Conformational dynamics of free and catalytically active thermolysin are indistinguishable by hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry

Conformational dynamics are thought to be a prerequisite for the catalytic activity of enzymes. However, the exact relationship between structural fluctuations and function is not well understood. In this work hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX) and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) are used for exploring the conformational dynamics of thermolysin. Amide HDX reflects the internal mobility of proteins; regions that undergo frequent unfolding-refolding show faster exchange than segments that are highly stable. Thermolysin is a zinc protease with an active site that is located between two lobes. Substrate turnover is associated with hinge bending that leads to a closed conformation. Product release regenerates the open form, such that steady-state catalysis involves a continuous closing/opening cycle. HDX/ESI-MS with proteolytic peptide mapping in the absence of substrate shows that elements in the periphery of the two lobes are most mobile. A comparison with previous X-ray data suggests that these peripheral regions undergo quite pronounced structural changes during the catalytic cycle. In contrast, active site residues exhibit only a moderate degree of backbone flexibility, and the central zinc appears to be in a fairly rigid environment. The presence of both rigid and moderately flexible elements in the active site may reflect a carefully tuned balance that is required for function. Interestingly, the HDX behavior of catalytically active thermolysin is indistinguishable from that of the free enzyme. This result is consistent with the view that catalytically relevant motions preexist in the resting state and that enzyme function can only be performed within the limitations given by the intrinsic dynamics of the protein. The data presented in this work indicate the prevalence of stochastic elements in the function of thermolysin, rather than supporting a deterministic mechanism.     

Conformational dynamics of partially denatured myoglobin studied by time-resolved electrospray mass spectrometry with online hydrogen-deuterium exchange

This study demonstrates the use of electrospray mass spectrometry in conjunction with rapid online mixing ("time-resolved" ESI-MS) for monitoring protein conformational dynamics under equilibrium conditions. The hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX) kinetics of mildly denatured myoglobin (Mb) at pD 9.3, in the presence of 27% acetonitrile, were studied with millisecond time resolution. Analytical ultracentrifugation indicates that the average protein compactness under these solvent conditions is similar to that of native holomyoglobin (hMb). The mass spectrum shows protein ions in a wide array of charge and heme binding states, indicating the presence of multiple coexisting conformations. The experimental approach used allows the HDX kinetics of all of these species to be monitored separately. A combination of EX1 and EX2 behavior was observed for hMb ions in charge states 7+ to 9+, which predominantly represent nativelike hMb in solution. The EX1 kinetics are biphasic, indicating the presence of two protein populations that undergo conformational opening events with different rate constants. The EX2 kinetics observed for nativelike hMb are biphasic as well. All other charge and heme binding states represent non-native protein conformations that are involved in rapid interconversion processes, thus leading to monoexponential EX2 kinetics with a common rate constant. Burst phase labeling for these non-native proteins occurs at 125 sites. In contrast, the nativelike protein conformation shows burst phase labeling only for 88 sites. A kinetic model is developed which is based on the assumption of three distinct (un)folding units in Mb. The model implies that the free energy landscape of the protein exhibits a major barrier. The crossing of this barrier is most likely associated with slow, cooperative opening/closing events of the heme binding pocket. Rapid conformational fluctuations on either side of the barrier give rise to the observed EX2 kinetics. Simulated HDX kinetics based on this model are in excellent agreement with the experimental data.     

Hydrogen/deuterium exchange reveals distinct agonist/partial agonist receptor dynamics within vitamin D receptor/retinoid X receptor heterodimer

Regulation of nuclear receptor (NR) activity is driven by alterations in the conformational dynamics of the receptor upon ligand binding. Previously, we demonstrated that hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX) can be applied to determine novel mechanism of action of PPARγ ligands and in predicting tissue specificity of selective estrogen receptor modulators. Here, we applied HDX to probe the conformational dynamics of the ligand binding domain (LBD) of the vitamin D receptor (VDR) upon binding its natural ligand 1α,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3 (1,25D3), and two analogs, alfacalcidol and ED-71. Comparison of HDX profiles from ligands in complex with the LBD with full-length receptor bound to its cognate receptor retinoid X receptor (RXR) revealed unique receptor dynamics that could not be inferred from static crystal structures. These results demonstrate that ligands modulate the dynamics of the heterodimer interface as well as provide insight into the role of AF-2 dynamics in the action of VDR partial agonists.     

