Cofactor binding protects flavodoxin against oxidative stress

In organisms, various protective mechanisms against oxidative damaging of proteins exist. Here, we show that cofactor binding is among these mechanisms, because flavin mononucleotide (FMN) protects Azotobacter vinelandii flavodoxin against hydrogen peroxide-induced oxidation. We identify an oxidation sensitive cysteine residue in a functionally important loop close to the cofactor, i.e., Cys69. Oxidative stress causes dimerization of apoflavodoxin (i.e., flavodoxin without cofactor), and leads to consecutive formation of sulfinate and sulfonate states of Cys69. Use of 7-chloro-4-nitrobenzo-2-oxa-1,3-diazole (NBD-Cl) reveals that Cys69 modification to a sulfenic acid is a transient intermediate during oxidation. Dithiothreitol converts sulfenic acid and disulfide into thiols, whereas the sulfinate and sulfonate forms of Cys69 are irreversible with respect to this reagent. A variable fraction of Cys69 in freshly isolated flavodoxin is in the sulfenic acid state, but neither oxidation to sulfinic and sulfonic acid nor formation of intermolecular disulfides is observed under oxidising conditions. Furthermore, flavodoxin does not react appreciably with NBD-Cl. Besides its primary role as redox-active moiety, binding of flavin leads to considerably improved stability against protein unfolding and to strong protection against irreversible oxidation and other covalent thiol modifications. Thus, cofactors can protect proteins against oxidation and modification.     

A chemical approach for detecting sulfenic acid-modified proteins in living cells

Oxidation of the thiol functional group in cysteine (Cys-SH) to sulfenic (Cys-SOH), sulfinic (Cys-SO2H) and sulfonic acids (Cys-SO3H) is emerging as an important post-translational modification that can activate or deactivate the function of many proteins. Changes in thiol oxidation state have been implicated in a wide variety of cellular processes and correlate with disease states but are difficult to monitor in a physiological setting because of a lack of experimental tools. Here, we describe a method that enables live cell labeling of sulfenic acid-modified proteins. For this approach, we have synthesized the probe DAz-1, which is chemically selective for sulfenic acids and cell permeable. In addition, DAz-1 contains an azide chemical handle that can be selectively detected with phosphine reagents via the Staudinger ligation for identification, enrichment and visualization of modified proteins. Through a combination of biochemical, mass spectrometry and immunoblot approaches we characterize the reactivity of DAz-1 and highlight its utility for detecting protein sulfenic acids directly in mammalian cells. This novel method to isolate and identify sulfenic acid-modified proteins should be of widespread utility for elucidating signaling pathways and regulatory mechanisms that involve oxidation of cysteine residues.     

Sulfenic acid chemistry,detection and cellular lifetime

Background

Reactive oxygen species-mediated cysteine sulfenic acid modification has emerged as an important regulatory mechanism in cell signaling. The stability of sulfenic acid in proteins is dictated by the local microenvironment and ability of antioxidants to reduce this modification. Several techniques for detecting this cysteine modification have been developed, including direct and in situ methods.

Scope of review

This review presents a historical discussion of sulfenic acid chemistry and highlights key examples of this modification in proteins. A comprehensive survey of available detection techniques with advantages and limitations is discussed. Finally, issues pertaining to rates of sulfenic acid formation, reduction, and chemical trapping methods are also covered.

Major conclusions

Early chemical models of sulfenic acid yielded important insights into the unique reactivity of this species. Subsequent pioneering studies led to the characterization of sulfenic acid formation in proteins. In parallel, the discovery of oxidant-mediated cell signaling pathways and pathological oxidative stress has led to significant interest in methods to detect these modifications. Advanced methods allow for direct chemical trapping of protein sulfenic acids directly in cells and tissues. At the same time, many sulfenic acids are short-lived and the reactivity of current probes must be improved to sample these species, while at the same time, preserving their chemical selectivity. Inhibitors with binding scaffolds can be rationally designed to target sulfenic acid modifications in specific proteins.

General significance

Ever increasing roles for protein sulfenic acids have been uncovered in physiology and pathology. A more complete understanding of sulfenic acid-mediated regulatory mechanisms will continue to require rigorous and new chemical insights. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled Current methods to study reactive oxygen species - pros and cons and biophysics of membrane proteins. Guest Editor: Christine Winterbourn.     

