Mutations in human nuclear genes encoding for subunits of mitochondrial respiratory complex I: the NDUFS4 gene

Among the mitochondrial disorders, complex I deficiencies are encountered frequently. Although some complex I deficiencies have been associated with mitochondrial DNA mutations, in the majority of the complex I-deficient patients mutations of nuclear genes are expected. This review attempts to summarize genetic defects affecting nuclear encoded subunits of complex I reported to date focusing on those found in the NDUFS4 gene. NDUFS4 product is 18 kDa protein which appears to have a dual role in complex I, at least: cAMP-dependent phosphorylation activates the complex; non-sense mutation of NDUFS4 prevents normal assembly of a functional complex in the inner mitochondrial membrane.     

Mutations in structural genes of complex I associated with neurological diseases

This paper summarizes observations on the genetic and biochemical basis of hereditary defects of complex I (NADH-ubiquinone oxidoreductase) of the respiratory chain in human neurological patients. Two different types of functional defects of the complex are described. In one type mutations in the NDUFS1 and NDUFS4 nuclear structural genes of the complex were identified in two unrelated families. Both NDUFS1 and NDUFS4 neurological disorders were transmitted by autosomic recessive inheritance. The two mutations resulted in different impact on cellular metabolism. The NDUFS4 mutation, giving a more severe, fatal pathological pattern, resulted in a defective assembly of the complex and complete suppression of the enzymatic activity. The NDUFS1 mutation, with less severe progressive pathology, caused only partial inhibition of the complex but enhanced production of oxygen free radicals. In the second type of deficiencies extensive mutational analysis did not reveal pathogenic mutations in complex I genes but a decline in the level and activity of complex I, III, and IV were found, apparently associated with alteration in the cardiolipin membrane distribution.     

A constant and similar assembly defect of mitochondrial respiratory chain complex I allows rapid identification of NDUFS4 mutations in patients with Leigh syndrome

Isolated complex I deficiency is a frequent cause of respiratory chain defects in childhood. In this study, we report our systematic approach with blue native PAGE (BN-PAGE) to study mitochondrial respiratory chain assembly in skin fibroblasts from patients with Leigh syndrome and CI deficiency. We describe five new NDUFS4 patients with a similar and constant abnormal BN-PAGE profile and present a meta-analysis of the literature. All NDUFS4 mutations that have been tested with BN-PAGE result in a constant and similar abnormal assembly profile with a complete loss of the fully assembled complex I usually due to a truncated protein and the loss of its canonical cAMP dependent protein kinase phosphorylation consensus site. We also report the association of abnormal brain MRI images with this characteristic BN-PAGE profile as the hallmarks of NDUFS4 mutations and the first founder NDUFS4 mutations in the North-African population.     

Respiratory Complex I in Brain Development and Genetic Disease

A study is presented on the expression and activity of complex I, as well as of other complexes of the respiratory chain, in the course of brain development and inherited encephalopathies. Investigations on mouse hippocampal cells show that differentiation of these cells both in vivo and in cell cultures is associated with the expression of a functional complex I, whose activity markedly increases with respect to that of complexes III and IV. Data are presented on genetic defects of complex I in six children with inborn encephalopathy associated with isolated deficiency of the complex. Mutations have been identified in nuclear and mitochondrial genes coding for subunits of the complex. Different mutations were found in the nuclear NDUFS4 gene coding for the 18 kD (IP, AQDQ) subunit of complex I. All the NDUFS4 mutations resulted in impairment of the assembly of a functional complex. The observations presented provide evidence showing a critical role of complex I in differentiation and functional activity of brain cells.     

