Reactions of Cre with Methylphosphonate DNA: Similarities and Contrasts with Flp and Vaccinia Topoisomerase

Background

Reactions of vaccinia topoisomerase and the tyrosine site-specific recombinase Flp with methylphosphonate (MeP) substituted DNA substrates, have provided important insights into the electrostatic features of the strand cleavage and strand joining steps catalyzed by them. A conserved arginine residue in the catalytic pentad, Arg-223 in topoisomerase and Arg-308 in Flp, is not essential for stabilizing the MeP transition state. Topoisomerase or its R223A variant promotes cleavage of the MeP bond by the active site nucleophile Tyr-274, followed by the rapid hydrolysis of the MeP-tyrosyl intermediate. Flp(R308A), but not wild type Flp, mediates direct hydrolysis of the activated MeP bond. These findings are consistent with a potential role for phosphate electrostatics and active site electrostatics in protecting DNA relaxation and site-specific recombination, respectively, against abortive hydrolysis.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We have examined the effects of DNA containing MeP substitution in the Flp related Cre recombination system. Neutralizing the negative charge at the scissile position does not render the tyrosyl intermediate formed by Cre susceptible to rapid hydrolysis. Furthermore, combining the active site R292A mutation in Cre (equivalent to the R223A and R308A mutations in topoisomerase and Flp, respectively) with MeP substitution does not lead to direct hydrolysis of the scissile MeP bond in DNA. Whereas Cre follows the topoisomerase paradigm during the strand cleavage step, it follows the Flp paradigm during the strand joining step.

Conclusions/Significance

Collectively, the Cre, Flp and topoisomerase results highlight the contribution of conserved electrostatic complementarity between substrate and active site towards transition state stabilization during site-specific recombination and DNA relaxation. They have potential implications for how transesterification reactions in nucleic acids are protected against undesirable abortive side reactions. Such protective mechanisms are significant, given the very real threat of hydrolytic genome damage or disruption of RNA processing due to the cellular abundance and nucleophilicity of water.     

Unveiling hidden catalytic contributions of the conserved His/Trp-III in tyrosine recombinases: assembly of a novel active site in Flp recombinase harboring alanine at this position

The catalytic pentad of tyrosine recombinases, that assists the tyrosine nucleophile, includes a conserved histidine/tryptophan (His/Trp-III). Flp and Cre harbor tryptophan at this position; most of their kin recombinases display histidine. Contrary to the conservation rule, Flp(W330F) is a much stronger recombinase than Flp(W330H). The hydrophobicity of Trp330 or Phe330 is utilized in correctly positioning Tyr343 during the strand cleavage step of recombination. Why then is phenylalanine almost never encountered in the recombinase family at this conserved position? Using exogenous nucleophiles and synthetic methylphosphonate or 5'-thiolate substrates, we decipher that Trp330 also assists in the activation of the scissile phosphate and the departure of the 5'-hydroxyl leaving group. These two functions are consistent with the hydrogen bonding property of Trp330 as well as its location in structures of the Flp recombination complexes. However, van der Waals contact between Trp330 and Arg308 may also be important for the phosphate activation step. A structure based suppression strategy permits the inactive variant Flp(W330A) to be rescued by a second site mutation A339M. Modeling alanine and methionine at positions 330 and 339, respectively, in the Flp crystal structure suggests a plausible mechanism for active site restoration. Successful suppression suggests the possibility of evolving, by design, new active site configurations for tyrosine recombination.     

