3D electron microscopy of the interaction of kinesin with tubulin

We have studied the structure of microtubules decorated with kinesin motor domains in different nucleotide states by 3D electron microscopy. Having docked the atomic coordinates of both dimeric ADP.kinesin and tubulin heterodimer into a map of kinesin dimers bound to microtubules in the presence of ADP, we try to predict which regions of the proteins interact in the weakly binding state. When either the presence of 5'-adenylyimidodiphosphate (AMP-PNP) or an absence of nucleotides puts motor domains into a strongly-bound state, the 3D maps show changes in the motor domains which modify their interaction with beta-tubulin. The maps also show differences in beta-tubulin conformation compared with undecorated microtubules or those decorated with weakly-bound motors. Strongly-bound ncd appears to produce an identical change.     

Visualizing a new binding site of ncd-motor domain on tubulin

Ncd is a microtubule minus-end directed motor of the kinesin superfamily. Previously it has been shown that ncd and kinesin motor domains share the same major binding site on microtubules. Here we report a three-dimensional EM reconstruction of negatively stained two-dimensional Zn-induced tubulin crystal sheets (Zn-sheets) decorated with the ncd motor domain at a resolution of 16 A. This work has revealed a second specific binding site for the ncd motor domain. The motor binding site on the tubulin Zn-sheets spans both alpha and beta tubulin subunits. This binding site is located at a position different from the previously identified ncd binding site on microtubules and may play a role in motor function.     

A structural analysis of the interaction between ncd tail and tubulin protofilaments

ncd is a minus-end directed, kinesin-like motor, which binds to microtubules with its motor domain and its cargo domain as well. Typical of retrograde motors, the motor domain of ncd locates to the C-terminal end of the polypeptide chain, and hence, the cargo domain constitutes the N-terminal region. To date, several studies have investigated the interaction properties of the motor domain with microtubules, but very few structural data are available about the tail itself or its interaction with microtubules as cargo. Here, we applied cryo-electron microscopy and helical 3D image reconstruction to 15 protofilament microtubules decorated with an ncd tail fragment (N-terminal residues 83-187, named NT6). In our study, the ncd tail shows a behaviour resembling filamentous MAPs such as tau protein, exhibiting a highly flexible structure with no large globular domains. NT6 binds to four different sites on the outer side of microtubules within the proximity of the kinesin motor-binding site. Two of these sites locate within the groove between two neighbouring protofilaments, and appear as strong binding sites, while the other two sites, located at the outer rim, appear to play a secondary role. In addition, the ncd tail fragment induces the formation of large protofilament sheets, suggesting a tail-induced modification of lateral protofilament contacts.     

The crystal structure of the minus-end-directed microtubule motor protein ncd reveals variable dimer conformations

BACKGROUND: The kinesin superfamily of microtubule-associated motor proteins are important for intracellular transport and for cell division in eukaryotes. Conventional kinesins have the motor domain at the N terminus of the heavy chain and move towards the plus end of microtubules. The ncd protein is necessary for chromosome segregation in meiosis. It belongs to a subfamily of kinesins that have the motor domain at the C terminus and move towards the minus end of microtubules. RESULTS: The crystal structure of dimeric ncd has been obtained at 2.9 A resolution from crystals with the C222(1) space group, with two independent dimers per asymmetric unit. The motor domains in these dimers are not related by crystallographic symmetry and the two ncd dimers have significantly different conformations. An alpha-helical coiled coil connects, and interacts with, the motor domains. CONCLUSIONS: The ncd protein has a very compact structure, largely due to extended interactions of the coiled coil with the head domains. Despite this, we find that the overall conformation of the ncd dimer can be rotated by as much as 10 degrees away from that of the twofold-symmetric archetypal ncd. The crystal structures of conventional kinesin and of ncd suggest a structural rationale for the reversal of the direction of movement in chimeric kinesins.     