Differential hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry analysis of protein-ligand interactions

Functional regulation of ligand-activated receptors is driven by alterations in the conformational dynamics of the protein upon ligand binding. Differential hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX) coupled with mass spectrometry has emerged as a rapid and sensitive approach for characterization of perturbations in conformational dynamics of proteins following ligand binding. While this technique is sensitive to detecting ligand interactions and alterations in receptor dynamics, it also can provide important mechanistic insights into ligand regulation. For example, HDX has been used to determine a novel mechanism of ligand activation of the nuclear receptor peroxisome proliferator activated receptor-γ, perform detailed analyses of binding modes of ligands within the ligand-binding pocket of two estrogen receptor isoforms, providing insight into selectivity, and helped classify different types of estrogen receptor-α ligands by correlating their pharmacology with the way they interact with the receptor based solely on hierarchical clustering of receptor HDX signatures. Beyond small-molecule-receptor interactions, this technique has also been applied to study protein-protein complexes, such as mapping antibody-antigen interactions. In this article, we summarize the current state of the differential HDX approaches and the future outlook. We summarize how HDX analysis of protein-ligand interactions has had an impact on biology and drug discovery.     

Mapping protein energy landscapes with amide hydrogen exchange and mass spectrometry: I. A generalized model for a two-state protein and comparison with experiment

Protein amide hydrogen exchange (HDX) is a convoluted process, whose kinetics is determined by both dynamics of the protein and the intrinsic exchange rate of labile hydrogen atoms fully exposed to solvent. Both processes are influenced by a variety of intrinsic and extrinsic factors. A mathematical formalism initially developed to rationalize exchange kinetics of individual amide hydrogen atoms is now often used to interpret global exchange kinetics (e.g., as measured in HDX MS experiments). One particularly important advantage of HDX MS is direct visualization of various protein states by observing distinct protein ion populations with different levels of isotope labeling under conditions favoring correlated exchange (the so-called EX1 exchange mechanism). However, mildly denaturing conditions often lead to a situation where the overall HDX kinetics cannot be clearly classified as either EX1 or EX2. The goal of this work is to develop a framework for a generalized exchange model that takes into account multiple processes leading to amide hydrogen exchange, and does not require that the exchange proceed strictly via EX1 or EX2 kinetics. To achieve this goal, we use a probabilistic approach that assigns a transition probability and a residual protection to each equilibrium state of the protein. When applied to a small protein chymotrypsin inhibitor 2, the algorithm allows complex HDX patterns observed experimentally to be modeled with remarkably good fidelity. On the basis of the model we are now in a position to begin to extract quantitative dynamic information from convoluted exchange kinetics.     

Assessment of differences in the conformational flexibility of hepatitis B virus core‐antigen and e‐antigen by hydrogen deuterium exchange‐mass spectrometry

Hepatitis B virus core-antigen (capsid protein) and e-antigen (an immune regulator) have almost complete sequence identity, yet the dimeric proteins (termed Cp149_d and Cp(−10)149_d, respectively) adopt quite distinct quaternary structures. Here we use hydrogen deuterium exchange-mass spectrometry (HDX-MS) to study their structural properties. We detect many regions that differ substantially in their HDX dynamics. Significantly, whilst all regions in Cp(−10)149_d exchange by EX2-type kinetics, a number of regions in Cp149_d were shown to exhibit a mixture of EX2- and EX1-type kinetics, hinting at conformational heterogeneity in these regions. Comparison of the HDX of the free Cp149_d with that in assembled capsids (Cp149_c) indicated increased resistance to exchange at the C-terminus where the inter-dimer contacts occur. Furthermore, evidence of mixed exchange kinetics were not observed in Cp149_c, implying a reduction in flexibility upon capsid formation. Cp(−10)149_d undergoes a drastic structural change when the intermolecular disulphide bridge is reduced, adopting a Cp149_d-like structure, as evidenced by the detected HDX dynamics being more consistent with Cp149_d in many, albeit not all, regions. These results demonstrate the highly dynamic nature of these similar proteins. To probe the effect of these structural differences on the resulting antigenicity, we investigated binding of the antibody fragment (Fab E1) that is known to bind a conformational epitope on the four-helix bundle. Whilst Fab E1 binds to Cp149_c and Cp149_d, it does not bind non-reduced and reduced Cp(−10)149_d, despite unhindered access to the epitope. These results imply a remarkable sensitivity of this epitope to its structural context.     

