CMS sources in sunflower: different origin but same mechanism?

 The presence of orfH522, orfH708 and orfH873 in the mtDNA, as well as the expression of mitochondrially encoded proteins, were investigated for 28 sources of cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) and HA89, a fertile line of Helianthus annuus. The whole 5-kb insertion, found in PET1, is also present in all PET1-like CMS sources. However, with regard to the 11-kb inversion ANO1 demonstrated a different organization at the cob locus from the other PET1-like CMS sources. Only orfH873 gave hybridization patterns in all investigated cytoplasms. For the fertile cytoplasm, as well as ANN4, ANN5, ANL1, ANL2, ARG2 and MAX1, hybridizations obtained with orfH708 were highly polymorphic. Hybridization signals with orfH522 were only detectable in the PET1-like CMS sources and MAX1. Comparing the mitochondrially encoded proteins of the CMS sources characteristic patterns could be detected for seven cytoplasms in addition to the PET1-like CMS sources expressing the 16-kDa protein. For ANN1 and ANN3 three CMS-associated proteins of 16.3 kDa, 16.9 kDa and 34.0 kDa could be identified among the in organello translation products. Also ANT1 expressed three additional proteins of 13.4 kDa, 17.8 kDa and 19.7 kDa, respectively. In ARG3 and RIG1 one protein of 17.5 kDa was missing and instead a new protein of 16.9 kDa appeared. In addition, in GIG1 and PET2 a unique protein of 12.4 kDa could be identified. These results indicate that certain types of cytoplasmic male sterility are preferentially present in sunflower. Received: 15 June 1998 / Accepted: 13 July 1998     

Analyses of mitochondrial DNA structure and expression in three cytoplasmic male-sterile chicories originating from somatic hybridisation between fertile chicory and CMS sunflower protoplasts

Cytoplasmic male-sterile (CMS) chicories have been previously obtained by somatic hybridisation between fertile industrial chicory protoplasts and CMS sunflower protoplasts. In this study, we compared three different CMS chicory cybrids that originated from three different fusion events. The cybrids were backcrossed with different witloof chicories in order to transfer the three male-sterile cytoplasms from an industrial chicory nuclear environment to a witloof chicory nuclear context. Southern hybridisation, using different mitochondrial genes as probes, revealed that the three cybrid mitochondrial genomes were different and that they were stable throughout backcrossing generations regardless of the pollinator. However, pollinators were found to influence floral morphologies – with one being able to restore fertility – showing that nuclear context can affect the sterility of the cybrids. PCR and RFLP analyses revealed that the orf522 sequence, responsiblefor CMS in PET1 sunflower, was present in two out of the three cytoplasms studied, namely 411 and 523, but was absent from the other cytoplasm, 524. We thus concluded that orf522 is not responsible for CMS in the 524 cybrid. Although the orf522 gene is present in the 411 and 523 cytoplasms, it is probably not responsible for the sterile phenotype of these cybrids. Received: 3 June 1998 / Accepted: 30 April 1999     

Molecular diversity of male sterility inducing and male-fertile cytoplasms in the genus Helianthus

