Evidence that DNA fragmentation in apoptosis is initiated and propagated by single-strand breaks

Apoptosis is characterised by the degradation of DNA into a specific pattern of high and low molecular weight fragments seen on agarose gels as a distribution of sizes between 50-300 kb and sometimes, but not always, a ladder of smaller oligonucleosomal fragments. Using a 2D pulsed field-conventional agarose gel electrophoresis technique, where the second dimension is run under either normal or denaturing conditions, we show that single-strand breaks are introduced into DNA at the initial stages of fragmentation. Using single-strand specific nuclease probes we further show that the complete fragmentation pattern, including release of small oligonucleosomal fragments can also be generated by a single-strand endonuclease. Three classes of sites where single-strand breaks accumulate were identified. The initial breaks produce a distribution of fragment sizes (50 kb to >1 Mb) similar to those generated by Topoisomerase II inhibitors suggesting that cleavage may commence at sites of attachment of DNA to the nuclear matrix. A second class of rare sites is also cut further reducing the size distribution of the fragments to 50-300 kb. Thirdly, single-strand breaks accumulate at the linker region between nucleosomes eventually causing double-strand scissions which release oligonucleosomes. These observations further define the properties of the endonuclease responsible for DNA fragmentation in apoptosis.     

DNA loop organization and DNA fragmentation during radiation-induced apoptosis in human lymphocytes

Apoptotic DNA fragmentation induced by gamma-rays has been compared with the DNA loop sizes in G0-human lymphocytes using pulsed field gel electrophoresis (PFGE). Genomic DNA was cleaved into the DNA loops at the topoisomerase II mediated attachment points using short treatment of cells with etoposide. The apoptotic fragmentation, with a distinct cut-off around 50 kb for a maximum length of fragments, appeared 5 h after irradiation when the most part of radiation-induced DNA double strand breaks (DSBs) have been repaired. The data indicate that apoptotic fragmentation of DNA in the G0-human lymphocytes begins when repair of radiation-induced DSBs has been completed. Similar apoptotic DNA fragmentation was also observed following the treatment of cells with etoposide. All genomic DNA was fragmented into 50-kb fragments during the final stages of apoptosis. Most of the DNA in resting lymphocytes is organized into Mb-size loops but loops of sizes down to 50 kb were also observed. A sharp border between the size distributions of DNA loops and apoptotic fragments was found. The data suggest that 50 kb apoptotic fragmentation is not based on excision of the DNA loops. No apoptotic fragments with the sizes more than 5.7 Mb were seen during the whole course of apoptosis. This observation indicates that despite intensive apoptotic fragmentation into the 50-kb fragments the chromosomes maintain integrity during radiation-induced apoptosis in human lymphocytes. We propose a model for radiation-induced apoptotic fragmentation in human lymphocytes that involves four stages: induction of DNA breaks and relaxation of DNA loops; DNA repair followed by reorganization of the DNA loops into the 50-kb units of condensed chromatin; co-operative fragmentation of the reorganized DNA loops into the distinct 50-kb fragments and resealing of the chromosome ends at the sites of this fragmentation; cleavage of the 50-kb fragments at the internucleosomal spacers.     

Small DNA Pieces in C. elegans Are Intermediates of DNA Fragmentation during Apoptosis

While studying small noncoding RNA in C. elegans, we discovered that protocols used for isolation of RNA are contaminated with small DNA pieces. After electrophoresis on a denaturing gel, the DNA fragments appear as a ladder of bands, ∼10 nucleotides apart, mimicking the pattern of nuclease digestion of DNA wrapped around a nucleosome. Here we show that the small DNA pieces are products of the DNA fragmentation that occurs during apoptosis, and correspondingly, are absent in mutant strains incapable of apoptosis. In contrast, the small DNA pieces are present in strains defective for the engulfment process of apoptosis, suggesting they are produced in the dying cell prior to engulfment. While the small DNA pieces are also present in a number of strains with mutations in predicted nucleases, they are undetectable in strains containing mutations in nuc-1, which encodes a DNase II endonuclease. We find that the small DNA pieces can be labeled with terminal deoxynucleotidyltransferase only after phosphatase treatment, as expected if they are products of DNase II cleavage, which generates a 3′ phosphate. Our studies reveal a previously unknown intermediate in the process of apoptotic DNA fragmentation and thus bring us closer to defining this important pathway.     

Characterization and comparison of mitochondrial DNAs and rRNAs from Penicillium urticae and P. chrysogenum.

