Substrate ground state binding energy concentration is realized as transition state stabilization in physiological enzyme catalysis

Previously published kinetic data on the interactions of seventeen different enzymes with their physiological substrates are re-examined in order to understand the connection between ground state binding energy and transition state stabilization of the enzyme-catalyzed reactions. When the substrate ground state binding energies are normalized by the substrate molar volumes, binding of the substrate to the enzyme active site may be thought of as an energy concentration interaction; that is, binding of the substrate ground state brings in a certain concentration of energy. When kinetic data of the enzyme/substrate interactions are analyzed from this point of view, the following relationships are discovered: 1) smaller substrates possess more binding energy concentrations than do larger substrates with the effect dropping off exponentially, 2) larger enzymes (relative to substrate size) bind both the ground and transition states more tightly than smaller enzymes, and 3) high substrate ground state binding energy concentration is associated with greater reaction transition state stabilization. It is proposed that these observations are inconsistent with the conventional (Haldane) view of enzyme catalysis and are better reconciled with the shifting specificity model for enzyme catalysis.     

Thermodynamic and extrathermodynamic requirements of enzyme catalysis

An enzyme's affinity for the altered substrate in the transition state (symbolized here as S) matches the value of k(cat)/K(m) divided by the rate constant for the uncatalyzed reaction in water. The validity of this relationship is not affected by the detailed mechanism by which any particular enzyme may act, or on whether changes in enzyme conformation occur on the path to the transition state. It subsumes potential effects of substrate desolvation, H-bonding and other polar attractions, and the juxtaposition of several substrates in a configuration appropriate for reaction. The startling rate enhancements that some enzymes produce have only recently been recognized. Direct measurements of the binding affinities of stable transition-state analog inhibitors confirm the remarkable power of binding discrimination of enzymes. Several parts of the enzyme and substrate, that contribute to S binding, exhibit extremely large connectivity effects, with effective relative concentrations in excess of 10(8) M. Exact structures of enzyme complexes with transition-state analogs also indicate a general tendency of enzyme active sites to close around S in such a way as to maximize binding contacts. The role of solvent water in these binding equilibria, for which Walter Kauzmann provided a primer, is only beginning to be appreciated.     

An aspartate transcarbamylase lacking catalytic subunit interactions. Study of conformational changes by ultraviolet absorbance and circular dichroism spectroscopy.

A modified form of aspartate transcarbamylase is synthesized by Escherichia coli in the presence of 2-thiouracil which does not exhibit homotropic cooperative interactions between active sites yet retains heterotropic cooperative interactions due to nucleotide binding. The conformational changes induced in the modified enzyme by the binding of different ligands (substrates, substrate analogs, a transition state analog, and nucleotide effectors) were studied using ultraviolet absorbance and circular dichroism difference spectroscopy. Comparison of the results for the modified enzyme and its isolated subunits to those for the native enzyme and its isolated subunits showed that the conformational changes detected by these methods are qualitatively similar in the two enzymes. Comparison of the absorbance difference spectra due to the binding of a transition substrate analog to the intact native or modified enzymes to the corresponding results for the isolated subunits suggested that ligand binding causes an increased exposure to solvent of certain tyrosyl and phenylalanyl residues in the intact enzymes but not in the isolated subunits. This result is consistent with a diminution of subunit contacts due to substrate binding in the course of homotropic interactions in the native enzyme. Such conformational changes, though perhaps necessary for homotropic cooperativity, are not sufficient to cause homotropic cooperativity since the modified enzyme gave identical perturbations. Interactions of the transition state analog, N-(phosphonacetyl)-L-aspartate, with the modified enzyme were studied. Enzyme kinetic data obtained at low aspartate concentrations showed that this transition state analog does not stimulate activity, but rather exhibits the inhibition predicted for the total absence of homotropic cooperative interactions in the modified enzyme. Spectrophotometric titrations of the number of catalytic sites with the transition state analog showed that the modified enzyme and its isolated subunits possess, respectively, four and two high affinity sites for the inhibitor instead of six and three observed in the case of the normal enzyme and its isolated catalytic subunits. These results are correlated with the lower specific enzymatic activities of the modified enzyme and its catalytic subunits compared to the normal corresponding enzymatic species.     

Kinetic consequences of a slow substrate binding step in group transferases. Interpretation of product inhibition experiments.