Conformations of kinesin: solution vs. crystal structures and interactions with microtubules

Recently, the molecular structures of monomeric and dimeric kinesin constructs in complex with ADP have been determined by X-ray crystallography (Kull et al. 1996; Kozielski et al. 1997 a; Sack et al. 1997). The “motor” or “head” domains have almost identical conformations in the known crystal structures, yet the kinesin dimer is asymmetric: the orientation of the two heads relative to the coiled-coil formed by their neck regions is different. We used small angle solution scattering of kinesin constructs and microtubules decorated with kinesin in order to find out whether these crystal structures are of relevance for kinesin's structure under natural conditions and for its interaction with microtubules. Our preliminary results indicate that the crystal structures of monomeric and dimeric kinesin are similar to their structures in solution, though in solution the center-of-mass distance between the motor domains of the dimer could be slightly greater. The crystal structure of dimeric kinesin can be interpreted as representing two equivalent conformations. Transitions between these or very similar conformational states may occur in solution. Binding of kinesin to microtubules has conformational effects on both, the kinesin and the microtubule. Solution scattering of kinesin decorated microtubules reveals a peak in intensity that is characteristic for the B-surface lattice and that can be used to monitor the axial repeat of the microtubules under various conditions. In decoration experiments, dimeric kinesin dissociates, at least partly, leading to a stoichiometry of 1:1 (one kinesin head per tubulin dimer; Thormählen et al. 1998 a) in contrast to the stoichiometry of 2:1 reported for dimeric ncd. This discrepancy is possibly due to the effect of steric hindrance between kinesin dimers on adjacent binding sites.     

Complex formation with kinesin motor domains affects the structure of microtubules

Microtubules are highly dynamic components of the cytoskeleton. They are important for cell movement and they are involved in a variety of transport processes together with motor proteins, such as kinesin. The exact mechanism of these transport processes is not known and so far the focus has been on structural changes within the motor domains, but not within the underlying microtubule structure.Here we investigated the interaction between kinesin and tubulin and our experimental data show that microtubules themselves are changing structure during that process. We studied unstained, vitrified samples of microtubules composed of 15 protofilaments using cryo electron microscopy and helical image analysis. 3D maps of plain microtubules and microtubules decorated with kinesin have been reconstructed to approximately 17A resolution. The alphabeta-tubulin dimer could be identified and, according to our data, alpha- and beta-tubulin adopt different conformations in plain microtubules. Significant differences were detected between maps of plain microtubules and microtubule-kinesin complexes. Most pronounced is the continuous axial inter-dimer contact in the microtubule-kinesin complex, suggesting stabilized protofilaments along the microtubule axis. It seems, that mainly structural changes within alpha-tubulin are responsible for this observation. Lateral effects are less pronounced. Following our data, we believe, that microtubules play an active role in intracellular transport processes through modulations of their core structure.     

The shapes of the motor domains of two oppositely directed microtubule motors, ncd and kinesin: a neutron scattering study.

The shapes of the motor domains of kinesin and ncd, which move in opposite directions along microtubules, have been investigated. Using proteins expressed in Escherichia coli, it was found that at high salt (> 200 mM) Drosophila ncd motor domain (R335-K700) and human kinesin motor domain (M1-E349) were both sufficiently monomeric to allow an accurate determination of their radii of gyration (Rg) and their molecular weights. The measured Rg values of the ncd and kinesin motor domains in D2O were 2.06 +/- 0.06 and 2.05 +/- 0.04 nm, respectively, and the molecular weights were consistent with those computed from the amino acid compositions. Fitting of the scattering curves to approximately 3.5 nm resolution showed that the ncd and kinesin motor domains can be described adequately by triaxial ellipsoids having half-axes of 1.42 +/- 0.38, 2.24 +/- 0.44, and 3.65 +/- 0.22 nm, and half-axes of 1.52 +/- 0.23, 2.00 +/- 0.25, and 3.73 +/- 0.10 nm, respectively. Both motor domains are described adequately as somewhat flattened prolate ellipsoids with a maximum dimension of approximately 7.5 nm. Thus, it appears that the overall shapes of these motor domains are not the major determinants of the directionality of their movement along microtubules.     

