Soluble suppressor activity of concanavalin A-activated spleen cells on B-lymphocyte colony formation in vitro.

Supernates from concanavalin A (Con A)-activated mouse spleen cell cultures suppress the formation of B-lymphocyte colonies (BLC) in soft agar culture by 30 to 95%. Con A-induced BLC suppressive culture supernates can be heated at 80 °C for 1 hr without losing activity. The BLC suppressive activity is eliminated totally by trypsin treatment and partly by treatment with β-galactosidase. Activity is unaffected by treatment with DNAse, RNAse, and α-glucosidase. By ultrafiltration the BLC suppressive factor(s) was shown to have a molecular weight greater than 300,000. These data suggest that BLC suppression is mediated by a protein-carbohydrate complex. BLC suppression was obtained when normal spleen cells were preincubated in Con A-activated supernates for only 1 hr at 37 °C. BLC suppressor activity was absent in the supernatant fluid of Con A exposed anti-θ-treated spleen cells, nonadherent spleen cells, extensively washed spleen cells, and spleen cells from nude (athymic) mice suggesting that cells responsible for Con A-induced BLC suppression are adherent, fragile cells of the T lineage. Con A-activated spleen cell supernates do not suppress colony formation in soft agar by normal mouse granulocyte-macrophage precursors, by plasmacytoma cells, T-lymphoma cells, or by carcinoma cells. However, colony formation by Abelson's murine leukemia virus transformed B-lymphoma cells was suppressed by 95% suggesting a relationship between this immature B-lymphoma line and B-lymphocyte colony-forming cells. Con A-activated spleen cell supernates do not suppress lymphocyte activation in liquid culture by phytohemagglutinin, Con A, or lipopolysaccharide. Heat-treated supernates—which inhibited BLC development by 90–95%—did not suppress the plaque formation by spleen cells immunized in vivo or in vitro by sheep red blood cells.     

Humoral primary immune response in vitro in a homologous mouse system: replacement of fetal calf serum by a 2-mercaptoethanol or macrophage-activated fraction of mouse serum.

The primary immune response in mouse spleen cell cultures against heterologous red cell antigens is dependent on the medium being supplemented with selected batches of fetal calf serum. Mouse serum itself is not able to support this response. The active immune response-supporting component in fetal calf serum seems to be a distinct factor (s), which has been partially purified by Sephadex G-100 filtration and termed MaSF-2-mercaptoethanol-activated serum factor. In this report it is demonstrated that MaSF is also present in mouse serum. For functional detection, mouse MaSF has to be separated from higher m.w. inhibitors, and has to be activated by 2-ME. After separation and activation mouse MaSF can support the primary immune response in a completely homologous in vitro culture system. Evidence is presented that MaSF can also be activated by macrophages. It is concluded that macrophages and 2-ME have the same mode of action in the primary immune response in vitro, i.e., induction of lymphocyte competence by activation of a serum factor.     

Relation between structure of bacterial lipopolysaccharide and the stimulation of B lymphocytes into colony formation.

Lipopolysaccharide (LPS) was analyzed in order to determine which component, lipid A or polysaccharide (PS), is able to stimulate B lymphocytes from ICR lymph nodes and spleen cells from nude (nu/nu) mice into forming colonies in soft agar culture. Lipid A, obtained by acid hydrolysis of LPS and solubilized by complex-formation with bovine serum albumin, was found to be the active moiety of LPS capable of stimulating colony growth of lymphoid cells in soft agar culture. The PS portion exhibited no significant activity at the concentrations used. Glycolipids from mutant strains of S. minnesota which contain the intact lipid moiety but are deficient in PS content, were as potent as S. abortus equi LPS in stimulating B cells into colony growth. Alkaline hydrolysis of LPS which cleaves ester-linked fatty acids, substantially decreased the number of lymphocyte colonies formed. This indicates that the intact lipid moiety is required for stimulating lymphocytes into colony formation. The synthetic glycolipid, N-palmitoyl-D-glucosamine (NPG), whose structure is similar to some components of lipid A, was also able to induce B lymphocyte colony development. In summary, our data point to lipid A as the active moiety of the endotoxin which induces B lymphocytes to grow and develop into colonies in the 2-layer soft agar culture system.     

