Heat shock and ceramide have different apoptotic pathways in radiation induced fibrosarcoma (RIF) cells

Heat shock induces various cellular responses including inhibition of protein synthesis, production of heat shock proteins (HSPs) and induction of thermotolerance. The molecular mechanisms of the processes have not been well understood. It has been proposed that ceramide formation during heat shock mediates heat shock induced apoptosis. We examined whether C2-ceramide mimicked the cellular response to heat shock in RIF-1 cells and their thermotolerant derivative TR-RIF-1 cells. Discernible effects between heat shock and C2-ceramide treatments were observed in cellular changes such as total protein synthesis, HSP synthesis, stress-activated protein kinase/c-Jun N-terminal kinase (SAPK/JNK) activity and PARP cleavage. Heat shock immediately inhibited cellular protein synthesis, which was recovered by synthesizing HSPs first and then whole proteins later. Heat shock also activated SAPK/JNK and increased PARP cleavage in dose-dependent manner. Thermotolerant TR-RIF-1 cells responded to heat shock more insensitively than RIF-1 cells. On the other hand, C2-ceramide treatment did not accompany any changes induced by heat shock. No discernible differences between RIF-1 and TR-RIF-1 cells were observed by C2-ceramide treatment. We tried to figure out how C2-ceramide interacts with cellular membrane and found that exogenous C2-ceramide was incorporated into the outer monolayer and flipped into the inner monolayer of human erythrocytes in ATP-dependent manner. However, the rate of C2-ceramide incorporation was similar in control and thermotolerant cells. In summary, thermotolerant cells are resistant to heat shock induced apoptotic signaling but not resistant, rather sensitive to membrane disturbing C2-ceramide mediated apoptosis. These results suggest that heat shock and ceramide have different signal transduction pathways.     

Cyclic AMP and the heat shock response in Chinese hamster ovary cells

Heat shock leads to transient increases in cAMP levels in HA-1-CHO cells. Such pulses are correlated temporally with the induction of heat resistance (thermotolerance) and with heat shock protein synthesis. Although the kinetics of cAMP increase after heating suggest a role in thermotolerance induction, raising cAMP levels directly using dBcAMP did not produce full thermotolerance. The resistance induced by dBcAMP may thus be either a component of or different to heat-shock triggered resistance. Cells which had been made thermotolerant by heat shock did not produce a pulse in cAMP level on heating. The cAMP producing system thus seemed desensitized to heat in thermotolerant cells.     

The thermoresistant state: protection from initial damage or better repair?

The induction of and recovery from heat-induced perturbations in several cellular parameters were examined in normal, transiently thermotolerant, and permanently heat-resistant HA-1 Chinese hamster fibroblasts. The initial heat-induced perturbations in total cellular protein synthesis, RNA synthesis, vimentin-containing intermediate filaments, and nuclear protein mass were similar in the three different cell types which display various levels of thermal resistance as determined by clonogenic survival. The posthyperthermia recovery from the heat-induced perturbations in all of the cellular parameters was more rapid in both the permanently heat-resistant cells and in the transiently thermotolerant cells. This response was observed in cells in which transient thermotolerance was induced by either a mild heat shock or exposure to sodium arsenite. The development and decay of the capacity for more rapid recovery from the initial heat-induced perturbations in total cellular protein and RNA synthesis paralleled the development and decay of clonogenic thermotolerance. Overall, these results support the notion that more rapid recovery from similar levels of heat-induced perturbations in various cellular parameters are a salient feature of both the transiently and permanently heat-resistant state.     

