病毒疫苗制备用不同核型VERO细胞系在裸鼠体内致癌/致瘤性的系统实验研究

生产疫苗用细胞系可能具有致瘤性,一些常用的细胞系需要检查不同代次有无致癌性。在建立传代细胞种子库与工作库基础上,对研制生产病毒活疫苗所用8株VERO细胞系在219只裸鼠进行了致癌(瘤)实验。本研究结果表明,VERO细胞染色体核型可发生变异,亚四倍体JA株与超二倍体KA株具有强的致癌性,不能用于致弱活病毒疫苗制备,但可替代HeLa细胞系用作恶性肿瘤阳性对照细胞。筛出无致瘤性的YB、dC、M和JB株亚二倍体VERO细胞系,可替代BHK-21细胞用于狂犬病减毒活疫苗制备。VERO细胞系染色体遗传相对稳定。不同代次变化不大。研究发现细胞染色体遗传特征决定致瘤性质并具有种属特异性,不同核型细胞致瘤性不同,细胞染色体数目变异大小和致癌性成正相关,通过体内外交替选育可在裸鼠体内快速选育成功高变异率肿瘤细胞系。高变异率HeLa或VERO细胞系移植于裸鼠可能产生恶性横纹肌样瘤。因此,应当强调疫苗生产用细胞系致瘤性评价的重要性。     

Tumor formation by SV40-transformed human cells in nude mice: the role of SV40 T antigens

Human cells transformed in vitro by SV40 rarely form tumors in nude mice. We examined whether these cells as a group are inherently nontumorigenic or whether they are potentially tumorigenic but rejected by the athymic host, possibly by nonspecific immune mechanisms. SV80 and NG8 are SV40-transformed human cell lines that express all of the transformed properties, including anchorage-independent growth, but do not form tumors in adult nude mice after injection of as many as 10(8) cells. Both the SV80 and NG8 cell lines have SV40-specific transplantation antigens which crossreact with those present on SV40-transformed (but tumorigenic) rodent cells. We found that SV80 cells, though not NG8 cells, induced progressively growing lethal tumors if the cells are injected repeatedly into neonatal nude mice. Somatic cell hybrids between SV80 or NG8 cells and a highly tumorigenic cell line derived from a human tumor continue to express the virus-induced antigens and fail to form tumors in adult nude mice. These results strongly suggest that at least for some SV40-transformed human cells, the failure to form tumors in nude mice may be due to their expression of virus-induced transplantation antigens rather than the absence of tumorigenic potential.     

Tumorigenicity of Vero cells

One of the current criteria for evaluating the acceptability of cell lines for use in vaccine production is lack of tumorigenicity. Vero cells represent an example of a class of cells known as continuous cell lines. They were derived from African green monkey kidney, and their growth properties and culture characteristics have many advantages over other cell substrates for use in vaccine production. We have tested Vero cells for tumorigenicity in nude mice and in a human muscle organ culture system, and found a significant increase in their tumorigenic potential with increasing passage numbers. Cells at passage 232 and higher produced nodules in all nude mice inoculated. Histologically the nodules were well defined, anaplastic tumors, which exhibited some of the characteristics of renal adenocarcinomas. In about 6 to 8 days all of the nodules began to regress. Data were obtained that suggested an immune mechanism was the basis for the regression phenomenon.     

Evaluation of tumorigenic potential of high yielding cloned MDCK cells for live-attenuated influenza vaccine using in vitro growth characteristics,metastatic gene expression and in vivo nude mice model

Several mammalian cell lines, including Madin–Darby canine kidney (MDCK) cells have been approved by regulators for manufacturing of human vaccines. A new MDCK 9B9-1E4 cloned cell line has been created which is capable of producing live attenuated influenza vaccine (LAIV) with high yield. This cell line was shown to be non tumorigenic in eight week old adult athymic nude mouse model. This property is desirable for vaccine production and is unique to this cell line and is not known to be shared by other MDCK cell lines that are currently used for vaccine production. This significant difference in tumorigenic phenotype required further characterization of this cell line to ensure its safety for use in vaccine production. This is particularly important for LAIV production where it is not possible to incorporate a virus inactivation and/or removal step during manufacturing. Characterization of this cell line included extensive adventitious agent testing, tumorigenicity and oncogenicity assessment studies. Here, we describe the development of tumorigenic MDCK cell lines for use as positive controls and in vitro methods to aid in the evaluation of the tumorigenicity of MDCK 9B9-1E4 cloned cells. Tumorigenic MDCK cells were successfully generated following Hras and cMyc oncogene transfection of MDCK 9B9-1E4 cloned cells. In this study we demonstrate the lack of tumorigenic potential of the MDCK 9B9-1E4 cloned cell line in adult athymic nude mice model.     