Electrostatic Suppression Allows Tyrosine Site-specific Recombination in the Absence of a Conserved Catalytic Arginine

The active site of the tyrosine family site-specific recombinase Flp contains a conserved catalytic pentad that includes two arginine residues, Arg-191 and Arg-308. Both arginines are essential for the transesterification steps of strand cleavage and strand joining in DNA substrates containing a phosphate group at the scissile position. During strand cleavage, the active site tyrosine supplies the nucleophile to form a covalent 3′-phosphotyrosyl intermediate. The 5′-hydroxyl group produced by cleavage provides the nucleophile to re-form a 3′-5′ phosphodiester bond in a recombinant DNA strand. In previous work we showed that substitution of the scissile phosphate (P) by the charge neutral methylphosphonate (MeP) makes Arg-308 dispensable during the catalytic activation of the MeP diester bond. However, in the Flp(R308A) reaction, water out-competes the tyrosine nucleophile (Tyr-343) to cause direct hydrolysis of the MeP diester bond. We now report that for MeP activation Arg-191 is also not required. In contrast to Flp(R308A), Flp(R191A) primarily mediates normal cleavage by Tyr-343 but also exhibits a weaker direct hydrolytic activity. The cleaved MeP-tyrosyl intermediate formed by Flp(R191A) can be targeted for nucleophilic attack by a 5′-hydroxyl or water and channeled toward strand joining or hydrolysis, respectively. In collaboration with wild type Flp, Flp(R191A) promotes strand exchange between MeP- and P-DNA partners. Loss of a catalytically crucial positively charged side chain can thus be suppressed by a compensatory modification in the DNA substrate that neutralizes the negative charge on the scissile phosphate.     

Active site electrostatics protect genome integrity by blocking abortive hydrolysis during DNA recombination

Water, acting as a rogue nucleophile, can disrupt transesterification steps of important phosphoryl transfer reactions in DNA and RNA. We have unveiled this risk, and identified safeguards instituted against it, during strand cleavage and joining by the tyrosine site‐specific recombinase Flp. Strand joining is threatened by a latent Flp endonuclease activity (type I) towards the 3′‐phosphotyrosyl intermediate resulting from strand cleavage. This risk is not alleviated by phosphate electrostatics; neutralizing the negative charge on the scissile phosphate through methylphosphonate (MeP) substitution does not stimulate type I endonuclease. Rather, protection derives from the architecture of the recombination synapse and conformational dynamics within it. Strand cleavage is protected against water by active site electrostatics. Replacement of the catalytic Arg‐308 of Flp by alanine, along with MeP substitution, elicits a second Flp endonuclease activity (type II) that directly targets the scissile phosphodiester bond in DNA. MeP substitution, combined with appropriate active site mutations, will be useful in revealing anti‐hydrolytic mechanisms engendered by systems that mediate DNA relaxation, DNA transposition, site‐specific recombination, telomere resolution, RNA splicing and retrohoming of mobile introns.     

Restoration of catalytic functions in Cre recombinase mutants by electrostatic compensation between active site and DNA substrate

Two conserved catalytic arginines, Arg-173 and Arg-292, of the tyrosine site-specific recombinase Cre are essential for the transesterification steps of strand cleavage and joining in native DNA substrates containing scissile phosphate groups. The active site tyrosine (Tyr-324) provides the nucleophile for the cleavage reaction, and forms a covalent 3′-phosphotyrosyl intermediate. The 5′-hydroxyl group formed during cleavage provides the nucleophile for the joining reaction between DNA partners, yielding strand exchange. Previous work showed that substitution of the scissile phosphate (P) by methylphosphonate (MeP) permits strand cleavage by a Cre variant lacking Arg-292. We now demonstrate that MeP activation and cleavage are not blocked by substitution of Arg-173 or even simultaneous substitutions of Arg-173 and Arg-292 by alanine. Furthermore, Cre(R173A) and Cre(R292A) are competent in strand joining, Cre(R173A) being less efficient. No joining activity is detected with Cre(R173A, R292A). Consistent with their ability to cleave and join strands, Cre(R173A) and Cre(R292A) can promote recombination between two MeP-full-site DNA partners. These findings shed light on the overall contribution of active site electrostatics, and tease apart distinctive contributions of the individual arginines, to the chemical steps of recombination. They have general implications in active site mechanisms that promote important phosphoryl transfer reactions in nucleic acids.     