Effect of heat shock on the intracellular distribution of proteins

Exposure of cells to heat induces thermotolerance, a transient resistance to subsequent heat challenges. It has been shown that thermotolerance is correlated in time with the enhanced synthesis of heat shock proteins. In this study, the association of induced heat shock proteins with various cellular fractions was investigated and the heat-induced changes in skeletal protein composition in thermotolerant and control cells was compared. All three major heat shock proteins induced in Chinese hamster fibroblasts after a 46 degrees C, 4-min heat treatment (70, 87, and 110 kDa) were purified with the cytoplasmic fraction, whereas only the 70-kDa protein was also found in other cell fractions, including that containing the cellular skeleton. Immediately after a second heat treatment at 45 degrees C for 45 min, the 110-kDa protein from thermotolerant cells also purified extensively with the cellular skeletal fraction. In this regard, the 110-kDa protein behaved similarly to many other cellular proteins, since we observed an overall temperature-dependent increase in the total labeled protein content of the high-salt-resistant cellular skeletal fraction after heat shock. Pulse-chase studies demonstrated that this increased protein content gradually returned to normal levels after a 3-hr incubation at 37 degrees C. The alteration or recovery kinetics of the total labeled protein content of the cellular skeletal fraction after heat shock did not correlate with the dramatic increase in survival observed in thermotolerant cells. The relationship between heat shock proteins and thermotolerance, therefore, does not correlate directly with changes in the heat-induced cellular alterations leading to differences in protein fractionation.     

Dephosphorylation of S6 and expression of the heat shock response in Drosophila melanogaster.

A basic ribosomal phosphoprotein of 30,000 molecular weight was rapidly dephosphorylated in cultured Drosophila melanogaster cells heat shocked at 37 degrees C. The protein was associated with the 40S ribosomal subunit and had an electrophoretic mobility similar to that of purified rat liver protein S6 on basic two-dimensional polyacrylamide gels as well as a similar partial proteolysis peptide map. In logarithmically growing cultures, this D. melanogaster S6 protein appeared to have a single phosphorylated species consisting of 30 to 40% of the total cellular S6. Thus, the nearly complete dephosphorylation of this protein observed in heat shock involves a large fraction of the cellular S6. The significance of this dephosphorylation in the expression of the heat shock response was investigated by examining the phosphorylation status of S6 in recovery from heat shock and in response to chemical inducers of the heat shock response. During recovery from a 30-min heat shock, the recovery of normal protein synthesis was almost complete in 2 to 4 hr, whereas there was no significant rephosphorylation of S6 for 8 h. Two chemical inducers of the heat shock response, canavanine and sodium arsenite, induced the synthesis of heat shock proteins in D. melanogaster cells. Sodium arsenite also caused an inhibition of normal protein synthesis similar to that observed in heat shock. Neither agent, however, caused significant dephosphorylation of S6. These results suggest that the dephosphorylation of S6, although invariably observed in heat-shocked cells, may in some cases be dissociated from both the induction of heat shock protein synthesis and the turnoff of normal protein synthesis which occur in a heat shock response.     

Involvement of rRNA synthesis in the enhanced survival and recovery of protein synthesis seen in thermotolerance

Although acquired thermotolerance has been linked to the induction of heat shock proteins, the molecular mechanism(s) by which cells become resistant to heat is unknown. The present study shows a strong correlation between the survival of cells following heat shock and the rate of recovery of protein, total RNA, and rRNA synthesis. Increasing exposure of CHO cells to 45 degrees C was found to decrease survival and cause a lengthening delay in these synthetic processes. The same reciprocal correlation was seen in thermotolerant cells. As thermotolerance develops, more cells survive a heat challenge and the delay in synthesis decreases. These data argue that enhanced recovery of protein and RNA synthesis is one factor which plays a key role in thermotolerance. The involvement of rRNA synthesis was further investigated by using actinomycin D at 0.1 microgram m1(-1), a concentration at which rRNA synthesis is selectively inhibited. When the drug was present during the recovery from a challenge heat treatment, the survival of thermotolerant cells was approximately 3-fold lower than expected from the mild toxicity of the drug. As this could not be accounted for by an interaction of the drug with the response of cells to single heat treatments, it is concluded that the drug inhibits the expression of thermotolerance in cells which would otherwise express a full degree of thermotolerance. The time and concentration dependence of this effect indicates that the drug acts though inhibition of rRNA synthesis. Therefore, enhanced recovery of RNA synthesis, presumably rRNA synthesis, is identified as one of the mechanisms responsible for enhanced survival of thermotolerant cells following heat shock.     

