Leaves may function as temperature sensors in the heterophylly of Rorippa aquatica (Brassicaceae)

Many plants show heterophylly, which is variation in leaf form within a plant owing to environmental change. The molecular mechanisms underlying heterophylly have recently been investigated in several plant species. However, little is known about how plants exhibiting heterophylly sense environmental cues. Here, we used Rorippa aquatica (Brassicaceae), which shows heterophylly, to investigate whether a single leaf can sense and transit changes in ambient temperature. The morphology of newly developed leaves after single-leaf warming treatment was significantly different from that of mock-treated control leaves, suggesting that leaves are sensing organs that mediate the responses to changes in ambient temperature in R. aquatica.     

Integrative regulation of leaf morphogenesis by gibberellic and abscisic acids in the aquatic angiosperm proserpinaca palustris L

A two-hormone system regulating leaf development in the heterophyllous amphibious angiosperm Proserpinaca palustris L. is described. Aerial shoots develop expanded, lanceolate, serrate leaves under long-day photoperiods (LD, 16 h light: 8 h dark), whereas growth under short days (SD, 10 h light: 14 h dark) induces dissected leaf formation. The photoperiodic effect on leaf development of aerial shoots involves changes in endogenous gibberellins (GAs) since plants grown under SD in the presence of GA₃ develop expanded lanceolate serrate leaves. However, when submerged, shoots develop highly dissectedaquatic leaves regardless of photoperiod or GA₃ treatment. In the present study, submerged plants exposed to 1.0 or 5.0 μM abscisic acid (ABA) developed aerial-type leaves typical of the photoperiod under which they were cultured. Both exogenous ABA (5.0 μM) and GA₃ (10 μM) treatments were required for laminar expansion to occur on submerged shoots under SD. It is suggested that (1) leaf development in Proserpinaca is regulated by both endogenous GAs and ABA, and (2) the endogenous status of these phytohormones is modulated by different environmental stimuli of photoperiod and water stress, respectively. The adaptive significance of this mechanism is discussed.     

Herbivory and growth in terrestrial and aquatic populations of amphibious stream plants

1. Many amphibious plant species grow in the transition between terrestrial and submerged vegetation in small lowland streams. We determined biomass development, leaf turnover rate and invertebrate herbivory during summer in terrestrial and aquatic populations of three amphibious species to evaluate advantages and disadvantages of aerial and submerged life.
2. Terrestrial populations had higher area shoot density, biomass and leaf production than aquatic populations, while leaf turnover rate and longevity were the same. Terrestrial populations experienced lower percentage grazing loss of leaf production (average 1.2–5.1%) than aquatic populations (2.9–17.3%), while the same plant dry mass was consumed per unit ground area.
3. Grazing loss increased linearly with leaf age apart from the youngest leaf stages. Grazing loss during the lifetime of leaves was therefore 2.4–3.1 times higher than mean apparent loss to standing leaves of all ages. The results imply that variation in density of grazers relative to plant production can account for differences in grazing impact between terrestrial and aquatic populations, and that fast leaf turnover keeps apparent grazing damage down.
4. We conclude that the ability of amphibious plants to grow submerged permits them to expand their niche and escape intense competition on land, but the stream does not provide a refugium against grazing and constrains plant production compared with the terrestrial habitat.     

Endogenous Abscisic Acid Content Correlates with Photon Fluence Rate and Induced Leaf Morphology in Hippuris vulgaris

This research focused on studying how light and endogenous abscisic acid regulate leaf development in Hippuris vulgaris, a species of heterophyllic aquatic plant. Amounts of photosynthetically active radiation greater than 300 micromoles per square meter per second caused submerged H. vulgaris shoots to produce aerial-type leaves. Abscisic acid was not detected in shoots grown under noninducing light quantities (100 micromoles per square meter per second), but was present at 13.4 nanograms per gram fresh weight in shoot tips after plants were exposed to 1 photoperiod of inducing light (500 micromoles per square meter per second). This supports a role for abscisic acid in the high light-induced heterophylly in H. vulgaris, and provides additional support for the general hypothesis that abscisic acid regulates leaf development in heterophyllic aquatic plants. No relationship was observed here between postphotoperiodic light treatments of various red/far red ratios and heterophylly in H. vulgaris.     

