Homing pigeons as a model for avian navigation?

The findings on the navigational mechanisms of homing pigeons and the available data on those of wild birds, in particular migrants, are compared. There are important parallels in the use of the magnetic field and the sun for directional orientation. Also the findings on the navigational ‘map’, its preferred use by experienced birds and the strategy of using route information to acquire the necessary knowledge to establish the ‘map’, obtained in pigeons studies, can probably be generalized to wild birds and migrants in their home region. It seems that birds share a common navigational system. Special development of migratory birds, however, is the innate migration program that enables young first‐time migrants to reach their still unknown wintering area.     

Changes in the short-term deflector loft effect are linked to the sun compass of homing pigeons

Despite being the most studied of all avian orientation systems, important questions still remain about the sun compass of homing pigeons, Columba livia. White it is well-documented that the sun compass is usually learned by young pigeons during the first 10–12 weeks of life, the mechanism by which it is calibrated to adjust for seasonal changes in the sun's azimuth is not known with certainty. Previous experiments using short-term deflector loft pigeons indicated that the sun compass may be calibrated by referencing celestial polarization patterns. The present paper describes important measurable changes in the previously reported orientation behaviour of short-term deflector loft birds, and suggests a correlation between these changes and the presence of a massive upper-atmospheric dust cloud of volcanic origin which significantly altered natural skylight polarization patterns in 1982 and 1983. Moreover, it is shown that when the short-term effect was absent (at times when data from previous years suggested it should be present), the birds were also not using sun compass orientation, as demonstrated by their failure to show the standard ‘clockshift’ response to a 6-h fast shift of their internal clocks. These results support the hypothesis that reflected light cues, rather than odours, are the basis of the deflector loft effect in pigeon homing.     

Pigeon homing: change in navigational strategy during ontogeny

Pigeons of various ages and experience were prevented from collecting meaningful information during the outward journey by being transported in either a distorted magnetic field or in total darkness. In very young, inexperienced birds, these manipulations caused disorientation, the effect decreasing as the birds grew older. Experienced, trained pigeons did not seem to be affected. These results suggest a switch in strategy during the development of the pigeons' navigational system: young pigeons first determine their home direction using information collected en route during the outward journey, but with increasing age and experience, they switch to using local ‘map’ information obtained at the release site. The advantages of using a navigational ‘map’ are discussed.     

The Orientation Behaviour of Chaffinches, Fringilla coelebs, Caught during Active Migratory Flight, in Relation to the Sun

The few orientation studies that have been carried out with day-migrating birds show that they are able to use solar and magnetic orientation cues for orientation. Previous orientation experiments in Emlen funnels have been carried out either with hand-raised birds or with birds caught during resting periods at stop-over sites. The aim of our study was to test whether birds caught during active flight show a higher concentration of migratory activity in the seasonally appropriate migratory direction in the funnels than birds that had not experienced migration just before the funnel experiments. The topography at the alpine pass Col de Bretolet at the border of Switzerland and France allowed us to capture birds during active migratory flight. These birds were in full migration disposition. Orientation experiments with chaffinches suggested an influence of the sun because chaffinches did not orient in the seasonally expected direction, but probably showed positive phototaxis towards the light of the sun at the opposite side of the funnel. Chaffinches tested under overcast conditions oriented to the north-west which probably was a 'nonsense' orientation and not a reverse migration or compensatory behaviour. We conclude that freshly caught birds are too stressed to show appropriate orientation when tested immediately after catching.     

Effects of exogenous melatonin on sun-compass orientation of homing pigeons

Experiments were performed to test whether melatonin plays a role in sun-compass orientation of homing pigeons. Birds were kept for a period of time in dim continuous light (LL) or in artificial light-dark (LD) cycles and then released under the sun from unfamiliar sites. Control birds in dim LL were oriented homeward in all cases. Birds with melatonin implants in LD were capable of a correct use of the sun compass at release. Birds with melatonin implants in dim LL, on the contrary, performed very poorly in orientation. The present results demonstrate for the first time that melatonin is involved in the control of the circadian rhythms underlying sun-compass orientation in birds.     

