Induced thermotolerance in bovine two-cell embryos and the role of heat shock protein 70 in embryonic development

Induced thermotolerance is a phenomenon whereby exposure to a mild heat shock can induce heat shock proteins (HSP) and other cellular changes to make cells more resistant to a subsequent, more severe heat shock. Given that the 2-cell bovine embryo is very sensitive to heat shock, but can also produce HSP70 in response to elevated temperature, experiments were conducted to test whether 2-cell embryos could be made to undergo induced thermotolerance. Another objective was to test the role of the heat-inducible form of heat shock protein 70 (HSP70i) in development and sensitivity of bovine embryos to heat shock. To test for induced thermotolerance, 2-cell bovine embryos were first exposed to a mild heat shock (40 degrees C for 1 hr, or 41 degrees C or 42 degrees C for 80 min), allowed to recover at 38.5 degrees C and 5% (v/v) CO2 for 2 hr, and then exposed to a severe heat shock (41 degrees C for 4.5, 6, or 12 hr). Regardless of the conditions, previous exposure to mild heat shock did not reduce the deleterious effect of heat shock on development of embryos to the blastocyst stage. The role of HSP70i in embryonic development was tested in two experiments by culturing embryos with a monoclonal antibody to the inducible form of HSP70. At both 38.5 degrees C and 41 degrees C, the proportion of 2-cell embryos that developed to blastocyst was reduced (P < 0.05) by addition of anti-HSP70i to the culture medium. In contrast, sensitivity to heat shock was not generally increased by addition of antibody. In conclusion, bovine 2-cell embryos appear incapable of induced thermotolerance. Lack of capacity for induced thermotolerance could explain in part the increased sensitivity of 2-cell embryos to heat shock as compared to embryos at later stages of development. Results also implicate a role for HSP70i in normal development of bovine embryos.     

Heat shock affects cell cycling in the neural plate of cultured rat embryos: a flow cytometric study

The effects of heat shock on cell cycling in the mammalian neuroectoderm were determined by applying heat shocks to cultured rat embryos at the neural plate stage, as part of a study on the teratogenic effects of heat shock on neural development. The heat shocks had been characterized previously (Walsh et al.: Teratology 36:181-191, 1987) with respect to their effects on the gross morphological development of the rat embryos. The effects on cell cycling were observed in DNA histograms of neural plate cells recorded in a flow cytometer after staining with DAPI. The mild heat shock (42 degrees C for 10 min) arrested cells at entry to S phase. The teratogenic heat shock (43 degrees C for 7.5 min) arrested cells at entry to S phase also but for a longer time and inhibited cycling through S phase. After each arrest, a synchronized peak of cells later entered S phase and progressed through the cycle. The induced-thermotolerance heat shock, which was the mild heat shock followed after an interval by the teratogenic heat shock, showed that pre-treatment with the mild heat shock reduced the magnitude of the response to the teratogenic heat shock. The cell-cycle inhibitor ICRF 159 showed the effects on cycling rates of the heat-shock treatments. The arrest of cells at entry to S phase by heat shock may function to prevent cells entering DNA synthesis under non-optimal conditions. We report estimates of proportions of non-proliferative cells in the neural plate of the rat embryos.     

Lack of concordance between heat shock proteins and the development of tolerance to teratogen-induced neural tube defects

The present study was undertaken to examine the role of heat shock response in the development of tolerance and cross-tolerance in an in vivo murine model of teratogen-induced neural tube defects. The experimental paradigm designed to address this question was to utilize inbred mouse strains that differed in their sensitivity to hyperthermia and valproic acid induced neural tube defects, subjecting the dams to subteratogenic pretreatments with either heat or valproic acid at two different timepoints during development prior to the administration of the teratogenic insult. A statistically significant reduction in the frequency of neural tube defects and/or embryolethality following a pretreatment in dams subsequently exposed to a teratogenic treatment was considered evidence for the induction of tolerance. This was observed in the SWV embryos exposed to the 38°C pretreatment at 8:06 and to embryos exposed to either pretreatment temperature at 8:10 priorto a teratogenic heat shock at 8:12. In the LM/Bc embryos, only the 41°C pretreatment at 8:06 induced thermotolerance. There was no evidence of tolerance induced in either mouse strain using valproic acid. On the other hand, cross-tolerance was clearly demonstrated in this study, with a low temperature (41°C) pretreatment successfully protecting SWV fetuses from a subsequent teratogenic treatment with valproic acid, while valproic acid (200 mg/kg) was effective in reducing the risk of hyperthermia-induced neural tube defects in the LM/Bc fetuses. In all instances, tolerance was induced in the absence of significant induction of hsp synthesis. The lack ofconcordance between hsps and thermotolerance suggests that some other factor(s) is involved in conferring thermotolerance on developing murine embryos. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Induction of the heat shock response and translational thermotolerance in day 15 ovine trophectoderm