The organisation of mtDNA was investigated for 28 sources of cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) and a fertile line (normal cytoplasm) of Helianthus annuus by Southern hybridisation. In addition to nine known mitochondrial genes (atp6, atp9, cob, coxI, coxII, coxIII, 18S, 5S and nd5) three probes for the open reading frames in the rearranged area of PET1, orfH522, orfH708 and orfH873, were used. Genetic similarities of the investigat-ed cytoplasms varied between 0.3 and 1. Cluster analyses using the UPGMA method allowed the distinction of ten mitochondrial (mt) types between the 29 investigated cytoplasms. Most mitochondrial types comprise two or more CMS sources, which could not be further separated, like the PET1-like CMS sources (with the exception of ANO1 and PRR1), or ANN1/ANN2/ANN3, ANN4/ ANN5, ARG3/RIG1, BOL1/EXI1/PEF1/PEP1 and GIG1/ PET2. ANL1, ANL2 and the fertile cytoplasms are also regarded as one mitochondrial type. Unique banding patterns were only observed for ANT1 (atp6), MAX1 (atp6, orfH522 and orfH708) and PRR1 (coxII). However, four of the mitochondrial types showed unique hybridisation signals: ANN4/ANN5 had characteristic bands for atp6 and orfH708, PEF1/PEP1/EXI1/BOL1 for atp6 and coxII, and PET2/GIG1 for atp9. The PET1-like cytoplasms all shared the same patterns for orfH522, orfH708 and cob (except ANO1). It could be demonstrated that CMS sources, like, e.g., PET2 and PEF1, are different from PET1 in mtDNA organisation and the CMS mechanism. Therefore, these CMS sources represent interesting candidates for the development of new hybrid breeding systems based on new CMS mechanisms. Received: 20 April 2001 / Accepted: 3 August 2001     

Stoichiometric differences in DNA molecules containing the atpA gene suggest mechanisms for the generation of mitochondrial genome diversity in maize

Four genomic arrangements of the maize mitochondrial atpA gene (encoding the α subunit of the F₁ ATPase), have been characterized. Most N (fertile) and S (male-sterile) cytoplasms contain two atpA arrangements of equal abundance. Prolonged exposure of blots of maize mitochondrial DNA probed with atpA-specific sequences show that cytoplasms previously reported to lack one of the atpA arrangements do contain the second arrangement but at low levels. Similarly, restriction fragments containing the atpA gene previously thought unique to male-sterile S and T cytoplasms are present in low abundance in fertile cytoplasms. These observations suggest that fertile and male-sterile cytoplasms of maize may be more closely related than previously thought, and suggest possible mechanisms to explain the observed mitochondrial genome diversity.     

Cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) in Lolium perenne L.: 1. Development of a diagnostic probe for the male-sterile cytoplasm

Analysis of reciprocal crosses between nonrestoring fertile genotypes and restored male-sterile genotypes of Lolium perenne confirmed the cytoplasmic nature of the sterility trait. This prompted a search for a molecular probe that could be used to distinguish between fertile and cytoplasmic male-sterile (CMS) cytoplasms. We describe the identification and cloning of a 4.5-kb BamHI-HindIII restriction fragment from the mtDNA of the CMS line. The cloned fragment (pCMS45) failed to hybridise to sequences in the mtDNA of fertile lines and was thus capable of unambiguously distinguishing between fertile and CMS cytoplasms. The use of pCMS45 as a diagnostic probe provided a simple test for positive identification of young non-flowering plants carrying the CMS cytoplasm and also permitted confirmation at the molecular level of the maternal transmission of the CMS trait suggested by the genetic data.     

Variation in mitochondrial translation products in fertile and cytoplasmic male-sterile sugar beets

Summary Intact and functional mitochondria were isolated from sugar beet plants (Beta vulgaris L.) containing normal fertile (F) or cytoplasmic male-sterile (S₁–S₄) cytoplasms. Incorporation of ³⁵S-methionine by mitochondria isolated from both roots and leaves showed approximately 20 major and ten minor translation products. Comparison of the polypeptide synthesis patterns produced by leaf mitochondria from fertile plants of three different species within the genus Beta revealed several taxonomically related differences. Contrary to this, the patterns of polypeptides synthesized by mitochondria from roots and leaves of sugar beet plants containing the F and S₁–S₄ cytoplasms were very similar; in the S₁ and S₂ cytoplasms no qualitative, and only a few quantitative, differences from the F cytoplasm were observed. Thus, in these cases, cytoplasmic male sterility in sugar beet is not correlated with the constitutive expression of variant polypeptides. In the S₃ cytoplasm, however, an additional 6 kDa polypeptide was synthesized and in the S₄ cytoplasm an additional 10 kDa polypeptide was observed when compared with the F cytoplasm. The expression of cytoplasmic male sterility in sugar beet may be associated with these variant polypeptides. The mitochondrial polypeptides synthesized were identical in plants with different nuclear backgrounds but with identical S₁ cytoplasms. Mitochondria from plants with variants of the S₄ cytoplasm in the same nuclear genotype also showed identical patterns of polypeptide synthesis, including the synthesis of the 10 kDa S₄-specific polypeptide. Pulse-chase experiments did not affect the synthesis of this polypeptide.     