Orientation Cage and Release Experiments with Migratory Wheatears (Oenanthe oenanthe) in Scandinavia and Greenland: The Importance of Visual Cues

Migratory orientation of Scandinavian and Greenland wheatears was recorded during the autumn migration periods of 1988 and 1989. Orientation cage tests were conducted under clear sunset skies, to investigate the importance of different visible sky sections on orientation performance. In addition, wheatears were released under clear starry skies and under total overcast to examine the orientation of free-flying birds. The following results were obtained:

• 1 Wheatears tested with a restricted visible sky section (90° centered around zenith) in orientation cages, showed a mean orientation towards geographic W/geomagnetic NW (Greenland) and towards geographic and magnetic WNW-NW (Sweden). These mean directions are clearly inconsistent with the expected autumn migration directions, SW-SSW in Scandinavia and SE in Greenland, as revealed by ringing recoveries for the two populations.
• 2 When the birds were allowed a much more extensive view of the sky, almost down to the horizon (above 10° elevation), Scandinavian wheatears chose headings in agreement with ringing data. Greenland birds were not significantly oriented.
• 3 Release experiments under clear starry skies resulted in mean vanishing directions in good agreement with ringing data from both sites. Greenland wheatears released under total overcast showed a similar orientation as under clear skies, indicating that a view of the stars may not be of crucial importance for selecting a seasonally accurate migratory direction.

The results suggest that an unobstructed view of the sky, including visual cues low over the horizon, is important, possibly in combination with geomagnetic cues, for the orientation of migratory naive wheatears. Furthermore, the birds showed remarkably similar orientation responses in Greenland and Scandinavia, respectively, indicating that they use basically the same orientation system, despite considerable differences in visual and geomagnetic orientation premises at the two different geographic and magnetic latitudes.     

Pineal Body and Magnetic Sensitivity: Homing in Pinealectomized Pigeons under Overcast Skies

Since birds use the earth's magnetic field for compass orientation when astronomical cues are lacking and it has recently been suggested that the pineal body is part of their magnetic compass, test releases have been performed in overcast conditions with pigeons deprived of the pineal body. On the whole, both experimental and control birds were capable of homeward orientation, though the bearings of experimental were rather more scattered. No differences in homing speed or success were recorded. Thus, the pineal body does not appear to play an important role in the homing of pigeons.     

Acetylcholine as sensory transmitter in crustacea

Summary In an attempt to learn more about the so-called map component in pigeon navigation, nine series of tests comprising 34 test releases were performed at a release site, 89 miles NNE of Ithaca, New York, where Cornell pigeons regularly depart nonrandomly but with a large clockwise deviation from the true home direction. The tests included releases of: (1) experienced pigeons new to the site, under sun; (2) pigeons with previous experience at the site, under sun; (3) experienced pigeons new to the site, under total overcast; (4) pigeons with previous experience at the site, under total overcast; (5) first-flight youngsters, under sun; (6) directionally trained pigeons; (7) pigeons from two other Ithaca-area lofts; (8) pigeons from two more distant lofts; (9) Bank Swallows from an Ithaca colony; (10) clock-shifted pigeons; (11) radio- and airplane-tracked pigeons.The results of these tests indicate that the directional bias of the Cornell pigeons is, in general, not dependent on weather conditions or on the previous experience of the birds. Moreover, a similar bias is shown by both pigeons from other Ithacaarea lofts and Bank Swallows from Ithaca. And a similar bias from their respective home directions is shown by birds from other areas. Clock-shifted pigeons departing more directly toward home have poorer homing success than controls. It is concluded that some environmental factor basic to the avian homing process is rotated clockwise at this release site, that biologically the birds are not making an error but are probably reading correctly a distorted map.I thank Irene Brown and Timothy Larkin for their aid in all phases of this project; Donald Windsor for help in two releases; Charles Walcott and Martin Michener for aid in airplane tracking; J. Downhower for collaboration in the radio tracking and swallow releases; Andre Gobert, Howard French, A. E. Newton, and Ludwig Karl for permitting me to use their pigeons, George Yerdon, Forest Ranger, and Andy Misura, District Ranger, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, for their cooperation in making the facilities of the Castor Hill Fire Tower available to us; Monica Howland for preparing the drawings; and Bertha Blaker for typing. Research supported in part by NSF Grants GB-13046X and GB-35199X, and in part by Federal Hatch funds.     

