Italic">in vitro</Emphasis> Synergistically Fight Against Pathogens

Puroindolines, for years largely investigated for their involvement in wheat kernel hardness, have recently attracted attention thanks to their possible role as antimicrobial proteins. With the aim to enhance our knowledge of these proteins we studied their localization in the kernel, and their antimicrobial activity in vitro against six different bacterial strains. Immunolocalization showed that both the PINs are strongly concentrated in the aleurone layer, but also highly present in the endosperm. Interestingly we observed that puroindolines not only have the same spatial distribution in the kernel, they are also always found co-localized. Their co-localization suggests that they could cooperate in defending the plant against pathogens. We therefore tested antimicrobial activity of PINA and PINB, and a putative synergism between these proteins. The results showed that the two polypeptides can in vitro inhibit growth of all the bacteria tested; furthermore when combined together they are able to enhance each other’s toxicity. In view of their antimicrobial activity and of their natural presence in Triticum aestivum wheat flour, puroindolines look promising antibacterial agents and thus deserve further studies aimed at establishing their possible future applications in fields of food and health care. Since PINs were still detectable in bakery products, these proteins may be promising tools in investigating natural ways of food preservation.     

Evidence of physical interactions of puroindoline proteins using the yeast two-hybrid system

The puroindoline proteins PINA and PINB play key roles in determining wheat grain texture and also have potential antimicrobial roles. Many recent studies show that their roles in grain texture involve some interaction or interdependence, and their antimicrobial activity may also involve formation of protein complexes. The issue of whether any homo- and/or heteromeric associations occur amongst the PIN proteins is thus critical for understanding their biological functions and exploiting them for grain texture modifications or antimicrobial applications, but is as yet unresolved. This work has utilised the well-established yeast two-hybrid system to directly address this issue. The results confirm occurrence of in vivo interactions between the two PIN proteins for the first time, and show that PINB interacts with itself and also interacts, although somewhat weakly, with PINA, while PINA is a weaker interactor. The results explain the many reported observations suggesting a co-operative interaction between the two proteins and provide a rapid and efficient tool for testing the effects of various alleles/mutations on the interactions and lipid binding properties of these proteins, which are of functional significance to grain texture and antimicrobial defence functions.     

New Frame Shift Mutation in Puroindoline B in Indian Wheat Cultivars Hyb65 and NI5439

Puroindoline genes pinA and pinB are the main components of the 15 kD friabilin protein reported to be associated with kernel softness. However, grain hardness of Hyb65 and NI5439, the two Indian wheat varieties, could not be explained based on the earlier identified alleles in puroindolines in wheat. Hyb65 and NI5439 are hard but based on the earlier identified allelic forms of puroindolines both the varieties could have been soft. In this investigation, puroindolines (a and b) from Hyb65 and NI5439 were characterised to understand their role in determining grain hardness. The sequence of puroindoline genes from both the varieties indicated that there was no mutation in pinA. However, there was frame shift mutation in pinB generated by insertion of a guanine residue 126 bp downstream from the start codon in both the varieties. This created new hardness allele of pinB designated as pinb-D1h. Frame shift also culminated into stop codon (TGA) 231 bp downstream from the start codon terminating protein synthesis at 77^th amino acid position. Five more stop codons (4TGA & 1TAG) were also created to the downstream positions of the first stop codon because of frame shift. There was additional point mutation in NI5439 (transition from A to G) resulting into change of amino acid residue from thymine to arginine at 205^th nucleotide position. Thus single nucleotide change in pinB resulted into truncated pin B and consequently the harder texture.     

Molecular Characterization of Puroindolines and their Encoding Genes in Aegilops Ventricosa