Copper dependence of the biotin switch assay: modified assay for measuring cellular and blood nitrosated proteins

Studies have shown that modification of critical cysteine residues in proteins leads to the regulation of protein function. These modifications include disulfide bond formation, glutathionylation, sulfenic and sulfinic acid formation, and S-nitrosation. The biotin switch assay was developed to specifically detect protein S-nitrosation (S. R. Jaffrey et al., Nat. Cell Biol. 3:193-197; 2001). In this assay, proteins are denatured with SDS in the presence of methyl methane thiosulfonate (MMTS) to block free thiols. After acetone precipitation or Sephadex G25 separation to remove excess MMTS, HPDP-biotin and 1 mM ascorbate are added to reduce the S-nitrosothiol bonds and label the reduced thiols with biotin. The proteins are then separated by nonreducing SDS PAGE and detected using either streptavidin-HRP or anti-biotin-HRP conjugate. Our examination of this labeling scheme has revealed that the extent of labeling depends on the buffer composition and, importantly, on the choice of metal-ion chelator (DTPA vs EDTA). Unexpectedly, using purified S-nitrosated albumin, we have found that "contaminating" copper is required for the ascorbate-dependent degradation of S-nitrosothiol; this is consistent with the fact that ascorbate itself does not rapidly reduce S-nitrosothiols. Removal of copper from buffers by DTPA and other copper chelators preserves approximately 90% of the S-nitrosothiol, whereas the inclusion of copper and ascorbate completely eliminates the S-nitrosothiol in the preparation and increases the specific biotin labeling. These biotin switch experiments were confirmed using triiodide-based and copper-based reductive chemiluminescence. Additional modifications of the assay using N-ethylmaleimide for thiol blockade, ferricyanide pretreatment to stabilize S-nitrosated hemoglobin, and cyanine dye labeling instead of biotin are presented for the measurement of cellular and blood S-nitrosothiols. These results indicate that degradation of S-nitrosothiol in the standard biotin switch assay is metal-ion dependent and that experimental variability in S-nitrosothiol yields using this assay occurs secondary to the inclusion of metal-ion chelators in reagents and variable metal-ion contamination of buffers and labware. The addition of copper to ascorbate allows for a simple assay modification that dramatically increases sensitivity while maintaining specificity.     

A critical evaluation of probes for cysteine sulfenic acid

Cysteine oxidation is important in cellular redox regulation, signaling, and biocatalysis. To understand the biological relevance of cysteine oxidation, it is desirable to identify the proteins involved, the site of the oxidized cysteine, and the relevant oxidation states. Because the thiol of cysteine can be converted to a wide range of oxidation states, mapping these oxidative modifications is challenging. The dynamic and reversible nature of many cysteine oxidation states compounds the difficulty in such proteomic analyses. In this review, we examine methods to detect cysteine sulfenic acid — a particularly challenging functional group to analyze because of its reactive nature. We focus on the selectivity of recently reported probes and discuss some challenges and opportunities in this field.     

RegB Kinase Activity Is Repressed by Oxidative Formation of Cysteine Sulfenic Acid

RegB/RegA comprise a global redox-sensing signal transduction system utilized by a wide range of proteobacteria to sense environmental changes in oxygen tension. The conserved cysteine 265 in the sensor kinase RegB was previously reported to form an intermolecular disulfide bond under oxidizing conditions that converts RegB from an active dimer into an inactive tetramer. In this study, we demonstrate that a stable sulfenic acid (-SOH) derivative also forms at Cys-265 in vitro and in vivo when RegB is exposed to oxygen. This sulfenic acid modification is reversible and stable in the air. Autophosphorylation assay shows that reduction of the SOH at Cys-265 to a free thiol (SH) can increase RegB kinase activity in vitro. Our results suggest that a sulfenic acid modification at Cys-265 performs a regulatory role in vivo and that it may be the major oxidation state of Cys-265 under aerobic conditions. Cys-265 thus functions as a complex redox switch that can form multiple thiol modifications in response to different redox signals to control the kinase activity of RegB.     