The objectives of this study were to determine the ability of trophectoderm from preimplantation ovine embryos to synthesize hsp70 in response to heat shock and to identify conditions which induce translational thermotolerance in this tissue. Day 15 embryos were collected, and proteins synthesized in 1.5-mm sections of trophectoderm were radioactively labeled with (35)S-methionine. One-dimensional SDS-PAGE gels, two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and Western blots were utilized to characterize the heat shock response and to examine the induction of translational thermotolerance. Increased synthesis of the 70 kDa heat shock proteins and a protein with an approximate molecular weight of 15 to 20 kDa was observed with heat shock (> or = 42 degrees C). Total protein synthesis decreased (P < 0.05) with increased intensity of heat shock. At 45 degrees C, protein synthesis was suppressed with little or no synthesis of all proteins including hsp70. Recovery of protein synthesis following a severe heat shock (45 degrees C for 20 min) occurred faster (P < 0.05) in trophectoderm pretreated with a mild heat shock (42 degrees C for 30 min) than trophectoderm not pretreated with mild heat. In summary, trophoblastic tissue obtained from ovine embryos exhibit the characteristic "heatshock" response similar to that described for other mammalian systems. In addition, a sublethal heat shock induced the ability of the tissue to resume protein synthesis following severe heat stress. Since maintaining protein synthesis is crucial to embryonic survival, manipulation of the heat-shock response may provide a method to enhance embryonic survival.     

Splicing thermotolerance maintains pre-mRNA transcripts in the splicing pathway during severe heat shock

Thermotolerance, the ability of cells and organisms to withstand severe elevated temperatures after brief exposure to mild elevated temperatures, has been studied in numerous laboratories. Survival thermotolerance is defined as the increase in cell or organism survival at severe elevated temperatures after a pretreatment at mild elevated temperatures. This study examines splicing thermotolerance in Drosophila melanogaster, the ability to splice pre-mRNAs made at the severe temperature (38 degrees C) after a brief pretreatment at a milder temperature (35 degrees C). It is probably one of a number of mechanisms by which cells adapt to heat shock. These experiments demonstrate that pre-mRNAs synthesized at the severe temperatures in splicing thermotolerant cells, although protected in splicing-competent complexes, are not actually processed to mature mRNAs until the cells are returned to their normal temperature. We have also studied the kinetics of acquisition and loss of splicing thermotolerance. As little as 10 min of pretreatment at 35 degrees C was sufficient to provide full splicing thermotolerance to a 30-min severe heat shock of 38 degrees C. Pretreatments of less than 10 min provide partial splicing thermotolerance for a 30-min severe heat shock. Full splicing thermotolerance activity begins to decay about 4 h after the cessation of the 35 degrees C incubation and is completely lost by 8 h after the pretreatment. The kinetics experiments of pre-mRNAs synthesized during the 38 degrees C treatment in splicing thermotolerant cells indicate that one or more splicing thermotolerance factors are synthesized during the 35 degrees C pretreatment which interact with pre-mRNA-containing complexes to keep them in a splicing-competent state. These kinetic experiments also indicate that in cells which are partially splicing thermotolerant, the pre-mRNAs synthesized early during the 38 degrees C incubation are protected, whereas those synthesized late are not. In the absence of splicing thermotolerant factors, the pre-mRNA-containing complexes leave the normal splicing pathway and are allowed to exit to the cytoplasm.     

