Retinoid antagonists inhibit normal patterning during limb regeneration in the axolotl, Ambystoma mexicanum

Retinoic acid (RA) has been detected in the regenerating limb of the axolotl, and exogenous RA can proximalize, posteriorize, and ventralize blastemal cells. Thus, RA may be an endogenous regulatory factor during limb regeneration. We have investigated whether endogenous retinoids are essential for patterning during axolotl (Ambystoma mexicanum) limb regeneration by using retinoid antagonists that bind to specific RAR (retinoic acid receptor) or RXR (retinoid X receptor) retinoid receptor subtypes. Retinoid antagonists (Ro41-5253, Ro61-8431, LE135, and LE540) were administered to regenerating limbs using implanted silastin blocks loaded with each antagonist. The skeletal pattern of regenerated limbs treated with Ro41-5253 or Ro61-8431 differed only slightly from control limbs. Treatment with LE135 inhibited limb regeneration, while treatment with LE540 allowed relatively normal limb regeneration. When LE135 and LE540 were implanted together, regeneration was not completely inhibited and a hand-like process regenerated. These results demonstrate that interfering with retinoid receptors can modify pattern in the regenerating limb indicating that endogenous retinoids are important during patterning of the regenerating limb.     

Retinoic acid and its receptors in limb regeneration

The effects of retinoids on the regenerating amphibian limb are described: the mesenchymal cells of the blastema can be proximalized, posteriorized and ventralized. Ectopic limbs are also induced after retinoid treatment of regenerating tails, but not during limb development unless the limb bud is damaged. The cellular and molecular alterations induced by retinoids are reported as well as experiments which have revealed the importance of endogenous retinoids for normal limb regeneration. Various retinoic acid receptors are expressed in the regeneration blastema and the experiments which have revealed functions for individual isoforms are described. These experiments reveal that retinoids are a crucial component of the normal, regenerating limb and demonstrate the value of the regenerating limb as an experimental system for providing functional data on individual retinoic acid receptors.     

The effect of vitamin A (retinoids) on pattern formation implies a uniformity of developmental mechanisms throughout the animal kingdom

Retinoids are low molecular weight, lipophilic derivatives of vitamin A which have a profound effect upon the development of a diverse array of animals. Here, I review these effects on Invertebrates: a colonial hydroid, a colonial ascidian, and Vertebrates: the regenerating amphibian limb, the developing chick limb bud, the regenerating amphibian tail, the anteroposterior axis of the early embryo, the developing chick embryo skin. There is a striking uniformity of effect of retinoids on pattern formation when applied to these diverse organisms. The majority react by being posteriorized in their development, although additional effects can also be seen. Several hypotheses which can explain these results are discussed along with the deduction that they lead to: retinoids may be components of a universal developmental mechanism or they may simply act in a similar way to alter a universal developmental mechanism. In either case the experimental analysis of retinoid effects on development has important implications for the evolution of developmental mechanisms.     

Characterization of retinoid metabolism in the developing chick limb bud

Retinoids (vitamin A derivatives) have been shown to have striking effects on developing and regenerating vertebrate limbs. In the developing chick limb, retinoic acid is a candidate morphogen that may coordinate the pattern of cellular differentiation along the anteroposterior limb axis. We describe a series of investigations of the metabolic pathway of retinoids in the chick limb bud system. To study retinoid metabolism in the bud, all-trans-[3H]retinol, all-trans-[3H]retinal and all-trans-[3H]retinoic acid were released into the posterior region of the limb anlage, the area that contains the zone of polarizing activity, a tissue possibly involved in limb pattern formation. We found that the locally applied [3H]retinol is primarily converted to [3H]retinal, [3H]retinoic acid and a yet unidentified metabolite. When [3H]retinal is locally applied, it is either oxidized to [3H]retinoic acid or reduced to [3H]retinol. In contrast, local delivery of retinoic acid to the bud yields neither retinal nor retinol nor the unknown metabolite. This flow of metabolites agrees with the biochemical pathway of retinoids that has previously been elucidated in a number of other animal systems. To find out whether metabolism takes place directly in the treated limb bud, we have compared the amount of [3H]retinoid present in each of the four limb anlagen following local treatment of the right wing bud. The data suggest that retinoid metabolism takes place mostly in the treated limb bud. This local metabolism could provide a simple mechanism to generate in a controlled fashion the biologically active all-trans-retinoic acid from its abundant biosynthetic precursor retinol. In addition, local metabolism supports the hypothesis that retinoids are local chemical mediators involved in pattern formation.     