Stimulation and inhibition of human T-lymphocyte colony cell proliferation by hemopoietic cell factors.

Human lymphocytes, isolated from peripheral blood and stimulated with phytohemagglutinin M (PHA) prior to being seeded on a two-layer medium of soft agar which contained the mitogen, developed into colonies 3–4 days after seeding in the culture system. The cloning potential of PHA-treated lymphocytes is significantly enhanced by adding, to the soft agar culture, culture fluid (CF) obtained from mitogen-treated lymphocytes or a feeder layer (FL) prepared either from lymphocytes isolated from peripheral blood or from T-cell enriched populations. PHA seems to stimulate the release of lymphocyte colony enhancing factor (LCEF) from the T-sensitized lymphocytes. The addition of CF or FL to the culture medium appears to increase the amount of LCEF, resulting in enhancement of the number and size of lymphocyte colonies. When CF derived from spleen cells or from the peripheral blood adherent-cell population was added to the lower layer of the soft agar culture, the growth and development of lymphocyte colonies was inhibited. This suggests that monocyte-macrophages release a lymphocyte colony inhibiting factor (LCIF) into the CF. The extent of inhibition or stimulation of colony formation is a function of the number and type of cells used to prepare the CF or FL and the concentration of CF in the culture medium. The presence of FL or CF derived from spleen non-adherent cells, white blood cells, bone marrow cells, or a B-cell enriched population had no effect on colonies growing in the culture. This may possibly be due to the paucity of T lymphocytes and monocyte-macrophages present in these materials. A control system in which LCIF, produced by monocyte-macrophages, and LCEF, produced by T lymphocytes, participate in the regulation of lymphocyte production is postulated.     

Stimulation of human T cell colony growth by a lymphocyte colony enhancement factor derived from lymphocyte subpopulations

Blood mononuclear cells (MNC) develop into T cell colonies when the cells are sensitized with PHA and seeded in a two-layer soft agar system. Conditioned medium (CM) derived from MNC enhanced lymphocyte colony formation when it was added to the culture system. CFU-TL appear to be stimulated into colony formation by molecules secreted by lymphocyte subpopulations contained in the seeded cells. In this study, human peripheral blood MNC were fractionated by a battery of techniques into adherent, E+, CD4+, CD8+, B and null cells. CM was prepared from each of the subpopulations and its effects on T cell colony growth assayed. All the lymphocyte subpopulations were found to generate lymphocyte colony enhancement factor (LCEF). After several purification procedures, CM prepared from CD4 and CD8+, displayed LCEF activity corresponding to proteins of molecular weight 30-40 and 100-140 kD.     

2-Mercaptoethanol acts as a potentiating factor of interleukin-2-dependent lymphocyte proliferation

An interleukin-2 (IL-2) dependent cell line which could be grown continuously with crude concanavalin A-stimulated rat or mouse spleen cell culture supernatant could not survive for over 48 hr in the culture medium supplemented with partially purified or recombinant IL-2. The cell growth was restored by adding another factor obtained from the same crude culture supernatant. This potentiating activity which was physicochemically inseparable from serum albumin was also obtained from the culture medium containing 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME) and incubated at 37 C for 24 hr without the spleen cells. By further experiments, it was demonstrated that 2-ME itself had the potentiating activity on the IL-2-dependent proliferation of this cell line and cysteine mediated the activity of 2-ME. The cells could not enter S-phase in the absence of 2-ME even in the presence of IL-2.     

2-Mercaptoethanol acts at the restricted stage of interleukin-2 dependent lymphocyte proliferation

An interleukin-2 (IL-2) dependent murine cell line (TN-9) which could be grown continuously with the crude culture supernatant of concanavaline A-stimulated rat or mouse spleen cells could not synthesize DNA in the culture medium supplemented with partially purified or recombinant IL-2. The cell growth was restored by adding another factor obtained from the same crude culture supernatant. This factor, physicochemically inseparable from serum albumin, was also obtained from the culture medium added with 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME) and incubated at 37 degrees C for 24 hr without the cells. By the experiments using semi-synchronized cell population, it was demonstrated that 2-ME or 2-ME carrying protein acted at the restricted process(es) of cell proliferation which occurred between IL-2-acting stage and the initiation of DNA synthesis.     