Nitric oxide stress induces different responses but mediates comparable protein thiol protection in Bacillus subtilis and Staphylococcus aureus

The nonpathogenic Bacillus subtilis and the pathogen Staphylococcus aureus are gram-positive model organisms that have to cope with the radical nitric oxide (NO) generated by nitrite reductases of denitrifying bacteria and by the inducible NO synthases of immune cells of the host, respectively. The response of both microorganisms to NO was analyzed by using a two-dimensional gel approach. Metabolic labeling of the proteins revealed major changes in the synthesis pattern of cytosolic proteins after the addition of the NO donor MAHMA NONOate. Whereas B. subtilis induced several oxidative stress-responsive regulons controlled by Fur, PerR, OhrR, and Spx, as well as the general stress response controlled by the alternative sigma factor SigB, the more resistant S. aureus showed an increased synthesis rate of proteins involved in anaerobic metabolism. These data were confirmed by nuclear magnetic resonance analyses indicating that NO causes a drastically higher increase in the formation of lactate and butanediol in S. aureus than in B. subtilis. Monitoring the intracellular protein thiol state, we observed no increase in reversible or irreversible protein thiol modifications after NO stress in either organism. Obviously, NO itself does not cause general protein thiol oxidations. In contrast, exposure of cells to NO prior to peroxide stress diminished the irreversible thiol oxidation caused by hydrogen peroxide.     

Measurement and meaning of cellular thiol:disufhide redox status

The functional group of cysteine is a thiol group (SH) that, due to its chemical reactivity, is able to undergo a wide array of modifications each with the potential to confer a different property or function to the molecule harboring this residue. Most of these modifications involve the reversible oxidation of the thiol to sulfenic acid (SOH), and disulfide, including intra- and intermolecular disulfides between polypeptides and glutathione (glutathionylation). The reversibility of these oxidations allows thiol groups to serve as versatile chemical and structural transducing elements in several low molecular mass metabolites and proteins. A plethora of cellular functions such as DNA and protein synthesis, protein secretion, cytoskeleton architecture, differentiation, apoptosis, and anti-oxidant defense, are recognized to be modulated, at certain stage, by thiol–disulfide exchange mechanisms of redox active thiol groups. All organisms are equipped with enzymatic systems composed by NADPH-dependent reductases, redoxins, and peroxidases that provide kinetic control of global thiol-redox homeostasis as well as target selectivity. These redox systems are distributed in different subcellular compartments and are not in equilibrium with each other. In consequence, measuring cellular thiol–disulfide status represents a challenge for studies aimed to obtain dynamic and spatio-temporal resolution. This review provides a summary of the methods and tools available to quantify the thiol redox status of cells.     

Oxidative stress of human erythrocytes by iodate and periodate. Reversible formation of aqueous membrane pores due to SH-group oxidation

Human erythrocytes were exposed to oxidative stress by iodate and periodate. Oxidation causes a time- and concentration-dependent increase in membrane permeability for hydrophilic molecules and ions. The induced leak discriminates nonelectrolytes on the basis of molecular size and exhibits a very low activation energy (Ea = 1-4 kcal.mol-1). These results are reconcilable with the formation of aqueous pores. The pore size was approximated to be between 0.45 and 0.6 nm. This increase in permeability is reversible upon treatment with dithioerythritol. Blocking of membrane thiol groups with N-ethylmaleimide protects the membranes against leak formation. The oxidation causes dithioerythritol-reversible modification of membrane proteins as indicated by the gel electrophoretic behavior. These modifications can also be suppressed by blocking the membrane thiol groups with N-ethylmaleimide. About half of the membrane methionine is oxidized to acid hydrolysis-stable derivatives. A fast saturating increase in diene conjugation was observed in whole cells but not in isolated membranes, with only minor degradation of fatty acid chains. The oxidation of cell membrane lipids as well as oxidation of cell surface carbohydrates are not involved in leak formation. Taken together with earlier data (Deuticke, B., Poser, B., Lütkemeier, P. and Haest, C.W.M. (1983) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 731, 196-210), these findings indicate that formation of disulfide bonds by different oxidative mechanisms results in leaks with similar properties.     

