Comparison of Protein Structures in Solution Using Local Conformations Derived from NMR Data: Application to Cytochrome c

Abstract

Structural comparisons of proteins in solution are often required to examine structure-functional relationships, study structural effects of mutations or distinguish between various forms of the same molecule under different conditions. A nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) based probabilistic strategy is presented and used to study the structural differences between the two redox states of cytochrome C in solution. A probabilistic approach is employed to calculate the main chain conformations of horse ferro- and ferricytochrome C in solution, based on the published sequential d connectivity data. Conformational differences between the two oxidation states of horse cytochrome C in solution are found to be statistically significant. The largest changes in conformation are at residues Lys27, Thr28, Leu32, Gln42, Thr47, Tyr48, Thr49, Glu69, Lys72, Met80, Phe82, Ile85 and Lys86, all of which are close to the heme (within 14 Å of the heme iron in the high resolution Xray structure of tuna cytochrome c). We suggest that these conformational changes may modulate local dipole moments and hence influence the interactions of cytochrome C with its physiological redox partners during the electron transfer process. The oxidation state dependent conformational differences are found to be much greater in solution than in the crystalline state, and the solution and crystal structures differ significantly in regions close to the heme. These results suggest that the highly charged nature of cytochrome C makes this protein particularly sensitive to the ionic strength of its environment and leads to differences between crystal and solution structures in the same oxidation state. In such cases, crystal structures must be used with caution for modeling molecular interactions in vivo. More generally, this analysis indicates that the determination of accurate local conformations based on nmr data can provide useful information about structure-functional aspects of proteins in solution.     

Fourier-transform infra-red studies of the alkaline isomerization of mitochondrial cytochrome c and the ionization of carboxylic acids.

The alkaline transitions of tuna and horse ferricytochromes c and the trifluoroacetyl-lysine derivative of horse ferricytochrome c have been studied by Fourier-transform (FT) i.r. spectroscopy. The spectral perturbations resulting from the transition have been interpreted by reference to FT i.r. data on simple carboxylic-acid-containing compounds and a bacterial cytochrome c551 in which a haem propionate ionizes without causing a significant conformational change. The analysis strongly suggests that ionization of a haem propionate of mitochondrial cytochrome c triggers the alkaline conformation change.     

Resonance Raman scattering on the haem group of cytochrome c

Resonance Raman spectra of the haem group of 8 × 10^?5 M horse heart ferro- and ferricytochrome c solutions have been obtained. The spectra are almost identical to that of haemoglobin. The frequency of the Raman line near 1370 cm^?1, which in haemoglobin is sensitive to the position of the haem iron, indicates that the iron atom of cytochrome c lies in the plane of the porphyrin for both oxidation states.     

The stability of ferricytochrome c. Temperature dependence of its NMR spectrum

The temperature dependence of the nuclear magnetic resonance spectrum of horse ferricytochrome c is described. The protein maintains an ordered structure over the temperature range 20 degrees C to 77 degrees C. The temperature dependence of the spectrum of ferricytochrome c arises from a number of causes including the paramagnetism of the ferric ion and protein structural changes. Preliminary analysis of the data show that the region of the protein about Ile-57 is flexible. Comparison of the data with the analogous data for horse ferrocytochrome c reveals that there is a small difference in structure between cytochrome c in its two oxidation states in the region about Ile-57.     

The solution structures of tuna and horse cytochromes c

The nuclear magnetic resonance spectra of tuna ferricytochrome c and tuna ferrocytochrome c are described. Resonance assignments are made using NMR double-resonance techniques. A comparison of the NMR data for tuna cytochrome c with the previously reported data for horse cytochrome c shows that the proteins have virtually identical main-chain folds. Three regions of local conformational differences have been distinguished.     

