Molecular structure and dynamics of the dimeric human small heat shock protein HSPB6

ATP-independent small heat-shock proteins (sHSPs) are an essential component of the cellular chaperoning machinery. Under both normal and stress conditions, sHSPs bind partially unfolded proteins and prevent their irreversible aggregation. Canonical vertebrate sHSPs, such as the α-crystallins, form large polydisperse oligomers from which smaller, functionally active subspecies dissociate. Here we focus on human HSPB6 which, despite having considerable homology to the α-crystallins in both the N-terminal region and the signature α-crystallin domain (ACD), only forms dimers in solution that represent the basic chaperoning subspecies. We addressed the three-dimensional structure and functional properties of HSPB6 in a hybrid study employing X-ray crystallography, solution small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), mutagenesis, size-exclusion chromatography and chaperoning assays. The crystal structure of a proteolytically stable fragment reveals typical ACD dimers which further form tetrameric assemblies as a result of extensive inter-dimer patching of the β4/β8 grooves. The patching is surprisingly mediated by tripeptide motifs, found in the N-terminal domain directly adjacent to the ACD, that are resembling but distinct from the canonical IxI sequence commonly binding this groove. By combining the crystal structure with SAXS data for the full-length protein, we derive a molecular model of the latter. In solution, HSPB6 shows a strong attractive self-interaction, a property that correlates with its chaperoning activity. Both properties are dictated by the unstructured yet compact N-terminal domain, specifically a region highly conserved across vertebrate sHSPs.     

pH-dependent structural modulation is conserved in the human small heat shock protein HSBP1

The holdase activity and oligomeric propensity of human small heat shock proteins (sHSPs) are regulated by environmental factors. However, atomic-level details are lacking for the mechanisms by which stressors alter sHSP responses. We previously demonstrated that regulation of HSPB5 is mediated by a single conserved histidine over a physiologically relevant pH range of 6.5–7.5. Here, we demonstrate that HSPB1 responds to pH via a similar mechanism through pH-dependent structural changes that are induced via protonation of the structurally analogous histidine. Results presented here show that acquisition of a positive charge, either by protonation of His124 or its substitution by lysine, reduces the stability of the dimer interface of the α-crystallin domain, increases oligomeric size, and modestly increases chaperone activity. Our results suggest a conserved mechanism of pH-dependent structural regulation among the human sHSPs that possess the conserved histidine, although the functional consequences of the structural modulations vary for different sHSPs.     

The small heat shock proteins and their role in human disease

Small heat shock proteins (sHSPs) function as molecular chaperones, preventing stress induced aggregation of partially denatured proteins and promoting their return to native conformations when favorable conditions pertain. Sequence similarity between sHSPs resides predominately in an internal stretch of residues termed the alpha-crystallin domain, a region usually flanked by two extensions. The poorly conserved N-terminal extension influences oligomer construction and chaperone activity, whereas the flexible C-terminal extension stabilizes quaternary structure and enhances protein/substrate complex solubility. sHSP polypeptides assemble into dynamic oligomers which undergo subunit exchange and they bind a wide range of cellular substrates. As molecular chaperones, the sHSPs protect protein structure and activity, thereby preventing disease, but they may contribute to cell malfunction when perturbed. For example, sHSPs prevent cataract in the mammalian lens and guard against ischemic and reperfusion injury due to heart attack and stroke. On the other hand, mutated sHSPs are implicated in diseases such as desmin-related myopathy and they have an uncertain relationship to neurological disorders including Parkinson's and Alzheimer's disease. This review explores the involvement of sHSPs in disease and their potential for therapeutic intervention.     

Three-dimensional structure of α-crystallin domain dimers of human small heat shock proteins HSPB1 and HSPB6