Utilization of fluorescent probes for the quantification and identification of subcellular proteomes and biological processes regulated by lipid peroxidation products

Oxidative modifications to cellular proteins are critical in mediating redox-sensitive processes such as autophagy, the antioxidant response, and apoptosis. The proteins that become modified by reactive species are often compartmentalized to specific organelles or regions of the cell. Here, we detail protocols for identifying the subcellular protein targets of lipid oxidation and for linking protein modifications with biological responses such as autophagy. Fluorophores such as BODIPY-labeled arachidonic acid or BODIPY-conjugated electrophiles can be paired with organelle-specific probes to identify specific biological processes and signaling pathways activated in response to oxidative stress. In particular, we demonstrate “negative” and “positive” labeling methods using BODIPY-tagged reagents for examining oxidative modifications to protein nucleophiles. The protocol describes the use of these probes in slot immunoblotting, quantitative Western blotting, in-gel fluorescence, and confocal microscopy techniques. In particular, the use of the BODIPY fluorophore with organelle- or biological process-specific dyes and chromophores is highlighted. These methods can be used in multiple cell types as well as isolated organelles to interrogate the role of oxidative modifications in regulating biological responses to oxidative stress.     

Specific modification of mitochondrial protein thiols in response to oxidative stress: a proteomics approach

Mitochondria play a central role in redox-linked processes in the cell through mechanisms that are thought to involve modification of specific protein thiols, but this has proved difficult to assess. In particular, specific labeling and quantitation of mitochondrial protein cysteine residues have not been achieved due to the lack of reagents available that can be applied to the intact organelle or cell. To overcome these problems we have used a combination of mitochondrial proteomics and targeted labeling of mitochondrial thiols using a novel compound, (4-iodobutyl)triphenylphosphonium (IBTP). This lipophilic cation is accumulated by mitochondria and yields stable thioether adducts in a thiol-specific reaction. The selective uptake into mitochondria, due to the large membrane potential across the inner membrane, and the high pH of the matrix results in specific labeling of mitochondrial protein thiols by IBTP. Individual mitochondrial proteins that changed thiol redox state following oxidative stress could then be identified by their decreased reaction with IBTP and isolated by two-dimensional electrophoresis. We demonstrate the selectivity of IBTP labeling and use it to show that glutathione oxidation and exposure to an S-nitrosothiol or to peroxynitrite cause extensive redox changes to mitochondrial thiol proteins. In conjunction with blue native gel electrophoresis, we used IBTP labeling to demonstrate that thiols are exposed on the matrix faces of respiratory Complexes I, II, and IV. This novel approach enables measurement of the thiol redox state of individual mitochondrial proteins during oxidative stress and cell death. In addition the methodology has the potential to identify novel redox-dependent modulation of mitochondrial proteins.     

Oxidative modification of hepatic mitochondria protein thiols: effect of chronic alcohol consumption

Redox modification of mitochondrial proteins is thought to play a key role in regulating cellular function, although direct evidence to support this hypothesis is limited. Using an in vivo model of mitochondrial redox stress, ethanol hepatotoxicity, the modification of mitochondrial protein thiols was examined using a proteomics approach. Specific labeling of reduced thiols in the mitochondrion from the livers of control and ethanol-fed rats was achieved by using the thiol reactive compound (4-iodobutyl)triphenylphosphonium (IBTP). This molecule selectively accumulates in the organelle and can be used to identify thiol-containing proteins. Mitochondrial proteins that have been modified are identified by decreased labeling with IBTP using two-dimensional SDS-PAGE followed by immunoblotting with an antibody directed against the triphenylphosphonium moiety of the IBTP molecule. Analyses of these data showed a significant decrease in IBTP labeling of thiols present in specific mitochondria matrix proteins from ethanol-fed rats compared with their corresponding controls. These proteins were identified as the low-K(m) aldehyde dehydrogenase and glucose-regulated protein 78. The decrease in IBTP labeling in aldehyde dehydrogenase was accompanied by a decrease in specific activity of the enzyme. These data demonstrate that mitochondrial protein thiol modification is associated with chronic alcohol intake and might contribute to the pathophysiology associated with hepatic injury. Taken together, we have developed a protocol to chemically tag and select thiol-modified proteins that will greatly enhance efforts to establish posttranslational redox modification of mitochondrial protein in in vivo models of oxidative or nitrosative stress.     