Mechanism of accessory cell requirement in inducing IL 2 responsiveness by human T4 lymphocytes that generate colonies under PHA stimulation

PHA-driven monoclonal colony formation by low concentrations of resting T4 lymphocytes in agar culture requires the presence of interleukin 2 (IL 2) and accessory cells. Using recombinant IL 2 and anti-Tac monoclonal antibody as a probe for the IL 2 receptor, we demonstrate that the requirement of accessory cells (here an irradiated B cell line) in inducing IL 2 responsiveness relies on their enhancing effect in functional IL 2 receptor expression by the T colony progenitors. Furthermore, it is shown that cell to cell interaction between accessory cells and colony progenitors results in IL 2 response, i.e., colony formation, when the IL 2 receptor density reaches a critical threshold. The asynchronism in IL 2 responsiveness expression by the T colony progenitors upon activation and the short-lived T cell-accessory cell interaction, due to accessory cell death, determine the 10% colony efficiency of the culture system. In addition, we demonstrate that the accessory function in IL 2 receptor and IL 2 responsiveness expression by the T colony progenitors can be supported by irradiated T lymphocytes as well as B cells. The absence of lineage restriction of the signal delivered by accessory cells, and the requirement of physical interaction between T colony progenitors and accessory cells, emphasize the necessity of cross-linking the activation-signal receptors in inducing IL 2 responsiveness by resting T4 cells.     

B Lymphocyte Colony Formation in vitro: Ultrastructural Development of Individual Colonies

B lymphocyte colony development in agar culture was studied using an electron microscope, and more than 3,000 colony cells were identified and photographed. In early cultures (day 4) lymphoblasts dominated the colonies. From day 5 onwards plasmablasts and small lymphocytes were present in the colonies. From day 6 onward mature plasma cells were observed in increasing numbers. On day 9 of culture the colonies started to degenerate and on day 10 of culture approximately 70% of the colony consisted of pyknotic and degenerating cells. Topographically, the degenerating cells were concentrated in the center of the colony whereas proliferation took place in the periphery. Colony growth occurred in an exponential fashion, the number of viable colony cells being maximal on day 8 of culture (400–600 cells/colony). At this time the frequencies of the four B cell categories were: lymphoblasts 72%, plasmablasts 20%, plasma cells 6%, and small lymphocytes 2%. Recloning experiments showed that dispersed colony cells were capable of forming only small cell clusters. It is concluded that B lymphocyte colony formation reflects a series of B cell developmental stages including the formation of the end cell categories of this lymphocyte lineage.     

Colony formation by subpopulations of human T lymphocytes. VI. Further studies on colony phenotype, function, and cloning efficiency

Phytohemagglutinin (PHA)-induced colony formation in semisolid agar medium by human peripheral blood T lymphocytes showed an increasing cloning efficiency with decreasing numbers of cultured cells. Ninety percent of CD4+ cells (inducer/helper phenotype) and 20% of CD8+ cells (cytotoxic/suppressor phenotype) formed colonies when cultured at 10-200 cells/ml culture in the presence of sheep red blood cells (SRBC) and a source of interleukin-2 (IL-2). Probably all T-colony-forming cells, but none of the subsequent colony cells, expressed the Leu-8 antigen. The cloning efficiencies of FACS-sorted cells expressing the natural killer antigenic phenotypes Leu-7+ and CD16+ were found to be less than 1%. The costimulatory effect of red blood cells for colony formation was specific for SRBC and not observed in the presence of red cells obtained from seven other species including man. All T-lymphocyte colonies obtained from unseparated peripheral blood mononuclear cells expressed the CD25 antigen (IL-2 receptor) and colonies were always composed of either CD4+ or CD8+ cells. None of the colony cells expressed the Leu-8 or the CD16 antigens. By their specific morphology in agar culture the majority of colonies composed of CD4+ cells were easily recognized, but but approximately one-third of the CD4+ colonies could not be distinguished from colonies composed of CD8+ cells. On expansion of individual colonies in liquid subculture in the presence of interleukin-2, approximately 15% of the colonies developed natural killer (NK)-like cytotoxic activity, being capable of direct killing of K562 tumor cells. It is concluded that the present method for growing human T colonies exhibits the same cloning efficiency as the most efficient liquid culture systems. Individual T colonies are composed exclusively of T inducer/helper or T cytotoxic/suppressor cells, they are never of mixed phenotype, and they do not contain cells of natural killer phenotype. Regulatory mechanisms influencing colony formation are operating between and within the various subsets of T lymphocytes.     

