Rate-limiting guanosine 5'-triphosphate hydrolysis during nucleotide turnover by FtsZ, a prokaryotic tubulin homologue involved in bacterial cell division

FtsZ is a prokaryotic tubulin homologue that polymerizes into a dynamic ring during cell division. GTP binding and hydrolysis provide the energy for FtsZ dynamics. However, the precise role of hydrolysis in polymer assembly and turnover is not understood, limiting our understanding of how FtsZ functions in the cell. Here we investigate GTP hydrolysis during the FtsZ polymerization cycle using several complementary approaches that avoid technical caveats of previous studies. We find that at steady state approximately 80% of FtsZ polymer subunits are bound to GTP. In addition, we use pre-steady-state, single turnover assays to directly measure the rate of hydrolysis. Hydrolysis was found to occur at approximately 8/min and to be a rate-limiting step in GTP turnover; phosphate release rapidly followed. These results clarify previously conflicting results in the literature and suggest that pure FtsZ polymers, unlike microtubules, may not be able to undergo dynamic instability or to store energy in the polymer for force production.     

The relative contributions of polymer annealing and subunit exchange to microtubule dynamics in vitro

Microtubules that are free of microtubule-associated protein undergo dynamic changes at steady state, becoming longer but fewer in number with time through a process which was previously assumed to be based entirely on mechanisms of subunit exchange at polymer ends. However, we recently demonstrated that brain and erythrocyte microtubules are capable of joining end-to-end and suggested that polymer annealing may also affect the dynamic behavior of microtubules in vitro (Rothwell, S. W., W. A. Grasser, and D. B. Murphy, 1986, J. Cell Biol. 102:619-627). In the present study, we first show that annealing is a general property of cytoplasmic microtubules and is not a specialized characteristic of erythrocyte microtubules by documenting annealing between tryosinolated and detyrosinolated brain microtubules. We then examine the contributions of polymer annealing and subunit exchange to microtubule dynamics by analyzing the composition and length of individual polymers in a mixture of brain and erythrocyte microtubules by immunoelectron microscopy. In concentrated preparations of short-length microtubules at polymer-mass steady state, annealing was observed to be the principal factor responsible for the increase in polymer length, whereas annealing and subunit exchange contributed about equally to the reduction in microtubule number.     

STOP proteins

Microtubules assembled from purified tubulin in vitro are labile, rapidly disassembling when exposed to a variety of depolymerizing conditions such as cold temperature. In contrast, in many cell types, microtubules seem to be unaffected when the cell is exposed to the cold. This resistance of microtubules to the cold has been intriguing because the earliest and by far most studied microtubule-associated proteins such as MAP2 and tau are devoid of microtubule cold stabilizing activity. Over the past several years, it has been shown that resistance of microtubules to the cold is largely due to polymer association with a class of microtubule-associated proteins called STOPs. STOPs are calmodulin-binding and calmodulin-regulated proteins which, in mammals, are encoded by a single gene but exhibit substantial cell specific variability due to mRNA splicing and alternative promoter use. STOP microtubule stabilizing activity has been ascribed to two classes of new bifunctional calmodulin- and microtubule-binding motifs, with distinct microtubule binding properties in vivo. STOPs seem to be restricted to vertebrates and are composed of a conserved domain split by the apparent insertion of variable sequences that are completely unrelated among species. Recently, STOP suppression in mice has been found to induce synaptic defects associated with neuroleptic-sensitive behavioral disorders. Thus, STOPs are important for synaptic plasticity. Additionally, STOP-deficient mice may yield a pertinent model for the study of neuroleptics in illnesses such as schizophrenia, currently thought to result from defects in synapse function.     