Heterogeneity of the tumorigenic phenotype expressed by Madin-Darby canine kidney cells

The mechanisms by which cells spontaneously immortalized in tissue culture develop the capacity to form tumors in vivo likely embody fundamental processes in neoplastic development. The evolution of Madin-Darby canine kidney (MDCK) cells from presumptively normal kidney cells to immortalized cells that become tumorigenic represents an example of neoplastic development in vitro. Studies of the mechanisms by which spontaneously immortalized cells develop the capacity to form tumors would benefit from quantitative in vivo assays. Most mechanistic correlations are evaluated by using single-dose tumor-induction experiments, which indicate only whether cells are or are not tumorigenic. Here we used quantitative tumorigenicity assays to measure dose-and time-dependent tumor development in nude mice of 3 lots of unmodified MDCK cells. The results revealed lot-to-lot variations in the tumorigenicity of MDCK cells, which were reflected by their tumor-inducing efficiency (threshold cell dose represented by mean tumor-producing dose; log(10) 50% endpoints of 5.2 for vial 1 and 4.4 for vial 2, and a tumor-producing dose of 5.8 for vial 3) and mean tumor latency (vial 1,6.6 wk; vial 2,2.9 wk; and vial 3,3.8 wk). These studies provide a reference for further characterization of the MDCK cell neoplastic phenotype and may be useful in delineating aspects of neoplastic development in vitro that determine tumor-forming capacity. Such data also are useful when considering MDCK cells as a reagent for vaccine manufacture.     

Synergy between Apc min and an activated ras mutation is sufficient to induce colon carcinomas.

Colon carcinomas appear to arise from the cumulative effect of mutations to several genes (APC, DCC, p53, ras, hMLH1, and hMSH2). By using novel colonic epithelial cell lines derived from the Immorto mouse, named the YAMC (young adult mouse colon) cell line, and an Immorto-Min mouse hybrid, named the IMCE (Immorto-Min colonic epithelial) cell line, carrying the Apc min mutation, we investigated the effect of an activated v-Ha-ras gene on tumor progression. The YAMC and IMCE cell lines are normal colonic epithelial cell lines which are conditionally immortalized by virtue of expression of a temperature-sensitive simian virus 40 (SV40) large T antigen. Under conditions which permit expression of a functional SV40 large T antigen (33 degrees C plus gamma interferon), neither the YAMC nor the IMCE cell line grows in soft agar or is tumorigenic in nude mice. In vitro, when the SV40 large T antigen is inactivated (39 degrees C without gamma interferon), the cells stop proliferating and die. By infecting the YAMC and IMCE cell lines with a replication-defective psi2-v-Ha-ras virus, we derived cell lines which overexpress the v-Ha-ras gene (YAMC-Ras and IMCE-Ras). In contrast to the parental cell lines, under conditions in which the SV40 large T antigen is inactive, both the YAMC-Ras and IMCE-Ras cell lines continue to proliferate. Initally YAMC-Ras cells do not form tumors; however, tumors are visible after 90 days of incubation. IMCE-Ras cells form colonies in soft agar under both permissive and nonpermissive culture conditions. Furthermore, IMCE-Ras cells form tumors in nude mice within 3 weeks. The phenotype of the IMCE-Ras cell line thus clearly demonstrates that a defective Apc allele and an activated ras gene are sufficient to transform normal colonic epithelial cells and render them tumorigenic.     

