Evolution of secondary structure in the family of 7SL-like RNAs

Primate and rodent genomes are populated with hundreds of thousands copies of Alu and B1 elements dispersed by retroposition, i.e., by genomic reintegration of their reverse transcribed RNAs. These, as well as primate BC200 and rodent 4.5S RNAs, are ancestrally related to the terminal portions of 7SL RNA sequence. The secondary structure of 7SL RNA (an integral component of the signal recognition particle) is conserved from prokaryotes to distant eukaryotic species. Yet only in primates and rodents did this molecule give rise to retroposing Alu and B1 RNAs and to apparently functional BC200 and 4.5S RNAs. To understand this transition and the underlying molecular events, we examined, by comparative analysis, the evolution of RNA structure in this family of molecules derived from 7SL RNA.RNA sequences of different simian (mostly human) and prosimian Alu subfamilies as well as rodent B1 repeats were derived from their genomic consensus sequences taken from the literature and our unpublished results (prosimian and New World Monkey). RNA secondary structures were determined by enzymatic studies (new data on 4.5S RNA are presented) and/or energy minimization analyses followed by phylogenetic comparison. Although, with the exception of 4.5S RNA, all 7SL-derived RNA species maintain the cruciform structure of their progenitor, the details of 7SL RNA folding domains are modified to a different extent in various RNA groups. Novel motifs found in retropositionally active RNAs are conserved among Alu and B1 subfamilies in different genomes. In RNAs that do not proliferate by retroposition these motifs are modified further. This indicates structural adaptation of 7SL-like RNA molecules to novel functions, presumably mediated by specific interactions with proteins; these functions were either useful for the host or served the selfish propagation of RNA templates within the host genome.Abbreviations FAM fossil Alu element - FLAM free left Alu monomer - FRAM free right Alu monomer - L-Alu left Alu subunit - R-Alu right Alu subunit Correspondence to: D. LabudaDedicated to Dr. Robert Cedergren on the occasion of his 25th anniversary at the University of Montreal     

Evolution of mouse B1 repeats: 7SL RNA folding pattern conserved

Summary In a recent report mouse B1 genomic repeats were divided into six families representing different waves of fixation of B1 variants, consistent with the retroposition model of human Alu elements. These data are used to examine the distribution of nucleotide substitutions in individual genomic repeats with respect to family consensus sequences and to compare the minimal energy structures of the corresponding B1 RNAs. By an enzymatic approach the predicted structure of B1 RNAs is experimentally confirmed using as a model sequence an RNA of a young B1 family member transcribed in vitro by T7 RNA polymerase. B1 RNA preserves folding domains of the Alu fragment of 7SL RNA, its progenitor molecule. Our results reveal similarities among 7SL-like retroposons, human Alu, and rodent B1 repeats, and relate the evolutionary conservation of B1 family consensus sequences to selection at the RNA level.     

Sequence conservation in Alu evolution

A statistical analysis of a set of genomic human Alu elements is based on a published alignment and a recent classification of these sequences. After separation of the Alu sequences into families, the consensus sequences of these families are determined, using the correct weighting of the unidirectional decay of CG-dinucleotides. For, the tenfold greater mutation rate at CG's requires separate consideration of an independent clock at every stage of analysis. The distributions of the substitutions with respect to the new consensus sequences, taking the CG and the non-CG-nucleotide positions separately, lie far closer to the expected distributions than the total diversity. Computer analysis of the folding of RNAs derived from these sequences indicates that RNA secondary structure is conserved among Alu families, suggesting its importance for Alu proliferation and/or function. The folding pattern, further substantiated by a number of compensatory mutations, includes secondary structure domains which are homologous to those observed in 7SL RNA and a defined region of interaction between the two Alu subunits. These results are consistent with a model in which a small number of conserved Alu master genes give rise via retroposition to the numerous copies of Alu pseudogenes, that then diversify by random substitution. The master genes appeared at different periods during evolution giving rise to different families of Alu sequences.     

Identification of a minimal Alu RNA folding domain that specifically binds SRP9/14.