Increased thermostability of thermotolerant CHL V79 cells as determined by differential scanning calorimetry

Heat shock denatures cellular protein and induces both a state of acquired thermotolerance, defined as resistance to a subsequent heat shock, and the synthesis of a category of proteins referred to as heat-shock proteins (HSPs). Thermotolerance may be due to the stabilization of thermolabile proteins that would ordinarily denature during heat shock, either by HSPs or some other factors. We show by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) that mild heat shock irreversibly denatures a small fraction of Chinese hamster lung V79-WNRE cell protein (i.e., the enthalpy change, which is proportional to denaturation, on scanning to 45 degrees C at 1 degree C/min is approximately 2.3% of the total calorimetric enthalpy). Thermostability, defined by the extent of denaturation during heat shock and determined from DSC scans of whole cells, increases as the V79 cells become thermotolerant. Cellular stabilization appears to be due to an increase in the denaturation temperature of the most thermolabile proteins; there is no increase in the denaturation temperatures of the most thermally resistant proteins, i.e., those denaturing above 65 degrees C. Cellular stabilization is also observed in the presence of glycerol, which is known to increase resistance to heat shock and to stabilize proteins in vitro. A model is presented, based on a direct relationship between the extent of hyperthermic killing and the denaturation or inactivation of a critical target that defines the rate-limiting step in killing, which predicts a transition temperature (Tm) of the critical target for control V79-WNRE cells of 46.0 degrees C and a Tm of 47.3 degrees C for thermotolerant cells. This shift of 1.3 degrees C is consistent with the degree of stabilization detected by DSC.     

The effect of amino acid analogues and heat shock on gene expression in chicken embryo fibroblasts

The addition of certain amino acid analogues (canavanine, hydroxynorvaline, o-methylthreonine) or a mild heat shock at 45 degrees C caused chicken embryo fibroblasts to increase rapidly the synthesis of three proteins (molecular weights 22,000, 76,000 and 95,000 daltons) to levels which dominate the cells biosynthetic capacity and exceed the level of synthesis of the major cell structural proteins. Actinomycin D blocked the increased synthesis of p22, p76 and p95 in both analogue and heat shock-treated cells, while cycloheximide addition during the "induction" period blocked formation of these proteins only in analoguetreated cells. The elevated levels of synthesis for this set of proteins began to decrease shortly after restoration of the normal amino acid or normal temperature, and the normal pattern of cell protein synthesis was found 8 hr later. Induction of a similar set of proteins was detected in mouse L cells and baby hamster kidney cells after treatment with amino acid analogues or heat shock. Several laboratories have reported synthesis of proteins with similar molecular weights in cells subjected to conditions that alter glucose metabolism, and we speculate that these proteins may be associated with a hexose transport system.     

Adaptive cellular response to hyperthermia: 31P-NMR studies

Dynamic intracellular ATP and Pi levels were measured non-invasively for Chinese hamster V79 cells by 31P-NMR under conditions of thermotolerance and heat-shock protein induction. High densities of cells were embedded in agarose strands, placed within a standard NMR sample tube, and perfused with medium maintained either at 37 or 43 degrees C at pH 7.35. Cell survival and heat-shock protein synthesis were assessed either from parallel monolayer cultures or cells dislodged from the agarose strands post-treatment. Thermotolerance (heat resistance) and heat-shock protein synthesis was induced by a 1 h exposure to 43 degrees C followed by incubation for 5 h at 37 degrees C. After the 5 h incubation at 37 degrees C, marked thermal resistance was observed in regard to survival with concomitant synthesis of two major heat-shock proteins at 70 and 103 kDa. Studies were also conducted where tolerance and heat-shock protein synthesis were partially inhibited by depletion of cellular glutathione (GSH) prior to and during heat treatment. Dynamic measurement of intracellular ATP of cells heated with or without GSH depletion revealed no change in steady-state levels immediately after heating or during the 5 h post-heating incubation at 37 degrees C where thermotolerance and heat-shock proteins develop. These data are consistent with other reported data for mammalian cells and indicate that the steady-state ATP levels in mammalian cells remain unchanged during and after the acquisition of the thermotolerant state.     