Colony formation in agar by murine plasmacytoma cells: potentiation by hemopoietic cells and serum

Clonal growth in semisolid agar medium was obtained using cells from 19 of 25 transplanted murine plasmacytomas when the medium was supplemented by whole mouse blood or washed red cells. With different tumors cloning efficiency ranged from 0.01% to 21.6%. With two exceptions, mouse blood did not potentiate colony formation in agar by cells from transplantable myelomonocytic, myeloid, and lymphoid leukemias, reticulum cell sarcomas and fibrosarcomas. The clonal growth of some plasmacytomas was also potentiated by syngeneic thymic, spleen or bone marrow cells. Plasmacytoma colony growth was not stimulated by normal mouse serum but serum from mice injected with endotoxin or polymerised flagellin stimulated colony growth by some plasmacytomas. The active serum factor was not the colony stimulating factor (CSF) and its appearance after antigenic stimulation was not T cell-dependent. Preimmunised mice failed tq respond to antigenic stimulation. Whole body irradiation did not induce a rise in the capacity of serum to stimulate colony formation by plasmacytoma cells.     

Heterogeneous accessory cell requirement for human peripheral blood T lymphocyte activation by PHA into IL-2-responsive colony-forming cells

Mitogen-driven T cell proliferation in liquid culture requires accessory cells that cooperate in interleukin 2 production. We have investigated the accessory cell requirement for human lymphocyte colony formation under PHA stimulation. Semisolid medium limits cell-to-cell contact emphasizing the role of cooperating cells both in growth factor production and in triggering events. Culturing at high T cell density demonstrates that accessory cells can be substituted for colony formation by exogenous IL-2. Culturing at low T cell density in the presence of IL-2 also demonstrates that accessory cells are required for activation of a subset of progenitors into IL-2 responsive colony-forming cells. Consequently, T colony progenitors, contained in the E-rosetting cell fraction of peripheral blood, are heterogeneous in their triggering signals: a minor subset is directly inducible by PHA, and a major subset is inducible by PHA in the presence of accessory cells. We found that monocytes and some leukemic B cells support effective accessory function in both colony growth factor production and colony progenitor sensitization.     

The in vitro differentiation of density sub-populations of colony-forming cells under the influence of different types of colony-stimulating factor.

The in vitro proliferation and differentiation of myeloid progenitor cells (CFU-c) in agar culture from CBA/Ca mouse bone marrow cells was studied. Density subpopulations of marrow cells were obtained by equilibrium centrifugation in continuous albumin density gradients. The formation of colonies of granulocytes and/or macrophages was studied under the influence of three types of colony-stimulating factor (CSF) from mouse lung conditioned medium CSFMLCM), post-endotoxin mouse serum (CSFES) and from human urine (CSFHu). The effect of the sulphydryl reagent mercaptoethanol on colony development was also examined. The density distribution of CFU-c was dependent on the type of CSF. Functional heterogeneity was found among CFU-c with partial discrimination between progenitor cells forming pure granulocytic colonies and those forming pure macrophage colonies. Mercaptoethanol increased colony incidence but had no apparent effect on colony morphology or the density distribution of CFU-c.     

Increased cytolytic T lymphocyte activity induced by 2-mercaptoethanol in mixed leukocyte cultures: kinetics and possible mechanisms of action.