DNA recognition, strand selectivity, and cleavage mode during integrase family site-specific recombination

We have probed the association of Flp recombinase with its DNA target using protein footprinting assays. The results are consistent with the domain organization of the Flp protein and with the general features of the protein-DNA interactions revealed by the crystal structures of the recombination intermediates formed by Cre, the Flp-related recombinase. The similarity in the organization of the Flp and Cre target sites and in their recognition by the respective recombinases implies that the overall DNA-protein geometry during strand cleavage in the two systems must also be similar. Within the functional recombinase dimer, it is the interaction between two recombinase monomers bound on either side of the strand exchange region (or spacer) that provides the allosteric activation of a single active site. Whereas Cre utilizes the cleavage nucleophile (the active site tyrosine) in cis, Flp utilizes it in trans (one monomer donating the tyrosine to its partner). By using synthetic Cre and Flp DNA substrates that are geometrically restricted in similar ways, we have mapped the positioning of the active and inactive tyrosine residues during cis and trans cleavage events. We find that, for a fixed substrate geometry, Flp and Cre cleave the labile phosphodiester bond at the same spacer end, not at opposite ends. Our results provide a model that accommodates local heterogeneities in peptide orientations in the two systems while preserving the global functional architecture of the reaction complex.     

Chimeras of the Flp and Cre recombinases: tests of the mode of cleavage by Flp and Cre

The Flp and Cre recombinases are members of the integrase family of tyrosine recombinases. Each protein consists of a 13 kDa NH(2)-terminal domain and a larger COOH-terminal domain that contains the active site of the enzyme. The COOH-terminal domain also contains the major determinants for the binding specificity of the recombinase to its cognate DNA binding site. All family members cleave the DNA by the attachment of a conserved nucleophilic tyrosine residue to the 3'-phosphate group at the sites of cleavage. In order to gain further insights into the determinants of the binding specificity and modes of cleavage of Flp and Cre, we have made chimeric proteins in which we have fused the NH(2)-terminal domain of Flp to the COOH-terminal domain of Cre ("Fre") and the NH(2)-terminal domain of Cre to the COOH-terminal domain of Flp ("Clp"). These chimeras have novel binding specificities in that they bind strongly to hybrid sites containing elements from both the Flp and Cre DNA targets but poorly to the native target sites.In this study we have taken advantage of the unique binding specificities of Fre and Clp to examine the mode of cleavage by Cre, Flp, Fre and Clp. We find that the COOH-terminal domain of the recombinases determines their mode of cleavage. Thus Flp and Clp cleave in trans whereas Cre and Fre cleave in cis. These results agree with the studies of Flp and with the cocrystal structure of Cre bound to its DNA target site. They disagree with our previous findings that Cre could carry out trans cleavage. We discuss the variations in the experimental approaches in order to reconcile the different results.     

Functional analysis of box I mutations in yeast site-specific recombinases Flp and R: pairwise complementation with recombinase variants lacking the active-site tyrosine.

The site-specific recombinases Flp and R from Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Zygosaccharomyces rouxii, respectively, are related proteins that belong to the yeast family of site-specific recombinases. They share approximately 30% amino acid matches and exhibit a common reaction mechanism that appears to be conserved within the larger integrase family of site-specific recombinases. Two regions of the proteins, designated box I and box II, also harbor a significantly high degree of homology at the nucleotide sequence level. We have analyzed the properties of Flp and R variants carrying point mutations within the box I segment in substrate-binding, DNA cleavage, and full-site and half-site strand transfer reactions. All mutations abolish or seriously diminish recombinase function either at the substrate-binding step or at the catalytic steps of strand cleavage or strand transfer. Of particular interest are mutations of Arg-191 of Flp and R, residues which correspond to one of the two invariant arginine residues of the integrase family. These variant proteins bind substrate with affinities comparable to those of the corresponding wild-type recombinases. Among the binding-competent variants, only Flp(R191K) is capable of efficient substrate cleavage in a full recombination target. However, this protein does not cleave a half recombination site and fails to complete strand exchange in a full site. Strikingly, the Arg-191 mutants of Flp and R can be rescued in half-site strand transfer reactions by a second point mutant of the corresponding recombinase that lacks its active-site tyrosine (Tyr-343). Similarly, Flp and R variants of Cys-189 and Flp variants at Asp-194 and Asp-199 can also be complemented by the corresponding Tyr-343-to-phenylalanine recombinase mutant.     