The minimum GTP cap required to stabilize microtubules

Background: Microtubules polymerized from pure tubulin show the unusual property of dynamic instability, in which both growing and shrinking polymers coexist at steady state. Shortly after its addition to a microtubule end, a tubulin subunit hydrolyzes its bound GTP. Studies with non-hydrolyzable analogs have shown that GTP hydrolysis is not required for microtubule assembly, but is essential for generating a dynamic polymer, in which the subunits at the growing tip have bound GTP and those in the bulk of the polymer have bound GDP. It has been suggested that loss of the ‘GTP cap’ through dissociation or hydrolysis exposes the unstable GDP core, leading to rapid depolymerization. However, evidence for a stabilizing cap has been very difficult to obtain.Results We developed an assay to determine the minimum GTP cap necessary to stabilize a microtubule from shrinking. Assembly of a small number of subunits containing a slowly hydrolyzed GTP analog (GMPCPP) onto the end of dynamic microtubules stabilized the polymer to dilution. By labeling the subunits with rhodamine, we measured the size of the cap and found that as few as 40 subunits were sufficient to stabilize a microtubule.Conclusion On the basis of statistical arguments, in which the proportion of stabilized microtubules is compared to the probability that when 40 GMPCPP-tubulin subunits have polymerized onto a microtubule end, all protofilaments have added at least one GMPCPP-tubulin subunit, our measurements of cap size support a model in which a single GTP subunit at the end of each of the 13 protofilaments of a microtubule is sufficient for stabilization. Depolymerization of a microtubule may be initiated by an exposed tubulin–GDP subunit at even a single position. These results have implications for the structure of microtubules and their means of regulation.     

Effect of fluctuating surface structure and free energy on the growth of linear tubular aggregates.

Simple linear tubular aggregates with up to eight strands are studied theoretically at equilibrium and under conditions of steady growth or shortening. The surface structure and free energy at an end of the polymer fluctuate as a consequence of the gain or loss of individual subunits. The surface free energy governs the probability distribution of surface structures at equilibrium. At steady state, on and off rate constants are crucial for this purpose; these depend on the gain or loss of neighbor interactions at the polymer end when a subunit is gained or lost. The observed on and off rate constants are averages of microscopic rate constants. A consequence of this is that the subunit flux onto the polymer end is, in general, not a linear function of the free subunit concentration, as is usually assumed. Monte Carlo calculations are needed at steady state for three or more strands. The general approach can be applied to microtubules, which have 13 strands. Actin is a special case, included here, with two strands.     

GDP-Tubulin Incorporation into Growing Microtubules Modulates Polymer Stability

Microtubule growth proceeds through the endwise addition of nucleotide-bound tubulin dimers. The microtubule wall is composed of GDP-tubulin subunits, which are thought to come exclusively from the incorporation of GTP-tubulin complexes at microtubule ends followed by GTP hydrolysis within the polymer. The possibility of a direct GDP-tubulin incorporation into growing polymers is regarded as hardly compatible with recent structural data. Here, we have examined GTP-tubulin and GDP-tubulin incorporation into polymerizing microtubules using a minimal assembly system comprised of nucleotide-bound tubulin dimers, in the absence of free nucleotide. We find that GDP-tubulin complexes can efficiently co-polymerize with GTP-tubulin complexes during microtubule assembly. GDP-tubulin incorporation into microtubules occurs with similar efficiency during bulk microtubule assembly as during microtubule growth from seeds or centrosomes. Microtubules formed from GTP-tubulin/GDP-tubulin mixtures display altered microtubule dynamics, in particular a decreased shrinkage rate, apparently due to intrinsic modifications of the polymer disassembly properties. Thus, although microtubules polymerized from GTP-tubulin/GDP-tubulin mixtures or from homogeneous GTP-tubulin solutions are both composed of GDP-tubulin subunits, they have different dynamic properties, and this may reveal a novel form of microtubule “structural plasticity.”     