Probing the Impact of Temperature and Substrates on the Conformational Dynamics of the Neurotransmitter:Sodium symporter LeuT

The crucial function of neurotransmitter:sodium symporters (NSS) in facilitating the reuptake of neurotransmitters into neuronal cells makes them attractive drug targets for treating multiple mental diseases. Due to the challenges in working with eukaryotic NSS proteins, LeuT, a prokaryotic amino acid transporter, has served as a model protein for studying structure–function relationships of NSS family proteins. With hydrogen–deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX-MS), slow unfolding/refolding kinetics were identified in multiple regions of LeuT, suggesting that substrate translocation involves cooperative fluctuations of helical stretches. Earlier work has solely been performed at non-native temperatures (25 °C) for LeuT, which is evolutionarily adapted to function at high temperatures (85 – 95 °C). To address the effect of temperature on LeuT dynamics, we have performed HDX-MS experiments at elevated temperatures (45 °C and 60 °C). At these elevated temperatures, multiple regions in LeuT exhibited increased dynamics compared to 25 °C. Interestingly, coordinated slow unfolding/refolding of key regions could still be observed, though considerably faster. We have further investigated the conformational impact of binding the efficiently transported substrate alanine (Ala) relative to the much slower transported substrate leucine (Leu). Comparing the HDX of the Ala-bound versus Leu-bound state of LeuT, we observe distinct differences that could explain the faster transport rate (k_cat) of Ala relative to Leu. Importantly, slow unfolding/refolding dynamics could still be observed in regions of Ala-bound LeuT . Overall, our work brings new insights into the conformational dynamics of LeuT and provides a better understanding of the transport mechanism of LeuT and possibly other transporters bearing the LeuT fold.     

Structural and dynamic characteristics of a partially folded state of ubiquitin revealed by hydrogen exchange mass spectrometry

Structural and dynamic properties of a partially folded conformation (A-state) of ubiquitin are studied using amide hydrogen exchange in solution (HDX) and mass spectrometric detection. A clear distinction between the native state of the protein and the A-state can be made when HDX is carried out in a semicorrelated regime. Convoluted exchange patterns are interpreted with the aid of HDX simulations in a three-state system (highly structured, partially unstructured, and fully unstructured states). The data clearly indicate a highly dynamic character of the non-native state. Furthermore, combination of HDX and protein ion fragmentation in the gas phase [by means of collision-induced dissociation (CAD)] is used to evaluate the conformational stability of various protein segments specifically in the molten globular state. Chain flexibility appears to be distributed very unevenly in this non-native conformation. The highest degree of structural disorder is displayed by the C-terminal segment (Gly(53)-Gly(76)), which was previously suggested to form a transient alpha-helix. The least dynamic segment of ubiquitin in the A-state is Thr(9)-Glu(18) (which was previously suggested to form a stable nativelike beta-strand), with the adjacent segments exhibiting somewhat diminished conformational stability. The study also demonstrates the power of mass spectrometry as a tool in providing conformer-specific information about the structure and dynamics of both native and non-native protein states coexisting in solution under equilibrium.     