Induced thermotolerance during early development of murine and bovine embryos

During early development, elevated temperatures have deleterious effects on embryonic viability and development. The primary objective of the current study was to determine the ontogeny of induced thermotolerance during early murine embryonic development. Embryos were either retrieved from superovulated ICR female mice at the 2 cell and 4 cell stages and cultured thereafter or were retrieved from oviducts or uterine horns at the desired stage of development. Induction of thermotolerance was detected by evaluating viability and further development after embryos were exposed to homeothermic temperature (37°C), mild heat shock (40°C for 1 h), severe heat shock (42°C for 1 h or 43°C for 2 h), or mild heat shock followed by severe heat shock (to induce thermotolerance). Induction of thermotolerance was observed beginning at the 8 cell stage when embryos were developed in culture from the 2 cell to 4 cell stage. When embryos were developed in vivo (i.e., were retrieved from the reproductive tract at the desired stage of development), thermotolerance was not induced until the blastocyst stage of development. The induction of thermotolerance was dependent on serum supplementation since induction of thermotolerance was not observed when embryos were placed in medium without serum. Induced thermotolerance could also be demonstrated in bovine blastocysts. In conclusion, embryos acquire the ability to undergo thermotolerance as they progress through development. The timing of processes leading to acquisition of thermotolerance can, however, be hastened by exposure of embryos to in vitro conditions.     

Role of glutathione and hsp 70 in the acquisition of thermotolerance in postimplantation rat embryos

Studies were initiated to determine the extent to which reduced glutathione (GSH) may be involved in the capacity of cultured rat embryos to develop heat-induced tolerance to the deleterious effects of exposure to high temperatures (heat shock). Investigations of the modulation of dysmorphogenic responses of embryos to heat shock (43 degrees C, 30 min) as well as to the expression of the hsp70 gene and subsequent formation of hsps indicated that the acquisition of thermotolerance by rat embryos could be significantly influenced by the inhibition of GSH synthesis. Treatment of conceptuses with L-buthionine-S,R-sulfoximine (BSO) reduced intracellular GSH concentrations and compromised the capacity of embryos to mount a thermotolerance response as assessed by alterations in indices of growth and development. Embryonic thermotolerance elicited by preexposure to 42 degrees C for 30 min was accompanied by increases in GSH to levels greater than those measured in control embryos at 37 degrees C just prior to the subsequent 43 degrees C heat exposure. Expression of hsp70 mRNA was detectable soon after elevation of the temperature to 42 degrees C and reached its highest level of accumulation 1.5 hr after the 43 degrees C heat shock. BSO treatment had little if any effect on hsp70 message levels or on the synthesis of hsp70. The fact that BSO-treatment attenuated the thermotolerance response but did not produce a decrease in hsp70 RNA or the synthesis of hsp70 suggests that hsp70 alone is not sufficient to confer thermotolerance upon cultured rat embryos.     

Heat shock-induced apoptosis in preimplantation bovine embryos is a developmentally regulated phenomenon

Apoptosis is a form of cell death that can function to eliminate cells damaged by environmental stress. One stress that can compromise embryonic development is elevated temperature (i.e., heat shock). For the current studies, we hypothesized that heat shock induces apoptosis in bovine embryos in a developmentally regulated manner. Studies were performed to 1) determine whether heat shock can induce apoptosis in preimplantation embryos, 2) test whether heat-induced apoptosis is developmentally regulated, 3) evaluate whether heat shock-induced changes in caspase activity parallel patterns of apoptosis, and 4) ascertain whether exposure to a mild heat shock can protect embryos from heat-induced apoptosis. As determined by TUNEL reaction, exposure of bovine embryos > or =16 cells on Day 5 after insemination to 41 or 42 degrees C for 9 h increased the percentage of cells undergoing apoptosis. In addition, there was a duration-dependent increase in the proportion of blastomeres that were apoptotic when embryos were exposed to temperatures of 40 or 41 degrees C, which are more characteristic of temperatures experienced by heat-stressed cows. Heat shock also increased caspase activity in Day 5 embryos. However, heat shock did not induce apoptosis in 2- or 4-cell embryos, nor did it increase caspase activity in 2-cell embryos. The apoptotic response of 8- to 16-cell-stage bovine embryos to heat shock depended upon the day after insemination that heat shock occurred. When 8- to 16-cell embryos were collected on Day 3 after insemination, heat shock of 41 degrees C for 9 h did not induce apoptosis. In contrast, when 8- to 16-cell embryos were collected on Day 4 after insemination and exposed to heat shock, there was an increase in the percentage of cells undergoing apoptosis. Exposure of 8- to 16-cell embryos at Day 4 to a mild heat shock of 40 degrees C for 80 min blocked the apoptotic response to a subsequent, more-severe heat shock of 41 degrees C for 9 h. In conclusion, apoptosis is a developmentally acquired phenomenon that occurs in embryos exposed to elevated temperature, and it can be prevented by induced thermotolerance.     

