Partner-specific prediction of RNA-binding residues in proteins: A critical assessment

RNA-protein interactions play essential roles in regulating gene expression. While some RNA-protein interactions are “specific”, that is, the RNA-binding proteins preferentially bind to particular RNA sequence or structural motifs, others are “non-RNA specific.” Deciphering the protein-RNA recognition code is essential for comprehending the functional implications of these interactions and for developing new therapies for many diseases. Because of the high cost of experimental determination of protein-RNA interfaces, there is a need for computational methods to identify RNA-binding residues in proteins. While most of the existing computational methods for predicting RNA-binding residues in RNA-binding proteins are oblivious to the characteristics of the partner RNA, there is growing interest in methods for partner-specific prediction of RNA binding sites in proteins. In this work, we assess the performance of two recently published partner-specific protein-RNA interface prediction tools, PS-PRIP, and PRIdictor, along with our own new tools. Specifically, we introduce a novel metric, RNA-specificity metric (RSM), for quantifying the RNA-specificity of the RNA binding residues predicted by such tools. Our results show that the RNA-binding residues predicted by previously published methods are oblivious to the characteristics of the putative RNA binding partner. Moreover, when evaluated using partner-agnostic metrics, RNA partner-specific methods are outperformed by the state-of-the-art partner-agnostic methods. We conjecture that either (a) the protein-RNA complexes in PDB are not representative of the protein-RNA interactions in nature, or (b) the current methods for partner-specific prediction of RNA-binding residues in proteins fail to account for the differences in RNA partner-specific versus partner-agnostic protein-RNA interactions, or both.     

Effect of training datasets on support vector machine prediction of protein-protein interactions

Knowledge of protein-protein interaction is useful for elucidating protein function via the concept of 'guilt-by-association'. A statistical learning method, Support Vector Machine (SVM), has recently been explored for the prediction of protein-protein interactions using artificial shuffled sequences as hypothetical noninteracting proteins and it has shown promising results (Bock, J. R., Gough, D. A., Bioinformatics 2001, 17, 455-460). It remains unclear however, how the prediction accuracy is affected if real protein sequences are used to represent noninteracting proteins. In this work, this effect is assessed by comparison of the results derived from the use of real protein sequences with that derived from the use of shuffled sequences. The real protein sequences of hypothetical noninteracting proteins are generated from an exclusion analysis in combination with subcellular localization information of interacting proteins found in the Database of Interacting Proteins. Prediction accuracy using real protein sequences is 76.9% compared to 94.1% using artificial shuffled sequences. The discrepancy likely arises from the expected higher level of difficulty for separating two sets of real protein sequences than that for separating a set of real protein sequences from a set of artificial sequences. The use of real protein sequences for training a SVM classification system is expected to give better prediction results in practical cases. This is tested by using both SVM systems for predicting putative protein partners of a set of thioredoxin related proteins. The prediction results are consistent with observations, suggesting that real sequence is more practically useful in development of SVM classification system for facilitating protein-protein interaction prediction.     

Protein function classification via support vector machine approach

Support vector machine (SVM) is introduced as a method for the classification of proteins into functionally distinguished classes. Studies are conducted on a number of protein classes including RNA-binding proteins; protein homodimers, proteins responsible for drug absorption, proteins involved in drug distribution and excretion, and drug metabolizing enzymes. Testing accuracy for the classification of these protein classes is found to be in the range of 84-96%. This suggests the usefulness of SVM in the classification of protein functional classes and its potential application in protein function prediction.     