Conversion of premalignant human cells to tumorigenic cells by methylmethane sulfonate and methylnitronitrosoguanidine

Nine human tumor cell lines derived from both epithelial and mesenchymal tumors exhibited either an anchorage-independent growth non-tumorigenic phenotype or an anchorage-independent tumorigenic phenotype. Transformed epithelial cell lines with the non-tumorigenic phenotype could be converted to a progressively growing tumor phenotype following treatment with either methylmethane sulfonate (MMS) or N-methyl-N-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG). In contrast, sarcoma derived cell lines with a non-tumorigenic phenotype could be converted to a progressively growing tumor phenotype only with MNNG. SV40 immortalized HET-1A non-tumorigenic phenotype cells could be converted to a progressively growing tumorigenic phenotype, infrequently, when treated with MNNG, but not MMS. Progressively growing tumors produced by either MMS or MNNG treated non-tumorigenic phenotypes exhibited metastatic potential in nude mice. Chemically treated HET-1A cells acquired the ability to produce tumor in mice but the tumor did not exhibit metastatic potential. In contrast, populations of tumorigenic cells were not rendered more biologically aggressive after treatment with either MMS or MNNG; i.e., the latency period for tumor development was not accelerated and the tumors did not exhibit metastatic potential. These results suggest that the biological effects of MMS and MNNG on non-tumorigenic, tumorigenic and immortalized cell lines are phenotype specific.Abbreviations AIG anchorage-independent growth - DMSO dimethyl sulfoxide - FBS fetal bovine serum - GM growth medium - MEM Eagle's minimum essential medium - MMS methylmethane sulfonate - MNNG N-Methyl-N-Nitro-N-Nitrosoguanidine - PDL population doubling - SCC squamous cell carcinoma     

In vivo or in vitro selection for resistance to natural cytotoxic cell lysis selects for variants with increased tumorigenicity

Experiments were designed to test the hypothesis that transformed cells that are NC sensitive must escape NC activity if they are to grow as tumors in normal individuals. NC-resistant variants were selected either in vivo or in vitro from NC-sensitive cell lines that grow as tumors in immunodeficient mice but not in syngeneic normal mice. The tumorigenicity of cloned NC-resistant variants was compared with the parental cell lines and to cell lines that went through the selection procedure, but after cloning remained NC sensitive. Cloned NC-resistant cell lines derived from tumors that developed in x-irradiated nude mice after the injection of an NC-sensitive cell line are tumorigenic in normal mice, whereas cloned NC-sensitive cell lines derived from the same tumors are unable to grow as tumors in normal mice. Similarly, six of seven NC-resistant cloned cell lines independently isolated after in vitro selection for NC-resistance are tumorigenic in normal mice, whereas cloned NC-sensitive cell lines isolated from the same in vitro selected populations are not tumorigenic in normal mice. Thus, either the in vivo or in vitro selection of NC-resistant cells selects for cells tumorigenic in normal mice; these findings, along with our previous observations that selection for cells tumorigenic in normal mice selects for NC resistance, provide compelling evidence that escape from NC activity is required before some transformed cells can grow as tumors in normal mice.     

Tumorigenicity testing of primate cell lines in nude mice, muscle organ culture and for colony formation in soft agarose

Primate neoplastic and finite cell lines were tested in one in vivo and two in vitro test systems: adult nude mice, muscle organ culture (MOC) and soft agarose (SA). Comparison of the sensitivity of the systems indicated that nude mice were inferior to either in vitro system: WI-38 VA13 (an SV40 transformed cell line) did not cause tumours in these animals yet it behaved as if it were neoplastic in MOC and formed colonies in SA. There was complete correlation between results obtained in MOC and SA. All cell lines which produced tumors in vivo were positive in both in vitro test systems. None of the lines which showed normal patterns in MOC and in SA was tumorigenic in nude mice. Since testing in vitro is simpler, faster, and is thought to be reliable, we recommend SA followed by MOC as the initial assays for determining tumorigenicity of cells.     

Expression of retrovirus-related, cytotoxic T lymphocyte- and transplantation-defined antigens in NIH/3T3 transfectants after a single passage in nude mice