Teratogen-induced activation of ERK, JNK, and p38 MAP kinases in early postimplantation murine embryos

BACKGROUND: Although many teratogens are known to activate apoptotic pathways culminating in abnormal development, little is known about how the embryo transduces a teratogenic exposure into specific responses. Signal reception and transduction are regulated by a number of signal transduction pathways, including the extracellular signal-regulated protein kinases (ERKs), c-Jun N-terminal kinases (JNKs) and the stress-activated protein kinase, p38. METHODS: To analyze the effects of teratogens on MAP kinases, we used whole embryo culture, Western blot analyses, and antibodies recognizing inactive or active MAP kinases, or both. RESULTS: We show that heat shock (HS) induces a rapid, strong, but transient activation of ERK, JNK, and p38 with maximal activation occurring within 30 min of the heat shock. By contrast, cyclophosphamide (CP) and staurosporine (ST) failed to activate ERK or JNK during the time period studied (7. 5 hr). ST and CP did induce a low but reproducible activation of p38 beginning at around 3 hr and 5 hr, respectively, after the initiation of exposure. Previous work has shown that heat shock induces elevated cell death in the embryo, primarily in the developing neuroepithelium, but not in the embryonic heart. Thus, we also compared the activation of these three MAP kinase pathways in heads, hearts, and trunks isolated from day 9 embryos exposed to 43 degrees C for 15 min. The results show that ERK, JNK, and p38 are activated in heads, hearts, and trunks. CONCLUSIONS: Our results show that day 9 embryos do activate MAP kinase signaling pathways in response to teratogenic exposures; however, activation of a particular pathway does not appear to be required for teratogen-induced apoptosis.     

Acquisition of thermotolerance in sea urchin embryos correlates with the synthesis and age of the heat shock proteins

Preheating at 31 degrees C induces thermotolerance in Paracentrotus lividus embryos, which therefore become able to withstand 1-h treatment at the otherwise lethal temperature of 35 degrees C, and to develop normally. The acquisition of thermotolerance is positively correlated with the amount of heat shock proteins produced during the 31 degrees C treatment. Evidence is provided that the heat shock proteins, although present in the embryo for long periods after synthesis, lose their effect on thermotolerance within 3 h of the cessation of synthesis.     

Hyperthermia-induced heat shock response and thermotolerance in postimplantation rat embryos

Postimplantation stage rat embryos (6-10 somites) undergo abnormal development after exposure to a temperature of 43 degrees C for 30 min. A heat shock of 43 degrees C for 30 min also induces the synthesis of a set of eight heat shock proteins (hsps) with molecular masses ranging from 28,000 to 82,000 Da. The synthesis of these hsps is rapidly induced after the heat shock is applied and rapidly decays after embryos are returned to 37 degrees C. A heat shock of 42 degrees C for 30 min has no effect on rat embryo growth and development, but does induce the synthesis of three hsps. The most prominent of these three is believed to be the typical mammalian 70 kDa hsp. Furthermore, a 42 degrees C, 30-min heat shock followed by a 43 degrees C 30-min heat shock leads to partial protection from the embryotoxic effects of a single exposure at 43 degrees C, i.e., thermotolerance.     

Heat shock response of Saccharomyces cerevisiae mutants altered in cyclic AMP-dependent protein phosphorylation.

When Saccharomyces cerevisiae cells grown at 23 degrees C were transferred to 36 degrees C, they initiated synthesis of heat shock proteins, acquired thermotolerance to a lethal heat treatment given after the temperature shift, and arrested their growth transiently at the G1 phase of the cell division cycle. The bcy1 mutant which resulted in production of cyclic AMP (cAMP)-independent protein kinase did not synthesize the three heat shock proteins hsp72A, hsp72B, and hsp41 after the temperature shift. The bcy1 cells failed to acquire thermotolerance to the lethal heat treatment and were not arrested at the G1 phase after the temperature shift. In contrast, the cyr1-2 mutant, which produced a low level of cAMP, constitutively produced three heat shock proteins and four other proteins without the temperature shift and was resistant to the lethal heat treatment. The results suggest that a decrease in the level of cAMP-dependent protein phosphorylation results in the heat shock response, including elevated synthesis of three heat shock proteins, acquisition of thermotolerance, and transient arrest of the cell cycle.     