Mitochondrial DNA (mt DNA) from a patulin producer, Penicillium urticae (synonym P. griseofulvum), was 27.8 kb +/- 0.6 kb in size by electron microscopy and 27.2 kb by agarose gel electrophoresis. Restriction endonuclease maps for nine restriction enzymes were constructed, and eleven fragments which covered the total range of the mt DNA were cloned into the Escherichia coli plasmid vector pUC19. Southern analysis of the native genomes of P. urticae and P. chrysogenum with six of the cloned fragments as probes indicated similar genome arrangements as well as similar restriction maps. Both the large and small rRNA genes of P. urticae and P. chrysogenum were located on these restriction maps using Southern hybridization, and the result also supported the similar arrangement. Agarose/formaldehyde gel electrophoresis indicated that the small rRNA was 1.5 kb in size in both species; but, surprisingly, the large rRNA was 4.2 kb in size for P. urticae and 3.5 kb for P. chrysogenum. These sizes were, respectively, 1.1 kb and 0.4 kb larger than those from the very closely related Aspergillus nidulans.     

Determination of microbial genome sizes by two-dimensional denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis.

In two-dimensional denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis, DNA is digested with a restriction endonuclease and the resulting DNA fragments are separated as a function of size by conventional agarose gel electrophoresis. Following this first dimension electrophoresis, the fragment distribution is placed at the top of a denaturing gradient slab gel and electrophoresis is carried out parallel to the gradient direction. This second dimension separation is a complex function of the base sequence of each fragment. Analysis of the DNA fragment distribution as a function of fragment size allows the DNA size to be calculated. This method has been applied to calculate three microbial genome sizes: Mycoplasma capricolum, 724 kb; Acholeplasma laidlawii, 1646 kb; and Hemophilus influenzae, 1833 kb.     

Failure of zinc to inhibit hyperthermia-induced apoptosis predicts differential nuclease activity detection by comet assay

Apoptotic DNA cleavage generally proceeds in two stages, first producing large 50–300kb fragments, and later oligonucleosomal pieces which create the characteristic DNA ladder. We show that zinc treatment of hyperthermia-induced apoptotic cultures is sufficient to prevent ladder formation, but not apoptosis (all features of which were inhibited by actinomycin D and cycloheximide). DNA damage measured in single cells using the comet (single cell gel) assay is detectable in zinc treated cultures using both alkaline and non-denaturing conditions. Both assays predict the same fraction of cells undergoing apoptosis, and damage is detectable earlier than shown by DNA ladder appearance. We conclude that the comet assay is detecting damage consistent with the initial 50–300kb fragments. Additionally, various cell lines when heattreated follow different temporal pathways or display differential apoptotic phenotypes. Also, we were unable to demonstrate an apoptotic window for cells refractory to hyperthermia by increasing the heat load.     

DNA cleavage by homo- and heterotetranuclear Cu(II) and Mn(II) complexes with tetrathioether-tetrathiol moiety

Novel homotetranuclear Cu(II) and heteronuclear Cu(II)-Mn(II) complexes with tetrathioether-tetrathiol moiety have been prepared and their DNA relaxation activities with plasmid pCYTEXP (5kb) were electrophoretically established. The cleavage products analyzed by neutral agarose gel electrophoresis indicated that the interaction of the metal complexes with supercoiled plasmid DNA yielded linear, nicked or degraded DNA. The relaxation activities of both homo- and heterotetranuclear (SK4) complexes are time- and concentration-dependent. The findings suggest that SK4 with potent nucleolytic activity is a good nuclease substitute in the presence of cooxidant. Furthermore, the observation of induction of DNA into smaller fragments by SK4 is also significant.     

High capacity gel preparative electrophoresis for purification of fragments of genomic DNA

We have designed a high-capacity gel electrophoretic device for the purification of large amounts of restriction endonuclease fragments of genomic DNA. This device exploits the high resolution of gel electrophoresis in conjunction with an electronic system permitting discontinuous sample elution over a large gel surface area. This feature preserves resolution and greatly increases capacity and yield. The resulting DNA fractions may be used in restriction endonuclease, ligation, transfection, and transformation reactions without further extensive manipulation. Furthermore, DNA fragments of a broad size range are recovered with high efficiency from the gel.     