Anfangsorientierung und Heimkehrverhalten von Brieftauben unter dem Einflu? von Kurzwellen

Zusammenfassung Um den potentiellen Einfluß von Kurzwellen auf die Orientierung und das Heimkehrverhalten von Brieftauben zu testen, wurden zwei Schläge in der Nähe eines Kurzwellensenders eingerichtet, der eine der Strahlung voll ausgesetzt, der anderer in einem tagsüber nicht für Sendungen benutzten Sektor und zudem topographisch gegen den Sender geschützt. In beiden Schlägen wurden Jungtauben aufgezogen und im Alter von drei Monaten für Testflüge genutzt. Die mit bzw. ohne Kurzwellen am neuen Standort angewöhnten Alttauben sowie die mit bzw. ohne Kurzwellen an diesem Standort aufgewachsenen Jungtauben wurden von einem etwa 11 km entfernten Auflaßort für Heimflüge gegen den Sender mit und ohne Kurzwellen-Einfluß im relevanten Sektor eingesetzt.Es ergaben sich keine Unterschiede in der Anfangsorientierung zwischen den Versuchsgruppen. Dagegen flogen alle ohne Kurzwellen-Einfluß aufgewachsenen Gruppen tendenziell rascher heim, wenn kein aktueller Kurzwellen-Einfluß vorhanden war. Faßte man alle drei Gruppen zusammen, so wurde dieser Unterschied signifikant. Demgegenüber zeigten die beiden mit Strahlung aufgewachsenen Gruppen unter den beiden Strahlungsbedingungen keine unterschiedlichen Heimkehrgeschwindigkeiten. Die fünf Testgruppen zusammengefaßt zeigten geringere Flughöhen unter Kurzwellen-Einfluß. Diese Ergebnisse lassen darauf schließen, daß die Brieftauben die Kurzwellen fühlen können, daß aber ihre Anfangsorientierung dadurch nicht beeinträchtigt wird. Reduzierte Heimkehrgeschwindigkeiten und geringe Flughöhen unter Kurzwellen-Einfluß, deuten auf einen störenden Effekt der elektromagnetischen Felder hin. Das Verhalten der unter Kurzwellen aufgewachsenen juvenilen Gruppen erlaubt den Schluß, daß sich Tauben an gewisse Kurzwellenbedingungen gewöhnen können.

---

Initial orientation and homing behaviour of pigeons under the influence of short wave transmissions

Summary In order to test the potential influence of short wave radiation on the homing behaviour of pigeons we positioned two lofts with adult homing pigeons in the vicinity of a short wave transmitter. One loft was next to the transmitter and fully exposed to the radiation, the second protected against the radiation (a) by topographical features and (b) by its position in a sector that was not used for transmission during daytime. In both lofts young pigeons were raised and used for experimental flights at the age of three months. Adults accustomed to the new sites as well as young birds from the exposed and non-exposed lofts, respectively, were released some 11 km from the loft for homeward flights towards the transmitter, with and without transmission towards the relevant sector.Vanishing direction and vanishing time were not affected by the short wave radiation in any of the groups, thus corroborating earlier experiments with pigeons flying homewards from the transmitter towards distant lofts. However, all three groups raised in the absence of short wave radiation (A–, A+, J–) homed tendentially faster in situations where radiation was absent compared to situations with radiation. Pooled in one data set the three groups were significantly faster without radiation. On the other hand, the two juvenile groups raised under radiation (J1+ and J2+) homed at the same speed under both short wave situations. Furthermore, all five groups tended to choose lower flight altitudes when released under the influence of short wave radiation (significantly when groups were pooled). Besides the experiments, observations near the loft gave the impression that the pigeons kept in the exposed loft were reluctant to fly in the neighbourhood of the loft, particularly the adults.We conclude that short wave radiation can be felt by the pigeons, but does not interfere with their initial orientation. Reduced homing speeds of birds grown up without experiencing radiation, low flight levels in flights under radiation in all groups, and a general reluctance to fly of the pigeons next to the exposed loft, suggest that the radiation has an undefined negative effect on the birds. Unimpaired homing speeds in juveniles having grown up under varying field strengths suggest that homing pigeons can become accustomed to short wave radiation to a certain extent.

     

Hippocampal participation in the sun compass orientation of phase-shifted homing pigeons

The orientation of phase-shifted control and hippocampal lesioned homing pigeons with previous homing experience was examined to investigate the possible participation of the hippocampal formation in sun compass orientation. Hippocampal lesioned pigeons displayed appropriate shifts in orientation indicating that such birds possess a functional sun compass that is used for orientation. However, their shift in orientation was consistently larger than in control pigeons revealing a difference in orientation never observed in pigeons that have not undergone a phase shift. Although alternative interpretations exist, the data suggest the intriguing possibility that following a change in the light-dark cycle, the hippocampal formation participates in the re-entrainment of a circadian rhythm that regulates sun compass orientation.     