We have identified functionally and analyzed a minimal Alu RNA folding domain that is recognized by SRPphi14-9. Recombinant SRPphi14-9 is a fusion protein containing on a single polypeptide chain the sequences of both the SRP14 and SRP9 proteins that are part of the Alu domain of the signal recognition particle (SRP). SRPphi14-9 has been shown to bind to the 7SL RNA of SRP and it confers elongation arrest activity to reconstituted SRP in vitro. Alu RNA variants with homogeneous 3' ends were produced in vitro using ribozyme technology and tested for specific SRPphi14-9 binding in a quantitative equilibrium competition assay. This enabled identification of an Alu RNA of 86 nt (SA86) that competes efficiently with 7SL RNA for SRPphi14-9 binding, whereas smaller RNAs did not. The secondary structure of SA86 includes two stem-loops that are connected by a highly conserved bulge and, in addition, a part of the central adaptor stem that contains the sequence at the very 3' end of 7SL RNA. Circularly permuted variants of SA86 competed only if the 5' and 3' ends were joined with an extended linker of four nucleotides. SA86 can thus be defined as an autonomous RNA folding unit that does not require its 5' and 3' ends for folding or for specific recognition by SRPphi14-9. These results suggest that Alu RNA identity is determined by a characteristic tertiary structure, which might consist of two flexibly linked domains.     

Transfer RNA-like structure of the human Alu family: Implications of its generation mechanism and possible functions

Summary Structural resemblance of the human Alu family with a subset of vertebrate tRNAs was detected. Of four tRNAs, tRNA^Lys, tRNA^Ile, tRNA^Thr, and tRNA^Tyr, which comprise a structurally related family, tRNA^Lys is the most similar to the human Alu family. Of the 76 nucleotides in lysine tRNA (including the CCA tail), 47 are similar to the human Alu family (60% identity). The secondary structure of the human Alu family corresponding to the D-stem and anticodon stem regions of the tRNA appears to be very stable. The 7SL RNA, which is a progenitor of the human Alu family, is less similar to lysine tRNA (55% identity), and the secondary structure of the 7SL RNA folded like a tRNA is less stable than that of the human Alu family folded likewise. Insertion of the tetranucleotide GAGA, which is an important region of the second promoter for RNA polymerase III in the Alu sequence, occurred during the deletion and ligation process to generate the Alu sequence from the parental 7SL RNA. These results suggest that the human Alu family was generated from the 7SL RNA by deletion, insertion, and mutations, which thus modified the ancestral 7SL sequence so that it could form a structure more closely resembling lysine tRNA. The similarities of several short interspersed sequences to the lysine tRNA were also examined. TheGalago type 2 family, which was reported to be derived from a methionine initiator tRNA, was also found to be similar to the lysine tRNA. Thus lysine tRNA-like structures are widespread in genomes in the animal kingdom. The implications of these findings in relation to the mechanism of generation of the human Alu family and its possible functions are discussed.     

Sequence composition similarities with the 7SL RNA are highly predictive of functional genomic features

Transposable elements derived from the 7SL RNA gene, such as Alu elements in primates, have had remarkable success in several mammalian lineages. The results presented here show a broad spectrum of functions for genomic segments that display sequence composition similarities with the 7SL RNA gene. Using thoroughly documented loci, we report that DNaseI-hypersensitive sites can be singled out in large genomic sequences by an assessment of sequence composition similarities with the 7SL RNA gene. We apply a root word frequency approach to illustrate a distinctive relationship between the sequence of the 7SL RNA gene and several classes of functional genomic features that are not presumed to be of transposable origin. Transposable elements that show noticeable similarities with the 7SL sequence include Alu sequences, as expected, but also long terminal repeats and the 5′-untranslated regions of long interspersed repetitive elements. In sequences masked for repeated elements, we find, when using the 7SL RNA gene as query sequence, distinctive similarities with promoters, exons and distal gene regulatory regions. The latter being the most notoriously difficult to detect, this approach may be useful for finding genomic segments that have regulatory functions and that may have escaped detection by existing methods.     

Alu repeats in the human genome

Highly repetitive DNA sequences account for more than 50% of the human genome. The L1 and Alu families harbor the most common mammalian long (LINEs) and short (SINEs) interspersed elements. Alu elements are each a dimer of similar, but not identical, fragments of total size about 300 bp, and originate from the 7SL RNA gene. Each element contains a bipartite promoter for RNA polymerase III, a poly(A) tract located between the monomers, a 3'-terminal poly(A) tract, and numerous CpG islands, and is flanked by short direct repeats. Alu repeats comprise more than 10% of the human genome and are capable of retroposition. Possibly, these elements played an important part in genome evolution. Insertion of an Alu element into a functionally important genome region or other Alu-dependent alterations of gene functions cause various hereditary disorders and are probably associated with carcinogenesis. In total, 14 Alu families differing in diagnostic mutations are known. Some of these, which are present in the human genome, are polymorphic and relatively recently inserted into new loci. Alu copies transposed during ethnic divergence of the human population are useful markers for evolutionary genetic studies.     