Biochemical and kinetic analysis of the RNase active sites of the integrase/tyrosine family site-specific DNA recombinases

In this study, we have used multiple strategies to characterize the mechanisms of the type I and type II RNA cleavage activities harbored by the Flp (pronounced here as "flip") site-specific DNA recombinase (Flp-RNase I and II, respectively). Reactions using half-sites pre-bound by step-arrest mutants of Flp agree with a "shared active site" being responsible for the type I reaction (as is the case with normal DNA recombination). In a "pre-cleaved" type I substrate containing a 3'-phosphotyrosyl bond, the Flp-RNase I activity can be elicited by either wild type Flp or by Flp(Y343F). Kinetic analyses of the type I reaction are consistent with the above observations and support the notion that the DNA recombinase and type I RNase active sites are identical. The type II RNase activity is expressed by Flp(Y343F) in a half-site substrate and is unaffected by the catalytic constitution of a Flp monomer present on a partner half-site. Reaction conditions that proscribe the assembly of a DNA bound Flp dimer have no effect on Flp-RNase II. These biochemical results, together with kinetic data, are consistent with the reaction being performed from a "non-shared active site" contained within a single Flp monomer. The Flp-related recombinase Cre, which utilizes a non-shared recombination active site, exhibits the type I RNA cleavage reaction. So far, we have failed to detect the type II RNase activity in Cre. Despite their differences in active site assembly, Cre functionally mimics Flp in being able to provide two functional active sites from a trimer of Cre bound to a three-armed (Y-shaped) substrate.     

Crystal structure of a Flp recombinase-Holliday junction complex: assembly of an active oligomer by helix swapping

The crystal structure of a Flp recombinase tetramer bound to a Holliday junction intermediate has been determined at 2.65 A resolution. Only one of Flp's two domains, containing the active site, is structurally related to other lambda integrase family site-specific recombinases, such as Cre. The Flp active site differs, however, in that the helix containing the nucleophilic tyrosine is domain swapped, such that it cuts its DNA target in trans. The Flp tetramer displays pseudo four-fold symmetry matching that of the square planar Holliday junction substrate. This tetramer is stabilized by additional novel trans interactions among monomers. The structure illustrates how mechanistic unity is maintained on a chemical level while allowing for substantial variation on the structural level within a family of enzymes.     

The Flp recombinase cleaves Holliday junctions in trans

The Flp site-specific recombinase is encoded by the 2 µm plasmid of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and is a member of the integrase family of recombinases. Like all members of the integrase family studied, Flp mediates recombination in two steps. First, a pair of strand exchanges creates a Holliday-like intermediate; second, this intermediate is resolved to recombinant products by a second pair of strand exchanges.
Evidence derived from experiments using linear substrates indicates that Flp's active site is composed of two Flp protomers. One binds to the Flp recognition target site (FRT site) and activates the scissile phosphodiester bond for cleavage. Another molecule of Flp bound elsewhere in the synaptic complex ( in trans ) donates the nucleophilic tyrosine that executes cleavage and thereby becomes covalently attached to the 3' phosphoryl group at the cleavage site.
It has previously been shown that Flp efficiently resolves synthetic, Holliday-like (χ) structures to linear products. In this paper, we examined whether resolution of χ structures by Flp also occurs via the trans cleavage mechanism. We used in vitro complementation studies of mutant Flp proteins as well as nicked χ structures to show that Flp resolves χ structures by trans cleavage. We propose a model for Flp-mediated recombination that incorporates trans cleavage at both the initial and resolution steps of strand exchange.     