The steady state kinetic properties of a simple model for an enzyme catalyzed group transfer reaction between two substrates have been calculated. One substrate is assumed to bind slowly and the other rapidly to the enzyme. Apparent substrate inhibition or substrate activation by the rapidly binding substrate may result if the slowly binding substrate binds at unequal rates to the free enzyme and to the complex between the enzyme and the rapidly binding substrate. Competitive inhibition by each product with respect to its structurally analogous substrate is to be expected if both substrates are in rapid equilibrium with their enzyme-substrate complexes. This product inhibition pattern, however, may also be observed when one substrate binds slowly. Noncompetitive inhibition with respect to the rapidly binding substrate by its structurally analogous product may result if the slowly binding substrate binds more slowly to the enzyme-product complex than to the free enzyme. Inhibition by substrate analogs which are not products should follow the same rules as inhibition by products. Thus substrate analog inhibition experiments are not particularly informative. The form of inhibition by "transition state analog" inhibitors should reveal which substrate binds slowly. There is no sharp conceptual distinction between ordered and random "kinetic mechanisms". I therefore suggest that the use of these concepts should be abandoned.     

Conformational aspects of inhibitor design: enzyme-substrate interactions in the transition state.

The theory of absolute reaction rates suggests that enzymes, like other catalysts, can enhance the rate of a reaction only to the extent that they bind the altered substrate in the transition state (S++) more tightly than they bind the substrate in the ground state (S). ES dissociation constants commonly fall in the physiological range, but recent kinetic studies indicate that formal ES++ dissociation constants of less than 10(-20) M are achieved by enzymes of several classes. Studies with stable analogues suggest that these remarkable powers of discrimination involve a tendency of the enzyme to close around S++ in such a way as to maximize binding contacts; that several parts of the substrate contribute to S++ binding; and that their contributions to binding affinity can be strongly synergistic.     

Subunit interactions in enzyme transition states--antagonism between substrate binding and reaction rate

The principles of structural kinetics as applied to polymeric enzymes have been reinvestigated in order to take account of the probable existence of subunit interactions in the enzyme transition states. On the basis of simple and plausible postulates, structural rate equations have been derived for dimeric enzymes and compared to substrate binding isotherms. It then becomes possible to understand how subunit interactions affect substrate affinity and enzyme reaction rate. There exists an antagonism between substrate binding to the enzyme and the steady state rate of product appearance. If subunit interactions increase the rate of product appearance, they decrease the fractional saturation of the enzyme by the substrate. Alternatively, if they decrease the reaction velocity they increase the fractional saturation. This seemingly paradoxical effect is the direct consequence of subunit interactions occurring in both the ground and the transition states.     

Interrogating the mechanism of a tight binding inhibitor of AIR carboxylase

The enzyme aminoimidazole ribonucleotide (AIR) carboxylase catalyzes the synthesis of the purine intermediate, 4-carboxy-5-aminoimidazole ribonucleotide (CAIR). Previously, we have shown that the compound 4-nitro-5-aminoimidazole ribonucleotide (NAIR) is a slow, tight binding inhibitor of the enzyme with a Ki of 0.34 nM. The structural attributes and the slow, tight binding characteristics of NAIR implicated this compound as a transition state or reactive intermediate analog. However, it is unclear what molecular features of NAIR contribute to the mimetic properties for either of the two proposed mechanisms of AIR carboxylase. In order to gain additional information regarding the mechanism for the potent inhibition of AIR carboxylase by NAIR, a series of heterocyclic analogs were prepared and evaluated. We find that all compounds are weaker inhibitors than NAIR and that CAIR analogs are not alternative substrates for the enzyme. Surprisingly, rather subtle changes in the structure of NAIR can lead to profound changes in binding affinity. Computational investigations of enzyme intermediates and these inhibitors reveal that NAIR displays an electrostatic potential surface similar to a proposed reaction intermediate. The result indicates that AIR carboxylase is likely sensitive to the electrostatic surface of reaction intermediates and thus compounds which mimic these surfaces should possess tight binding characteristics. Given the evolutionary relationship between AIR carboxylase and N⁵-CAIR mutase, we believe that this concept extends to the mutase enzyme as well. The implications of this hypothesis for the design of selective inhibitors of the N⁵-CAIR mutase are discussed.     