Small heat shock proteins (sHSPs) are a family of evolutionary conserved ATP-independent chaperones. These proteins share a common architecture defined by a signature α-crystallin domain (ACD) flanked by highly variable N- and C-terminal extensions. The ACD, which has an immunoglobulin-like fold, plays an important role in sHSP assembly. This domain mediates dimer formation of individual protomers, which then may assemble into larger oligomers. In vertebrate sHSPs, the dimer interface is formed by the symmetrical antiparallel pairing of two β-strands (β7), generating an extended β-sheet on one face of the ACD dimer. Recent structural studies of isolated ACDs from a number of vertebrate sHSPs suggest a variability in the register of the β7/β7 strand interface, which may, in part, give rise to the polydispersity often associated with the full-length proteins. To further analyze the structure of ACD dimers, we have employed a combination of X-ray crystallography and solution small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) to study the ACD-containing fragments of human HSPB1 (HSP27) and HSPB6 (HSP20). Unexpectedly, the obtained crystal structure of the HSPB1 fragment does not reveal the typical β7/β7 dimers but, rather, hexamers formed by an asymmetric contact between the β4 and the β7 strands from adjacent ACDs. Nevertheless, in solution, both ACDs form stable dimers via the symmetric antiparallel interaction of β7 strands. Using SAXS, we show that it is possible to discriminate between different putative registers of the β7/β7 interface, with the results indicating that, under physiological conditions, there is only a single register of the strands for both proteins.     

Characterization of rice small heat shock proteins targeted to different cellular organelles

Small heat shock proteins (sHSPs) are a family of ATP-independent molecular chaperones which prevent cellular protein aggregation by binding to misfolded proteins. sHSPs form large oligomers that undergo drastic rearrangement/dissociation in order to execute their chaperone activity in protecting substrates from stress. Substrate-binding sites on sHSPs have been predominantly mapped on their intrinsically disordered N-terminal arms. This region is highly variable in sequence and length across species, and has been implicated in both oligomer formation and in mediating chaperone activity. Here, we present our results on the functional and structural characterization of five sHSPs in rice, each differing in their subcellular localisation, viz., cytoplasm, nucleus, chloroplast, mitochondria and peroxisome. We performed activity assays and dynamic light scattering studies to highlight differences in the chaperone activity and quaternary assembly of sHSPs targeted to various organelles. By cloning constructs that differ in the length and sequence of the tag in the N-terminal region, we have probed the sensitivity of sHSP oligomer assembly and chaperone activity to the length and amino acid composition of the N-terminus. In particular, we have shown that the incorporation of an N-terminal tag has significant consequences on sHSP quaternary structure.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1007/s12192-015-0570-7) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Exploring the multifaceted roles of heat shock protein B8 (HSPB8) in diseases

HSPB8 is a member of ubiquitous small heat shock protein (sHSP) family, whose expression is induced in response to a wide variety of unfavorable physiological and environmental conditions. Investigation of HSPB8 structure indicated that HSPB8 belongs to the group of so-called intrinsically disordered proteins and possesses a highly flexible structure. Unlike most other sHSPs, HSPB8 tends to form small-molecular-mass oligomers and exhibits substrate-dependent chaperone activity. In cooperation with BAG3, the chaperone activity of HSPB8 was reported to be involved in the delivery of misfolded proteins to the autophagy machinery. Through this way, HSPB8 interferes with pathological processes leading to neurodegenerative diseases. Accordingly, published studies have identified genetic links between mutations of HSPB8 and some kind of neuromuscular diseases, further supporting its important role in neurodegenerative disorders. In addition to their anti-aggregation properties, HSPB8 is indicated to interact with a wide range of client proteins, modulating their maturations and activities, and therefore, regulates a large repertoire of cellular functions, including apoptosis, proliferation, inflammation and etc. As a result, HSPB8 has key roles in cancer biology, autoimmune diseases, cardiac diseases and cerebral vascular diseases.     

The N-terminal arm of small heat shock proteins is important for both chaperone activity and substrate specificity

Small heat shock proteins (sHSPs) are a ubiquitous class of molecular chaperones that interacts with substrates to prevent their irreversible insolubilization during denaturation. How sHSPs interact with substrates remains poorly defined. To investigate the role of the conserved C-terminal alpha-crystallin domain versus the variable N-terminal arm in substrate interactions, we compared two closely related dodecameric plant sHSPs, Hsp18.1 and Hsp16.9, and four chimeras of these two sHSPs, in which all or part of the N-terminal arm was switched. The efficiency of substrate protection and formation of sHSP-substrate complexes by these sHSPs with three different model substrates, firefly luciferase, citrate synthase, and malate dehydrogenase (MDH) provide new insights into sHSP/substrate interactions. Results indicate that different substrates have varying affinities for different domains of the sHSP. For luciferase and citrate synthase, the efficiency of substrate protection was determined by the identity of the N-terminal arm in the chimeric proteins. In contrast, for MDH, efficient protection clearly required interactions with the alpha-crystallin domain in addition to the N-terminal arm. Furthermore, we show that sHSP-substrate complexes with varying stability and composition can protect substrate equally, and substrate protection is not correlated with sHSP oligomeric stability for all substrates. Protection of MDH by the dimeric chimera composed of the Hsp16.9 N-terminal arm and Hsp18.1 alpha-crystallin domain supports the model that a dimeric form of the sHSP can bind and protect substrate. In total, results demonstrate that sHSP-substrate interactions are complex, likely involve multiple sites on the sHSP, and vary depending on substrate.     