Structure-based prediction of RNA-binding domains and RNA-binding sites and application to structural genomics targets

Mechanistic understanding of many key cellular processes often involves identification of RNA binding proteins (RBPs) and RNA binding sites in two separate steps. Here, they are predicted simultaneously by structural alignment to known protein-RNA complex structures followed by binding assessment with a DFIRE-based statistical energy function. This method achieves 98% accuracy and 91% precision for predicting RBPs and 93% accuracy and 78% precision for predicting RNA-binding amino-acid residues for a large benchmark of 212 RNA binding and 6761 non-RNA binding domains (leave-one-out cross-validation). Additional tests revealed that the method makes no false positive prediction from 311 DNA binding domains but correctly detects six domains binding with both DNA and RNA. In addition, it correctly identified 31 of 75 unbound RNA-binding domains with 92% accuracy and 65% precision for predicted binding residues and achieved 86% success rate in its application to SCOP RNA binding domain superfamily (Structural Classification Of Proteins). It further predicts 25 targets as RBPs in 2076 structural genomics targets: 20 of 25 predicted ones (80%) are putatively RNA binding. The superior performance over existing methods indicates the importance of dividing structures into domains, using a Z-score to measure relative structural similarity, and a statistical energy function to measure protein-RNA binding affinity.     

Function prediction for DNA-/RNA-binding proteins, GPCRs, and drug ADME-associated proteins by SVM

This paper explores the use of support vector machine (SVM) for protein function prediction. Studies are conducted on several groups of proteins with different functions including DNA-binding proteins, RNA-binding proteins, G-protein coupled receptors, drug absorption proteins, drug metabolizing enzymes, drug distribution and excretion proteins. The computed accuracy for the prediction of these proteins is found to be in the range of 82.32% to 99.7%, which illustrates the potential of SVM in facilitating protein function prediction.     

A knowledge-based potential function predicts the specificity and relative binding energy of RNA-binding proteins

RNA-protein interactions are fundamental to gene expression. Thus, the molecular basis for the sequence dependence of protein-RNA recognition has been extensively studied experimentally. However, there have been very few computational studies of this problem, and no sustained attempt has been made towards using computational methods to predict or alter the sequence-specificity of these proteins. In the present study, we provide a distance-dependent statistical potential function derived from our previous work on protein-DNA interactions. This potential function discriminates native structures from decoys, successfully predicts the native sequences recognized by sequence-specific RNA-binding proteins, and recapitulates experimentally determined relative changes in binding energy due to mutations of individual amino acids at protein-RNA interfaces. Thus, this work demonstrates that statistical models allow the quantitative analysis of protein-RNA recognition based on their structure and can be applied to modeling protein-RNA interfaces for prediction and design purposes.     

Prediction of the functional class of lipid binding proteins from sequence-derived properties irrespective of sequence similarity

Lipid binding proteins play important roles in signaling, regulation, membrane trafficking, immune response, lipid metabolism, and transport. Because of their functional and sequence diversity, it is desirable to explore additional methods for predicting lipid binding proteins irrespective of sequence similarity. This work explores the use of support vector machines (SVMs) as such a method. SVM prediction systems are developed using 14,776 lipid binding and 133,441 nonlipid binding proteins and are evaluated by an independent set of 6,768 lipid binding and 64,761 nonlipid binding proteins. The computed prediction accuracy is 78.9, 79.5, 82.2, 79.5, 84.4, 76.6, 90.6, 79.0, and 89.9% for lipid degradation, lipid metabolism, lipid synthesis, lipid transport, lipid binding, lipopolysaccharide biosynthesis, lipoprotein, lipoyl, and all lipid binding proteins, respectively. The accuracy for the nonmember proteins of each class is 99.9, 99.2, 99.6, 99.8, 99.9, 99.8, 98.5, 99.9, and 97.0%, respectively. Comparable accuracies are obtained when homologous proteins are considered as one, or by using a different SVM kernel function. Our method predicts 86.8% of the 76 lipid binding proteins nonhomologous to any protein in the Swiss-Prot database and 89.0% of the 73 known lipid binding domains as lipid binding. These findings suggest the usefulness of SVMs for facilitating the prediction of lipid binding proteins. Our software can be accessed at the SVMProt server (http://jing.cz3.nus.edu.sg/cgi-bin/svmprot.cgi).     