Human kinetochore-associated kinesin CENP-E visualized at 17 A resolution bound to microtubules

The highly dynamic process of cell division is effected, in part, by molecular motors that generate the forces necessary for its enactment. Several members of the kinesin superfamily of motor proteins are implicated in mitosis, such as CENP-E, which plays essential roles in cell division, including association with the kinetochore to stabilize attachment of chromosomes to microtubules prior to and during their separation. Neither the functional assembly state of CENP-E nor its direction of motion along the polar microtubule are certain. To determine the mode of interaction between CENP-E and microtubules, we have used cryo-electron microscopy to visualize CENP-E motor domains complexed with microtubules and calculated a density map of the complex to 17 A resolution by combining helical and single-particle reconstruction methods. The interface between the motor domain and microtubules was modeled by docking atomic-resolution models of the subunits into the cryoEM density map. Our results support a plus end motion for CENP-E, consistent with features of the crystallographic structure. Despite considerable functional differences from the monomeric transporter kinesin KIF1A and the oppositely directed ncd kinesin, CENP-E appears to share many features of the intermolecular interactions, suggesting that differences in motor function are governed by small variations in the loops at the microtubule interface.     

Structures of kinesin and kinesin-microtubule interactions

Several X-ray crystal structures of kinesin motor domains have recently been solved at high resolution ( approximately 0.2-0.3 nm), in both their monomeric and dimeric states. They show the folding of the polypeptide chain and different arrangements of subunits in the dimer. In addition, cryo-electron microscopy and image reconstruction have revealed microtubules decorated with kinesin at intermediate resolution ( approximately 2 nm), showing the distribution and orientation of kinesin heads on the microtubule surface. The comparison of the X-ray and electron microscopy results yields a model of how monomeric motor domains bind to the microtubule but the binding of dimeric motors, their stoichiometry, or the influence of nucleotides remains a matter of debate.     

A new look at the microtubule binding patterns of dimeric kinesins

The interactions of monomeric and dimeric kinesin and ncd constructs with microtubules have been investigated using cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) and several biochemical methods. There is a good consensus on the structure of dimeric ncd when bound to a tubulin dimer showing one head attached directly to tubulin, and the second head tethered to the first. However, the 3D maps of dimeric kinesin motor domains are still quite controversial and leave room for different interpretations. Here we reinvestigated the microtubule binding patterns of dimeric kinesins by cryo-EM and digital 3D reconstruction under different nucleotide conditions and different motor:tubulin ratios, and determined the molecular mass of motor-tubulin complexes by STEM. Both methods revealed complementary results. We found that the ratio of bound kinesin motor-heads to alphabeta-tubulin dimers was never reaching above 1.5 irrespective of the initial mixing ratios. It appears that each kinesin dimer occupies two microtubule-binding sites, provided that there is a free one nearby. Thus the appearances of different image reconstructions can be explained by non-specific excess binding of motor heads. Consequently, the use of different apparent density distributions for docking the X-ray structures onto the microtubule surface leads to different and mutually exclusive models. We propose that in conditions of stoichiometric binding the two heads of a kinesin dimer separate and bind to different tubulin subunits. This is in contrast to ncd where the two heads remain tightly attached on the microtubule surface. Using dimeric kinesin molecules crosslinked in their neck domain we also found that they stabilize protofilaments axially, but not laterally, which is a strong indication that the two heads of the dimers bind along one protofilament, rather than laterally bridging two protofilaments. A molecular walking model based on these results summarizes our conclusions and illustrates the implications of symmetry for such models.     

Proteolytic mapping of kinesin/ncd-microtubule interface: nucleotide-dependent conformational changes in the loops L8 and L12.

We used a battery of proteases to probe the footprint of microtubules on kinesin and ncd, and to search for nucleotide-induced conformational changes in these two oppositely-directed yet homologous molecular motors. Proteolytic cleavage sites were identified by N-terminal microsequencing and electrospray mass spectrometry, and then mapped onto the recently-determined atomic structures of ncd and kinesin. In both kinesin and ncd, microtubule binding shields a set of cleavage sites within or immediately flanking the loops L12, L8 and L11 and, in ncd, the loop L2. Even in the absence of microtubules, exchange of ADP for AMPPNP in the motor active site drives conformational shifts involving these loops. In ncd, a chymotryptic cleavage at Y622 in L12 is protected in the strong binding AMPPNP conformation, but cleaved in the weak binding ADP conformation. In kinesin, a thermolysin cleavage at L154 in L8 is protected in AMPPNP but cleaved in ADP. We speculate that ATP turnover in the active site governs microtubule binding by cyclically retracting or displaying the loops L8 and L12. Curiously, the retracted state of the loops corresponds to microtubule strong binding. Conceivably, nucleotide-dependent display of loops works as a reversible block on strong binding.     