Protein structural dynamics at the gas/water interface examined by hydrogen exchange mass spectrometry

Gas/water interfaces (such as air bubbles or foam) are detrimental to the stability of proteins, often causing aggregation. This represents a potential problem for industrial processes, for example, the production and handling of protein drugs. Proteins possess surfactant-like properties, resulting in a high affinity for gas/water interfaces. The tendency of previously buried nonpolar residues to maximize contact with the gas phase can cause significant structural distortion. Most earlier studies in this area employed spectroscopic tools that could only provide limited information. Here we use hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX) mass spectrometry (MS) for probing the conformational dynamics of the model protein myoglobin (Mb) in the presence of N₂ bubbles. HDX/MS relies on the principle that unfolded and/or highly dynamic regions undergo faster deuteration than tightly folded segments. In bubble-free solution Mb displays EX2 behavior, reflecting the occurrence of short-lived excursions to partially unfolded conformers. A dramatically different behavior is seen in the presence of N₂ bubbles; EX2 dynamics still take place, but in addition the protein shows EX1 behavior. The latter results from interconversion of the native state with conformers that are globally unfolded and long-lived. These unfolded species likely correspond to Mb that is adsorbed to the surface of gas bubbles. N₂ sparging also induces aggregation. To explain the observed behavior we propose a simple model, that is, “semi-unfolded” ↔ “native” ↔ “globally unfolded” → “aggregated”. This model quantitatively reproduces the experimentally observed kinetics. To the best of our knowledge, the current study marks the first exploration of surface denaturation phenomena by HDX/MS.     

Hydrogen deuterium exchange mass spectrometry applied to chaperones and chaperone-assisted protein folding

Introduction: Hydrogen–deuterium exchange (HDX) mass spectrometry (MS) is ideal for monitoring the protein folding and unfolding. The exchange of a deuterium in solution for an amide hydrogen in a protein can be very different depending on the degree of folding and protection of backbone amide positions. Molecular chaperones that assist with protein folding in vivo are necessary for folding of many substrate (client) proteins. HDX MS provides valuable insight into what chaperones are doing in protein folding and how they are doing it.

Areas covered: Application of HDX MS to the protein folding problem was desirable from the outset of the technique, but technical issues prohibited many studies. In the last 20 years, conformational changes of chaperones themselves (e.g., GroEL/GroES, Hsp70, and Hsp90) have been studied. Studies of interactions between chaperones, co-chaperones, and substrate proteins have revealed binding interfaces, allosteric conformational changes, and remodeling of components during various chaperone cycles. Experiments elucidating how chaperones contribute to and enhance the folding pathway of substrate proteins have been demonstrated.

Expert opinion: Technical issues that once prevented the analysis of chaperones have largely been resolved, permitting exciting comprehensive HDX MS studies of folding pathways during chaperone-assisted protein folding.     

Structure and conformational dynamics of base excision repair DNA glycosylases

DNA glycosylases are key enzymes participating in the process of DNA repair, which maintains the integrity of the cellular genome. Currently, structures for many of these enzymes have been solved. This review is devoted to the analysis of these structures and the dynamics of the interactions of DNA glycosylases with DNA. The available data suggest that lesion recognition by DNA glycosylases is a highly dynamic process accompanied with multiple conformational changes in the enzyme and the DNA substrate molecules.     

A glimpse into the molecular mechanism of integral membrane proteins through hydrogen–deuterium exchange mass spectrometry

Integral membrane proteins (IMPs) control countless fundamental biological processes and constitute the majority of drug targets. For this reason, uncovering their molecular mechanism of action has long been an intense field of research. They are, however, notoriously difficult to work with, mainly due to their localization within the heterogeneous of environment of the biological membrane and the instability once extracted from the lipid bilayer. High‐resolution structures have unveiled many mechanistic aspects of IMPs but also revealed that the elucidation of static pictures has limitations. Hydrogen–deuterium exchange coupled to mass spectrometry (HDX‐MS) has recently emerged as a powerful biophysical tool for interrogating the conformational dynamics of proteins and their interactions with ligands. Its versatility has proven particularly useful to reveal mechanistic aspects of challenging classes of proteins such as IMPs. This review recapitulates the accomplishments of HDX‐MS as it has matured into an essential tool for membrane protein structural biologists.     

