Retinoic acid and its receptors in limb regeneration

The effects of retinoids on the regenerating amphibian limb are described: the mesenchymal cells of the blastema can be proximalized, posteriorized and ventralized. Ectopic limbs are also induced after retinoid treatment of regenerating tails, but not during limb development unless the limb bud is damaged. The cellular and molecular alterations induced by retinoids are reported as well as experiments which have revealed the importance of endogenous retinoids for normal limb regeneration. Various retinoic acid receptors are expressed in the regeneration blastema and the experiments which have revealed functions for individual isoforms are described. These experiments reveal that retinoids are a crucial component of the normal, regenerating limb and demonstrate the value of the regenerating limb as an experimental system for providing functional data on individual retinoic acid receptors.     

Retinoid signaling is required for chondrocyte maturation and endochondral bone formation during limb skeletogenesis

Retinoids have long been known to influence skeletogenesis but the specific roles played by these effectors and their nuclear receptors remain unclear. Thus, it is not known whether endogenous retinoids are present in developing skeletal elements, whether expression of the retinoic acid receptor (RAR) genes alpha, beta, and gamma changes during chondrocyte maturation, or how interference with retinoid signaling affects skeletogenesis. We found that immature chondrocytes present in stage 27 (Day 5.5) chick embryo humerus exhibited low and diffuse expression of RARalpha and gamma, while RARbeta expression was strong in perichondrium. Emergence of hypertrophic chondrocytes in Day 8-10 embryo limbs was accompanied by a marked and selective up-regulation of RARgamma gene expression. The RARgamma-rich type X collagen-expressing hypertrophic chondrocytes lay below metaphyseal prehypertrophic chondrocytes expressing Indian hedgehog (Ihh) and were followed by mineralizing chondrocytes undergoing endochondral ossification. Bioassays revealed that cartilaginous elements in Day 5.5, 8.5, and 10 chick embryo limbs all contained endogenous retinoids; strikingly, the perichondrial tissues surrounding the cartilages contained very large amounts of retinoids. Implantation of beads filled with retinoid antagonist Ro 41-5253 or AGN 193109 near the humeral anlagens in stage 21 (Day 3.5) or stage 27 chick embryos severely affected humerus development. In comparison to their normal counterparts, antagonist-treated humeri in Day 8.5-10 chick embryos were significantly shorter and abnormally bent; their diaphyseal chondrocytes had remained prehypertrophic Ihh-expressing cells, did not express RARgamma, and were not undergoing endochondral ossification. Interestingly, formation of an intramembranous bony collar around the diaphysis was not affected by antagonist treatment. Using chondrocyte cultures, we found that the antagonists effectively interfered with the ability of all-trans-retinoic acid to induce terminal cell maturation. The results provide clear evidence that retinoid-dependent and RAR-mediated mechanisms are required for completion of the chondrocyte maturation process and endochondral ossification in the developing limb. These mechanisms may be positively influenced by cooperative interactions between the chondrocytes and their retinoid-rich perichondrial tissues.     

Cellular contribution to supernumerary limbs resulting from the interaction between developing and regenerating tissues in the axolotl

The relationship between limb development and limb regeneration is considered with regard to the mechanisms by which pattern is established during limb outgrowth. In a previous paper (Muneoka, K. and Bryant, S. V. 1982 Nature (London) 298, 369-371) the interaction between cells from the developing limb bud and the regenerating limb blastema was found to result in the production of organized supernumerary limb structures. In this paper the relative cellular contribution from developing and regenerating cells to supernumerary limbs resulting from contralateral grafts between limb buds and blastemas has been analyzed using the triploid cell marker in the axolotl. Results show that there is substantial participation from both developing and regenerating limb cells to all supernumerary limbs analyzed. These data lend further support to the hypothesis that developing and regenerating limbs utilize the same patterning mechanisms during limb outgrowth. This conclusion is discussed in terms of patterning models for developing and regenerating limbs and it is proposed that the rules of the polar coordinate model can best explain the behavior of cells during limb development as well as limb regeneration.     

