The mutational specificity of DNA polymerases-alpha and -gamma during in vitro DNA synthesis

The frequency and specificity of mutations produced during in vitro DNA synthesis of the lacZ alpha gene in M13mp2 DNA by eucaryotic DNA polymerase-alpha (pol-alpha) and DNA polymerase-gamma (pol-gamma) have been determined. Pol-alpha, purified from five different sources, produces mutations resulting in loss of alpha-complementation at a frequency of 0.8-1.6%/single round of gap-filling DNA synthesis. DNA sequence analysis of 420 independent mutants produced by pol-alpha demonstrates three classes of errors. The majority of mutations result from single base substitutions, while single base frameshifts are detected at a lower but substantial frequency. Large deletions are also observed, with a frequency and specificity suggesting that they too are produced by pol-alpha in vitro. In contrast, pol-gamma is more accurate, producing mutants at a frequency of 0.3-0.5%. The specificity of pol-gamma errors is also different, since more than 90% of the mutants result from single base substitutions, while frameshift errors are not observed at a frequency significantly above background. The pol-gamma mutant spectrum also contains deletion mutations (10 of 179 mutants) presumably resulting from aberrant in vitro synthesis. When considered together with previous results using pol-beta (Kunkel, T. A. (1985) J. Biol. Chem. 260, 5787-5796) the relative accuracy of the three classes of purified vertebrate DNA polymerases for base substitutions, frameshifts, and deletions is in the order gamma greater than alpha greater than beta. These data demonstrate a correlation between the accuracy and processivity of DNA polymerization. Thus, the most accurate DNA polymerase (pol-gamma) also incorporates the most nucleotides per association with the primer-template, while the least accurate enzyme (pol-beta) is the least processive. This correlation exists both for base substitution mutations and for single base frameshifts, and is most obvious for minus-one-base frameshifts in runs of pyrimidines. In support of this correlation, increasing the processivity of pol-beta from 1 to 4-6 incorporations per association increases the accuracy of in vitro DNA synthesis by severalfold. The data imply that the processivity of DNA synthesis could be an important factor in controlling the levels of spontaneous and perhaps induced mutations.     

Sequence dependence for bypass of thymine glycols in DNA by DNA polymerase I.

Single-stranded phage DNAs containing thymine glycols were prepared by oxidation with osmium tetroxide (OsO4) and were used as templates for DNA synthesis by E. coli DNA polymerase I. The induction of thymine glycol lesions in DNA, as measured by immunoassay, quantitatively accounted for an inhibition of in vitro DNA synthesis on modified templates. Analysis of termination sites for synthesis by DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment) showed that DNA synthesis terminated at most template thymine sites in OsO4-treated DNA, indicating that incorporation occurred opposite putative thymine glycols in DNA. Nucleotides 5' and 3' to putative thymine glycol sites affect the reaction, however, since termination was not observed at thymines in the sequence 5'-CTPur-3'. Conversion of thymine glycols to urea residues in DNA by alkali treatment caused termination of DNA synthesis one nucleotide 3' to template thymine sites, including thymines in the 5'-CTPur-3' sequence, showing that the effect of surrounding sequence is on the elongation reaction by DNA polymerase rather than differential damage induction by OsO4.     

Processing of DNA base damage by DNA polymerases. Dihydrothymine and beta-ureidoisobutyric acid as models for instructive and noninstructive lesions