Retinoic acid signalling in the zebrafish embryo is necessary during pre-segmentation stages to pattern the anterior-posterior axis of the CNS and to induce a pectoral fin bud

A number of studies have suggested that retinoic acid (RA) is an important signal for patterning the hindbrain, the branchial arches and the limb bud. Retinoic acid is thought to act on the posterior hindbrain and the limb buds at somitogenesis stages in chick and mouse embryos. Here we report a much earlier requirement for RA signalling during pre-segmentation stages for proper development of these structures in zebrafish. We present evidence that a RA signal is necessary during pre-segmentation stages for proper expression of the spinal cord markers hoxb5a and hoxb6b, suggesting an influence of RA on anteroposterior patterning of the neural plate posterior to the hindbrain. We report the identification and expression pattern of the zebrafish retinaldehyde dehydrogenase2 (raldh2/aldh1a2) gene. Raldh2 synthesises retinoic acid (RA) from its immediate precursor retinal. It is expressed in a highly ordered spatial and temporal fashion during gastrulation in the involuting mesoderm and during later embryogenesis in paraxial mesoderm, branchial arches, eyes and fin buds, suggesting the involvement of RA at different times of development in different functional contexts. Mapping of the raldh2 gene reveals close linkage to no-fin (nof), a newly discovered mutant lacking pectoral fins and cartilaginous gill arches. Cloning and functional tests of the wild-type and nof alleles of raldh2 reveal that nof is a raldh2 mutant. By treating nof mutants with RA during different time windows and by making use of a retinoic acid receptor antagonist, we show that RA signalling during pre-segmentation stages is necessary for anteroposterior patterning in the CNS and for fin induction to occur.     

Distribution of retinoids in the chick limb bud: analysis with monoclonal antibody

Retinoic acid induces anteroposterior duplicate formation in developing chick limb bud, and it may be a natural morphogen involved in limb pattern formation. Retinoic acid is produced from retinol locally in the limb bud via retinal, and thus, to elucidate the distribution of these retinoids in the limb bud seems to be important for the understanding of the morphogen formation. We produced a monoclonal antibody against the retinoids with BSA-RA (bovine serum albumin-retinoic acid) conjugate for antigen, and investigated the distribution of retinoids in the chick limb bud. The antibody predominantly bound to retinoic acid, but weakly to retinol and retinal. Retinoids appeared in the limb bud at stage 18 and were distributed through stages 20-24, when the pattern formation in distal mesoderm was in progress. Initially they were found evenly in the whole mesoderm, but disappeared gradually from core mesoderm and remained only in the region of peripheral mesoderm at stage 24. At stage 26, retinoids were detected only in ectoderm. These results support the idea that the retinoids actually play roles in limb pattern formation and suggest that the retinoids in the peripheral mesoderm are important for pattern formation. Further, the role of retinoids in epidermis development at later limb bud stages is also suggested.     

Effects of vitamin D metabolites on axolotl limb regeneration

Vitamin D is essential for normal metabolism of phosphorus and calcium, and differentiation of skeletal elements. 1,25 dihydroxyvitamin-D₃, the biologically active metabolite, acts as an induction/proliferation switch in various cell types and promotes chondrogenesis of chick limb bud mesenchymal cells. The function of vitamin D is mediated through its nuclear receptor, the vitamin D receptor (VDR). The proliferative actions of 1,25(OH)₂-D₃ on limb bud mesenchymal cells are similar to the ones produced by retinoids, such as all- trans retinoic acid (RA) or 9- cis retinoic acid (9- cis ). The retinoids have been shown to be compounds of extreme importance in the field of limb development and regeneration. In order to examine possible roles of vitamin D metabolites on limb regeneration, the effects of 1,25(OH)₂-D₃, 24,25(OH)₂-D₃ and KH1060 (a more potent metabolite) alone or in conjunction with all- trans RA or 9- cis RA on the regenerating axolotl limb. Vitamin D affects limb morphogenesis by generating abnormalities in skeletal elements. Synergism of vitamin D with retinoic acid in affecting pattern formation is suggested by the results.     

