Stable Non-Mutator Stocks of Maize Have Sequences Homologous to the Mu1 Transposable Element

Mutator stocks of maize produce mutants at many loci at rates 20- to 50-fold above spontaneous levels. Current evidence suggests that this high mutation rate is mediated by an active transposable element system, Mu. Members of this transposable element family are found in approximately 10-60 copies in Mutator stocks. We report here an initial characterization of previously undetected sequences homologous to Mu elements in eight non-Mutator inbred lines and varieties of maize that have a normal low mutation rate. All stocks have approximately 40 copies of sequences homologous only to the terminal repeat and show weak homology to an internal probe. In addition, several of the stocks contain an intact Mu element. One intact Mu element and two terminal-specific clones have been isolated from one non-Mutator line, B37. The cloned sequences have been used to demonstrate that in genomic DNA the intact element, termed Mu1.4B37, is modified, such that restriction sites in its termini are not accessible to cleavage by the HinfI restriction enzyme. This modification is similar to that observed in Mutator lines that have lost activity. We hypothesize that the DNA modification of the Mu-like element may contribute to the lack of Mutator activity in B37.     

Genetic Study of the Loss and Restoration of Mutator Transposon Activity in Maize: Evidence against Dominant-Negative Regulator Associated with Loss of Activity

The Mutator system of transposable elements is characterized by a family of transposons called Mu transposons that share common termini and are actively transposing in Robertson's Mutator (Mu) lines of maize. Mu lines lose transposition activity during propagation by either outcrossing or inbreeding. This loss of transposition activity, which can occur at non-Mendelian frequencies, is in the form of loss of forward transposition activity resulting in a decrease in the generation of new mutations, as well as the loss of mutability of Mu transposon induced mutations, and it has been correlated with hypermethylation of the Mu elements. Previous studies have concluded that restoration of Mutator transposon activity by crossing inactive lines back to active lines is incomplete or transient, and depends upon the sex of the inactive parent. Further, it has been proposed that the inactive system is dominant to the active system, with the dominance possibly mediated through a negative regulatory factor that is preferentially transmitted through the female. In this study, we have examined the frequencies of loss and restoration of Mu transposon activity using a Mu line carrying an insertion in the bronze 1 locus. We find that transmission of Mu transposon activity to non-Mu plants can occur at high rates through males and females, but individual cases of decreased transmission through the male were observed. We also find that in crosses between inactive-Mu and active-Mu plants, reactivation was efficient as well as heritable, regardless of the sex of the inactive parent. Similar results were obtained whether the inactivation occurred in an outcross or a self. In all cases examined, loss of Mu transposon activity was correlated with hypermethylation of Mu elements, and reactivation was correlated with their demethylation. Our results indicate that an inactive Mu system does not exhibit dominance over an active Mu system. We conclude that contrary to current models, inactivation and its maintenance is not obligatorily associated with a dominant negative regulatory factor whether nuclear or cytoplasmic, and we propose a revised model to account for these and other observations.     

Molecular and Genetic Characterization of Mu Transposable Elements in Zea Mays: Behavior in Callus Culture and Regenerated Plants

Active Mutator lines of maize (Zea mays L.) have a high mutation rate and contain multiple hypomethylated 1.4-kb and 1.7-kb Mu transposable elements. Correlated with the inactivation of the Mutator system, these Mu elements cease to transpose and become more methylated. To determine whether the shock of tissue culture can affect Mutator activities, F1 progenies of outcrosses between active or inactive Mutator stocks and inbred line A188 were used to initiate embryogenic callus cultures. HinfI restriction digestion of genomic DNA isolated from 3-5-month-old cultures demonstrated that there is a very good correlation between the modification state of Mu elements in the cultures and the Mutator parent. Despite the dedifferentiation and rapid proliferation characteristic of tissue culture, the Mutator activity state is relatively stable during an extended tissue culture period. Cultures established from inactive Mutator lines were not reactivated; cultures established from active lines maintained a high Mu copy number, and most Mu elements remained unmodified. In contrast, weakly active Mutator parents gave rise to cultures in which Mu element modification could switch between low and high methylation during the culture period. Evidence for transposition was investigated with EcoRI digestion of genomic DNA isolated at different times during culture. The appearance of novel Mu-hybridizing fragments and a strong background hybridization are interpreted as evidence that transposition events occur during culture. Plants regenerated from such active cultures transmitted Mutator activity to their progeny.     