Origins of reversed directionality in the ncd molecular motor.

The head or motor domain of the ncd (non-claret disjunctional) molecular motor is 41% identical to that of kinesin, yet moves along microtubules in the opposite direction to kinesin. We show here that despite the reversed directionality of ncd, its kinetics in solution are homologous in key respects to those of kinesin. The rate limiting step, ADP release, occurs at 0.0033 s-1 at 100 mM NaCl and is accelerated approximately 1000-fold when the motor binds to microtubules. Other reaction steps are all very fast (> 0.1 s-1) compared with ADP release, and the motor is consequently paused in the ncd.ADP state until microtubule binding occurs (Kd = 2 microM), at which point ADP release is triggered and the motor locks onto the microtubule in a rigor-like state. These data identify close functional homology between the strong binding states of kinesin and ncd, and in view of this we discuss a possible mechanism for directional reversal, in which the strong binding states of ncd and kinesin are functionally identical, but the weak binding states are biased in opposite directions.     

Congruent Docking of Dimeric Kinesin and ncd into Three-dimensional Electron Cryomicroscopy Maps of Microtubule–Motor ADP Complexes

We present a new map showing dimeric kinesin bound to microtubules in the presence of ADP that was obtained by electron cryomicroscopy and image reconstruction. The directly bound monomer (first head) shows a different conformation from one in the more tightly bound empty state. This change in the first head is amplified as a movement of the second (tethered) head, which tilts upward. The atomic coordinates of kinesin.ADP dock into our map so that the tethered head associates with the bound head as in the kinesin dimer structure seen by x-ray crystallography. The new docking orientation avoids problems associated with previous predictions; it puts residues implicated by proteolysis-protection and mutagenesis studies near the microtubule but does not lead to steric interference between the coiled-coil tail and the microtubule surface. The observed conformational changes in the tightly bound states would probably bring some important residues closer to tubulin. As expected from the homology with kinesin, the atomic coordinates of nonclaret disjunctional protein (ncd).ADP dock in the same orientation into the attached head in a map of microtubules decorated with dimeric ncd.ADP. Our results support the idea that the observed direct interaction between the two heads is important at some stages of the mechanism by which kinesin moves processively along microtubules.     

Highly processive motility is not a general feature of the kinesins

Evidence is presented that the kinesin-related ncd protein is not as processive as kinesin. In low surface density motility experiments, a dimeric ncd fusion protein behaved mechanistically more similar to non-processive myosins than to the highly processive kinesin. First, there was a critical microtubule length for motility; only microtubules longer than this critical length moved in low density ncd surfaces, which suggested that multiple ncd proteins must cooperate to move microtubules in the surface assay. Under similar conditions, native kinesin demonstrated no critical microtubule length, consistent with the behavior of a highly processive motor. Second, addition of methylcellulose to decrease microtubule diffusion decreased the critical microtubule length for motility. Also, the rates of microtubule motility were microtubule length dependent in methylcellulose; short microtubules, that interacted with fewer ncd proteins, moved more slowly than long microtubules that interacted with more ncd proteins. In contrast, short microtubules, that interacted with one or a few kinesin proteins, moved on average slightly faster than long microtubules that interacted with multiple kinesins. We conclude that a degree of processivity as high as that of kinesin, where a single dimer can move over distances on the order of one micrometer, may not be a general mechanistic feature of the kinesin superfamily. Received: 16 September 1997 / Accepted: 4 November 1997     

The microtubule lattice--20 years on

In 1974, optical diffraction and image analysis indicated that tubulin dimers in the cylindrically complete A-tubule of flagellar doublet microtubules are arranged with helical symmetry, while those in the incomplete B-tubule associate differently. Recently, electron micrographs of reassembled brain microtubules decorated with kinesin heads have shown that the tubulin dimers there are arranged as in the B-tubule. The lack of symmetry of microtubules assembled in vitro prompts Linda Amos to speculate here that the assembly process in vitro may differ from that occurring in the cell.     