Regeneration of mirror symmetrical limbs in the axolotl

Measurements of tubulin exchange into and from bovine brain microtubules at steady state in vitro were made with 3H-GTP as a marker for tubulin addition to or loss from microtubules. Tubulin has an exchangeable GTP binding site that becomes nonexchangeable in the microtubule. We found that tubulin addition to and loss from microtubules under steady state conditions occurred at equivalent rates, that loss and gain were linear, and that exchange rates (percentage of total tubulin in microtubules lost or gained per hour) were dependent upon microtubule length. Furthermore, we found that podophyllotoxin blocked steady state assembly, but did not alter the rate of steady state tubulin loss. When the assembling microtubule end was pulsed with 3H-GTP at steady state, the label was almost completely retained during a subsequent chase. We conclude that the microtubule assembly-disassembly "equilibrium" is a steady state summation of two different reactions which occur at opposite ends of the microtubule, and that assembly and disassembly occur predominantly and perhaps exclusively at the opposite ends under steady state conditions in vitro.     

Identification of novel bifunctional calmodulin-binding and microtubule-stabilizing motifs in STOP proteins.

Although microtubules are intrinsically labile tubulin assemblies, many cell types contain stable polymers, resisting depolymerizing conditions such as exposure to the cold or the drug nocodazole. This microtubule stabilization is largely due to polymer association with STOP proteins. There are several STOP variants, some with capacity to induce microtubule resistance to both the cold and nocodazole, others with microtubule cold stabilizing activity only. These microtubule-stabilizing effects of STOP proteins are inhibited by calmodulin and we now demonstrate that they are determined by two distinct kinds of repeated modular sequences (Mn and Mc), both containing a calmodulin-binding peptide, but displaying different microtubule stabilizing activities. Mn modules induce microtubule resistance to both the cold and nocodazole when expressed in cells. Mc modules, which correspond to the STOP central repeats, have microtubule cold stabilizing activity only. Mouse neuronal STOPs, which induce both cold and drug resistance in cellular microtubules, contain three Mn modules and four Mc modules. Compared with neuronal STOPs, the non-neuronal F-STOP lacks multiple Mn modules and this corresponds with an inability to induce nocodazole resistance. STOP modules represent novel bifunctional calmodulin-binding and microtubule-stabilizing sequences that may be essential for the generation of the different patterns of microtubule stabilization observed in cells.     

Phase dynamics at microtubule ends: the coexistence of microtubule length changes and treadmilling

The length dynamics both of microtubule-associated protein (MAP)-rich and MAP-depleted bovine brain microtubules were examined at polymer mass steady state. In both preparations, the microtubules exhibited length redistributions shortly after polymer mass steady state was attained. With time, however, both populations relaxed to a state in which no further changes in length distributions could be detected. Shearing the microtubules or diluting the microtubule suspensions transiently increased the extent to which microtubule length redistributions occurred, but again the microtubules relaxed to a state in which changes in the polymer length distributions were not detected. Under steady-state conditions of constant polymer mass and stable microtubule length distribution, both MAP-rich and MAP-depleted microtubules exhibited behavior consistent with treadmilling. MAPs strongly suppressed the magnitude of length redistributions and the steady-state treadmilling rates. These data indicate that the inherent tendency of microtubules in vitro is to relax to a steady state in which net changes in the microtubule length distributions are zero. If the basis of the observed length redistributions is the spontaneous loss and regain of GTP-tubulin ("GTP caps") at microtubule ends, then in order to account for stable length distributions the microtubule ends must reside in the capped state far longer than in the uncapped state, and uncapped microtubule ends must be rapidly recapped. The data suggest that microtubules in cells may have an inherent tendency to remain in the polymerized state, and that microtubule disassembly must be induced actively.     

Kinetic analysis of tubulin exchange at microtubule ends at low vinblastine concentrations

