Confidence limits for estimates of gene linkage based on analysis of recombinant inbred strains

Recombinant inbred (RI) strains are extremely useful for genetic mapping. This paper presents a simple method for determining confidence intervals for linkage estimates based on analysis of RI strains. The results show that such confidence intervals are usually large with the currently available numbers of RI strains. Therefore, map positions based only on analysis of RI strains should be interpreted with caution. To facilitate interpretation of linkage data derived from RI strains, a table is presented giving the 95 percent and 99 percent confidence intervals for all possible linkages detected with up to 45 RI strains.     

Location of theSas-1 locus on mouse chromosome 1

Using three sets of recombinant inbred strains (BXD, BXH, and BXJ), we found the locus controlling an antigenic substance (Sas}-1) in murine serum to be closely linked to the Chromosome-1 marker,Dip-1. This linkage was confirmed by an analysis of backcross linkage. The BXD and backcross data suggest that the gene order isId-1-Dip-1-Sas-1-Mls. Data from the three sets of RI strains and the 32 backcross mice lead to the estimate that the recombination frequency betweenDip-1 andSas-1 is 0.030 ±0.015.     

An edited linkage map for the AXB and BXA recombinant inbred mouse strains

We have updated the history of the AXB and BXA recombinant inbred (RI) strains, typed additional loci, and edited the AXB, BXA RI database. Thirteen of the original 51 AXB and BXA RI strains are either extinct or genetically contaminated, leaving 33 living strains available from The Jackson Laboratory. However, we found a high degree of similarity among three sets of strains, indicating that these strains are not independent, which leaves 27 independent RI strains in the set. Accordingly, we modified the database by combining the AXB and BXA RI sets and eliminating strains that were genetically contaminated or extinct with no available DNA. We added 92 newly typed loci, retyped some questionable genotypings, and removed loci with excessive double crossovers or an insufficient number of typed strains. The edited strain distribution pattern (SDP) is available on the World Wide Web (WWW) (http://www.informatics.jax.org/riset.html) and now includes over 700 loci. Each locus is linked to adjacent loci with a LOD score of at least 3.0 with a few described exceptions. We also carried out a second editing designed for the analysis of quantitative trait loci by deleting extinct strains and loci with identical SDPs; this edited database is also available on the WWW. Received: 20 March 1998 / Accepted: 26 May 1998     

Typing recombinant inbred mouse strains for microsatellite markers on Chromosomes 10, 16, 18, 19, and X

A total of 57 different microsatellite variants have been typed in one or more of five different sets of recombinant inbred (RI) mouse strains. The present report concentrates on markers for Chromosomes (Chrs) 10, 16, 18, 19 and X. These markers extend the regions swept in these RI strains, provide reference markers for integrating RI and conventional maps, and provide additional estimates of genetic distances. Multilocus maps, based on maximum likelihood analysis of present and previously published RI SDPs on five chromosomes, are presented. Unexpectedly, three microsatellite markers, previously assigned to Chr 10, detected polymorphic fragments mapping to other chromosomes.     

The genetic structure of recombinant inbred mice: High-resolution consensus maps for complex trait analysis

Background

Recombinant inbred (RI) strains of mice are an important resource used to map and analyze complex traits. They have proved particularly effective in multidisciplinary genetic studies. Widespread use of RI strains has been hampered by their modest numbers and by the difficulty of combining results derived from different RI sets.

Results

We have increased the density of typed microsatellite markers 2- to 5-fold in each of several major RI sets that share C57BL/6 as a parental strain (AXB, BXA, BXD, BXH, and CXB). A common set of 490 markers was genotyped in just over 100 RI strains. Genotypes of another ~1100 microsatellites were generated, collected, and error checked in one or more RI sets. Consensus RI maps that integrate genotypes of ~1600 microsatellite loci were assembled. The genomes of individual strains typically incorporate 45-55 recombination breakpoints. The collected RI set - termed the BXN set - contains approximately 5000 breakpoints. The distribution of recombinations approximates a Poisson distribution and distances between breakpoints average about 0.5 cM. Locations of most breakpoints have been defined with a precision of < 2 cM. Genotypes deviate from Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium in only a small number of intervals.