Temperature effects on the catalytic efficiency, rate enhancement, and transition state affinity of cytidine deaminase, and the thermodynamic consequences for catalysis of removing a substrate "anchor"

To obtain a clearer understanding of the forces involved in transition state stabilization by Escherichia coli cytidine deaminase, we investigated the thermodynamic changes that accompany substrate binding in the ground state and transition state for substrate hydrolysis. Viscosity studies indicate that the action of cytidine deaminase is not diffusion-limited. Thus, K(m) appears to be a true dissociation constant, and k(cat) describes the chemical reaction of the ES complex, not product release. Enzyme-substrate association is accompanied by a loss of entropy and a somewhat greater release of enthalpy. As the ES complex proceeds to the transition state (ES), there is little further change in entropy, but heat is taken up that almost matches the heat that was released with ES formation. As a result, k(cat)/K(m) (describing the overall conversion of the free substrate to ES is almost invariant with changing temperature. The free energy barrier for the enzyme-catalyzed reaction (k(cat)/K(m)) is much lower than that for the spontaneous reaction (k(non)) (DeltaDeltaG = -21.8 kcal/mol at 25 degrees C). This difference, which also describes the virtual binding affinity of the enzyme for the activated substrate in the transition state (S), is almost entirely enthalpic in origin (DeltaDeltaH = -20.2 kcal/mol), compatible with the formation of hydrogen bonds that stabilize the ES complex. Thus, the transition state affinity of cytidine deaminase increases rapidly with decreasing temperature. When a hydrogen bond between Glu-91 and the 3'-hydroxyl moiety of cytidine is disrupted by truncation of either group, k(cat)/K(m) and transition state affinity are each reduced by a factor of 10(4). This effect of mutation is entirely enthalpic in origin (DeltaDeltaH approximately 7.9 kcal/mol), somewhat offset by a favorable change in the entropy of transition state binding. This increase in entropy is attributed to a loss of constraints on the relative motions of the activated substrate within the ES complex. In an Appendix, some objections to the conventional scheme for transition state binding are discussed.     

Signal peptide peptidase and gamma-secretase share equivalent inhibitor binding pharmacology

The enzyme gamma-secretase has long been considered a potential pharmaceutical target for Alzheimer disease. Presenilin (the catalytic subunit of gamma-secretase) and signal peptide peptidase (SPP) are related transmembrane aspartyl proteases that cleave transmembrane substrates. SPP and gamma-secretase are pharmacologically similar in that they are targeted by many of the same small molecules, including transition state analogs, non-transition state inhibitors, and amyloid beta-peptide modulators. One difference between presenilin and SPP is that the proteolytic activity of presenilin functions only within a multisubunit complex, whereas SPP requires no additional protein cofactors for activity. In this study, gamma-secretase inhibitor radioligands were used to evaluate SPP and gamma-secretase inhibitor binding pharmacology. We found that the SPP enzyme exhibited distinct binding sites for transition state analogs, non-transition state inhibitors, and the nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug sulindac sulfide, analogous to those reported previously for gamma-secretase. In the course of this study, cultured cells were found to contain an abundance of SPP binding activity, most likely contributed by several of the SPP family proteins. The number of SPP binding sites was in excess of gamma-secretase binding sites, making it essential to use selective radioligands for evaluation of gamma-secretase binding under these conditions. This study provides further support for the idea that SPP is a useful model of inhibitory mechanisms and structure in the SPP/presenilin protein family.     

Role of protein conformational dynamics in the catalysis by 6-hydroxymethyl-7,8-dihydropterin pyrophosphokinase

Enzymatic catalysis has conflicting structural requirements of the enzyme. In order for the enzyme to form a Michaelis complex, the enzyme must be in an open conformation so that the substrate can get into its active center. On the other hand, in order to maximize the stabilization of the transition state of the enzymatic reaction, the enzyme must be in a closed conformation to maximize its interactions with the transition state. The conflicting structural requirements can be resolved by a flexible active center that can sample both open and closed conformational states. For a bisubstrate enzyme, the Michaelis complex consists of two substrates in addition to the enzyme. The enzyme must remain flexible upon the binding of the first substrate so that the second substrate can get into the active center. The active center is fully assembled and stabilized only when both substrates bind to the enzyme. However, the side-chain positions of the catalytic residues in the Michaelis complex are still not optimally aligned for the stabilization of the transition state, which lasts only approximately 10(-13) s. The instantaneous and optimal alignment of catalytic groups for the transition state stabilization requires a dynamic enzyme, not an enzyme which undergoes a large scale of movements but an enzyme which permits at least a small scale of adjustment of catalytic group positions. This review will summarize the structure, catalytic mechanism, and dynamic properties of 6-hydroxymethyl-7,8-dihydropterin pyrophosphokinase and examine the role of protein conformational dynamics in the catalysis of a bisubstrate enzymatic reaction.     

