Patterns of gene duplication and intron loss in the ENCODE regions suggest a confounding factor

The exon-intron structure of eukaryotic genes allows for phenomena such as alternative splicing, nonsense-mediated decay, and regulation through untranslated regions. However, the evolution of the exon structure of genes is not well elucidated because of limited and phylogenetically sparse data sets. In this study, we use the phylogenetically diverse sequencing of the ENCODE regions to study gene structure evolution in mammalian genomes. This first phylogenetically diverse study of gene structure changes offers insights into the mode and tempo of mammalian gene structure evolution. The genes undergoing structure changes appear to be moderately to highly expressed in germline cells and show levels of selection similar to those of other ENCODE genes. Patterns of gene duplication of the affected genes are more complex than expected. The number of sampled genomes is sufficiently dense to infer that certain gene duplications happened after intron loss. Thus, although gene duplication is highly correlated with intron loss, we conclude that structural changes in genes are not necessarily due to a loss of constraint following gene duplication as previously suggested.     

The Mutually Exclusive Flip and Flop Exons of AMPA Receptor Genes Were Derived from an Intragenic Duplication in the Vertebrate Lineage

The incomplete correlation between the organismal complexities and the number of genes among eukaryotic organisms can be partially explained by multiple protein products of a gene created by alternative splicing. One type of alternative splicing involves alternative selection of mutually exclusive exons and creates protein products with substitution of one segment of the amino acid sequence for another. To elucidate the evolution of the mutually exclusive 115-bp exons, designated flip and flop, of vertebrate AMPA receptor genes, the gene structures of chordate (tunicate, cephalochordate, and vertebrate) and protostome (Drosophila and Caenorhabditis elegans) AMPA receptor subunits were compared. Phylogenetic analysis supports that the vertebrate flip and flop exons evolved from a common sequence. Flip and flop exons exist in all vertebrate AMPA receptor genes but only one 115-bp exon is present in the genes of tunicates and cephalochordates, suggesting that the exon duplication event occurred at the ancestral vertebrate AMPA receptor gene after the separation of vertebrates from primitive chordates. The structures of animal AMPA receptor genes also suggest that an intron insertion to separate the primordial flip/flop exon from the M4-coding exon occurred before the exon duplication event and probably at the chordate lineage. [Reviewing Editor: Dr. Manyuan Long]     

Muscle-specific splicing enhancers regulate inclusion of the cardiac troponin T alternative exon in embryonic skeletal muscle.

The alternative exon 5 of the striated muscle-specific cardiac troponin T (cTNT) gene is included in mRNA from embryonic skeletal and cardiac muscle and excluded in mRNA from the adult. The embryonic splicing pattern is reproduced in primary skeletal muscle cultures for both the endogenous gene and transiently transfected minigenes, whereas in nonmuscle cell lines, minigenes express a default exon skipping pattern. Using this experimental system, we previously showed that a purine-rich splicing enhancer in the alternative exon functions as a constitutive splicing element but not as a target for factors regulating cell-specific splicing. In this study, we identify four intron elements, one located upstream,and three located downstream of the alternative exon, which act in a positive manner to mediate the embryonic splicing pattern of exon inclusion. Synergistic interactions between at least three of the four elements are necessary and sufficient to regulate splicing of a heterologous alternative exon and heterologous splice sites. Mutations in these elements prevent activation of exon inclusion in muscle cells but do not affect the default level of exon inclusion in nonmuscle cells. Therefore, these elements function as muscle-specific splicing enhancers (MSEs) and are the first muscle-specific positive-acting splicing elements to be described. One MSE located downstream from the alternative exon is conserved in the rat and chicken cTNT genes. A related sequence is found in a third muscle-specific gene, that encoding skeletal troponin T, downstream from an alternative exon with a developmental pattern of alternative splicing similar to that of rat and chicken cTNT. Therefore, the MSEs identified in the cTNT gene may play a role in developmentally regulated alternative splicing in a number of different genes.     

Revisit on the evolutionary relationship between alternative splicing and gene duplication

Gene duplications and alternative splicing (AS) isoforms are two widespread types of genetic variations that can facilitate diversification of protein function. A number of studies claimed that after gene duplication, two AS isoforms with differential functions can be 'fixed', respectively, in each of the duplicate copies. This simple 'functional-sharing' hypothesis was recently challenged by Roux and Robinson-Rechavi (2011). Instead, they proposed a more sophisticated hypothesis, invoking that less alternative splicing genes tend to be duplicated more frequently, and single-copy genes are younger than duplicate genes, or the 'duplicability-age' hypothesis for short. In this letter, we show that all these genome-wide analyses of AS isoforms actually did not provide clear-cut evidence to nullify the basic idea of functional-sharing hypothesis. After updating our understanding of genome-wide alternative splicing, duplicability and CNV (copy number variation), we argue that the foundation of the duplicability-age hypothesis remains to be justified carefully. Finally, we suggest that a better approach to resolving this controversy is the correspondence analysis of indels (insertions and deletions) between duplicate genes to the genomic exon-intron structure, which can be used to experimentally test the effect of functional-sharing hypothesis.     