Molecular Adaptation of rbcL in the Heterophyllous Aquatic Plant Potamogeton

Background

Heterophyllous aquatic plants show marked phenotypic plasticity. They adapt to environmental changes by producing different leaf types: submerged, floating and terrestrial leaves. By contrast, homophyllous plants produce only submerged leaves and grow entirely underwater. Heterophylly and submerged homophylly evolved under selective pressure modifying the species-specific optima for photosynthesis, but little is known about the evolutionary outcome of habit. Recent evolutionary analyses suggested that rbcL, a chloroplast gene that encodes a catalytic subunit of RuBisCO, evolves under positive selection in most land plant lineages. To examine the adaptive evolutionary process linked to heterophylly or homophylly, we analyzed positive selection in the rbcL sequences of ecologically diverse aquatic plants, Japanese Potamogeton.

Principal Findings

Phylogenetic and maximum likelihood analyses of codon substitution models indicated that Potamogeton rbcL has evolved under positive Darwinian selection. The positive selection has operated specifically in heterophyllous lineages but not in homophyllous ones in the branch-site models. This suggests that the selective pressure on this chloroplast gene was higher for heterophyllous lineages than for homophyllous lineages. The replacement of 12 amino acids occurred at structurally important sites in the quaternary structure of RbcL, two of which (residue 225 and 281) were identified as potentially under positive selection.

Conclusions/Significance

Our analysis did not show an exact relationship between the amino acid replacements and heterophylly or homophylly but revealed that lineage-specific positive selection acted on the Potamogeton rbcL. The contrasting ecological conditions between heterophyllous and homophyllous plants have imposed different selective pressures on the photosynthetic system. The increased amino acid replacement in RbcL may reflect the continuous fine-tuning of RuBisCO under varying ecological conditions.     

Effects of light quality on leaf morphogenesis of a heterophyllous amphibious plant, Rotala hippuris

Background and Aims

For heterophyllous amphibious plants that experience fluctuating water levels, it is critical to control leaf development precisely in response to environmental cues that can serve as a quantitative index of water depth. Light quality can serve as such a cue because the ratio of red light relative to far-red light (R/FR) increases and blue-light intensity decreases with increasing water depth. Growth experiments were conducted to examine how R/FR and blue-light intensity alter leaf morphology of a heterophyllous amphibious plant, Rotala hippuris.

Methods

Using combinations of far red (730 nm), red (660 nm) and blue (470 nm) light-emitting diodes (LEDs), growth experiments were used to quantitatively evaluate the effects of the R/FR ratio and blue-light intensity on leaf morphology.

Key Results

Under the natural light regime in an outside growth garden, R. hippuris produced distinct leaves under submerged and aerial conditions. R/FR and blue-light intensity were found to markedly affect heterophyllous leaf formation. Higher and lower R/FR caused leaf characters more typical of submerged and aerial leaves, respectively, in both aerial and submerged conditions, in accordance with natural distribution of leaf types and light under water. High blue light caused a shift of trait values toward those of typical aerial leaves, and the response was most prominent under conditions of R/FR that were expected near the water surface.

Conclusions

R/FR and blue-light intensity provides quantitative cues for R. hippuris to detect water depth and determine the developmental fates of leaves, especially near the water surface. The utilization of these quantitative cues is expected to be important in habitats where plants experience water-level fluctuation.     

Induction of reduced photorespiratory activity in submersed and amphibious aquatic macrophytes

Incubation under water in a 30 C/14-hour or 12 C/10-hour photoperiod caused the CO₂ compensation points of 10 aquatic macrophytes to decrease below 25 or increase above 50 microliters CO₂ per liter, respectively. Submerged and aerial leaves of two amphibious angiosperms (Myriophyllum brasiliense and Proserpinaca palustris) maintained high compensation points when incubated in air but, when the submerged or aerial leaves of Proserpinaca were incubated under water, the compensation points dropped as low as 10. This suggests that, in addition to temperature and photoperiod, some factor associated with submergence regulates the compensation point of aquatic plants. In the high-compensation point plants, photorespiration, as a percentage of net photosynthesis, was equivalent to that in terrestrial C₃ plants. For Hydrilla verticillata, the decreasing CO₂ compensation points (110, 40, and 10) were associated with reduced photorespiration, as indicated by decreased O₂ inhibition, decreased rates of CO₂ evolution into CO₂-free air, and increased net photosynthetic rates.     

