Comparative analysis of thylakoid protein complexes in the mesophyll and bundle sheath cells from C3, C4 and C3–C4 Paniceae grasses

To better understand the coordination between dark and light reactions during the transition from C₃ to C₄ photosynthesis, we optimized a method for separating thylakoids from mesophyll (MC) and bundle sheath cells (BSCs) across different plant species. We grew six Paniceae grasses including representatives from the C₃, C₃–C₄ and C₄ photosynthetic types and all three C₄ biochemical subtypes [nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate‐dependent malic enzyme (NADP‐ME), nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide‐dependent malic enzyme (NAD‐ME) and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase (PEPCK)] in addition to Zea mays under control conditions (1000 μmol quanta m^?2 s^?1 and 400 ppm of CO₂). Proteomics analysis of thylakoids under native conditions, using blue native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis followed by liquid chromatography‐mass spectrometry (LC‐MS), demonstrated the presence of subunits of all light‐reaction‐related complexes in all species and cell types. C₄ NADP‐ME species showed a higher photosystems I/II ratio and a clear accumulation of the NADH dehydrogenase‐like complexes in BSCs, while Cytb₆f was more abundant in BSCs of C₄ NAD‐ME species. The C₄ PEPCK species showed no clear differences between cell types. Our study presents, for the first time, a good separation between BSC and MC for a C₃–C₄ intermediate grass which did not show noticeable differences in the distribution of the thylakoid complexes. For the NADP‐ME species Panicum antidotale, growth at glacial CO₂ (180 ppm of CO₂) had no effect on the distribution of the light‐reaction complexes, while growth at low light (200 μmol quanta m^?2 s^?1) promoted the accumulation of light‐harvesting proteins in both cell types. These results add to our understanding of thylakoid distribution across photosynthetic types and subtypes, and introduce thylakoid distribution between the MC and BSC of a C₃–C₄ intermediate species.     

The efficiency of the CO2-concentrating mechanism during single-cell C4 photosynthesis

The photosynthetic efficiency of the CO₂‐concentrating mechanism in two forms of single‐cell C₄ photosynthesis in the family Chenopodiaceae was characterized. The Bienertioid‐type single‐cell C₄ uses peripheral and central cytoplasmic compartments (Bienertia sinuspersici), while the Borszczowioid single‐cell C₄ uses distal and proximal compartments of the cell (Suaeda aralocaspica). C₄ photosynthesis within a single‐cell raises questions about the efficiency of this type of CO₂‐concentrating mechanism compared with the Kranz‐type. We used measurements of leaf CO₂ isotope exchange (Δ¹³C) to compare the efficiency of the single‐cell and Kranz‐type forms of C₄ photosynthesis under various temperature and light conditions. Comparisons were made between the single‐cell C₄ and a sister Kranz form, S. eltonica[NAD malic enzyme (NAD ME) type], and with Flaveria bidentis[NADP malic enzyme (NADP‐ME) type with Kranz Atriplicoid anatomy]. There were similar levels of Δ¹³C discrimination and CO₂ leakiness (?) in the single‐cell species compared with the Kranz‐type. Increasing leaf temperature (25 to 30 °C) and light intensity caused a decrease in Δ¹³C and ? across all C₄ types. Notably, B. sinuspersici had higher Δ¹³C and ? than S. aralocaspica under lower light. These results demonstrate that rates of photosynthesis and efficiency of the CO₂‐concentrating mechanisms in single‐cell C₄ plants are similar to those in Kranz‐type.     