The 20- to 50-fold increase in cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) activity caused by the addition of 50 muM 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME) at the onset of a one-way murine mixed leukocyte culture (MLC) between C57BL/6 and DBA/2 splenic lymphocytes appears to be unrelated to early events in the culture: if 2-ME was present for the first 24 hr of culture only, there was no increase on day 4, but if addition of 2-ME was delayed until the last 24 hr of culture, the CTL activity was almost as high as that of cultures that were exposed to 2-ME for the entire 4-day culture period. The increase of CTL activity caused by delayed addition of 2-ME ("2-ME rescue") was used to investigate the mechanism by which the thiol induces differentiation of CTL from precursor cells. 2-ME rescue was mimicked by two other thiols, dithiothreitol and cysteamine phosphate, but at higher concentrations. Because the latter compound has no free sulhydryl group until it diffuses into cells and is enzymatically dephosphorylated, we conclude that thiols may increase the differentiation of CTL from precursor cells by an intracellular process involving free sulphydryl groups rather than by interaction with membrane sulfhydryls or destruction of inhibitor cells or their products. Cell separation experiments indicated that 2-ME rescue was independent of the presence of B lymphocytes and of adherent cells (macrophages) and was restricted to a subpopulation of T lymphocytes that developed into large lymphoid precursor cells during the first 3 days in culture even without 2-ME. The development of this subpopulation required DNA synthesis between 24 nad 72 hr after the onset of MLC. When 2-ME was added to day-3 MLC, CTL activity increased slightly as early as 4 hr later, but the major increase occurred during the second half of the 24 hr "rescue"period. Because this increase was inhibited by cytosine arabinoside (ARA-C), it seems likely that DNA synthesis is associated with and may be required for the differentiation of large precursor lymphoid cells into CTL after the addition of 2-ME.     

B lymphocyte colony-forming cells in the SJL/J mouse.

Mercatoethanol-induced B lymphocyte cloning in semi-solid agar has been used to study lymphocyte colony formation by cells from the SJL/J mouse thymus. From the 3rd month of life, the SJL/J mouse thymus. From the 3rd month of life, the SJL thymus develops an increasing frequency of cells forming B lymphocyte colonies in agar. The peak frequency in 6- to 12-month-old mice was one colony per 1000 to 2000 cultured thymus cells. In contrast, 10 to 100 times lower frequencies were found in the thymus of five other inbred mouse strains. The rise in B lymphocyte colony-forming cells correlated well with the age-related rise in Ig-positive cells and approximately 50% of the colony cells reacted with anti-micron-serum indicating the B lymphocyte nature of the colony cells. Colony-forming cells from the thymus showed higher sensitivity than colony-forming spleen cells to cortisol and irradiation. Cell transfer experiments and thymus grafting suggested that the increased frequency of colony-forming cells in the thymus is caused by development of special thymus-seeking B lymphocytes in ageing SJL/J mice. Finally, B lymphocyte colony-forming cells were found to be more frequent in the thymus, spleen, and lymph nodes from healthy aged mice than in lymphoid organs from mice with spontaneous reticulum cell tumors.     

Function of 2-mercaptoethanol as a macrophage substitute in the primary immune response in vitro.

The mechanism by which 2-ME acts as a macrophage-substitute for the induction of a primary PFC response to SRC in vitro was studied in macrophage-depleted mouse spleen cell cultures. 2-ME could replace macrophages only in FCS-supplemented cultures. Evidence is presented that the function of 2-ME is independent of residual macrophages. Neither normal nor macrophage-depleted spleen cell cultures from congenitally athymic nude mice supplemented with 2-ME, with or without FCS, could give rise to a primary in vitro anti-SRC immune response. 2-ME, at an optimal concentration of 10(-5) M, induced DNA synthesis in normal and macrophage-depleted spleen cells in both FCS-containing and serum-free cultures. The peak response occurred on day 3. The stimulation was accompanied by a polyclonal B cell activation to antibody secretion which was much more pronounced in FCS-containing than in serum-free cultures. Spleen cells from nude mice showed a weaker DNA stimulation than did cells from normal mice in FCS-containing cultures, and nearly no response under serum-free conditions. T cells obtained by a nylon column adherence method from normal mouse spleen cells showed good DNA synthetic responses in FCS-containing, but no response in serum-free cultures. These results show that 2-ME has weak mitogenic activity for B cells, and in combination with FCS, strong mitogenic activity for T cells. Since the macrophage provides stimulation to the T cell in the primary anti-SRC PFC response in vitro, these results suggest that the direct mitogenic activity of 2-ME with FCS on T cells provides the functional substitution for macrophages.     