Intricacies of interactions,dynamics and solvent effects in enzyme catalysis: a computational perspective on cyclophilin A

The essential role of enzymes in biological processes has continually ignited sparks of interest in their mechanism of action. Fully understanding the mechanism of enzymes has broad implications in protein engineering and drug design. The more than five order of magnitude speed-up in the rate of peptidyl–prolyl cis–trans isomerisation by cyclophilin A (CypA) has been the target of intense research. CypA serves as a tractable model system, because it reversibly catalyses the rotation around peptidyl–prolyl bonds without any bond breakage or formation. Here, we discuss the results of recent computational approaches used to study the mechanism of CypA. We highlight the critical role of enzyme and substrate conformational dynamics in the developing interactions as the substrate approaches the transition state that results in an astonishing enhancement of isomerisation rate. The rate of isomerisation is affected by the intricate coupling between the dynamics of the substrate, enzyme and solvent. CypA binds its substrates via conformational selection, where rearrangements of key active site residues are necessary for substrate recognition. The conformational plasticity of the active site allows the enzyme to accommodate the most favourable interactions with the transition state that can be exploited for structure-based drug design.     

Coupling between catalytic site and collective dynamics: a requirement for mechanochemical activity of enzymes

Growing evidence supports the view that enzymatic activity results from a subtle interplay between chemical kinetics and molecular motions. A systematic analysis is performed here to delineate the type and level of coupling between catalysis and conformational mechanics. The dynamics of a set of 98 enzymes representative of different EC classes are analyzed with the Gaussian network model (GNM) and compared with experimental data. In more than 70% of the examined enzymes, the global hinge centers predicted by the GNM are found to be colocalized with the catalytic sites experimentally identified. Low translational mobility (< 7%) is observed for the catalytic residues, consistent with the fine-tuned design of enzymes to achieve precise mechanochemical activities. Ligand binding sites, while closely neighboring catalytic sites, enjoy a moderate flexibility to accommodate the ligand binding. These findings could serve as additional criteria for assessing drug binding residues and could lessen the computational burden of substrate docking searches.     

Intrinsic local destabilization of the C‐terminus predisposes integrin α1 I domain to a conformational switch induced by collagen binding

Integrin–collagen interactions play a critical role in a myriad of cellular functions that include immune response, and cell development and differentiation, yet their mechanism of binding is poorly understood. There is increasing evidence that conformational flexibility assumes a central role in the molecular mechanisms of protein–protein interactions and here we employ NMR hydrogen–deuterium exchange (HDX) experiments to explore the impact of slower timescale dynamic events. To gain insight into the mechanisms underlying collagen‐induced conformational switches, we have undertaken a comparative study between the wild type integrin α1 I and a gain‐of‐function E317A mutant. NMR HDX results suggest a relationship between regions exhibiting a reduced local stability in the unbound I domain and those that undergo significant conformational changes upon binding. Specifically, the αC and α7 helices within the C‐terminus are at the center of such major perturbations and present reduced local stabilities in the unbound state relative to other structural elements. Complementary isothermal titration calorimetry experiments have been performed to derive complete thermodynamic binding profiles for association of the collagen‐like triple‐helical peptide with wild type α1 I and E317A mutant. The differential energetics observed for E317A are consistent with the HDX experiments and support a model in which intrinsically destabilized regions predispose conformational rearrangement in the integrin I domain. This study highlights the importance of exploring different timescales to delineate allosteric and binding events.     

Integration of hydrogen/deuterium exchange and cyanylation-based methodology for conformational studies of cystinyl proteins

This report documents the feasibility and advantages of integrating hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX) methodology with cyanylation (CN)-based methodology to determine the conformation of cystinyl proteins and intermediates during refolding. The CN-based methodology can be used to trap, identify, and preserve the disulfide structure of a given cystinyl protein folding intermediate, while the HDX methodology can be used to assess other conformational features of the intermediate. Specifically, in this study, CN-based methodology was used to trap a 1-disulfide bond and a 2-disulfide intermediate of long Arg(3) insulin-like growth factor-I (LR(3)IGF-I), which was then exposed to HDX using D(2)O at pD 6.8 and subsequently digested with pepsin before analysis by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry. The HDX results show an increasing degree of secondary and tertiary structure as a function of disulfide bond formation. In addition, the HDX results for two overlapping peptic fragments suggest that a segment of the polypeptide exists in two conformations, which can be distinguished by HDX and pepsin. These results from HDX mass spectrometry are in reasonably good agreement with those from nuclear magnetic resonance studies of native LR(3)IGF-I and IGF-I, in which approximately 5000 times more material was used than in our study. Indications are that the integrated use of HDX and CN-based methodologies will be effective in studying the refolding of cystinyl proteins at the subnanomole level.     