Alternative splicing for members of human mosaic domain superfamilies. I. The CH and LIM domains containing group of proteins

In this paper we examine (restricted to homo sapiens) the products resulting from gene duplication and the subsequent alternative splicing for the members of a multidomain group of proteins which possess the evolutionary conserved calponin homology CH domain, i.e. an “actin binding domain”, as a singlet and which, in addition, contain the conserved cysteine rich double Zn finger possessing Lim domain, also as a singlet. Seven genes, resulting from gene duplications, were identified that code for seven group members for which pre-mRNAs appear to have undergone multiple alternative splicing: Mical 1, 2 and 3 are located on chromosomes 6q21, 11p15 and 22q11, respectively. The LMO7 gene is present on chromosome 13q22 and the LIMCH1 gene on chromosome 4p13. Micall1 is mapped to chromosome 22q13 and Micall2 to chromosome 7p22. Translated Gen/Bank ESTs suggest the existence of multiple products alternatively spliced from the pre-mRNAs encoded by these genes. Characteristic indicators of such splicing among the proteins derived from one gene must include containment of some common extensive 100% identical regions. In some instances only one exon might be partly or completely eliminated. Sometimes alternative splicing is also associated with an increased frequency of creation of an exon or part of an exon from an intron. Not only coding regions for the body of the protein but also for its N– or –C ends could be affected by the splicing. If created forms are merely beginning at different starting points but remain identical in sequence thereafter, their existence as products of alternate splicing must be questioned. In the splicings, described in this paper, multiple isoforms rather than a single isoform appear as products during the gene expression. Computer Facilitation kindly provided by Guy Lingani.     

Massive expansions of Dscam splicing diversity via staggered homologous recombination during arthropod evolution

The arthropod Down syndrome cell adhesion molecule (Dscam) gene can generate tens of thousands of protein isoforms via combinatorial splicing of numerous alternative exons encoding immunoglobulin variable domains organized into three clusters referred to as the exon 4, 6, and 9 clusters. Dscam protein diversity is important for nervous system development and immune functions. We have performed extensive phylogenetic analyses of Dscam from 20 arthropods (each containing between 46 and 96 alternative exons) to reconstruct the detailed history of exon duplication and loss events that built this remarkable system over 450 million years of evolution. Whereas the structure of the exon 4 cluster is ancient, the exon 6 and 9 clusters have undergone massive, independent expansions in each insect lineage. An analysis of nearly 2000 duplicated exons enabled detailed reconstruction of the timing, location, and boundaries of these duplication events. These data clearly show that new Dscam exons have arisen continuously throughout arthropod evolution and that this process is still occurring in the exon 6 and 9 clusters. Recently duplicated regions display boundaries corresponding to a single exon and the adjacent intron. The boundaries, homology, location, clustering, and relative frequencies of these duplication events strongly suggest that staggered homologous recombination is the major mechanism by which new Dscam exons evolve. These data provide a remarkably detailed picture of how complex gene structure evolves and reveal the molecular mechanism behind this process.     

Exon duplication from a fork head to a homeodomain protein

The evolution of complex organisms such as animals requires a large expansion of the number of genes controlling developmental events. In addition, it is thought that domains are shuffled between genes to further increase the complexity and generate new types of genes and functions. Working with the Caenorhabditis elegans homeobox gene ceh-43, the orthologue of fly Distal-less (Dll), we observed sequence similarity to the C. elegans gene fkh-1. Now, with the complete genomic sequence available, we examined this similarity in detail. The region of similarity is confined essentially to one exon in the carboxy terminus of the two genes. Based on the gene structure, we think that an exon of fkh-1 was duplicated to the carboxy terminus of ceh-43, where it was incorporated as the last exon. This duplication event seems to have happened recently since the similarity on the nucleotide level is higher than the sequence similarity between fkh-1 of C. elegans and C. briggsae. Potentially the duplication event was mediated via a short region of sequence similarity between the two open reading frames of the genes. This duplication event clear shows that a part of a gene can successfully be juxtaposed to another gene. These events may perhaps not be rare. Received: 28 March 1999 / Accepted: 8 June 1999     