Electron-paramagnetic-resonance studies of structure and function of the two-haem enzymes Pseudomonas cytochrome c peroxidase and beef heart cytochrome c oxidase

Beef heart cytochrome c oxidase contains two cytochromes, a and a3, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa cytochrome c peroxidase has one high- and one low-potential c haem, cHP and cLP. The parallelism in co-ordination and spin states between cytochrome a and haem cHP on the one hand and between cytochrome a3 and haem cLP on the other is illustrated. The two latter haems become accessible to cyanide, when the former are reduced. Such reduction also leads to an activation of the enzymes. Mechanisms are presented in which ferryl forms of cytochromes a3 and haem cLP take part. The enzymes reach an oxidation state, formally the same as resting enzyme, but with different properties.     

Solution structure of mitochondrial cytochrome c. I. 1H nuclear magnetic resonance of ferricytochrome c

The 1H nuclear magnetic resonance spectra of tuna and horse ferricytochromes c have been investigated and the resonances of all amino acid methyl groups have been assigned to specific absorption lines. The assignment procedure involves principally the comparison of one-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance spectra from a range of homologous ferricytochromes c and does not require a prior knowledge of the secondary or tertiary protein structure. Of the 49 methyl groups of tuna cytochrome c, the assignment of 33 is made without reference to the X-ray crystal structure. The method should therefore be applicable to other proteins of similar size where X-ray structures are unavailable. The assignments will be used to investigate the structure of cytochrome c in solution.     

Local structure of cytochrome c from horse heart in solution. Conformational analysis using data of two-dimensional nuclear Overhauser effect spectroscopy]

Using the earlier suggested method the calculation of the backbone conformations of horse heart cytochrome c in oxidized (ferricytochrome c) and reduced (ferrocytochrome c) states has been performed by the two-dimensional nuclear Overhauser effect spectroscopy data. For both protein forms the secondary structure elements have been revealed and the conformations of the irregular polypeptide chain segments have been analysed. The similarity of the secondary structures of ferri- and ferrocytochrome c in solution was established from the comparison of their conformations. Small differences between the conformations of two molecule forms are shown to be localized within the polypeptide chain fragments situated in the spatial structure near the heme crevice. The comparison of the dihedral phi and psi angles in the calculated conformations of horse cytochrome C with the corresponding characteristics of X-ray structures of tuna ferri- and ferrocytochrome c made for the oxidized and reduced protein forms using the quantitative criteria testifies the similarity of their conformations in solution and crystal. In is shown that the conformational changes of the separate amino acid residues which take place as the result of the "solution-to-crystal" transition occur on the surface fragments of protein globule and do not lead to essential alterations of the secondary molecule structure.     

Ultraviolet resonance Raman spectra of cytochrome c conformational states

Ultraviolet resonance Raman (UV RR) spectra are reported for ferricytochrome c from tuna and horse heart at pH 1.6, 7, 10, and 13, representing distinct conformational states of the protein (states II, III, IV, and V, respectively). The spectra were obtained with pulsed laser excitation at 200 and 218 nm, via H2 Raman shifting the fourth harmonic output of a pulsed YAG laser. At these deep UV wavelengths, strong enhancement is observed for vibrational modes associated with tryptophan, tyrosine, and phenylalanine side chains and with the amide groups of the polypeptide backbone. The amide I peak frequency is consistent with a dominant contribution from alpha-helical regions, although a broad high-frequency tail reflects a variety of unordered conformations. The peak frequency is 12 cm-1 higher for cytochrome c from tuna than from horse, suggesting a less tightly wound structure, which is consistent with the lower denaturation temperature previously reported for the tuna protein. The amide I peak broadens when native protein (state III) is converted to the low- or high-pH forms (states II and IV), reflecting some disordering of the polypeptide chain, but the peak frequencies are unshifted, establishing that the alpha-helical segments are not completely unfolded in these states. Raising the pH to 13 (state V), however, does produce a frequency upshift, reflecting helix unfolding. The amide II and III frequencies are likewise consistent with a dominant alpha-helix contribution in the native proteins; they gain intensity, and amide III is shifted to a lower frequency, in states II and IV, consistent with partial disordering.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Proton NMR comparison of noncovalent and covalently cross-linked complexes of cytochrome c peroxidase with horse, tuna, and yeast ferricytochromes c.