Roles for cysteine residues in the regulatory CXXC motif of human mitochondrial branched chain aminotransferase enzyme

The redox-active dithiol/disulfide C315-Xaa-Xaa-C318 center has been implicated in the regulation of the human mitochondrial branched chain aminotransferase isozyme (hBCATm) [Conway, M. E., Yennawar, N., Wallin, R., Poole, L. B., and Hutson, S. M. (2002) Biochemistry 41, 9070-9078]. To explore further the mechanistic details of this CXXC center, mutants of the Cys residues at positions 315 and 318 of hBCATm were individually and in combination converted to alanine or serine by site-directed mutagenesis (C315A, C315S, C318A, C318S, C315/318A, and C315/318S). The effects of these mutations on cofactor absorbance, secondary structures, steady-state kinetics, and sensitivity toward hydrogen peroxide (H(2)O(2)) treatment were examined. Neither the UV-visible spectroscopic studies nor the circular dichroism data showed any major perturbations in the structure of the mutants. Kinetic analyses of the CXXC mutant proteins indicated primarily a modest reduction in k(cat) with no significant change in K(m). The largest effect on the steady-state kinetics was observed with the C315 single mutants, in which substitution of the thiol group resulted in a reduced k(cat) (to 26-33% of that of wild-type hBCATm). Moreover, the C315 single mutants lost their sensitivity to oxidation by H(2)O(2). The kinetic parameters of the C318 mutants were largely unaffected by the substitutions, and as with wild-type hBCATm, reaction of the C318A mutant protein with H(2)O(2) resulted in the complete loss of activity. In the case of oxidized C318A, this loss was largely irreversible on incubation with dithiothreitol. Mass spectrometry and dimedone modification results revealed overoxidation of the thiol group at position 315 to sulfonic acid occurring via a sulfenic acid intermediate in the H(2)O(2)-treated C318A enzyme. Thus, C315 appears to be the sensor for redox regulation of BCAT activity, whereas C318 acts as the "resolving cysteine", allowing for reversible formation of a disulfide bond.     

A new method to specifically label thiophosphorylatable proteins with extrinsic probes. Labeling of serine-19 of the regulatory light chain of smooth muscle myosin.

We present a new method to specifically and stably label proteins by attaching extrinsic probes to amino acids that are thiophosphorylated by protein kinases and ATP gamma S. The method was demonstrated for labeling of a thiophosphorylatable serine of the isolated regulatory light chain of smooth muscle myosin. We stoichiometrically blocked the single thiol (Cys-108) either by forming a reversible intermolecular disulfide bond or by reacting with iodoacetic acid. The protein was stoichiometrically thiophosphorylated at Ser-19 by myosin light chain kinase and ATP gamma S. The nucleophilic sulfur of the protein phosphorothioate was coupled at pH 7.9 and 25 degrees C to the fluorescent haloacetate [3H]-5-[[2-[(iodoacetyl)-amino]ethyl]amino]naphthalene-1- sulfonic acid ([3H]IAEDANS) by displacement of the iodide. Typical labeling efficiencies were 70-100%. The labeling was specific for the thiophosphorylated Ser-19, as determined from the sequences of two labeled peptides isolated from a tryptic digest of the labeled protein. [3H]IAEDANS attached to the thiophosphorylated Ser-19 was stable at pH 3-10 at 25 degrees C, and to boiling in high concentrations of reductant. The labeled light chains were efficiently exchanged for unlabeled regulatory light chains of the whole myosin molecule. The resulting labeled myosin had normal ATPase activities in the absence of actin, indicating that the modification of Ser-19 and the exchange of the labeled light chain into myosin did not significantly disrupt the protein. The labeled myosin partially retained the elevated actin-activated Mg(2+)-ATPase activity which is characteristic of thiophosphorylated myosin. This indicates that labeling of the thiophosphate group with [3H]IAEDANS did not completely disrupt the functional properties of the thiophosphorylated protein in the presence of actin.     