选择性剪接的理论预测

可变剪接作为真核生物转录后加工机制普遍存在于不同组织、不同发育时期或不同病理状态下的基因表达调控过程中。对同一基因不同剪接变体的研究可使我们更深入的了解发育、进化、疾病发生机理等基本的生物学问题。讨论了一些基于序列比对而建立的可变剪接的理论预测方法,尚存不足之处,有待于进一步完善。     

A DNA damage signal activates and derepresses exon inclusion in Drosophila TAF1 alternative splicing

Signal-dependent alternative splicing is important for regulating gene expression in eukaryotes, yet our understanding of how signals impact splicing mechanisms is limited. A model to address this issue is alternative splicing of Drosophila TAF1 pre-mRNA in response to camptothecin (CPT)-induced DNA damage signals. CPT treatment of Drosophila S2 cells causes increased inclusion of TAF1 alternative cassette exons 12a and 13a through an ATR signaling pathway. To evaluate the role of TAF1 pre-mRNA sequences in the alternative splicing mechanism, we developed a TAF1 minigene (miniTAF1) and an S2 cell splicing assay that recapitulated key aspects of CPT-induced alternative splicing of endogenous TAF1. Analysis of miniTAF1 indicated that splice site strength underlies independent and distinct mechanisms that control exon 12a and 13a inclusion. Mutation of the exon 13a weak 5' splice site or weak 3' splice site to a consensus sequence was sufficient for constitutive exon 13a inclusion. In contrast, mutation of the exon 12a strong 5' splice site or moderate 3' splice site to a consensus sequence was only sufficient for constitutive exon 12a inclusion in the presence of CPT-induced signals. Analogous studies of the exon 13 3' splice site suggest that exon 12a inclusion involves signal-dependent pairing between constitutive and alternative splice sites. Finally, intronic elements identified by evolutionary conservation were necessary for full repression of exon 12a inclusion or full activation of exon 13a inclusion and may be targets of CPT-induced signals. In summary, this work defines the role of sequence elements in the regulation of TAF1 alternative splicing in response to a DNA damage signal.     

Identification of a novel cis-element that regulates alternative splicing of Bcl-x pre-mRNA

Alternative splicing plays an important role in the control of apoptosis. A number of genes related to apoptosis undergo alternative splicing. Among them, the apoptotic regulator Bcl-x produces two major isoforms, Bcl-xL and Bcl-xS, through the alternative splicing of exon 2 in its pre-mRNA. These isoforms have antagonistic function in apoptotic pathway; Bcl-xL is pro-apoptotic, while Bcl-xS is anti-apoptotic. The balanced ratio of two isoforms is important for cell survival. However, regulatory mechanisms of Bcl-x splicing remain poorly understood. Using a mini-gene system, we have found that a 105 nt exonic region (E3b) located within exon 3 affects exon 2 splicing in the Bcl-x gene. Further deletion and mutagenesis studies demonstrate that this 105 nt sequence contains various functional elements which promote skipping of exon 2b. One of these elements forms a stem-loop structure that stimulates skipping of exon 2b. Furthermore our results prove that the stem-loop structure functions as an enhancer in general pre-mRNA splicing. We conclude that we have identified a cis-regulatory element in exon 3 that affects splicing of exon 2 in the Bcl-x gene. This element could be potentially targeted to alter the ratio of Bcl-xL and Bcl-xS for treatment of tumors through an apoptotic pathway.     

Gene duplication and the evolution of phenotypic diversity in insect societies

Gene duplication is an important evolutionary process thought to facilitate the evolution of phenotypic diversity. We investigated if gene duplication was associated with the evolution of phenotypic differences in a highly social insect, the honeybee Apis mellifera. We hypothesized that the genetic redundancy provided by gene duplication could promote the evolution of social and sexual phenotypes associated with advanced societies. We found a positive correlation between sociality and rate of gene duplications across the Apoidea, indicating that gene duplication may be associated with sociality. We also discovered that genes showing biased expression between A. mellifera alternative phenotypes tended to be found more frequently than expected among duplicated genes than singletons. Moreover, duplicated genes had higher levels of caste‐, sex‐, behavior‐, and tissue‐biased expression compared to singletons, as expected if gene duplication facilitated phenotypic differentiation. We also found that duplicated genes were maintained in the A. mellifera genome through the processes of conservation, neofunctionalization, and specialization, but not subfunctionalization. Overall, we conclude that gene duplication may have facilitated the evolution of social and sexual phenotypes, as well as tissue differentiation. Thus this study further supports the idea that gene duplication allows species to evolve an increased range of phenotypic diversity.