Proton NMR spectroscopy at 500 and 361 MHz has been used to characterize the noncovalent or electrostatic complexes of yeast cytochrome c peroxidase (CcP) with horse, tuna, yeast isozyme-1, and yeast isozyme-2 ferricytochromes c and the covalently cross-linked complexes of cytochrome c peroxidase with horse and yeast isozyme-1 ferricytochromes c. Under the conditions employed in this work, the stoichiometry of the predominant complex formed in solution (which totaled greater than 90% of complex formed) was found to be 1:1 in all cases. These studies have elucidated significant differences in the proton NMR absorption spectra and the one-dimensional nuclear Overhauser effect difference spectra of the complexes, depending on the specific species of ferricytochrome c incorporated. In particular, the results indicate that the noncovalent complexes formed between CcP and physiological redox partners (yeast isozyme-1 or yeast isozyme-2 ferricytochromes c) are distinctly different from the noncovalent complexes formed between CcP and ferricytochromes c from horse and tuna. Parallel chemical cross-linking studies carried out using mixtures of cytochrome c peroxidase with horse ferricytochrome c, and cytochrome c peroxidase with yeast isozyme-1 ferricytochrome c further emphasize such cytochrome c-dependent differences, with only the covalently cross-linked complex of physiological redox partners (cytochrome c peroxidase/yeast isozyme-1) displaying NMR spectra characteristic of a heterogeneous mixture of different 1:1 complexes. Finally, one-dimensional nuclear Overhauser effect experiments have proven valuable in selectively and efficiently probing the protein-protein interface in these complexes, including the environment around the cytochrome c heme 3-methyl group and Phe-82.     

Haem ligands of the ferricytochrome c of Ustilago sphaerogena

The mammalian-type cytochrome c of the basidiomycete Ustilago sphaerogena contains in a single polypeptide chain of 107 residues, two histidine residues located at positions 18 and 33, and one methionine residue situated at position 80 (Bitar et al., 1972). The reaction of Ustilago ferricytochrome c with bromoacetate at neutral pH resulted in the modification of histidine-33, but not of histidine-18 or of the invariant methionine residue. The activities of Ustilago cytochrome c with mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase and with NADH-cytochrome c reductase were unaltered by the modification. The equilibrium constants for the formation of low-spin complexes of the ferrihaem octapeptide of horse cytochrome c (residues 14-21, including the haem bound covalently to cysteines 14 and 17) with imidazole, N(2)-acetylhistidine and monocarboxymethyl derivatives of N(2)-acetylhistidine were determined spectrophotometrically. Alkylation of the imidazole side-chain group of N(2)-acetylhistidine resulted in a marked decrease in its ability to form low-spin ferrihaem complexes. These results indicate that in Ustilago ferricytochrome c in solution histidine-33 is not involved in the central co-ordination complex. Since side-chain groups of residues other than histidine and methionine do not appear to be involved in the central complexes of other mammalian-type cytochromes c (Hettinger & Harbury, 1964, 1965; Myer & Harbury, 1965) it is likely that in Ustilago ferricytochrome c in solution at neutral pH, the side-chain groups of histidine-18 and methionine-80 are involved in the central co-ordination complex. The latter is stable over the pH range 2.6-8.4.     

The identification of cation-binding domains on the surface of microsomal cytochrome b5 using 1H-NMR paramagnetic difference spectroscopy.

