Neonatally induced tolerance to soluble protein antigens. II. A role for the thymus in prolonging tolerance

Mice were rendered tolerant to bovine serum albumin (BSA) or fowl γ-globulin (FGG) by neonatal injection. Spleen and thymus cells from tolerant mice were able to suppress responsiveness of normal adult spleen cells, but only if tolerant donor mice were between the ages of 6 weeks and the age at which mice were no longer tolerant (10 weeks for BSA tolerance and 20 weeks for FGG tolerance). To determine whether T-cell-dependent suppression was obligatory for the maintenance of tolerance, neonatal nude and euthymic littermate mice were injected with tolerizing doses of FGG. FGG-specific B-cell tolerance in nude mice lasted until the mice were 8 weeks of age. In sharp contrast, B-cell tolerance in euthymic littermates lasted until 22 weeks of age. These results are consistent with a “fail-safe” role of T-cell-dependent immune suppression in the maintenance of tolerance.     

Delayed hypersensitivity reaction to transplantation antigens in mice with induced tolerance for allo- and xenografts

The delayed-type hypersensitivity reaction (DTH) in mice tolerant to allo- and xenoantigens has been investigated. To induce tolerance adult mice were thymectomized and given 1 X 10(8) allogeneic or xenogeneic spleen cells and cyclophosphamide (200 mg/kg). Such mice failed to develop DTH to donor antigens, while DTH reaction to foreign allo- and xenoantigens was retained. Spleen cells of mice tolerant to alloantigens significantly suppressed the afferent and efferent DTH phases. The suppression was specific and T-cell-mediated. Spleen cells of mice tolerant to xenoantigens could suppress only the afferent DTH phase. The treatment of cells with anti-T-globulin and complement did not abrogate the suppression. The role of DTH suppressors in the induction and maintenance of transplantation tolerance is discussed.     

Specific suppression of the immune response by HGG tolerant spleen cells. I. Parameters affecting the level of suppression.

After adoptive transfer, the spleen cells from mice made tolerant to human gamma-globulin (HGG) specifically suppress the immune response of normal spleen cells. However, this suppressive activity in the spleen cells of tolerant mice is only present for a brief period after treatment with tolerogen. Spleen cells from animals injected 10 days earlier with tolerogen reduce the immune response of an equal number of normal spleen cells by 75%. Spleen cells from mice made tolerant 40 days previously are, however, no longer suppressive, even though they remain completely unresponsive. These data suggest that active suppression of antigen-reactive cells is not the mechanism responsible for maintaining tolerance to HGG, but rather is only transiently associated with the tolerant state. Further evidence in favor of the separation of the tolerant state from suppressive activity is that complete suppression of the normal spleen cell response requires either a high ratio of tolerant to immune competent cells or a delay in the antigenic challenge of the reconstituted recipients. By contrast, such manipulations are not required to demonstrate the complete unresponsiveness of the tolerant cells after adoptive transfer.     

Loss of carrier-determined tolerance in vitro with loss of receptor blockade.

Experiments were done to determine whether carrier-determined tolerance is reversible and whether the loss of tolerance is accompanied by the loss of receptor blockade. Spleen cells from mice made tolerant with DNP-isologous IgG remained tolerant when transferred to irradiated syngeneic mice. If these same tolerant spleen cells were incubated for 24 hr or more before transfer the tolerance was lost. Autoradiology was done on the tolerant cells with either 125I anti-DNP or 125DNP-KLH, before and after incubation in vitro. When the cells were tolerant the number of DNP ABC was decreased whereas cells having DNP on their surface were increased. When the cells lost tolerance after in vitro incubation, the hapten-bearing cells were no longer present although the number of cells free DNP receptors increased to normal. These data suggest that in carrier determined tolerance the reactivation of tolerant lymphocytes may involve reversible receptor blockade.     