We have investigated the effects of vinblastine at micromolar concentrations and below on the dynamics of tubulin exchange at the ends of microtubule-associated-protein-rich bovine brain microtubules. The predominant behavior of these microtubules at polymer-mass steady state under the conditions examined was tubulin flux, i.e., net addition of tubulin at one end of each microtubule, operationally defined as the assembly or A end, and balanced net loss at the opposite (disassembly or D) end. No dynamic instability behavior could be detected by video-enhanced dark-field microscopy. Addition of vinblastine to the microtubules at polymer-mass steady state resulted in an initial concentration-dependent depolymerization predominantly at the A ends, until a new steady-state plateau at an elevated critical concentration was established. Microtubules ultimately attained the same stable polymer-mass plateau when vinblastine was added prior to initiation of polymerization as when the drug was added to already polymerized microtubules. Vinblastine inhibited tubulin exchange at the ends of the microtubules at polymer-mass steady state, as determined by using microtubules differentially radiolabeled at their opposite ends. Inhibition of tubulin exchange occurred at concentrations of vinblastine that had very little effect on polymer mass. Both the initial burst of incorporation that occurs in control microtubule suspensions following a pulse of labeled GTP and the relatively slower linear incorporation of label that follows the initial burst were inhibited in a concentration-dependent manner by vinblastine. Both processes were inhibited to the same extent at all vinblastine concentrations examined. If the initial burst of label incorporation represents a low degree of dynamic instability (very short excursions of growth and shortening of the microtubules at one or both ends), then vinblastine inhibits both dynamic instability and flux to similar extents. The ability of vinblastine to inhibit tubulin exchange at microtubule ends in the micromolar concentration range appeared to be mediated by the reversible binding of vinblastine to tubulin binding sites exposed at the polymer ends. Determination by dilution analysis of the effects of vinblastine on the apparent dissociation rate constants for tubulin loss at opposite microtubule ends indicated that a principal effect of vinblastine is to decrease the dissociation rate constant at A ends (i.e., it produces a kinetic cap at A ends), whereas it has no effect on the D-end dissociation rate constant.     

Kinetics and mechanism of microtubule length changes by dynamic instability

Microtubules at steady state were found to undergo dramatic changes in length, with only very little change in number concentration and mean length. This result is accounted for by a mechanism in which microtubules are capped at ends by tubulin-GTP subunits; loss of the tubulin-GTP cap at one end results in disassembly of all the tubulin-GDP subunits, so that the medial edge of the distal tubulin-GTP cap is exposed; the exposed tubulin-GTP cap is sufficiently stable, so that microtubule regrowth from the cap rather than loss of the cap occurs. This mechanism predicts that a bell-shaped length distribution of sheared microtubules will be transiently bimodal, with peaks of short and moderate length microtubules, in rearranging to an exponential length distribution. We have observed the predicted transient bimodal length distribution experimentally and in a Monte Carlo simulation. Dynamic instability has recently been accounted for by assuming that microtubule ends are capped with only a single tubulin-GTP subunit at each end of the five helices that serve as elongation sites. Such a minimal tubulin-GTP cap is apparently ruled out by our observations, which require that the remnant tubulin-GTP cap generated from disassembly be able to serve as nucleating site; we do not expect that a stable nucleating site can be generated from five tubulin-GTP subunits, oriented as the five helices that serve as elongation sites.     

Differentiation between dynamic instability and end-to-end annealing models for length changes of steady-state microtubules

Short microtubules can be formed by shearing a sample at polymerization steady state of microtubules formed by glycerol-induced assembly of pure tubulin dimer. Such short microtubules show a rapid increase in mean length. The rate of this increase is too fast to be accounted for by statistical redistribution of subunits between microtubules. We propose that the fast length changes are a result of the end-to-end annealing of microtubules demonstrated by Rothwell et al. (Rothwell, S. W., Grasser, W. A., and Murphy, D. B. (1986) J. Cell Biol. 102, 619-627). This proposal has been tested by measuring the rate of annealing of free microtubules to Tetrahymena axonemes under conditions identical to those used for the lengthening of sheared microtubules. That free microtubules anneal to axonemal microtubules is indicated by the following observations. Axonemes elongate at both ends in the presence of steady state microtubules, as predicted for a symmetrical annealing process; under conditions where the microtubule number concentration is greater than that for axonemes, the initial rate of axoneme elongation is more rapid with a low concentration of long microtubules at steady state than with a high number concentration of short microtubules at steady state. These observations are inconsistent with the predictions of a model based on microtubule dynamic instability (Mitchison, T., and Kirschner, M. (1984) Nature 312, 237-242). The annealing rate observed with axonemes can account for the rate of elongation of sheared steady state microtubules.     