Retinoic acid-dependent attraction of adult spinal cord axons towards regenerating newt limb blastemas in vitro

Adult urodele amphibians possess the unique ability to regenerate amputated limbs and to re-innervate these regenerating structures; however, the factors involved in mediating this re-innervation are largely unknown. Here, we investigated the role of retinoic acid (RA) and one of its receptors, RARbeta, in the reciprocal neurotropic interactions between regenerating limb blastemas and spinal cord explants from the adult newt Notophthalmus viridescens. First, we showed that retinoic acid induced directed axonal outgrowth from cultured spinal cord tissue. This RA-induced outgrowth was significantly reduced when spinal cord explants were pre-treated with either the synthetic RAR pan antagonist, LE540, or the specific RARbeta antagonist, LE135. The role of RARbeta was also investigated using co-cultured regenerating limb blastemas and spinal cord explants. Blastemas induced significantly more axonal outgrowth from the near side of co-cultured explants, than from the far side (when cultured less than 1 mm apart). This blastema-induced directed outgrowth from co-cultured spinal cord explants was also abolished in the presence of the RARbeta antagonist, LE135. These data strongly suggest that endogenous retinoic acid is one of the tropic factors produced by the blastema and that it may be capable of guiding re-innervating axons to their targets. Moreover, this interaction is likely mediated by the retinoic acid beta nuclear receptor.     

The relationship among retinoid structure, affinity for retinoic acid-binding protein, and ability to respecify pattern in the regenerating axolotl limb

To further our understanding of the action of retinoids on the respecification of pattern in the regenerating axolotl limb we have studied the relative potencies of a range of synthetic and natural retinoids administered locally to the blastema. Alterations in the polar end group of the retinoic acid (RA) molecule to produce esters, the alcohol, or the aldehyde abolish the ability of the molecule to respecify pattern. On the other hand, alterations of the ring or side chain to produce the synthetic retinoids arotinoid and TTNPB considerably increases the potency of the molecule to respecify pattern--TTNPB is at least 100X more potent than retinoic acid. To examine the role of cellular retinoic acid-binding protein (CRABP) in the respecification process we determined the relative binding affinities of these retinoids for CRABP. These data correlated well with the respecification series: retinoids which showed no affinity for CRABP did not respecify pattern and those which did show affinity for CRABP did respecify pattern. Furthermore the most potent retinoid, TTNPB, has a higher affinity for CRABP than RA itself. This suggests that CRABP may be playing an important role in the action of RA on pattern formation in the regenerating limb.     

Effects of vitamin D metabolites on axolotl limb regeneration

Vitamin D is essential for normal metabolism of phosphorus and calcium, and differentiation of skeletal elements. 1,25 dihydroxyvitamin-D₃, the biologically active metabolite, acts as an induction/proliferation switch in various cell types and promotes chondrogenesis of chick limb bud mesenchymal cells. The function of vitamin D is mediated through its nuclear receptor, the vitamin D receptor (VDR). The proliferative actions of 1,25(OH)₂-D₃ on limb bud mesenchymal cells are similar to the ones produced by retinoids, such as all- trans retinoic acid (RA) or 9- cis retinoic acid (9- cis ). The retinoids have been shown to be compounds of extreme importance in the field of limb development and regeneration. In order to examine possible roles of vitamin D metabolites on limb regeneration, the effects of 1,25(OH)₂-D₃, 24,25(OH)₂-D₃ and KH1060 (a more potent metabolite) alone or in conjunction with all- trans RA or 9- cis RA on the regenerating axolotl limb. Vitamin D affects limb morphogenesis by generating abnormalities in skeletal elements. Synergism of vitamin D with retinoic acid in affecting pattern formation is suggested by the results.     

Fibroblast growth factors in regenerating limbs of Ambystoma: cloning and semi-quantitative RT-PCR expression studies

Urodele amphibians (newts and salamanders) have the ability to regenerate amputated limbs throughout their life span. Because fibroblast growth factors (Fgfs) play important roles in developing limbs, we initiated studies to investigate these growth factors in regenerating limbs. Partial cDNAs of Fgf4, 8, and 10 were cloned from both the Mexican axolotl, Ambystoma mexicanum, and locally collected spotted salamander, Ambystoma maculatum, two salamanders well recognized for their regenerative capabilities. cDNAs from the two Ambystoma species were virtually identical, ranging from 97-100% nucleotide identity. Axolotl Fgf4, 8, and 10 showed nucleotide sequence identity with chick Fgf4, 8, and 10 of 79%, 83%, and 72%, respectively. RT-PCR showed that these growth factors are expressed in regenerating axolotl limbs as well as in developing salamander larvae at the three-digit forelimb stage. Fgf8 and 10 are upregulated during regeneration and thus may be involved in distal signaling similar to that of the developing chick limb. Fgf4, however, was undetectable by RT-PCR in the distal tips of regenerates, suggesting that it does not play the same role in limb regeneration that it does in limb development. We also investigated the role these Fgfs may have in the nerve-dependence of regeneration. They were expressed similarly in aneurogenic and innervated limbs, suggesting that they are not the neurotrophic factors responsible for nerve-dependence. Denervation prevented Fgf8 and 10 upregulation, suggesting Fgf pathways are downstream of nerve-dependence. These data highlight important similarities and differences in Fgf expression between limb development and limb regeneration. J. Exp. Zool. 290:529-540, 2001.     