One-dimensional and two-dimensional 1H-NMR methods and paramagnetic difference spectroscopy have defined cation binding domains on the surface of the tryptic fragment of microsomal cytochrome b5. The addition of tris(ethylenediamine) chromium(III) [Cr(en)3(3+)] to solutions of ferricytochrome b5 reveals at least three distinct sites on the surface of the protein to which highly charged cations may bind (20 mM phosphate pH 7.0, T = 300 K). Surprisingly only one of these sites is located close to the haem edge region of the protein, whilst the remaining two sites are more remote. Site I contains the exposed haem C13 propionate and a series of carboxylate residues that includes glutamates 37, 38, 43, 44, and 48. Sites II and III are located away from the haem edge region and are delineated by the broadening of aromatic resonances of histidines 26 and 80. Further investigation of the interaction between Cr(en)3(3+) and cytochrome b5 using two-dimensional double-quantum-filtered correlated spectroscopy shows that resonances assigned to Glu59, Asp60, Glu79, Asp82 and Asp83 are broadened with the distribution of these charged side chains correlating with the relaxation broadening observed from one-dimensional experiments. In a binary complex with ferricytochrome c, Cr(en3(3+) broadens many cytochrome b45 resonances including the haem propionates, His26, Ala54, Thr55 and His80. Although the pattern of line-broadening of resonances at sites II and III is unaltered by complex formation, cytochrome c shields residues at site I, the haem edge site. The results indicate that the interaction between cytochrome b5 and c in a binary complex involves multiple protein configurations.     

Tuna cytochrome c at 2.0 A resolution. II. Ferrocytochrome structure analysis.

The x-ray crystal structure analysis of tuna ferrocytochrome c has been extended from 2.45 to 2.0 A resolution. The overall folding is unchanged and is the same as has been reported for tuna ferricytochrome c (Swanson R., Trus, B.L., Mandel, N., Mandel, G., Kallai, O.B., and Dickerson, R.E. (1977) J. Biol. Chem. 252, 759-755). No significant structural differences are observed between oxidation states. Difference map studies using reoxidized crystals of ferrocytochrome c confirm the absence of a conformation change. A detailed analysis of hydrogen bonding shows the presence of six beta or 310 bends of type II with obligatory glycines in the 3rd residue position. This explains 6 of the 10 nearly invariant glycines in the molecule. Close packing contacts account for three more, and only the invariant glycine 1 remains a mystery.     

Solution structure of mitochondrial cytochrome c. II. 1H nuclear magnetic resonance of ferrocytochrome c

The 1H nuclear magnetic resonance spectrum of tuna ferrocytochrome c has been studied and the resonances of all 49 amino acid methyl groups have been assigned to specific absorption lines. In comparison with resonance assignments in the ferricytochrome c spectrum, the secondary shifts of resonances of ferrocytochrome c are smaller and the identification of characteristic spin-systems from comparison of spectra from homologous proteins more difficult. For this reason, two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance exchange correlated spectroscopy has been used to correlate the assigned resonances of tuna ferricytochrome c with previously unassigned resonances of tuna ferrocytochrome c.     

Tuna cytochrome c at 2.0 A resolution. I.Ferricytochrome structure analysis.

The crystal structure of oxidized cytochrome c from tuna hearts has been solved by x-ray diffraction to a resolution of 2.0 A, using four isomorphous heavy atom derivatives. The crystals, space group P43, have 2 independent cytochrome molecules in the asymmetric repeating unit. No significant difference is seen between these 2 molecules, aside from conformations of a few surface side chains. The molecular folding observed is essentially that reported for tuna ferrocytochrome c. In particular, the ring of phenylalanine 83 lies against the heme group and closes the heme crevice, and is not swung out into the surroundings as had been believed from the 2.8 A horse ferricytochrome c structure.     

Nuclear-magnetic-resonance studies of Desulfuromonas acetoxidans cytochrome c551.5 (c7)

1H nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy has been used to examine cytochrome c551.5 (c7) from the sulfur reducer, Desulfuromonas acetoxidans. This protein contains three hemes. Two stable oxidation states (the fully oxidized and the fully reduced) as well as intermediate oxidation states were studied. The axial ligands of the iron were found to be neutral histidines. The redox properties of cytochrome c7 were examined and good quantitative agreement found between the NMR results and previously reported redox potential measurements. The properties of cytochrome c7 are discussed together with those of the homologous tetraheme cytochromes c3 isolate from sulfate-reducing bacteria.     