Classifying RNA-binding proteins based on electrostatic properties

Protein structure can provide new insight into the biological function of a protein and can enable the design of better experiments to learn its biological roles. Moreover, deciphering the interactions of a protein with other molecules can contribute to the understanding of the protein's function within cellular processes. In this study, we apply a machine learning approach for classifying RNA-binding proteins based on their three-dimensional structures. The method is based on characterizing unique properties of electrostatic patches on the protein surface. Using an ensemble of general protein features and specific properties extracted from the electrostatic patches, we have trained a support vector machine (SVM) to distinguish RNA-binding proteins from other positively charged proteins that do not bind nucleic acids. Specifically, the method was applied on proteins possessing the RNA recognition motif (RRM) and successfully classified RNA-binding proteins from RRM domains involved in protein-protein interactions. Overall the method achieves 88% accuracy in classifying RNA-binding proteins, yet it cannot distinguish RNA from DNA binding proteins. Nevertheless, by applying a multiclass SVM approach we were able to classify the RNA-binding proteins based on their RNA targets, specifically, whether they bind a ribosomal RNA (rRNA), a transfer RNA (tRNA), or messenger RNA (mRNA). Finally, we present here an innovative approach that does not rely on sequence or structural homology and could be applied to identify novel RNA-binding proteins with unique folds and/or binding motifs.     

Prediction of transporter family from protein sequence by support vector machine approach

Transporters play key roles in cellular transport and metabolic processes, and in facilitating drug delivery and excretion. These proteins are classified into families based on the transporter classification (TC) system. Determination of the TC family of transporters facilitates the study of their cellular and pharmacological functions. Methods for predicting TC family without sequence alignments or clustering are particularly useful for studying novel transporters whose function cannot be determined by sequence similarity. This work explores the use of a machine learning method, support vector machines (SVMs), for predicting the family of transporters from their sequence without the use of sequence similarity. A total of 10,636 transporters in 13 TC subclasses, 1914 transporters in eight TC families, and 168,341 nontransporter proteins are used to train and test the SVM prediction system. Testing results by using a separate set of 4351 transporters and 83,151 nontransporter proteins show that the overall accuracy for predicting members of these TC subclasses and families is 83.4% and 88.0%, respectively, and that of nonmembers is 99.3% and 96.6%, respectively. The accuracies for predicting members and nonmembers of individual TC subclasses are in the range of 70.7-96.1% and 97.6-99.9%, respectively, and those of individual TC families are in the range of 60.6-97.1% and 91.5-99.4%, respectively. A further test by using 26,139 transmembrane proteins outside each of the 13 TC subclasses shows that 90.4-99.6% of these are correctly predicted. Our study suggests that the SVM is potentially useful for facilitating functional study of transporters irrespective of sequence similarity.     

Enzyme family classification by support vector machines

One approach for facilitating protein function prediction is to classify proteins into functional families. Recent studies on the classification of G-protein coupled receptors and other proteins suggest that a statistical learning method, Support vector machines (SVM), may be potentially useful for protein classification into functional families. In this work, SVM is applied and tested on the classification of enzymes into functional families defined by the Enzyme Nomenclature Committee of IUBMB. SVM classification system for each family is trained from representative enzymes of that family and seed proteins of Pfam curated protein families. The classification accuracy for enzymes from 46 families and for non-enzymes is in the range of 50.0% to 95.7% and 79.0% to 100% respectively. The corresponding Matthews correlation coefficient is in the range of 54.1% to 96.1%. Moreover, 80.3% of the 8,291 correctly classified enzymes are uniquely classified into a specific enzyme family by using a scoring function, indicating that SVM may have certain level of unique prediction capability. Testing results also suggest that SVM in some cases is capable of classification of distantly related enzymes and homologous enzymes of different functions. Effort is being made to use a more comprehensive set of enzymes as training sets and to incorporate multi-class SVM classification systems to further enhance the unique prediction accuracy. Our results suggest the potential of SVM for enzyme family classification and for facilitating protein function prediction. Our software is accessible at http://jing.cz3.nus.edu.sg/cgi-bin/svmprot.cgi.     

