Influence of a valgus knee brace on muscle activation and co-contraction in patients with medial knee osteoarthritis

The purpose of this study was to analyse the effect of a valgus knee orthosis designed for patients with knee osteoarthritis on the electromyographic activity (EMG) of seven muscles of the lower limb during gait. Twelve patients with medial knee osteoarthritis walked on a treadmill in three different conditions: without orthosis, with a knee orthosis in 4° valgus adjustment and with an orthosis in a neutral flexible adjustment. Root-mean-square (RMS) was analysed in each condition during a 150 ms pre-activation phase and during the stance phase of gait, which was divided in four sub-phases. In addition, co-contraction ratios (CCRs) were calculated between extensor/flexor, medial/lateral muscles and between agonist and antagonist muscle pairs. Significant decreases in muscle activity and CCRs were observed with the use of the knee orthosis in both adjustments compared to the condition without orthosis. Using the valgus brace, medial/lateral CCR decreased significantly during the late stance and the flexor/extensor CCR decreased significantly during the loading phase and late stance. Decreases of muscle pairs CCRs were observed with the neutral flexible adjustment. The results support the theory of a possible beneficial effect of knee braces in reducing knee loading by decreasing muscle activation and co-contraction levels, which could contribute to decelerate disease progression in patients with knee osteoarthritis.     

Trainability of Muscular Activity Level during Maximal Voluntary Co-Contraction: Comparison between Bodybuilders and Nonathletes

Antagonistic muscle pairs cannot be fully activated simultaneously, even with maximal effort, under conditions of voluntary co-contraction, and their muscular activity levels are always below those during agonist contraction with maximal voluntary effort (MVE). Whether the muscular activity level during the task has trainability remains unclear. The present study examined this issue by comparing the muscular activity level during maximal voluntary co-contraction for highly experienced bodybuilders, who frequently perform voluntary co-contraction in their training programs, with that for untrained individuals (nonathletes). The electromyograms (EMGs) of biceps brachii and triceps brachii muscles during maximal voluntary co-contraction of elbow flexors and extensors were recorded in 11 male bodybuilders and 10 nonathletes, and normalized to the values obtained during the MVE of agonist contraction for each of the corresponding muscles (% EMG_MVE). The involuntary coactivation level in antagonist muscle during the MVE of agonist contraction was also calculated. In both muscles, % EMG_MVE values during the co-contraction task for bodybuilders were significantly higher (P<0.01) than those for nonathletes (biceps brachii: 66±14% in bodybuilders vs. 46±13% in nonathletes, triceps brachii: 74±16% vs. 57±9%). There was a significant positive correlation between a length of bodybuilding experience and muscular activity level during the co-contraction task (r = 0.653, P = 0.03). Involuntary antagonist coactivation level during MVE of agonist contraction was not different between the two groups. The current result indicates that long-term participation in voluntary co-contraction training progressively enhances muscular activity during maximal voluntary co-contraction.     

Interlimb symmetry of dynamic knee joint stiffness and co-contraction is maintained in early stage knee osteoarthritis

Individuals with knee OA often exhibit greater co-contraction of antagonistic muscle groups surrounding the affected joint which may lead to increases in dynamic joint stiffness. These detrimental changes in the symptomatic limb may also exist in the contralateral limb, thus contributing to its risk of developing knee osteoarthritis. The purpose of this study is to investigate the interlimb symmetry of dynamic knee joint stiffness and muscular co-contraction in knee osteoarthritis.Muscular co-contraction and dynamic knee joint stiffness were assessed in 17 subjects with mild to moderate unilateral medial compartment knee osteoarthritis and 17 healthy control subjects while walking at a controlled speed (1.0 m/s). Paired and independent t-tests determined whether significant differences exist between groups (p < 0.05).There were no significant differences in dynamic joint stiffness or co-contraction between the OA symptomatic and OA contralateral group (p = 0.247, p = 0.874, respectively) or between the OA contralateral and healthy group (p = 0.635, p = 0.078, respectively). There was no significant difference in stiffness between the OA symptomatic and healthy group (p = 0.600); however, there was a slight trend toward enhanced co-contraction in the symptomatic knees compared to the healthy group (p = 0.051).Subjects with mild to moderate knee osteoarthritis maintain symmetric control strategies during gait.     