Downy mildew incidence of pearl millet hybrids with different male-sterility inducing cytoplasms

The use of different sources of cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) in hybrid seed production of pearl millet [Pennisetum glaucum (L.) R. Br.] is advocated to avoid possible disease epidemics occurring due to cytoplasmic uniformity. The effects of commercially unexploited, but potentially exploitable, sources of CMS, like A₂, A₃ and A₄, on downy mildew [Sclerospora graminicola (Sacc.) Schroet] incidence were studied by using the disease incidence of isonuclear hybrids with male-sterile and fertile cytoplasm. The mean downy mildew incidence of hybrids carrying different male-sterile cytoplasm was similar to that of hybrids retaining the fertile cytoplasm. The cytoplasm accounted for only 0.6% of the total variation and its effect was non-significant; pollinators could explain most of the variation in determining the disease incidence of hybrids. This suggested that these male-sterile cytoplasms are not linked to downy mildew susceptibility and thus can be exploited commercially to broaden the cytoplasmic base of the male-sterile lines and, ultimately, of hybrids.     

Diversifying Sunflower Germplasm by Integration and Mapping of a Novel Male Fertility Restoration Gene

The combination of a single cytoplasmic male-sterile (CMS) PET-1 and the corresponding fertility restoration (Rf) gene Rf₁ is used for commercial hybrid sunflower (Helianthus annuus L., 2n = 34) seed production worldwide. A new CMS line 514A was recently developed with H. tuberosus cytoplasm. However, 33 maintainers and restorers for CMS PET-1 and 20 additional tester lines failed to restore the fertility of CMS 514A. Here, we report the discovery, characterization, and molecular mapping of a novel Rf gene for CMS 514A derived from an amphiploid (Amp H. angustifolius/P 21, 2n = 68). Progeny analysis of the male-fertile (MF) plants (2n = 35) suggested that this gene, designated Rf₆, was located on a single alien chromosome. Genomic in situ hybridization (GISH) indicated that Rf₆ was on a chromosome with a small segment translocation on the long arm in the MF progenies (2n = 34). Rf₆ was mapped to linkage group (LG) 3 of the sunflower SSR map. Eight markers were identified to be linked to this gene, covering a distance of 10.8 cM. Two markers, ORS13 and ORS1114, were only 1.6 cM away from the gene. Severe segregation distortions were observed for both the fertility trait and the linked marker loci, suggesting the possibility of a low frequency of recombination or gamete selection in this region. This study discovered a new CMS/Rf gene system derived from wild species and provided significant insight into the genetic basis of this system. This will diversify the germplasm for sunflower breeding and facilitate understanding of the interaction between the cytoplasm and nuclear genes.     