Sequence, Genomic Distribution and DNA Modification of a Mu1 Element from Non-Mutator Maize Stocks

The increased mutation rate of Mutator stocks of maize has been shown to be the result of transposition of Mu elements. One element, Mu1, is present in 10-60 copies in Mutator stocks and approximately 0-3 copies in non-Mutator stocks. The sequence, structure and genomic distribution of an intact Mu1 element cloned from the non-Mutator inbred line B37 has been determined. The sequence of this element, termed Mu1.4-B37, is identical to Mu1 and it is flanked by 9-bp direct repeats indicative of a target site duplication. Mu1.4-B37 is not in the same genomic location in all stocks, which further suggests that it transposed into its genomic location in B37. We previously reported that in genomic DNA this element is modified such that certain methylation-sensitive restriction enzymes will not cut sites within the element. This is similar to that observed for Mu elements in Mutator stocks that have lost activity. We report herein that the Mu1.4-B37 element loses its modification and becomes accessible to digestion when placed in an active Mutator stock by genetic crosses. This suggests that factors conditioning unmodified elements are dominant in the initial cross between Mutator and non-Mutator stocks. In F2 individuals that have subsequently lost Mutator activity the Mu1.4-B37 element again becomes modified as do most of the Mu elements in the stock. Thus, the modification state of the Mu1.4-B37 element and the other Mu1-like elements correlates with Mutator activity. We hypothesize that factor(s) within an active Mutator stock may inhibit the modification of Mu elements, and that this activity is missing in non-Mutator stocks and may become limiting in certain Mutator stocks resulting in DNA modification.     

Duplication and suppression of chloroplast protein translocation genes in maize

The HCF106 (high chlorophyll fluorescence) gene of maize encodes a chloroplast membrane protein required for translocation of a subset of proteins across the thylakoid membrane. Mutations in HCF106 caused by the insertion of Robertson's Mutator transposable elements have been mapped to chromosome 2S. Here we show that there is a closely related homolog of HCF106 encoded elsewhere in the maize genome (HCF106c) that can partially compensate for these mutations. This homolog maps on chromosome 10L and is part of the most recent set of segmental duplications in the maize genome. Triple mutants that are disrupted in both the HCF106 and Sec-dependent protein translocation pathways provide evidence that they act independently. The HCF106c gene accounts for a previously reported exception to the correlation between epigenetic suppression of hcf106 and methylation of Mutator transposons. We also demonstrate that insertions of Robertson's Mutator elements into either introns or promoters can lead to mutations whose phenotypes are suppressed in the absence of Mu activity, while alleles with insertions in both positions are not suppressed. The implications of these observations are discussed.     

Mu1-Related Transposable Elements of Maize Preferentially Insert into Low Copy Number DNA

The Mutator transposable element system of maize was originally identified through its induction of mutations at an exceptionally high frequency and at a wide variety of loci. The Mu1 subfamily of transposable elements within this system are responsible for the majority of Mutator-induced mutations. Mu 1-related elements were isolated from active Mutator plants and their flanking DNA was characterized. Sequence analyses revealed perfect nine base target duplications directly flanking the insert for 13 of the 14 elements studied. Hybridizational studies indicated that Mu1-like elements insert primarily into regions of the maize genome that are of low copy number. This preferential selection of low copy number DNA as targets for Mu element insertion was not directed by any specific secondary structure(s) that could be detected in this study, but the 9-bp target duplications exhibited a discernibly higher than random match with the consensus sequence 5'-G-T-T-G-G/C-A-G-G/A-G-3'.     

Characterization of bz1 mutants isolated from mutator stocks with high and low numbers of Mu1 elements

The high frequency of mutations in Mutator stocks of maize is the result of transposition of Mu elements. Nine different Mu elements that share the 220 bp Mu terminal inverted repeats have been described. Mu1 elements have been found inserted into most of the molecularly characterized mutant alleles isolated from Mutator stocks, and most Mutator stocks contain a high number of Mu1 elements (10-60). However, it is clear that additional Mu elements, which share the Mu1 termini but have unrelated internal sequences, can also transpose in Mutator stocks. We were interested in comparing the mutation frequency and type of elements that inserted into a particular locus when Mutator stocks with differing numbers of Mu1 elements were utilized. Furthermore, previous studies with Mu-induced mutations have demonstrated that the element that inserted most frequently was Mu1. Therefore, to try to obtain Mu elements different from Mu1 we utilized a stock that had a low number (3-6) of Mu1 elements as well as a Mutator stock with a more typical number of Mu1 elements (20-60). Utilizing both stocks, we isolated numerous mutants at one gene, Bronze 1 (Bz1), and compared the type of elements inserted. In this paper we report that both the high and low Mu1 stocks produced bz1 mutants at frequencies characteristic of Mutator stocks, 6.6 and 4.3 x 10(-5), respectively. We describe the isolation of 20 bz1 mutations, and the initial molecular characterization of eight unstable mutations: two from the high Mu1 stock and six from the low Mu1 stock. The six alleles isolated from the low Mu1 stock appear to contain deleted Mu1 elements, and the two alleles isolated from the high Mu1 stock contain elements very similar to Mu1. When the mutants from the low Mu1 stocks were examined, it was found that the Mu1-related elements increased from 3-6 copies to 9-20 copies in one generation. The high number of Mu1-related elements was maintained in subsequent outcrosses. This spontaneous activation and amplification of Mu1-related elements occurred in at least 1% of the low Mu1 plants.     