Differentiation of Citrobacter strains using chromosomal DNA restriction patterns

The aim of this study was checking of the usefulness of chromosomal DNA restriction patterns in differentiation of Citrobacter strains. Molecular characterization of total 56 isolates of Citrobacter from Poland and Czech Republic, was performed by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis after digestion of chromosomal DNA with restriction endonuclease Xba I (5'-TCTAGA-3'). Chromosomal DNA of all tested Citrobacter strains gave after electrophoresis 12 to 21 bands and patterns consisting of 12 to 21 fragments ranging in size from 790 kb to 48.5 kb and smaller, which where not distinguishable. Pulsed-field gel electrophoresis patterns were useful for comparing Citrobacter strains. Identical restriction patterns generated by PFGE were observed in the case of selected strains e.g. strains C. sedlakii studied in this study, coming from an outbreak, having the some phenotype. In addition, PFGE patterns can be used to evaluate the clonal relatedness among bacterial isolates. PFGE can be helpful for assessing genetic relatedness among strains epidemiologicaly unrelated e.g. C. werkmanii strains tested in this study. The sum of DNA fragments after Xba I digestion indicates the genome size of Citrobacter strains. This suggests that PFGE should be useful for epidemiological investigations of Citrobacter strains.     

Structure of amplified DNA, analyzed by pulsed field gradient gel electrophoresis

Pulsed field gradient electrophoresis allows the separation of large DNA molecules up to 2,000 kilobases (kb) in length and has the potential to close the resolution gap between standard electrophoresis of DNA molecules (smaller than 50 kb) and standard cytogenetics (larger than 2,000 kb). We have analysed the amplified DNA in four cell lines containing double minute chromosomes (DMs) and two lines containing homogeneously staining regions. The cells were immobilized in agarose blocks, lysed, deproteinized, and the liberated DNA was digested in situ with various restriction endonucleases. Following electrophoretic separation by pulsed field gel electrophoresis, the DNA in the gel was analysed by Southern blotting with appropriate probes for the amplified DNA. We find that the DNA in intact DMs is larger than 1,500 kb. Our results are also compatible with the notion that the DNA in DMs is circular, but this remains to be proven. The amplified segment of wild-type DNA covers more than 550 kb in all lines and possibly up to 2,500 kb in some. We confirm that the repeat unit is heterogeneous in some of the amplicons. In two cell lines, however, with low degrees of gene amplification, we find no evidence for heterogeneity of the repeats up to 750 (Y1-DM) and 800 kb (3T6-R50), respectively. We propose that amplicons start out long and homogeneous and that the heterogeneity in the repeat arises through truncation during further amplification events in which cells with shorter repeats have a selective advantage. Even if the repeats are heterogeneous, however, pulsed field gradient gels can be useful to establish linkage of genes over relatively short chromosomal distances (up to 1,000 kb). We discuss some of the promises and pitfalls of pulsed field gel electrophoresis in the analysis of amplified DNA.     

DNA fragmentation during apoptosis is caused by frequent single-strand cuts.

One of the hallmarks of apoptosis is the digestion of genomic DNA by an endonuclease, generating a ladder of small fragments of double-stranded DNA. We have examined the nature of the DNA breaks produced in mouse thymocytes triggered to undergo apoptosis by steroids or by stimulation of the T cell receptor. Whereas the typical ladder pattern of oligonucleosomal fragments was observed after agarose gel electrophoresis, numerous single-strand cuts were detected after electrophoresis under denaturing conditions. Single-strand nicks were found to be very frequent in the internucleosomal regions, but also to occur in the core particle-associated DNA. An identical pattern of single-strand nicks was obtained when chromatin DNA was exposed to the single-strand cleaving deoxyribonuclease I. The nicked DNA fragments, extracted from apoptotic thymocytes, were sensitive to the action of S1-nuclease. We propose that DNA fragmentation induced during apoptosis is not due to a double-strand cutting enzyme as previously postulated, but rather is the result of single-strand breaks. This ensures the dissociation of the DNA molecule at sites where cuts are found within close proximity.     

Large DNA fragment sizing by flow cytometry: application to the characterization of P1 artificial chromosome (PAC) clones.

A flow cytometry-based, ultrasensitive fluorescence detection technique is used to size individual DNA fragments up to 167 kb in length. Application of this technology to the sizing of P1 artificial chromosomes (PACs) in both linear and supercoiled forms is described. It is demonstrated that this method is well suited to characterizing PAC/BAC clones and will be very useful for the analysis of large insert libraries. Fluorescence bursts are recorded as individual, dye stained DNA fragments pass through a low power, focused, continuous laser beam. The magnitudes of the fluorescence bursts are linearly proportional to the lengths of the DNA fragments. The histograms of the burst sizes are generated in <3 min with <1 pg of DNA. Results on linear fragments are consistent with those obtained by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis. In comparison with pulsed-field gel electrophoresis, sizing of large DNA fragments by this approach is more accurate, much faster, requires much less DNA, and is independent of the DNA conformation.     

