Toward elucidating the membrane topology of helix two of the colicin E1 channel domain

The membrane-bound closed state of the colicin E1 channel domain was investigated by site-directed fluorescence labeling using a bimane fluorophore attached to each single cysteine residue within helix 2 of each mutant protein. The fluorescence properties of the bimane fluorophore were measured for the membrane-associated form of the closed channel and included fluorescence emission maximum, fluorescence anisotropy, apparent polarity, surface accessibility, and membrane bilayer penetration depth. The fluorescence data show that helix 2 is an amphipathic alpha-helix that is situated parallel to the membrane surface, but it is less deeply embedded within the bilayer interfacial region than is helix 1 in the closed channel. A least squares fit of the various data sets to a harmonic wave function indicated that the periodicity and angular frequency for helix 2 in the membrane-bound state are typical for an amphipathic alpha-helix (3.8 +/- 0.1 residues per turn and 94 +/- 4 degrees, respectively) that is located at an interfacial region of a membrane bilayer. Dual quencher analysis also revealed that helix 2 is peripherally membrane associated, with one face of the helix dipping into the interfacial region of the lipid bilayer and the other face projecting outwardly into the aqueous solvent. Finally, our data show that helices 1 and 2 remain independent helices upon membrane association with a short connector link (Tyr(363)-Gly(364)) and that short amphipathic alpha-helices participate in the formation of a lipid-dependent, toroidal pore for this colicin.     

Dynamic properties of the colicin E1 ion channel

Abstract The mechanism of channel formation and action of channel-forming colicins is a paradigm for the study of dynamic aspects of membrane-protein interactions. The following experimental results concerning interaction of the colicin E1 channel domain with target membranes, in vitro and in vivo, are discussed: (1) the nature of the translocation-competent state of the channel-forming domain; (2) unfolding of the colicin channel peptide during in vitro binding and anchoring of the channel to liposome membranes at acidic pH; (3) reversal of channel peptide binding to liposomes by an alkaline-directed pH shift; (4) voltage-driven translocation and gating of the ion channel, discussed in the context of a four-helix model for a monomeric channel; (5) rescue of colicin-treated cells by high levels of external K⁺; (6) trypsin rescue of cells depolarized by the colicin ion channel; and (7) interaction of the channel domain with its immunity protein.     

Structure and dynamics of the colicin E1 channel

The toxin-like and bactericidal colicin E1 molecule is of interest for problems of toxin action, polypeptide translocation across membranes, voltage-gated channels, and receptor function. Colicin E1 binds to a receptor in the outer membrane and is translocated across the cell envelope to the inner membrane. Import of the colicin channel-forming domain into the inner membrane involves a translocation-competent intermediate state and a membrane potential-dependent movement of one third to one half of the channel peptide into the membrane bilayer. The voltage-gated channel has a conductance sufficiently large to depolarize the Escherichia coli cytoplasmic membrane. Amino acid residues that affect the channel ion selectivity have been identified by site-directed mutagenesis. The colicin E1 channel is one of a few membrane proteins whose secondary structures in the membrane, predominantly alpha-helix, have been determined by physico-chemical techniques. Hypothesis for the identity of the trans-membrane helices, and the mechanism of binding to the membrane, are influenced by the solved crystal structure of the soluble colicin A channel peptide. The protective action of immunity protein is a unique aspect of the colicin problem, and information has been obtained, by genetic techniques, about the probable membrane topography of the imm gene product.     

Scanning the membrane-bound conformation of helix 1 in the colicin E1 channel domain by site-directed fluorescence labeling

Helix 1 of the membrane-associated closed state of the colicin E1 channel domain was studied by site-directed fluorescence labeling where bimane was covalently attached to a single cysteine residue in each mutant protein. A number of fluorescence properties of the tethered bimane fluorophore were measured in the membrane-bound state of the channel domain, including fluorescence emission maximum, fluorescence quantum yield, fluorescence anisotropy, membrane bilayer penetration depth, surface accessibility, and apparent polarity. The data show that helix 1 is an amphipathic alpha-helix that is situated parallel to the membrane surface. A least squares fit of the various data sets to a harmonic function indicated that the periodicity and angular frequency for helix 1 are typical for an amphipathic alpha-helix (3.7 +/- 0.1 residues per turn and 97 +/- 3.0 degrees, respectively) that is partially bathing into the membrane bilayer. Dual fluorescence quencher analysis also revealed that helix 1 is peripherally membrane-associated, with one face of the helix dipping into the lipid bilayer and the other face projecting toward the solvent. Finally, our data suggest that the helical boundaries of helix 1, at least at the C-terminal region, remain unaffected upon binding to the surface of the membrane in support of a toroidal pore model for this colicin.     