Cellular aspects of tolerance. II. Unresponsiveness of B cells

The responsiveness of bone marrow cells from tolerant donors was examined by reconstitution of lethally irradiated tolerogen-free recipients. In these animals, stem cells from tolerant donors gave rise to immunologically competent antigen sensitive B cells. The antibody produced by these cells could be detected by a sensitive plaque assay in liquid and by antigen elimination. The antibody was not demonstrable by an assay which only detected plaque forming antibody which was highly avid or was formed in large quantity per cell. In lethally irradiated animals, partially purified B cells from a tolerant animal could not cooperate with T cells from normal donors to reconstitute immunological responsiveness to immunogenic doses of the tolerance inducing antigen. We concluded that antigen sensitive B cells in the bone marrow become unresponsive following administration of tolerogenic forms of antigen. Responsiveness of the reconstituted recipient animals was due to the differentiation of donor stem cells and subsequent antibody production by their descendants. Earlier contradictory findings could be unified in terms of these observations and conclusions.     

Absence of suppression in natural and induced tolerance to F antigen

The role of suppression in natural and induced tolerance to F antigen was investigated in two sets of experiments. In the first, CBA mice were submitted to pretreatments which decrease suppression and the antibody response to self- or allo-F type was investigated. The second set of experiments involved the transfer of spleen cells from tolerized or from naturally tolerant mice into normal mice which were then primed with allo-F, as well as the co-transfer of tolerant and primed lymphocytes into normal mice, to test whether tolerant lymphocytes present suppressor cells. The results indicate that the immune response against allo-F antigen is normally kept in a low level by a suppressive mechanism, and that F-specific suppressor T cells are absent from tolerant mice.Abbreviations used in this paper ATx adult thymectomy - BSS buffered salt solution - CFA Freund's complete adjuvant - CY cyclophosphamide - F.1 type-1 F antigen - F.2 type-2 F antigen - PBS phosphate-buffered saline - RIA radioimmunoassay - Th T helper cell - Ts T suppressor cell     

Suppressor cells in tolerance to HGG: kinetics and cross-suppression in high dose tolerance--absence in low dose tolerance.

Spleen cells from mice made tolerant with high doses of human gamma-globulin (HGG) specifically suppress the immune response of normal, syngeneic, spleen cells. These suppressor cells were found to be cross-reactive in that they would suppress the immune response of normal spleen cells to bovine gamma-globulin (BGG) as well as to HGG. In contrast, suppressor cells could not be demonstrated in spleens of mice made tolerant with low doses of HGG (i.e., T-cell tolerance), nor could they be found in high dose tolerant mice following a second injection of DHGG at a time when the initial suppressor activity had waned. The role of suppressor cells in the induction, maintenance, and loss of tolerance is discussed.     

Immune suppression in vivo with antigen-modified syngeneic cells. II. T cell-mediated nonresponsiveness to fowl gamma-globulin.

Intravenous administration of syngeneic spleen cells coupled with the palmitoyl derivative of fowl gammma-globulin (p-F gamma G) results in a profound state of F gamma G-specific tolerance in C57BL/6 mice. Administration of p-F gamma G coupled syngeneic cells specifically reduces both the primary and secondary hapten and carrier-specific PFC responses to TNP-F gamma G. Since the haptenic response is affected, the tolerance functions at the level of the F gamma G-specific helper T cell. As few as 10(3) p-F gamma G spleen cells carrying only 1 ng of p-F gamma G can induce tolerance. At least a 2-day-induction period is required. This nonresponsiveness is long lived, lasting over 120 days. Spleen cells from tolerized mice can transfer suppression to normal syngeneic recipients. Treatment of tolerant spleens with anti-Thy 1.2 antiserum + C eliminates the suppressor cell activity. In addition, thymocytes and purified splenic T cells from tolerized mice can transfer suppression to normal recipients. Thus, at least a component of this nonresponsiveness is mediated by suppressor T cells. The requirement of antigen association with cell membrane components and the general applicability of this method of inducing T cell nonresponsiveness are discussed.     

Immunologic tolerance to HGG in mice. I. Suppression of the HGG response in normal mice with spleen cells or a spleen cell lysate from tolerant mice.

Adoptive transfer of spleen cells or spleen cell lysates from mice tolerant to human-gamma-globulin (HGG) specifically suppressed the response of normal syngeneic recipients to HGG. The suppressive activity could be transferred for over 100 days after tolerance induction. The suppression induced by both spleen cells and spleen cell lysate was found to be specific as evidenced by a normal response to a challenge with turkey-gamma-globulin or goat erythrocytes. The activity of the suppressive lysate could be removed by passing the material through an HGG immunoadsorbent column but not by passing it through an anti-HGG column or a BSA column. These results indicated that the factor had antigen specificity and was probably not antigen-antibody complexes. That this suppression was not due to a shifting of the kinetics of the antibody response has also been demonstrated. The antigen-specific suppressor factor in the tolerant spleen cell lysates was a protein with a m.w. of approximately 45,000 daltons. The kinetics of the appearance of both suppressor cells and suppressor factor were consistent with a mechanism of active suppression functioning in the maintenance of tolerance to HGG.     

