Proteomics without polyacrylamide: qualitative and quantitative uses of tandem mass spectrometry in proteome analysis

Proteomics can be thought of as an attempt to understand the information encoded in genomic sequences from the perspective of proteins; i.e. the structure, function and regulation of biological processes at the protein level. In practice it stands in stark contrast to the hypothesis-driven serial approach practiced in the last century that was so successful for protein chemists and is built on the basic understanding of protein physicochemical properties developed during that era. Proteomics attempts to study biological processes comprehensively or globally by systematic parallel analysis of proteins expressed in a cell. While there are many analytical techniques in use and under development in proteomics, mass spectrometry is currently one of the field's most important discovery-based tools. This article will review some of the current approaches for qualitative and quantitative uses of tandem mass spectrometry in the field of proteomics specifically avoiding a discussion of the use of gel electrophoresis prior to mass spectrometry. Electronic Publication     

Mass spectrometry‐based methods to study protein architecture and dynamics

Mass spectrometry is now an indispensable tool in the armamentarium of molecular biophysics, where it is used for tasks ranging from protein sequencing and mapping of post‐translational modifications to studies of higher order structure, conformational dynamics, and interactions of proteins with small molecule ligands and other biopolymers. This mini‐review highlights several popular mass spectrometry‐based tools that are now commonly used for structural studies of proteins beyond their covalent structure with a particular emphasis on hydrogen exchange and direct electrospray ionization mass spectrometry.     

Prediction of missed cleavage sites in tryptic peptides aids protein identification in proteomics

Protein identification via peptide mass fingerprinting (PMF) remains a key component of high-throughput proteomics experiments in post-genomic science. Candidate protein identifications are made using bioinformatic tools from peptide peak lists obtained via mass spectrometry (MS). These algorithms rely on several search parameters, including the number of potential uncut peptide bonds matching the primary specificity of the hydrolytic enzyme used in the experiment. Typically, up to one of these "missed cleavages" are considered by the bioinformatics search tools, usually after digestion of the in silico proteome by trypsin. Using two distinct, nonredundant datasets of peptides identified via PMF and tandem MS, a simple predictive method based on information theory is presented which is able to identify experimentally defined missed cleavages with up to 90% accuracy from amino acid sequence alone. Using this simple protocol, we are able to "mask" candidate protein databases so that confident missed cleavage sites need not be considered for in silico digestion. We show that that this leads to an improvement in database searching, with two different search engines, using the PMF dataset as a test set. In addition, the improved approach is also demonstrated on an independent PMF data set of known proteins that also has corresponding high-quality tandem MS data, validating the protein identifications. This approach has wider applicability for proteomics database searching, and the program for predicting missed cleavages and masking Fasta-formatted protein sequence databases has been made available via http:// ispider.smith.man.ac uk/MissedCleave.     

Rational design of complementary peptides to the betaAmyloid 29-42 fusion peptide: an application of PepDesign

Peptides in solution currently exist under several conformations; an equilibrium which varies with solvent polarity. Despite or because of this structure versatility, peptides can be selective biological tools: they can adapt to a target, vary conformation with solvents and so on. These capacities are crucial for cargo carriers. One promising way of using peptides in biotechnologies is to decipher their medium-sequence-structure-function relationships and one approach is molecular modelling. Only few "in silico" methods of peptide design are described in the literature. Most are used in support of experimental screening of peptide libraries. However, the way they are made does not teach us much for future researches. In this paper, we describe an "in silico" method (PepDesign) which starts by analysing the native interaction of a peptide with a target molecule in order to define which points are important. From there, a modelling protocol for the design of 'better' peptides is set. The PepDesign procedure calculates new peptides fulfilling the hypothesis, tests the conformational space of these peptides in interaction with the target by angular dynamics and goes up to the selection of the best peptide based on the analysis of complex structure properties. Experimental biological assays are finally used to test the selected peptides, hence to validate the approach. Applications of PepDesign are wide because the procedure will remain similar irrespective of the target which can be a protein, a drug or a nucleic acid. In this paper, we describe the design of peptides which binds to the fusogenic helical form of the C-terminal domain of the Abeta peptide (Abeta29-42).     