Rapid pulsed field separation of DNA molecules up to 250 kb.

Pulsed field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) is capable of resolving a wide size range of DNA molecules which would all co-migrate in conventional agarose gels. We describe pulsed field gel conditions which permit DNA fragments of up to 250 kilobases (kb) to be separated in only 3.5 h. The separations, which employ commercially available gel boxes, are achieved using conditions which deviate significantly from traditional pulsed field conditions. PFGE separations have been thought to require reorientation angles greater than 90 degrees to be effective. However, reorientation angles of 90 degrees and even less will resolve DNA fragments a few hundred kb and smaller approximately 5 x faster than with standard pulsed field conditions. The mobility of DNA fragments separated with 90 degrees reorientation angles is switch time-dependent, as is seen for DNA run with the commonly used reorientation angle of 120 degrees. With DNA fragments of several hundred kb and smaller, higher field strengths may be used, resulting in still greater increases in separation speed. The conditions described allow DNA from large insert bacterial clones, such as those using cosmid, Fosmid, P1, bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC), or P1-derived artificial chromosome (PAC) vectors, to be prepared, digested and analyzed on gels within a single working day.     

Stress-induced DNA fragmentation in cardiomyocytes of MDX and C57Bl mice

The study deals with apoptosis of cardiomyocytes of adult mdx mice. Our previous investigation of the total DNA from mdx mice myocardium in 0.5% agarose and 5% PAAG revealed middle sized DNA fragments about 64 kb only. The DNA electrophoresis in 5% PAAG after alpha-32P-dATP incorporation into DNA, fragments mediated by terminal transferase, showed no presence of smaller DNA fragments. The low size DNA fragments (0.2, 0.4 and 11.0 kb) were observed only following stress (a 5 min swimming in water bath) by means of alpha-32P-dATP incorporation mediated by TdT reaction. DNA fragmentation lasted for 48 h after the stress. A study of the total DNA extracts of C57B1 mice also demonstrated middle and low molecular sized DNA fragmentation 2 h after the stress under the same condition of the experiment. But during the next 48 h the signs of DNA fragmentation of the total DNA disappeared. The authors conclude that the first stage of apoptosis is a permanent property of cardiomyocytes of mdx mice.     

Localization of Single-Chain Interruptions in Bacteriophage T5 DNA. II. Electrophoretic Studies

Upon denaturation, T5 DNA yields a large number of discrete, single-chain fragments that can be resolved by agarose gel electrophoresis. The positions of the more prominent of these fragments in the T5 duplex were determined by analyzing their sensitivity to digestion with λ exonuclease and their distribution among EcoRI fragments of T5 DNA. These experiments also provide firm evidence concerning the polarity of the strands in T5 DNA. An analogous study was carried out on the fragments produced by treating exonuclease III-degraded T5 DNA with the single-strand-specific SI endonuclease. This procedure yielded over 40 discrete duplex fragments that could be resolved with considerable precision by agarose gel electrophoresis. The positions of most of these fragments were determined by analyzing EcoRI fragments of T5st(+) and T5st(0) DNA. Over 20 sites where single-chain interruptions can occur in T5 DNA were identified, and the distribution of interruptions within the terminal repetition was shown to be identical at both ends of the molecule. A precise value for the size of the terminal repetition in T5 DNA was obtained by analyzing SI endonuclease digests of ligase-repaired, circular T5 DNA in agarose gels. The repeated segment represented 8.3% of the T5st(+) DNA. The results of this study also provide information concerning the properties of λ exonuclease. Hydrolysis by this enzyme was not terminated when single-chain interruptions were encountered either in the strand being degraded or in the complementary strand.     

A Schizosaccharomyces pombe artificial chromosome large DNA cloning system.

