Induction of central deletional T cell tolerance by gene therapy

Transgenic mice expressing an alloreactive TCR specific for the MHC class I Ag K(b) were used to examine the mechanism by which genetic engineering of bone marrow induces T cell tolerance. Reconstitution of lethally irradiated mice with bone marrow infected with retroviruses carrying the MHC class I gene H-2K(b) resulted in lifelong expression of K(b) on bone marrow-derived cells. While CD8 T cells expressing the transgenic TCR developed in control mice reconstituted with mock-transduced bone marrow, CD8 T cells expressing the transgenic TCR failed to develop in mice reconstituted with H-2K(b) transduced bone marrow. Analysis of transgene-expressing CD8 T cells in the thymus and periphery of reconstituted mice revealed that CD8 T cells expressing the transgenic TCR underwent negative selection in the thymus of mice reconstituted with K(b) transduced bone marrow. Negative selection induced by gene therapy resulted in tolerance to K(b). Thus, genetic engineering of bone marrow can be used to alter T cell education in the thymus by inducing negative selection.     

Unusual T cell populations in adult murine bone marrow. Prevalence of CD3+CD4-CD8- and alpha beta TCR+NK1.1+ cells

The T cell populations present in normal murine bone marrow have not been previously analyzed in detail, mainly because of their relative rarity. In order to permit such analyses, bone marrow T cells were enriched by depleting Mac1-positive cells, which constitute 65 to 90% of bone marrow cells (BMC), and then studied by two-color flow cytometry. Analysis of the remaining cells revealed that the T cell profile of adult murine bone marrow is markedly different from that of other lymphoid organs. A very high proportion of bone marrow CD3+ cells (approximately one-third) are CD4-CD8-. CD3+CD4-CD8- cells are much more concentrated among BMC T cells than among thymocytes or splenic T cells, suggesting that bone marrow may be either a site of extrathymic TCR gene rearrangement, or a major site to which such cells home from the thymus. The expression of NK1.1 was also evaluated on Mac1-depleted BMC populations. Surprisingly, up to 39% of alpha beta TCR+ BMC were found to express NK1.1. Most alpha beta TCR+NK1.1+ BMC also expressed CD4 or CD8. NK1.1+ alpha beta TCR+ cells represented a much greater proportion of BMC T cells than of other lymphoid (splenocyte or thymocyte) T cell populations. Mac1-depleted BMC of nude mice contained very few cells with this phenotype. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that NK1.1+ alpha beta TCR+ cells are generated primarily in the thymus of normal animals and migrate preferentially to bone marrow, where they may function as regulatory elements in hematopoiesis.     

Demonstration of a CD3+ lymphocyte subset in the epidermis of athymic nude mice. Evidence for T cell receptor diversity.

The existence of CD3/TCR-bearing lymphocytes in athymic and thymectomized chimeric mice implies that T cell maturation can occur in the absence of a thymus. Considering the possibility that the epidermis may be one of the organs providing T cell educating stimuli, we attempted to characterize the Thy-1+ epidermal lymphocyte population of athymic mice. Immunohistologic studies of epidermal sheets revealed (1) that Thy-1+ epidermal cells of C57BL/6 nu/nu mice are CD5-, CD4-, and predominantly CD8-, and (2) that a minor subset of these cells displays anti-CD3 epsilon reactivity. Although these CD3+ epidermal cells could hardly be detected at 6 wk of age, they comprised approximately 2% of all Thy-1+ epidermal cells in 12-mo-old athymic mice. Most of these CD3+ cells expressed TCR-gamma/delta, but TCR-alpha/beta+ cells were also present. TCR-gamma/delta+ epidermal T cells of athymic mice preferentially expressed TCR V gamma 2, V gamma 4, and V gamma 5 specificities rather than TCR V gamma 3 as found on DETC of euthymic mice. Using mitogenic stimuli, we have succeeded in establishing cell lines and clones from BALB/c nu/nu and C57BL/6 nu/nu epidermis. Their marker profile corresponds to that seen on resident CD3+ epidermal cells, as well as on a very small subset of CD3+ splenic and lymph node lymphocytes of athymic mice. The ontogenetic relationship, if any, between the epidermal and lymphoid CD3+, CD5-, CD4-, CD8- cells, has yet to be clarified. Cell lines/clones representative of resident CD3+ epidermal cells of nu/nu mice should provide a useful tool in the elucidation of homing patterns and functional properties of extrathymically matured T cells.     