Muscle co-contraction after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: Influence of functional level

Background

ACL reconstruction is recommended to improve function in subjects with ligament injuries. However, after surgery, some individuals are not able to return to their pre-injury functional level. The mechanisms related to this incapacity are not well understood.

Study design

Cross-sectional study.

Methods

Co-contraction levels were assessed in individuals who returned to their pre-injury functional level and in 10 individuals who were not able to return to full activity after unilateral ACL reconstruction. Electromyography of the vastus lateralis and biceps femoris muscles before and after sudden perturbations applied during the stance phase of walking was used to calculate co-contraction.

Results

The involved limb had lower co-contraction pre-perturbation than the non-involved limb in both groups (p = 0.049). The co-contraction level post-perturbation was significantly higher in the limited return group than in the full return group (p = 0.03).

Conclusion

Decreased co-contraction in the involved limb before perturbation may be caused by sensorial changes resulting from surgery or injury. Increased co-contraction levels observed in the limited return group after perturbation may be a compensatory mechanism to make up for possible decreased intrinsic stability of the knee joint.

Clinical relevance

Increased co-contraction after perturbation does not contribute to knee stability.     

Alterations in quadriceps and hamstrings coordination in persons with medial compartment knee osteoarthritis

Altered muscle coordination strategies in persons with knee osteoarthritis (OA) result in an increase in co-contraction of the quadriceps and hamstrings during walking. While this may increase intersegmental joint contact force and expedite disease progression, it is not currently known whether the magnitude of co-contraction increases with a progressive loss of joint space or whether the level of co-contraction is dependent on walking speed. The purposes of this study were to (1) determine if co-contraction increased with OA severity and (2) discern whether differences in co-contraction were a result of altered freely chosen walking speeds or rather an inherent change associated with disease progression. Forty-two subjects with and without knee osteoarthritis were included in the study. Subjects were divided into groups based on disease severity. When walking at a controlled speed of 1.0 m/s, subjects with moderate and severe knee OA showed significantly higher co-contraction when compared to a healthy control group. At freely chosen walking speeds only the moderate OA group had significantly higher co-contraction values. Increased walking speed also resulted in a significant increase in co-contraction, regardless of group. The results of this study demonstrate that persons with knee OA develop higher antagonistic muscle activity. This occurs despite differences in freely chosen walking speed. Although subjects with OA had higher co-contraction than the control group, co-contraction may not increase with disease severity.     

Limb and sex-related differences in knee muscle co-contraction exist 3 months after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Interlimb and sex-based differences in gait mechanics and neuromuscular control are common after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR). Following ACLR, individuals typically exhibit elevated co-contraction of knee muscles, which may accelerate knee osteoarthritis (OA) onset. While directed (medial/lateral) co-contractions influence tibiofemoral loading in healthy people, it is unknown if directed co-contractions are present early after ACLR and if they differ across limbs and sexes. The purpose of this study was to compare directed co-contraction indices (CCIs) of knee muscles in both limbs between men and women after ACLR. Forty-five participants (27 men) completed overground walking at a self-selected speed 3 months after ACLR during which quadriceps, hamstrings, and gastrocnemii muscle activities were collected bilaterally using surface electromyography. CCIs of six muscle pairs were calculated during the weight acceptance interval. The CCIs of the vastus lateralis/biceps femoris muscle pair (lateral musculature) was greater in the involved limb (vs uninvolved; p = 0.02). Compared to men, women exhibited greater CCIs in the vastus medialis/lateral gastrocnemius and vastus lateralis/lateral gastrocnemius muscle pairs (p < 0.01 and p = 0.01, respectively). Limb- and sex-based differences in knee muscle co-contractions are detectable 3 months after ACLR and may be responsible for altered gait mechanics.     