The processing of unrepaired DNA lesions is a key to understanding and predicting the biological end points of particular DNA damages. In this study, we prepared single-stranded f1 phage (f1-K12) DNA containing dihydrothymine or beta-ureidoisobutyric acid as models for instructive or noninstructive base lesions and assessed the potential biological consequences of these lesions in vitro and in vivo. To determine the effect of the two lesions on in vitro DNA synthesis, the extent of DNA synthesis was measured by 3H-labeled nucleotide incorporation, and the newly synthesized DNA was analyzed by DNA sequencing gels. The results showed that dihydrothymine in the template was at most a weak block to in vitro DNA synthesis catalyzed by Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I Klenow fragment (Pol I) and T4 DNA polymerase. In contrast, beta-ureidoisobutyric acid constituted a very strong (probably absolute) replicative block in vitro. With Pol I, termination bands were observed either opposite or one base prior to (3' to) the putative beta-ureidoisobutyric acid depending on its position in the template. However, when DNA synthesis was catalyzed by Pol I lacking a 3'----5' exonuclease activity, termination bands were only observed opposite beta-ureidoisobutyric acid, with purine nucleotides being incorporated preferentially opposite the lesion. With T4 DNA polymerase that contains a very active 3'----5' exonuclease activity, DNA synthesis was arrested almost exclusively one base prior to (3' to) the putative beta-ureidoisobutyric acid site in the template. We also measured survival of transfecting DNA containing dihydrothymine or beta-ureidoisobutyric acid in an attempt to correlate the in vitro data with in vivo processing. In keeping with the results obtained in vitro, dihydrothymine present in transfecting f1-K12 DNA did not constitute an inactivating lesion. On the other hand, it took 0.9 beta-ureidoisobutyric acid residues per molecule to inactivate transfecting f1-K12 DNA, indicating that the lesion was an absolute replicative block in vivo. When host cells were ultraviolet-irradiated to induce the SOS response, a slight increase (about 2-fold) in survival of transfecting f1-K12 DNA containing beta-ureidoisobutyric acid was observed. The potential effects of the structures of base lesions on lesion-polymerase interactions are discussed.     

Stimulation of replicative DNA synthesis by eukaryotic proteins bound to single-stranded DNA]

The paper deals with the effect of the single-strand (ss) DNA-binding proteins (SSB-proteins) from the Ehrlich ascites tumor (EAT) cells and from the eggs of silkworm, as well as the mouse serum blood proteins, having preferential affinity to ss DNA, on the DNA replicative synthesis in the EAT cells permeable for the macromolecules, and, for the silkworm proteins and on the DNA replicative synthesis in the nuclei from the eggs of silkworm proteins and on the DNA replicative synthesis in the nuclei from the eggs of silkworm permeable for macromolecules. SSB-proteins of EAT to considerable extent stimulated the DNA synthesis. At the same time, the other proteins (from the silkworm and from the serum) activated the DNA synthesis in the permeable cells to the less extent. It was found that SSB-proteins from the silkworm had a 1.5-13 fold stimulating effect on the DNA replicative synthesis in the homologous system (in the permeable nuclei). If the permeability for the macromolecules of the cells and nuclei treatment with Triton X-100 may be different, it is supposed that the activation of the DNA synthesis by the exogenous proteins depends on the homologous system of the DNA replicative complex. It is possible that the effect of the serum proteins on the DNA synthesis is connected with the masking of the ss regions of DNA which inhibited DNA-polymerase alpha. Perhaps the mechanisms of the activation of the DNA replicative synthesis by the proteins in vitro with the purified DNA polymerase alpha and in vivo are of different nature and are conditioned by homology of the deoxyribonucleoproteins.     

Bacteriophage T4-Directed DNA Synthesis in Toluene-Treated Cells

DNA synthesis has been studied in T4-infected Escherichia coli cells made permeable to nucleotides by treatment with toluene. The rate of incorporation of labeled deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates into DNA at various times after infection is proportional to the in vivo rate. This in vitro incorporation is dependent on all four deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates (5-hydroxymethyldeoxy-cytidine triphosphate can substitute for dCTP) and Mg(2+). It is stimulated by rATP, partially inhibited by pancreatic DNase, and abolished by N-ethylmalei-mide and 1-beta-d-arabinofuranosylcytosine triphosphate. T4 amber DO (DNA negative) and temperature-sensitive DO mutants under nonpermissive conditions of infection fail to induce DNA synthesis in vitro. The synthesizing activity is intracellular and the DNA product is exclusively T4 DNA. The in vitro synthesis proceeds in a discontinuous manner involving synthesis and subsequent joining of small DNA fragments (about 10S in alkaline sucrose gradients) into larger molecules predominantly one-half the length of mature T4 DNA. No restriction of C-containing or nonglucosylated HMC-containing T4 DNA product is observed in this system.     