Regulation of ncd by the oligomeric state of tubulin

We have compared the interaction of ncd (non-claret disjunctional), a kinesin related protein, with microtubules and tubulin heterodimer. Ultracentrifugation experiments revealed that the ncd motor domain, residues 335-700 (ncd335), does not induce tubulin polymerization but stabilizes pre-formed microtubules with a maximum effect at a 1:1 ncd335:tubulin ratio. Ncd335 binding to tubulin or microtubules was estimated by following the change in fluorescence polarization of an exogenous dye attached to Cys670 of ncd335. Ncd335 binding to tubulin (containing GTP or GDP-bound) is characterized by a 2:1 stoichiometry, a higher affinity and an increased sensitivity towards salt, ADP, ATP and AMPPNP, as compared with ncd335 binding to microtubules. Maximum ATPases were 0.06-0.08 sec(-1) and 1.8-2.0 sec(-1) for the ncd335-tubulin and ncd335-microtubules complexes, respectively. Only the polymerized complex is fully functional, suggesting the presence of additional contacts between adjacent protofilaments. Moreover, the data reveal that the oligomeric state of microtubules is a potent regulator for the activity of kinesin related proteins.     

Situs: A package for docking crystal structures into low-resolution maps from electron microscopy

Three-dimensional image reconstructions of large-scale protein aggregates are routinely determined by electron microscopy (EM). We combine low-resolution EM data with high-resolution structures of proteins determined by x-ray crystallography. A set of visualization and analysis procedures, termed the Situs package, has been developed to provide an efficient and robust method for the localization of protein subunits in low-resolution data. Topology-representing neural networks are employed to vector-quantize and to correlate features within the structural data sets. Microtubules decorated with kinesin-related ncd motors are used as model aggregates to demonstrate the utility of this package of routines. The precision of the docking has allowed for the extraction of unique conformations of the macromolecules and is limited only by the reliability of the underlying structural data.     

Crystallization and preliminary structural studies of the ncd motor domain

The motor domain of the kinesin homolog ncd has been crystallized in the presence of MgATP by the vapor diffusion method using polyethylene glycol as the precipitant. The crystals belong to the orthorhombic space group I222 with unit cell dimensions a = 127.1 Å, b = 122.3 Å, c = 68.0 Å, and there is one ncd molecule per asymmetric unit. The crystals diffract X-ray to at least 2.3 Å and are appropriate for high-resolution structure determination. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

These motors were made for walking

Kinesins are a diverse group of adenosine triphosphate (ATP)‐dependent motor proteins that transport cargos along microtubules (MTs) and change the organization of MT networks. Shared among all kinesins is a ~40 kDa motor domain that has evolved an impressive assortment of motility and MT remodeling mechanisms as a result of subtle tweaks and edits within its sequence. Several elegant studies of different kinesin isoforms have exposed the purpose of structural changes in the motor domain as it engages and leaves the MT. However, few studies have compared the sequences and MT contacts of these kinesins systematically. Along with clever strategies to trap kinesin–tubulin complexes for X‐ray crystallography, new advancements in cryo‐electron microscopy have produced a burst of high‐resolution structures that show kinesin–MT interfaces more precisely than ever. This review considers the MT interactions of kinesin subfamilies that exhibit significant differences in speed, processivity, and MT remodeling activity. We show how their sequence variations relate to their tubulin footprint and, in turn, how this explains the molecular activities of previously characterized mutants. As more high‐resolution structures become available, this type of assessment will quicken the pace toward establishing each kinesin's design–function relationship.     

Kinesins and microtubules: their structures and motor mechanisms

Atomic resolution three-dimensional structures of two oppositely directed kinesin motors - conventional kinesin and non-claret disjunctional (ncd) protein - are now available in their functional dimeric form. A detailed model of the microtubule has also been recently obtained by docking the 3.7 A structure of tubulin into a 20 A map of the microtubule. Recent structural studies of kinesin motors and their microtubule tracks are contributing to our current understanding of kinesin motor mechanisms.