Dual-task and anticipation impact lower limb biomechanics during a single-leg cut with body borne load

This study quantified how a dual cognitive task impacts lower limb biomechanics during anticipated and unanticipated single-leg cuts with body borne load. Twenty-four males performed anticipated and unanticipated cuts with and without a dual cognitive task with three load conditions: no load (∼6 kg), medium load (15% of BW), and heavy load (30% of BW). Lower limb biomechanics were submitted to a repeated measures linear mixed model to test the main and interaction effects of load, anticipation, and dual task. With body borne load, participants increased peak stance (PS) hip flexion (p = .004) and hip internal rotation (p = .001) angle, and PS hip flexion (p = .001) and internal rotation (p = .018), and knee flexion (p = .016) and abduction (p = .001) moments. With the dual task, participants decreased PS knee flexion angle (p < .001) and hip flexion moment (p = .027), and increased PS knee external rotation angle (p = .034). During the unanticipated cut, participants increased PS hip (p = .040) and knee flexion angle (p < .001), and decreased PS hip adduction (p = .001), and knee abduction (p = .005) and external rotation (p = .026) moments. Adding body borne load produces lower limb biomechanical adaptations thought to increase risk of musculoskeletal injury, but neither anticipation nor dual task exaggerated those biomechanical adaptations. With a dual task, participants adopted biomechanics known to increase injury risk; whereas, participants used lower limb biomechanics thought to decrease injury risk during unanticipated cuts.     

Impact of the EMG normalization method on muscle activation and the antagonist-agonist co-contraction index during active elbow extension: Practical implications for post-stroke subjects

Electromyographic (EMG) raw signals are sensitive to intrinsic and extrinsic factors. Consequently, EMG normalization is required to draw proper interpretations of standardized data. Specific recommendations are needed regarding a relevant EMG normalization method for participants who show atypical EMG patterns, such as post-stroke subjects. This study compared three EMG normalization methods (“isometric MVC”, “isokinetic MVC”, “isokinetic MVC kinematic-related”) on muscle activations and the antagonist-agonist co-contraction index. Fifteen post-stroke subjects and fifteen healthy controls performed active elbow extensions, followed by isometric and isokinetic maximum voluntary contractions (MVC). Muscle activations were obtained by normalizing EMG envelopes during active movement using a reference value determined for each EMG normalization method. The results showed no significant difference between the three EMG normalization methods in post-stroke subjects on muscle activation and the antagonist-agonist co-contraction index. We highlighted that the antagonist-agonist co-contraction index could underestimate the antagonist co-contraction in the presence of atypical EMG patterns. Based on its practicality and feasibility, we recommend the use of isometric MVC as a relevant procedure for EMG normalization in post-stroke subjects. We suggest combined analysis of the antagonist-agonist co-contraction index and agonist and antagonist activations to properly investigate antagonist co-contraction in the presence of atypical EMG patterns during movement.     

Velocity-dependent muscle strategy during plantarflexion in humans

This work examines the relative contribution of the triceps surae heads and the tibialis anterior (TA) to tension development with reference to voluntary plantarflexion at various velocities and at two articular positions of the knee joint (extended and flexed at 90 °). Subjects were instructed to perform plantarflexion at various submaximal and maximal velocities with no intention of stopping the movement. Voluntary electromyographic (EMG) activity was recorded and the amplitude, duration and integral were analysed. Integrated EMG (IEMG) was normalized with respect to duration. The maximal M wave and the Hoffmann (H) reflex elicited by electrical stimulation of the tibial nerve were recorded in the triceps surae to estimate the effects in gastrocnemii (G) length and motoneuron excitability differences, respectively, in the two knee positions. The results indicate that: (a) although the largest EMG activity was recorded in the extended limb, the greatest maximal velocities were performed in the flexed knee position; (b) with increasing velocity of movement, all triceps surae muscles showed enhanced IEMG activities; (c) at a low velocity of movement the soleus (So1)/G IEMG ratio was larger in the flexed compared to the extended knee; and (d) with increasing velocity, co-activation of agonist and antagonist muscles appeared. It is concluded that the larger maximal velocity of movement observed in the flexed compared to the extended knee was not primarily related to the neural command of the different triceps surae components, but rather to their mechanical properties. Furthermore, co-activation of agonist and antagonist muscles may contribute to the performance of the contractile strategy during rapid movements.     