Puroindolines, the tryptophan-rich proteins controlling grain hardness in wheat, appeared as two pairs of 13 kDa polypeptides in the Acid-PAGE (A-PAGE) and two-dimensional A-PAGE×SDS-PAGE patterns of starch-granule proteins from wild allotetraploid wheat Aegilops ventricosa Tausch. (2n = 4x = 28, genomes D^vD^vN^vN^v). Puroindoline pair a1 + a2 reacted strongly with an antiserum specific for puroindoline-a from common wheat (Triticum aestivum L.), whereas puroindoline pair b1 + b2 exhibited A-PAGE relative mobilities similar to that of puroindoline-b in Aegilops tauschii (Coss.), the D-genome donor to both common wheat and Ae. ventricosa. Puroindolines a2 and b1 were found to be encoded by alleles Pina-D1a and Pinb-D1h on chromosome 5D^v, respectively, whereas puroindolines a1 and b2 were assumed to be under the genetic control of chromosome 5N^v. Puroindoline a1 encoded by the novel Pina-N1a allele exhibited a high level of amino acid variation with respect to puroindoline-a. On the other hand, the tryptophan-rich region of puroindoline b2 encoded by allele Pinb-N1a showed a sequence change from lysine-42 to arginine, with no effect on the amount of protein b2 accumulated on the starch granules. A partial duplication of the pin-B gene (Pinb-relic) was identified about 1100 bp downstream from Pinb-D1 on chromosome 5D^v. The present findings are the first evidence of a tetraploid wheat species in which four puroindoline genes are expressed. The potential of Ae. ventricosa as a source of genes that may be used to modulate endosperm texture and other valuable traits in cultivated wheat species is discussed.     

Puroindolines: the molecular genetic basis of wheat grain hardness

The variation in grain hardness is the single most important trait that determines end-use quality of wheat. Grain texture classification is based primarily on either the resistance of kernels to crushing or the particle size distribution of ground grain or flour. Recently, the molecular genetic basis of grain hardness has become known, and it is the focus of this review. The puroindoline proteins a and b form the molecular basis of wheat grain hardness or texture. When both puroindolines are in their `functional' wild state, grain texture is soft. When either one of the puroindolines is absent or altered by mutation, then the result is hard texture. In the case of durum wheat which lacks puroindolines, the texture is very hard. Puroindolines represent the molecular-genetic basis of the Hardness locus on chromosome 5DS and the soft (Ha) and hard (ha) alleles present in hexaploid bread wheat varieties. To date, seven discrete hardness alleles have been described for wheat. All involve puroindoline a or b and have been designated Pina-D1b and Pinb-D1b through Pinb-D1g. A direct role of a related protein, grain softness protein (as currently defined), in wheat grain texture has yet to be demonstrated.     

Wheat puroindolines enhance fungal disease resistance in transgenic rice

Antimicrobial peptides play a role in the immune systems of animals and plants by limiting pathogen infection and growth. The puroindolines, endosperm-specific proteins involved in wheat seed hardness, are small proteins reported to have in vitro antimicrobial properties. Rice, the most widely used cereal crop worldwide, normally does not contain puroindolines. Transgenic rice plants that constitutively express the puroindoline genes pinA and/or pinB throughout the plants were produced. PIN extracts of leaves from the transgenic plants reduced in vitro growth of Magnaporthe grisea and Rhizoctonia solani, two major fungal pathogens of rice, by 35 to 50%. Transgenic rice expressing pinA and/or pinB showed significantly increased tolerance to M. grisea (rice blast), with a 29 to 54% reduction in symptoms, and R. solani (sheath blight), with an 11 to 22% reduction in symptoms. Puroindolines are effective in vivo in antifungal proteins and could be valuable new tools in the control of a wide range of fungal pathogens of crop plants.     

Prevalence of Puroindoline D1 and Puroindoline b-2 variants in U.S. Pacific Northwest wheat breeding germplasm pools, and their association with kernel texture

Kernel texture is a major factor influencing the classification and end use properties of wheat (Triticum aestivum L.), and is mainly controlled by the Puroindoline a (Pina) and Puroindoline b (Pinb) genes. Recently, a new puroindoline gene, Puroindoline b-2 (Pin b-2), was identified. In this study, 388 wheat cultivars and advanced breeding lines from the U.S. Pacific Northwest were investigated for frequencies of Puroindoline D1 alleles and Pinb-2 variants 2 and 3. Results indicated that Pinb–D1b (74.0%) was the predominant genotype among hard wheats (N = 196), the only other hard allele encountered was Pina-D1b (26.0%). Across all varieties, Pinb-2v3 was the predominant genotype (84.5%) compared with Pinb-2v2 (15.5%). However, among 240 winter wheat varieties (124 soft white, 15 club, 68 hard red and 33 hard white varieties), all carried Pinb-2v3. Among spring wheats, Pinb-2v2 and Pinb-2v3 frequencies were more variable (soft white 25.0:75.0, hard red 58.2:41.8 and hard white 40.0:60.0, respectively). Kernel texture variation was analyzed using 247 of the 388 wheat varieties grown in multi-location factorial trials in up to 7 crop years. The range of variety means among the four groups, soft winter, soft spring, hard winter and hard spring, was on the order of 15–25 single kernel characterization system (SKCS) Hardness Index. The least significant difference for each of these trials ranged from 2.8 to 5.6 SKCS Hardness Index. Observations lead to the conclusion that Pinb-2 variants do not exert a prominent effect on kernel texture, however, Pinb–2 variants do identify features of wheat germ plasm structure in the U.S. Pacific Northwest.     