Supressor activity of spleen cells during medically induced immunologic tolerance]

SRBC tolerance was induced in mice (CBA X C57BL/6) F1 by single intraperitoneal injection of 6 X 10(9) SRBC and of cyclophosphamide (100-200 mg/kg) in 44-46 hours. Spleen cells of tolerant mice obtained at various periods after the tolerance induction (in 12-26 days) failed to decrease their immune response to SRBC after administration to intact syngeneic recipients. Contrary to intact mice, tolerant animals were incapable of producing suppressor cells after a single SRBC immunization. Only when 3 additional injections of high SRBC doses (6 X 10(9)) were given to tolerant mice the spleen cells in them acquired the capacity to inhibit the immune response after administration to normal mice. It is supposed that the absence of suppressor cells in induction of the immunological tolerance by means of cyclophosphane was caused by the processes of clone elimination. Suppressor cells can originate in tolerant animals under the effect of intensive antigenic stimulation, this leading to enhancement of the tolerance state as a result of additional SRBC injections.     

Suppressors of the graft vs graft reaction in tolerance to alloantigens

Immune response and suppressor cell activity of CBA (H-2k) mice made tolerant to allogeneic C57B1/6 (H-2b) heart graft were studied in graft-versus-graft reaction (GvGR). Intact CBA spleen cells inhibited response of (CBA X C57B1/6)F1 cells to antigenic stimulus (sheep red blood cells--SRBC), when injected together into lethally irradiated (CBA X C57B1/6)F1 mice. Spleen cells of tolerant mice were unable to decrease immune response of (CBA X C57B1/6F1 lymphocytes to SRBC and suppressed specifically the inhibition induced by intact CBA spleen cells. Spleen cells from tolerant mice were also capable of suppressing GvGR induced by CBA lymphocytes immune to C57B1/6 cells. Pretreatment of tolerant spleen cells with rabbit antithymocyte globulin and complement before adoptive transfer diminished markedly the suppression. The results obtained in the study suggest that suppression of transplantation immunity in this model is mostly due to T suppressor cells.     

Cellular events in tolerance. VII. Decrease in tolerant spleens of PFC precursors stimulated in vitro by specific antigen or mitogen.

Spleen cells from adult mice rendered tolerant to the fluorescein (FL) hapten (as FL-sheep γ-globulin) were analyzed at limiting dilution for the numbers of precursors stimulatable either by specific antigen (FL-polymerized flagellin; FL-POL) or by a polyclonal B-cell activator (E. coli lipopolysaccharide; LPS). As expected, the number of PFC presursors activated by FL-POL was reduced more than fourfold in the spleens of FL-tolerant mice compared to normal controls. In contrast, LPS was able to trigger equivalent numbers of “FL-specific” PFC precursors in both normal and tolerant spleens. However, the clones stimulated by LPS were predominantly the “low-avidity” precursors in FL-tolerant spleens as shown by plaque inhibition studies. In addition, after FL-gelatin enrichment of normal or tolerant spleen cells, which contain equal numbers of antigen-binding cells, we found that purified cells from tolerant mice were in fact reduced in the numbers of clonable precursors upon LPS stimulation. Two other B-cell mitogens, POL and PPD, also failed to activate PFC precursors from FL-gelatin-purified tolerant spleen cells. Our results suggest that some high-avidity clones may be functionally deleted even in adult B-cell tolerance as previously noted for neonatal tolerance.     

Transplantation tolerance at the T-lymphocyte receptor level. I. Spontaneous release of T-cell receptors by lymphocytes from tolerant mice.