Propulsion Phase of the Single Leg Triple Hop Test in Women with Patellofemoral Pain Syndrome: A Biomechanical Study

Asymmetry in the alignment of the lower limbs during weight-bearing activities is associated with patellofemoral pain syndrome (PFPS), caused by an increase in patellofemoral (PF) joint stress. High neuromuscular demands are placed on the lower limb during the propulsion phase of the single leg triple hop test (SLTHT), which may influence biomechanical behavior. The aim of the present cross-sectional study was to compare kinematic, kinetic and muscle activity in the trunk and lower limb during propulsion in the SLTHT using women with PFPS and pain free controls. The following measurements were made using 20 women with PFPS and 20 controls during propulsion in the SLTHT: kinematics of the trunk, pelvis, hip, and knee; kinetics of the hip, knee and ankle; and muscle activation of the gluteus maximus (GM), gluteus medius (GMed), biceps femoris (BF) and vastus lateralis (VL). Differences between groups were calculated using three separate sets of multivariate analysis of variance for kinematics, kinetics, and electromyographic data. Women with PFPS exhibited ipsilateral trunk lean; greater trunk flexion; greater contralateral pelvic drop; greater hip adduction and internal rotation; greater ankle pronation; greater internal hip abductor and ankle supinator moments; lower internal hip, knee and ankle extensor moments; and greater GM, GMed, BL, and VL muscle activity. The results of the present study are related to abnormal movement patterns in women with PFPS. We speculated that these findings constitute strategies to control a deficient dynamic alignment of the trunk and lower limb and to avoid PF pain. However, the greater BF and VL activity and the extensor pattern found for the hip, knee, and ankle of women with PFPS may contribute to increased PF stress.     

Co-activation of vastus lateralis and biceps femoris muscles in pubertal children and adults

Determining the mechanisms of co-activation around the knee joint with respect to age and sex is important in terms of our greater understanding of strength development. The purpose of this study was to examine the effects of age, sex and muscle action on moment of force and electromyographic (EMG) activity of the agonist and antagonist muscle groups during isokinetic eccentric and concentric knee extension and flexion. The study comprised nine pubertal boys [mean age 12.6 (SD 0.5) years], nine girls [12.7 (SD 0.5) years] nine adult men [23.1 (SD 2.1) years] and nine adult women [23.7 (SD 3.1) years] who performed maximal isometric eccentric and concentric efforts of knee extensors and flexors on a dynamometer at 30 degrees x s(-1). The moment of force and surface EMG activity of vastus lateralis and biceps femoris muscles were recorded. The moment of force:agonist averaged EMG (aEMG) ratios were calculated. The antagonist aEMG values were expressed as a percentage of the aEMG activity of the same muscle, at the same angle, angular velocity and muscle action when the muscle was acting as agonist. Three-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) designs indicated no significant effects of age or sex on moment:aEMG ratios. Eccentric ratios were significantly higher than the corresponding concentric ones (P < 0.05). The results also indicated no significant effect of age and sex on the aEMG of the vastus lateralis and biceps femoris muscles when acting as antagonists. The antagonist aEMG was significantly greater during concentric agonist efforts compared with the corresponding eccentric ones (P < 0.05). These findings would suggest that the moment exerted per unit of agonist EMG and the antagonist activity are similar in children compared with adults and are not sex dependent. Future comparisons between eccentric and concentric moments of force and agonist ENG should take into consideration the antagonist effects, irrespective of age or sex.     