Proton-NMR studies of the effects of ionic strength and pH on the hyperfine-shifted resonances and phenylalanine-82 environment of three species of mitochondrial ferricytochrome c.

Ferricytochromes c from three species (horse, tuna, yeast) display sensitivity to variations in solution ionic strength or pH that is manifested in significant changes in the proton NMR spectra of these proteins. Irradiation of the heme 3-CH3 resonances in the proton NMR spectra of tuna, horse and yeast iso-1 ferricytochromes c is shown to give NOE connectivities to the phenyl ring protons of Phe82 as well as to the beta-CH2 protons of this residue. This method was used to probe selectively the Phe82 spin systems of the three cytochromes c under a variety of solution conditions. This phenylalanine residue has previously been shown to be invariant in all mitochondrial cytochromes c, located near the exposed heme edge in proximity to the heme 3-CH3, and may function as a mediator in electron transfer reactions [Louie, G. V., Pielak, G. J., Smith, M. & Brayer, G. D. (1988) Biochemistry 27, 7870-7876]. Ferricytochromes c from all three species undergo a small but specific structural rearrangement in the environment around the heme 3-CH3 group upon changing the solution conditions from low to high ionic strength. This structural change involves a decrease in the distance between the Phe82 beta-CH2 group and the heme 3-CH3 substituent. In addition, studies of the effect of pH on the 1H-NMR spectrum of yeast iso-1 ferricytochrome c show that the heme 3-CH3 proton resonance exhibits a pH-dependent shift with an apparent pK in the range of 6.0-7.0. The chemical shift change of the yeast iso-1 ferricytochrome c heme 3-CH3 resonance is not accompanied by an increase in the linewidth as previously described for horse ferricytochrome c [Burns, P. D. & La Mar, G. N. (1981) J. Biol. Chem. 256, 4934-4939]. These spectral changes are interpreted as arising from an ionization of His33 near the C-terminus. In general, the larger spectral changes observed for the resonances in the vicinity of the heme 3-CH3 group in yeast iso-1 ferricytochrome c with changes in solution conditions, relative to the tuna and horse proteins, suggest that the region around Phe82 is more open and that movement of the Phe82 residue is less constrained in yeast ferricytochrome c. Finally, it is demonstrated here that both the heme 8-CH3 and the 7 alpha-CH resonances of yeast ferricytochrome c titrate with p2H and exhibit apparent pK values of approximately 7.0. The titrating group responsible for these spectral changes is proposed to be His39.     

The electric potential field around cytochrome c and the effect of ionic strength on reaction rates of horse cytochrome c.

1. The electric potential fields around tuna ferri- and ferrocytochrome c were calculated assuming that (i) all of the lysines and arginines are protonated, (ii) all of the glutamic and aspartic acids and the terminal carboxylic acid are dissociated, and (iii) the haem has a net charge of +1e in the oxidized form. 2. Near the haem crevice high values for the potential (greater than +2.5 kT/e) are found. Consequently, electron transfer via the haem edge is favored if the oxidant or reductant is negatively charged. 3. The inhomogeneous distribution of charges leads to a dipole moment of 244 and 238 debye for oxidized and reduced tuna cytochrome c, respectively. Horse cytochrome c has dipole moments of 303 (oxidized) and 286 (reduced) debye. 4. A line through the positive and negative charge centres, the dipole axis, crosses the tuna cytochrome c surface at Ala 83 (positive part) and Lys 99 (negative part). The direction of the dipole axis of horse cytochrome c is very similar. Since the centre of the domain on the cytochrome c surface, which is involved in the binding to cytochrome c oxidase, is found at the beta-carbon of the Phe 82 in horse cytochrome c (Ferguson-Miller, S., Brautigan, D.L. and Margoliash, E. (1978) J. Biol. Chem. 253, 149--159) it is suggested that the direction of the dipole is of physiological importance. 5. The activity coefficients of horse ferri- and ferrocytochrome c were calculated as a function of ionic strength using a formula derived by Kirkwood (Kirkwood, J.G. (1934) J. Chem. Phys. 2, 351--361). 6. Due to the high net charge at pH 7.5 the influence of the dipole moments of horse ferri- and ferrocytochrome c on the respective activity coefficients can be neglected at I less than or equal to 50 mM. 7. Using the Br?nsted relation the effect of ionic strength on reaction rates of horse cytochrome c was calculated. Good agreement is found between theory and experimental results reported in the literature.     