Transfection of T24c-Ha-ras oncogene into NIH/3T3 fibroblasts resulted in the establishment of a transformed cell line (pT) that was tumorigenic when injected s.c. both into Swiss outbred nude mice and normal NIH inbred mice. The passage into nude mice, however, led to the development of a tumor variant (pT-nude) able to subsequently grow into sublethally x-irradiated but not into immunocompetent NIH mice. NIH mice immunized with this tumor variant developed a strong specific CTL response against the immunizing cell line, whereas the parental transformed pT cell line was not lysed. Clones were derived by limiting dilution from anti-pT-nude bulk population and were tested on a panel of transformed NIH/3T3 lines before and after their growth as tumor into nude mice. All of these lines were lysed by the Lyt-2+ CTL clones as a sole consequence of one in vivo passage into nude mice. The cross-reactive Ag were shown to be related to endogenous retroviral products as assessed by 1) immunoprecipitations of gp70, p15E, and p30 viral proteins in the nude variants but not in parental lines, and 2) by the ability of retroviruses from irradiated pT-nude cells to infect NIH/3T3 or pT lines making them susceptible to lysis by anti-pT-nude CTL clones. These results show that a single passage in nude mice can induce retrovirus-related, cell-surface Ag in transplanted neoplastic cells.     

Transforming viruses directly reduce the cellular growth requirement for a platelet derived growth factor

Early passage mouse embryo fibroblasts, mouse 3T3 cell lines, and early passage diploid human fibroblasts grew to higher cell densities in tissue culture medium supplemented with serum than in medium supplemented with defibrinogenated platelet-poor plasma (PPP). Unlike the mouse cells, the human fibroblasts displayed this differential growth response only in the presence of hypophysiologic concentrations of calcium. The addition of heat-treated extracts of human platelets to PPP-supplemented medium stimulated the replication of both the normal mouse cells and early passage human embryo fibroblasts. Human or mouse fibroblasts transformed by either retroviruses or by SV40, including SV40 infected “serum revertants” and “flat transformants,” grew to equal cell densities in medium supplemented with either serum or PPP. Infection of Balb/c-3T3 cells with SV40 rapidly induced them to grow in PPP-supplemented medium demonstrating that the ability of SV40-transformed cell lines to proliferate in PPP-supplemented medium does not arise from the cell culture selection procedures usually employed to obtain stable virus-transformed cell lines. 3T3 cells infected but not transformed by retroviruses do not replicate in PPP-supplemented medium demonstrating that reduction of the growth requirement for the platelet growth factor(s) by retroviruses is a transformation-specific response. Cell cultures that did not proliferate well in PPP-supplemented medium did not form tumors when inoculated into athymic nude mice. Many, although not all, of the lines which grew well in PPP medium were tumorigenic in nude mice. Together, these findings indicate that: (1) normal fibroblast-like cells display a growth requirement for factor(s) present in serum but not found in PPP; (2) this serum specific growth factor is derived from platelets; (3) a primary response to viral transforming genes is a reduction in the growth requirement for these platelet-derived factors; and (4) cells that have a reduced requirement for the platelet-derived growth factor are often tumorigenic.     

Kaposi's sarcoma-like tumors in a human herpesvirus 8 ORF74 transgenic mouse

The product of human herpesvirus 8 (HHV-8) open reading frame 74 (ORF74) is related structurally and functionally to cellular chemokine receptors. ORF74 activates several cellular signaling pathways in the absence of added ligands, and NIH 3T3 cells expressing ORF74 are tumorigenic in nude mice. We have generated a line of transgenic (Tg) mice with ORF74 driven by the simian virus 40 early promoter. A minority (approximately 30%) of the Tg mice, including the founder, developed tumors resembling Kaposi's sarcoma (KS) lesions, which occurred most typically on the tail or legs. The tumors were highly vascularized, had a spindle cell component, expressed VEGF-C mRNA, and contained a majority of CD31(+) cells. CD31 and VEGF-C are typically expressed in KS. Tumors generally (but not always) occurred at single sites and most were relatively indolent, although several mice developed large visceral tumors. ORF74 was expressed in a minority of cells in the Tg tumors and in a few other tissues of mice with tumors; mice without tumors did not express detectable ORF74 in any tissues tested. Cell lines established from tumors expressed ORF74 in a majority of cells, expressed VEGF-C mRNA, and were tumorigenic in nude mice. The resultant tumors grew rapidly, metastasized, and continued to express ORF74. Cell lines established from these secondary tumors also expressed ORF74 and were tumorigenic. These data strongly suggest that ORF74 plays a role in the pathology of KS and confirm and extend previous findings on the tumorigenic potential of ORF74.     