Conclusions

Consensus maps derived from RI strains conform almost precisely with theoretical expectation and are close to the length predicted by the Haldane-Waddington equation (X3.6 for a 2-3 cM interval between markers). Non-syntenic associations among different chromosomes introduce predictable distortions in QTL data sets that can be partly corrected using two-locus correlation matrices.     

A new framework marker-based linkage map and SDPs for the Rat HXB/BXH strain set

A new contiguous genetic linkage map of the HXB/BXH set of rat recombinant inbred (RI) strains was constructed to enhance QTL mapping power and precision, and thereby make the RI strain set a better genomics resource. The HXB/BXH rat RI strains were developed from a cross between the hypertensive SHR/OlaIpcv and normotensive BN-Lx/Cub rat strains and have been shown useful for identifying quantitative trait loci (QTL) for a variety of cardiovascular, metabolic, and behavioral phenotypes. In the current analysis, the DNAs from 31 existing strains, 1 substrain, and 4 extinct strains were genotyped for a selection of polymorphic microsatellite marker loci, predominantly polymorphic framework markers from high-density integrated rat genome maps. The resulting linkage map consists of 245 microsatellite markers spanning a total length of 1789 cM with an average inter-marker distance of ~8.0 cM. This map covers the rat genome contiguously and completely with the exception of two locations on Chromosomes (Chrs) 11 and 16. The new genotypic information obtained also permitted further genetic characterization of the RI strain set including strain independence, genetic similarity among the individual strains, and non-syntenic associations between loci.     

Use of AFLP Markers for Gene Mapping and QTL Detection in the Rat

The AFLP technique is a new DNA marker technology based on the selective amplification of restriction fragments. Multiple polymorphic markers are simultaneously produced and can be tested in one PCR. No prior information on genomic DNA sequences is needed. In the current study, we contribute 18 AFLP markers to the linkage map of the rat. Seven AFLP markers were assigned to specific chromosomes by analysis of a (BN × ACI)F1 × ACI backcross progeny. Another 11 AFLP markers were mapped by using a panel of the H × B/B × H recombinant inbred (RI) strains. Genotypes of these AFLP markers were also tested for correlations with some blood pressure phenotypes in the RI strains. Suggestive correlation was found between the mean arterial pressure and two closely linked AFLP markers located on chromosome 20. The current study illustrates the value of AFLP markers for the construction of linkage maps and the detection of quantitative trait loci.     

Limitation of Number of Strains and Persistence of False Positive Loci in QTL Mapping Using Recombinant Inbred Strains

While the identification of causal genes of quantitative trait loci (QTL) remains a difficult problem in the post-genome era, the number of QTL continues to accumulate, mainly identified using the recombinant inbred (RI) strains. Over the last decade, hundreds of publications have reported nearly a thousand QTL identified from RI strains. We hypothesized that the inaccuracy of most of these QTL makes it difficult to identify causal genes. Using data from RI strains derived from C57BL/6J (B6) X DBA/2J (D2), we tested the possibility of detection of reliable QTL with different numbers of strains in the same trait in five different traits. Our results indicated that studies using RI strains of less than 30 in general have a higher probability of failing to detect reliable QTL. Errors in many studies could include false positive loci, switches between QTL with small and major effects, and missing the real major loci. The similar data was obtained from a RI strain population derived from a different pair of parents and a RI strain population of rat. Thus, thousands of reported QTL from studies of RI strains may need to be double-checked for accuracy before proceeding to causal gene identification.     