Two Maize Genes Are Each Targeted Predominantly by Distinct Classes of Mu Elements

The Mutator transposable element system of maize has been used to isolate mutations at many different genes. Six different classes of Mu transposable elements have been identified. An important question is whether particular classes of Mu elements insert into different genes at equivalent frequencies. To begin to address this question, we used a small number of closely related Mutator plants to generate multiple independent mutations at two different genes. The overall mutation frequency was similar for the two genes. We then determined what types of Mu elements inserted into the genes. We found that each of the genes was preferentially targeted by a different class of Mu element, even when the two genes were mutated in the same plant. Possible explanations for these findings are discussed. These results have important implications for cloning Mu-tagged genes as other genes may also be resistant or susceptible to the insertion of particular classes of Mu elements.     

The Mu Transposable Elements of Maize: Evidence for Transposition and Copy Number Regulation during Development

The Mu transposon of maize exists in a highly mutagenic strain called Robertson's Mutator. Plants of this strain contain 10-50 copies of the Mu element, whereas most maize strains and other plants have none. When Mutator plants are crossed to plants of the inbred line 1S2P, which does not have copies of Mu, the progeny plants have approximately the same number of Mu sequences as did their Mutator parent. Approximately one-half of these copies have segregated from their parent and one-half have arisen by transposition and are integrated into new positions in the genome. This maintenance of copy number can be accounted for by an extremely high rate of transposition of the Mu elements (10-15 transpositions per gamete per generation). When Mutator plants are self-pollinated, the progeny double their Mu copy number in the first generation, but maintain a constant number of Mu sequences with subsequent self-pollinations. Transposition of Mu and the events that lead to copy number maintenance occur very late in the development of the germ cells but before fertilization. A larger version of the Mu element transposes but is not necessary for transposition of the Mu sequences. The progeny of crosses with a Mutator plant occasionally lack Mutator activity; these strains retain copies of the Mu element, but these elements no longer transpose.     

Developmental and genetic aspects of Mutator excision in maize

The regulation of excision of Mu elements of the Mutator transposable element family of maize is not well understood. We have used somatic instability of Mu receptor elements from the Bronze 1 and Bronze 2 loci to monitor the frequency and the timing of excision of Mu elements in several tissues. We show that spot size in the aleurone of a bz2::mu1 stock varies between one to approximately 256 cells. This indicates that excision events begin eight divisions prior to full aleurone differentiation and end after the last division of the aleurone. We show that excision is equally biased for late events in all other tissues studied. A locus on chromosome 5 has been identified that affects spot size, possibly by altering the timing of Mu excision. Using somatic excision as an assay of Mutator activity, we found that activity can change in small sectors of the tassel; however, there are no overall activity changes in the tassel during the period of pollen shedding. We also report the recovery of germinal revertants for the bz1::mu1 and bz2::mu1 alleles. One of these revertant alleles was characterized by Southern blot analysis and found to be similar to the progenitor of the mutable allele.     

Inheritance of Mutator Activity in ZEA MAYS as Assayed by Somatic Instability of the bz2-mu1 Allele

Mutator lines of maize were originally defined by their high forward mutation rate, now known to be caused by the transposition of numerous Mu elements. A high frequency of somatic instability, seen as a fine purple spotting pattern on the aleurone tissue, is characteristic of Mu-induced mutable alleles of genes of the anthocyanin pathway. Loss of such somatic instability has been correlated with the de novo, specific modification of Mu element DNA. In this report the presence or loss of somatic instability at the bz2-mu1 allele has been monitored to investigate the inheritance of the Mutator phenomenon. The active state is labile and may become weakly active (low fraction of spotted kernel progeny) or totally inactive (no spotted kernel progeny) during either outcrossing to non-Mutator lines or on self-pollination. In contrast, the inactive state is relatively permanent with rare reactivation in subsequent crosses to non-Mutator lines. Cryptic bz2-mu1 alleles in weakly active lines can be efficiently reactivated to somatic instability when crossed with an active line. However, in reciprocal crosses of active and totally inactive individuals, strong maternal effects were observed on the inactivation of a somatically unstable bz2-mu1 allele and on the reactivation of cryptic bz2-mu1 alleles. In general, the activity state of the female parent determines the mutability of the progeny.