SVM-Prot: Web-based support vector machine software for functional classification of a protein from its primary sequence

Prediction of protein function is of significance in studying biological processes. One approach for function prediction is to classify a protein into functional family. Support vector machine (SVM) is a useful method for such classification, which may involve proteins with diverse sequence distribution. We have developed a web-based software, SVMProt, for SVM classification of a protein into functional family from its primary sequence. SVMProt classification system is trained from representative proteins of a number of functional families and seed proteins of Pfam curated protein families. It currently covers 54 functional families and additional families will be added in the near future. The computed accuracy for protein family classification is found to be in the range of 69.1-99.6%. SVMProt shows a certain degree of capability for the classification of distantly related proteins and homologous proteins of different function and thus may be used as a protein function prediction tool that complements sequence alignment methods. SVMProt can be accessed at http://jing.cz3.nus.edu.sg/cgi-bin/svmprot.cgi.     

Analysis of electric moments of RNA-binding proteins: implications for mechanism and prediction

Background  

Protein-RNA interactions play important role in many biological processes such as gene regulation, replication, protein synthesis and virus assembly. Although many structures of various types of protein-RNA complexes have been determined, the mechanism of protein-RNA recognition remains elusive. We have earlier shown that the simplest electrostatic properties viz. charge, dipole and quadrupole moments, calculated from backbone atomic coordinates of proteins are biased relative to other proteins, and these quantities can be used to identify DNA-binding proteins. Closely related, RNA-binding proteins are investigated in this study. In particular, discrimination between various types of RNA-binding proteins, evolutionary conservation of these bulk electrostatic features and effect of conformational changes by complex formation are investigated. Basic binding mechanism of a putative RNA-binding protein (HI1333 from Haemophilus influenza) is suggested as a potential application of this study.     

Protein-RNA interface residue prediction using machine learning: an assessment of the state of the art

ABSTRACT: BACKGROUND: RNA molecules play diverse functional and structural roles in cells. They function as messengers for transferring genetic information from DNA to proteins, as the primary genetic material in many viruses, as catalysts (ribozymes) important for protein synthesis and RNA processing, and as essential and ubiquitous regulators of gene expression in living organisms. Many of these functions depend on precisely orchestrated interactions between RNA molecules and specific proteins in cells. Understanding the molecular mechanisms by which proteins recognize and bind RNA is essential for comprehending the functional implications of these interactions, but the recognition 'code' that mediates interactions between proteins and RNA is not yet understood. Success in deciphering this code would dramatically impact the development of new therapeutic strategies for intervening in devastating diseases such as AIDS and cancer. Because of the high cost of experimental determination of protein-RNA interfaces, there is an increasing reliance on statistical machine learning methods for training predictors of RNA-binding residues in proteins. However, because of differences in the choice of datasets, performance measures, and data representations used, it has been difficult to obtain an accurate assessment of the current state of the art in protein-RNA interface prediction. RESULTS: We provide a review of published approaches for predicting RNA-binding residues in proteins and a systematic comparison and critical assessment of protein-RNA interface residue predictors trained using these approaches on three carefully curated non-redundant datasets. We directly compare two widely used machine learning algorithms (Naive Bayes (NB) and Support Vector Machine (SVM)) using three different data representations in which features are encoded using either sequence- or structure-based windows. Our results show that (i) Sequence-based classifiers that use a position-specific scoring matrix (PSSM)-based representation (PSSMSeq) outperform those that use an amino acid identity based representation (IDSeq) or a smoothed PSSM (SmoPSSMSeq); (ii) Structure-based classifiers that use smoothed PSSM representation (SmoPSSMStr) outperform those that use PSSM (PSSMStr) as well as sequence identity based representation (IDStr). PSSMSeq classifiers, when tested on an independent test set of 44 proteins, achieve performance that is comparable to that of three state-of-the-art structure-based predictors (including those that exploit geometric features) in terms of Matthews Correlation Coefficient (MCC), although the structure-based methods achieve substantially higher Specificity (albeit at the expense of Sensitivity) compared to sequence-based methods. We also find that the expected performance of the classifiers on a residue level can be markedly different from that on a protein level. Our experiments show that the classifiers trained on three different non-redundant protein-RNA interface datasets achieve comparable cross-validation performance. However, we find that the results are significantly affected by differences in the distance threshold used to define interface residues. CONCLUSIONS: Our results demonstrate that protein-RNA interface residue predictors that use a PSSM-based encoding of sequence windows outperform classifiers that use other encodings of sequence windows. While structure-based methods that exploit geometric features can yield significant increases in the Specificity of protein-RNA interface residue predictions, such increases are offset by decreases in Sensitivity. These results underscore the importance of comparing alternative methods using rigorous statistical procedures, multiple performance measures, and datasets that are constructed based on several alternative definitions of interface residues and redundancy cutoffs as well as including evaluations on independent test sets into the comparisons.     