Heat shock protein synthesis and thermotolerance in Salmonella typhimurium

The resistance of stationary phase Salmonella typhimurium to heating at 55°C was greater in cells grown in nutritionally rich than in minimal media, but in all media tested resistance was enhanced by exposing cells to a primary heat shock at 48°C. Chloramphenicol reduced the acquisition of thermotolerance in all media but did not completely prevent it in any.
The onset of thermotolerance was accompanied by increased synthesis of major heat shock proteins of molecular weight about 83, 72, 64 and 25 kDa. When cells were shifted from 48°C to 37°C, however, thermotolerance was rapidly lost with no corresponding decrease in the levels of these proteins. There is thus no direct relationship between thermotolerance and the cellular content of the major heat shock proteins. One minor protein of molecular weight about 34 kDa disappeared rapidly following a temperature down-shift. Its presence in the cell was thus correlated with the thermotolerant state.     

T lymphocyte stress response. II. Protection of translation and DNA replication against some forms of stress by prior hyperthermic stress

We have compared the effects of a mild heat shock and febrile temperatures on heat-shock protein (hsp) synthesis and development of stress tolerance in T lymphocytes. Our previous studies demonstrated that febrile temperatures (less than or equal to 41 degrees C) induced the synthesis of hsp110, hsp90, and the constitutive or cognate form of hsp70 (hscp70; a weak induction of the strongly stress-induced hsp70 was also observed. In the studies reported herein, we demonstrate that a mild heat shock (42.5 degrees C) reverses this ratio; that is, hsp70 and not hscp70 is the predominate member of this family synthesized at this temperature. Modest heat shock also enhanced the synthesis of hsp110 and hsp90. In order to assess the relationship between hsp synthesis and the acquisition of thermotolerance, purified T cells were first incubated at 42.5 degrees C (induction temperature) and then subsequently subjected to a severe heat-shock challenge (45 degrees C, 30 min). T cells first incubated at a mild heat-shock temperature were capable of total protein synthesis at a more rapid rate following a severe heat shock than control cells (induction temperature 37 degrees C). This phenomenon, which has been previously termed translational tolerance, did not develop in cells incubated at the febrile temperature (induction temperature 41 degrees C). Protection of translation also extended to immunologically relevant proteins such as interleukin-2 and the interleukin-2 receptor. Because clonal expansion is a critical event during an immune response, the effects of hyperthermic stress on DNA replication (mitogen-induced T cell proliferation) was also evaluated in thermotolerant T cells. DNA synthesis in control cells (induction temperature 37 degrees C) was severely inhibited following heat-shock challenge at 44 degrees C or 45 degrees C; in contrast, T cells preincubated at 42.5 degrees C rapidly recovered their DNA synthetic capacity. T cells preincubated at a febrile temperature were moderately protected against hyperthermic stress. The acquisition of thermotolerance was also associated with enhanced resistance to chemical (ethanol)-induced stress but not to heavy metal toxicity (cadmium) or dexamethasone-induced immunosuppression. These studies suggest that prior hsp synthesis may protect immune function against some forms of stress (e.g., febrile episode) but would be ineffective against others such as elevated glucocorticoid levels which normally occur during an immune response.     