Serine proteinase inhibitor proteins: Exogenous and endogenous functions

Summary Proteinase inhibitor II (PIN2) proteins from the Solanaceae family have been previously used in plant transformation to acquire protection against caterpillars. Some of these PIN2 proteins have been shown to exhibit exogenous activities against trypsin and/or chymotrypsin in vitro. Despite their application in conferring insect resistance in transgenic plants, the endogenous roles of this family of proteins in various plant species have not been well defined. To investigate the exogenous and endogenous functions of PIN2 proteins, cDNAs encoding PIN2 proteins from the weed Solanum americanum (American black nightshade), designated SaPIN2a and SaPIN2b, were cloned and characterized. The localization of S. americanum SaPIN2a and SaPIN2b mRNAs and proteins in the reproductive tissues destined to undergo developmental programmed cell death subsequently led to investigations into their function during seed development. Using plant transformation of lettuce and S. americanum, it was evident that: (1) the expression of SaPIN2a in transgenic lettuce conferred resistance to cabbage looper (Trichoplusia ni) caterpillars; and (2) the expression of siRNAs from a PIN2-RNAi construct resulted in transgenic S. americanum that were impaired in seed development. These results suggest that S. americanum PIN2 proteins not only enhance resistance to caterpillars (when expressed exogenously) but they function in inhibiting endogenous proteases that are expressed during seed development. Specifically, the aborted seeds of PIN2-RNAi lines showed abnormal endothelium that subsequently affected endosperm and embryo development.     

Anti‐biofilm and sporicidal activity of peptides based on wheat puroindoline and barley hordoindoline proteins

The broad‐spectrum activity of antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) and low probability of development of host resistance make them excellent candidates as novel bio‐control agents. A number of AMPs are found to be cationic, and a small proportion of these are tryptophan‐rich. The puroindolines (PIN) are small, basic proteins found in wheat grains with proposed roles in biotic defence of seeds and seedlings. Synthetic peptides based on their unique tryptophan‐rich domain (TRD) display antimicrobial properties. Bacterial endospores and biofilms are highly resistant cells, with significant implications in both medical and food industries. In this study, the cationic PIN TRD‐based peptides PuroA (FPVTWRWWKWWKG‐NH₂) and Pina‐M (FSVTWRWWKWWKG‐NH₂) and the related barley hordoindoline (HIN) based Hina (FPVTWRWWTWWKG‐NH₂) were tested for effects on planktonic cells and biofilms of the common human pathogens including Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Listeria monocytogenes and the non‐pathogenic Listeria innocua. All peptides showed significant bactericidal activity. Further, PuroA and Pina‐M at 2 × MIC prevented initial biomass attachment by 85–90% and inhibited >90% of 6‐h preformed biofilms of all three organisms. However Hina, with a substitution of Lys‐9 with uncharged Thr, particularly inhibited Listeria biofilms. The PIN based peptides were also tested against vegetative cells and endospores of Bacillus subtilis. The results provided evidence that these tryptophan‐rich peptides could kill B. subtilis even in sporulated state, reducing the number of viable spores by 4 log units. The treated spores appeared withered under scanning electron microscopy. The results establish the potential of these tryptophan‐rich peptides in controlling persistent pathogens of relevance to food industries and human health. Copyright © 2016 European Peptide Society and John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Physical mapping and a new variant of Puroindoline b-2 genes in wheat