Retinoic acid proximalizes level-specific properties responsible for intercalary regeneration in axolotl limbs

The objective of this study was to determine whether retinoic acid (RA) coordinately proximalizes positional memory and the cellular recognition system that detects pattern discontinuity in regenerating amphibian limbs. The strategy was to test the capacity of RA-treated blastemas to evoke intercalary regeneration when grafted to an amputation level proximal to their level of origin. Control wrist and ankle, or elbow and knee blastemas treated with the retinoid solvent, dimethylsulphoxide, evoked intercalary regeneration as effectively as untreated blastemas, when grafted to the midstylopodial amputation surface of host limbs. RA-treated wrist and ankle or elbow and knee blastemas were proximalized and formed complete limbs that were at an angle to, or continuous with, the midstylopodium of the host limb. No intercalary regeneration, from either graft or host, was observed in these cases. The results indicate that the cellular mechanism that recognizes disparities between non-neighbouring cells and initiates intercalary regeneration is coordinately proximalized with positional memory. Thus the recognition mechanism and positional memory are directly related. Intercalary regeneration and corrective displacement (affinophoresis), both of which restore a pattern of normal cell neighbours by different means in regenerating axolotl limbs, appear to use the same mechanism to recognize pattern discontinuity.     

Effects of retinoids on the production of tumour necrosis factor-alpha and nitric oxide by lipopolysaccharide-stimulated rat Kupffer cells in vitro: evidence for participation of retinoid X receptor signalling pathway

Kupffer cells play important roles in the development of liver injury by producing cytokines and free radicals. In consequence inhibition of these inflammatory mediators will be one of the targets for treating liver diseases. Retinoids modulate a wide variety of functions of monocytes/macrophages. Cellular effects of retinoids are mediated by two families of nuclear receptors, retinoic acid receptors (RARs) and retinoid X receptors (RXRs). We examined the effects of several kinds of natural and synthetic retinoids on the production of tumour necrosis factor-α (TNF-α) and nitric oxide (NO) by LPS-stimulated rat Kupffer cells in vitro. Of the various retinoids tested, 9-cis-retinoic acid (9-cis-RA) and Ro 13-6307, which are agonists of both RARs and RXRs, suppressed the production of TNF-α and NO in a concentration-dependent fashion, whereas three types of RAR-selective agonists, Ro 13-7410, Ro 40-6055 and Ro 19-0645 did not show any effect. Furthermore, the RARα antagonist, Ro 41-5253, did not prevent the effects induced by 9-cis-RA. The results suggest that these effects of 9-cis RA and Ro 13-6307 were induced by the RXRs-dependent signalling pathway. © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

A role for retinoic acid in regulating the regeneration of deer antlers

Deer antlers are the only mammalian organs that can be repeatedly regenerated; each year, these complex structures are shed and then regrow to be used for display and fighting. To date, the molecular mechanisms controlling antler regeneration are not well understood. Vitamin A and its derivatives, retinoic acids, play important roles in embryonic skeletal development. Here, we provide several lines of evidence consistent with retinoids playing a functional role in controlling cellular differentiation during bone formation in the regenerating antler. Three receptors (alpha, beta, gamma) for both the retinoic acid receptor (RAR) and retinoid X receptor (RXR) families show distinct patterns of expression in the growing antler tip, the site of endochondral ossification. RAR alpha and RXR beta are expressed in skin ("velvet") and the underlying perichondrium. In cartilage, which is vascularised, RXR beta is specifically expressed in chondrocytes, which express type II collagen, and RAR alpha in perivascular cells, which also express type I collagen, a marker of the osteoblast phenotype. High-performance liquid chromatography analysis shows significant amounts of Vitamin A (retinol) in antler tissues at all stages of differentiation. The metabolites all-trans-RA and 4-oxo-RA are found in skin, perichondrium, cartilage, bone, and periosteum. The RXR ligand, 9-cis-RA, is found in perichondrium, mineralised cartilage, and bone. To further define sites of RA synthesis in antler, we immunolocalised retinaldehyde dehydrogenase type 2 (RALDH-2), a major retinoic acid-generating enzyme. RALDH-2 is expressed in the skin and perichondrium and in perivascular cells in cartilage, although chondroprogenitors and chondrocytes express very low levels. At sites of bone formation, differentiated osteoblasts which express the bone-specific protein osteocalcin express high levels of RALDH2. The effect of RA on antler cell differentiation was studied in vitro; all-trans-RA inhibits expression of the chondrocyte phenotype, an effect that is blocked by addition of the RAR antagonist Ro41-5253. In monolayer cultures of mesenchymal progenitor cells, all-trans-RA increases the expression of alkaline phosphatase, a marker of the osteoblastic phenotype. In summary, this study has shown that antler tissues contain endogenous retinoids, including 9-cis RA, and the enzyme RALDH2 that generates RA. Sites of RA synthesis in antler correspond closely with the localisation of cells which express receptors for these ligands and which respond to the effects of RA.     