Variations in nitrogen use efficiency reflect the biochemical subtype while variations in water use efficiency reflect the evolutionary lineage of C4 grasses at inter‐glacial CO2

C₄ photosynthesis evolved multiple times in diverse lineages. Most physiological studies comparing C₄ plants were not conducted at the low atmospheric CO₂ prevailing during their evolution. Here, 24 C₄ grasses belonging to three biochemical subtypes [nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide malic enzyme (NAD‐ME), phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase (PCK) and nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate malic enzyme (NADP‐ME)] and six major evolutionary lineages were grown under ambient (400 μL L^?1) and inter‐glacial (280 μL L^?1) CO₂. We hypothesized that nitrogen‐related and water‐related physiological traits are associated with subtypes and lineages, respectively. Photosynthetic rate and stomatal conductance were constrained by the shared lineage, while variation in leaf mass per area (LMA), leaf N per area, plant dry mass and plant water use efficiency were influenced by the subtype. Subtype and lineage were equally important for explaining variations in photosynthetic nitrogen use efficiency (PNUE) and photosynthetic water use efficiency (PWUE). CO₂ treatment impacted most parameters. Overall, higher LMA and leaf N distinguished the Chloridoideae/NAD‐ME group, while NADP‐ME and PCK grasses were distinguished by higher PNUE regardless of lineage. Plants were characterized by high photosynthesis and PWUE when grown at ambient CO₂ and by high conductance at inter‐glacial CO₂. In conclusion, the evolutionary and biochemical diversity among C₄ grasses was aligned with discernible leaf physiology, but it remains unknown whether these traits represent ecophysiological adaptation.     

Intracellular localization of certain photosynthetic enzymes in bundle sheath cells of plants possessing the C4 pathway of photosynthesis.

Bundle sheath cells were enzymatically isolated from representatives of three groups of C₄ plants: Zea mays (NADP malic enzyme type), Panicum miliaceum (NAD malic enzyme type), and Panicum maximum (phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) carboxykinase type). Cellular organelles from bundle sheath homogenates were partially resolved by differential centrifugation and on isopycnic sucrose density gradients in order to study compartmentation of photosynthetic enzymes. A 48-h-dark pretreatment of the leaves allowed the isolation of relatively intact chloroplasts. Enzymes that decarboxylate C₄ acids and furnish CO₂ to the Calvin cycle are localized as follows: NADP malic enzyme, chloroplastic in Z. mays; NAD malic enzyme, mitochondrial in all three species; PEP carboxykinase, chloroplastic in P. maximum. The activity of NAD malic enzyme in the three species was in the order of P. miliaceum > P. maximum > Z. mays. There were high levels of aspartate and alanine aminotransferases in bundle sheath extracts of P. miliaceum and P. maximum and substantial activity in Z. mays. In all three species, aspartate aminotransferase was mitochondrial whereas alanine aminotransferase was cytoplasmic. Based on the activity and localization of certain enzymes, the concept for aspartate and malate as transport metabolites from mesophyll to bundle sheath cells in C₄ species of the three C₄ groups is discussed.     

Association of NADP- and NAD-linked malic enzyme acitivities in Zea mays: relation to C4 pathway photosynthesis.

Two of the three metabolic subtypes of species utilizing C₄-pathway photosynthesis are defined by high activities of either NADP malic enzyme (NADP malic enzyme type) or a coenzyme A (CoA)- and acetyl-CoA-activated NAD malic enzyme (NAD malic enzyme type). These enzymes function to decarboxylate malate as an integral part of the photosynthetic process. Leaves of NADP malic enzyme-type species also contain significant NAD-dependent malic enzyme activity. The purpose of the present study was to examine the nature and photosynthetic role of this activity. With Zea mays, this NAD-dependent activity was found to vary widely in fresh leaf extracts. Incubating extracts at 25 °C resulted in a disproportionate increase in NAD activity so that the final ratio of NADP to NAD activity was always about 5. Strong evidence was provided that the NADP and NAD malic enzyme activities in Z. mays extracts were catalyzed by the same enzyme. These activities remained associated during purification and were coincident after polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The pH optimum for NAD-dependent activity was about 7.1, compared with 8.3 for NADP malic enzyme activity. Other properties of the NAD-dependent activity are described, a particularly notable feature being the inhibition of this activity by less than 1 μm NADP and NADPH. Evidence is provided that the NADP malic enzyme of several other NADP malic enzyme-type C₄ species also has associated activity toward NAD. We concluded that the NAD-dependent malic enzyme activity would have no significant function in photosynthesis.     