Changes in oligomerization are essential for the chaperone activity of a small heat shock protein in vivo and in vitro

The ability of small heat shock proteins (sHSPs) to prevent thermal aggregation of other proteins may require disassembly and reassembly of sHSP oligomers. We investigated the role of changes in sHSP oligomerization by studying a mutant with reduced oligomeric stability. In HSP16.6, the single sHSP in the cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803, the mutation L66A causes oligomer instability and reduced chaperone activity in vitro. Because thermotolerance of Synechocystis depends on HSP16.6, a phenotype that is enhanced in a deltaClpB1 strain, the effect of mutations can also be assayed in vivo. L66A causes severe defects in thermotolerance, suggesting that oligomeric stability of sHSPs is required for cellular function. This hypothesis was supported by a selection for intragenic suppressors of L66A, which identified mutations that stabilize oligomers of both L66A and wild-type HSP16.6. Analysis of both over- and under-oligomerizing mutants suggests that sHSPs must disassemble before they can release substrates. Furthermore, the suppressor mutations not only restore in vivo activity to L66A, they also ameliorate chaperone defects in vitro, and thus provide the first direct evidence for a chaperone function of an sHSP in cellular thermotolerance.     

小热休克蛋白的结构和功能

小热休克蛋白（small heat shock protein,sHSP）几乎存在于所有生物体中,其主要结构是一个保守的α晶体蛋白(α-crystallin)结构域,由约90个氨基酸残基组成,与其相邻的是可变的N端域. N端域能够调节低聚体形成、亚单位动力学及其与底物的结合.sHSP能够与细胞内各组分（蛋白质、细胞核、细胞骨架元件、膜）进行相互作用,以维持细胞的稳定.小热休克蛋白家族成员的共同特点是特殊丝氨酸残基上的磷酸化,磷酸化作用对于受到胁迫时的细胞非常重要.由MAPKAP激酶 2/3和p38参与的级联反应能够诱导sHSP发生磷酸化,从而调节sHSP的低聚体状态,而低聚体状态和sHSP的生物学功能密切相关.本文介绍sHSP的结构特征和细胞内的作用底物,并讨论sHSP被不同的蛋白激酶磷酸化及磷酸化作用对低聚体状态和伴侣活性的影响.     

Truncation attenuates molecular chaperoning and apoptosis inhibition by p26, a small heat shock protein from Artemia franciscana

The small heat shock proteins (sHSPs), which prevent irreversible protein denaturation and inhibit apoptosis, consist of an amino-terminus, the canonical α-crystallin domain, and a carboxy-terminal extension. It remains difficult, however, to define sHSP structure-function relationships and with this in mind p26, an sHSP from the crustacean Artemia franciscana, was truncated by deletion mutagenesis. Wild-type p26 cDNA and three truncated variants inserted into the eukaryotic expression vector pcDNA3.1/HisC were used to generate stably transfected 293H cells. p26 shielded transfected cells against death upon exposure to heat and oxidative stress. Truncation reduced chaperone activity, with cells synthesizing the p26 α-crystallin domain being the least resistant. Wild-type p26 inhibited apoptosis in transfected cells, with protection against oxidation-generated apoptosis being more effective than that against heat-induced apoptosis. Truncation reduced p26 apoptotic inhibitory activity, with the α-crystallin domain again being the least effective. The results show that a crustacean sHSP functions effectively in mammalian cells, demonstrating interchangeability of these proteins between distantly related organisms and indicating similarities in their mechanisms of action. Moreover, maximal activity was observed for full-length p26, indicating that structural elements required for chaperone activity and apoptosis inhibition reside throughout the protein.     