Studies of CD4- CD8- alpha beta bone marrow T cells with suppressor activity.

The predominant T cell subset in the bone marrow of specific pathogen-free C57BL/Ka and BALB/c mice expressed the alpha beta+ TCR CD4- CD8- surface phenotype. Purified C57BL/Ka alpha beta+ TCR CD4- CD8- marrow cells obtained by cell sorting suppressed the MLR of C57BL/Ka responder and BALB/c stimulator spleen cells. Although the percentage of typical T cells in the spleen was markedly reduced in adult nude mice or normal neonatal mice as compared to the normal adult, the percentage of alpha beta+ TCR CD4- CD8- cells in the spleen and marrow was not. The percentage of "self-reactive" V beta 5+ T cells in the BALB/c spleen was markedly reduced as compared to that in the C57BL/Ka spleen. However, the percentages in the bone marrow were similar. The results indicate that the predominant subset of marrow T cells in these pathogen-free mice differ with regard to surface marker phenotype, function, dependence on the adult thymus, and deletion of certain self-reactive V beta receptors as compared to typical spleen T cells. The marrow T cells appear to develop directly from marrow precursors without rearranged beta chain genes during a 48 hour in vitro culture.     

T hybridoma alpha/beta gene transfected in a murine T cell hybridoma: role of CD4 molecule in vitro and in vivo--engraftment in SCID mice induces T cell maturation.

In the present work, we tested in SCID and Balb/c mice the activity of T hybridoma transfected with T cell receptor (TCR) alpha/beta chain genes. A T cell hybridoma denoted D011107 was used as recipient for transfection of cytotoxic KB5C20 TCR alpha/beta heterodimer genes by protoplast fusion or electroporation. After transfection, the parental D011107 T cell line reexpressed CD5 and CD4 surface molecules. In vitro, we noted strong proliferation and unusual cytotoxic reactivities against H-2k target cells although the transfected cell line does not express the CD8 molecule. The fate of parental and transfected cells was examined in severe combined immunodeficient (SCID) and Balb/c mice at Day 16 after intravenous injection. Cells from bone marrow, thymus, and spleen tissues were analyzed by immunofluorescence. The transfected T cell hybridoma was CD3+ Desire 1+ CD4+ Thy1.2. The SCID mice grafted with the transfected T cell hybridoma presented a high percentage of CD3+ (15%), CD4+ (27%), Thy1.2+ (27.52%), and Desire 1+ (8.74%) cells in the spleen. The percentages of CD3+ (6.2%) and Thy1.2+ (5.06%) cells in the spleen from SCID mice grafted with parental T cell D011107 and from untreated SCID were similar and lower (CD3+, 3.52%; Thy1.2+, 4.34%). It seems that transfected T cells hybridoma grafted in the SCID mice induce significant expression of CD4+ Thy1.2+ Desire 1- cells (17%) in the spleen. These results indicate that transfected T cells graft may allow T cell differentiation. In Balb/c mice, the percentage of different T cell subsets in bone marrow, thymus, or spleen cells in mice injected with transfected T cells was similar to that in untreated mice. We did not observe any cytotoxic or significant allogeneic proliferation in vitro.     