Retionic acid and its receptors are required for expression of aryl hydrocarbon receptor mRNA and embryonic development of blood vessel and bone in the medaka fish, Oryzias latipes

Retinoic acid (RA), the active derivative of vitamin A, is essential for normal embryonic development of vertebrates because both the lack and excess of RA result in developmental malformations. We previously reported that aryl hydrocarbon receptor (AHR) is also required for vascular and bone formation by regulating cytochrome P450 expression. However, little is known about the roles of retinoic acid receptors (RAR) and retinoid X receptors (RXR) in the embryonic development of blood vessels and molecular cross-talk between RAR/RXR and AHR. We report for the first time that RA and RAR/RXR are required for expression of AHR mRNA and the embryonic development of blood vessel and bone. The embryonic organogenesis of medaka fish was specifically inhibited by an inhibitor of RA synthesis (diethylaminobenzaldehyde), antagonists of RAR (Ro41-5253) and RXR (Ro71-4595), agonist (beta-naphthoflavone) and antagonist (alpha-naphthoflavone) of AHR, and excess RA. These reagents are useful for future studies to elucidate molecular mechanisms for vascular and bone formation in the medaka embryogenesis. Our results also show that medaka embryos may be useful for screening inhibitors of vascular formation for anti-cancer drugs.     

Transforming growth factor: beta signaling is essential for limb regeneration in axolotls

Axolotls (urodele amphibians) have the unique ability, among vertebrates, to perfectly regenerate many parts of their body including limbs, tail, jaw and spinal cord following injury or amputation. The axolotl limb is the most widely used structure as an experimental model to study tissue regeneration. The process is well characterized, requiring multiple cellular and molecular mechanisms. The preparation phase represents the first part of the regeneration process which includes wound healing, cellular migration, dedifferentiation and proliferation. The redevelopment phase represents the second part when dedifferentiated cells stop proliferating and redifferentiate to give rise to all missing structures. In the axolotl, when a limb is amputated, the missing or wounded part is regenerated perfectly without scar formation between the stump and the regenerated structure. Multiple authors have recently highlighted the similarities between the early phases of mammalian wound healing and urodele limb regeneration. In mammals, one very important family of growth factors implicated in the control of almost all aspects of wound healing is the transforming growth factor-beta family (TGF-beta). In the present study, the full length sequence of the axolotl TGF-beta1 cDNA was isolated. The spatio-temporal expression pattern of TGF-beta1 in regenerating limbs shows that this gene is up-regulated during the preparation phase of regeneration. Our results also demonstrate the presence of multiple components of the TGF-beta signaling machinery in axolotl cells. By using a specific pharmacological inhibitor of TGF-beta type I receptor, SB-431542, we show that TGF-beta signaling is required for axolotl limb regeneration. Treatment of regenerating limbs with SB-431542 reveals that cellular proliferation during limb regeneration as well as the expression of genes directly dependent on TGF-beta signaling are down-regulated. These data directly implicate TGF-beta signaling in the initiation and control of the regeneration process in axolotls.     