Establishment of a molecular genetic map of distal mouse chromosome 1: further definition of a conserved linkage group syntenic with human chromosome 1q

A linkage map of distal mouse chromosome 1 was constructed by restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis of DNAs from seven sets of recombinant inbred (RI) strains. The data obtained with seven probes on Southern hybridization combined with data from previous studies suggest the gene order Cfh, Pep-3/Ren-1,2, Ly-5, Lamb-2, At-3, Apoa-2/Ly-17,Spna-1. These results confirm and extend analyses of a large linkage group which includes genes present on a 20-30 cM span of mouse chromosome 1 and those localized to human chromosome 1q21-32. Moreover, the data indicate similar relative positions of human and mouse complement receptor-related genes REN, CD45, LAMB2, AT3, APOA2, and SPTA. These results suggest that mouse gene analyses may help in detailed mapping of human genes within such a syntenic group.     

The genetic structure of recombinant inbred mice: high-resolution consensus maps for complex trait analysis

Background  

Recombinant inbred (RI) strains of mice are an important resource used to map and analyze complex traits. They have proved particularly effective in multidisciplinary genetic studies. Widespread use of RI strains has been hampered by their modest numbers and by the difficulty of combining results derived from different RI sets.     

Analysis of oocyte quality in recombinant inbred mouse strains developed from KE and CBA strains that differ in fertilization efficiency

Recombinant inbred (RI) mouse strains were developed from reciprocal crosses between two inbred strains differing in the proportion of fertilized ova (CBA, 100%; KE, 77%), to analyse the underlying factors. A correlation (r = 0.83, P < 0.01) between fertilization efficiency within 22 RI strains and after mating RI females with KE males proved that oocyte quality was involved. The following oocyte parameters were analysed in RI and progenitor strains: time of meiotic maturation, rapidity of enzymatic removal of egg investments, and proportion of fertilized ova with supplementary spermatozoa in the perivitelline space. Among the RI strains, high incidence of supplementary spermatozoa was correlated with lower efficiency of fertilization (r = -0.58, P < 0.05) and with slow meiotic maturation (r = -64, P < 0.01), suggesting that delayed maturation may affect oocyte ability of being fertilized by the first penetrating spermatozoon. However, significant correlations were also found between characters which coexist within the progenitor strains, but are not likely to be physiologically related; this suggests that RI strains have inherited large blocks of progenitor genomes, not disrupted by recombination. The strain distribution pattern (SDP) of the analysed traits revealed CBA-like, KE-like, and intermediate phenotypes, indicating that they are polygenically determined. No linkages were found between the studied traits and 12 enzymatic markers. However, the SDP for fertilization efficiency showed a preponderance of non-matching strains (15/19) in relation to agouti locus; the known instability of this chromosome region makes it possible that a putative linkage was disrupted by recombination when RI strains were created.     

Esterase-16 (ES-16) of the rat (Rattus norvegicus): Identification and genetic characterization

Esterase-16, an esterase present in lung and other tissues of the laboratory rat, has been characterized by its biochemical properties (electrophoretic mobility, substrate pattern, sensitivity to inhibitors) and genetic variation in 107 inbred strains and substrains including 14 RI strains. It was classified as a carboxylesterase (EC 3.1.1.1). The phenotype ES-16A (BN/Han and 63 other strains) was defined as a narrow electrophoretic band migrating between ES-1A and ES-13A, ES-16B (LEW/Han and 42 other strains) exhibited the same electrophoretic mobility as ES-16A but was distinguished by its extremely weak activity. Segregation of ES-16 in RI strains and backcrosses indicated linkage to linkage group V (LGV). The Es-16 locus was tentatively placed into esterase cluster 2 and homology with Es-7 of the house mouse is proposed.     