Inhibition of the cytochrome c/cytochrome c oxidase system by cytochrome c derivatives and related fragments

The oxidation of ferrocytochrome c mediated by cytochrome c oxidase was investigated in the presence of ferricytochrome c, trifluoroacetyl-cytochrome c, the heme fragments Hse65-[1-65] and Hse80-[1-80] and their respective porphyrin derivatives, as well as carboxymethylated apoprotein and related fragments, polycations, salts and neutral additives. The inhibition of the redox reaction by salts and neutral molecules, even if in theoretical agreement with their effect on electrostatic interactions, may alternatively be interpreted in terms of hydrophobicity. The latter can account for the inhibitory properties of trifluoroacetylated ferricytochrome c, similar to those of ferricytochrome c. On the assumption that the inhibitory properties of some of the investigated derivatives monitor their binding affinities to the cytochrome c oxidase at the cytochrome c binding sites, the experimental results do not confirm a primarily electrostatic character for the cytochrome c/cytochrome c oxidase association process. Strong indication was found that the cytochrome c C-terminal sequence is critically involved in the complex formation. Conformational studies by circular dichroism measurements and IR spectroscopy in solution and in solid state respectively, show that some of the derivatives examined may possibly acqkuire in the binding process to the oxidase, as secondary structure similar to that present in the native cytochrome c.     

Characterization of purified cytochrome c1 from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26

Cytochrome c1 from a photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26 has been purified to homogeneity. The purified protein contains 30 nmol heme per mg protein, has an isoelectric point of 5.7, and is soluble in aqueous solution in the absence of detergents. The apparent molecular weight of this protein is about 150,000, determined by Bio Gel A-0.5 m column chromatography; a minimum molecular weight of 30,000 is obtained by sodium dodecylsulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The absorption spectrum of this cytochrome is similar to that of mammalian cytochrome c1, but the amino acid composition and circular dichroism spectral characteristics are different. The heme moiety of cytochrome c1 is more exposed than is that of mammalian cytochrome c1, but less exposed than that of cytochrome c2. Ferricytochrome c1 undergoes photoreduction upon illumination with light under anaerobic conditions. Such photoreduction is completely abolished when p-chloromercuriphenylsulfonate is added to ferricytochrome c1, suggesting that the sulfhydryl groups of cytochrome c1 are the electron donors for photoreduction. Purified cytochrome c1 contains 3 +/- 0.1 mol of the p-chloromercuriphenylsulfonate titratable sulfhydryl groups per mol of protein. In contrast to mammalian cytochrome c1, the bacterial protein does not form a stable complex with cytochrome c2 or with mammalian cytochrome c at low ionic strength. Electron transfer between bacterial ferrocytochrome c1 and bacterial ferricytochrome c2, and between bacterial ferrocytochrome c1 and mammalian ferricytochrome c proceeds rapidly with equilibrium constants of 49 and 3.5, respectively. The midpoint potential of purified cytochrome c1 is calculated to be 228 mV, which is identical to that of mammalian cytochrome c1.