The emerging role of native mass spectrometry in characterizing the structure and dynamics of macromolecular complexes

Mass spectrometry (MS) is a powerful tool for determining the mass of biomolecules with high accuracy and sensitivity. MS performed under so-called “native conditions” (native MS) can be used to determine the mass of biomolecules that associate noncovalently. Here we review the application of native MS to the study of protein−ligand interactions and its emerging role in elucidating the structure of macromolecular assemblies, including soluble and membrane protein complexes. Moreover, we discuss strategies aimed at determining the stoichiometry and topology of subunits by inducing partial dissociation of the holo-complex. We also survey recent developments in "native top-down MS", an approach based on Fourier Transform MS, whereby covalent bonds are broken without disrupting non-covalent interactions. Given recent progress, native MS is anticipated to play an increasingly important role for researchers interested in the structure of macromolecular complexes.     

Derivatization of carbohydrates for chromatographic,electrophoretic and mass spectrometric structure analysis

Carbohydrates, either alone or as constituents of glycoproteins, proteoglycans and glycolipids, are mediators of several cellular events and (patho)physiological processes. Progress in the "glycome" project is closely related to the analytical tools used to define carbohydrate structure and correlate structure with function. Chromatography, electrophoresis and mass spectrometry are the indispensable analytical tools of the on-going research. Carbohydrate derivatization is required for most of these analytical procedures. This review article gives an overview of derivatization methods of carbohydrates for their liquid chromatographic and electrophoretic separation, as well as the mass spectrometric characterization. Pre-column and on-capillary derivatization methods are presented with special emphasis on the derivatization of large carbohydrates.     

A new approach for plant proteomics: characterization of chloroplast proteins of Arabidopsis thaliana by top-down mass spectrometry

A recently developed methodology for the characterization of complex proteomes, top-down Fourier transform mass spectrometry (FTMS), is applied for the first time to a plant proteome, that of the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana. Of the 3000 proteins predicted by the genome sequence, 97 were recently identified in two separate "bottom-up" mass spectrometry studies in which the proteins were purified and digested and in which the mass spectrometry-measured mass values of the resulting peptides matched against those expected from the DNA-predicted proteins. In the top-down approach applied here, molecular ions from a protein mixture are purified, weighed exactly (+/-1 Da), and fragmented in the FTMS. Of the 22 molecular weight values found in three isolated mixtures, 7 were chosen, and their primary structures were fully characterized; in only one case was the bottom-up structure in full agreement. The top-down technique is not only efficient for identification of the DNA-predicted precursors, such as that of a protein present as a 5% mixture component, but also for characterization of the primary structure of the final protein. For two proteins the previously predicted cleavage site for loss of the signal peptide was found to be incorrect. Two 27-kDa proteins are fully characterized, although they are found to differ by only 12 residues and 6 Da in mass in a 3:1 ratio; the bottom-up studies did not distinguish these proteins. Direct tandem mass spectrometry dissociation of two 15-kDa molecular ions showed >90% sequence similarity, whereas three-stage mass spectrometry traced their +14-Da molecular mass discrepancies to an unusual N-methylation on the N-terminal amino group; the bottom-up approach identified only one precursor protein. The high potential of the top-down FTMS approach for characterization as well as identification of complex plant proteomes should provide a real incentive for its further automation.     

Biological insights from hydrogen exchange mass spectrometry

Over the past two decades, hydrogen exchange mass spectrometry (HXMS) has achieved the status of a widespread and routine approach in the structural biology toolbox. The ability of hydrogen exchange to detect a range of protein dynamics coupled with the accessibility of mass spectrometry to mixtures and large complexes at low concentrations result in an unmatched tool for investigating proteins challenging to many other structural techniques. Recent advances in methodology and data analysis are helping HXMS deliver on its potential to uncover the connection between conformation, dynamics and the biological function of proteins and complexes. This review provides a brief overview of the HXMS method and focuses on four recent reports to highlight applications that monitor structure and dynamics of proteins and complexes, track protein folding, and map the thermodynamics and kinetics of protein unfolding at equilibrium. These case studies illustrate typical data, analysis and results for each application and demonstrate a range of biological systems for which the interpretation of HXMS in terms of structure and conformational parameters provides unique insights into function. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Mass spectrometry in structural biology.     