Small heat-shock proteins function in the insoluble protein complex

Small heat-shock proteins (sHSPs) represent an abundant and ubiquitous family of molecular chaperones. The current model proposes that sHSPs function to prevent irreversible aggregation of non-native proteins by forming soluble complex. The chaperone activity of sHSPs is usually determined by the capacity to suppress thermally or chemically induced protein aggregation. However, sHSPs were frequently found in the insoluble complex particularly in vivo. In this report, it is clearly revealed that the insoluble sHSP/substrate complex is formed when sHSP is overloaded with non-native substrates, which is the very case under in vivo conditions. The proposal that sHSPs function to prevent the protein aggregation seems misleading. sHSPs appear to promote the elimination of protein aggregates by incorporating into the insoluble protein complex.     

Crystal structure of an activated variant of small heat shock protein Hsp16.5

How does the sequence of a single small heat shock protein (sHSP) assemble into oligomers of different sizes? To gain insight into the underlying structural mechanism, we determined the crystal structure of an engineered variant of Methanocaldococcus jannaschii Hsp16.5 wherein a 14 amino acid peptide from human heat shock protein 27 (Hsp27) was inserted at the junction of the N-terminal region and the α-crystallin domain. In response to this insertion, the oligomer shell expands from 24 to 48 subunits while maintaining octahedral symmetry. Oligomer rearrangement does not alter the fold of the conserved α-crystallin domain nor does it disturb the interface holding the dimeric building block together. Rather, the flexible C-terminal tail of Hsp16.5 changes its orientation relative to the α-crystallin domain which enables alternative packing of dimers. This change in orientation preserves a peptide-in-groove interaction of the C-terminal tail with an adjacent β-sandwich, thereby holding the assembly together. The interior of the expanded oligomer, where substrates presumably bind, retains its predominantly nonpolar character relative to the outside surface. New large windows in the outer shell provide increased access to these substrate-binding regions, thus accounting for the higher affinity of this variant to substrates. Oligomer polydispersity regulates sHSPs chaperone activity in vitro and has been implicated in their physiological roles. The structural mechanism of Hsp16.5 oligomer flexibility revealed here, which is likely to be highly conserved across the sHSP superfamily, explains the relationship between oligomer expansion observed in disease-linked mutants and changes in chaperone activity.     

Muscle develops a specific form of small heat shock protein complex composed of MKBP/HSPB2 and HSPB3 during myogenic differentiation

Previously, we identified a new mammalian sHSP, MKBP, as a myotonic dystrophy protein kinase-binding protein, and suggested its important role in muscle maintenance (Suzuki, A., Sugiyama, Y., Hayashi, Y., Nyu-i, N., Yoshida, M., Nonaka, I., Ishiura, S., Arahata, K., and Ohno, S. (1998) J. Cell Biol. 140, 1113-1124). In this paper, we develop the former work by performing extensive characterization of five of the six sHSPs so far identified, that is, HSP27, alphaB-crystallin, p20, MKBP/HSPB2, and HSPB3, omitting lens-specific alphaA-crystallin. Tissue distribution analysis revealed that although each sHSP shows differential constitutive expression in restricted tissues, tissues that express all five sHSPs are only muscle-related tissues. Especially, the expressions of HSPB3, identified for the first time as a 17-kDa protein in this paper, and MKBP/HSPB2 are distinctly specific to muscles. Moreover, these sHSPs form an oligomeric complex with an apparent molecular mass of 150 kDa that is completely independent of the oligomers formed by HSP27, alphaB-crystallin, and p20. The expressions of MKBP/HSPB2 and HSPB3 are induced during muscle differentiation under the control of MyoD, suggesting that the sHSP oligomer comprising MKBP/HSPB2 and HSPB3 represents an additional system closely related to muscle function. The functional divergence among sHSPs in different oligomers is also demonstrated in several ways: 1) an interaction with myotonic dystrophy protein kinase, which has been suggested to be important for the maintenance of myofibril integrity, was observed only for MKBP/HSPB2; 2) a myotube-specific association with actin bundles was observed for HSP27 and alphaB-crystallin, but not for MKBP/HSPB2; and 3) sHSPs whose mRNAs are induced by heat shock are alphaB-crystallin and HSP27. Taken together, the results suggest that muscle cells develop two kinds of stress response systems composed of diverged sHSP members, and that these systems work independently in muscle maintenance and differentiation.     