Role of thyroid hormone and retinoid receptors in the homeotic transformation of tails into limbs in frogs

We provide here further data on the dramatic homeotic transformation of tails into limbs which is induced by retinoids during frog tadpole tail regeneration. The effect can still be produced up to nine days after tail amputation by which time tail regeneration has essentially been completed. Complete tail amputation is needed for the effects to be manifest, partial damage of various sorts to the tail is not enough. We show that as well as retinyl palmitate, other retinoids such as all-trans-retinoic acid and TTNPB, which is a RAR specific retinoid, can induce the homeotic transformation. TTNPB has a 300x greater potency than retinoic acid. Prolactin, which inhibits thyroid hormone production, prevents the appearance of limbs on the tail from which we conclude that thyroid hormone is needed. We present preliminary evidence from RT-PCR that all six retinoid receptors, the three retinoic acid receptors (RARs), and the three retinoid X receptors (RXRs), are present in the normal tail blastema and that after retinoid treatment RARα, RXRα, and RXRβ may be up-regulated. Finally, we show that when RA synthesis is inhibited, normal tail regeneration is inhibited. We conclude that tail regeneration depends upon a particular endogenous level of RA, but that when this level is raised by external administration and thyroid hormone receptors are present the up-regulation of certain retinoid receptors allows novel nuclear receptor interactions which results in the induction of limb-specific genes leading to the appearance of limbs on the tail. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Identification of a novel isoform of the retinoic acid receptor gamma expressed in the mouse embryo.

Retinoic acid is known to have profound effects on developmental processes. It has been implicated as a putative morphogen in the developing chick limb bud and regenerating amphibian limb blastema and has been demonstrated to have powerful teratogenic effects in mammals, including humans. Recently, three specific retinoic acid receptors (RARs), RAR alpha, -beta, and -gamma, were identified and shown to be members of the steroid receptor superfamily. We report the identification of a novel RAR gamma isoform, mRAR gamma B, which differs from the previously described mouse RAR gamma at its amino terminus. In addition, we show that both RAR gamma isoforms are expressed maximally at midgestation in structures known to be affected adversely by retinoic acid administration to pregnant mice. Multiple RAR isoforms, each of which may play a unique or combinatorial role as a regulator of mammalian development, are thus expressed in the mouse embryo.     

Regional differences in retinoid release from embryonic neural tissue detected by an in vitro reporter assay.

Retinoic acid and related retinoids have been suggested to contribute to the pattern of cell differentiation during vertebrate embryonic development. To identify cell groups that release morphogenetically active retinoids, we have developed a reporter assay that makes use of a retinoic acid inducible response element (RARE) to drive lacZ or luciferase reporter genes in stably transfected cell lines. This reporter gene assay allows detection of retinoids released from embryonic tissues over a range equivalent to that induced by femtomole amounts of retinoic acid. We have used this assay first to determine whether the floor plate, a cell group that has polarizing properties in neural tube and limb bud differentiation, is a local source of retinoids within the spinal cord. We have also examined whether the effects of exogenously administered retinoic acid on anteroposterior patterning of cells in the developing central nervous system correlate with differences in retinoid release from anterior and posterior neural tissue. We find that the release of morphogenetically active retinoids from the floor plate is only about 1.5-fold that of the dorsal spinal cord, which does not have neural tube or limb polarizing activity. These results suggest that the spatial distribution of retinoid release from spinal cord tissues differs from that of the neural and limb polarizing activity. This assay has also shown that retinoids are released from the embryonic spinal cord at much greater levels than from the forebrain. This result, together with previous observations that the development of forebrain structures is suppressed by low concentrations of retinoic acid, suggest that the normal development of forebrain structures is dependent on the maintenance of low concentrations of retinoids in anterior regions of the embryonic axis. This assay has also provided initial evidence that other embryonic tissues with polarizing properties in vivo release retinoids in vitro.     

The chick oligozeugodactyly (ozd) mutant lacks sonic hedgehog function in the limb