Heat shock protein synthesis and thermotolerance in Salmonella typhimurium

The resistance of stationary phase Salmonella typhimurium to heating at 55 degrees C was greater in cells grown in nutritionally rich than in minimal media, but in all media tested resistance was enhanced by exposing cells to a primary heat shock at 48 degrees C. Chloramphenicol reduced the acquisition of thermotolerance in all media but did not completely prevent it in any. The onset of thermotolerance was accompanied by increased synthesis of major heat shock proteins of molecular weight about 83, 72, 64 and 25 kDa. When cells were shifted from 48 degrees C to 37 degrees C, however, thermotolerance was rapidly lost with no corresponding decrease in the levels of these proteins. There is thus no direct relationship between thermotolerance and the cellular content of the major heat shock proteins. One minor protein of molecular weight about 34 kDa disappeared rapidly following a temperature down-shift. Its presence in the cell was thus correlated with the thermotolerant state.     

Comparative studies on the heat-induced thermotolerance of protein synthesis and cell division in synchronized mouse neuroblastoma cells

Mouse neuroblastoma (N2A) cells react to a heat treatment by inhibition of DNA and protein synthesis and induction of cell cycle progression delay. Mitotic delay of heat-treated G1 cells correlates with reduction of protein synthesis and is due to an extensive delay of entrance into S phase, while the G2 phase of these cells is shortened. Mitotic delay of heat-treated G2 cells is more than in G1 cells and no correlation with protein synthesis reduction is found. In heat-treated G1 phase cells, both protein synthesis and cell cycle progression become thermotolerant to a second incubation at increased temperature. Moreover, the process of DNA synthesis becomes thermotolerant. In contrast, when heat-treated G1 phase cells have progressed into G2 phase and are then incubated at increased temperature, this G2 phase delay is not diminished. Apparently, additional targets for hyperthermia are present in late S and G2 phase cells.     

Induction of acquired thermotolerance in Tetrahymena thermophila: effects of protein synthesis inhibitors.

When Tetrahymena thermophila cells growing at 30 degrees C are shifted to either 40 or 43 degrees C, the kinetics and extent of induction of heat shock mRNAs in both cases are virtually indistinguishable. However, the cells shifted to 40 degrees C show a typical induction of heat shock protein (HSP) synthesis and survive indefinitely (100% after 24 h), whereas those at 43 degrees C show an abortive synthesis of HSPs and die (less than 0.01% survivors) within 1 h. Cells treated at 30 degrees C with the drugs cycloheximide or emetine, at concentrations which are initially inhibitory to protein synthesis and cell growth but from which cells can eventually recover and resume growth, are after this recovery able to survive a direct shift from 30 to 43 degrees C (ca. 70% survival after 1 h). This induction of thermotolerance by these drugs is as efficient in providing thermoprotection to cells as is a prior sublethal heat treatment which elicits the synthesis of HSPs. However, during the period when drug-treated cells recover their protein synthesis ability and simultaneously acquire the ability to subsequently survive a shift to 43 degrees C, none of the major HSPs are synthesized. The ability to survive a 1-h, 43 degrees C heat treatment, therefore, does not absolutely require the prior synthesis of HSPs. But, as extended survival at 43 degrees Celsius depends absolutely on the ability of cells to continually synthesize HSPs, it appears that a prior heat shock as well as the recovery from protein synthesis inhibition elicits a change in the protein synthetic machinery which allows the translation of HSP mRNAs at what would otherwise be a nonpermissive temperature for protein synthesis.     

Induction of Thermotolerance by Prostaglandin A in Human Cells

Cyclopentenone prostaglandins (PGs) induce the synthesis of heat shack proteins (HSPs) in mammalian cells. Since arachidonic acid metabolites are implicated in the control of fever, we investigated the effect of PG treatment on thermal injury in human K562 erythroleukemia cells. Prostaglandin A₁ (PGA₁) was found to protect cells after severe heat shock and to induce a thermotolerant state, which persisted for 24-48 h. Prostaglandins of the B, E, and F type were not effective. Kinetics of thermotolerance induction was comparable to heat-induced heat resistance. Establishment of a thermotolerant state was not a direct effect of PGA₁, since it was dependent on de novo protein synthesis and was associated with HSP70 induction. This activity of PGA₁ could be part of a protective control mechanism during fever.     