The importance of quadriceps and hamstring muscle loading on knee kinematics and in-situ forces in the ACL

This study investigated the effect of hamstring co-contraction with quadriceps on the kinematics of the human knee joint and the in-situ forces in the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) during a simulated isometric extension motion of the knee. Cadaveric human knee specimens (n = 10) were tested using the robotic universal force moment sensor (UFS) system and measurements of knee kinematics and in-situ forces in the ACL were based on reference positions on the path of passive flexion/extension motion of the knee. With an isolated 200 N quadriceps load, the knee underwent anterior and lateral tibial translation as well as internal tibial rotation with respect to the femur. Both translation and rotation increased when the knee was flexed from full extension to 30 of flexion; with further flexion, these motion decreased. The addition of 80 N antagonistic hamstrings load significantly reduced both anterior and lateral tibial translation as well as internal tibial rotation at knee flexion angles tested except at full extension. At 30 of flexion, the anterior tibial translation, lateral tibial translation, and internal tibial rotation were significantly reduced by 18, 46, and 30%, respectively (p<0.05). The in-situ forces in the ACL under the quadriceps load were found to increase from 27.8+/-9.3 N at full extension to a maximum of 44.9+/-13.8 N at 15 of flexion and then decrease to 10 N beyond 60 of flexion. The in-situ force at 15 was significantly higher than that at other flexion angles (p<0.05). The addition of the hamstring load of 80 N significantly reduced the in-situ forces in the ACL at 15, 30 and 60 of flexion by 30, 43, and 44%, respectively (p<0.05). These data demonstrate that maximum knee motion may not necessarily correspond to the highest in-situ forces in the ACL. The data also suggest that hamstring co-contraction with quadriceps is effective in reducing excessive forces in the ACL particularly between 15 and 60 of knee flexion.     

Analyses of dynamic co-contraction level in individuals with anterior cruciate ligament injury.

BACKGROUND: A complete understanding of neural mechanisms by which ligament receptors may contribute to joint stability is not well established. It has been suggested that these receptors may be involved in a neuromuscular process related to the modulation of dynamic co-contraction, as a means of guaranteeing functional joint stability. HYPOTHESIS: Individuals with ACL injury have diminished dynamic co-contraction. STUDY DESIGN: Exploratory, cross-sectional design. METHODS: Ten subjects with unilateral ACL injury treated conservatively, and ten subjects without history of injury participated in the study. The co-contraction level was assessed through EMG recordings of the vastus lateralis and biceps femoris before and after a perturbation imposed on the subjects during a walking task. RESULTS: Subjects with ACL injury presented significantly lower co-contraction level pre-perturbation (p = 0.045) and post-perturbation (p = 0.046) than those in the control group. CONCLUSIONS: The bilateral decrease in muscular co-contraction presented by individuals with ACL injury suggests that ligament and joint receptors may be responsible for a bilateral dynamic increase in muscle and joint stiffness that could result in a greater joint stability. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: This study analyzed a neuromuscular mechanism that might contribute to the functional stability of the knee joint.     

The effects of core muscle activation on dynamic trunk position and knee abduction moments: Implications for ACL injury

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury is one of the most common serious lower-extremity injuries experienced by athletes participating in field and court sports and often occurs during a sudden change in direction or pivot. Both lateral trunk positioning during cutting and peak external knee abduction moments have been associated with ACL injury risk, though it is not known how core muscle activation influences these variables. In this study, the association between core muscle pre-activation and trunk position as well as the association between core muscle pre-activation and peak knee abduction moment during an unanticipated run-to-cut maneuver were investigated in 46 uninjured individuals. Average co-contraction indices and percent differences between muscle pairs were calculated prior to initial contact for internal obliques, external obliques, and L5 extensors using surface electromyography. Outside tilt of the trunk was defined as positive when the trunk was angled away from the cutting direction. No significant associations were found between pre-activations of core muscles and outside tilt of the trunk. Greater average co-contraction index of the L5 extensors was associated with greater peak knee abduction moment (p=0.0107). Increased co-contraction of the L5 extensors before foot contact could influence peak knee abduction moment by stiffening the spine, limiting sagittal plane trunk flexion (a motion pattern previously linked to ACL injury risk) and upper body kinetic energy absorption by the core during weight acceptance.     