Hierarchical assembly of the Alu domain of the mammalian signal recognition particle

The mammalian signal recognition particle (SRP) catalytically promotes cotranslational translocation of signal sequence containing proteins across the endoplasmic reticulum membrane. While the S-domain of SRP binds the N-terminal signal sequence on the nascent polypeptide, the Alu domain of SRP temporarily interferes with the ribosomal elongation cycle until the translocation pore in the membrane is correctly engaged. Here we present biochemical and biophysical evidence for a hierarchical assembly pathway of the SRP Alu domain. The proteins SRP9 and SRP14 first heterodimerize and then initially bind to the Alu RNA 5' domain. This creates the binding site for the Alu RNA 3' domain. Alu RNA then undergoes a large conformational change with the flexibly linked 3' domain folding back by 180 degrees onto the 5' domain complex to form the final compact Alu ribonucleoprotein particle (Alu RNP). We discuss the possible mechanistic consequences of the likely reversibility of this final step with reference to translational regulation by the SRP Alu domain and with reference to the structurally similar Alu RNP retroposition intermediates derived from Alu elements in genomic DNA.     

cis-Acting determinants of 7SL RNA packaging by HIV-1

The host noncoding RNA 7SL is highly enriched in the virions of retroviruses. We examined the regions of 7SL that mediate packaging by HIV-1. Both the Alu domain and the S domain were sufficient to mediate specific packaging when expressed separately as truncations of 7SL. However, while the Alu domain competed with endogenous 7SL for packaging in proportion to Gag, the S domain was packaged additively, implying that the Alu and S domains are packaged via separate mechanisms and that the Alu domain is packaged by the same mechanism as endogenous 7SL. Further truncations of the Alu domain or mutation of the Alu domain helix 5c region significantly reduced packaging efficiency, implicating helix 5c as critical for packaging, reinforcing the finding that 7SL packaging is highly selective, and confirming that 7SL is not passively acquired. Surprisingly, when the Alu domain was mutated so that it no longer contained a binding site for the SRP protein heterodimer SRP9/14, it was no longer packaged in a competitive manner but instead was packaged additively with endogenous 7SL. These data support a model in which 7SL RNA is packaged via interactions between Gag and a 7SL RNA structure that exists transiently at a discrete stage of SRP biogenesis. Our data further indicate that a secondary "additive" pathway exists that can result in the packaging of certain 7SL derivatives in molar excess to endogenously packaged 7SL.     

A BC200-derived element and Z-DNA as structural markers in annexin I genes: Relevance to Alu evolution and annexin tetrad formation

We have identified two types of structural elements in genomic DNA for annexin I that provide physical evidence of genetic events leading to conserved changes in gene structure. The sequence upstream of the transcribed region in human annexin I contained a rare, Alu-like repetitive element with flanking direct repeats, probably derived from the active BC200 gene via germline retroposition. Nucleotide substitutions in this BC200 insert relative to the 7SL gene and its absence in rodent annexins I identified it as a recent primate pseudogene. Phylogenetic analysis showed that the BC200 gene represents a new clade of primate Alu evolution that branched near the time of appearance of the progenitor to the free left Alu monomer, FLAM-C. Separate analysis identified a Z-DNA motif in pigeon annexin I intron 7 that may represent the vestigial recombination site involved in primordial assembly of the annexin tetrad. These distinct structural features in annexin I genes provide insight into the evolution of Alu repeats and the mechanism of annexin tetrad formation.     

A trinucleotide repeat-associated increase in the level of Alu RNA-binding protein occurred during the same period as the major Alu amplification that accompanied anthropoid evolution.