Binding determinants of the small heat shock protein, αB‐crystallin: recognition of the ‘IxI’ motif

Small heat shock proteins (sHSPs) play a central role in protein homeostasis under conditions of stress by binding partly unfolded, aggregate‐prone proteins and keeping them soluble. Like many sHSPs, the widely expressed human sHSP, αB‐crystallin (‘αB’), forms large polydisperse multimeric assemblies. Molecular interactions involved in both sHSP function and oligomer formation remain to be delineated. A growing database of structural information reveals that a central conserved α‐crystallin domain (ACD) forms dimeric building blocks, while flanking N‐ and C‐termini direct the formation of larger sHSP oligomers. The most commonly observed inter‐subunit interaction involves a highly conserved C‐terminal ‘IxI/V’ motif and a groove in the ACD that is also implicated in client binding. To investigate the inherent properties of this interaction, peptides mimicking the IxI/V motif of αB and other human sHSPs were tested for binding to dimeric αB‐ACD. IxI‐mimicking peptides bind the isolated ACD at 22°C in a manner similar to interactions observed in the oligomer at low temperature, confirming these interactions are likely to exist in functional αB oligomers.     

Insights into small heat shock protein and substrate structure during chaperone action derived from hydrogen/deuterium exchange and mass spectrometry

Small heat shock proteins (sHSPs) and the related alpha-crystallins are ubiquitous chaperones linked to neurodegenerative diseases, myopathies, and cataract. To better define their mechanism of chaperone action, we used hydrogen/deuterium exchange and mass spectrometry (HXMS) to monitor conformational changes during complex formation between the structurally defined sHSPs, pea PsHsp18.1, and wheat TaHsp16.9, and the heat-denatured model substrates malate dehydrogenase (MDH) and firefly luciferase. Remarkably, we found that even when complexed with substrate, the highly dynamic local structure of the sHSPs, especially in the N-terminal arm (>70% exchange in 5 s), remains unchanged. These results, coupled with sHSP-substrate complex stability, indicate that sHSPs do not adopt new secondary structure when binding substrate and suggest sHSPs are tethered to substrate at multiple sites that are locally dynamic, a feature that likely facilitates recognition and refolding of sHSP-bound substrate by the Hsp70/DnaK chaperone system. Both substrates were found to be stabilized in a partially unfolded state that is observed only in the presence of sHSP. Furthermore, peptide-level HXMS showed MDH was substantially protected in two core regions (residues 95-156 and 228-252), which overlap with the MDH structure protected in the GroEL-bound MDH refolding intermediate. Significantly, despite differences in the size and structure of TaHsp16.9-MDH and PsHsp18.1-MDH complexes, peptide-level HXMS patterns for MDH in both complexes are virtually identical, indicating that stabilized MDH thermal unfolding intermediates are not determined by the identity of the sHSP.     

Tsp36, a tapeworm small heat-shock protein with a duplicated alpha-crystallin domain, forms dimers and tetramers with good chaperone-like activity

Small heat shock proteins (sHSPs), which range in monomer size between 12 and 42 kDa, are characterized by a conserved C-terminal alpha-crystallin domain of 80-100 residues. They generally form large homo- or heteromeric complexes, and typically have in vitro chaperone-like activity, keeping unfolding proteins in solution. A special type of sHSP, with a duplicated alpha-crystallin domain, is present in parasitic flatworms (Platyhelminthes). Considering that an alpha-crystallin domain is essential for the oligomerization and chaperone-like properties of sHSPs, we characterized Tsp36 from the tapeworm Taenia saginata. Both wild-type Tsp36 and a mutant (Tsp36C-->R) in which the single cysteine has been replaced by arginine were expressed and purified. Far-UV CD measurements of Tsp36 were in agreement with secondary structure predictions, which indicated alpha-helical structure in the N-terminal region and the expected beta-sandwich structure for the two alpha-crystallin domains. Gel permeation chromatography and nano-ESI-MS showed that wild type Tsp36 forms dimers in a reducing environment, and tetramers in a non-reducing environment. The tetramers are stabilized by disulfide bridges involving a large proportion of the Tsp36 monomers. Tsp36C-->R exclusively occurs as dimers according to gel permeation chromatography, while the nondisulfide bonded fraction of wild type Tsp36 dissociates from tetramers into dimers under nonreducing conditions at increased temperature (43 degrees C). The tetrameric form of Tsp36 has a greater chaperone-like activity than the dimeric form.     