Induction of alloreactive CD4 T cell tolerance in molecular chimeras: a possible role for regulatory T cells

Induction of molecular chimerism following reconstitution of mice with autologous bone marrow cells expressing a retrovirally encoded allogeneic MHC class I Ag results in donor-specific tolerance. To investigate the mechanism by which CD4 T cells that recognize allogeneic MHC class I through the indirect pathway of Ag presentation are rendered tolerant in molecular chimeras, transgenic mice expressing a TCR on CD4 T cells specific for peptides derived from K(b) were used. CD4 T cells expressing the transgenic TCR were detected in mice reconstituted with bone marrow cells transduced with retroviruses carrying the gene encoding H-2K(b), albeit detection was at lower levels than in mice receiving mock-transduced bone marrow. Despite the presence of CD4 T cells expressing an alloreactive TCR, mice receiving H-2K(b)-transduced bone marrow permanently accepted K(b) disparate skin grafts. CD4+CD25+ T cells from mice reconstituted with H-2K(b)-transduced bone marrow prevented rejection of K(b) disparate skin grafts when adoptively transferred into immunodeficient mice along with effector T cells, suggesting that induction of molecular chimerism leads to the generation of donor specific regulatory T cells, which may be involved in preventing alloreactive CD4 T cell responses that lead to rejection.     

In vivo and in absence of a thymus, the enforced expression of the Notch ligands delta-1 or delta-4 promotes T cell development with specific unique effects

The role of Notch signaling in T cell commitment during lymphoid development is well established. However, the identity of the ligand that triggers this critical signal in vivo is still unclear. By overexpressing Delta-1 and Delta-4 ligands in the hemopoietic cells of athymic nu/nu host mice, we demonstrate that, in vivo and in the absence of a thymus, Delta-1 or Delta-4 expression is sufficient to promote T cell development from the most immature progenitor stages to complete maturation of both CD8(+) and CD4(+) alphabeta T cells. The mature T cells developing in a Delta-1- or Delta-4-enriched environment express a diverse TCR repertoire, are able to proliferate upon in vitro TCR stimulation, but show different profiles of cytokine production after in vitro anti-CD3 stimulation.     

Identification of pro-thymocytes in murine fetal blood: T lineage commitment can precede thymus colonization.

Phenotype and commitment of thymus-colonizing precursors are unknown. Here we report the identification of T lineage-committed precursors (designated prothymocytes) in murine fetal blood at day 15.5 of development. Fetal blood pro-thymocytes are Thy-1+c-kit(low)CD3- in contrast to fetal blood-derived pluripotent hematopoietic progenitors which are Thy-1-c-kit+. Upon transfer into the thymus, fetal blood pro-thymocytes generate a single wave of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes and subsequently mature TCR alpha beta+ peripheral T cells. However, fetal blood pro-thymocytes lack multipotent progenitor potential since they fail to reconstitute B lymphocytes and myeloid and erythroid lineages. In contrast, T and B lymphocytes as well as myeloid and erythroid lineages are reconstituted from fetal blood-derived pluripotent progenitors. Pro-thymocytes are equally present in peripheral blood of athymic fetal mice, suggesting that this novel precursor population is T lineage-committed prior to thymus colonization and represents the earliest T lineage precursor identified.     

Pregnancy allows the transfer and differentiation of fetal lymphoid progenitors into functional T and B cells in mothers

T lymphocytes of fetal origin found in maternal circulation after gestation have been reported as a possible cause for autoimmune diseases. During gestation, mothers acquire CD34+CD38+ cells of fetal origin that persist decades. In this study, we asked whether fetal T and B cells could develop from these progenitors in the maternal thymus and bone marrow during and after gestation. RAG-/--deficient female mice (Ly5.2) were mated to congenic wild-type Ly5.1 mice (RAG+/+). Fetal double-positive T cells (CD4+CD8+) with characteristic TCR and IL-7R expression patterns could be recovered in maternal thymus during the resulting pregnancies. We made similar observations in the thymus of immunocompetent mothers. Such phenomenon was observed overall in 12 of 68 tested mice compared with 0 of 51 controls (p=0.001). T cells could also be found in maternal spleen and produced IFN-gamma in the presence of an allogenic or an Ag-specific stimulus. Similarly, CD19+IgM+ fetal B cells as well as plasma Igs could be found in maternal RAG-/- bone marrow and spleen after similar matings. Our results suggest that during gestation mothers acquire fetal lymphoid progenitors that develop into functional T cells. This fetal cell microchimerism may have a direct impact on maternal health.     