Puroindoline a and b proteins soften the endosperm of wheat kernels. When the underlying puroindoline genes are altered by mutation or are deleted, kernels become harder. Thus, puroindoline a and b (Pina and Pinb) play an important role in wheat quality and utilization. Recently, additional Pinb genes have been reported. In the present report, we provide corroborating coding and additional 5′ and 3′ flanking sequence for three Pinb variants: Pinb-2v1, Pinb-2v2, and Pinb-2v3. Additionally, a new Pinb variant, Pinb-2v4, is reported. All four variants were physically mapped using Chinese Spring (CS) diteolosomics, nullisomic–tetrasomics, and CS-Cheyenne disomic substitution lines. Results place Pinb-2v1 on 7DL, Pinb-2v2 on 7BL, Pinb-2v3 on 7B, and Pinb-2v4 on 7AL. Pinb-2v1 and Pinb-2v4 were present in all cvs. examined: CS, Cheyenne, Recital, Wichita and Winsome. Pinb-2v2 was present in CS and Recital; Pinb-2v3 was present in Cheyenne, Wichita, and Winsome. These results are not wholly consistent with prior research and additional studies will be required to reconcile discrepancies. The discovery of Pinb-2v4 and the mapping of all four variants will contribute to a better understanding of gene duplication events in wheat and their bearing on wheat kernel texture and grain utilization.     

Real Time RT-PCR and flow cytometry to investigate wheat kernel hardness: role of puroindoline genes and proteins

Developing seeds from Triticum aestivum (wheat) cultivars were collected after flowering and analysed for puroindoline a and b gene expression by Real Time RT-PCR. Mature seeds were investigated for the presence and the amount of starch-associated puroindoline a and b proteins by flow cytometry. Puroindoline a gene and protein were found to have a predominant role in controlling wheat kernel hardness.     

Screening and cloning of antimicrobial DNA sequences using a vital staining method

A novel method for cloning of genes coding for cytotoxic molecules based on a cell viability assay is described. The working hypothesis is that expression of DNA sequences coding for cytotoxic molecules in bacterial cells will lead to cell death or impairment, and the isolation of the impaired or dead cells could lead to identification of DNA sequences responsible for debilitating the host cells. We verified this concept by isolating the well known antimicrobial Puroindoline b gene in Escherichia coli cells. We further demonstrated the feasibility to use this approach for isolating DNA encoding for antimicrobials from cDNA expression libraries. Sequence analysis and bioassay indicated that the isolated clones encoded previously characterized antimicrobial proteins (AMPs), proteins not previously characterized as AMPs, as well as novel antimicrobial peptides. In addition, clones harboring ribosomal protein encoding cDNA were also identified. Therefore, this method could also be used to identify host genes important in maintaining bacterial cell viability.     

粗山羊草(Aegilops tauschii)中Pinb基因的克隆和表达分析

puroindoline a(Pina)和puroindoline b(Pinb)是控制小麦籽粒硬度的主效基因。根据已报道的小麦Pinb基因的保守序列,设计合成了一对特异性引物,对粗山羊草Aegilops tauschii(DD)的基因组DNA进行Pinb基因扩增、克隆和序列分析,发现了一个新型Pinb等位基因。该基因长447 bp,编码148个氨基酸残基,具有麦类作物PinB蛋白所特有的WPTKWWK色氨酸结构域和10个半胱氨酸所形成的5个二硫键结构。与软粒小麦cv.Capitole的Pinb-D1a相比较,该基因含有14个氨基酸变异位点,其中包括一个紧邻色氨酸结构域的变异位点(Val66Phe),其核苷酸和氨基酸同源性分别为93.3%和90.5%。RT-PCR和Western Blot证实了Pinb基因在籽粒胚乳中的表达。Southern Blot分析结果表明,粗山羊草中Pinb基因为单拷贝。研究结果表明,粗山羊草中包含着与小麦差异较大的籽粒硬度控制基因,对此基因的进一步研究将加深对小麦籽粒硬度形成分子机制的了解。     

Proteomes of hard and soft near-isogenic wheat lines reveal that kernel hardness is related to the amplification of a stress response during endosperm development

Wheat kernel texture, a major trait determining the end-use quality of wheat flour, is mainly influenced by puroindolines. These small basic proteins display in vitro lipid binding and antimicrobial properties, but their cellular functions during grain development remain unknown. To gain an insight into their biological function, a comparative proteome analysis of two near-isogenic lines (NILs) of bread wheat Triticum aestivum L. cv. Falcon differing in the presence or absence of the puroindoline-a gene (Pina) and kernel hardness, was performed. Proteomes of the two NILs were compared at four developmental stages of the grain for the metabolic albumin/globulin fraction and the Triton-extracted amphiphilic fraction. Proteome variations showed that, during grain development, folding proteins and stress-related proteins were more abundant in the hard line compared with the soft one. These results, taken together with ultrastructural observations showing that the formation of the protein matrix occurred earlier in the hard line, suggested that a stress response, possibly the unfolded protein response, is induced earlier in the hard NIL than in the soft one leading to earlier endosperm cell death. Quantification of the albumin/globulin fraction and amphiphilic proteins at each developmental stage strengthened this hypothesis as a plateau was revealed from the 500 °Cd stage in the hard NIL whereas synthesis continued in the soft one. These results open new avenues concerning the function of puroindolines which could be involved in the storage protein folding machinery, consequently affecting the development of wheat endosperm and the formation of the protein matrix.     