DNA polymerase mutagenic bypass and proofreading of endogenous DNA lesions

DNA polymerases differentiate between correct and incorrect substrates during synthesis on undamaged DNA templates through the biochemical steps of base incorporation, primer-template extension and proofreading excision. Recent research examining DNA polymerase processing of abasic, alkylation and oxidative lesions is reviewed in light of these discrimination mechanisms. Inhibition of DNA synthesis results from correct polymerase discrimination against utilization of geometrically incorrect template bases or 3' terminal basepairs. The efficiency of translesion synthesis is thus related to the physical structure of the lesion containing DNA. However, variations in enzyme structure and kinetics result in translesion synthesis efficiencies that are also dependent upon the DNA polymerase. With a low probability, polymerase misinsertion events create a 3' lesion terminus which is geometrically favored over the correct lesion basepair, resulting in mutagenic translesion synthesis. For example, both polymerase alpha and polymerase beta appear to require the formation of a stable 3' primer-template structure for efficient abasic site translesion synthesis. However, the enzymes differ as to the precise molecular make-up of the stable DNA structure, resulting in different mutational specificities. Similar mechanisms may be applicable to oxidative damage, where mutational specificities dependent upon the DNA polymerase also have been observed. In vitro reaction conditions also influence DNA polymerase processing of lesions. Using an in vitro herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (HSV-tk) gene forward mutation assay, we demonstrate that high dNTP substrate concentrations affect the mutagenic specificity of translesion synthesis using alkylated templates. The exonuclease-deficient Klenow polymerase error frequency for G-->A transition mutations using templates modified by N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (ENU) was four-fold higher at 1000 microM [dNTP], relative to 50 microM [dNTP], consistent with an increased efficiency of extension of the etO6G.T mispair. Moreover, the frequency of other ENU-induced polymerase errors was suppressed when polymerase reactions contained 50 microM dNTP, relative to 1000 microM dNTP. The efficiency of proofreading as a polymerase error discrimination mechanism reflects a balance between the competing processes of 3'-->5' exonuclease removal of mispairs and polymerization of the next correct nucleotide. Polymerases that are devoid of a proofreading exonuclease generally display enhanced abasic site translesion synthesis relative to proofreading-proficient enzymes. In addition, the proofreading exonucleases of Escherichia coli Pol I and T4 DNA polymerases have been found to remove mispairs caused by abasic sites and oxidative lesions, respectively, resulting in lowered polymerase error rates. However, the magnitude of the exonuclease effect is small (less than 10-fold), and highly dependent upon the DNA polymerase-exonuclease. We have studied proofreading exonuclease removal of alkylation damage in the HSV-tk forward assay. We observed no significant reduction in the magnitude of the mutant frequency vs. dose-response curves when N-methyl-N-nitrosourea or ENU-treated templates were used in exonuclease-proficient Klenow polymerase reactions, as compared to the exonuclease-deficient polymerase reactions. Thus, available data suggest that proofreading excision of endogenous lesion mispairs does occur, but the efficiency is dependent upon the lesion and the DNA polymerase-exonuclease studied.     

Inhibition of replicative DNA synthesis and induction of unscheduled DNA synthesis in permeable sarcoma cell by bleomycin.

Unscheduled DNA synthesis was induced by bleomycin in isolated rat liver nuclei and in permeable mouse ascites sarcoma cells. ATP significantly enhanced the bleomycin effect of inducing unscheduled DNA synthesis. Replicative DNA synthesis in permeable mouse ascites sarcoma cells was inhibited by bleomycin. The apparent inhibition or stimulation by bleomycin of in vitro DNA synthesis was thought to be determined by a balance between inhibited DNA replicase activity and induced unscheduled DNA synthesis.     