Resistance to CO2 diffusion in cuticular membranes of amphibious plants and the implication for CO2 acquisition

Cuticular membranes (CMs) were isolated from leaves of amphibious and submerged plants and their CO2 resistances were determined as a contribution to establish quantitatively the series of resistances met by CO2 diffusing from bulk water to the chloroplasts of submerged leaves. The isolation was performed enzymatically; permeabilities were determined and converted to resistances. The range of permeance values was 3 to 43 x 10(-6) m s(-1) corresponding to resistance values of 23 to 295 x 10(3) s m(-1), i.e. of the same order of magnitude as boundary layer resistances. The sum of boundary layer, CM, leaf cell and carboxylation resistances could be contained within the total diffusion resistance as determined from the photosynthetic CO2 affinity of the leaf. From the same species, the aerial leaf CM resistance was always higher than the aquatic leaf CM resistance. In a terrestrial plant, the CM resistance to CO2 diffusion was found lower in leaves developed submerged.     

Sensitivity to ethylene: the key factor in submergence-induced shoot elongation of Rumex

Rosettes of flooding-resistant Rumex palustris plants show a submergence-induced stimulation of elongation, which is confined to the petioles of young leaves. This response increases the probability of survival. It is induced by ethylene that accumulates in submerged tissues. Flooding-intolerant Rumex acetosella plants do not show this response. We investigated whether differences in shoot elongation between the species, between old and young leaves and between the petiole and leaf blade of a R. palustris plant result from differences in internal ethylene concentration or in sensitivity to the gas. Concentrations of free and conjugated ACC in petioles and leaf blades of R. palustris indicated that ethylene is synthesized throughout the submerged shoot, although production rates varied locally. Nevertheless, no differences in ethylene concentration were found between submerged leaves of various ages. In contrast, dose-response curves showed that only elongation of young petioles of R. palustris was sensitive to ethylene. In R. acetosella, elongation of all leaves was insensitive to ethylene. We conclude that variation in ethylene sensitivity rather than content explains the differences in submergence-induced shoot elongation between the two Rumex species and between leaves of R. palustris.     

Regulation of the KNOX-GA Gene Module Induces Heterophyllic Alteration in North American Lake Cress

Plants show leaf form alteration in response to changes in the surrounding environment, and this phenomenon is called heterophylly. Although heterophylly is seen across plant species, the regulatory mechanisms involved are largely unknown. Here, we investigated the mechanism underlying heterophylly in Rorippa aquatica (Brassicaceae), also known as North American lake cress. R. aquatica develops pinnately dissected leaves in submerged conditions, whereas it forms simple leaves with serrated margins in terrestrial conditions. We found that the expression levels of KNOTTED1-LIKE HOMEOBOX (KNOX1) orthologs changed in response to changes in the surrounding environment (e.g., change of ambient temperature; below or above water) and that the accumulation of gibberellin (GA), which is thought to be regulated by KNOX1 genes, also changed in the leaf primordia. We further demonstrated that exogenous GA affects the complexity of leaf form in this species. Moreover, RNA-seq revealed a relationship between light intensity and leaf form. These results suggest that regulation of GA level via KNOX1 genes is involved in regulating heterophylly in R. aquatica. The mechanism responsible for morphological diversification of leaf form among species may also govern the variation of leaf form within a species in response to environmental changes.     

Heterophylly in some Species of Callitriche, with especial reference to Callitriche intermedia

Callitriche stagnalis, C. obtusangula, and C. intermedia, inthat order, were found to show a progressively greater variationin leaf form. Axes of C. intermedia bearing crowns of ovateleaves were submerged under various light and temperature conditionsand the growth rates studied in relation to the form of theleaves produced. Leaf movements were also studied in connexionwith the growth of such submerged shoots and with the generalquestion of heterophylly.     

Comparison of Aerial and Submerged Leaves in Two Amphibious Species,Myosotis scorpioides and Ranunculus trichophyllus

Both amphibious species, Myosotis scorpioides and Ranunculus trichophyllus, thrive in a stressful environment (alternated flooding and drying), which is variable regarding water and radiation regimes. Plants from the field and plants grown under controlled water table maintained at 40 cm were analysed for content of chlorophyll (Chl) and UV-B screening compounds, and the efficiencies of PS2 and electron transport systems. We detected no significant differences in contents of Chl and UV-B screening compounds between submerged and aerial leaves. The measurements of respiratory potential and photochemical efficiency revealed the presence of permanent stress in M. sporpioides in the natural environment. Differences in physiological responses of submerged and aerial leaves indicated that the terrestrial environment was more favourable for M. scorpioides than for R. trichophyllus. Characteristics of both species suggested that R. trichophyllus might be a phylogenetically older aquatic plant than M. scorpioides.     