Heat shock proteins do not provide thermoprotection to normal cellular protein synthesis, α-amylase mRNA and endoplasmic reticulum lamellae in barley aleurone layers

Heat shock in barley ( Hordeum vulgare L. cv. Himalaya) aleurone layers induces the synthesis of heat shock proteins (hsps) and suppresses the synthesis and secretion of α-amylase, the principal secretory protein. This is accompanied by the destabilization of α-amylase mRNA and a concomitant dissociation of ER lamellae. In the absence of heat shock α-amylase mRNA is extremely stable (Belanger et al. 1986. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 83: 1354–1358). In most organisms there is a direct correlation between the synthesis of hsps and thermotolerance. The ability of hsps to provide thermoprotection to secretory protein synthesis, α-amylase mRNA and ER lamellae was analyzed. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) of pulse-chased, [³⁵S]-methionine-labeled proteins revealed that the half-life of hsps in barley aleurone cells recovering from heat shock was approximately 12 h. Within approximately 6 h, there was a recovery of α-amylase mRNA and a reformation of ER lamellae. Heat shock protein synthesis was induced by either heat shock (40°C) or arsenite, the cells were allowed to recover for 8 h, then were re-exposed to heat shock. Results from SDS-PAGE showed that, despite the presence of hsps, α-amylase synthesis was suppressed. Northern blot hybridizations showed that α-amylase mRNA levels were reduced in heat-shocked tissues. Transmission electron microscopy demonstrated that ER lamellar structures were dissociated. The synthesis of hsps did not enable barley aleurone cells to sustain the synthesis of any proteins at lethal temperature. In contrast, similar conditions established thermotolerance and provided thermoprotection to protein synthesis in germinating barley embryos. Our findings suggest that the aleurone layer does not become thermotolerant following the induction of hsp synthesis.     

Induction of thermotolerance in T cells protects nuclear DNA topoisomerase I from heat stress.

In this study, we have demonstrated that topoisomerase I DNA relaxing activity is protected against a severe heat shock in T cells made thermotolerant by a prior modest heat treatment. However, following a severe heat-shock challenge and incubation at 37 degrees C, topoisomerase activity in the control population eventually returned to levels similar to those detected in thermotolerant cells. This recovery of topoisomerase activity appears to result from the renaturation of heat-inactivated enzyme rather than from synthesis of new protein because the rate of recovery of catalytic activity was not inhibited by the presence of the protein synthesis inhibitor, cycloheximide.     

Effects of cycloheximide on thermotolerance expression, heat shock protein synthesis, and heat shock protein mRNA accumulation in rat fibroblasts.

A single hyperthermic exposure can render cells transiently resistant to subsequent high temperature stresses. Treatment of rat embryonic fibroblasts with cycloheximide for 6 h after a 20-min interval at 45 degrees C inhibits protein synthesis, including heat shock protein (hsp) synthesis, and results in an accumulation of hsp 70 mRNA, but has no effect on subsequent survival responses to 45 degrees C hyperthermia. hsp 70 mRNA levels decreased within 1 h after removal of cycloheximide but then appeared to stabilize during the next 2 h (3 h after drug removal and 9 h after heat shock). hsp 70 mRNA accumulation could be further increased by a second heat shock at 45 degrees C for 20 min 6 h after the first hyperthermic exposure in cycloheximide-treated cells. Both normal protein and hsp synthesis appeared increased during the 6-h interval after hyperthermia in cultures which received two exposures to 45 degrees C for 20 min compared with those which received only one treatment. No increased hsp synthesis was observed in cultures treated with cycloheximide, even though hsp 70 mRNA levels appeared elevated. These data indicate that, although heat shock induces the accumulation of hsp 70 mRNA in both normal and thermotolerant cells, neither general protein synthesis nor hsp synthesis is required during the interval between two hyperthermic stresses for Rat-1 cells to express either thermotolerance (survival resistance) or resistance to heat shock-induced inhibition of protein synthesis.