PeptideAtlas: a resource for target selection for emerging targeted proteomics workflows

A crucial part of a successful systems biology experiment is an assay that provides reliable, quantitative measurements for each of the components in the system being studied. For proteomics to be a key part of such studies, it must deliver accurate quantification of all the components in the system for each tested perturbation without any gaps in the data. This will require a new approach to proteomics that is based on emerging targeted quantitative mass spectrometry techniques. The PeptideAtlas Project comprises a growing, publicly accessible database of peptides identified in many tandem mass spectrometry proteomics studies and software tools that allow the building of PeptideAtlas, as well as its use by the research community. Here, we describe the PeptideAtlas Project, its contents and components, and show how together they provide a unique platform to select and validate mass spectrometry targets, thereby allowing the next revolution in proteomics.     

Direct evidence for the cooperative unfolding of cytochrome c in lipid membranes from H-(2)H exchange kinetics

The interaction of cytochrome c (cyt c) with anionic lipid membranes is known to disrupt the tightly packed native structure of the protein. This process leads to a lipid-inserted denatured state, which retains a native-like alpha-helical structure but lacks any specific tertiary interactions. The structural and dynamic properties of cyt c bound to vesicles containing an anionic phospholipid (DOPS) were investigated by amide H-(2)H exchange using two-dimensional NMR spectroscopy and electrospray ionisation mass spectrometry. The H-(2)H exchange kinetics of the core amide protons in cyt c, which in the native protein undergo exchange via an uncorrelated EX2 mechanism, exchange in the lipid vesicles via a highly concerted global transition that exposes these protected amide groups to solvent. The lack of pH dependence and the observation of distinct populations of deuterated and protonated species by mass spectrometry confirms that exchange occurs via an EX1 mechanism with a common rate of 1(+/-0.5) h(-1), which reflects the rate of transition from the lipid-inserted state, H(l), to an unprotected conformation, D(i), associated with the lipid interface.     