Differentiation and functional maturation of bone marrow-derived intestinal epithelial T cells expressing membrane T cell receptor in athymic radiation chimeras

The thymus dependency of murine intestinal intraepithelial lymphocytes (IEL) was studied in an athymic F1----parent radiation chimera model. IEL, although not splenic or lymph node lymphocytes, from athymic chimeras displayed normal levels of cells bearing the class-specific T cell Ag, CD4 and CD8; the TCR-associated molecule, CD3; and the Thy-1 Ag. Moreover, two-color flow cytometric analyses of IEL from athymic mice demonstrated regulated expression of T cell Ag characteristic of IEL subset populations from thymus-bearing mice. In immunoprecipitation experiments, surface TCR-alpha beta or TCR-gamma delta were expressed on IEL, although not on splenic lymphocytes, from athymic chimeras. That IEL from athymic chimeras constituted a population of functionally mature effector cells activated in situ, similar to IEL from thymus-bearing mice, was demonstrated by the presence of CD3-mediated lytic activity of athymic lethally irradiated bone marrow reconstituted IEL. These data provide compelling evidence that intestinal T cells do not require thymic influence for maturation and development, and demonstrate that the microenvironment of the intestinal epithelium is uniquely adapted to regulate IEL differentiation.     

Double-negative T regulatory cells can develop outside the thymus and do not mature from CD8+ T cell precursors

Recent studies have demonstrated that activated peripheral alphabeta TCR+ CD3+ CD4- CD8- NK1.1- (double-negative, DN) regulatory T cells (Tregs) from both mice and humans are able to down-regulate immune responses in vitro and in vivo. However, the origin and developmental requirements of functional DN Tregs remain unclear. In this study, we investigated the requirement for CD8 expression as well as the presence of a thymus for the development of functional DN Tregs. We demonstrate that DN Tregs exist in CD8-deficient mice and that stimulation of CD8+ T cells in vivo with TCR-specific Ag does not convert CD8+ T cells into DN Tregs. In addition, we found that DN T cells are present in the spleens and lymph nodes of thymectomized mice that are irradiated and reconstituted with T cell-depleted bone marrow cells. Interestingly, DN Tregs that develop in thymectomized mice can suppress syngeneic CD8+ T cells more effectively than those that develop in sham-thymectomized mice. Taken together, our data suggest that DN Tregs are not derived from CD8+ T cell precursors and that functional DN Tregs may preferentially develop outside of the thymus. These data suggest that DN Tregs may represent a developmentally and functionally unique cell population.     

Natural killer cells in the thymus. Studies in mice with severe combined immune deficiency

The relationship between NK cell and T cell progenitors was investigated by using mice with severe combined immune deficiency (scid). Scid mice are devoid of mature T and B cells because they cannot rearrange their Ig and TCR genes. However, they have normal splenic NK cells. Thymus of scid mice, although markedly hypocellular, contains cells that lyse YAC-1, an NK-sensitive tumor cell. By flow cytometry, two populations of cells were identified in the scid thymus. Eighty percent of the cells were Thy-1+, IL-2R(7D4)+, J11d+, CD3-, CD4-, CD8- whereas the remaining were IL-2R-, J11d-, CD3-, CD4-, and CD8-. By cell sorting, all NK activity was found in the latter population, which is phenotypically similar to splenic NK cells. To determine if the thymus contains a bipotential NK/T progenitor cell, J11d+, IL-2R+ cells were cultured and analyzed for the generation of NK cells in vitro. These cells were used because they resemble 15-day fetal and adult CD4- CD8- thymocytes that are capable of giving rise to mature T cells. Cultured J11d+ thymocytes acquired non-MHC-restricted cytotoxicity, but in contrast to mature NK cells, the resulting cells contained mRNA for the gamma, delta, and epsilon-chains of CD3. This suggests that J11d+ cells are early T cells that can acquire the ability to kill in a non-MHC-restricted manner, but which do not give rise to NK cells in vitro. The differentiative potential of scid thymocytes was also tested in vivo. Unlike bone marrow cells, scid thymocytes containing 80% J11d+ cells failed to give rise to NK cells when transferred into irradiated recipients. Together these results suggest that mature NK cells reside in the thymus of scid mice but are not derived from a common NK/T progenitor.     

