Strand antagonism in RNAi: an explanation of differences in potency between intracellularly expressed siRNA and shRNA

Strategies to regulate gene function frequently use small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) that can be made from their shRNA precursors via Dicer. However, when the duplex components of these siRNA effectors are expressed from their respective coding genes, the RNA interference (RNAi) activity is much reduced. Here, we explored the mechanisms of action of shRNA and siRNA and found the expressed siRNA, in contrast to short hairpin RNA (shRNA), exhibits strong strand antagonism, with the sense RNA negatively and unexpectedly regulating RNAi. Therefore, we altered the relative levels of strands of siRNA duplexes during their expression, increasing the level of the antisense component, reducing the level of the sense component, or both and, in this way we were able to enhance the potency of the siRNA. Such vector-delivered siRNA attacked its target effectively. These findings provide new insight into RNAi and, in particular, they demonstrate that strand antagonism is responsible for making siRNA far less potent than shRNA.     

Functional and intracellular localization properties of U6 promoter-expressed siRNAs, shRNAs, and chimeric VA1 shRNAs in mammalian cells

RNA polymerase III (Pol III) expression systems for short hairpin RNAs (U6 shRNAs or chimeric VA1 shRNAs) or individually expressed sense/antisense small interfering RNA (siRNA) strands have been used to trigger RNA interference (RNAi) in mammalian cells. Here we show that individually expressed siRNA expression constructs produce 21-nucleotide siRNAs that strongly accumulate as duplex siRNAs in the nucleus of human cells, exerting sequence-specific silencing activity similar to cytoplasmic siRNAs derived from U6 or VA1-expressed hairpin precursors. In contrast, 29-mer siRNAs separately expressed as sense/antisense strands fail to elicit RNAi activity, despite accumulation of these RNAs in the nucleus. Our findings delineate different intracellular accumulation patterns for the three expression strategies and suggest the possibility of a nuclear RNAi pathway that requires 21-mer duplexes.     

siRNA function in RNAi: a chemical modification analysis

Various chemical modifications were created in short-interfering RNAs (siRNAs) to determine the biochemical properties required for RNA interference (RNAi). Remarkably, modifications at the 2'-position of pentose sugars in siRNAs showed the 2'-OHs were not required for RNAi, indicating that RNAi machinery does not require the 2'-OH for recognition of siRNAs and catalytic ribonuclease activity of RNA-induced silencing complexes (RISCs) does not involve the 2'-OH of guide antisense RNA. In addition, 2' modifications predicted to stabilize siRNA increased the persistence of RNAi as compared with wild-type siRNAs. RNAi was also induced with chemical modifications that stabilized interactions between A-U base pairs, demonstrating that these types of modifications may enhance mRNA targeting efficiency in allele-specific RNAi. Modifications altering the structure of the A-form major groove of antisense siRNA-mRNA duplexes abolished RNAi, suggesting that the major groove of these duplexes was required for recognition by activated RISC*. Comparative analysis of the stability and RNAi activities of chemically modified single-stranded antisense RNA and duplex siRNA suggested that some catalytic mechanism(s) other than siRNA stability were linked to RNAi efficiency. Modified or mismatched ribonucleotides incorporated at internal positions in the 5' or 3' half of the siRNA duplex, as defined by the antisense strand, indicated that the integrity of the 5' and not the 3' half of the siRNA structure was important for RNAi, highlighting the asymmetric nature of siRNA recognition for initiation of unwinding. Collectively, this study defines the mechanisms of RNAi in human cells and provides new rules for designing effective and stable siRNAs for RNAi-mediated gene-silencing applications.     

Both Strands of siRNA Have Potential to Guide Posttranscriptional Gene Silencing in Mammalian Cells

Despite the widespread application of RNA interference (RNAi) as a research tool for diverse purposes, the key step of strand selection of siRNAs during the formation of RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC) remains poorly understood. Here, using siRNAs targeted to the complementary region of Survivin and the effector protease receptor 1 (EPR-1), we show that both strands of the siRNA duplex can find their target mRNA and are equally eligible for assembly into Argonaute 2 (Ago2) of RISC in HEK293 cells. Transfection of the synthetic siRNA duplexes with different thermodynamic profiles or short hairpin RNA (shRNA) vectors that generate double-stranded RNAs (dsRNAs), permitting processing specifically from either the 5′ or 3′ end of the incipient siRNA, results in the degradation of the respective target mRNAs of either strand of the siRNA duplex with comparable efficiencies. Thus, while most RNAi reactions may follow the thermodynamic asymmetry rule in strand selection, our study suggests an exceptional mode for certain siRNAs in which both strands of the duplex are competent in sponsoring RNAi, and implies additional factors that might dictate the RNAi targets.     