Effect of exogenous DNA fragments on human cell extract-mediated DNA repair synthesis

Extracts from HeLa cells were used to study the susceptibility of repair synthesis in UV-irradiated plasmid DNA to inhibition by exogenously added nucleic acid. Purified DNA restriction fragments have little inhibitory effect on repair synthesis. However, activated calf thymus DNA fragments, genomic DNA fragments in cell extracts, and sonicated plasmid DNA all inhibited repair synthesis. Degraded DNA fragments arising from E. coli during bacterial plasmid purification were found to be particularly inhibitory. tRNA is not a potent inhibitor of in vitro repair synthesis. In order to observe efficient DNA repair synthesis mediated by human cell extracts, it is essential to prepare highly purified closed circular plasmid DNA, and we describe a reliable method for doing so.     

Cycloheximide effect on DNA degradation and delta-crystallin synthesis in terminally differentiating lens cells

Low concentrations of a protein synthesis inhibitor, cycloheximide, were added throughout the process of in vitro differentiation of 11-day old embryonic chick lens cells. We found with low concentrations of cycloheximide (0.01 to 0.03 microgram/ml, 3 days of culture), that there was an almost complete delay of DNA degradation as observed on alkaline sucrose gradient. Identical concentrations and exposure time had no blocking effect on increased delta-crystallin synthesis as detected by immunoprecipitation and electrophoresis. Higher concentrations of cycloheximide (0.1 to 1 microgram/ml) showed a marked effect on DNA size and a net inhibition on delta-crystallin synthesis. Thus a selective effect of low doses of cycloheximide was observed on terminal differentiation suggesting that there was not a relationship between DNA degradation and delta-crystallin synthesis in these short term experiments. The investigations of minor proteins could be of interest as they may have a crucial role in intact nuclei cataracts.     

Mechanism of stimulation of T7 DNA polymerase by Escherichia coli single-stranded DNA binding protein (SSB)

Single-stranded DNA binding protein is a key component in growth of bacteriophage T7. In addition, DNA synthesis by the purified in vitro replication system is markedly stimulated when the DNA template is coated with Escherichia coli single-stranded DNA binding protein (SSB). In an attempt to understand the mechanism for this stimulation, we have studied the effect of E. coli SSB on DNA synthesis by the T7 DNA polymerase using a primed single-stranded M13 DNA template which serves as a model for T7 lagging strand DNA synthesis. Polyacrylamide gel analysis of the DNA product synthesized on this template in the absence of SSB indicated that the T7 DNA polymerase pauses at many specific sites, some stronger than others. By comparing the position of pausing with the DNA sequence of this region and by using a DNA template that contains an extremely stable hairpin structure, it was found that many, but not all, of these pause positions correspond to regions of potential secondary structure. The presence of SSB during synthesis resulted in a large reduction in the frequency of hesitations at many sites that correspond to these secondary structures. However, the facts that a large percentage of the pause sites remain unaffected even at saturating levels of SSB and that SSB stimulates synthesis on a singly primed poly(dA) template suggested that other mechanisms also contribute to the stimulation of DNA synthesis caused by SSB. Using a sucrose gradient analysis, we found that SSB increases the affinity of the polymerase for single-stranded DNA that this increased binding is only noticed when the polymerase concentration is limiting. The effect of this difference in polymerase affinity was clearly observed by a polyacrylamide gel analysis of the product DNA synthesized during a limited DNA synthesis reaction using conditions where only two nucleotides are added to the primer. Under these circumstances, where the presence of hairpin structures should not contribute to the stimulatory effect of SSB, we found that the extension of the primer is stimulated 4-fold if the DNA template is coated with SSB. Furthermore, SSB had no effect on this synthesis at large polymerase to template ratios.     