Clinical and molecular findings in children with complex I deficiency

Isolated complex I deficiency, the most frequent OXPHOS disorder in infants and children, is genetically heterogeneous. Mutations have been found in seven mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) and eight nuclear DNA encoded subunits, respectively, but in most of the cases the genetic basis of the biochemical defect is unknown. We analyzed the entire mtDNA and 11 nuclear encoded complex I subunits in 23 isolated complex I-deficient children, classified into five clinical groups: Leigh syndrome, progressive leukoencephalopathy, neonatal cardiomyopathy, severe infantile lactic acidosis, and a miscellaneous group of unspecified encephalomyopathies. A genetic definition was reached in eight patients (35%). Mutations in mtDNA were found in six out of eight children with Leigh syndrome, indicating a prevalent association between this phenotype and abnormalities in ND genes. In two patients with leukoencephalopathy, homozygous mutations were detected in two different nuclear-encoded complex I genes, including a novel transition in NDUFS1 subunit. In addition to these, a child affected by mitochondrial encephalomyopathy had heterozygous mutations in NDUFA8 and NDUFS2 genes, while another child with neonatal cardiomyopathy had a complex rearrangement in a single NDUFS7 allele. The latter cases suggest the possibility of unconventional patterns of inheritance in complex I defects.     

Leigh syndrome associated with mitochondrial complex I deficiency due to novel mutations In NDUFV1 and NDUFS2

Leigh syndrome (LS) is a progressive neurodegenerative disease caused by either mitochondrial or nuclear DNA mutations resulting in dysfunctional mitochondrial energy metabolism. Mutations in genes encoding for subunits of the respiratory chain or assembly factors of respiratory chain complexes are often documented in LS cases. Nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH):ubiquinone oxidoreductase (complex I) enzyme deficiencies account for a significant proportion of mitochondrial disorders, including LS. In an attempt to expand the repertoire of known mutations accounting for LS, we describe the clinical, radiological, biochemical and molecular data of six patients with LS found to have novel mutations in two complex I subunits (NDUFV1 and NDUFS2). Two siblings were homozygous for the previously undescribed R386C mutation in NDUFV1, one patient was a compound heterozygote for the R386C mutation in NDUFV1 and a frameshift mutation in the same gene, one patient was a compound heterozygote for the R88G and R199P mutations in NDUFV1, and two siblings were compound heterozygotes for an undescribed E104A mutation in NDUFS2. After the novel mutations were identified, we employed prediction models using protein conservation analysis (SIFT, PolyPhen and UCSC genome browser) to determine pathogenicity. The R386C, R88G, R199P, and E104A mutations were found to be likely pathogenic, and thus presumably account for the LS phenotype. This case series broadens our understanding of the etiology of LS by identifying new molecular defects that can result in complex I deficiency and may assist in targeted diagnostics and/or prenatal diagnosis of LS in the future.     

Understanding mitochondrial complex I assembly in health and disease

Complex I (NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase) is the largest multimeric enzyme complex of the mitochondrial respiratory chain, which is responsible for electron transport and the generation of a proton gradient across the mitochondrial inner membrane to drive ATP production. Eukaryotic complex I consists of 14 conserved subunits, which are homologous to the bacterial subunits, and more than 26 accessory subunits. In mammals, complex I consists of 45 subunits, which must be assembled correctly to form the properly functioning mature complex. Complex I dysfunction is the most common oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) disorder in humans and defects in the complex I assembly process are often observed. This assembly process has been difficult to characterize because of its large size, the lack of a high resolution structure for complex I, and its dual control by nuclear and mitochondrial DNA. However, in recent years, some of the atomic structure of the complex has been resolved and new insights into complex I assembly have been generated. Furthermore, a number of proteins have been identified as assembly factors for complex I biogenesis and many patients carrying mutations in genes associated with complex I deficiency and mitochondrial diseases have been discovered. Here, we review the current knowledge of the eukaryotic complex I assembly process and new insights from the identification of novel assembly factors. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Biogenesis/Assembly of Respiratory Enzyme Complexes.     