RNA interference-mediated simultaneous silencing of four genes using cross-shaped RNA

The structural flexibility of RNA interference (RNAi)-triggering nucleic acids suggests that the design of unconventional RNAi trigger structures with novel features is possible. Here, we report a cross-shaped RNA duplex structure, termed quadruple interfering RNA (qiRNA), with multiple target gene silencing activity. qiRNA triggers the simultaneous down-regulation of four cellular target genes via an RNAi mechanism. In addition, qiRNA shows enhanced intracellular delivery and target gene silencing over conventional siRNA when complexed with jetPEI, a linear polyethyleneimine (PEI). We also show that the long antisense strand of qiRNA is incorporated intact into an RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC). This novel RNA scaffold further expands the repertoire of RNAi-triggering molecular structures and could be used in the development of therapeutics for various diseases including viral infections and cancer.     

RNAi in human cells: basic structural and functional features of small interfering RNA

We investigated the mechanism of RNA interference (RNAi) in human cells. Here we demonstrate that the status of the 5' hydroxyl terminus of the antisense strand of a siRNA determines RNAi activity, while a 3' terminus block is tolerated in vivo. 5' hydroxyl termini of antisense strands isolated from human cells were phosphorylated, and 3' end biotin groups were not efficiently removed. We found no requirement for a perfect A-form helix in siRNA for interference effects, but an A-form structure was required for antisense-target RNA duplexes. Strikingly, crosslinking of the siRNA duplex by psoralen did not completely block RNA interference, indicating that complete unwinding of the siRNA helix is not necessary for RNAi activity in vivo. These results suggest that RNA amplification by RNA-dependent RNA polymerase is not essential for RNAi in human cells.     

Specific interference of urokinase-type plasminogen activator receptor and matrix metalloproteinase-9 gene expression induced by double-stranded RNA results in decreased invasion, tumor growth, and angiogenesis in gliomas

We have previously demonstrated the effectiveness of adenovirus-mediated expression of antisense urokinase-type plasminogen activator receptor (uPAR) and matrix metalloproteinase-9 (MMP-9) in inhibiting tumor invasion in vitro and ex vivo. However, the therapeutic effect of the adenovirus-mediated antisense approach was shown to be transient and required potentially toxic, high viral doses. In contrast, RNA interference (RNAi)-mediated gene targeting may be superior to the traditional antisense approach, because the target mRNA is completely degraded and the molar ratio of siRNA required to degrade the target mRNA is very low. Here, we have examined the siRNA-mediated target RNA degradation of uPAR and MMP-9 in human glioma cell lines. Using RNAi directed toward uPAR and MMP-9, we achieved specific inhibition of uPAR and MMP-9. This bicistronic construct (pUM) inhibited the formation of capillary-like structures in both in vitro and in vivo models of angiogenesis. We demonstrated that blocking the expression of these genes results in significant inhibition of glioma tumor invasion in Matrigel and spheroid invasion assay models. RNAi for uPAR and MMP-9 inhibited cell proliferation, and significantly reduced the levels of phosphorylated forms of MAPK, ERK, and AKT signaling pathway molecules when compared with parental and empty vector/scrambled vector-transfected SNB19 cells. Furthermore, using RNAi to simultaneously target two proteases resulted in total regression of pre-established intracerebral tumor growth. Our results provide evidence that the use of hairpin siRNA expression vectors for uPAR and MMP-9 may provide an effective tool for cancer therapy.     