We have analyzed a new limb mutant in the chicken that we name oligozeugodactyly (ozd). The limbs of this mutant have a longitudinal postaxial defect, lacking the posterior element in the zeugopod (ulna/fibula) and all digits except digit 1 in the leg. Classical recombination experiments show that the limb mesoderm is the defective tissue layer in ozd limb buds. Molecular analysis revealed that the ozd limbs develop in the absence of Shh expression, while all other organs express Shh and develop normally. Neither Ptc1 nor Gli1 are detectable in mutant limb buds. However, Bmp2 and dHAND are expressed in the posterior wing and leg bud mesoderm, although at lower levels than in normal embryos. Activation of Hoxd11-13 occurs normally in ozd limbs but progressively declines with time. Phase III of expression is more affected than phase II, and expression is more severely affected in the more 5' genes. Interestingly, re-expression of Hoxd13 occurs at late stages in the distal mesoderm of ozd leg buds, correlating with formation of digit 1. Fgf8 and Fgf4 expression are initiated normally in the mutant AER but their expression is progressively downregulated in the anterior AER. Recombinant Shh protein or ZPA grafts restore normal pattern to ozd limbs; however, retinoic acid fails to induce Shh in ozd limb mesoderm. We conclude that Shh function is required for limb development distal to the elbow/knee joints, similar to the Shh(-/-) mouse. Accordingly we classify the limb skeletal elements as Shh dependent or independent, with the ulna/fibula and digits other than digit 1 in the leg being Shh dependent. Finally we propose that the ozd mutation is most likely a defect in a regulatory element that controls limb-specific expression of Shh.     

An essential role for retinoid signaling in anteroposterior neural specification and neuronal differentiation

Vitamin A and its derivatives, the retinoids, have been implicated as important signaling molecules in vertebrate development, primarily due to numerous gain-of-function experiments involving treatment of embryos with exogenous retinoic acid. Collectively, the results from these experiments suggested that retinoids were sufficient to mimic the action of endogenous factors which posteriorize the embryonic axis, however the question of their necessity has remained unclear. Recent loss-of-function experiments from several laboratories have shown that retinoids are indispensable for regionalizing the anteroposterior axis and promoting neuronal differentiation. These results firmly establish retinoids as endogenous signaling molecules that are required for embryonic patterning.     

Localization of specific retinoid-binding sites and expression of cellular retinoic-acid-binding protein (CRABP) in the early mouse embryo

Retinoids (vitamin A derivatives) are important for normal embryogenesis and retinoic acid, an acidic derivative of vitamin A, was recently proposed to be an endogenous morphogen. Several retinoids are also potent teratogens. Using an autoradiographic technique, we have identified tissues and cells in early mouse embryos that are able to specifically accumulate a radiolabelled synthetic derivative of retinoic acid. Strong accumulation of radioactivity was seen in several neural crest derivatives and in specific areas of the CNS. Gel filtration analyses of cytosols from embryos that received the radiolabelled retinoid in utero suggested that cellular retinoic acid-binding protein (CRABP) was involved in the accumulation mechanism. Immunohistochemical localization confirmed that cells accumulating retinoids also expressed CRABP. Strong CRABP immunoreactivity was found in neural crest-derived mesenchyme of the craniofacial area, in visceral arches, in dorsal root ganglia and in cells along the gut and the major vessels of the trunk region. In CNS, CRABP expression and retinoid binding was largely restricted to the hindbrain, to a single layer of cells in the roof of the midbrain and to cells in the mantle layer of the neural tube. Our data suggest that cells in the embryo expressing CRABP are target cells for exogenous retinoids as well as endogenous retinoic acid. Retinoic acid may thus play an essential role in normal development of the CNS and of tissues derived from the neural crest. We propose that the teratogenic effects of exogenous retinoids are due to an interference with mechanisms by which endogenous retinoic acid regulates differentiation and pattern formation in these tissues.     

Role of retinoic acid receptors alpha1 and gamma in the response of murine limbs to retinol in vitro

BACKGROUND: Derivatives of retinol (vitamin A), commonly referred to as retinoids, signal through retinoic acid and retinoid X receptors (RARs/RXRs) and are essential for normal limb formation. Retinoid imbalances or perturbations in receptor function result in aberrant limb development. To examine the mechanisms underlying retinol-induced limb defects, we determined the responsiveness of limbs from RARalpha1-/-gamma mice to excess retinol in vitro. METHODS: RARalpha1-/-gamma+/- mice were bred and their embryos were recovered at gestational day (GD) 12.5. The forelimbs were excised and cultured in vitro in the presence of all-trans retinol acetate (0, 1.25, 12.5, or 62.5 microM) for 6 days. The expression profiles of genes known to affect chondrogenesis (sox9 and col2a1) and limb outgrowth (meis1, meis2, and pbx1a) were examined by real-time qRT-PCR following retinol exposure for 3 hr. RESULTS: Whereas RARalpha1-/-gamma+/+ and RARalpha1-/-gamma+/- limbs exhibited deleterious effects on limb outgrowth and chondrogenesis in the presence of exogenous retinol, this outcome was significantly attenuated in RARalpha1-/-gamma-/- limbs. The expressions of sox9 and col2a1 were significantly decreased in retinol-exposed RARalpha1-/-gamma+/+ limbs. In contrast, expression was not altered in limbs from their RARalpha1-/-gamma+/- or RARalpha1-/-gamma-/- littermates. Retinol exposure upregulated the expression of meis1 and meis2 in RARalpha1-/-gamma+/+ limbs; however, in RARalpha1-/-gamma-/- limbs the expression of both genes was unresponsive to retinol. Pbx1a remained unresponsive to retinol treatment in all genotypes. CONCLUSION: In the absence of RARalpha1, RARgamma is a functionally important mediator of retinoid-induced limb dysmorphogenesis.     