Application of the obligate aerobic yeast Yarrowia lipolytica as a eucaryotic model to analyse Leigh syndrome mutations in the complex I core subunits PSST and TYKY

We have used the obligate aerobic yeast Yarrowia lipolytica to reconstruct and analyse three missense mutations in the nuclear coded subunits homologous to bovine TYKY and PSST of mitochondrial complex I (proton translocating NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase) that have been shown to cause Leigh syndrome (MIM 25600), a severe progressive neurodegenerative disorder. While homozygosity for a V122M substitution in NDUFS7 (PSST) has been found in two siblings with neuropathologically proven Leigh syndrome (R. Triepels et al., Ann. Neurol. 45 (1999) 787), heterozygosity for a P79L and a R102H substitution in NDUFS8 (TYKY) has been found in another patient (J. Loeffen et al., Am. J. Hum. Genet. 63 (1998) 1598). Mitochondrial membranes from Y. lipolytica strains carrying any of the three point mutations exhibited similar complex I defects, with V(max) being reduced by about 50%. This suggests that complex I mutations that clinically present as Leigh syndrome may share common characteristics. In addition changes in the K(m) for n-decyl-ubiquinone and I(50) for hydrophobic complex I inhibitors were observed, which provides further evidence that not only the hydrophobic, mitochondrially coded subunits, but also some of the nuclear coded subunits of complex I are involved in its reaction with ubiquinone.     

Cytochrome c oxidase-deficient patients have distinct subunit assembly profiles

Cytochrome c oxidase (COX) deficiency is the most common respiratory chain defect in childhood and is clinically heterogeneous. We report a study of six patients with COX deficiencies. Two of the patients had as yet undefined defects, three patients had Surf-1 mutations, and one patient had a 15-base pair deletion in the COX III subunit. We show that quantitative measurements of steady-state levels of subunits by monoclonal antibody reactivity, when used in combination with a discontinuous sucrose gradient methods, provide an improved diagnosis of COX deficiencies by distinguishing between kinetic, stability, and assembly defects. The two mutants of undefined etiology had a full complement of subunits with one stable and the other partially unstable to detergent solubilization. Both are likely to carry mutations in nuclear-encoded subunits of the complex. The three Surf-1 mutants and the COX III mutant each had reduced steady-state levels of subunits but variable associations of the residual subunits. This information, as well as aiding in diagnosis, helps in understanding the genotype-phenotype relationships of COX deficiencies and provides insight into the mechanism of assembly of the enzyme complex.     

Eukaryotic complex I: functional diversity and experimental systems to unravel the assembly process

With more than 40 subunits, one FMN co-factor and eight FeS clusters, complex I or NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase is the largest multimeric respiratory enzyme in the mitochondria. In this review, we focus on the diversity of eukaryotic complex I. We describe the additional activities that have been reported to be associated with mitochondrial complex I and discuss their physiological significance. The recent identification of complex I-like enzymes in the hydrogenosome, a mitochondria-derived organelle is also discussed here. Complex I assembly in the mitochondrial inner membrane is an intricate process that requires the cooperation of the nuclear and mitochondrial genomes. The most prevalent forms of mitochondrial dysfunction in humans are deficiencies in complex I and remarkably, the molecular basis for 60% of complex I-linked defects is currently unknown. This suggests that mutations in yet-to-be-discovered assembly genes should exist. We review the different experimental systems for the study of complex I assembly. To our knowledge, in none of them, large screenings of complex I mutants have been performed. We propose that the unicellular green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii is a promising system for such a study. Complex I mutants can be easily scored on a phenotypical basis and a large number of transformants generated by insertional mutagenesis can be screened, which opens the possibility to find new genes involved in the assembly of the enzyme. Moreover, mitochondrial transformation, a recent technological advance, is now available, allowing the manipulation of all five complex I mitochondrial genes in this organism.     

Large-scale deletion and point mutations of the nuclear NDUFV1 and NDUFS1 genes in mitochondrial complex I deficiency

Reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH):ubiquinone oxidoreductase (complex I) is the largest complex of the mitochondrial respiratory chain and complex I deficiency accounts for approximately 30% cases of respiratory-chain deficiency in humans. Only seven mitochondrial DNA genes, but >35 nuclear genes encode complex I subunits. In an attempt to elucidate the molecular bases of complex I deficiency, we studied the six most-conserved complex I nuclear genes (NDUFV1, NDUFS8, NDUFS7, NDUFS1, NDUFA8, and NDUFB6) in a series of 36 patients with isolated complex I deficiency by denaturing high-performance liquid chromatography and by direct sequencing of the corresponding cDNA from cultured skin fibroblasts. In 3/36 patients, we identified, for the first time, five point mutations (del222, D252G, M707V, R241W, and R557X) and one large-scale deletion in the NDUFS1 gene. In addition, we found six novel NDUFV1 mutations (Y204C, C206G, E214K, IVS 8+41, A432P, and del nt 989-990) in three other patients. The six unrelated patients presented with hypotonia, ataxia, psychomotor retardation, or Leigh syndrome. These results suggest that screening for complex I nuclear gene mutations is of particular interest in patients with complex I deficiency, even when normal respiratory-chain-enzyme activities in cultured fibroblasts are observed.     

Novel Insights into the Role of Neurospora crassa NDUFAF2, an Evolutionarily Conserved Mitochondrial Complex I Assembly Factor

Complex I deficiency is commonly associated with mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation diseases. Mutations in nuclear genes encoding structural subunits or assembly factors of complex I have been increasingly identified as the cause of the diseases. One such factor, NDUFAF2, is a paralog of the NDUFA12 structural subunit of the enzyme, but the mechanism by which it exerts its function remains unknown. Herein, we demonstrate that the Neurospora crassa NDUFAF2 homologue, the 13.4L protein, is a late assembly factor that associates with complex I assembly intermediates containing the membrane arm and the connecting part but lacking the N module of the enzyme. Furthermore, we provide evidence that dissociation of the assembly factor is dependent on the incorporation of the putative regulatory module composed of the subunits of 13.4 (NDUFA12), 18.4 (NDUFS6), and 21 (NDUFS4) kDa. Our results demonstrate that the 13.4L protein is a complex I assembly factor functionally conserved from fungi to mammals.     

Assembly of mitochondrial complex I and defects in disease

Isolated complex I deficiency is the most common cause of respiratory chain dysfunction. Defects in human complex I result in energy generation disorders and they are also implicated in neurodegenerative disease and altered apoptotic signaling. Complex I dysfunction often occurs as a result of its impaired assembly. The assembly process of complex I is poorly understood, complicated by the fact that in mammals, it is composed of 45 different subunits and is regulated by both nuclear and mitochondrial genomes. However, in recent years we have gained new insights into complex I biogenesis and a number of assembly factors involved in this process have also been identified. In most cases, these factors have been discovered through their gene mutations that lead to specific complex I defects and result in mitochondrial disease. Here we review how complex I is assembled and the factors required to mediate this process.     

Human CIA30 is involved in the early assembly of mitochondrial complex I and mutations in its gene cause disease

In humans, complex I of the respiratory chain is composed of seven mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA)-encoded and 38 nuclear-encoded subunits that assemble together in a process that is poorly defined. To date, only two complex I assembly factors have been identified and how each functions is not clear. Here, we show that the human complex I assembly factor CIA30 (complex I intermediate associated protein) associates with newly translated mtDNA-encoded complex I subunits at early stages in their assembly before dissociating at a later stage. Using antibodies we identified a CIA30-deficient patient who presented with cardioencephalomyopathy and reduced levels and activity of complex I. Genetic analysis revealed the patient had mutations in both alleles of the NDUFAF1 gene that encodes CIA30. Complex I assembly in patient cells was defective at early stages with subunits being degraded. Complementing the deficiency in patient fibroblasts with normal CIA30 using a novel lentiviral system restored steady-state complex I levels. Our results indicate that CIA30 is a crucial component in the early assembly of complex I and mutations in its gene can cause mitochondrial disease.     

The human complex I NDUFS4 subunit: from gene structure to function and pathology

Complex I is the first and largest enzyme of the oxidative phosphorylation system. It consists of at least 43 subunits. Recent studies have shown that the NDUFS4 subunit of complex I contributes to the activation of the complex through cAMP dependent phosphorylation of a conserved site (RVS) located at the C-terminal region of this protein. This report focuses on the NDUFS4 subunit. Summarized is the current knowledge of this subunit, from gene structure to function and pathology.     