FlEx‐based transgenic reporter lines for visualization of Cre and Flp activity in live zebrafish

Site‐specific recombinases such as Cre and Flp are invaluable tools for genetic manipulations, but their usage in zebrafish has been limited. Incorporating recently developed flip‐excision (FlEx) design that allows stable inversions, we have established zebrafish reporter lines that express bright and ubiquitous EGFP, but switch to express mCherry in the presence of Cre or Flp. Here, we demonstrate the stable inversion in the reporter lines, both in somatic cells and in the germ line by Cre or Flp, and the subsequent reinversion using the other recombinase. Using the reporter lines, we characterized cardiomyocyte‐specific Cre lines and neuronal progenitor‐specific and tamoxifen‐dependent Cre lines. We also used the reporter lines for screening Cre‐ and Flp‐based enhancer trap lines. Similar to the widely used Cre reporter lines in mice, these FlEx‐based reporter lines will facilitate the use of recombinases for genetic manipulations in zebrafish. genesis 47:484–491, 2009. © 2009 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Sequence of the loxP site determines the order of strand exchange by the Cre recombinase

Conservative site-specific recombinases of the integrase family carry out recombination via a Holliday intermediate. The Cre recombinase, a member of the integrase family, was previously shown to initiate recombination by cleaving and exchanging preferentially on the bottom strand of its loxP target sequence. We have confirmed this strand bias for an intermolecular recombination reaction that used wild-type loxP sites and Cre protein. We have examined the sequence determinants for this strand preference by selectively mutating the two asymmetric scissile base-pairs in the lox site (those immediately adjacent to the sites of cleavage by Cre). We found that the initial strand exchange occurs preferentially next to the scissile G residue. Resolution of the Holliday intermediate thus formed takes place preferentially next to the scissile A residue. Lys86, which contacts the scissile nucleotides in the Cre-lox crystal structures, was important for establishing the strand preference in the resolution of the loxP-Holliday intermediate, but not for the initiation of recombination between loxP sites.     

Peptide trapping of the Holliday junction intermediate in Cre-loxP site-specific recombination

Cre recombinase is a prototypical member of the tyrosine recombinase family of site-specific recombinases. Members of this family of enzymes catalyze recombination between specific DNA sequences by cleaving and exchanging one pair of strands between the two substrate sites to form a 4-way Holliday junction (HJ) intermediate and then resolve the HJ intermediate to recombinant products by a second round of strand exchanges. Recently, hexapeptide inhibitors have been described that are capable of blocking the second strand exchange step in the tyrosine recombinase recombination pathway, leading to an accumulation of the HJ intermediate. These peptides are active in the lambda-integrase, Cre recombinase, and Flp recombinase systems and are potentially important tools for both in vitro mechanistic studies and as in vivo probes of cellular function. Here we present biochemical and crystallographic data that support a model where the peptide inhibitor binds in the center of the recombinase-bound DNA junction and interacts with solvent-exposed bases near the junction branch point. Peptide binding induces large conformational changes in the DNA strands of the HJ intermediate, which affect the active site geometries in the recombinase subunits.     

Structural plasticity of the Flp-Holliday junction complex

The Flp recombinase, a member of the lambda integrase or tyrosine-based family of site-specific recombinases, is an interesting example of an enzyme whose catalytic activity is regulated by protein-protein contacts. It exhibits half-of-the-sites activity throughout its catalytic cycle. Flp is unique among these recombinases, in that it assembles each active site in trans through the interaction of two protein monomers within the catalytic tetramer, with isomerization of interacting pairs being essential to complete a full reaction. We report here the structure of a DNA-bound tetramer of Flpe, a variant of Flp that is more active at 37 degrees C than the wild-type recombinase. This new structure includes the first observation of a tyrosine recombinase with an invading 5'-OH poised to attack the covalent phosphotyrosine residue. Comparison with the previously determined Flp structure highlights differences in flexibility between the two types of protein-protein interfaces in the tetramer and better defines the range of conformations available to this remarkably flexible complex. These results suggest a steric occlusion model for enforcement of half-of-the-sites activity.     