Sunset and the orientation of European robins (Erithacus rubecula)

The migratory orientation of European robins (Erithacus rubecula) in autumn was tested immediately after sunset and also after the beginning of astronomical darkness. In twilight tests under clear skies, the birds selected an appropriate migratory direction. During the course of autumn, along with the shift of sunset azimuth, the orientation of birds also shifted, always in a counter-clockwise direction. Although this shift of orientation was not statistically significant, the difference between the mean direction and the sunset was the same for each autumn period. This suggests that the migratory direction was selected on the basis of menotactic orientation re the setting sun. Random directions were observed under solid overcast skies as well as during tests under starry skies, begun after all trace of the sunset position had disappeared.     

Moonlight and the Migratory Orientation of Savannah Sparrows (Passerculus sandwichensis)

Migratory birds might respond to moonlight in at least four ways: (1) a geographical reference for selecting a compass direction, (2) a celestial ‘landmark’ to facilitate maintenance of a preferred heading, (3) a stimulus that distracts migrants and introduces error in compass orientation, or (4) a source of illumination that facilitates nocturnal flight. This study examines the response of migratory savannah sparrows (Passerculus sandwichensis) to moonlight during controlled tests in orientation cages. I found no evidence that savannah sparrows use a lunar compass to select a direction. If savannah sparrows do use the moon as a ‘landmark’ to maintain a direction selected with reference to a different cue, I expected birds to be better oriented on overcast nights when the moon is present than they are when the moon is absent. The results suggest otherwise. Usually, savannah sparrows respond phototactically to the moon by directing their cage activity toward or at a constant angle with respect to the moon's azimuth. Interestingly, the migrant's response to moonlight depended on whether the bird viewed the setting sun earlier that evening.     

Field studies of avian nocturnal migratory orientation I. interaction of sun,wind and stars as directional cues

Tracking radar and visual observation techniques were used to observe the orientation of free-flying passerine nocturnal migrants in situations in which potentially usable directional cues were absent or gave conflicting information. When migrants had seen the sun near the time of sunset and/or the stars, they oriented in appropriate migratory directions even when winds were opposed. Under solid overcast skies that prevented a view of both sun and stars, the birds headed downwind in opposing winds and thus moved in seasonally inappropriate directions. The data point to the primacy of visual cues over wind direction, with either sun or stars being sufficient to allow the birds to determine the appropriate migration direction.     

Solar cues in the migratory orientation of the Savannah sparrow, Passerculus sandwichensis

Results clearly implicate the setting sun as a critical source of directional information in the migratory orientation of the savannah sparrow, Passerculus sandwichensis. Savannah sparrows allowed a view of both sunset and stars displayed oriented behaviour in biologically meaningful directions during spring and fall seasons. When the same individuals were denied a view of sunset, and tested under the stars alone, disorientation characterized their behaviour. Furthermore, birds allowed a view of sunset, but tested under ‘overcast’ night skies (no stars visible), displayed well-oriented behaviour indicating the sufficiency of sunset. Experiments in which the migrant's internal chronometer was shifted suggested a fixed-angle (menotactic) response to the sunset cue rather than a time-compensating compass mechanism. I believe stars are valuable to this migrant as celestial reference points. Orientational information gained at the time of sunset is transferred to stars on a nightly basis. The relationship between solar and stellar cues is apparently hierarchical in the savannah sparrow. Information necessary to select the appropriate migratory direction is gained from the primary cue, the setting sun, while maintenance of that heading is dependent on a secondary cue, probably the stars.     

Light-dependent information: influence of loft conditions on young pigeon’s navigational system

This study compares the initial orientation and homing performance of young inexperienced pigeons following their transportation to near and distant places in total darkness (treatment) and their subsequent release. The birds were housed in two lofts at the Lisbon Zoo. Each loft had its own specific features: the H-loft was exposed to prevailing winds and allowed an unhindered view of the surrounding landscape; the L-loft was protected from the wind and allowed only a partial view of the surroundings. Pigeons used in the release tests were between 6 and 7 weeks old. We found that, in general, the initial orientation of the pigeons was affected by the treatment: following release at near places, there was an increase in the scatter and a decrease the homeward component, suggesting that light-dependent information collected en route was used by young pigeons. The effect of the treatment was only temporary based on the observation that the homing performance was not affected. However, the distance of the release site strongly influenced the homing performances as pigeons appeared to be unable to home when released at locations distant from the loft. Based on the scatter or the homeward component, inter-loft differences were apparent with respect to different median vanishing intervals and the reactions of specific pigeons when subjected to the same treatment (transport in darkness) following release at near and distant places. These findings suggest that light-dependent information collected en route is a component of the young pigeon’s navigational system but that, at the young age of the birds tested here, it is preferentially used in familiar areas. In addition, the importance of the light-dependent information appears to depend upon prior experience obtained in the lofts.     