Escherichia coli serine hydroxymethyltransferase. The role of histidine 228 in determining reaction specificity.

Serine hydroxymethyltransferase has a conserved histidine residue (His-228) next to the lysine residue (Lys-229) which forms the internal aldimine with pyridoxal 5'-phosphate. This histidine residue is also conserved at the equivalent position in all amino acid decarboxylases and tryptophan synthase. Two mutant forms of Escherichia coli serine hydroxymethyltransferase, H228N and H228D, were constructed, expressed, and purified. The properties of the wild type and mutant enzymes were studied with substrates and substrate analogs by differential scanning calorimetry, circular dichroism, steady state kinetics, and rapid reaction kinetics. The conclusions of these studies were that His-228 plays an important role in the binding and reactivity of the hydroxymethyl group of serine in the one-carbon-binding site. The mutant enzymes utilize substrates and substrate analogs more effectively for a variety of alternate non-physiological reactions compared to the wild type enzyme. As one example, the mutant enzymes cleave L-serine to glycine and formaldehyde when tetrahydropyteroylglutamate is replaced by 5-formyltetrahydropteroylglutamate. The released formaldehyde inactivates these mutant enzymes. The loss of integrity of the one-carbon-binding site with L-serine in the two mutant forms of the enzyme may be the result of these enzymes not undergoing a conformational change to a closed form of the active site when serine forms the external aldimine complex.     

Studies on the Active Site of Dihydroxy-acid Dehydratase

Several classes of substrate analogs of dihydroxy-acid dehydratase have been tested as inhibitors of this enzyme in an attempt to characterize its binding site and find what modifications in substrate structure lead to an affinity higher than that of the natural substrates. The substrate analogs were tested on dihydroxy-acid dehydratase from both spinach and Escherichia coli. One modification of the substrate that led to as much as a 1000-fold increase in binding affinity was replacement of the 3-hydroxyl group with a thiol. It has been shown previously that the 3-hydroxyl group of the substrate becomes a ligand for one Fe of the Fe-S clusters of these enzymes on binding to their active sites. It seems likely then that the tighter binding of the thiol containing analogs is due to the thiol group becoming a ligand to an iron of the Fe-S clusters of these enzymes. A second modification in substrate that led to as much as 1000-fold increase in binding affinity was the addition of a large lipophilic group. This suggests there is a large hydrophobic pocket or hydrophobic surface near the active site of dihydroxy-acid dehydratase. A modification in substrate that led to as much as a 50-fold increase in binding was the replacement of the carboxyl group of the substrate with phosphonate; however, this increase was limited to substrate analogs without a polar functionality on the carbon β to the phosphonate group. Bromopyruvate was found to irreversibly inactivate dihydroxy-acid dehydratase. Each good inhibitor we found was active on spinach dihydroxy-acid dehydratase and E. coli dihydroxy-acid dehydratase to a similar extent suggesting the active sites of the enzymes from these two organisms are similar. Some of the better inhibitors described in this report have mild herbicidal activity.     

Engineering substrate preference in subtilisin: structural and kinetic analysis of a specificity mutant