Real-Time Monitoring of Protein Conformational Changes Using a Nano-Mechanical Sensor

Proteins can switch between different conformations in response to stimuli, such as pH or temperature variations, or to the binding of ligands. Such plasticity and its kinetics can have a crucial functional role, and their characterization has taken center stage in protein research. As an example, Topoisomerases are particularly interesting enzymes capable of managing tangled and supercoiled double-stranded DNA, thus facilitating many physiological processes. In this work, we describe the use of a cantilever-based nanomotion sensor to characterize the dynamics of human topoisomerase II (Topo II) enzymes and their response to different kinds of ligands, such as ATP, which enhance the conformational dynamics. The sensitivity and time resolution of this sensor allow determining quantitatively the correlation between the ATP concentration and the rate of Topo II conformational changes. Furthermore, we show how to rationalize the experimental results in a comprehensive model that takes into account both the physics of the cantilever and the dynamics of the ATPase cycle of the enzyme, shedding light on the kinetics of the process. Finally, we study the effect of aclarubicin, an anticancer drug, demonstrating that it affects directly the Topo II molecule inhibiting its conformational changes. These results pave the way to a new way of studying the intrinsic dynamics of proteins and of protein complexes allowing new applications ranging from fundamental proteomics to drug discovery and development and possibly to clinical practice.     

Role of substrate inhibition kinetics in enzymatic chemical oscillations.

Two chemical kinetic models are investigated using standard nonlinear dynamics techniques to determine the conditions under which substrate inhibition kinetics can lead to oscillations. The first model is a classical substrate inhibition scheme based on Michaelis-Menten kinetics and involves a single substrate. Only when this reaction takes place in a flow reactor (i.e., both substrate and product are taken to follow reversible flow terms) are oscillations observed; however, the range of parameter values over which such oscillations occur is so narrow it is experimentally unobservable. A second model based on a general mechanism applied to the kinetics of many pH-dependent enzymes is also studied. This second model includes both substrate inhibition kinetics as well as autocatalysis through the activation of the enzyme by hydrogen ion. We find that it is the autocatalysis that is always responsible for oscillatory behavior in this scheme. The substrate inhibition terms affect the steady-state behavior but do not lead to oscillations unless product inhibition or multiple substrates are present; this is a general conclusion we can draw from our studies of both the classical substrate inhibition scheme and the pH-dependent enzyme mechanism. Finally, an analysis of the nullclines for these two models allows us to prove that the nullcline slopes must have a negative value for oscillatory behavior to exist; this proof can explain our results. From our analysis, we conclude with a brief discussion of other enzymes that might be expected to produce oscillatory behavior based on a pH-dependent substrate inhibition mechanism.     

Kinetics and mechanism of refolding of bovine carbonic anhydrase. A probe study of the formation of the active site.

In kinetic studies of the folding of bovine carbonic anhydrase from disorganized to native structure, an azosulfonamide, 2-(4-sulfomylphenylazo)-7-acetamido-1-hydroxynaphthalene-3,6-disulfonate (I), has been used as a probe to follow the dynamics of formation of the active site region. The probe is a specific inhibitor of the native enzyme that binds in the active site crevice. The experiments, with previous data (Yazgan, A., and Henkens, R. W. (1972), Biochemistry 11, 1314), show that a tight binding site for I forms at an intermediate stage in the folding process. A subsequent conformational change perturbs the visible absorption and circular dichroism of bound I and could result in even tighter binding. The subsequent change completes formation of the active site. This is shown by results from separate experiments on the kinetics of recovery of activity (p-nitrophenyl acetate as substrate). Similar probe methods could be used with other proteins and enzymes to study the kinetics and mechanism of regeneration of specific sites--for example, the active site.