Bleomycin-induced DNA damage and DNA repair in chicken embryo cells as compared to X-irradiation

Following in vitro- and in ovo-exposure of chicken embryo cells, the level of bleomycin (BM)-induced damage was evaluated by using DNA synthesis, nucleoid sedimentation (SED), and viscometry of alkaline cell lysates (VISC). This damage was compared to X-irradiation, using 5.9-378 nM BM in vitro, 1.5-116 micrograms BM/egg in ovo, and 2-32 Gy, respectively, in vitro as well as in ovo. With respect to BM, the most notable result is the increase in DNA synthesis and VISC at the lowest concentrations of the drug. A decrease in both parameters was observed at high BM concentrations and following exposure to X-rays, concomitantly with an increase in SED. Regarding the radiomimetic drug BM and X-rays, different modes of DNA damage and DNA repair are suggested by previous investigations and the present results. Therefore, further evidence is presented, that the chicken embryo can act as a simple, rapid and inexpensive test system to characterize the biological effects of many nucleo- and/or cytotoxic agents.     

Slippage synthesis of simple sequence DNA.

The analysis of slippage synthesis of simple sequence DNA in vitro sheds some light on the question of how simple sequences arise in vivo. We show that it is possible to synthesize all types of repetitious di- and trinucleotide motifs starting from short primers and a polymerase in vitro. The rate of this synthesis depends on a sequence specific slippage rate, but is independent of the length of the fragments being synthesized. This indicates that only the ends of the DNA fragments are involved in determining this rate and that slippage is accordingly a short range effect. Slippage synthesis occurs also on a fixed template where only one strand is free to move, a situation which resembles chromosome replication in vivo. It seems therefore likely that slippage during replication is the cause of the observed length polymorphism of simple sequence stretches between individuals of a population.     

Relationship between poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase activity and DNA synthesis in cultured hepatocytes

Previous studies have demonstrated that an increase in poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase activity could be closely related to DNA replication during liver regeneration and to DNA repair synthesis in different experimental systems. This relationship was further investigated by studying the time course of endogenous and total poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase activity in cultured rat hepatocytes stimulated by epidermal growth factor. This mitogen has been shown to stimulate DNA synthesis in liver cells both in vivo and in vitro. A 6-fold increase in endogenous activity was observed early after epidermal growth factor addition, just before DNA synthesis. A subsequent 4-fold increment in total enzyme activity, concomitant with DNA synthesis, was detected. Orotic acid, which has recently shown mitoinhibitory effect, abolished the epidermal-growth-factor-induced increase in endogenous and total poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase activity, as well as DNA synthesis. On the contrary, 3-aminobenzamide inhibitor of poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase completely suppressed the endogenous activity but only partially modified the increase in total catalytic level and the overall pattern of thymidine incorporation. Taken together, these data indicate that, in cultured hepatocytes, the induction of DNA synthesis is supported by an increased poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase activity.     

Application of an in vitro system in the study of chemotherapeutic drug effects on DNA replication

DNA replication machinery is an important target for chemotherapeutic drugs. We have used an in vitro system to study the effect of drugs on mammalian DNA replication, either by direct interaction with the DNA structure or with replication proteins and machinery. The anthracycline doxorubicin (Dox) showed a dose-dependent inhibitory effect on DNA replication, whether incubated with HeLa cell extracts or with DNA and nucleotides. Earliest-labeled fragment analysis revealed that inhibition of replication began within the origin-containing fragment in both control and Dox-containing reactions in vitro. AraC, a nucleoside analog, had no significant effect on DNA synthesis. In contrast, araCTP was able to inhibit DNA replication in vitro. Since metabolism is diminished in this in vitro system, the degree of phosphorylation of araC was apparently low. Progesterone showed an increase in nucleotide incorporation (sensitive to BuPdGTP inhibition of replication-specific polymerases α and δ) after preincubation with HeLa cell extracts, although progesterone receptors were not detectable in the HeLa cell extracts. In addition, we observed an inhibition in DNA replication when progesterone was preincubated with DNA and nucleotides. These results suggest that progesterone may have a mechanism of action that is different from any known to be mediated through progesterone receptors. In conclusion, these results indicate that this mammalian in vitro replication system will be useful for the study of mechanisms and design of therapeutic drugs that inhibit mammalian DNA replication. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