Platform Dependencies in Bottom-up Hydrogen/Deuterium Exchange Mass Spectrometry

Hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry is an important method for protein structure-function analysis. The bottom-up approach uses protein digestion to localize deuteration to higher resolution, and the essential measurement involves centroid mass determinations on a very large set of peptides. In the course of evaluating systems for various projects, we established two (HDX-MS) platforms that consisted of a FT-MS and a high-resolution QTOF mass spectrometer, each with matched front-end fluidic systems. Digests of proteins spanning a 20–110 kDa range were deuterated to equilibrium, and figures-of-merit for a typical bottom-up (HDX-MS) experiment were compared for each platform. The Orbitrap Velos identified 64% more peptides than the 5600 QTOF, with a 42% overlap between the two systems, independent of protein size. Precision in deuterium measurements using the Orbitrap marginally exceeded that of the QTOF, depending on the Orbitrap resolution setting. However, the unique nature of FT-MS data generates situations where deuteration measurements can be inaccurate, because of destructive interference arising from mismatches in elemental mass defects. This is shown through the analysis of the peptides common to both platforms, where deuteration values can be as low as 35% of the expected values, depending on FT-MS resolution, peptide length and charge state. These findings are supported by simulations of Orbitrap transients, and highlight that caution should be exercised in deriving centroid mass values from FT transients that do not support baseline separation of the full isotopic composition.Hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX-MS)¹ provides a powerful means to study the link between protein structure and function (1). The method involves a chemical process in which labile hydrogens within a protein are exchanged with hydrogen from bulk water. When D₂O is used in place of H₂O, a mass shift results at every point of exchange, but it is the backbone amide hydrogens that offer exchange rates on a measurable timescale (2, 3). Measuring an amide hydrogen exchange rate can provide access to conformational dynamics, stability, and the interaction characteristics in that location of structure (4, 5). H/D exchange rates have be used to explore mechanisms of protein folding (6), determine the allosteric impact of post-translational modifications and ligand binding (7, 8), define truncation points for enhancing crystallization success (9), and they have also found a role in mapping interactions between proteins (10). Applications have stepped outside of primary research to include the characterization of protein drugs for stability and similarity testing (11–13). The capacity to provide such information has attracted increased attention from regulatory bodies and is generating a push for standardizing HDX methods.Mass spectrometers are very effective tools for measuring exchange rates, from whole proteins down to the individual amide levels. Classical methods of rate measurement have used NMR (3), but mass spectrometry offers all the advantages of speed, sensitivity and scale that have made the tool so useful in proteomics. Measurements at the peptide level provide an important intermediate resolution. As with bottom-up proteomics, rendering deuterated proteins into smaller peptides through digestion provides opportunities to analyze protein systems of considerable complexity, and at the same time support analysis at higher structural resolution through MS/MS methods (14, 15). A considerable amount of effort has been applied by the research community and instrument manufacturers to produce instrument configurations that are suitable for managing the many processing steps required for labeling, digesting, separating and introducing deuterated peptides into the mass spectrometer (16). This has been supported by parallel efforts to develop software tools for the detection of deuterated peptides and the extraction of deuteration data (17–19).A successful application of the bottom-up HDX-MS method requires a full peptide sequence map of the protein, so that deuteration rates at every point in protein structure can be quantified and related back to structure. Once the peptide is identified, the primary measurement is the peptide centroid mass of the deuterated state, relative to the unlabeled state. It requires intensity measurements for a minimum of two peaks in the isotopic cluster to determine when the centroid mass changes (20), although most often the full distribution is quantified in HDX-MS applications. As the range of applications continues to grow, particularly in the regulatory area, it is important to better understand how various elements of the HDX platform deliver the essential data (21, 22). In the current study, we are interested in the contribution of the mass spectrometer alone. Most users of the HDX-MS method are migrating from low resolution to high resolution systems, operated in a single-stage MS mode. This includes FT-MS and higher-resolution QTOF platforms, therefore in this study, we explore how an LTQ Orbitrap Velos (Thermo) and a 5600 TripleTOF (AB Sciex) influence the measurement of deuteration data for proteins of increasing size. Identical front-end fluidic systems and protein digests, as well as back-end analysis procedures, allow us to perform a direct comparison of performance in areas of sequence mapping, centroid measurement precision and centroid mass accuracy. We demonstrate that the Orbitrap system returns greater sequencing depth and marginally better precision than the 5600, however the measurement accuracy is strongly influenced by destructive interference arising from unequal mass defects between ¹³C and ²H. This has implications for any application that involves centroid mass determinations, beyond HDX-MS.     

Deconvolution of targeted protein-protein interaction maps

Current proteomic techniques allow researchers to analyze chosen biological pathways or an ensemble of related protein complexes at a global level via the measure of physical protein-protein interactions by affinity purification mass spectrometry (AP-MS). Such experiments yield information-rich but complex interaction maps whose unbiased interpretation is challenging. Guided by current knowledge on the modular structure of protein complexes, we propose a novel statistical approach, named BI-MAP, complemented by software tools and a visual grammar to present the inferred modules. We show that the BI-MAP tools can be applied from small and very detailed maps to large, sparse, and much noisier data sets. The BI-MAP tool implementation and test data are made freely available.     