Detection of reactive oxygen species-sensitive thiol proteins by redox difference gel electrophoresis: implications for mitochondrial redox signaling

Reactive oxygen species (ROS) produced by the mitochondrial respiratory chain can be a redox signal, but whether they affect mitochondrial function is unclear. Here we show that low levels of ROS from the respiratory chain under physiological conditions reversibly modify the thiol redox state of mitochondrial proteins involved in fatty acid and carbohydrate metabolism. As these thiol modifications were specific and occurred without bulk thiol changes, we first had to develop a sensitive technique to identify the small number of proteins modified by endogenous ROS. In this technique, redox difference gel electrophoresis, control, and redox-challenged samples are labeled with different thiol-reactive fluorescent tags and then separated on the same two-dimensional gel, enabling the sensitive detection of thiol redox modifications by changes in the relative fluorescence of the two tags within a single protein spot, followed by protein identification by mass spectrometry. Thiol redox modification affected enzyme activity, suggesting that the reversible modification of enzyme activity by ROS from the respiratory chain may be an important and unexplored mode of mitochondrial redox signaling.     

Thiol oxidation in signaling and response to stress: detection and quantification of physiological and pathophysiological thiol modifications

Cysteine thiol modifications are increasingly recognized to occur under both physiological and pathophysiological conditions, making their accurate detection, identification, and quantification of growing importance. Among free cysteines, the bulk of modifications occurs on a subset of cysteines that are more reactive. These exist as thiolate anions at physiological pH because of their surrounding electrostatic environment. Reagents with iodoacetamide-active groups can be used to selectively label these reactive thiols with a high degree of selectivity. Thiol adducts can be detected by the failure to label with iodoacetamide or other reagents; restoration of labeling by specific reducing agents (e.g., ascorbate or glutaredoxin) can be used to detect reversible S-nitroso and S-glutathione adducts. These adducts also may be detected with radiolabels and antibodies. S-Glutathiolation in response to physiological stimuli may be detected in cells and tissues with glutathione ester labeled with biotin. Mass spectrometry can identify thiol modifications with precision, and with isotope-coded affinity tags, used to quantify modification of specific thiols. Combinations of these methods increase sensitivity and specificity, and enable quantification and precise identification of thiol modifications that occur under physiological and pathological conditions.     

Proteomic approaches to the characterization of protein thiol modification

Protein cysteine residues are central to redox signaling and to protection against oxidative damage through their interactions with reactive oxygen and nitrogen species, and electrophiles. Although there is considerable evidence for a functional role for cysteine modifications, the identity and physiological significance of most protein thiol alterations are unknown. One way to identify candidate proteins involved in these processes is to utilize the proteomic methodologies that have been developed in recent years for the identification of proteins that undergo cysteine modification in response to redox signals or oxidative damage. These tools have proven effective in uncovering novel protein targets of redox modification and are important first steps that allow for a better understanding of how reactive molecules may contribute to signaling and damage. Here, we discuss a number of these approaches and their application to the identification of a variety of cysteine-centered redox modifications.     

Errata

Human erythrocytes were exposed to oxidative stress by iodate and periodate. Oxidation causes a time- and concentration-dependent increase in membrane permeability for hydrophilic molecules and ions. The induced leak discriminates nonelectrolytes on the basis of molecular size and exhibits a very low activation energy (E_a = 1–4 kcal · mol^?1). These results are reconcilable with the formation of aqeous pores. The pore size was approximated to be between 0.45 and 0.6 nm. This increase in permeability is reversible upon treatment with dithioerythritol. Blocking of membrane thiol groups with N-ethylmaleimide protects the membranes against leak formation. The oxidation causes dithioerythritol-reversible modification of membrane proteins as indicated by the gel electrophoretic behavior. These modifications can also be suppressed by blocking the membrane thiol groups with N-ethylmaleimide. About half of the membrane methionine is oxidized to acid hydrolysis-stable derivatives. A fast saturating increase in diene conjugation was observed in whole cells but not in isolated membranes, with only minor degradation of fatty acid chains. The oxidation of cell membrane lipids as well as oxidation of cell surface carbohydrates are not involved in leak formation. Taken together with earlier data (Deuticke, B., Poster, B., Lütkemeier, P., and Haest, C.W.M. (1983) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 731, 196–210), these findings indicate that formation of disulfide bonds by different oxidative mechanisms results in leaks with similar properties.