Nearly 1 million Alu elements in human DNA were inserted by an RNA-mediated retroposition-amplification process that clearly decelerated about 30 million years ago. Since then, Alu sequences have proliferated at a lower rate, including within the human genome, in which Alu mobility continues to generate genetic variability. Initially derived from 7SL RNA of the signal recognition particle (SRP), Alu became a dominant retroposon while retaining secondary structures found in 7SL RNA. We previously identified a human Alu RNA-binding protein as a homolog of the 14-kDa Alu-specific protein of SRP and have shown that its expression is associated with accumulation of 3'-processed Alu RNA. Here, we show that in early anthropoids, the gene encoding SRP14 Alu RNA-binding protein was duplicated and that SRP14-homologous sequences currently reside on different human chromosomes. In anthropoids, the active SRP14 gene acquired a GCA trinucleotide repeat in its 3'-coding region that produces SRP14 polypeptides with extended C-terminal tails. A C-->G substitution in this region converted the mouse sequence CCA GCA to GCA GCA in prosimians, which presumably predisposed this locus to GCA expansion in anthropoids and provides a model for other triplet expansions. Moreover, the presence of the trinucleotide repeat in SRP14 DNA and the corresponding C-terminal tail in SRP14 are associated with a significant increase in SRP14 polypeptide and Alu RNA-binding activity. These genetic events occurred during the period in which an acceleration in Alu retroposition was followed by a sharp deceleration, suggesting that Alu repeats coevolved with C-terminal variants of SRP14 in higher primates.     

Monophyletic Origin of Alu Elements in Primates

To get insight into the early evolution of the primate Alu elements, we characterized sequences of these repeats from the Malagasy prosimians, lemurs (Lemuridae) and sifakas (Indriidae), as well as from galagos (Lorisidae). These sequences were compared with the oldest Alu species known from the human genome: dimeric Alu J and S and free Alu monomers. Our analysis indicates that about 60 Myr ago, before the prosimian divergence, free left and right monomers formed an Alu heterodimer connected by a 19-nucleotide-long A-rich linker. The resulting elements successfully propagated in diverging primate lineages until about ∼20 Myr ago, conserving similar sequence features and essentially the same Alu RNA secondary structure. We suggest that until that time the same ``retropositional niche', molecular machinery making possible the proliferation by retroposition, constrained the evolution of Alu elements in extant primate species. These constraints became subsequently relaxed. In the Malagasy prosimians the dimeric Alu continued to amplify after acquiring a 34- to 36-nucleotide extension of their linker segment, whereas in the galago genome the ``retropositional niche' was occupied by novel short elements. Received: 1 December 1997 / Accepted: 30 January 1998     

Characterization of novel Alu- and tRNA-related SINEs from the tree shrew and evolutionary implications of their origins

We characterized two novel 7SL RNA-derived short interspersed nuclear element (SINE) families (Tu types I and II) and a novel tRNA-derived SINE family (Tu type III) from the tree shrew (Tupaia belangeri). Tu type I contains a monomer unit of a 7SL RNA-derived Alu-like sequence and a tRNA-derived region that includes internal RNA polymerase III promoters. Tu type II has a similar hybrid structure, although the monomer unit of the 7SL RNA-derived sequence is replaced by a dimer. Along with the primate Alu, the galago Alu type II, and the rodent B1, these two families represent the fourth and fifth 7SL RNA-derived SINE families to be identified. Furthermore, comparison of the Alu domains of Tu types I and II with those of other 7SL RNA-derived SINEs reveals that the nucleotides responsible for stabilization of the Alu domain have been conserved during evolution, providing the possibility that these conserved nucleotides play an indispensable role in retropositional activity. Evolutionary relationships among these 7SL RNA-derived SINE families, as well as phylogenetic relationships of their host species, are discussed.     

Origin of the Alu family: a family of Alu-like monomers gave birth to the left and the right arms of the Alu elements.

The Alu dimeric elements are a common feature of the primate genomes, where they constitute a family of related sequences (1). The identification of a free left Alu monomer (FLAM) family plus a free right Alu monomer (FRAM) family suggests that the dimeric structure results from the fusion of a FLAM sequence with a FRAM sequence (2). Here, we describe a very old Alu-like monomeric family, referred to as FAM for fossil Alu monomer. This family arose from a 7SL RNA sequence and gave birth to the FLAM and FRAM families. From the results obtained, the evolution of the Alu family can be subdivided into two phases. The first phase, which involves only monomeric elements, is characterized by deep remodelling of the progenitor sequences and ends with the appearance of the first Alu dimeric element through the fusion of a FLAM and a FRAM element. The second phase, still in progress, starts with the first Alu dimeric element. This phase is characterized by the stabilization of the progenitor sequences.