Das Richtungsverhalten verfrachteter Brieftauben (Columba livia) im Orientierungsk?fig

The orientation of displaced homing pigeons at the moment of their release was tested using an octagonal orientation cage. Under certain conditions, the cage bearings of old, experienced pigeons show rather good homeward orientation, while the directional choices of young birds are not related to the home direction.     

Why do migrating robins,Erithacus rubecula,captured at two nearby stop-over sites orient differently?

The orientation of robins captured during autumn and spring migration at two different sites, Falsterbo and Ottenby, in southern Sweden was investigated by cage experiments during the twilight period after sunset. The robins were tested under clear skies with skylight from sunset visible, and under simulated total overcast. The robins from the two sites differed in orientation, especially during autumn migration. While robins from Ottenby generally oriented in their expected migratory direction, the birds from Falsterbo under clear skies oriented towards the sunset direction with a narrow scatter in individual mean headings. Under simulated total overcast the robins from Falsterbo perferred northerly directions in autumn. Short-distance recoveries, one or only a few days after ringing, show that robins in autumn regularly fly 20–80 km from Falsterbo on northerly courses, indicating that they have temporarily reoriented from their normal migratory direction when confronted with the Baltic Sea. In contrast, most robins arrive at Ottenby by extensive flights across the Baltic Sea, and rapidly continue their sea crossing in the normal migratory directions. Mean fat deposits in autumn robins were significantly larger at Ottenby than at Falsterbo. These results indicate that migrating birds may show markedly different orientational dispositions depending on body condition and on their situation with respect to preceding and impending migration over land and sea, respectively.     

Sexual maturation and moult in juvenile Starlings Sturnus vulgaris in response to different daylengths

Starlings, like most other species, show no gonadal development until spring of the year after they hatch, even though they hatch and attain full body size during long days. This could be because they develop in a physiological state analogous to that of photorefractory adults and so need to experience short days in order to activate the reproductive system. To test this possibility, young were hand-reared under different photoperiodic regimes. Young raised under constant long days showed no gonadal development, nor did birds initially raised under short days and then transferred to long days at 3 weeks of age. However, birds transferred from short to long days at 10 weeks of age did show gonadal development, followed by gonadal regression, while birds raised under constant short days showed slow continual gonadal development. This last group, unlike the other three groups, did not moult into adult plumage. Since 4 weeks of long days are required to terminate photorefractoriness in adult Starlings, these results demonstrate that the reproductive system of young birds is in a similar state to that of photorefractory adults, and hence that puberty is analogous to the termination of photofractoriness.     

Compass orientation and possible migration routes of passerine birds at high arctic latitudes

The use of celestial or geomagnetic orientation cues can lead migratory birds along different migration routes during the migratory journeys, e.g. great circle routes (approximate), geographic or magnetic loxodromes. Orientation cage experiments have indicated that migrating birds are capable of detecting magnetic compass information at high northern latitudes even at very steep angles of inclination. However, starting a migratory journey at high latitudes and following a constant magnetic course often leads towards the North Magnetic Pole, which means that the usefulness of magnetic compass orientation at high latitudes may be questioned. Here, we compare possible long‐distance migration routes of three species of passerine migrants breeding at high northern latitudes. The initial directions were based on orientation cage experiments performed under clear skies and simulated overcast and from release experiments under natural overcast skies. For each species we simulated possible migration routes (geographic loxodrome, magnetic loxodrome and sun compass route) by extrapolating from the initial directions and assessing a fixed orientation according to different compass mechanisms in order to investigate what orientation cues the birds most likely use when migrating southward in autumn. Our calculations show that none of the compass mechanisms (assuming fixed orientation) can explain the migration routes followed by night‐migrating birds from their high Nearctic breeding areas to the wintering sites further south. This demonstrates that orientation along the migratory routes of arctic birds (and possibly other birds as well) must be a complex process, involving different orientation mechanisms as well as changing compass courses. We propose that birds use a combination of several compass mechanisms during a migratory journey with each of them being of a greater or smaller importance in different parts of the journey, depending on environmental conditions. We discuss reasons why birds developed the capability to use magnetic compass information at high northern latitudes even though following these magnetic courses for any longer distance will lead them along totally wrong routes. Frequent changes and recalibrations of the magnetic compass direction during the migratory journey are suggested as a possible solution.