Computational methods for prediction of protein-RNA interactions

Understanding the molecular mechanism of protein-RNA recognition and complex formation is a major challenge in structural biology. Unfortunately, the experimental determination of protein-RNA complexes by X-ray crystallography and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR) is tedious and difficult. Alternatively, protein-RNA interactions can be predicted by computational methods. Although less accurate than experimental observations, computational predictions can be sufficiently accurate to prompt functional hypotheses and guide experiments, e.g. to identify individual amino acid or nucleotide residues. In this article we review 10 methods for predicting protein-RNA interactions, seven of which predict RNA-binding sites from protein sequences and three from structures. We also developed a meta-predictor that uses the output of top three sequence-based primary predictors to calculate a consensus prediction, which outperforms all the primary predictors. In order to fully cover the software for predicting protein-RNA interactions, we also describe five methods for protein-RNA docking. The article highlights the strengths and shortcomings of existing methods for the prediction of protein-RNA interactions and provides suggestions for their further development.     

Identification of RNA-binding sites in proteins by integrating various sequence information

RNA–protein interactions play a pivotal role in various biological processes, such as mRNA processing, protein synthesis, assembly, and function of ribosome. In this work, we have introduced a computational method for predicting RNA-binding sites in proteins based on support vector machines by using a variety of features from amino acid sequence information including position-specific scoring matrix (PSSM) profiles, physicochemical properties and predicted solvent accessibility. Considering the influence of the surrounding residues of an amino acid and the dependency effect from the neighboring amino acids, a sliding window and a smoothing window are used to encode the PSSM profiles. The outer fivefold cross-validation method is evaluated on the data set of 77 RNA-binding proteins (RBP77). It achieves an overall accuracy of 88.66% with the Matthew’s correlation coefficient (MCC) of 0.69. Furthermore, an independent data set of 39 RNA-binding proteins (RBP39) is employed to further evaluate the performance and achieves an overall accuracy of 82.36% with the MCC of 0.44. The result shows that our method has good generalization abilities in predicting RNA-binding sites for novel proteins. Compared with other previous methods, our method performs well on the same data set. The prediction results suggest that the used features are effective in predicting RNA-binding sites in proteins. The code and all data sets used in this article are freely available at .     

Challenges in structural modeling of RNA-protein interactions

In the past few years, the number of RNA-binding proteins (RBP) and RNA-RBP interactions has increased significantly. Here, we review recent developments in the methodology for protein-RNA and protein–protein complex structure modeling with deep learning and co-evolution, as well as discuss the challenges and opportunities for building a reliable approach for protein-RNA complex structure modelling. Protein Data bank (PDB) and Cross-linking immunoprecipitation (CLIP) data could be combined together and used to infer 2D geometry of protein-RNA interactions by deep learning.     

基于SVM 的药物靶点预测方法及其应用

目的:基于已知药物靶点和潜在药物靶点蛋白的一级结构相似性,结合SVM技术研究新的有效的药物靶点预测方法。方法:构造训练样本集,提取蛋白质序列的一级结构特征,进行数据预处理,选择最优核函数,优化参数并进行特征选择,训练最优预测模型,检验模型的预测效果。以G蛋白偶联受体家族的蛋白质为预测集,应用建立的最优分类模型对其进行潜在药物靶点挖掘。结果:基于SVM所建立的最优分类模型预测的平均准确率为81.03%。应用最优分类器对构造的G蛋白预测集进行预测,结果发现预测排位在前20的蛋白质中有多个与疾病相关。特别的,其中有两个G蛋白在治疗靶点数据库(TTD)中显示已作为临床试验的药物靶点。结论:基于SVM和蛋白质序列特征的药物靶点预测方法是有效的,应用该方法预测出的潜在药物靶点能够为发现新的药靶提供参考。     