Molecular approaches for identification and construction of novel insecticidal genes for crop protection

Summary The insecticidal cry (crystal) genes from Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) have been used for insect control both as biopesticides and in transgenic plants. Discovery of new insecticidal genes is of importance for delaying the development of resistance in target insects. The diversity of Bt strains facilitates isolation of new types of cry and vip (vegetative insecticidal protein) genes. PCR is a useful technique for quick and simultaneous screening of Bt strains for classification and prediction of insecticidal activities. PCR together with other methods of analysis such as RFLP, gene sequence determination, electrophoretic, immunological and chromatographic analysis of Cry proteins and insect bioassays for evaluation of toxicity have been employed for identification of new insecticidal proteins. Some other new approaches have also been devised. Many Bt strains with novel insecticidal genes have been found. A desired combination of Cry proteins can be assembled via site-specific recombination vectors into a recipient Bt strain to create a genetically improved biopesticide. For better pest control, the cry genes have been transferred to plants. Stacking of more than one insecticidal gene is required for resistance management in transgenic crops. Modification of Cry proteins through protein engineering for increasing the toxicity and/or the insecticidal spectrum is also a promising approach, but requires detailed understanding of the structure and function of these proteins and analysis of toxin-receptor interactions. More research into this area will provide useful insights for the design of toxins for management of insect resistance. Insecticidal genes from other bacteria and plants are also being examined for their potential for deployment in transgenic crops. Stringent implementation of resistance management is needed for maintaining the efficacy of Bt transgenic crops and deriving maximum economic and environmental benefit.     

Analysis of storage proteins (prolamines, puroindolines and Waxy) in common wheat lines Triticum aestivum L. × (Triticum timopheevii Zhuk. × Triticum tauschii) with complex resistance to fungal infections

Storage proteins (prolamines, puroindolines, and Waxy) were studied in common wheat introgression lines obtained with the use of the Saratovskaya 29 (S29) cultivar line and synthetic hexaploid wheat (Triticum timopheevii Zhuk. × T. tauschii) (Sintetik, Sin.) displaying complex resistance to fungal infections. Comparative analysis of storage proteins in the introgression lines of common wheat Triticum aestivum L. and in the parental forms revealed the only line (BC5) having a substitution at the Gli-B2 locus from Sintetik. Hybrid lines subjected to nine backcrosses with the recurrent parental form S29 and selections for resistance to pathogens can be considered as nearly isogenic for the selected trait and retaining the allelic composition of (1) prolamines responsible for the bread-making qualitiy, (2) puroindolines associated with grain texture, and (3) Waxy proteins responsible for nutritive qualities. These lines are valuable as donors of immunity in breeding programs without the loss of the quality of flour and grain as compared to the S29 line and are also important in searching for genes determining resistance to leaf and stem rust and to powdery mildew. The amphiploid has a number of characters (silent Glu-A1 locus and Ha genotype) that can negatively affect the quality of flour and grain and thus should be taken into account when choosing this donor.     

The Wheat Puroindoline Genes Confer Fungal Resistance in Transgenic Corn

Puroindoline a and b (Pina and Pinb), together make up the functional components of the wheat grain hardness locus (Ha) and have antimicrobial properties. The antifungal activity of puroindoline proteins, PINA and PINB, has been demonstrated in vitro and in vivo. In this study, Pina and Pinb were introduced into corn under the control of a corn Ubiquitin promoter. Two Pina/Pinb expression–positive transgenic events were evaluated for resistance to Cochliobolus heterostrophus, the corn southern leaf blight (SLB) pathogen. Transgenic corn expressing Pins showed significantly increased tolerance to C. heterostrophus, averaging 42.1% reduction in symptoms. Pins are effective in vivo as antifungal proteins and could be valuable tools in corn SLB control.