Structure, stability, and chaperone function of alphaA-crystallin: role of N-terminal region

Small heat shock protein alphaA-crystallin, the major protein of the eye lens, is a molecular chaperone. It consists of a highly conserved central domain flanked by the N-terminal and C-terminal regions. In this article we studied the role of the N-terminal domain in the structure and chaperone function of alphaA-crystallin. Using site directed truncation we raised several deletion mutants of alphaA-crystallin and their protein products were expressed in Escherichia coli. Size exclusion chromatography of these purified proteins showed that deletion from the N-terminal beyond the first 20 residues drastically reduced the oligomeric association of alphaA-crystallin and its complete removal resulted in a tetramer. Chaperone activity of alphaA-crystallin, determined by thermal and nonthermal aggregation and refolding assay, decreased with increasing length of deletion and little activity was observed for the tetramer. However it was revealed that N-terminal regions were not responsible for specific recognition of natural substrates and that low affinity substrate binding sites existed in other part of the molecule. The number of exposed hydrophobic sites and the affinity of binding hydrophobic probe bis-ANS as well as protein substrates decreased with N-terminal deletion. The stability of the mutant proteins decreased with increase in the length of deletion. The role of thermodynamic stability, oligomeric size, and surface hydrophobicity in chaperone function is discussed. Detailed analysis showed that the most important role of N-terminal region is to control the oligomerization, which is crucial for the stability and in vivo survival of this protein molecule.     

The function of the beta3 interactive domain in the small heat shock protein and molecular chaperone, human alphaB crystallin

Knowledge of the interactive domains on the surface of small heat shock proteins (sHSPs) is necessary for understanding the assembly of complexes and the activity as molecular chaperones. The primary sequences of 26 sHSP molecular chaperones were aligned and compared. In the interactive beta3 sequence, 73DRFSVNLDVKHFS85 of human alphaB crystallin, Ser-76, Asn-78, Lys-82, and His-83 were identified as nonconserved residues on the exposed surface of the alpha crystallin core domain. Site-directed mutagenesis produced the mutant alphaB crystallins: S76E, N78G, K82Q, and H83F. Domain swapping with homologous beta3 sequences, 32EKFEVGLDVQFFT44 from Caenorhabditis elegans sHSP12.2 or 69DKFVIFLDVKHFS81 from alphaA crystallin, resulted in the mutant alphaB crystallins, CE1 and alphaA1, respectively. Decreased chaperone activity was observed with the point mutants N78G, K82Q, and H83F and with the mutant, CE1, in aggregation assays using betaL crystallin, alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH), or citrate synthase (CS). The S76E mutant had minimal effect on chaperone activity, and domain swapping with alphaA crystallin had no effect on chaperone activity. The mutations that resulted in altered chaperone activity, produced minimal modification to the secondary, tertiary, and quaternary structure of human alphaB crystallin as determined by ultraviolet circular dichroism spectroscopy, chymotrypsin proteolysis, and size exclusion chromatography. Chaperone activity was influenced by the amount of unfolding of the target proteins and independent of complex size. The results characterized the importance of the exposed side chains of Glu-78, Lys-82, and His-83 in the interactive beta3 sequence of the alpha crystallin core domain in alphaB crystallin for chaperone function.     

Mutants in a small heat shock protein that affect the oligomeric state. Analysis and allele-specific suppression

Oligomerization is an essential property of small heat shock proteins (sHSPs) that appears to regulate their chaperone activity. We have examined the role of conserved hydrophobic residues that are postulated to stabilize sHSP oligomers. We identified a mutation of Synechocystis Hsp16.6 that impairs function in vivo and in vitro. The V143A mutation is in the C-terminal extension, a region predicted to form an oligomeric interaction with a hydrophobic region that includes the site of a previously characterized mutation, L66A. Both mutants were dimeric, but V143A had a stronger oligomerization defect than L66A. However, V143A protected a model substrate better than L66A. This suggests that although the two regions both play a role in oligomerization, they are not equivalent. Nevertheless, the addition of either dimeric sHSP enhanced the in vitro chaperone activity of wild type Hsp16.6, consistent with models that the sHSP dimers initiate interactions with substrates. Suppressor analysis of V143A identified mutations in the N terminus that restored activity by restabilizing the oligomer. These mutants were allele-specific and unable to suppress L66A, although they suppressed a dimeric C-terminal truncation of Hsp16.6. Conversely, suppressors of L66A were unable to suppress either V143A or the truncation, although they, like suppressors of V143A, stabilize the Hsp16.6 oligomer. We interpret these data as evidence that the mutations V143A and L66A stabilize two different dimeric structures and as further support that sHSP dimers are active species.