Thymus and autoimmunity: production of CD25+CD4+ naturally anergic and suppressive T cells as a key function of the thymus in maintaining immunologic self-tolerance

This study shows that the normal thymus produces immunoregulatory CD25+4+8- thymocytes capable of controlling self-reactive T cells. Transfer of thymocyte suspensions depleted of CD25+4+8- thymocytes, which constitute approximately 5% of steroid-resistant mature CD4+8- thymocytes in normal naive mice, produces various autoimmune diseases in syngeneic athymic nude mice. These CD25+4+8- thymocytes are nonproliferative (anergic) to TCR stimulation in vitro, but potently suppress the proliferation of other CD4+8- or CD4-8+ thymocytes; breakage of their anergic state in vitro by high doses of IL-2 or anti-CD28 Ab simultaneously abrogates their suppressive activity; and transfer of such suppression-abrogated thymocyte suspensions produces autoimmune disease in nude mice. These immunoregulatory CD25+4+8- thymocytes/T cells are functionally distinct from activated CD25+4+ T cells derived from CD25-4+ thymocytes/T cells in that the latter scarcely exhibits suppressive activity in vitro, although both CD25+4+ populations express a similar profile of cell surface markers. Furthermore, the CD25+4+8- thymocytes appear to acquire their anergic and suppressive property through the thymic selection process, since TCR transgenic mice develop similar anergic/suppressive CD25+4+8- thymocytes and CD25+4+ T cells that predominantly express TCRs utilizing endogenous alpha-chains, but RAG-2-deficient TCR transgenic mice do not. These results taken together indicate that anergic/suppressive CD25+4+8- thymocytes and peripheral T cells in normal naive mice may constitute a common T cell lineage functionally and developmentally distinct from other T cells, and that production of this unique immunoregulatory T cell population can be another key function of the thymus in maintaining immunologic self-tolerance.     

Immunoregulatory function of CD3+, CD4-, and CD8- T cells. Gamma delta T cell receptor-positive T cells from nude mice abrogate oral tolerance

Previous work has shown that abrogation of oral tolerance is mediated by T cells which are found in the CD3+, L3T4- (CD4-), and Lyt-2- (CD8-) subset (termed double-negative; DN) in mice. Inasmuch as it is known that athymic, nude (nu/nu) mice possess Thy 1+, CD4-, and CD8- T cells which also exhibit a functionally rearranged TCR gamma-chain, we investigated whether this subset of nude T cells contained functional immunoregulatory cells. In this report, we examined the phenotype and distribution of CD3+ T cells in the spleen and in the mesenteric and peripheral lymph nodes of BALB/c nu/nu mice in comparison with normal mice (+/+). In the spleens of nude mice, the predominant CD3+ T cell subpopulation was DN. Further, in mesenteric and peripheral lymph nodes, approximately one-third and one-half of the CD3+ T cells were double negative, respectively. In contrast, CD3+, DN T cells represent a small subpopulation in normal (+/+) mice. We next showed that functional regulatory T cells which possess the ability to abrogate oral tolerance were induced in nu/nu mice by Ag priming. BALB/c nude mice were immunized with SRBC, and the splenic CD3+, Vicia villosa-adherent cells were obtained by panning. Adoptive transfer of CD3+, V. villosa-adherent T cells to orally tolerant BALB/c mice restored responsiveness to SRBC, whereas V. villosa nonadherent cells were without effect. In other experiments, CD3+ T cells from the spleens of SRBC-primed mice were further enriched for the CD5+, DN phenotype and adoptive transfer of this subset completely abrogated oral tolerance to SRBC. To characterize the nature of the TCR expressed on these CD3+, DN T cells, we developed a rabbit antibody to a synthetic peptide (residues 209-218: Tyr-Ala-Asn-Ser-Phe-Asn-Asn-Glu-Lys-Leu) which was synthesized from a deduced sequence of the murine delta-gene. Immunoprecipitation of a cell membrane fraction from CD3+, DN T cells with anti-delta TCR antibody isolated a 45-kDa band. Furthermore, immunoprecipitation of these cells with anti-CD3 (145-2C11) revealed bands at 45 and 35 kDa (corresponding to delta- and gamma-chains, respectively). Taken together, these results are the first to show that gamma delta-TCR bearing CD3+, CD4-, and CD8- T cells are functional and reverse oral tolerance when adoptively transferred.     