Form of inorganic carbon involved as a product and as an inhibitor of c(4) Acid decarboxylases operating in c(4) photosynthesis

These studies demonstrated that CO₂ rather than HCO₃⁻ is the inorganic carbon metabolite produced by the C₄ acid decarboxylases involved in C₄ photosynthesis (chloroplast located NADP malic enzyme, mitochondrial NAD malic enzyme, and cytosolic phosphoenolpyruvate [PEP] carboxykinase). The effect of varying CO₂ or HCO₃⁻ as a substrate for the carboxylation reaction catalyzed by these enzymes or as inhibitors of the decarboxylation reaction was also determined. The K_mCO₂ was 1.1 millimolar for NADP malic enzyme and 2.5 millimolar for PEP carboxykinase. For these two enzymes the velocity in the carboxylating direction was substantially less than for the decarboxylating direction even with CO₂ concentrations at the upper end of the range of expected cellular levels. Activity of NAD malic enzyme in the carboxylating direction was undetectable. The decarboxylation reaction of all three enzymes was inhibited by added HCO₃⁻. For NADP malic enzyme CO₂ was shown to be the inhibitory species but PEP carboxykinase and NAD malic enzyme were apparently inhibited about equally by CO₂ and HCO₃⁻.     

Diversity in forms of C4 in the genus Cleome (Cleomaceae)

Background and Aims

Cleomaceae is one of 19 angiosperm families in which C₄ photosynthesis has been reported. The aim of the study was to determine the type, and diversity, of structural and functional forms of C₄ in genus Cleome.

Methods

Plants of Cleome species were grown from seeds, and leaves were subjected to carbon isotope analysis, light and scanning electron microscopy, western blot analysis of proteins, and in situ immunolocalization for ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase oxygenase (Rubisco) and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC).

Key Results

Three species with C₄-type carbon isotope values occurring in separate lineages in the genus (Cleome angustifolia, C. gynandra and C. oxalidea) were shown to have features of C₄ photosynthesis in leaves and cotyledons. Immunolocalization studies show that PEPC is localized in mesophyll (M) cells and Rubisco is selectively localized in bundle sheath (BS) cells in leaves and cotyledons, characteristic of species with Kranz anatomy. Analyses of leaves for key photosynthetic enzymes show they have high expression of markers for the C₄ cycle (compared with the C₃–C₄ intermediate C. paradoxa and the C₃ species C. africana). All three are biochemically NAD-malic enzyme sub-type, with higher granal development in BS than in M chloroplasts, characteristic of this biochemical sub-type. Cleome gynandra and C. oxalidea have atriplicoid-type Kranz anatomy with multiple simple Kranz units around individual veins. However, C. angustifolia anatomy is represented by a double layer of concentric chlorenchyma forming a single compound Kranz unit by surrounding all the vascular bundles and water storage cells.

Conclusions

NAD-malic enzyme-type C₄ photosynthesis evolved multiple times in the family Cleomaceae, twice with atriplicoid-type anatomy in compound leaves having flat, broad leaflets in the pantropical species C. gynandra and the Australian species C. oxalidea, and once by forming a single Kranz unit in compound leaves with semi-terete leaflets in the African species C. angustifolia. The leaf morphology of C. angustifolia, which is similar to that of the sister, C₃–C₄ intermediate African species C. paradoxa, suggests adaptation of this lineage to arid environments, which is supported by biogeographical information.     