The feasibility of using the fission yeast, Schizosaccharomyces pombe , as a host for the propagation of cloned large fragments of human DNA has been investigated. Two acentric vector arms were utilized; these carry autonomously replicating sequences ( ars elements), selectable markers ( ura4(+) or LEU2 ) and 250 bp of S. pombe terminal telomeric repeats. All cloning was performed between the unique sites in both vector arms for the restriction endonuclease Not I. Initially the system was tested by converting six previously characterized cosmids from human chromosome 11p13 into a form that could be propagated in S.pombe as linear episomal elements of 50-60 kb in length. In all transformants analysed these cosmids were maintained intact. To test if larger fragments of human DNA could also be propagated total human DNA was digested with Not I and size fractionated by pulsed field gel electrophoresis (PFGE). Fractions of 100-1000 kb were ligated to Not I-digested vector arms and transformed into S.pombe protoplasts in the presence of lipofectin. Prototrophic ura+leu+transformants were obtained which upon examination by PFGE were found to contain additional linear chromosomes migrating at between 100 and 500 kb with a copy number of 5-10 copies/cell. Hybridization analyses revealed that these additional bands contained human DNA. Fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) analyses of several independent clones indicated that the inserts were derived from single loci within the human genome. These analyses clearly demonstrate that it is possible to clone large fragments of heterologous DNA in fission yeast using this S.p ombe artificial chromosome system which we have called SPARC. This vector-host system will complement the various other systems for cloning large DNA fragments.     

Characterization of apoptosis-like endonuclease activity in avian thymocytes.

In the current study the internucleosomal DNA cleavage activity associated with apoptosis was investigated in avian thymocytes. Thymocyte nuclear proteins from glucocorticoid-treated chickens were incubated with chicken red blood cell (cRBC) nuclei, and DNA degradation was analyzed by agarose gel electrophoresis and fluorescence-activated flow cytometry. The thymocyte nuclear extract contained an endonuclease activity that degraded cRBC chromatin at internucleosomal sites as detected by agarose gel electrophoresis. Flow cytometry analysis of cRBC nuclei that were treated with thymocyte nuclear proteins demonstrated a loss of cellular DNA as a function of the amount of added nuclease activity. Furthermore, it was demonstrated that the thymocyte nuclear extract contained a nuclease activity that was capable of degrading radiolabelled naked 32P-DNA into acid soluble DNA fragments. All three assay methods demonstrate that the thymocyte nuclease activity can be inhibited by EDTA, zinc ions and the nuclease inhibitor aurintricarboxylic acid. Based on the analysis of cofactor requirement of this nuclease activity and its susceptibility to inhibitors, the endonuclease activity present in avian apoptotic thymocytes appears to be identical to the mammalian counterpart.     

Pulsed-field gel electrophoresis analysis of higher-order chromatin structures of Zea mays. Highly methylated DNA in the 50 kb chromatin structure

We have investigated the presence of higher-order chromatin structures in different maize tissues. Taking advantage of the pulsed-field gel electrophoresis technique to analyse large DNA fragments from intact nuclei and cells, we have determined the size distribution of the high-molecular-weight DNA fragments obtained from chromatin degradation by endogenous nucleases in isolated nuclei. Chromatin digestion leads to the appearance of stable DNA fragments of about 50 kb in all the tissues examined, suggesting the folding of DNA in higher-order chromatin domain structures. It has been reported that such chromatin domains are formed by loops of the 30 nm fibres anchored to the nuclear matrix by a complex set of proteins, including DNA topoisomerase II. Treatment of maize protoplasts with the calcium ionophore A23187 and the antitumour drug VM-26, which specifically inhibit the religation of the cleaved DNA in the topoisomerase II reaction, also produces the 50 kb structure. Analysis of the DNA contained in the 50 kb chromatin structure shows a higher degree of methylation than in bulk maize chromosomal DNA. The role of methylated DNA in the chromatin folding is discussed.     

Apoptosis of mouse liver nuclei induced in the cytosol of carrot cells

We report here the apoptosis of mouse liver nuclei induced in the cytosol of carrot cells by cytochrome c. Several typical characteristics of apoptosis, such as chromatin condensation, margination and apoptotic bodies, were detected. The result of DNA gel electrophoresis showed that DNA was degraded into nucleosomal fragments. The terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP-digoxigenin nick end labelling procedure was also performed to detect the breakage of 3'-OH ends of a DNA strand. Furthermore, we found that nuclear lamins were degraded from 88 kDa and 66 kDa to 37 kDa and 47 kDa fragments. The DNA fragmentation could be inhibited by AC-DEVD-CHO and AC-YVAD-CHO. The results indicate that the apoptosis in plant cells may share some similar pathways to apoptosis in animal cells.     

Presence of two independent chromosomes in the Brucella melitensis 16M genome.

Mapping the restriction fragments of the Brucella melitensis 16M genome with a new restriction endonuclease, PacI, which cut the DNA into only eight fragments, indicated that this species contains two unique and independent replicons of about 2,100 and 1,150 kb. Pulsed-field gel electrophoresis of intact DNA revealed two bands migrating the expected distances. These replicons were identified as two unique and independent chromosomes by the presence of rRNA operons and genes for heat shock proteins mapping to separate replicons.