Species specificity of resistance to oxygen diffusion in thin cuticular membranes from amphibious plants

Cuticular membranes (CM) were isolated enzymatically from leaves of amphibious and submerged plants, and the oxygen permeability of aerial and aquatic CMs was compared using a specially constructed oxygen electrode. Their thicknesses were estimated from transmission electron micrographs of intact leaves. When dry CMs were moistened, the permeability of typical aerial CMs changed differently from that of typical aquatic CMs during the desiccation, apparently reflecting different internal structures. The cuticle thickness was mostly < 100 nm, and the range of permeance values was 5–143 × 10^?6 m s^?1, corresponding to resistance values of 7–210 × 10³ s m^?1. The resistance of an aerial CM was always higher than that of an aquatic one from the same species. Only the aquatic CMs showed a weak proportionality between resistance and thickness. The relation between resistance and thickness varied from aquatic to aerial CMs in a species specific way.     

Plasticity in carbon acquisition of the heterophyllous Luronium natans: An endangered freshwater species in Europe

Luronium natans (L.) Raf. (Floating Water-plantain) is an endangered amphibious freshwater species endemic to Europe. We examined the plasticity in carbon acquisition and photosynthesis in L. natans to assess if lack of plasticity could contribute to explain the low competitive ability of the species. The plasticity of photosynthesis in submerged leaves towards inorganic carbon availability was examined and the photosynthesis of submerged, floating and aerial leaves was contrasted. L. natans was shown to be plastic in inorganic carbon uptake, as it was able to effectively acclimate to changed concentrations of free-CO₂. The photosynthetic apparatus was down-regulated in plants grown at high CO₂. Chlorophyll concentration, Rubisco activity and maximum photosynthesis were significantly lower in submerged leaves of plants grown at high CO₂ (200 μM free-CO₂) compared to plants grown at low CO₂ (18 μM free-CO₂). Furthermore, bicarbonate utilization was down-regulated in response to high CO₂. Carbon acquisition of submerged, floating and aerial leaves of L. natans differed significantly. The aerial leaves were superior in photosynthesising in air and, surprisingly, the floating leaves had the highest rates of photosynthesis in water. The study did not support the hypothesis that the low competitive ability of L. natans is caused by inefficient photosynthesis or a lack of plasticity in photosynthesis. However, the somewhat low photosynthetic performance of the submerged leaves may be a contributing factor.     

Heterophylly in Ranunculus flabellaris: The Effect of Abscisic Acid on Leaf Anatomy

Ranunculus flabellaris Raf., the yellow water crowfoot, exhibitsstriking heterophylly between submerged and terrestrial leaves.Leaves produced under water are highly divided with numerousnarrow lobes and deep sinuses, whereas terrestrial leaves havefew broad lobes and shallow sinuses. When plants are submergedin a 25 µM solution of ABA, the typical transition fromterrestrial to submerged leaves is completely suppressed and,instead, terrestrial-like leaves are produced. Image analysistechniques show that, in addition to this modification of leafmorphology, leaves produced under ABA treatment possess surfaceand internal features characteristic of terrestrial leaf anatomy.This study provides evidence that the environmental factorsthat influence the morphological and anatomical expression ofheterophylly may act through endogenous ABA. Ranunculus flabellaris, yellow water crowfoot, ABA, heterophylly, leaf anatomy     

Morphological and anatomical changes of Melaleuca cajuputi under submergence

Melaleuca cajuputi is a woody plant of the Myrtaceae which is a dominant species in tropical peat swamps in southern Thailand, where the groundwater level fluctuates greatly. Although the current year seedlings are likely submerged, their adaptive responses have never been studied. The objective of the present study was to examine their responses to submergence, and especially their morphological and anatomical changes. Not only did the seedlings of M. cajuputi survive submergence for 56 days, but they could also increase their dry weight, shoot length, and leaf number during submergence. These growth responses to submergence indicate that the seedlings of M. cajuputi could make photosynthetic production under water. The leaves that developed under water were heterophyllous “aquatic leaves” that appear to represent adaptations to improve the uptake of gases from the water. Intercellular spaces in the stems and leaves were more strongly developed in the submerged seedlings than in non-submerged seedlings with the shoot and leaves in the air. The intercellular spaces appear to be schizogenous aerenchyma that facilitates gas exchange. The growth responses and anatomical responses in stems and leaves to submergence, which were found in M. cajuputi, are commonly known in herbaceous plants with amphibious characteristics, but had not been reported in woody plants. And our results suggest that M. cajuputi adapts to submergence similarly to other amphibious plants, thereby ensuring continuing biomass production.     