Environmental induction of differentiation-specific keratins in malignant mouse keratinocyte lines

Four spontaneously transformed keratinocyte lines (HELP I-IV) were raised from primary cultures of mouse epidermal cells grown on gas-permeable (Petriperm) dishes. Although tumorigenic, these cell lines still expressed the differentiated phenotype under mesenchymal influence in vivo in a fashion similar to normal cells and in contrast to previous observations on other transformed cell lines. Initially, after transplantation onto adult mice, HELP cells generally formed well organized ortho-keratinizing epithelia closely resembling those of normal epidermal cells. Later, dysplastic epithelia and papilloma-like structures developed and cells invaded subcutaneous host tissue. When injected subcutaneously into newborn syngeneic mice, all four cell lines gave rise to differentiated carcinomas at high frequency. Keratinized metastases were detected in the lung with HELP I, albeit at low frequency. Although the four HELP cell lines differed morphologically and biochemically in their degree of ortho-keratinization, no inverse relationship to their malignant potential was evident. In contrast to cell cultures, HELP transplants and tumors expressed epidermis-type "suprabasal" keratins. Metabolic labeling and electrophoresis on one and two-dimensional gels revealed both the basic 67 kilodaltons (kDa) and acidic 58 kDa components, including presumptive derivatives analogous to those observed in epidermal stratum corneum. However, associated with alterations in tissue architecture, the spatial control of keratin expression was gradually lost in papilloma-like and invading transplants and tumors, as demonstrated by indirect immunofluorescence microscopy (IIF). Thus, while cell differentiation appeared virtually normal, the progressive disturbances in tissue differentiation indicate important changes in the responsiveness of these malignant keratinocytes to environmental conditions.     

Decreased tumorigenicity correlates with expression of altered cell surface carbohydrates in Lec9 CHO cells.

To investigate a role for surface carbohydrates in cellular malignancy, 15 different glycosylation-defective CHO cell mutants were examined for their tumorigenic and metastatic capacities after subcutaneous injection into nude mice. Most of the glycosylation mutants displayed similar or slightly decreased tumorigenicity compared with parental CHO cells. Neither parental CHO cells nor any of the mutants were observed to metastasize. However, independent isolates of one mutant type, Lec9, showed a dramatic reduction in tumor formation. The altered carbohydrates expressed at the surface of Lec9 cells appeared to be responsible for their loss of tumorigenicity, because revertants for lectin resistance were able to form tumors, and a double mutant (Lec9.Lec1) that expressed a Lec1 glycosylation phenotype also formed tumors. Finally, Lec9 cells were able to form tumors in gamma-irradiated nude mice, suggesting that recognition by an irradiation-sensitive host cell(s) was responsible for their reduced tumorigenicity in untreated nude mice.     

Karyotype evolution of the human HBL-100 cell line and mapping of the integration site of SV40 DNA

Cytogenetic analysis of the human HBL-100 cell line, that we have previously shown to harbour SV40 genetic information (Caron de Fromentel et al., 1985), reveals numerous chromosomal rearrangements as soon as the 30th in vitro passage. The karyotype is relatively stable during in vitro maintenance and even at late passages (approximately 70) when the cells have acquired the capacity to form tumors in nude mice. In all the somatic cell hybrids obtained after fusion of mouse 3T3-4E cells with HBL-100 cells, several human chromosomes are maintained and a derivative from chromosome 15-der(15)- is the most frequently observed. The der(15) marker is present in the HBL-100 cell line at every passage studied as well as in different cell lines derived from tumors induced by HBL-100 cells. The various hybrids, originally isolated for a transformed phenotype on the basis of their ability to grow in soft-agar, were all found to express the SV40 T-antigen. In situ hybridization of an SV40 DNA probe to chromosome spreads obtained from one of these hybrids shows that the integration site of the viral genome is located on the der(15) marker chromosome, at band 15q24. The possible cooperation of SV40 T-antigen with some other oncogene(s), required by human HBL-100 cells in order to express a malignant phenotype, is discussed.     