Functional characterization of T lymphocytes grown in semisolid agar

T lymphocyte colony forming cells (TL-CFC) grown in agar in the presence of PHA were assayed for their capacity to induce or suppress polyclonal PWM dependent B lymphocyte differentiation into plasma cells. This was measured by identifying cells containing intracytoplasmatic immunoglobulins by direct immunofluorescence. To validate the helper and suppressor system used in this paper, the inductive capacity of unfractionated T lymphocytes and their subpopulations bearing Fc-receptors for IgM (TM) and for IgG (TG) was measured. The unfractionated T cells and the TM fraction showed helper activity, whereas the TG cells expressed suppressor activity. The TL-CFC grown in agar in the presence of PHA manifested helper activity at low cell concentration. However, increasing the TL-CFC concentration finally caused suppression of B cell differentiation. The suppressor effect could be abolished by prior irradiation of the TL-CFC before seeding them in agar. These results indicate that T cells grown in agar have the functional capacity of T helper and T suppressor cells to induce and suppress polyclonal PWM dependent B lymphocyte differentiation into plasma cells.     

T cells and the anti-trinitrophenyl antibody response to fetal calf serum and 2-mercaptoethanol

Unprimed murine lymphocytes maintained in culture medium containing fetal calf serum (FCS) and 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME) developed very high levels of anti-trinitrophenyl (TNP) plaque forming cells (PFC). Both FCS and 2-ME contributed to the response. The development of anti-TNP PFC during culture was accompanied by a 10-fold expansion in the number of immunoglobulin-secreting cells, indicating polyclonal stimulation. However, the number of anti-TNP PFC was disproportionately high and not accompanied by a similar increase in plaques specific for sheep red blood cells. The TNP-specific plaques were not artifacts of the plaque assay since they were 98% inhibited by specific antigen. The in vitro induction of anti-TNP PFC by FCS and 2-ME was common to a number of mouse strains, although some genetic variation occurred. Nylon-wool-separated B cells, nude mouse spleen cells, and bone marrow cells all produced high levels of anti-TNP after culture with medium containing FCS and 2-ME. The addition of T cells to B-cell cultures increased the numbers of anti-TNP PFC by 1.5- to 2.5-fold. The presence of a TNP-cross-reacting antigen in FCS probably contributed to the unexpectedly high anti-TNP response. The response to the antigen in FCS was potentiated by the enhancing activity of 2-ME.     

Role of mercaptoethanol and endotoxin in stimulating B lymphocyte colony formation in vitro.

Mercaptoethanol is necessary to permit B lymphocyte colony formation in semi-solid agar cultures of cells from normal mouse lymphoid organs. Transfer studies on developing colonies showed that, in part, this was a direct action on B lymphocyte colony cells but evidence was produced that in the presence of mercaptoethanol lymphoid organ cells release a factor promoting colony growth. Endotoxin strongly potentiated B lymphocyte colony formation in vitro by a direct action on colony cells but in the absence of mercaptoethanol did not allow cell survival or proliferation.     

A monoclonal antibody to antigens expressed on MLR-activated T cells inhibits granulocyte macrophage colony formation

A monoclonal antibody specifically reactive with MLR-activated T cells (MLR2) was added to light density normal marrow cells, depleted of adherent cells and T lymphocytes, and plated in soft agar for granulocyte macrophage colony formation. Colonies from MLR2-treated marrow cells were reduced to less than 10% of expected growth. The inhibition was not complement dependent, did not require the continuous presence of MLR2 in culture, and could not be detected also when human placenta-conditioned medium was used in the place of leukocyte feeder layers as a source of colony-stimulating factor (CSF). Co-culture experiments with MLR2 treated and untreated marrow cells further excluded the possibility of an indirect effect of MLR2 on CFU-c via auxiliary cells. The results of this study suggest that myeloid progenitor cells express a lymphoid antigen that is absent on resting or activated B cells and on resting T cells, but is expressed on activated T cells.