Bacillus subtilisin has been a popular model protein for engineering altered substrate specificity. Although some studies have succeeded in increasing the specificity of subtilisin, they also demonstrate that high specificity is difficult to achieve solely by engineering selective substrate binding. In this paper, we analyze the structure and transient state kinetic behavior of Sbt160, a subtilisin engineered to strongly prefer substrates with phenylalanine or tyrosine at the P4 position. As in previous studies, we measure improvements in substrate affinity and overall specificity. Structural analysis of an inactive version of Sbt160 in complex with its cognate substrate reveals improved interactions at the S4 subsite with a P4 tyrosine. Comparison of transient state kinetic behavior against an optimal sequence (DFKAM) and a similar, but suboptimal, sequence (DVRAF) reveals the kinetic and thermodynamic basis for increased specificity, as well as the limitations of this approach. While highly selective substrate binding is achieved in Sbt160, several factors cause sequence specificity to fall short of that observed with natural processing subtilisins. First, for substrate sequences which are nearly optimal, the acylation reaction becomes faster than substrate dissociation. As a result, the level of discrimination among these substrates diminishes due to the coupling between substrate binding and the first chemical step (acylation). Second, although Sbt160 has 24-fold higher substrate affinity for the optimal substrate DFKAM than for DVRAF, the increased substrate binding energy is not translated into improved transition state stabilization of the acylation reaction. Finally, as interactions at subsites become stronger, the rate-determining step in peptide hydrolysis changes from acylation to product release. Thus, the release of the product becomes sluggish and leads to a low k(cat) for the reaction. This also leads to strong product inhibition of substrate turnover as the reaction progresses. The structural and kinetic analysis reveals that differences in the binding modes at subsites for substrates, transition states, and products are subtle and difficult to manipulate via straightforward protein engineering. These findings suggest several new strategies for engineering highly sequence selective enzymes.     

Transition state analogs for protocatechuate 3,4-dioxygenase. Spectroscopic and kinetic studies of the binding reactions of ketonized substrate analogs

The binding reactions of two heterocyclic analogs of protocatechuate (PCA), 2-hydroxyisonicotinic acid N-oxide and 6-hydroxynicotinic acid N-oxide, to Brevibacterium fuscum protocatechuate 3,4-dioxygenase have been characterized. These analogs were synthesized as models for the ketonized tautomer of PCA which we have previously proposed as the form which reacts with O2 in the enzyme complex (Que, L., Jr., Lipscomb, J.D., Munck, E., and Wood, J.M. (1977) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 485, 60-74). Both analogs have much higher affinity for the enzyme than PCA. Repetitive scan optical spectra of each binding reaction show that at least one intermediate is formed. The spectra of the intermediates are red-shifted (lambda max = 500 nm) relative to that of native enzyme (lambda max = 435 nm) but are similar to that of the anaerobic enzyme-PCA complex. In contrast, the spectrum of the final, deadend complex formed by each analog is significantly blue-shifted (lambda max less than 340 nm) resulting in an apparent bleaching of the chromophore of the enzyme. A transient intermediate exhibiting a similar bleached spectrum has been detected in the enzyme reaction cycle immediately after O2 is added to the enzyme-PCA complex (Bull C., Ballou D.P., and Otsuka, S. (1981) J. Biol. Chem. 256, 12681-12686). Stopped flow measurements of the analog binding reactions show that a relatively weak enzyme complex is initially formed followed by at least two isomerizations leading to the bleached, high affinity complexes. EPR spectra of both the early and final complexes reveal only high spin Fe3+ with negative zero field splitting, showing that the optical bleaching is not due to Fe reduction. The studies show that the ketonized analogs are poor models for the enzyme-substrate complex but do successfully mimic many features of the first oxy complex of the reaction cycle. We propose that substrate ketonization occurs coincident with or after O2 binding and may be involved directly in the O2 insertion reaction.     

Modulatory ATP binding affinity in intermediate states of E2P dephosphorylation of sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca2+-ATPase

The mechanism of ATP modulation of E2P dephosphorylation of sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca(2+)-ATPase wild type and mutant forms was examined in nucleotide binding studies of states analogous to the various intermediates of the dephosphorylation reaction, obtained by binding of metal fluorides, vanadate, or thapsigargin. Wild type Ca(2+)-ATPase displays an ATP affinity of 4 μM for the E2P ground state analog, 1 μM for the E2P transition state and product state analogs, and 11 μM for the E2 dephosphoenzyme. Hence, ATP binding stabilizes the transition and product states relative to the ground state, thereby explaining the accelerating effect of ATP on dephosphorylation. Replacement of Phe(487) (N-domain) with serine, Arg(560) (N-domain) with leucine, or Arg(174) (A-domain) with alanine or glutamate reduces ATP affinity in all E2/E2P intermediate states. Alanine substitution of Ile(188) (A-domain) increases the ATP affinity, although ATP acceleration of dephosphorylation is disrupted, thus indicating that the critical role of Ile(188) in ATP modulation is mechanistically based rather than being associated with the binding of nucleotide. Mutants with alanine replacement of Lys(205) (A-domain) or Glu(439) (N-domain) exhibit an anomalous inhibition by ATP of E2P dephosphorylation, due to ATP binding increasing the stability of the E2P ground state relative to the transition state. The ATP affinity of Ca(2)E2P, stabilized by inserting four glycines in the A-M1 linker, is similar to that of the E2P ground state, but the Ca(2+)-free E1 state of this mutant exhibits 3 orders of magnitude reduction of ATP affinity.     