Induction of heat shock protein 27 in rat embryos exposed to hyperthermia

Previously we reported that eight proteins were reproducibly induced in postimplantation rat embryos exposed to a brief heat shock (43°C, 15 min). The major heat-inducible rat embryo protein has now been identified as heat shock protein 72 (Hsp 72). In addition, the induction of Hsp 72 is temporally correlated with induction of thermotolerance. One of the other rat embryo proteins previously shown to be induced by elevated temperature is a heat shock protein of approximately 27 kilodaltons (Hsp 27). In this report we show that this protein is recognized by an antibody directed against a conserved peptide sequence of Hsp 27. Unlike Hsp 72, Hsp 27 is constitutively expressed in the rat embryo in the absence of any thermal stress; however, the level of Hsp 27 is increased approximately 2–3-fold after thermal stress (43°C, 10 min). Immunohistochemical analysis revealed that the constitutively expressed Hsp 27 is localized primarily to cells of the heart, cells that are uniquely resistant to the cytotoxic effects of hyperthermia. After thermal stress, Hsp 27 is expressed in all tissues of the embryo. Finally, our data show that Hsp 27 exists in the rat embryo as three major isoforms indicative of different phosphorylation states. Furthermore, most Hsp 27 in the heart is phosphorylated, whereas in the rest of the embryo, nonphosphorylated Hsp 27 predominates. After thermal stress, levels of phosphorylated isoforms increase dramatically in nonheart tissues of the embryo. Together, these results suggest that Hsp 27 may play a role in the development of thermotolerance in the postimplantation mammalian embryo. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Response of preimplantation murine embryos to heat shock as modified by developmental stage and glutathione status

Summary Objectives were to characterize developmental changes in response to heat shock in the preimplantation mouse embryo and to evaluate whether ability to synthesize glutathione is important for thermal resistance in mouse embryos. Heat shock (41° C for 1 or 2 h) was most effective at disrupting development to the blastocyst stage when applied to embryos at the 2-cell stage that were delayed in development. Effects of heat shock on ability of embryos to undergo hatching were similar for 2-cell, 4-cell, and morula stage embryos. The phenomenon of induced thermotolerance, for which exposure to a mild heat shock increases resistance to a more severe heat shock, depended upon stage of development and whether embryos developed in vitro or in vivo. In particular, induced thermotolerance was observed for morulae derived from development in vivo but not for 2-cell embryos or morulae that developed in culture. Administration of buthionine sulfoximine to inhibit glutathione synthesis did not increase thermal sensitivity of 2-cell embryos or morulae but did reduce subsequent development of 2-cell embryos at both 37° and 41° C. In summary, changes in the ability of 2-cell through morula stages to continue to develop following a single heat shock were generally minimal. However, 2-cell embryos delayed in development had reduced thermal resistance, and therefore, maternal heat stress may be more likely to cause mortality of embryos that are already compromised in development. There were also developmental changes in the capacity of embryos to undergo induced thermotolerance. Glutathione synthesis was important for development of embryos but inhibition of glutathione synthesis did not make embryos more susceptible to heat shock.     

Effects of several factors on the heat-shock-induced thermotolerance of Listeria monocytogenes.

The influence of the temperature at which Listeria monocytogenes had been grown (4 or 37 degrees C) on the response to heat shocks of different durations at different temperatures was investigated. For cells grown at 4 degrees C, the effect of storage, prior to and after heat shock, on the induced thermotolerance was also studied. Death kinetics of heat-shocked cells is also discussed. For L. monocytogenes grown at 37 degrees C, the greatest response to heat shock was a fourfold increase in thermotolerance. For L. monocytogenes grown at 4 degrees C, the greatest response to heat shock was a sevenfold increase in thermotolerance. The only survival curves of cells to have shoulders were those for cells that had been heat shocked. A 3% concentration of sodium chloride added to the recovery medium made these shoulders disappear and decreased decimal reduction times. The percentage of cells for which thermotolerance increased after a heat shock was smaller the milder the heat shock and the longer the prior storage.     

Acquired thermotolerance and heat shock proteins in thermophiles from the three phylogenetic domains.

Thermophilic organisms from each of the three phylogenetic domains (Bacteria, Archaea, and Eucarya) acquired thermotolerance after heat shock. Bacillus caldolyticus grown at 60 degrees C and heat shocked at 69 degrees C for 10 min showed thermotolerance at 74 degrees C, Sulfolobus shibatae grown at 70 degrees C and heat shocked at 88 degrees C for 60 min showed thermotolerance at 95 degrees C, and Thermomyces lanuginosus grown at 50 degrees C and heat shocked at 55 degrees C for 60 min showed thermotolerance at 58 degrees C. Determinations of protein synthesis during heat shock revealed differences in the dominant heat shock proteins for each species. For B. caldolyticus, a 70-kDa protein dominated while for S. shibatae, a 55-kDa protein dominated and for T. lanuginosus, 31- to 33-kDa proteins dominated. Reagents that disrupted normal protein synthesis during heat shock prevented the enhanced thermotolerance.     