Use of recombinant inbred strains to map genes of aging

Recombinant inbred strains have been used in a number of organisms for segregation and linkage analysis of quantitative traits. One major advantage of the recombinant inbred (RI) methodology is that the genetic identity of individuals within a strain permits replicate measures of the same recombinant genotype. Such replicability is important for traits such as aging inDrosophila, where phenotypic expression is highly influenced by different environmental conditions. RI strain methodology has an added advantage for DNA marker-based linkage analysis of traits measured over the lifespan of the organism. The DNA can be extracted from individuals of the same genotype as those measured in a longevity study. In this paper an argument is presented for the use of a set of recombinant inbred strains to map the quantitative trait loci involved in the aging process inDrosophila. A unique use of a set of stable, transposable moleular markers to trace the quantitative trait loci involved is suggested.     

Genetic loci for diet-induced atherosclerotic lesions and plasma lipids in mice

Genetic factors independent of those affecting plasma lipid levels are a major contributor to risk for atherosclerosis in humans, yet the basis for these is poorly understood. This study examined plasma lipids and diet-induced atherosclerosis in 16-month-old female mice of strains C56BL/6J and DBA/2J. Mice of the parental strains, from recombinant inbred strains derived from these (BXD RI), and F₂ progeny were fed an atherogenic diet for 16 weeks, beginning at 1 year of age. This induced atherosclerotic lesion formation in both parental strains, accompanied by increased plasma LDL levels. However, individual BXD RI strains and the BXD F₂ mice demonstrated a range of atherosclerotic lesion formation that was not or at best weakly correlated with plasma lipid levels. Quantitative trait locus (QTL) analysis of the BXD F₂ mice identified a locus with significant linkage (lod 4.5) for aortic lesion size on Chromosome (Chr) 10 that was independent of plasma lipids. Other loci with suggestive or significant linkage for various plasma lipid measures were identified on Chr 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 11, and 17. In this intercross, the genes primarily influencing atherosclerosis are distinct from those controlling plasma lipid levels.     

Host defenses in experimental scrub typhus: mapping the gene that controls natural resistance in mice

Natural resistance of mice to lethal ifections of Rickettsia tsutsugamushi, strain Gilliam, is controlled by a single, autosomal, dominant gene, which we have designated Ric, with r and s representing the resistant nd susceptible alleles, respectively. Using three sets of recombinant inbred mouse strains (BXD, BXH, and BXJ), the Ric locus was mapped to Chromosome 5 closely linked to the retinal degeneration (rd) locus. This linkage was confirmed by a backcross analysis. Based on the RI strains and the C57BL/6Ty-le congenic strain (the only proven Ric-rd cross-over), we estimate the recombination frequency between Ric and rd to be 0.015. Three presumptive Ric-rd recombinants detected among 93 backcross mice may represent caes of incomplete penetrance of the resistance allele rather than recombination. Analyis of th C57BL/6JTy-le congenic strain indicates that Ric is proximal to rd on Chromosome 5. If so, the correct gene order is Pgm-1-W-Ric-rd-Gus.     

Evaluation of LEXF/FXLE rat recombinant inbred strains for genetic dissection of complex traits.

Recombinant inbred (RI) strains are formed from an outcross between two well-characterized inbred stains followed by at least 20 generations of inbreeding. RI strains can be utilized for the analysis of many complex phenotypic traits. The LEXF/FXLE RI strain set consists of 34 RI strains derived by reciprocal crossing of LE/Stm and F344/Stm. Here we report on genetic dissections of complex traits using this RI set and their parental strains. We have developed strain distribution patterns for 232 informative simple sequence length polymorphism markers. The framework map covers the rat genome except for chromosome Y. Seventy-six phenotype parameters, which included physiological and behavioral traits, were examined for these RI lines. Quantitative trait locus (QTL) analysis of these parameters revealed 27 significant and 91 suggestive QTLs, illustrating the potential of this RI resource for the detection of underlying gene functions for various phenotypes. Although this RI set was originally developed to study susceptibility to chemical-induced tumors, it has been shown to be equally powerful for a wide spectrum of traits. The LEXF/FXLE RI strains have been deposited at the National Bio Resource Project for the Rat in Japan and are maintained under specific pathogen-free conditions. They are available at http://www.anim.med.kyoto-u.ac.jp/nbr.     