Properties of T antigen-positive phenotypic revertants isolated from SV40-transformed rat and mouse cells

Four T antigen-positive phenotypic revertants were isolated by negative selection with BUdR from SV40-transformed rat and mouse cells which contain six and two viral genome equivalents per cell, respectively. Karyological analysis indicated that one rat and one mouse revertant had a hyperploid number of chromosomes, while the remaining two rat revertants had a subtetraploid number similar to those of the transformed parent cells. The hyperploid revertants were unable to grow in soft agar medium and were nontumorigenic in nude mice. One of the subtetraploid revertants formed large colonies at a very low frequency and induced tumors after a prolonged incubation period. These results indicate that there is a good correlation between the capacity of cells to grow without anchorage and the capacity to form tumors in nude mice and suggest that the revertant phenotype is stable in the presence of T antigen when the number of chromosomes is greatly increased as compared with that of the transformed parent cells.     

Suppression of tumorigenicity in transformed cells after transfection with vinculin cDNA

Transfection of chicken vinculin cDNA into two tumor cell lines expressing diminished levels of the endogenous protein, brought about a drastic suppression of their tumorigenic ability. The SV-40-transformed Balb/c 3T3 line (SVT2) contains four times less vinculin than the parental 3T3 cells, and the rat adenocarcinoma BSp73ASML has no detectable vinculin. Restoration of vinculin in these cells, up to the levels found in 3T3 cells, resulted in an apparent increase in substrate adhesiveness, a decrease in the ability to grow in soft agar, and suppression of their capacity to develop tumors after injection into syngeneic hosts or nude mice. These results suggest that vinculin, a cytoplasmic component of cell-matrix and cell-cell adhesions, may have a major suppressive effect on the transformed phenotype.     

Cellular tumorigenicity in nude mice. Test of associations among loss of cell-surface fibronectin, anchorage independence, and tumor-forming ability

Fibronectin (FN; also called large external transformation-sensitive [LETS] protein or cell-surface protein [CSP]) is a large cell-surface glycoprotein that is frequently observed to be either absent or greatly reduced on the surfaces of malignant cells grown in vitro. Because FN may be a useful molecular marker of cellular malignancy, we have carried out an extensive screening to test the specific association among the degree of expression of FN, anchorage-independent growth, and tumorigenicity in the athymic nude mouse. A variety of diploid cell strains and established cell lines were tested for the expression of surface FN by indirect immunofluorescence using rabbit antisera against human cold insoluble globulin, rodent plasma FN, or chicken cell- surface FN. Concomitantly, the cells were assayed for tumor formation in nude mice and for the ability to form colonies in methylcellulose. Tumorigenic cells often showed very low surface fluorescence, confirming earlier reports. However, many highly tumorigenic fibroblast lines from several species stained strongly with all three antisera. In contrast, the anchorage-independent phenotype was nearly always associated with tumorigenicity in approximately 35 cell lines examined in this study. In another series of experiments, FN-positive but anchorage-independent cells were grown as tumors in nude mice and then reintroduced into culture. In five of the six tumor-derived cell lines, cell-surface FN was not significantly reduced; one such cell line showed very little surface FN. Our data thus indicate that the loss of cell-surface FN is not a necessary step in the process of malignant transformation and that the growth of FN-positive cells as tumors does not require a prior selection in vivo for FN-negative subpopulations.     

Malignant transformation of immortalized transgenic hepatocytes after transfection with hepatitis B virus DNA

Persistent infection by hepatitis B virus (HBV) is epidemiologically correlated with the prevalence of hepatocellular carcinoma, but its role in tumor development is not yet understood. To study the putative oncogenic potential of HBV, a non-malignant immortal mouse hepatocyte line FMH202 harboring metallothionein promoter-driven simian virus 40 large tumor antigen was transfected with HBV DNA. All stably transfected clones which replicated HBV displayed malignant growth characteristics in soft agar and were tumorigenic upon inoculation in nude mice. The nude mice tumors were histologically classified as differentiated or anaplastic hepatocellular carcinomas. As with human liver carcinomas, rearrangements of in vitro integrated HBV sequences were observed in the nude mouse tumors, and in tumor-derived cell lines. In one case, expression of viral core and surface antigens was blocked in the tumors, correlating with hypermethylation of the HBV genome. However, the expression of X gene was maintained in most tumors and tumor-derived cell lines. X protein was detected in nuclei by immune fluorescence and by immune blot. These results provide the first demonstration that HBV displays oncogenic potential in an experimental system. This system could be useful to functionally identify HBV genes which convey a tumorigenic phenotype.