Photosynthetic,hydraulic and biomass properties in closely related C3 and C4 species

In plants, most water is absorbed by roots and transported through vascular conduits of xylem which evaporate from leaves during photosynthesis. As photosynthesis and transport processes are interconnected, it was hypothesized that any variation in water transport demand influencing water use efficiency (WUE), such as the evolution of C₄ photosynthesis, should affect xylem structure and function. Several studies have provided evidence for this hypothesis, but none has comprehensively compared photosynthetic, hydraulic and biomass allocation properties between C₃ and C₄ species. In this study, photosynthetic, hydraulic and biomass properties in a closely related C₃ Tarenaya hassleriana and a C₄ Cleome gynandra are compared. Light response curves, measured at 30°C, showed that the C₄ C. gynandra had almost twice greater net assimilation rates than the C₃ T. hassleriana under each increasing irradiation level. On the contrary, transpiration rates and stomatal conductance were around twice as high in the C₃, leading to approximately 3.5 times higher WUE in the C₄ compared with the C₃ species. The C₃ showed about 3.3 times higher hydraulic conductivity, 4.3 times greater specific conductivity and 2.6 times higher leaf‐specific conductivity than the C₄ species. The C₃ produced more vessels per xylem area and larger vessels. All of these differences resulted in different biomass properties, where the C₄ produced more biomass in general and had less root to shoot ratio than the C₃ species. These results are in support of our previous findings that WUE, and any changes that affect WUE, contribute to xylem evolution in plants.     

Purification and Characterization of NAD Malic Enzyme from Leaves of Eleusine coracana and Panicum dichotomiflorum

NAD malic enzyme (EC 1.1.1.39), which is involved in C₄ photosynthesis, was purified to electrophoretic homogeneity from leaves of Eleusine coracana and to near homogeneity from leaves of Panicum dichotomiflorum. The enzyme from each C₄ species was found to have only one type of subunit by SDS polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The M_r of subunits of the enzme from E. coracana and P. dichotommiflorum was 63 and 61 kilodaltons, respectively. The native Mr of the enzyme from each species was determined by gel filtration to be about 500 kilodaltons, indicating that the NAD malic enzyme from C₄ species is an octamer of identical subunits. The purified NAD malic enzyme from each C₄ species showed similar kinetic properties with respect to concentrations of malate and NAD; each had a requirement for Mn²⁺ and activation by fructose- 1,6-bisphosphate (FBP) or CoA. A cooperativity with respect to Mn²⁺ was apparent with both enzymes. The activator (FBP) did not change the Hill value but greatly decreased K_0.5 (the concentration giving half-maximal activity) for Mn²⁺. The enzyme from E. coracana showed a very low level of activity when NADP was used as substrate, but this activity was also stimulated by FBP. Significant differences between the enzymes from E. coracana and P. dichotomiflorum were observed in their responses to the activators and their immunochemical properties. The enzyme from E. coracana was largely dependent on the activators FBP or CoA, regardless of concentration of Mn²⁺. In contrast, the enzyme from P. dichotomiflorum showed significant activity in the absence of the activator, especially at high concentrations of Mn²⁺. Both immunodiffusion and immunoprecipitation, using antiserum raised against the purified NAD malic enzyme from E. coracana, revealed partial antigenic differences between the enzymes from E. coracana and P. dichotomiflorum. The activity of the NAD malic enzyme from Amaranthus edulis, a typical NAD malic enzyme type C₄ dicot, was not inhibited by the antiserum raised against the NAD malic enzyme from E. coracana.     

Mitochondria as a site of C4 acid decarboxylation in C4-pathway photosynthesis.

One group of C₄, species utilize a NAD-malic enzyme to decarboxylate C₄ acids. This enzyme, together with a major isoenzyme of aspartate aminotransferase and a NAD-malate dehydrogenase, is localized in the mitochondria of the bundle sheath cells and the following pathway for C₄, acid decarboxylation has been proposed: aspartate → oxaloacetate → malate → CO₂ + pyruvate. The present study reports that mitochondria isolated from the bundle sheath cells of one of these species, Atriplex spongiosa, are capable of decarboxylating C₄, acids at rates between 5 and 8 μmol/min/mg chlorophyll. For maximum decarboxylating activities, these particles required aspartate, 2-oxoglutarate and phosphate as well as malate; in the absence of any one of these compounds, activity was reduced to 0.3–0.8 μmol/min/mg chlorophyll. Rates for C₄ acid decarboxylation were much greater than the respiratory activities of these particles, including the capacity to form citrate or to oxidize malate, succinate, pyruvate or 2-oxoglutarate (0.03–0.6 μmol/min/mg chlorophyll). A comparison of mitochondria prepared from leaves of various C₄, and C₃, species showed that only the mitochondria from the bundle sheath cells of plants with high NAD-malic enzyme have capacities for rapid C₄ acid decarboxylation. The effects of a variety of experimental conditions on C₄ acid decarboxylating activities are also reported. The role of these mitochondria in C₄ photosynthesis is discussed.     