Effect of target secondary structure on RNAi efficiency

RNA interference (RNAi) mediated by small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) or short hairpin RNAs (shRNAs) has become a powerful tool for gene knockdown studies. However, the levels of knockdown vary greatly. Here, we examine the effect of target disruption energy, a novel measure of target accessibility, along with other parameters that may affect RNAi efficiency. Based on target secondary structures predicted by the Sfold program, the target disruption energy represents the free energy cost for local alteration of the target structure to allow target binding by the siRNA guide strand. In analyses of 100 siRNAs and 101 shRNAs targeted to 103 endogenous human genes, we find that the disruption energy is an important determinant of RNAi activity and the asymmetry of siRNA duplex asymmetry is important for facilitating the assembly of the RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC). We estimate that target accessibility and duplex asymmetry can improve the target knockdown level significantly by nearly 40% and 26%, respectively. In the RNAi pathway, RISC assembly precedes target binding by the siRNA guide strand. Thus, our findings suggest that duplex asymmetry has significant upstream effect on RISC assembly and target accessibility has strong downstream effect on target recognition. The results of the analyses suggest criteria for improving the design of siRNAs and shRNAs.     

Fundamental differences in the equilibrium considerations for siRNA and antisense oligodeoxynucleotide design

Both siRNA and antisense oligodeoxynucleotides (ODNs) inhibit the expression of a complementary gene. In this study, fundamental differences in the considerations for RNA interference and antisense ODNs are reported. In siRNA and antisense ODN databases, positive correlations are observed between the cost to open the mRNA target self-structure and the stability of the duplex to be formed, meaning the sites along the mRNA target with highest potential to form strong duplexes with antisense strands also have the greatest tendency to be involved in pre-existing structure. Efficient siRNA have less stable siRNA–target duplex stability than inefficient siRNA, but the opposite is true for antisense ODNs. It is, therefore, more difficult to avoid target self-structure in antisense ODN design. Self-structure stabilities of oligonucleotide and target correlate to the silencing efficacy of siRNA. Oligonucleotide self-structure correlations to efficacy of antisense ODNs, conversely, are insignificant. Furthermore, self-structure in the target appears to correlate with antisense ODN efficacy, but such that more effective antisense ODNs appear to target mRNA regions with greater self-structure. Therefore, different criteria are suggested for the design of efficient siRNA and antisense ODNs and the design of antisense ODNs is more challenging.     

Improvements in siRNA properties mediated by 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro-beta-D-arabinonucleic acid (FANA)

RNA interference (RNAi) has emerged recently as an efficient mechanism for specific gene silencing. Short double-stranded small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) are now widely used for cellular or drug target validation; however, their use for silencing clinically relevant genes in a therapeutic setting remains problematic because of their unfavourable metabolic stability and pharmacokinetic properties. To address some of these concerns, we have investigated the properties of siRNA modified with 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro-beta-d-arabinonucleotide units (araF-N or FANA units). Here we provide evidence that these modified siRNAs are compatible with the intracellular RNAi machinery and can mediate specific degradation of target mRNA. We also show that the incorporation of FANA units into siRNA duplexes increases activity and substantially enhances serum stability of the siRNA. A fully modified sense 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro-beta-D-arabinonucleic acid (FANA) strand when hybridized to an antisense RNA (i.e. FANA/RNA hybrid) was shown to be 4-fold more potent and had longer half-life in serum (approximately 6 h) compared with an unmodified siRNA (<15 min). While incorporation of FANA units is well tolerated throughout the sense strand of the duplex, modifications can also be included at the 5' or 3' ends of the antisense strand, in striking contrast to other commonly used chemical modifications. Taken together, these results offer preliminary evidence of the therapeutic potential of FANA modified siRNAs.     

Uncoupling of RNAi from active translation in mammalian cells

Small inhibitory RNAs (siRNAs) are produced from longer RNA duplexes by the RNAse III family member Dicer. The siRNAs function as sequence-specific guides for RNA cleavage or translational inhibition. The precise mechanism by which siRNAs direct the RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC) to find the complementary target mRNA remains a mystery. Some biochemical evidence connects RNAi with translation making attractive the hypothesis that RISC is coupled with the translational apparatus for scanning mRNAs. Such coupling would facilitate rapid alignment of the siRNA antisense with the complementary target sequence. To test this hypothesis we took advantage of a well-characterized translational switch afforded by the ferritin IRE-IRP to analyze RNAi mediated cleavage of a target mRNA in the presence and absence of translation. Our results demonstrate that neither active translation nor unidirectional scanning is required for siRNA mediated target degradation. Our findings demonstrate that nontranslated mRNAs are highly susceptible to RNAi, and blocking scanning from both the 5' and 3' ends of an mRNA does not impede RNAi. Interestingly, RNAi is about threefold more active in the absence of translation.     