Typing recombinant inbred mouse strains for microsatellite markers

In total, 41 different microsatellite variants have been typed in one or more of four different sets of recombinant inbred (RI) mouse strains. Microsatellite variants were selected that were located in chromosomal regions previously lacking markers. These markers extend the regions swept in these RI strains.     

Linkage of loci affecting a murine liver protein and arylsulfatase B to chromosome 13

As-1 is the putative structural locus for murine arylsulfatase B, and Lth-1 determines the presence or absence of a 35 000 dalton acidic liver protein. As-1 and Lth-1 were found to be closely linked using recombinant inbred (RI) strains. Both loci were found to have been cotransferred with the pearl (pe) coat color mutation (chromosome 13) in the B6.C3H pe/pe congenic strain. The linkage relationships between pe, Lth-1, and As-1 were further defined in a backcross. On the basis of the RI data, the congenic strain result, and the backcross data, the following genetic distances were estimated: pe--As-1, 7.1 +/- 4.0 cM; As-1--Lth-1, 2.5 +/- 1.0 cM; and pe--Lth-1, less than 6.9 cM. As-1 and Lth-1 are the first biochemically defined loci to be added to the chromosome 13 linkage map.     

Genetic heterogeneity of plasma lipoproteins in the mouse: control of low density lipoprotein particle sizes by genetic factors

In order to assess the genetic control of sizes and concentrations of mouse plasma low density (LDL) and high density lipoproteins (HDL), we used gel permeation fast protein liquid chromatography (FPLC) and nondenaturing gradient polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis to measure the particle sizes of LDL and HDL. Using chromatography we also quantified LDL-cholesterol and HDL-cholesterol concentrations in plasma and used them as indexes of plasma concentrations of the respective particles among 10 inbred strains (AKR/J, BALB/cByJ, C3H/HeJ, C57BL/6J, C57BL/6ByJ, C57L/J, DBA/1LacJ, 129/J, NZB/BINJ, SWR/J) and three sets of recombinant inbred (RI) strains (AKXL/TyJ, BXH/TyJ, CXB/ByJ) of mice. HDL had a dichotomous distribution among the 10 inbred strains. One group had large HDL particle sizes and high HDL-cholesterol concentrations. Another group had smaller HDL particles and lower HDL-cholesterol concentrations, and HDL sizes and HDL-cholesterol concentrations were significantly correlated. In the RI strains, HDL sizes and HDL-cholesterol cholesterol concentrations clearly segregated with one or another of the progenitor strains, and RI strain distributions showed a strong linkage to the apolipoprotein (apo) A-II gene (Apoa-2). In contrast, LDL-cholesterol concentrations and particle sizes on FPLC did not show dichotomous distributions among the 10 inbred strains. In RI strains, the configuration of the LDL FPLC profiles and LDL-cholesterol concentrations did resemble one or another of the progenitors in the majority of cases, but LDLs of several RI strains resembled neither progenitor strain in profile configuration, and LDL-cholesterol concentrations were both greater and smaller than those of progenitor strains. However, LDL particle diameters (as judged by peaks of LDL-cholesterol profiles) did segregate with progenitors in 29/33 (88%) of RI strains suggesting that a major gene may affect LDL size. In attempting to identify a major LDL-size determining gene, we compared apoB gene restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) to the distributions of peak LDL sizes in RI strains. Concordance rates of peak LDL sizes to apoB gene polymorphisms were 18/22 (82%) for the EcoRV RFLP, 5/7 (71%) for HindIII RFLP, and 23/29 (79%) for both (range of P values 0.90-0.95). Thus we could not unequivocally implicate the apoB gene in determining the size of LDL particles. In summary, the genetic control of LDL sizes is more complicated than is the case for HDL; however, the differences in LDL size among these strains of mice may be controlled by a major, as yet unidentified, gene.