Membrane binding of the colicin E1 channel: activity requires an electrostatic interaction of intermediate magnitude.

In vitro channel activity of the C-terminal colicin E1 channel polypeptide under conditions of variable electrostatic interaction with synthetic lipid membranes showed distinct maxima with respect to pH and membrane surface potential. The membrane binding energy was determined from fluorescence quenching of the intrinsic tryptophans of the channel polypeptide by liposomes containing N-trinitrophenyl-phosphatidylethanolamine. Maximum in vitro colicin channel activity correlated with an intermediate magnitude of the electrostatic interaction. For conditions associated with maximum activity (40% anionic lipid, I = 0.12 M, pH 4.0), the free energy of binding was delta G approximately -9 kcal/mol, with nonelectrostatic and electrostatic components, delta Gnel approximately -5 kcal/mol and delta Gel approximately -4 kcal/mol, and an effective binding charge of +7 at pH 4.0. Binding of the channel polypeptide to negative membranes at pH 8 is minimal, whereas initial binding at pH 4 followed by a shift to pH 8 causes only 3-10% reversal of binding, implying that it is kinetically trapped, probably by a hydrophobic interaction. It was inferred that membrane binding and insertion involves an initial electrostatic interaction responsible for concentration and binding to the membrane surface. This is followed by insertion into the bilayer driven by hydrophobic forces, which are countered in the case of excessive electrostatic binding.     

Determination of membrane protein topology by red-edge excitation shift analysis: application to the membrane-bound colicin E1 channel peptide

A new approach for the determination of the bilayer location of Trp residues in proteins has been applied to the study of the membrane topology of the channel-forming bacteriocin, colicin E1. This method, red-edge excitation shift (REES) analysis, was initially applied to the study of 12 single Trp-containing channel peptides of colicin E1 in the soluble state in aqueous medium. Notably, REES was observed for most of the channel peptides in aqueous solution upon low pH activation. The extent of REES was subsequently characterized using a model membrane system composed of the tripeptide, Lys-Trp-Lys, bound to dimyristoyl-sn-glycerol-3-phosphatidylserine liposomes. Subsequently, data accrued from the model peptide-lipid system was used to interpret information obtained on the channel peptides when bound to dioleoyl-sn-glycerol-3-phosphatidylcholine/dioleoyl-sn-glycerol-3-phosphatidylglycerol membrane vesicles. The single Trp mutant peptides were divided into three categories based on the change in the REES values observed for the Trp residues when the peptides were bound to liposomes as compared to the REES values measured for the soluble peptides. F-404W, F-413W, F-443W, F-484W, and W-495 peptides exhibited small and/or insignificant REES changes (ΔREES) whereas W-424, F-431W, and Y-507W channel peptides possessed modest REES changes (3 nm≤ΔREES≤7 nm). In contrast, wild-type, Y-367W, W-460, Y-478W, and I-499W channel peptides showed large ΔREES values upon membrane binding (7 nm<ΔREES≤12 nm). The REES data for the membrane-bound structure of the colicin E1 channel peptide proved consistent with previous data for the topology of the closed channel state, which lends further credence to the currently proposed channel model. In conclusion, the REES method provides another source of topological data for assignment of the bilayer location for Trp residues within membrane-associated proteins; however, it also requires careful interpretation of spectral data in combination with structural information on the proteins being investigated.     