Local RNA target structure influences siRNA efficacy: systematic analysis of intentionally designed binding regions

Contradictory reports in the literature have emphasised either the sequence of small interfering RNAs (siRNA) or the structure of their target molecules to be the major determinant of the efficiency of RNA interference (RNAi) approaches. In the present study, we analyse systematically the contributions of these parameters to siRNA activity by using deliberately designed mRNA constructs. The siRNA target sites were included in well-defined structural elements rendering them either highly accessible or completely involved in stable base-pairing. Furthermore, complementary sequence elements and various hairpins with different stem lengths and designs were used as target sites. Only one of the strands of the siRNA duplex was found to be capable of silencing via its respective target site, indicating that thermodynamic characteristics intrinsic to the siRNA strands are a basic determinant of siRNA activity. A significant obstruction of gene silencing by the same siRNA, however, was observed to be caused by structural features of the substrate RNA. Bioinformatic analysis of the mRNA structures suggests a direct correlation between the extent of gene-knockdown and the local free energy in the target region. Our findings indicate that, although a favourable siRNA sequence is a necessary prerequisite for efficient RNAi, complex target structures may limit the applicability even of carefully chosen siRNAs.     

Inhibition of genes expression of SARS coronavirus by synthetic small interfering RNAs

RNA interference (RNAi) is triggered by the presence of a double-stranded RNA (dsRNA), and results in the silencing of homologous gene expression through the specific degradation of an mRNA containing the same sequence, dsRNAmediated RNAi can be used in a wide variety of eucaryotes to induce the sequence-specific inhibition of gene expression.Synthetic 21-23 nucleotide (nt) small interfering RNA (siRNA) with 2 nt 3‘ overhangs was recently found to mediate efficient sequence-specific mRNA degradation in mammalian cells. Here, we studied the effects of synthetic siRNA duplexes targeted to SARS coronavirus structural proteins E, M, and N in a cell culture system. Among total 26 siRNAduplexes, we obtained 3 siRNA duplexes which could sequence-specifically reduce target genes expression over 80% at the concentration of 60 nM in Vero E6 cells. The downregulation effect was in correlation with the concentrations of the siRNA duplexes in a range of 0-450 nM. Our results also showed that many inactive siRNA duplexes may be brought to life simply by unpairing the 5‘ end of the antisense strands. Results suggest that siRNA is capable of inhibiting SARS coronavirus genes expression and thus may be a new therapeutic strategy for treatment of SARS.     

鸡传染性支气管炎病毒的RNA干扰

为探讨短的双链RNA(siRNA)对鸡传染性支气管炎病毒(IBV)增殖的干扰作用,利用软件设计siRNA1280个,75%位于Pol基因内。通过同源比较和保守性分析,筛选到针对Pol、M、N基因的12个siRNA(每个基因3～4个)作为后选目的片段,分别在Vero细胞、9日龄SPF鸡胚上进行基因干扰试验。结果,来自Pol、N靶序列的2个siRNA在Vero细胞上及鸡胚上均对IBV增殖产生明显的干扰作用,并与siRNA剂量有一定相关性,依赖于与mRNA互补的负链siRNA存在。本研究首次证实IBV增殖过程中存在siRNA干扰现象,为利用RNA干扰(RNAi)技术控制IBV提供了新手段。     

Influence of assembly of siRNA elements into RNA-induced silencing complex by fork-siRNA duplex carrying nucleotide mismatches at the 3'- or 5'-end of the sense-stranded siRNA element

RNA interference (RNAi) is a powerful method for suppressing the expression of a gene of interest, and can be induced by 21-25 nucleotide small interfering RNA (siRNA) duplexes homologous to the silenced gene, which function as sequence-specific RNAi mediators in RNA-induced silencing complexes (RISCs). In the previous study, it was shown that fork-siRNA duplexes, whose sense-stranded siRNA elements carried a few nucleotide mismatches at the 3'-ends against the antisense-stranded siRNA elements, could enhance RNAi activity more than conventional siRNA duplexes in cultured mammalian cells. In this study, we further characterized fork-siRNA duplexes using reporter plasmids carrying target sequences complementary to the sense- or antisense-stranded siRNA elements in the untranslated region of Renilla luciferase. The data presented here suggest that nucleotide mismatches at either the 3'- or 5'-end of the sense-stranded siRNA elements in fork-siRNA duplexes could influence assembly of not only the antisense-stranded siRNA elements but also the sense-stranded elements into RISCs. In addition, we further suggest the possibility that there could be a positional effect of siRNA duplex on RNAi activity.     