Probing active site chemistry in SHV beta-lactamase variants at Ambler position 244. Understanding unique properties of inhibitor resistance

Inhibitor-resistant class A beta-lactamases are an emerging threat to the use of beta-lactam/beta-lactamase inhibitor combinations (e.g. amoxicillin/clavulanate) in the treatment of serious bacterial infections. In the TEM family of Class A beta-lactamases, single amino acid substitutions at Arg-244 confer resistance to clavulanate inactivation. To understand the amino acid sequence requirements in class A beta-lactamases that confer resistance to clavulanate, we performed site-saturation mutagenesis of Arg-244 in SHV-1, a related class A beta-lactamase found in Klebsiella pneumoniae. Twelve SHV enzymes with amino acid substitutions at Arg-244 resulted in significant increases in minimal inhibitory concentrations to ampicillin/clavulanate when expressed in Escherichia coli. Kinetic analyses of SHV-1, R244S, R244Q, R244L, and R244E beta-lactamases revealed that the main determinant of clavulanate resistance was reduced inhibitor affinity. In contrast to studies in the highly similar TEM enzyme, we observed increases in clavulanate k(inact) for all mutants. Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry of clavulanate inhibited SHV-1 and R244S showed nearly identical mass adducts, arguing against a difference in the inactivation mechanism. Testing a wide range of substrates with C3-4 carboxylates in different stereochemical orientations, we observed impaired affinity for all substrates among inhibitor resistant variants. Lastly, we synthesized two boronic acid transition state analogs that mimic cephalothin and found substitutions at Arg-244 markedly affect both the affinity and kinetics of binding to the chiral, deacylation transition state inhibitor. These data define a role for Arg-244 in substrate and inhibitor binding in the SHV beta-lactamase.     

Time evolution of the quaternary structure of Escherichia coli aspartate transcarbamoylase upon reaction with the natural substrates and a slow, tight-binding inhibitor

Here, we present a study of the conformational changes of the quaternary structure of Escherichia coli aspartate transcarbamoylase, as monitored by time-resolved small-angle X-ray scattering, upon combining with substrates, substrate analogs, and nucleotide effectors at temperatures between 5 and 22 °C, obviating the need for ethylene glycol. Time-resolved small-angle X-ray scattering time courses tracking the T → R structural change after mixing with substrates or substrate analogs appeared to be a single phase under some conditions and biphasic under other conditions, which we ascribe to multiple ligation states producing a time course composed of multiple rates. Increasing the concentration of substrates up to a certain point increased the T → R transition rate, with no further increase in rate beyond that point. Most strikingly, after addition of N-phosphonacetyl-l-aspartate to the enzyme, the transition rate was more than 1 order of magnitude slower than with the natural substrates. These results on the homotropic mechanism are consistent with a concerted transition between structural and functional states of either low affinity, low activity or high affinity, high activity for aspartate. Addition of ATP along with the substrates increased the rate of the transition from the T to the R state and also decreased the duration of the R-state steady-state phase. Addition of CTP or the combination of CTP/UTP to the substrates significantly decreased the rate of the T → R transition and caused a shift in the enzyme population towards the T state even at saturating substrate concentrations. These results on the heterotropic mechanism suggest a destabilization of the T state by ATP and a destabilization of the R state by CTP and CTP/UTP, consistent with the T and R state crystallographic structures of aspartate transcarbamoylase in the presence of the heterotropic effectors.     