Identification of Factors that Cause Heterophylly in Ludwigia arcuata Walt. (Onagraceae)

Abstract: The submerged leaves of Ludwigia arcuata are much narrower than the terrestrial leaves. Such heterophyllous changes in leaf shape have been observed in other aquatic angiosperms, such as Callitriche heterophylla, Hippuris vulgaris and Ranunculus flabellaris, but the cause of the formation of heterophyllous leaves in L. arcuata seems to be quite different. In contrast to other species, in which the shapes of epidermal cells have been changed, the change of leaf shape in L. arcuata was found to be due to changes in the numbers of epidermal cells aligned in transverse sections. The susceptibility of leaves to changes in shape above and below the water is dependent on the developmental stages: leaves younger than the fourth leaf responded to a change in environment, while leaves older than the fifth leaf did not. Treatment with ACC (1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid), a precursor to ethylene, induced the formation of submerged-type leaves on terrestrial shoots, implying that ethylene might be the endogenous factor responsible for the change in leaf shape. The results are discussed with reference to the significance of the acclimation of plants to environmental changes.     

Leaf optical properties in amphibious plant species are affected by multiple leaf traits

The amphibious plant species Sagittaria sagittifolia and Ranunculus lingua here serve as model systems to study differences in leaf optical properties of different leaf types that develop in aquatic and terrestrial environments. We aimed to determine leaf traits that explain most of the variability in the reflectance and transmittance spectra in the range from 280 to 880 nm. Comparisons of leaves of the same form revealed marked differences in their structures and particularly in the content of total methanol-soluble UV-absorbing compounds. Submerged leaves transmit radiation over the whole range measured, but emerged leaves transmit only at wavelengths from 500 to 650 nm, and above 690 nm. Redundancy analysis shows that biochemical leaf traits, namely the UV-absorbing compounds chlorophyll a and b, together with the specific leaf area (SLA), significantly affect the reflectance spectra, explaining 60% of the spectra variability. Pigment levels negatively affect reflectance, while the effect of SLA is positive. Physical traits like thickness of the palisade mesophyll, SLA, and thickness of the lower and upper epidermis, along with anthocyanin content, explain 62% of the transmittance spectra variability. This study provides new insight into the understanding of data collected for aquatic and semi-aquatic plants based on spectral analyses.     

CAUSAL MECHANISMS OF LEAF DIMORPHISM IN THE AQUATIC ANGIOSPERM CALLITRICHE HETEROPHYLLA

This report investigates the physiological basis for the production of dimorphic leaves on the aquatic angiosperm Callitriche heterophylla. In nature, the leaf morphology of this plant depends on whether the shoot apex is submerged in or emergent from water. The water-form leaves that develop on submerged apices assume a long, linear shape in contrast to the short, obovate appearance of land forms on emergent apices. The parameters of length/width ratio and stomatal density were used as developmental indices to characterize how natural conditions, fluctuating water levels and other experimental treatments affect leaf shape. Transferring submerged and emergent shoots to the alternative culture conditions caused immature leaves to assume the characteristics appropriate to their new environment. Moreover, the treatments of 0.24 mol mannitol, high temperature (30 C) and 10^−-5 m abscisic acid induced submerged shoots to produce land-form leaves whereas 10^−-5 m gibberellic acid mediated the development of water-form leaves on emergent shoots. Water, osmotic and pressure potentials of immature leaves in the control and experimental treatments were determined by thermocouple psychrometry. Under natural conditions, growing water forms exhibited high turgors (3–5 bars) while developing land forms showed much lower turgors (0–1 bar). Similar correlations between turgor pressure and leaf morphology were observed in the case of the gibberellic acid and mannitol treatments. However, abscisic acid and high temperature caused the developing land-form leaves to exhibit high turgors without a concomitant change to the water-form morphology. Microscopic measurements of epidermal cells established that irrespective of the experimental conditions, water-form leaves had longer and narrower epidermal cells with less convoluted anticlinal walls than land forms. Cell counts indicated that the numbers of epidermal cells did not account for the observed differences in leaf morphology. The results are interpreted in terms of how cell expansion might regulate leaf morphology in aquatic angiosperms.