Polymerization of Ftsz, a bacterial homolog of tubulin. is assembly cooperative?

FtsZ is a bacterial homolog of tubulin that is essential for prokaryotic cytokinesis. In vitro, GTP induces FtsZ to assemble into straight, 5-nm-wide polymers. Here we show that the polymerization of these FtsZ filaments most closely resembles noncooperative (or "isodesmic") assembly; the polymers are single-stranded and assemble with no evidence of a nucleation phase and without a critical concentration. We have developed a model for the isodesmic polymerization that includes GTP hydrolysis in the scheme. The model can account for the lengths of the FtsZ polymers and their maximum steady state nucleotide hydrolysis rates. It predicts that unlike microtubules, FtsZ protofilaments consist of GTP-bound FtsZ subunits that hydrolyze their nucleotide only slowly and are connected by high affinity longitudinal bonds with a nanomolar K(D).     

Equilibrium studies of a fluorescent paclitaxel derivative binding to microtubules

A fluorescent derivative of paclitaxel, 3'-N-m-aminobenzamido-3'-N-debenzamidopaclitaxel (N-AB-PT), has been prepared in order to probe paclitaxel-microtubule interactions. Fluorescence spectroscopy was used to quantitatively assess the association of N-AB-PT with microtubules. N-AB-PT was found equipotent with paclitaxel in promoting microtubule polymerization. Paclitaxel and N-AB-PT underwent rapid exchange with each other on microtubules assembled from GTP-, GDP-, and GMPCPP-tubulin. The equilibrium binding parameters for N-AB-PT to microtubules assembled from GTP-tubulin were derived through fluorescence titration. N-AB-PT bound to two types of sites on microtubules (K(d1) = 61 +/- 7.0 nM and K(d2) = 3.3 +/- 0.54 microM). The stoichiometry of each site was less than one ligand per tubulin dimer in the microtubule (n(1) = 0.81 +/- 0.03 and n(2) = 0.44 +/- 0.02). The binding experiments were repeated after exchanging the GTP for GDP or for GMPCPP. It was found that N-AB-PT bound to a single site on microtubules assembled from GDP-tubulin with a dissociation constant of 2.5 +/- 0.29 microM, and that N-AB-PT bound to a single site on microtubules assembled from GMPCPP-tubulin with a dissociation constant of 15 +/- 4.0 nM. It therefore appears that microtubules contain two types of binding sites for paclitaxel and that the binding site affinity for paclitaxel depends on the nucleotide content of tubulin. It has been established that paclitaxel binding does not inhibit GTP hydrolysis and microtubules assembled from GTP-tubulin in the presence of paclitaxel contain almost exclusively GDP at the E-site. We propose that although all the subunits of the microtubule at steady state are the same "GDP-tubulin-paclitaxel", they are formed through two paths: paclitaxel binding to a tubulin subunit before its E-site GTP hydrolysis is of high affinity, and paclitaxel binding to a tubulin subunit containing hydrolyzed GDP at its E-site is of low affinity.     

Stabilization of microtubules by inorganic phosphate and its structural analogues, the fluoride complexes of aluminum and beryllium

In order to elucidate how the elementary reactions of GTP cleavage and subsequent inorganic phosphate (Pi) release, which accompany microtubule assembly, regulate microtubule dynamics, the effect of Pi and of its structural analogues AlF4- and BeF3- on the stability of GDP-microtubules has been investigated. Inorganic phosphate binds to microtubules with a low affinity (KD = 25 mM) and slows down the rate of GDP-subunit dissociation by about 2 orders of magnitude. AlF4- and BeF3- exhibit phosphate-like effects with 1000-fold higher affinity. Evidence has been obtained for direct binding of BeF3- to microtubules with a stoichiometry of 1 mol of BeF3- per mole of GDP-subunit and an equilibrium dissociation constant of 12-15 microM. AlF4- and Pi compete for this site. Phosphate analogues abolish oscillatory polymerization kinetics and slow down microtubule turnover at steady state. In view of these results, we propose that Pi and its structural analogues bind to the site of the gamma-phosphate of GTP in the E site and reconstitute a GDP-Pi-microtubule, from which tubulin subunits dissociate very slowly. We therefore understand that, following GTP cleavage on microtubules, Pi release in the medium is accompanied by a structural change resulting in a large destabilization of the polymer. A cap of slowly dissociating GDP-Pi-subunits prevents depolymerization of the microtubule GDP-core at steady state. The similarity with the actin system [Carlier, M.-F., & Pantaloni, D. (1988) J. Biol. Chem. 263, 817-825] is underlined.     