Spleen and lymph node T cells from CBA mice when cultivated in vitro almost immediately started to shed receptors for A alloantigens. In contrast, cultivated T lymphocytes from CBA mice tolerant of A alloantigens for 657 or 692 days began releasing receptors for the formerly tolerated A alloantigen after a delay of 8 h. This delay in receptor shedding coincided with that observed when nontolerant lymphocytes were treated with antisera to T-cell receptors. The results suggested a close similarity of mechanisms and indicated that transplantation tolerance may be maintained by active suppression of otherwise reactive T cells mediated by anti-receptor antibody. Lymphocytes from untreated tolerant mice and those treated with a nonspecific anti-receptor serum showed normal responses, as measured in terms of receptor release, to third-party alloantigens, as did cells from untreated normal mice. Precultivated normal lymphocytes treated with anti-receptor antibody and complement failed to release the appropriate receptor specificity but similarly treated tolerant lymphocytes were almost resistant, presumably because they expressed only few receptors at the time of treatments.     

Tolerance and contact sensitivity to DNFB in mice. VI. Inhibition of afferent sensitivity by suppressor T cells in adoptive tolerance.

Tolerance in contact sensitivity to DNFB can be adoptively transferred to normal mice with lymph node cells from tolerant donors. This tolerance is antigen specific and is mediated by T cells, i.e., "suppressor" T cells. Experiments were carried out to investigate the mechanism(s) by which the suppressor T cells induce tolerance to DNFB contact sensitivity. The suppressor cells were effective only if they were present during the early stages of the afferent limb of sensitization. As measured by DNA synthesis, cell proliferation in the draining lymph nodes of recipients of suppressor cells was found to be significantly less than in control animals indicating that the suppressor cells acted, at least in part, by limiting or inhibiting DNFB-induced cell proliferation. This inhibition was shown to be antigen specific since the DNFB suppressor cells did not inhibit cell proliferation induced by oxazolone, an unrelated contact sensitizer. The ability to DNFB tolerant cells to block afferent sensitization pathways differs from the mechanism of tolerance to picryl chloride, reported by others, where efferent pathways are blocked.     

Direct demonstration of specific suppressor T cells in the mice tolerant to type III pneumococcal polysaccharide: two-step requirement for development of detectable suppressor cells

Spleen cells from CAF1 mice made tolerant to type III pneumococcal polysaccharide (S3) with S3 coupled to syngeneic spleen cells (S3-SC) develop S3-specific suppressor T cells (Ts). These Ts could be demonstrated consistently only when spleen cells from tolerant mice were cultured in vitro with the specific antigen and the specific tolerogen. Spleen cells from normal mice cultured under the same conditions did not suppress the antibody response to S3. When different numbers of Ts were transferred to normal CAF1 mice, an unusual dose-effect pattern was observed. Maximal suppression of the S3 response occurred when relatively low numbers of Ts, 3 to 30 x 10(5) per recipient, were transferred, whereas larger numbers of cells, 150 x 10(5) per recipient, were not suppressive. These results indicate that a presumably T-independent antigen, S3, can activate antigen-specific Ts. These Ts exhibit unusual dose effects upon transfer and require both an in vivo induction period and in vitro activation for development of maximal activity. These latter observations suggest that S3 may activate a different population of T cells with suppressor function than do conventional T-dependent antigens. The loss of suppression observed when greater than optimal numbers of cells were transferred suggests that a second type of T cell, which has the ability to 'neutralize' the activity of S3-specific Ts, is also induced in the same spleen cell population.     

Role of self carriers in the immune response and tolerance. IV. Active T cell suppression in the maintenance of B cell tolerance to a "T-independent" antigen.

Previous studies indicated that T cells are required for tolerance induction by hapten-modified syngeneic spleen cells (TNP-SC) in vivo. The role of T cells in the maintenance of this unresponsive state has been examined herein. By three criteria--limiting dilution precursor analysis, removal of T cells by anti-Thy-1 + C, and direct mixing experiments--we show that T cells are required for the continued suppression of the B cell response to the T-independent antigen, TNP-POL. Suppressor cells can also be induced by TNP-teratoma cells, which lack detectable H-2 antigens. Both anti-Ly-1 + C and anti-Ly-2 + C treatment reversed suppression induced by TNP-SC. These results demonstrate that normal B cell reactivity is present in the spleens of mice rendered tolerant by haptenated self, but that Ly-1,2,3 or Ly-1 + Ly-2,3 suppressor T cells prevent their responsiveness.     