Influence of Light and Temperature on Photosynthesis and Transpiration in Some C3 and C4 Vegetable Plants from Kenya

Potted vegetable plants of Amaranthus lividus, Gynandropsis gynandra and Crotalaria brevidens were grown outside under normal tropical conditions and rate of photosynthesis and transpiration were determined simultaneously in attached leaves under a range of leaf temperatures and irradiances. Photosynthetic rates were consistently higher in G. gynandra than in A. lividus and C. brevidens. However, in C. brevidens and G. gynandra the leaf resistances were lower and transpiration rates were higher than those in A. lividus. The results on optimum temperature requirements for maximum rates of CO₂ fixation, coupled with data on CO₂ compensation points and leaf anatomy provided clear evidence that G. gynandra and A. lividus are C₄ species, while C. brevidens is a C₃ species. The differential effects of light intensity and temperature on stomata and mesophyll resistances in C₃ and C₄ species are discussed in relation to rates of photosynthesis and transpiration.     

Distribution of Nitrate-assimilating Enzymes between Mesophyll Protoplasts and Bundle Sheath Cells in Leaves of Three Groups of C(4) Plants

Intercellular distribution of enzymes involved in amino nitrogen synthesis was studied in leaves of species representing three C₄ groups, i.e. Sorghum bicolor, Zea mays, Digitaria sanguinalis (NADP malic enzyme type); Panicum miliaceum (NAD malic enzyme type); and Panicum maximum (phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase type). Nitrate reductase, nitrite reductase, glutamine synthetase, and glutamate synthase were predominantly localized in mesophyll cells of all the species, except in P. maximum where nitrite reductase had similar activity on a chlorophyll basis, in both mesophyll and bundle sheath cells. NADH-glutamate dehydrogenase was concentrated in the bundle sheath cells, while NADPH-glutamate dehydrogenase was localized in both mesophyll and bundle sheath cells. The activities of nitrate-assimilating enzymes, except for nitrate reductase, were high enough to account for the proposed in vivo rates of nitrate assimilation.     

Occurrence of C3 and C4 photosynthesis in cotyledons and leaves of Salsola species (Chenopodiaceae)

Most species of the genus Salsola (Chenopodiaceae) that have been examined exhibit C₄ photosynthesis in leaves. Four Salsola species from Central Asia were investigated in this study to determine the structural and functional relationships in photosynthesis of cotyledons compared to leaves, using anatomical (Kranz versus non-Kranz anatomy, chloroplast ultrastructure) and biochemical (activities of photosynthetic enzymes of the C₃ and C₄ pathways, ¹⁴C labeling of primary photosynthesis products and ¹³C/¹²C carbon isotope fractionation) criteria. The species included S. paulsenii from section Salsola, S. richteri from section Coccosalsola, S. laricina from section Caroxylon, and S. gemmascens from section Malpigipila. The results show that all four species have a C₄ type of photosynthesis in leaves with a Salsoloid type Kranz anatomy, whereas both C₃ and C₄ types of photosynthesis were found in cotyledons. S. paulsenii and S. richteri have NADP- (NADP-ME) C₄ type biochemistry with Salsoloid Kranz anatomy in both leaves and cotyledons. In S. laricina, both cotyledons and leaves have NAD-malic enzyme (NAD-ME) C₄ type photosynthesis; however, while the leaves have Salsoloid type Kranz anatomy, cotyledons have Atriplicoid type Kranz anatomy. In S. gemmascens, cotyledons exhibit C₃ type photosynthesis, while leaves perform NAD-ME type photosynthesis. Since the four species studied belong to different Salsola sections, this suggests that differences in photosynthetic types of leaves and cotyledons may be used as a basis or studies of the origin and evolution of C₄ photosynthesis in the family Chenopodiaceae.This revised version was published online in October 2005 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Correlations between photosynthetic enzymes,CO2-fixation and plastid structure in an albino mutant of Zea mays L.