A catalytic defect in mitochondrial respiratory chain complex I due to a mutation in NDUFS2 in a patient with Leigh syndrome

In this study, we investigated the pathogenicity of a homozygous Asp446Asn mutation in the NDUFS2 gene of a patient with a mitochondrial respiratory chain complex I deficiency. The clinical, biochemical, and genetic features of the NDUFS2 patient were compared with those of 4 patients with previously identified NDUFS2 mutations. All 5 patients presented with Leigh syndrome. In addition, 3 out of 5 showed hypertrophic cardiomyopathy. Complex I amounts in the patient carrying the Asp446Asn mutation were normal, while the complex I activity was strongly reduced, showing that the NDUFS2 mutation affects complex I enzymatic function. By contrast, the 4 other NDUFS2 patients showed both a reduced amount and activity of complex I. The enzymatic defect in fibroblasts of the patient carrying the Asp446Asn mutation was rescued by transduction of wild type NDUFS2. A 3-D model of the catalytic core of complex I showed that the mutated amino acid residue resides near the coenzyme Q binding pocket. However, the K(M) of complex I for coenzyme Q analogs of the Asp446Asn mutated complex I was similar to the K(M) observed in other complex I defects and in controls. We propose that the mutation interferes with the reduction of coenzyme Q or with the coupling of coenzyme Q reduction with the conformational changes involved in proton pumping of complex I.     

Mutation of C20orf7 disrupts complex I assembly and causes lethal neonatal mitochondrial disease

Complex I (NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase) is the first and largest multimeric complex of the mitochondrial respiratory chain. Human complex I comprises seven subunits encoded by mitochondrial DNA and 38 nuclear-encoded subunits that are assembled together in a process that is only partially understood. To date, mutations causing complex I deficiency have been described in all 14 core subunits, five supernumerary subunits, and four assembly factors. We describe complex I deficiency caused by mutation of the putative complex I assembly factor C20orf7. A candidate region for a lethal neonatal form of complex I deficiency was identified by homozygosity mapping of an Egyptian family with one affected child and two affected pregnancies predicted by enzyme-based prenatal diagnosis. The region was confirmed by microcell-mediated chromosome transfer, and 11 candidate genes encoding potential mitochondrial proteins were sequenced. A homozygous missense mutation in C20orf7 segregated with disease in the family. We show that C20orf7 is peripherally associated with the matrix face of the mitochondrial inner membrane and that silencing its expression with RNAi decreases complex I activity. C20orf7 patient fibroblasts showed an almost complete absence of complex I holoenzyme and were defective at an early stage of complex I assembly, but in a manner distinct from the assembly defects caused by mutations in the assembly factor NDUFAF1. Our results indicate that C20orf7 is crucial in the assembly of complex I and that mutations in C20orf7 cause mitochondrial disease.     

Subunits of mitochondrial complex I exist as part of matrix- and membrane-associated subcomplexes in living cells

Mitochondrial complex I (CI) is a large assembly of 45 different subunits, and defects in its biogenesis are the most frequent cause of mitochondrial disorders. In vitro evidence suggests a stepwise assembly process involving pre-assembled modules. However, whether these modules also exist in vivo is as yet unresolved. To answer this question, we here applied submitochondrial fluorescence recovery after photobleaching to HEK293 cells expressing 6 GFP-tagged subunits selected on the basis of current CI assembly models. We established that each subunit was partially present in a virtually immobile fraction, possibly representing the holo-enzyme. Four subunits (NDUFV1, NDUFV2, NDUFA2, and NDUFA12) were also present as highly mobile matrix-soluble monomers, whereas, in sharp contrast, the other two subunits (NDUFB6 and NDUFS3) were additionally present in a slowly mobile fraction. In the case of the integral membrane protein NDUFB6, this fraction most likely represented one or more membrane-bound subassemblies, whereas biochemical evidence suggested that for the NDUFS3 protein this fraction most probably corresponded to a matrix-soluble subassembly. Our results provide first time evidence for the existence of CI subassemblies in mitochondria of living cells.