Direct repeats as selective response elements for the thyroid hormone, retinoic acid, and vitamin D3 receptors.

We report here the identification of thyroid hormone response elements (TREs) that consist of a direct repeat, not a palindrome, of the half-sites. Unlike palindromic TREs, direct repeat TREs do not confer a retinoic acid response. The tandem TRE can be converted into a retinoic acid response element by increasing the spacing between the half-sites by 1 nucleotide, and the resulting retinoic acid response element is no longer a TRE. Decreasing the half-site spacing by 1 nucleotide converts the TRE to a vitamin D3 response element, while eliminating response to T3. These results correlate well with DNA-binding affinities of the thyroid hormone, retinoic acid, and vitamin D3 receptors. This study points to the general importance of tandem repeat hormone response elements and suggests a simple physiologic code exists in which half-site spacing plays a critical role in achieving selective hormonal response.     

A nuclear factor that enhances binding of thyroid hormone receptors to thyroid hormone response elements

Recent studies from this laboratory have demonstrated the presence of thyroid hormone response elements (TREs) in the 5'-flanking region of the rat alpha and TSH beta subunit genes. Using an avidin-biotin complex DNA binding assay, we have shown that these TREs bind the thyroid hormone (T3) receptor present in nuclear extracts of GH3 cells, as well as the in vitro synthesized Hc-erbA beta, which has been identified as a member of the family of T3 receptors. The binding of Hc-erbA beta to the alpha subunit TRE can be enhanced 3-4-fold by including GH3 nuclear extract in the binding assay. Binding to the TRE present in the TSH beta gene or the rat growth hormone gene was similarly enhanced, although to a lesser degree. The enhanced binding activity is trypsin-sensitive and heat labile, and is not reproduced by the addition of histones, bovine serum albumin, or cytosol instead of nuclear extract. Gel exclusion chromatography suggests a molecular size of approximately 65,000 Da. This protein, which is present in several different cell types, is also able to complement binding of the rat erbA alpha-1 and the pituitary-specific erbA beta-2 forms of the receptor. These data suggest that the binding of the T3 receptor to a TRE is augmented by another nuclear protein, which may be involved in the mechanism of action of thyroid hormone.     

Half-site spacing and orientation determines whether thyroid hormone and retinoic acid receptors and related factors bind to DNA response elements as monomers, homodimers, or heterodimers.

The receptors for thyroid hormone (T3R) and retinoic acid (RAR) are members of a nuclear receptor subfamily that are capable of recognizing similar DNA sequences. Native response elements for T3R and RAR consist of two or more putative half-site binding motifs organized as imperfect direct or inverted repeats separated by different sized nucleotide gaps. To clarify how T3R, RAR, and related factors recognize DNA response elements, we analyzed the interaction of purified receptors with a series of inverted and direct repeats of an idealized AGGTCA half-site separated by different sized nucleotide gaps. Our results indicate that RAR and T3R can bind to half-sites as monomers and, depending on the orientation and distance between half-sites, also bind as homodimers or T3R-RAR heterodimers. T3R also binds to certain DNA elements as a heterodimer with one or more nuclear factors from eucaryotic cells. Thus, the orientation and spacing of half-sites play a central role in determining which configuration of receptors and nuclear factors will interact with a specific DNA element. This along with the ability of these factors to participate in reversible protein-protein interactions serve to broaden and diversify the responses mediated by T3R, RAR, and related members of this nuclear receptor subfamily.     

Differential capacity of wild type promoter elements for binding and trans-activation by retinoic acid and thyroid hormone receptors.

Retinoic acid receptor (RAR) and thyroid hormone receptor (T3R) are structurally similar and can bind as homodimers or T3R-RAR heterodimers to a single synthetic DNA response element. The interaction of these two types of receptors with wild type elements, however, has not been systematically investigated. Promoter elements from genes regulated by retinoic acid (RA) or thyroid hormone (T3) were tested for response to T3 and RA in transient transfections in both JEG and COS cells. The elements were classified as primarily responsive to RA or to T3 or responsive to both ligands. Binding of highly purified RAR alpha and T3R alpha to the various elements was assessed using the gel shift assay. Those elements predominantly responsive to one ligand showed preferential binding to the appropriate receptor. A series of point mutations were introduced into the rat GH T3 response element to further define sequence requirements for response to both RA and T3. Down-mutations in any of the three hexamers (previously demonstrated to be required for full response to T3 and full binding of T3R) also decreased RA induction and RAR binding. However, only one of two sets of up-mutations for T3 response also increased RA induction, demonstrating differences in hexamer preference between RAR and T3R. Variation in spacing of the three hexamers did not influence RA vs. T3 induction or RAR vs. T3R binding according to the predictions of a simple hexamer spacing model. There was a strong correlation between the extent of T3R dimer binding and strength of T3 induction for a subset of elements studied in JEG cells (r = 0.97, P < 0.01) and a weaker but significant correlation in COS cells (r = 0.65, P < 0.05)). In contrast, RAR dimer binding by the wild type elements did not quantitatively correlate with RA induction in either JEG (r = 0.13, P > 0.05) or COS cells (r = 0.21, P > 0.05). These results suggests that RAR interacts with a heterodimer partner(s) which influences binding site specificity, whereas T3R heterodimer partner(s) is less likely to alter binding site recognition. The observed difference in COS and JEG cells as well as the weak T3R binding-function relationship of the malic enzyme element, however, suggest that the influence of T3R heterodimer partner(s) on binding site specificity is likely to vary with cell type and the specific element tested.     

Novel mode of deoxyribonucleic acid recognition by thyroid hormone receptors: thyroid hormone receptor beta-isoforms can bind as trimers to natural response elements comprised of reiterated half-sites

Thyroid hormone receptors (TRs) regulate gene expression by binding to specific DNA sequences, denoted thyroid hormone response elements (TREs). The accepted paradigm for TRs proposes that they bind as homo- or heterodimers to TREs comprised of two AGGTCA half-site sequences. In the prototypic TRE, these half-sites are arranged as direct repeats separated by a four-base spacer. This dimeric model of TR binding, derived from analysis of artificial DNA sequences, fails to explain why many natural TREs contain more than two half-sites. Therefore, we investigated the ability of different TR isoforms to bind to TREs possessing three or more half-sites. We report that the TRbeta isoforms (TRbeta0, TRbeta1, TRbeta2), but not TRalpha1, can bind to reiterated DNA elements, such as the rat GH-TRE, as complexes trimeric or greater in size. The TRbeta0 isoform, in particular, formed homo- and heterotrimers (with the retinoid X receptor) with high efficiency and cooperativity, and TRbeta0 preferentially used reporters containing these reiterated elements to drive gene expression in vivo. Our data demonstrate that TRbeta isoforms can form multimeric receptor complexes on appropriately reiterated DNA response elements, providing a functional distinction between the TR isoforms and an explanation for TREs possessing three or more half-sites.