RNABindRPlus: A Predictor that Combines Machine Learning and Sequence Homology-Based Methods to Improve the Reliability of Predicted RNA-Binding Residues in Proteins

Protein-RNA interactions are central to essential cellular processes such as protein synthesis and regulation of gene expression and play roles in human infectious and genetic diseases. Reliable identification of protein-RNA interfaces is critical for understanding the structural bases and functional implications of such interactions and for developing effective approaches to rational drug design. Sequence-based computational methods offer a viable, cost-effective way to identify putative RNA-binding residues in RNA-binding proteins. Here we report two novel approaches: (i) HomPRIP, a sequence homology-based method for predicting RNA-binding sites in proteins; (ii) RNABindRPlus, a new method that combines predictions from HomPRIP with those from an optimized Support Vector Machine (SVM) classifier trained on a benchmark dataset of 198 RNA-binding proteins. Although highly reliable, HomPRIP cannot make predictions for the unaligned parts of query proteins and its coverage is limited by the availability of close sequence homologs of the query protein with experimentally determined RNA-binding sites. RNABindRPlus overcomes these limitations. We compared the performance of HomPRIP and RNABindRPlus with that of several state-of-the-art predictors on two test sets, RB44 and RB111. On a subset of proteins for which homologs with experimentally determined interfaces could be reliably identified, HomPRIP outperformed all other methods achieving an MCC of 0.63 on RB44 and 0.83 on RB111. RNABindRPlus was able to predict RNA-binding residues of all proteins in both test sets, achieving an MCC of 0.55 and 0.37, respectively, and outperforming all other methods, including those that make use of structure-derived features of proteins. More importantly, RNABindRPlus outperforms all other methods for any choice of tradeoff between precision and recall. An important advantage of both HomPRIP and RNABindRPlus is that they rely on readily available sequence and sequence-derived features of RNA-binding proteins. A webserver implementation of both methods is freely available at http://einstein.cs.iastate.edu/RNABindRPlus/.     

PRINTR: Prediction of RNA binding sites in proteins using SVM and profiles

Protein–RNA interactions play a key role in a number of biological processes such as protein synthesis, mRNA processing, assembly and function of ribosomes and eukaryotic spliceosomes. A reliable identification of RNA-binding sites in RNA-binding proteins is important for functional annotation and site-directed mutagenesis. We developed a novel method for the prediction of protein residues that interact with RNA using support vector machine (SVM) and position-specific scoring matrices (PSSMs). Two cases have been considered in the prediction of protein residues at RNA-binding surfaces. One is given the sequence information of a protein chain that is known to interact with RNA; the other is given the structural information. Thus, five different inputs have been tested. Coupled with PSI-BLAST profiles and predicted secondary structure, the present approach yields a Matthews correlation coefficient (MCC) of 0.432 by a 7-fold cross-validation, which is the best among all previous reported RNA-binding sites prediction methods. When given the structural information, we have obtained the MCC value of 0.457, with PSSMs, observed secondary structure and solvent accessibility information assigned by DSSP as input. A web server implementing the prediction method is available at the following URL: .     

基于支持向量机的蛋白质相互作用识别

支持向量机（SVM）是广泛应用于各个领域的分类算法,包括生物信息学。本研究应用SVM作为蛋白质相互作用的分类算法,所用蛋白质相互作用数据下载于墨尼黑生物信息学中心的酿酒酵母数据集,包含有6736条蛋白质,其中相互作用的有4837对,不相互作用的有9674对。提取蛋白质主要结构的电荷和等电位点特征,并应用SVM分类算法对此进行了分类。结果显示,分类的正确率在60％左右,但是较系统发育谱法还是获得了较高的分类正确率。