Induction of immunological tolerance against sheep red blood cells in A/J mice by maternal immunization

Female A/J mice were immunized with sheep red blood cells (SRBC) before mating and boosted a few days before delivery. The progeny of these mothers was immunologically tolerant against SRBC at the level of plaque forming cells (PFC). The state of unresponsiveness was antigen specific. Exchange of the newborn mice between control mothers and immunized ones shows clearly that the tolerance is induced by factors present in the milk or the colostrum, respectively. Some others findings suggest that antibodies of the mothers and not small amounts of the injected antigen are responsible for the nearly complete suppression of the immune response of the offspring.     

Defective B-cell tolerance in New Zealand black mice. Fc receptor-independence of resistance to low-epitope-density tolerogens

Trinitrophenyl (TNP) human gamma-globulin with low-epitope-density tolerizes B cells from normal BDF1 mice in a Fc gamma receptor-dependent manner but does not tolerize B cells from preautoimmune NZB mice. In order to investigate the relationships between tolerance induction and epitope density independently of Fc gamma receptor function in these two strains, TNP conjugates of two additional thymic-independent tolerogenic carriers, D-glutamic acid-D-lysine (D-GL) and carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC), were tested. A brief pulse with low-epitope-density conjugates such as TNP4.4-D-GL rendered unfractionated or T-cell-depleted spleen cells from BDF1 but not NZB mice tolerant in a hapten-specific manner. Spleen cells from NZB mice, however, were susceptible to tolerization with TNP13.5-D-GL. NZB mice were also resistant to tolerance induction in vivo with TNP5.5-D-GL, TNP3-CMC, and TNP6-CMC, all of which tolerize BDF1 mice in vivo. Both strains were tolerized with TNP13.5-D-GL and TNP13-CMC in vivo. NZB mice were also significantly less susceptible to tolerance induction with TNP3-CMC when TNP-Ficoll was substituted for TNP Brucella abortus as the challenge antigen. These findings militate against the possibility that an Fc gamma receptor defect is the principal mechanism of resistance of NZB B cells to tolerance induction with-low-epitope density conjugates.     

Thymus dependency of neonatal tolerance induction in the absence of detectable suppressor cells

Neonatal thymectomy prevents tolerance induction with bovine serum albumin (BSA) in Wistar Furth (WF) rats whose thymus-derived (T) cell deficit is reconstituted with adult nonadherent peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL). Sham-thymectomized (STx) rats given PBL become tolerant. To establish whether the adult T cells become tolerant in STx rats, their carrier-reactivity was studied in a cooperative immune response following challenge with methylated BSA (mBSA). The results indicate that carrier-reactive cells, derived from PBL, do become tolerant of BSA in the presence, but not in the absence, of the thymus. To determine whether thymic function during tolerance induction is mediated by suppressor T cells, attempts were made to replace the thymus with various populations of thymocytes or lymphoid cells from neonatal or adult normal rats or neonatal BSA-injected rats. No cell population tried could substitute for the thymus during tolerance induction. In addition, it was found that BSA-tolerant rats with intact thymi do not contain either nonspecific suppressor cells whose activity can be boosted with mBSA or specific suppressor activity demonstrable on transfer to normal rats. Timed thymectomy experiments showed that the thymus is required for more than 2, but less than 5 to 7 days after tolerogen injection for significant tolerance induction. These results imply that the thymus itself is necessary for tolerance induction in a peripheral T-cell population and that its effect is not mediated by suppressor cells. It is suggested that peripheral T helper cells may periodically recirculate through the thymus, at least in young rats, and become tolerant of antigen complexed with Ia antigens in the thymic epithelium. Such a mechanism may be of great importance in the development of self-recognition.     

Antigen recognition and IL-2 receptor gene expression as evidence against clonal deletion in mice with neonatally induced transplantation tolerance.

Neonatal transplantation tolerance was induced in B10.A mice by the injection of spleen and bone marrow cells from semiallogeneic [C57BL/10(B10) x B10.A] F1 donors. The neonatally treated mice accepted skin grafts from B10 donors. Spleen cells from tolerant animals did not respond by proliferation to tolerated B10 antigens in vitro. However, spleen cells from tolerant mice recognized specific (B10) antigens and synthesized mRNA for the inducible 55-kDa interleukin-2 receptor (IL-2R) as did cells from normal animals. Maintenance of this early phase of cell activation upon contact with tolerated antigens is direct evidence against clonal deletion as a mechanism, in this particular model of neonatally induced transplantation tolerance.