Retinoic acid modifies the pattern of cell differentiation in the central nervous system of neurula stage Xenopus embryos.

Neural cell markers have been used to examine the effect of retinoic acid (RA) on the development of the central nervous system (CNS) of Xenopus embryos. RA treatment of neurula stage embryos resulted in a concentration-dependent perturbation of anterior CNS development leading to a reduction in the size of the forebrain, midbrain and hindbrain. In addition the overt segmental organization of the hindbrain was abolished by high concentrations of RA. The regional expression of two cell-specific markers, the homeobox protein Xhox3 and the neurotransmitter serotonin was also examined in embryos exposed to RA. Treatment with RA caused a concentration-dependent change in the pattern of expression of Xhox3 and serotonin and resulted in the ectopic appearance of immunoreactive neurons in anterior regions of the CNS, including the forebrain. Collectively, our results extend previous studies by showing that RA treatment of embryos at the neurula stage inhibits the development of anterior regions of the CNS while promoting the differentiation of more posterior cell types. The relevance of these findings to the possible role of endogenous retinoids in the determination of neural cell fate and axial patterning is discussed.     

Effects of retinoids on regenerating limbs: comparison of retinoic acid and arotinoid at different amputation levels

Summary Retinoic acid and the synthetic retinoid, arotinoid, were compared for their efficacy in inducing proximodistal (PD) pattern duplication in regenerating axolotl limbs, after amputation through either the distal zeugopodium (lower arm or leg) or distal stylopodium (upper arm or leg). At each level of amputation, the morphology of the duplications produced was the same for both retinoids, and the mean level of proximalization was dose-dependent. Blastema formation was delayed by both retinoids and the delay was associated with regression of the limb stump. Blastemas which produced PD duplication to the stylopodial or girdle level grew out from the stump in a posterior direction. In several zeugopodial regenerates, a partially duplicated, PD-reversed zeugopodium regenerated between the stump cartilages and a completely duplicated zeugopodium distally. Arotinoid was 50 times more effective than retinoic acid in evoking duplication. The dose of arotinoid required to duplicate a stylopodium in a stylopodial regenerate was several times higher than the dose required to duplicate a zeugopodium in a zeugopodial regenerate, suggesting differences either in the sensitivity of zeugopodial and stylopodial cells to retinoid, or in the numbers of positional value specifying these segments.     

The relationship among retinoid structure, affinity for retinoic acid-binding protein, and ability to respecify pattern in the regenerating axolotl limb

To further our understanding of the action of retinoids on the respecification of pattern in the regenerating axolotl limb we have studied the relative potencies of a range of synthetic and natural retinoids administered locally to the blastema. Alterations in the polar end group of the retinoic acid (RA) molecule to produce esters, the alcohol, or the aldehyde abolish the ability of the molecule to respecify pattern. On the other hand, alterations of the ring or side chain to produce the synthetic retinoids arotinoid and TTNPB considerably increases the potency of the molecule to respecify pattern--TTNPB is at least 100X more potent than retinoic acid. To examine the role of cellular retinoic acid-binding protein (CRABP) in the respecification process we determined the relative binding affinities of these retinoids for CRABP. These data correlated well with the respecification series: retinoids which showed no affinity for CRABP did not respecify pattern and those which did show affinity for CRABP did respecify pattern. Furthermore the most potent retinoid, TTNPB, has a higher affinity for CRABP than RA itself. This suggests that CRABP may be playing an important role in the action of RA on pattern formation in the regenerating limb.