Real-time single-molecule tethered particle motion analysis reveals mechanistic similarities and contrasts of Flp site-specific recombinase with Cre and λ Int

Flp, a tyrosine site-specific recombinase coded for by the selfish two micron plasmid of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, plays a central role in the maintenance of plasmid copy number. The Flp recombination system can be manipulated to bring about a variety of targeted DNA rearrangements in its native host and under non-native biological contexts. We have performed an exhaustive analysis of the Flp recombination pathway from start to finish by using single-molecule tethered particle motion (TPM). The recombination reaction is characterized by its early commitment and high efficiency, with only minor detraction from ‘non-productive’ and ‘wayward’ complexes. The recombination synapse is stabilized by strand cleavage, presumably by promoting the establishment of functional interfaces between adjacent Flp monomers. Formation of the Holliday junction intermediate poses a rate-limiting barrier to the overall reaction. Isomerization of the junction to the conformation favoring its resolution in the recombinant mode is not a slow step. Consistent with the completion of nearly every initiated reaction, the chemical steps of strand cleavage and exchange are not reversible during a recombination event. Our findings demonstrate similarities and differences between Flp and the mechanistically related recombinases λ Int and Cre. The commitment and directionality of Flp recombination revealed by TPM is consistent with the physiological role of Flp in amplifying plasmid DNA.     

Gene deletion from Plasmodium falciparum using FLP and Cre recombinases: Implications for applied site-specific recombination

The ability to manipulate the genome and induce site-specific recombination using either Flippase (FLP) or Cre recombinase has been useful in many systems including Plasmodium berghei for specific deletion events or to obtain conditional gene expression. To test whether these recombinases are active in Plasmodium falciparum we constructed gene knockouts that contain sequences recognised as templates for site-specific recombination. We tested the ability of FLP and Cre recombinases, expressed conditionally in P. falciparum, to mediate deletion of the human dihydrofolate reductase (hdhfr) drug resistance gene. We show that Cre recombinase is capable of efficient removal of hdhfr by site-specific recombination. In contrast, FLP recombinase is very inefficient, even at the optimum temperature of 30 °C for this enzyme. These results demonstrate that Cre recombinase can be utilised in P. falciparum for deletion of specific sequences such as drug resistance genes. This can be exploited for recycling of drug resistance cassettes and for the design of specific recombination events in P. falciparum.     

Functional analysis of Arg-308 mutants of Flp recombinase. Possible role of Arg-308 in coupling substrate binding to catalysis

The arginine residue at position 308 in the Flp recombinase corresponds to the only invariant arginine within the Int family of recombinases. Alterations of this residue result in Flp variants that retain substrate recognition, but form weaker protein-DNA complexes than wild type Flp. Furthermore, their DNA cleavage activity is significantly diminished. A conservative change of R308K results in a functional Flp variant; however, this protein has a lowered temperature optimum for recombination. The Arg-308 mutants can be stabilized on the DNA substrate through cooperativity with a partner Flp mutant that is tight binding. Thus, interactions between Flp monomers must be a relevant feature of the normal recombination reaction.     

Recommended Method for Chromosome Exploitation: RMCE-based Cassette-exchange Systems in Animal Cell Biotechnology

The availability of site-specific recombinases has revolutionized the rational construction of cell lines with predictable properties. Early efforts were directed to providing pre-characterized genomic loci with a single recombinase target site that served as an address for the integration of vectors carrying a compatible tag. Efficient procedures of this type had to await recombinases like ΦC31, which recombine attP and attB target sites in a one-way reaction – at least in the cellular environment of the higher eukaryotic cell. Still these procedures lead to the co-introduction of prokaryotic vector sequences that are known to cause epigenetic silencing. This review illuminates the actual status of the more advanced recombinase-mediated cassette exchange (RMCE) techniques that have been developed for the major members of site-specific recombinases (SR), Flp, Cre and ΦC31. In RMCE the genomic address consists of a set of heterospecific recombinase target (RT-) sites permitting the exchange of the intervening sequence for the gene of interest (GOI), as part of a similar cassette. This process locks the GOI in place and it is ‘clean’ in the sense that it does not co-introduce prokaryotic vector parts nor does it leave behind a selection marker.