Determination of membrane protein topology by red-edge excitation shift analysis: application to the membrane-bound colicin E1 channel peptide

A new approach for the determination of the bilayer location of Trp residues in proteins has been applied to the study of the membrane topology of the channel-forming bacteriocin, colicin E1. This method, red-edge excitation shift (REES) analysis, was initially applied to the study of 12 single Trp-containing channel peptides of colicin E1 in the soluble state in aqueous medium. Notably, REES was observed for most of the channel peptides in aqueous solution upon low pH activation. The extent of REES was subsequently characterized using a model membrane system composed of the tripeptide, Lys-Trp-Lys, bound to dimyristoyl-sn-glycerol-3-phosphatidylserine liposomes. Subsequently, data accrued from the model peptide-lipid system was used to interpret information obtained on the channel peptides when bound to dioleoyl-sn-glycerol-3-phosphatidylcholine/dioleoyl-sn-glycerol-3-phosphatidylglycerol membrane vesicles. The single Trp mutant peptides were divided into three categories based on the change in the REES values observed for the Trp residues when the peptides were bound to liposomes as compared to the REES values measured for the soluble peptides. F-404 W, F-413 W, F-443 W, F-484 W, and W-495 peptides exhibited small and/or insignificant REES changes (Delta REES) whereas W-424, F-431 W, and Y-507 W channel peptides possessed modest REES changes (3 nm< or = Delta REES< or = 7 nm). In contrast, wild-type, Y-367 W, W-460, Y-478 W, and I-499 W channel peptides showed large Delta REES values upon membrane binding (7 nm< Delta REES< or =12 nm). The REES data for the membrane-bound structure of the colicin E1 channel peptide proved consistent with previous data for the topology of the closed channel state, which lends further credence to the currently proposed channel model. In conclusion, the REES method provides another source of topological data for assignment of the bilayer location for Trp residues within membrane-associated proteins; however, it also requires careful interpretation of spectral data in combination with structural information on the proteins being investigated.     

Membrane topography of ColE1 gene products: the hydrophobic anchor of the colicin E1 channel is a helical hairpin.

The paucity of crystallographic data on the structure of intrinsic membrane proteins necessitates the development of additional techniques to probe their structures. The colicin E1 ion channel domain contains one prominent hydrophobic region near its COOH terminus that has been proposed to be an anchor for the assembly of the channel. Saturation site-directed mutagenesis of the hydrophobic anchor region of the colicin E1 ion channel was used to probe whether it spanned the bilayer once or twice. A nonpolar amino acid was replaced by a charged residue in 29 mutations made at 26 positions in the channel domain. Substitution of the charged amino acid at all positions except those in the center of the hydrophobic region and the periphery of the hydrophobic region caused a large decrease in the cytotoxicity of the purified mutant colicin E1 protein. This result implies that the hydrophobic domain spans the membrane bilayer twice in a helical hairpin loop, with the center of this domain residing in an aqueous or polar phase. The lengths of the trans-membrane helices appear to be approximately 18 and 16 residues. The absence of significant changes in ion selectivity in five of nine mutants indicated that these mutations did not cause a large change in the channel structure. The ion selectivity changes in four mutants and those previously documented for the flanking Lys residues imply that the hydrophobic hairpin is part of the channel lumen. Water may "abhor" the hydrophobic side of the channel, explaining the small effects of residue charge changes on ion selectivity.     

Unfolding pathway of the colicin E1 channel protein on a membrane surface

The channel-forming domain of colicin E1 is composed of a soluble helical bundle which, upon membrane binding, unfolds to form an extended, two-dimensional helical net in the membrane interfacial layer. To characterize the pathway of unfolding of the protein and the structure of the surface-bound intermediate, the time-course of intra-protein distance changes and unfolding on a millisecond time-scale were determined from the kinetics of changes in the efficiency of fluorescence resonance energy transfer, and of the donor-acceptor overlap integral, between each of six individual tryptophan residues and a Cys-conjugated energy transfer acceptor (C509-AEDANS). Comparison of the rate constants revealed the following order of events associated with unfolding of the protein at the membrane surface: (A) movement of the hydrophobic core helices VIII-IX, coincident with a small change in Trp-Cys509 distances of the outer helices; (B) unfolding of surface helices in the helical bundle in the order: helix I, helices III, IV, VI, VII, and helix V; (C) a slow (time-scale, seconds) condensation of the surface-bound helices. The rate of protein unfolding events increased with increasing anionic lipid content. Unfolding did not occur below the lipid thermal phase transition, indicating that unfolding requires mobility in the interfacial layer. The structure of the two-dimensional membrane-bound intermediate in the steady-state was inferred to consist of a quasi-circular arrangement of eight helices embedded in the membrane interfacial layer and anchored by the hydrophobic helical hairpin. The pathway of unfolding of the colicin channel at the membrane surface, catalyzed by electrostatic and hydrophobic forces, is the first described for a membrane-active protein. It is proposed that the pathway and principles described for the colicin protein are relevant to membrane protein import.     