Responsiveness of early embryos to environmental insults: potential protective roles of HSP70 and glutathione

Early embryos are not as passive as previously thought. In the bovine, embryos as early as the 2-cell stage can respond to environmental insults at both the cellular and molecular level by altering expression of specific genes and synthesis of proteins. Moreover, sex related differences exist in how early embryos respond to otherwise hostile environments. As aggressive as early embryos may be to tolerate environment insults, the majority will fail to continue in development. Reduced developmental potential of embryos exposed to elevated temperatures is likely due to direct effects on the early embryo. However, as embryos proceed in development they acquire the ability to better withstand environmental insults. Developmental acquisition of tolerance to environmental stress may be contingent upon acquisition of protective biochemical mechanisms or simply due to increased cell numbers. Correlative evidence has suggested a potential role of heat shock protein 70 and glutathione for protection of embryos in face of elevated temperature. Of these two possibilities, HSP70 appears least likely to play a significant role in developmental acquisition of thermotolerance. Bovine embryos as early as the 2-cell stage, are able to mount a heat shock response; a developmental stage that is most sensitive to elevated temperatures. A more likely candidate for conferring increased resistance of early embryos to elevated temperature is glutathione.     

Development profile of the heat shock response in early embryos of Drosophila

Drosophila melanogaster embryos reared at 22 degrees C were subjected to a mild heat shock (40 min at 37 degrees C) at various ages in order to determine whether there are changes in the heat shock response during embryogenesis. The effects of the heat shock were measured by assaying (1), subsequent developmental abnormalities (2), developmental time (3), hatchability, and (4), the ability to synthesize the heat shock proteins as assayed by 35S-methionine pulse labeling followed by protein separations using both one-and two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Our data show that, first, proteins with molecular weights similar to those of six of the seven major heat shock proteins are normally found in the embryo at control temperatures (22 degrees C); second, that the pregastrula embryo (stages 2-6) is not capable of displaying any aspect of the heat shock response upon treatment, although it may possess all of the so-called heat shock proteins; third, that the complete heat shock response is acquired very rapidly by early gastrula embryos; and fourth, that the heat shock treatment brings about developmental delays and/or abnormalities, depending on the developmental stage of the embryo at the time of the treatment. These developmental abnormalities appear to stem from the failure of early embryos to completely inhibit their synthesis of non-heat-shock proteins. In the light of these findings, it becomes important not to base conclusions about the putative presence of a heat shock response in a particular tissue or developmental stage solely on the presence or absence of the heat shock proteins.     

Heat-shock induced tolerance to the embryotoxic effects of hyperthermia and cadmium in mouse embryos in vitro

Mammalian embryos growing in vitro are harmed by short elevations in the culture temperature. However, a relatively mild hyperthermic exposure can induce thermotolerance, a transient state of resistance to the effects of a subsequent heat exposure. The present study examines the induction of tolerance to heat and cross-tolerance to another teratogen, cadmium, in day 8 CD-1 mouse embryos in vitro. The ability of a mild heat pretreatment (5 min at 43 degrees C) to partially protect embryos against an embryotoxic heat exposure (20 min at 43 degrees C) was demonstrated. The frequency of death was reduced from 43% to 20%, abnormal branchial arches from 44% to 13.2%, and retarded turning from 22% to 5% in pretreated embryos. Other malformations, such as small forebrains and microphthalmia, were not affected, and the rate of exencephaly was significantly increased. The same heat pretreatment (5 min at 43 degrees C) was also found to reduce the damaging effects of a subsequent exposure to 1.75 microM cadmium. In the absence of pretreatment, cadmium caused 55% embryo deaths and 87% malformations, but prior heat exposure caused significant reductions in these frequencies to 29% and 55%. The total morphological score was higher in the pretreated group, as were the measurements of the yolk sac diameter, crown-rump length, and head length. Thus, embryos that have developed resistance to hyperthermia are also partially protected against the harmful effects of a second teratogen, cadmium. The response of the embryo to elevated temperatures may be involved in the development of tolerance to a variety of stresses.