The prevention of adipose differentiation of 3T3-L1 cells caused by retinoic acid is elicited through retinoic acid receptor alpha

Retinoids, especially all-trans retinoic acid (RA), have been shown to inhibit the differentiation of preadipose cells. It is important to human health, especially to obesity, that the regulatory system for the differentiation of adipocytes is well defined. Previously, we have shown that retinoic acid receptor (RAR) γ2 gene expression is up-regulated by RA in 3T3-L1 preadipose cells. In this study, the RAR system was dissected and the RA-regulated function in 3T3-L1 cells was assigned to one given receptor. We used three synthetic retinoids; (1) Ro 41–5253, a selective RAR α antagonist, (2) Ch 55, an RAR α, β and γ agonist, and (3) Am 80, an RAR α and β agonist, which has less affinity to RAR γ. Ro 41–5253 reverted RA-induced inhibition of the differentiation of 3T3-L1 cells. However, there was no significant reversion in RA-induced RAR γ mRNA level by treatment with Ro 41–5253. In the case of RAR agonists, both Am 80 and Ch 55 strongly inhibited the differentiation of 3T3-L1 cells. However, Am 80 weakly increased RAR γ mRNA content less than did Ch 55. These findings suggest, that RAR α is involved in the prevention of adipose differentiation by RA in 3T3-L1 cells. Moreover, there seems no causal relationship between the prevention of adipose differentiation by RA and the up-regulation of RAR γ2 gene expression by RA in 3T3-L1 cells. We have shown the functional heterogeneity of RA action through different RARs in 3T3-L1 cells.     

Role of thyroid hormone and retinoid receptors in the homeotic transformation of tails into limbs in frogs

We provide here further data on the dramatic homeotic transformation of tails into limbs which is induced by retinoids during frog tadpole tail regeneration. The effect can still be produced up to nine days after tail amputation by which time tail regeneration has essentially been completed. Complete tail amputation is needed for the effects to be manifest, partial damage of various sorts to the tail is not enough. We show that as well as retinyl palmitate, other retinoids such as all-trans-retinoic acid and TTNPB, which is a RAR specific retinoid, can induce the homeotic transformation. TTNPB has a 300x greater potency than retinoic acid. Prolactin, which inhibits thyroid hormone production, prevents the appearance of limbs on the tail from which we conclude that thyroid hormone is needed. We present preliminary evidence from RT-PCR that all six retinoid receptors, the three retinoic acid receptors (RARs), and the three retinoid X receptors (RXRs), are present in the normal tail blastema and that after retinoid treatment RARα, RXRα, and RXRβ may be up-regulated. Finally, we show that when RA synthesis is inhibited, normal tail regeneration is inhibited. We conclude that tail regeneration depends upon a particular endogenous level of RA, but that when this level is raised by external administration and thyroid hormone receptors are present the up-regulation of certain retinoid receptors allows novel nuclear receptor interactions which results in the induction of limb-specific genes leading to the appearance of limbs on the tail. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Transforming Growth Factor: β Signaling Is Essential for Limb Regeneration in Axolotls

Axolotls (urodele amphibians) have the unique ability, among vertebrates, to perfectly regenerate many parts of their body including limbs, tail, jaw and spinal cord following injury or amputation. The axolotl limb is the most widely used structure as an experimental model to study tissue regeneration. The process is well characterized, requiring multiple cellular and molecular mechanisms. The preparation phase represents the first part of the regeneration process which includes wound healing, cellular migration, dedifferentiation and proliferation. The redevelopment phase represents the second part when dedifferentiated cells stop proliferating and redifferentiate to give rise to all missing structures. In the axolotl, when a limb is amputated, the missing or wounded part is regenerated perfectly without scar formation between the stump and the regenerated structure. Multiple authors have recently highlighted the similarities between the early phases of mammalian wound healing and urodele limb regeneration. In mammals, one very important family of growth factors implicated in the control of almost all aspects of wound healing is the transforming growth factor-beta family (TGF-β). In the present study, the full length sequence of the axolotl TGF-β1 cDNA was isolated. The spatio-temporal expression pattern of TGF-β1 in regenerating limbs shows that this gene is up-regulated during the preparation phase of regeneration. Our results also demonstrate the presence of multiple components of the TGF-β signaling machinery in axolotl cells. By using a specific pharmacological inhibitor of TGF-β type I receptor, SB-431542, we show that TGF-β signaling is required for axolotl limb regeneration. Treatment of regenerating limbs with SB-431542 reveals that cellular proliferation during limb regeneration as well as the expression of genes directly dependent on TGF-β signaling are down-regulated. These data directly implicate TGF-β signaling in the initiation and control of the regeneration process in axolotls.