Identification of a voltage-responsive segment of the potential-gated colicin E1 ion channel.

The voltage dependence of channel activity of the bactericidal protein colicin E1 was found to be correlated with insertion into the membrane bilayer of a specific segment of the 178-residue COOH-terminal thermolytic colicin channel peptide. The insertion into the bilayer was detected by an increase in labeling by one of two different lipophilic photoaffinity probes or by a decrease in iodination of peptide tyrosines from the external solution. Imposition of a potassium diffusion potential of -100 mV resulted in an increase of 35-60% in the labeling of the peptide by the lipophilic probe in the bilayer and a concomitant decrease in labeling of Tyr residues in the peptide by the iodination reagent in the external solution. The change in labeling decreased upon dissipation of the membrane potential with a half-time of about 1 min. The labeling change was localized to a 36-residue peptide segment bounded by alanine-425 and by tryptophan-460. This segment containing seven positively charged residues at low pH is a voltage-sensitive region that inserts into the membrane bilayer when the channel is turned on by the potential and is extruded from it when the voltage is removed and the channel is turned off.     

Lipid dependence of the channel properties of a colicin E1-lipid toroidal pore

Colicin E1 belongs to a group of bacteriocins whose cytotoxicity toward Escherichia coli is exerted through formation of ion channels that depolarize the cytoplasmic membrane. The lipid dependence of colicin single-channel conductance demonstrated intimate involvement of lipid in the structure of this channel. The colicin formed "small" conductance 60-picosiemens (pS) channels, with properties similar to those previously characterized, in 1,2-dieicosenoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (C20) or thinner membranes, whereas it formed a novel "large" conductance 600-pS state in thicker 1,2-dierucoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (C22) bilayers. Both channel states were anion-selective and voltage-gated and displayed a requirement for acidic pH. Lipids having negative spontaneous curvature inhibited the formation of both channels but increased the ratio of open 600 pS to 60 pS conductance states. Different diameters of small and large channels, 12 and 16 A, were determined from the dependence of single-channel conductance on the size of nonelectrolyte solute probes. Colicin-induced lipid "flip-flop" and the decrease in anion selectivity of the channel in the presence of negatively charged lipids implied a significant contribution of lipid to the structure of the channel, most readily described as toroidal organization of lipid and protein to form the channel pore.     

Mechanism of export of colicin E1 and colicin E3.

The mechanism of export of colicins E1 and E3 was examined. Neither colicin E1, colicin E3, Nor colicin E3 immunity protein appears to be synthesized as a precursor protein with an amino-terminal extension. Instead, the colicins, as well as the colicin E3 immunity protein, appear to leave the cells where they are made, long after their synthesis, by a nonspecific mechanism which results in increased permeability of the producing cells. Induction of ColE3-containing cells with mitomycin C leads to actual lysis of those cells, as some time after synthesis of the colicin E3 and its immunity protein has been completed. Induction of ColE1-containing cells results in increased permeability of the cells, but not in actual lysis, and most of the colicin E1 produced never leaves the producing cells. Intracellular proteins such as elongation factor G can be found outside of colicinogenic cells after mitomycin C induction, along with the colicin. Until substantial increases in permeability occur, most of the colicin remains cell associated, in the soluble cytosol, rather than in a membrane-associated form.     