Diversity among male-sterility-inducing and male-fertile cytoplasms of onion

Hybrid-onion (Allium cepa) seed is produced using systems of cytoplasmic-genic male sterility (CMS). Two different sources of CMS (S and T cytoplasms) have been genetically characterized. Testcrosses of N-cytoplasmic maintaining and restoring genotypes to S and T cytoplasmic lines demonstrated that different alleles, or loci, restore male fertility for these two male-sterile cytoplasms. Other sources of CMS have been used or reported in Europe, Japan and India, and their relationships to S and T cytoplasms are not clear. Restriction fragment length polymorphisms were identified in the organellar genomes among commercially used male-sterile cytoplasms from Holland, Japan and India, and were compared to S and T cytoplasms. Mitochondrial DNA diversity among 58 non-S-cytoplasmic open-pollinated onion populations was also assessed. All five putative CMS lines selected from the Indian population Nasik White Globe were identical to S cytoplasm for all polymorphisms in the chloroplast genome, and always possessed the same-sized mitochondrial fragments as S cytoplasm. T cytoplasm, the male-sterile cytoplasm used to produce the Dutch hybrid Hygro F₁, and two sources of CMS from Japan, were similar and showed numbers of mitochondrial polymorphisms similar to those observed among the 58 non-S-cytoplasmic open-pollinated populations. This research demonstrates that the same, or very similar, male-sterile cytoplasms have been independently isolated and exploited for hybrid-seed production in onion. Received: 27 October 1999 / Accepted: 12 February 2000     

Search for Protein Markers for the Genetic CMS–Rf System in Sunflower

Pollen and anthers of the F₁ hybrid with the restored fertility and the parental forms, a maternal male-sterile line harboring the mitochondrial orfH522 gene and a paternal male-fertile line harboring dominant alleles of the nuclear Rf gene, were studied. In order to find protein markers for the genetic CMS–Rf system in sunflower, we analyzed cytoplasmic proteins by disc electrophoresis under denaturing conditions. As a result, a protein fraction with a mol wt of 43 kD specific for cytoplasmic proteins of the paternal anthers, and a protein fraction with a mol wt of 16 kD specific for cytoplasmic proteins of the maternal anthers, were detected. The electrophoretic patterns of water-soluble proteins from the hybrid and paternal lines did not differ.     

Variant mitochondrial protein and DNA patterns associated with cytoplasmic male-sterile lines of Nicotiana

Summary Variation in mitochondrial protein synthesis and genome organization was investigated. Three different alloplasmic cytoplasmic male-sterile Nicotiana tabacum cultivars, carrying N. repanda, N. suaveolens or N. debneyi cytoplasm, were analysed together with corresponding male-fertile parental and restored material. Although several differences were detected in the proteins synthesized by isolated mitochondria from the male-sterile and male-fertile plants, most of these were related to the origin of the mitochondria. However, a 23 kD protein was synthesized in the male-sterile cultivar carrying N. debneyi mitochondria, but not in other lines containing this cytoplasm. This protein was also present in the male-fertile parent containing N. tabacum mitochondria. Only the enhanced production of a 30 kD protein in the lines carrying mitochondria from N. repanda or N. debneyi was exclusively correlated with CMS. This protein was not present in any of the corresponding male-fertile parental and restored lines. Restriction enzyme analysis of mitochondrial DNA revealed a difference in abundance of a 5.6 kb XhoI fragment between lines containing N. debneyi mitochondria. No rearrangements of mitochondrial DNA was found between male-fertile and male-sterile lines carrying N. repanda or N. suaveolens cytoplasm. These results might indicate that CMS in alloplasmic Nicotiana cultivars is caused by alterations in the expression of mitochondrial genes, rather than by induced changes in the genome.     

The use of mitochondrial DNA polymorphism in the classification of individual onion plants by cytoplasmic genotypes

Summary Individual plants of a Japanese onion variety Sapporo-ki, which is characterized by the occasional occurrence of male-sterile plants, have been investigated for mitochondrial (mt) DNA polymorphism. Male-fertile and the Jones' cytoplasmic male-sterile (CMS) onions were also included for comparison. Southern blot hybridization with rrn26, cox-I, cox-II, cob, atpA and atp9 genes as probes revealed the two classes of mtDNA variation within a population of Sapporo-ki: Out of the 41 plants examined 19 contained mtDNA typical of malefertile plants, and 22 individuals contained mtDNA typical of the Jones' CMS genotype. Our results thus indcate that the use of the mitochondrial gene probes may greatly facilitate the classification of individual plants by cytoplasmic genotypes.