Effects of Perturbations to Balance on Neuromechanics of Fast Changes in Direction during Locomotion

This study investigated whether the modular control of changes in direction while running is influenced by perturbations to balance. Twenty-two healthy men performed 90° side-step unperturbed cutting manoeuvres while running (UPT) as well as manoeuvres perturbed at initial contact (PTB, 10 cm translation of a moveable force platform). Surface EMG activity from 16 muscles of the supporting limb and trunk, kinematics, and ground reaction forces were recorded. Motor modules composed by muscle weightings and their respective activation signals were extracted from the EMG signals by non-negative matrix factorization. Knee joint moments, co-contraction ratios and co-contraction indexes (hamstrings/quadriceps) and motor modules were compared between UPT and PTB. Five motor modules were enough to reconstruct UPT and PTB EMG activity (variance accounted for UPT  = 92±5%, PTB = 90±6%). Moreover, higher similarities between muscle weightings from UPT and PTB (similarity = 0.83±0.08) were observed in comparison to the similarities between the activation signals that drive the temporal properties of the motor modules (similarity = 0.71±0.18). In addition, the reconstruction of PTB EMG from fixed muscle weightings from UPT resulted in higher reconstruction quality (82±6%) when compared to reconstruction of PTB EMG from fixed activation signals from UPT (59±11%). Perturbations at initial contact reduced knee abduction moments (7%), as well as co-contraction ratio (11%) and co-contraction index (12%) shortly after the perturbation onset. These changes in co-contraction ratio and co-contraction index were caused by a reduced activation of hamstrings that was also verified in the activation signals of the specific motor module related to initial contact. Our results suggested that perturbations to balance influence modular control of cutting manoeuvres, especially the temporal properties of muscle recruitment, due to altered afferent inputs to the motor patterns. Furthermore, reduced knee stability during perturbed events may be related to overall control of lower limb muscles.     

Lower limb joint stiffness and muscle co-contraction adaptations to instability footwear during locomotion

Unstable shoes (US) continually perturb gait which can train the lower limb musculature, but muscle co-contraction and potential joint stiffness strategies are not well understood. A shoe with a randomly perturbing midsole (IM) may enhance these adaptations. This study compares ankle and knee joint stiffness, and ankle muscle co-contraction during walking and running in US, IM and a control shoe in 18 healthy females. Ground reaction forces, three-dimensional kinematics and electromyography of the gastrocnemius medialis and tibialis anterior were recorded. Stiffness was calculated during loading and propulsion, derived from the sagittal joint angle-moment curves. Ankle co-contraction was analysed during pre-activation and stiffness phases. Ankle stiffness reduced and knee stiffness increased during loading in IM and US whilst walking (ankle, knee: p = 0.008, 0.005) and running (p < 0.001; p = 0.002). During propulsion, the opposite joint stiffness re-organisation was found in IM whilst walking (both joints p < 0.001). Ankle co-contraction increased in IM during pre-activation (walking: p = 0.001; running: p < 0.001), and loading whilst walking (p = 0.003), not relating to ankle stiffness. Results identified relative levels of joint stiffness change in unstable shoes, providing new evidence of how stability is maintained at the joint level.     

Ia presynaptic inhibition in human wrist extensor muscles: effects of motor task and cutaneous afferent activity.

The task-dependence of the presynaptic inhibition of the muscle spindle primary afferents in human forearm muscles was studied, focusing in particular on the modulation associated with the co-contraction of antagonist muscles and the activation of cutaneous afferents. The changes known to affect the motoneuron proprioceptive assistance during antagonist muscle co-activation in human leg and arm muscles were compared. The evidence available so far that these changes might reflect changes in the presynaptic inhibition of the muscle spindle afferent is briefly reviewed. The possible reasons for changes in presynaptic inhibition during the antagonist muscle co-contraction are discussed. Some new experiments on the wrist extensor muscles are briefly described. The results showed that the changes in the Ia presynaptic inhibition occurring during the co-contraction of the wrist flexor and extensor muscles while the hand cutaneous receptors were being activated (the subject's hand was clenched around a manipulandum) could be mimicked by contracting the wrist extensor muscles alone while applying extraneous stimulation to the hand cutaneous receptors. It is concluded that besides the possible contribution of inputs generated by the co-contraction of antagonist muscles and by supraspinal pathways, cutaneous inputs may play a major role in modulating the proprioceptive assistance during manipulatory movements.