Use of binding energy in catalysis analyzed by mutagenesis of the tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase

The utilization of enzyme-substrate binding energy in catalysis has been investigated by experiments on mutant tyrosyl-tRNA synthetases that have been generated by site-directed mutagenesis. The mutants are poorer enzymes because they lack side chains that form hydrogen bonds with ATP and tyrosine during stages of the reaction. The hydrogen bonds are not directly involved in the chemical processes but are at some distance from the seat of reaction. The free energy profiles for the formation of enzyme-bound tyrosyl adenylate and the equilibria between the substrates and products were determined from a combination of pre-steady-state kinetics and equilibrium binding methods. By comparison of the profile of each mutant with wild-type enzyme, a picture is built up of how the course of reaction is affected by the influence of each side chain on the energies of the complexes of the enzyme with substrates, transition states, and intermediates (tyrosyl adenylate). As the activation reaction proceeds, the apparent binding energies of certain side chains with the tyrosine and nucleotide moieties increase, being weakest in the enzyme-substrate complex, stronger in the transition state, and strongest in the enzyme-intermediate complex. Most marked is the interaction of Cys-35 with the 3'-hydroxyl of the ribose. Removal of the side chain of Cys-35 leads to no change in the dissociation constant of ATP but causes a 10-fold lowering of the catalytic rate constant. It contributes no net apparent binding energy in the E X Tyr X ATP complex and stabilizes the transition state by 1.2 kcal/mol and the E X Tyr-AMP complex by 1.6 kcal/mol.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Enzyme mechanism and catalytic property of beta propeller phytase

BACKGROUND: Phytases hydrolyze phytic acid (myo-inositol-hexakisphosphate) to less-phosphorylated myo-inositol derivatives and inorganic phosphate. Phytases are used in animal feed to reduce phosphate pollution in the environment. Recently, a thermostable, calcium-dependent Bacillus phytase was identified that represents the first example of the beta propeller fold exhibiting phosphatase activity. We sought to delineate the catalytic mechanism and property of this enzyme. RESULTS: The crystal structure of the enzyme in complex with inorganic phosphate reveals that two phosphates and four calcium ions are tightly bound at the active site. Mutation of the residues involved in the calcium chelation results in severe defects in the enzyme's activity. One phosphate ion, chelating all of the four calcium ions, is close to a water molecule bridging two of the bound calcium ions. Fluoride ion, which is expected to replace this water molecule, is an uncompetitive inhibitor of the enzyme. The enzyme is able to hydrolyze any of the six phosphate groups of phytate. CONCLUSIONS: The enzyme reaction is likely to proceed through a direct attack of the metal-bridging water molecule on the phosphorous atom of a substrate and the subsequent stabilization of the pentavalent transition state by the bound calcium ions. The enzyme has two phosphate binding sites, the "cleavage site", which is responsible for the hydrolysis of a substrate, and the "affinity site", which increases the binding affinity for substrates containing adjacent phosphate groups. The existence of the two nonequivalent phosphate binding sites explains the puzzling formation of the alternately dephosphorylated myo-inositol triphosphates from phytate and the hydrolysis of myo-inositol monophosphates.     

Structural basis for the altered activity of Gly794 variants of Escherichia coli beta-galactosidase

The open-closed conformational switch in the active site of Escherichia coli beta-galactosidase was studied by X-ray crystallography and enzyme kinetics. Replacement of Gly794 by alanine causes the apoenzyme to adopt the closed rather than the open conformation. Binding of the competitive inhibitor isopropyl thio-beta-D-galactoside (IPTG) requires the mutant enzyme to adopt its less favored open conformation, weakening affinity relative to wild type. In contrast, transition-state inhibitors bind to the enzyme in the closed conformation, which is favored for the mutant, and display increased affinity relative to wild type. Changes in affinity suggest that the free energy difference between the closed and open forms is 1-2 kcal/mol. By favoring the closed conformation, the substitution moves the resting state of the enzyme along the reaction coordinate relative to the native enzyme and destabilizes the ground state relative to the first transition state. The result is that the rate constant for galactosylation is increased but degalactosylation is slower. The covalent intermediate may be better stabilized than the second transition state. The substitution also results in better binding of glucose to both the free and the galactosylated enzyme. However, transgalactosylation with glucose to produce allolactose (the inducer of the lac operon) is slower with the mutant than with the native enzyme. This suggests either that the glucose is misaligned for the reaction or that the galactosylated enzyme with glucose bound is stabilized relative to the transition state for transgalactosylation.