The origin of mesoderm in phoronids

Integrin alphaIIb is a cell adhesion molecule expressed in association with beta3 by cells of the megakaryocytic lineage, from committed progenitors to platelets. While it is clear that lymphohemopoietic cells differentiating along other lineages do not express this molecule, it has been questioned whether mammalian hemopoietic stem cells (HSC) and various progenitor cells express it. In this study, we detected alphaIIb expression in midgestation embryo in sites of HSC generation, such as the yolk sac blood islands and the hemopoietic clusters lining the walls of the major arteries, and in sites of HSC migration, such as the fetal liver. Since c-Kit, which plays an essential role in the early stages of hemopoiesis, is expressed by HSC, we studied the expression of the alphaIIb antigen in the c-Kit-positive population from fetal liver and adult bone marrow differentiating in vitro and in vivo into erythromyeloid and lymphocyte lineages. Erythroid and myeloid progenitor activities were found in vitro in the c-Kit(+)alphaIIb(+) cell populations from both origins. On the other hand, a T cell developmental potential has never been considered for c-Kit(+)alphaIIb(+) progenitors, except in the avian model. Using organ cultures of embryonic thymus followed by grafting into athymic nude recipients, we demonstrate herein that populations from murine fetal liver and adult bone marrow contain T lymphocyte progenitors. Migration and maturation of T cells occurred, as shown by the development of both CD4(+)CD8- and CD4-CD8(+) peripheral T cells. Multilineage differentiation, including the B lymphoid lineage, of c-Kit(+)alphaIIb(+) progenitor cells was also shown in vivo in an assay using lethally irradiated congenic recipients. Taken together, these data demonstrate that murine c-Kit(+)alphaIIb(+) progenitor cells have several lineage potentialities since erythroid, myeloid, and lymphoid lineages can be generated.     

Regulation of extrathymic T cell development and turnover by oncostatin M

Chronic exposure to oncostatin M (OM) has been shown to stimulate extrathymic T cell development. The present work shows that in OM transgenic mice, 1) massive extrathymic T cell development takes place exclusively the lymph nodes (LNs) and not in the bone marrow, liver, intestines, or spleen; and 2) LNs are the sole site where the size of the mature CD4+ and CD8+ T cell pool is increased (6- to 7-fold). Moreover, when injected into OM transgenic mice, both transgenic and nontransgenic CD4+ and CD8+ T cells preferentially migrated to the LNs rather than the spleen. Studies of athymic recipients of fetal liver grafts showed that lymphopoietic pathway modulated by OM was truly thymus independent, and that nontransgenic progenitors could generate extrathymic CD4+CD8+ cells as well as mature T cells under the paracrine influence of OM. The progeny of the thymic-independent differentiation pathway regulated by OM was polyclonal in terms of Vbeta usage, exhibited a phenotype associated with previous TCR ligation, and displayed a rapid turnover rate (5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine pulse-chase assays). This work suggests that chronic exposure to OM 1) discloses a unique ability of LNs to sustain extrathymic T cell development, and 2) increases the number and/or function of LN niches able to support seeding of recirculating mature T cells. Regulation of the lymphopoietic pathway discovered in OM transgenic mice could be of therapeutic interest for individuals with thymic hypoplasia or deficient peripheral T cell niches.