Tilted, extended, and lying in wait: the membrane-bound topology of residues Lys-381-Ser-405 of the colicin E1 channel domain

The membrane-bound closed state (zero potential) of the helix 3 segment (Lys-381-Ser-405) of the colicin E1 channel domain was investigated by site-directed fluorescence labeling using a bimane probe tethered to a single cysteine residue of each mutant protein. A number of fluorescence properties of the tethered bimane probe were measured for the soluble channel mutant proteins as well as for the membrane-bound proteins. A new method called helical periodicity surface analysis was employed to fit the fluorescence data to a harmonic wave function using four different statistical methods. The fit of the various data sets to a harmonic wave function indicated that the periodicity of helix 3 in the membrane-bound state is typical for an amphipathic alpha helix (3.7-4.0 residues per turn and an angular frequency between 90 and 97 degrees). Notably, upon membrane binding, helix 3 elongates from 15 residues (soluble structure) to 20 residues by a three- and two-residue extension at the N- and C-termini of the helix, respectively. Dual quencher analysis also revealed that helix 3 is appressed to the surface of the membrane with its N-terminus more deeply buried within the interfacial region of the bilayer than its C-terminus. Finally, contrary to a previous report, our data show that helices 3 and 4 remain separate and independent helices upon membrane association in the absence of a membrane potential.     

Voltage-dependent,monomeric channel activity of colicin E1 in artificial membrane vesicles

Summary The dependence of colicin channel activity on membrane potential and peptide concentration was studied in large unilamellar vesicles using colicin E1, its COOH-terminal thermolytic peptide and other channel-forming colicins. Channel activity was assayed by release of vesicle-entrapped chloride, and could be detected at a peptide: lipid molar ratio as low as 10^–7. The channel activity was dependent on the magnitude of atrans-negative potassium diffusion potential, with larger potentials yielding faster rates of solute efflux. For membrane potentials greater than –60mV (K _in ⁺ /K _out ⁺ 10), addition of valinomycin resulted in a 10-fold increase in the rate of Cl^– efflux. A delay in Cl^– efflux observed when the peptide was added to vesicles in the presence of a membrane potential implied a potential-independent binding-insertion mechanism. The initial rate of Cl^– efflux was about 1% of the single-channel conductance, implying that only a small fraction of channels were initially open, due to the delay or latency of channel formation known to occur in planar bilayers.The amount of Cl^– released as a function of added peptide increased monotonically to a concentration of 0.7 ng peptide/ml, corresponding to release of 75% of the entrapped chloride. It was estimated from this high activity and consideration of vesicle number that 50–100% of the peptide molecules were active. The dependence of the initial rate of Cl^– efflux on peptide concentration was linear to approximately the same concentration, implying that the active channel consists of a monomeric unit.     

Adventures in membrane protein topology. A study of the membrane-bound state of colicin E1.

The molecular aggregate size of the closed state of the colicin E1 channel was determined by fluorescence resonance energy transfer experiments involving a fluorescence donor (three tryptophans, wild-type protein) and a fluorescence acceptor (5-(((acetyl)amino)ethyl)aminonaphthalene-1-sulfonic acid (AEDANS), Trp-deficient protein). There was no evidence of energy transfer between the donor and acceptor species when bound to membrane large unilamellar vesicles. These experiments led to the conclusion that the colicin E1 channel is monomeric in the membrane-bound closed channel state. Experiments were also conducted to study the membrane topology of the closed colicin channel in membrane large unilamellar vesicles using acrylamide as the membrane-impermeant, nonionic quencher of tryptophan fluorescence in a battery of single tryptophan mutant proteins. Furthermore, additional fluorescence parameters, including fluorescence emission maximum, fluorescence quantum yield, and fluorescence decay times, were used to assist in mapping the topology of the closed channel. Results suggest that the closed channel comprises most of the polypeptide of the channel domain and that the hydrophobic anchor domain does not transverse the membrane bilayer but nonetheless is deeply embedded within the hydrocarbon core of the membrane. Finally, a model is proposed which features at least two states that are in rapid equilibrium with each other and in which one state is more heavily populated than the other.     

Alteration of the pH-dependent ion selectivity of the colicin E1 channel by site-directed mutagenesis.