TRF1 inhibits telomere C-strand DNA synthesis in vitro

Human TTAGGG repeat-binding factor 1 (TRF1) is involved in the regulation of telomere length in vivo, but the mechanism of regulation remains largely undefined. We have developed an in vitro system for assessing the effect of TRF1 on DNA synthesis using purified proteins and synthetic DNA substrates. Results reveal that TRF1, when bound to telomeric duplex DNA, inhibits DNA synthesis catalyzed by DNA polymerase alpha/primase (pol alpha). Inhibition required that TRF1 be bound to duplex telomeric DNA as no effect of TRF1 was observed on nontelomeric, random DNA substrates. Inhibition was shown to be dependent on TRF1 concentration and the length of the telomeric duplex region of the DNA substrate. When bound in cis to telomeric duplex DNA, TRF1 was also capable of inhibiting pol alpha-catalyzed DNA synthesis on nontelomeric DNA sequences from positions both upstream and downstream of the extending polymerase. Inhibition of DNA synthesis was shown to be specific for TRF1 but not necessarily for the DNA polymerase used in the extension reaction. In a series of control experiments, we assessed T7 DNA polymerase-catalyzed synthesis on a DNA template containing tandem gal4 operators. In these experiments, the addition of the purified Gal4-DNA binding domain (Gal4-DBD) protein has no effect on the ability of T7 polymerase to copy the DNA template. Interestingly, TRF1 inhibition was observed on telomeric DNA substrates using T7 DNA polymerase. These results suggest that TRF1, when bound to duplex telomeric DNA, serves to block extension by DNA polymerases. These results are discussed with respect to the role of TRF1 in telomere length regulation.     

Poly(dG-dC) in the Z-form inhibits E. coli DNA polymerase I and AMV DNA polymerase activity

The effect of Z-conformation of DNA on its template activity in DNA synthesis reactions in vitro has been studied. Normal poly(dG-dC) in the B-form, brominated and unbrominated in the Z-form have been compared for their template activity in DNA synthesis reactions mediated by AMV DNA polymerase and E. coli DNA polymerase I. The results indicate that poly(dG-dC) in the Z-form is totally inactive as a template for DNA synthesis and further that it is a strong competitive inhibitor of copying of the B-form DNA.     

Inhibition of DNA synthesis in permeabilized L cells by novobiocin

Novobiocin was equipotent in inhibiting DNA and RNA synthesis in cultured mouse L cells. It also suppressed in vitro DNA and RNA synthesis in permeabilized L cells and nuclei; 50 percent inhibition of DNA and RNA synthesis was obtained by 1 mM and 20 mM novobiocin, respectively. ATP antagonized the effect of novobiocin. Nalidixic acid had a weak inhibitory effect on in vitro DNA synthesis; 10 mM nalidixic acid showed 60 percent inhibition. ATP did not antagonize nalidixic acid. The inhibitory effect of novobiocin exceeded that of aphidicolin. These findings suggest a participation of a gyrase- and/or type II topoisomerase-like enzyme in the DNA replication machinery in L cells.     

Inhibition of DNA polymerase alpha by gossypol

Our earlier studies have shown that gossypol is a specific inhibitor of DNA synthesis in cultured cells at low doses. In an attempt to determine the mechanism for the inhibition of DNA synthesis by gossypol we observed that gossypol does not interact with DNA per se but may affect some of the enzymes involved in DNA replication. These studies indicated that gossypol inhibits both in vivo and in vitro the activity of DNA polymerase alpha (EC 2.7.7.7), a major enzyme involved in DNA replication, in a time- and dose-dependent manner. Kinetic analysis revealed that gossypol acts as a noncompetitive inhibitor of DNA polymerase alpha with respect to all four deoxynucleotide triphosphates and to the activated DNA template. Inhibition of DNA polymerase alpha does not appear to be due to either metal chelation or reduction of sulfhydryl groups on the enzyme. Gossypol also inhibited HeLa DNA polymerase beta in a dose-dependent manner, but had no effect on DNA polymerase gamma. These results suggest that inhibition of DNA polymerase alpha may account in part for the inhibition of DNA synthesis and the S-phase block caused by gossypol. The data also raise the possibility that gossypol may interfere with DNA repair processes as well.