Summary An albino seedling of Zea mays L. was investigated for its potential for CO₂-assimilation. In the mesophyll the number, dimensions and fine structure of chloroplasts are drastically reduced but to a lesser extent in the bundle sheath. Chlorophyll concentration is zero and carotenoid concentration almost zero. Albinism also exerts a strong influence on the stroma of bundle sheath chloroplasts; ribulose-1.5-biphosphate carboxylase (EC 4.1.1.39) activity and glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (NADP) (EC 1.2.1.13) activity is not detectable. The C₄-enzymes phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (EC 4.1.1.31) and malate dehydrogenase (decarboxylating) (EC 1.1.1.40) and the non-photosynthetic linked enzymes malate dehydrogenase (NAD) (EC 1.1.1.37), aspartate-2-oxoglutarate aminotransferase (EC 1.1.1.37), aspartate-2-oxoglutarate aminotransferase (EC 2.6.1.1.) and glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (NAD) (EC 1.2.1.1.) are present in the albino seedling with activities comparable to those in etiolated maize seedlings. The potential for CO₂ fixation of the albino seedlings exceeds that of comparable dark seedlings considerably. The results are discussed with regard to enzyme localization of the C₄ pathway of photosynthesis.Abbreviations Aspartate aminotransferase L-aspartate-2-oxoglutarate aminotransferase-EC 2.6.1.1. - GAPDH (NAD) glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (NAD dep.)-EC 1.2.1.12 - GAPDH (NADP) glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (NADP dep.)-EC 1.2.1.13 - malic enzyme malate dehydrogenase (NADP dep., decarboxylating)-EC 1.1.1.40 - MDH malate dehydrogenase (NAD dep.)-1.1.1.37 - PEP carboxylase phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase-EC 4.1.1.31 - RuDP carboxylase ribulose-1.5-biphosphate carboxylase-EC 4.1.1.39     

Influence of salt stress on C4 photosynthesis in Miscanthus sinensis Anderss.

• Miscanthus sinensis Anderss. is a good candidate for C₄ bioenergy crop development for marginal lands. As one of the characteristics of marginal lands, salinization is a major limitation to agricultural production. The present work aimed to investigate the possible factors involved in the tolerance of M. sinensis C₄ photosynthesis to salinity stress.
• Seedlings of two accessions (salt‐tolerant ‘JM0119’ and salt‐sensitive ‘JM0099’) were subjected to 0 mm NaCl (control) or 250 mm NaCl (salt stress treatment) for 2 weeks. The chlorophyll content, parameters of photosynthesis and chlorophyll a fluorescence, activity of C₄ enzymes and expression of C₄ genes were measured.
• The results showed that photosynthesis rate, transpiration rate, chlorophyll content, PSII operating efficiency, coefficient of photochemical quenching, activity of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC) and pyruvate, orthophosphate dikinase (PPDK) and gene expression of PEPC and PPDK under salinity were higher after long‐term salinity exposure in ‘JM0119’ than in ‘JM0099’, while activity of NADP‐malate dehydrogenase (NADP‐MDH) and NADP‐malic enzyme (NADP‐ME), together with expression of NADP‐MDH and NADP‐ME, were much higher in ‘JM0099’ than in ‘JM0119’.
• In conclusion, the increased photosynthetic capacity under long‐term salt stress in the salt‐tolerant relative to the salt‐sensitive M. sinensis accession was mainly associated with non‐stomatal factors, such as reduced chlorophyll loss, higher PSII operating efficiency, enhanced activity of PEPC and PPDK and relatively lower activity of NADP‐ME.