A systematic analysis of the silencing effects of an active siRNA at all single-nucleotide mismatched target sites

The specificity of small interfering RNA (siRNA)-mediated gene silencing is a critical consideration for the application of RNA interference (RNAi). While the discovery of potential off-target effects by siRNAs is of concern, no systematic analysis has been conducted to explore the specificity of RNAi. Here, we present a study where a functionally validated siRNA (siCD46) was examined for silencing specificity on all possible 57 permutated target sites, each carrying a single-nucleotide mutation that would generate a mismatch when paired with siRNA antisense strand. We found that it was not only the position of the mismatched base pair, but also the identity of the nucleotides forming the mismatch that influenced silencing. Surprisingly, mismatches formed between adenine (A) and cytosine (C), in addition to the G:U wobble base pair, were well tolerated and target sites containing such mismatches were silenced almost as efficiently as its fully matched counterpart by siCD46. Northern blots showed that the silencing of fusion genes harboring the mutated target sites involved target mRNA degradation. This study provides direct evidence that the target recognition of siRNA is far more degenerative than previously considered. This finding is instrumental in the understanding of RNAi specificity and may aid the computational prediction of RNA secondary structure.     

ATP requirements and small interfering RNA structure in the RNA interference pathway.

We examined the role of ATP in the RNA interference (RNAi) pathway. Our data reveal two ATP-dependent steps and suggest that the RNAi reaction comprises at least four sequential steps: ATP-dependent processing of double-stranded RNA into small interfering RNAs (siRNAs), incorporation of siRNAs into an inactive approximately 360 kDa protein/RNA complex, ATP-dependent unwinding of the siRNA duplex to generate an active complex, and ATP-independent recognition and cleavage of the RNA target. Furthermore, ATP is used to maintain 5' phosphates on siRNAs. A 5' phosphate on the target-complementary strand of the siRNA duplex is required for siRNA function, suggesting that cells check the authenticity of siRNAs and license only bona fide siRNAs to direct target RNA destruction.     

Sequence,chemical, and structural variation of small interfering RNAs and short hairpin RNAs and the effect on mammalian gene silencing

Small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) induce sequence-specific gene silencing in mammalian cells and guide mRNA degradation in the process of RNA interference (RNAi). By targeting endogenous lamin A/C mRNA in human HeLa or mouse SW3T3 cells, we investigated the positional variation of siRNA-mediated gene silencing. We find cell-type-dependent global effects and cell-type-independent positional effects. HeLa cells were about 2-fold more responsive to siRNAs than SW3T3 cells but displayed a very similar pattern of positional variation of lamin A/C silencing. In HeLa cells, 26 of 44 tested standard 21-nucleotide (nt) siRNA duplexes reduced the protein expression by at least 90%, and only 2 duplexes reduced the lamin A/C proteins to <50%. Fluorescent chromophores did not perturb gene silencing when conjugated to the 5'-end or 3'-end of the sense siRNA strand and the 5'-end of the antisense siRNA strand, but conjugation to the 3'-end of the antisense siRNA abolished gene silencing. RNase-protecting phosphorothioate and 2'-fluoropyrimidine RNA backbone modifications of siRNAs did not significantly affect silencing efficiency, although cytotoxic effects were observed when every second phosphate of an siRNA duplex was replaced by phosphorothioate. Synthetic RNA hairpin loops were subsequently evaluated for lamin A/C silencing as a function of stem length and loop composition. As long as the 5'-end of the guide strand coincided with the 5'-end of the hairpin RNA, 19-29 base pair (bp) hairpins effectively silenced lamin A/C, but when the hairpin started with the 5'-end of the sense strand, only 21-29 bp hairpins were highly active.