Dissecting the hydrogen exchange properties of insulin under amyloid fibril forming conditions: a site-specific investigation by mass spectrometry

We have examined the hydrogen exchange properties of bovine insulin under solution conditions that cause it to aggregate and eventually form amyloid fibrils. The results have been obtained at the residue-specific level using peptic digestion and mass spectrometry. A total of 19 peptides were assigned to regions of the protein and their exchange properties monitored for a period of 24 hours. The results of the peptic digestion show that residues A13 to A21 and B11 to B30 are more susceptible to proteolysis than the N-terminal regions of the protein. A total of 15 slowly exchanging amides were observed for insulin under these solution conditions. Location of the protected amides was carried out using a peptic-digestion protocol at low pH. Chromatographic separation was not required. This enabled a direct comparison of the peptides within the same mass spectrum. From kinetic analysis of the rates slow exchange has been located to 4(+/-1) backbone amides in the A13-A19 helix and 6(+/-1) in the B chain helix. The remaining 5(+/-1) are assigned to helix A2-A8. Taken together the results from digestion and hydrogen exchange show that at low pH and relatively high concentrations the C termini of both chains are susceptible to proteolysis but that the solution structure contains the native state helices. More generally the results demonstrate that mass spectrometry can be applied to study site-specific hydrogen exchange properties of proteins even under conditions where they are known to be partially folded and aggregate extensively in solution.     

Isoforms of U1-70k Control Subunit Dynamics in the Human Spliceosomal U1 snRNP

Most human protein-encoding genes contain multiple exons that are spliced together, frequently in alternative arrangements, by the spliceosome. It is established that U1 snRNP is an essential component of the spliceosome, in human consisting of RNA and ten proteins, several of which are post-translationally modified and exist as multiple isoforms. Unresolved and challenging to investigate are the effects of these post translational modifications on the dynamics, interactions and stability of the particle. Using mass spectrometry we investigate the composition and dynamics of the native human U1 snRNP and compare native and recombinant complexes to isolate the effects of various subunits and isoforms on the overall stability. Our data reveal differential incorporation of four protein isoforms and dynamic interactions of subunits U1-A, U1-C and Sm-B/B''. Results also show that unstructured post-translationally modified C-terminal tails are responsible for the dynamics of Sm-B/B'' and U1-C and that their interactions with the Sm core are controlled by binding to different U1-70k isoforms and their phosphorylation status in vivo. These results therefore provide the important functional link between proteomics and structure as well as insight into the dynamic quaternary structure of the native U1 snRNP important for its function.     

Description of the quaternary structure of tetrameric proteins. Forms that show either right-handed or left-handed symmetry at the subunit level.

A method is described for comparing the shapes of tetrameric proteins whose three-dimensional structure is known. The centres of mass of single subunits are calculated as Cartesian co-ordinates with respect to their three dyad axes. The axes are allocated on the basis of the extent of the intersubunit contacts that they relate. This results in the division of proteins into two classes called right-handed and left-handed. A second division, which also contains right-handed and left-handed forms, is made according to the distances between the centres of mass of the subunits measured across the two axes with the most extensive contacts. Two other parameters have been calculated from the coordinates; they are named "aplanarity" and "twist". The eight tetramers so far investigated are discussed. One, lactate dehydrogenase, cannot be treated in this way. Among the others, right-handed structures (according to both definitions) are found to be commoner; most have low twist; all are of fairly high aplanarity except phosphoglycerate mutase. Prealbumin is exceptional, being left-handed in both ways and of high twist; it has a figure-of-eight structure with the centres of mass lying in one plane. The changes in the quaternary structure of haemoglobin are also presented by using this approach; on deoxygenation the aplanarity and the twist decrease.     

Removal of the conserved disulfide bridges from the scFv fragment of an antibody: effects on folding kinetics and aggregation.