Colicin E1 is a soluble, bacteriocidal protein that forms voltage-gated channels in planar lipid bilayers. The channel-forming region of the 522-amino acid protein is near the COOH terminus, and contains a 35-amino acid hydrophobic segment which is presumed to be important in interacting with the membrane. We have used site-directed mutagenesis in the region immediately upstream from the hydrophobic segment to construct several functional colicin mutants in which a wild-type residue was replaced with a cysteine. We also replaced the only naturally occurring cysteine in the molecule, Cys-505, with alanine, so that synthetically introduced cysteines could unambiguously serve as targets for chemical modification. All of the replacements reported here (at positions 449, 459, 473, 505, and some combinations) resulted in a channel that had an ion selectivity (K+ versus Cl-) identical to wild type at low pH. At higher pH, however, one of these mutations, which replaced the negatively charged aspartate at position 473 (the upstream boundary of the hydrophobic segment), resulted in a channel that was less cation-selective than was wild type. When the introduced Cys-473 was reacted with iodoacetic acid, which inserted a COOH group close to the position of the missing aspartate COOH, wild-type ion selectivity was restored, suggesting that the greater cation selectivity of the wild-type channel was directly produced by the negative charge at Asp-473. By comparing the ion selectivity of the Cys-473 mutant channel to that of the wild type as a function of the pH on the cis and trans sides of the membrane, it was possible to locate residue 473 close to the cis side. Locating in this manner the positions in the channel of particular residues places important constraints on channel model building.     

Effect of base substitutions in the colicin E1 gene on colicin E1 export and bacteriocin activity

Summary Base substitutions have been introduced into the segment of the colicin E1 gene corresponding to the polypeptide region between the 404th and the 502nd residues which was considered to participate in colicin E1 export and bacteriocin activity. The methods used were in vitro localized mutagenesis with sodium bisulphite and in vivo mutagenesis using either nitrosoguanidine or ethyl methane sulphonate. Cells carrying mutagenized plasmids were screened by their inability to form a clear zone on a lawn of colicin E1 sensitive cells. Mutation sites were determined from the nucleotide sequence analysis and the altered amino acid residues were reduced. The mutant proteins were analysed for their ability to be exported to the periplasmic space and for their bacteriocin activity. Out of eight mutants obtained, three had a single amino acid replacement. Mutant proteins that had Ser and Glu in place of Pro-462 and Gly-502, respectively, showed a decrease in both the export and the bacteriocin activity. A mutant protein having Arg in place of Gly-439 showed a decrease only in the bacteriocin activity. These results suggest that the target region of colicin E1 contributes to the export as well as the bacteriocin activity but the two functions are supported in part by different amino acid residues of the protein.     

Site-directed mutagenesis of the charged residues near the carboxy terminus of the colicin E1 ion channel

Colicin E1 was altered by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis at the site of three charged residues on the COOH side of the 35-residue hydrophobic segment in the channel-forming domain. Asp-509 is one of five conserved acidic residues in the channel domain of colicins A, B, E1, Ia, and Ib and is the first charged residue following the hydrophobic segment, followed by the basic residues Lys-510 and Lys-512. Asp-509 and Lys-512 were changed to amber and ochre stop codons, respectively, while Lys-510 was mutated to a Met codon. Proteins truncated after residue 508 or 511, and missing the last 14 or 11 residues, were obtained from a nonsuppressing cell strain harboring the mutant plasmid while full-length colicin molecules with single residue changes at Asp-509 to Leu, Ser, and Gln, and Lys-512 to Tyr, were obtained by using appropriate suppressor strains. The truncated colicins displayed (i) a low cytotoxicity, approximately 1% of intact wild-type colicin, (ii) 10-fold less in vitro channel activity with liposomes, and (iii) reduced labeling of the colicin in liposomes by a phospholipid photoaffinity probe, showing that one or more of the residues following Asn-511 is necessary for both in vivo and in vitro activity and insertion into the bilayer. (iv) The truncated mutants also displayed an altered conformation at pH 6 that allowed greater binding and activity with liposomes at this pH relative to wild type. The cytotoxicity of single residue substitutions at Asp-509 showed a range of cytotoxicities, wild type greater than Ser-509 greater than Gln-509 greater than Leu-509, although none of these changes greatly affected the in vitro channel activity or pH dependence.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)