Microtubule dynamics.

Although compelling evidence has been obtained for heterogeneity in the structure of subunits in microtubules, it has not been possible to prove that this results from the presence of tubulin-GDP and tubulin-GTP in polymers. There are reasons to exclude the existence of even a monolayer of tubulin-GTP subunits at microtubule ends. Dynamic behavior appears to be best accounted for by a mechanism in which tubulin-GDP in microtubules exists in two conformations. The mechanism of microtubule-associated protein binding to microtubules and the role of phosphorylation on this reaction are discussed.     

Interaction of STOP with neuronal tubulin is independent of polyglutamylation

In eukaryotes, the coordinated progress of the various cellular tasks along with the assembly of adapted cytoskeletal networks requires a tight regulation of the interactions between microtubules and their associated proteins. Polyglutamylation is the major post-translational modification of neuronal tubulin. Due to its oligomeric structure, polyglutamylation can serve as a potentiometer to modulate binding of diverse MAPs. In addition, it can exert a differential mode of regulation towards distinct microtubule protein partners. To find out to what extent polyglutamylation is a general regulator, we have analyzed its ability to affect the binding of STOPs, the major factors that confer cold- and nocodazole-resistance to microtubules. We have shown by blot overlay experiments that binding of STOP does not depend on the length of the polyglutamyl chains carried by tubulins. And contrary to the other microtubule-associated proteins tested so far, STOP can bind quantitatively to any tubulin isoform whatever its degree of polyglutamylation.     

Temperature-jump studies of microtubule dynamic instability

Evidence for a slowly dissociating tubulin-GTP cap at microtubule ends was derived from observation of a delay for attaining a maximum disassembly rate, after the temperature of steady state microtubules was rapidly decreased from 36 to 34 degrees C. The possibility that the microtubules were capped by a single tubulin-GTP subunit on each subhelix was ruled out, by comparison of the disassembly kinetics following a temperature decrease and dilution. The existence of a subpopulation of microtubules that underwent irreversible or near irreversible disassembly was demonstrated by a 30-s lag for attainment of a maximum assembly rate, after steady state microtubules were shifted from 34 to 36 degrees C. A dynamic instability model predicts that a maximum assembly rate will be delayed until disappearance of a subpopulation of microtubules that disassemble before being recapped. Analysis indicates that the 30-s lag resulted because approximately 2% of the mass in the steady state microtubule population was uncapped and disassembling and not readily recapped. The half-time for recapping of disassembling microtubules, by addition of tubulin-GTP subunits to ends, was equal to or greater than 20 s. Since tubulin-GDP dissociated from microtubules at a rate of about 4500 s-1, slow recapping resulted in dramatic shortening of disassembling microtubules.     

Role of nucleotide hydrolysis in the polymerization of actin and tubulin

Here is presented a short survey of the main aspects of the involvement of nucleotide hydrolysis in the polymerization of actin and microtubules: 1) XTP hydrolysis is not tightly coupled to the polymerization process; XTP hydrolysis and phosphate release generate an unstable XDP-polymer which is maintained at steady state, in the presence of XTP, by terminal XTP-subunits; this feature can generate patterns of phase transitions of the polymer between stable and unstable conformations; 2) Interactions between subunits are involved in the mechanism of XTP hydrolysis; 3) XTP cleavage on the polymer is followed by the slow release of P_i; the structural and thermodynamic characteristics of the transient XDP-P_i-polymer may play a crucial role in the regulation of the dynamics of microtubules and actin filaments.