Fluorescence measurements and H/2H exchange experiments monitored by mass spectrometry have been applied to investigate the influence of the conserved disulfide bridges on the folding behavior and in vitro aggregation properties of the scFv fragment of the antibody hu4D5-8. A set of four proteins, carrying none, one, or both of the disulfide bridges have been compared regarding their stabilities, folding kinetics and tendency to aggregate. The results show that refolding of all four scFvs is ultimately limited by a slow proline isomerization in the VLdomain, since the native cis -conformation of proline L95 seems to be a prerequisite for formation of the native interface. Starting from short-term denatured protein, with the proline residues in their native conformation, a kinetically trapped intermediate is populated depending on the conditions, whose rate of conversion is slower than that of the fast-folding molecules. According to deuteron protection patterns determined by mass spectrometry, those domains retaining the disulfide bridge are able to form stable native-like structure, independent of native interface formation. The disulfide-free domains, in contrast, require the native interface for sufficient stabilization. The resistance of the scFvs towards aggregation seems to be critically dependent on the presence of the disulfide bridge in the VHdomain, and thus on the ability of the VHdomain to form stable structure prior to interaction with the VLdomain. The presence of a stable VLdomain in combination with a disulfide-free VHdomain appears to further promote aggregation, indicating the involvement of structured domains in the aggregates.     

SMA-PAGE: A new method to examine complexes of membrane proteins using SMALP nano-encapsulation and native gel electrophoresis

Most membrane proteins function through interactions with other proteins in the phospholipid bilayer, the cytosol or the extracellular milieu. Understanding the molecular basis of these interactions is key to understanding membrane protein function and dysfunction. Here we demonstrate for the first time how a nano-encapsulation method based on styrene maleic acid lipid particles (SMALPs) can be used in combination with native gel electrophoresis to separate membrane protein complexes in their native state. Using four model proteins, we show that this separation method provides an excellent measure of protein quaternary structure, and that the lipid environment surrounding the protein(s) can be probed using mass spectrometry. We also show that the method is complementary to immunoblotting. Finally we show that intact membrane protein-SMALPs extracted from a band on a gel could be visualised using electron microscopy (EM). Taken together these results provide a novel and elegant method for investigating membrane protein complexes in a native state.     

Hydrogen exchange kinetics of RNase A and the urea:TMAO paradigm

A key paradigm in the biology of adaptation holds that urea affects protein function by increasing the fluctuations of the native state, while trimethylamine N-oxide (TMAO) affects function in the opposite direction by decreasing the normal fluctuations of the native ensemble. Using urea and TMAO separately and together, hydrogen exchange (HX) studies on RNase A at pH* 6.35 were used to investigate the basic tenets of the urea:TMAO paradigm. TMAO (1 M) alone decreases HX rate constants of a select number of sites exchanging from the native ensemble, and low urea alone increases the rate constants of some of the same sites. Addition of TMAO to urea solutions containing RNase A also suppresses HX rate constants. The data show that urea and TMAO independently or in combination affect the dynamics of the native ensemble in opposing ways. The results provide evidence in support of the counteraction aspect of the urea:TMAO paradigm linking structural dynamics with protein function in urea-rich organs and organisms. RNase A is so resistant to urea denaturation at pH* 6.35 that even in the presence of 4.8 M urea, the native ensemble accounts for >99.5% of the protein. An essential test, devised to determine the HX mechanism of exchangeable protons, shows that over the 0-4.8 M urea concentration range nearly 80% of all observed sites convert from EX2 to EX1. The slow exchange sites are all EX1; they do not exhibit global exchange even at urea concentrations (5.8 M) well into the denaturation transition zone, and their energetically distinct activated complexes leading to exchange gives evidence of residual structure. Under these experimental conditions, the use of DeltaG(HX) as a basis for HX analysis of RNase A urea denaturation is invalid.     

Insights into enzyme structure and dynamics elucidated by amide H/D exchange mass spectrometry

Conformational changes and protein dynamics play an important role in the catalytic efficiency of enzymes. Amide H/D exchange mass spectrometry (H/D exchange MS) is emerging as an efficient technique to study the local and global changes in protein structure and dynamics due to ligand binding, protein activation-inactivation by modification, and protein-protein interactions. By monitoring the selective exchange of hydrogen for deuterium along a peptide backbone, this sensitive technique probes protein motions and structural elements that may be relevant to allostery and function. In this report, several applications of H/D exchange MS are presented which demonstrate the unique capability of amide hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry for examining dynamic and structural changes associated with enzyme catalysis.