Rumen methanogens: a review

The Methanogens are a diverse group of organisms found in anaerobic environments such as anaerobic sludge digester, wet wood of trees, sewage, rumen, black mud, black sea sediments, etc which utilize carbon dioxide and hydrogen and produce methane. They are nutritionally fastidious anaerobes with the redox potential below −300 mV and usually grow at pH range of 6.0–8.0 [1]. Substrates utilized for growth and methane production include hydrogen, formate, methanol, methylamine, acetate, etc. They metabolize only restricted range of substrates and are poorly characterized with respect to other metabolic, biochemical and molecular properties.     

Production of methane and hydrogen by anaerobic ciliates containing symbiotic methanogens

Rates of methane production by three anaerobic ciliates containing symbiotic methanogens (the marine Metopus contortus and Plagiopyla frontata, and the limnic Metopus palaeformis) were quantified. Hydrogen production by normal (containing active symbionts), aposymbiotic and BES-treated cells was also measured in the case of the marine species. Methanogenesis was closely coupled to host metabolism and growth; at maximum ciliate growth rates (20°C) each methanogen produced about 1 fmol CH₄ per hour corresponding to about 7, 4 and 0.35 pmol per ciliate per hour for M. contortus, P. frontata and M. palaeformis, respectively. Normal cells produced traces of H₂. Hydrogen production by BES-treated or aposymbiotic cells accounted for 75 and 45% of the methane production of normal M. contortus and P. frontata cells, respectively. However, it is possible that hydrogen production was partly inhibited in the absence of methanogens. Theoretical considerations suggest that hydrogen transfer is significant to the metabolism of larger anaerobic ciliates. Ciliates with methanogens produced CH₄ under microaerobic conditions due to their ability to maintain an anoxic intracellular environment at low external oxygen tensions. Methanogenesis was still detectable at a pO₂ of 0.63 kPa (3 %atm sat).     

Systematic and morphological diversity of endosymbiotic methanogens in anaerobic ciliates

The identities and taxonomic diversity of the endosymbiotic methanogens from the anaerobic protozoaMetopus contortus, Metopus striatus, Metopus palaeformis, Trimyema sp. andPelomyxa palustris were determined by comparative analysis of their 16S ribosomal RNA sequences. Fluorescent oligonucleotide probes were designed to bind to the symbiont rRNA sequences and to provide direct visual evidence of their origins from methanogenic archaea contained within the host cells. Confocal microscopy was used to analyze the morphology of the endosymbionts in whole cells ofMetopus palaeformis, Metopus contortus, Trimyema sp. andCyclidium porcatum. The endosymbionts are taxonomically diverse and are drawn from three different genera;Methanobacterium, Methanocorpusculum andMethanoplanus. In every case the symbionts are closely related to, but different from, free-living methanogens for which sequences are available. It is thus apparent that symbioses have been formed repeatedly and independently. Ciliates which are unrelated to each other (Trimyema sp. andMetopus contortus) may contain symbionts which are closely related, and congeneric ciliates (Metopus palaeformis andM. contortus) may contain symbionts which are distantly related to each other. This suggests that some of the symbiotic associations must be relatively recent. For example, at least one of the symbioses inMetopus must postdate the speciation ofM. palaeformis andM. contortus. Despite this,Metopus contortus, Trimyema sp., Cyclidium porcatum and their respective endosymbionts show sophisticated morphological interactions which probably facilitate the exchange of materials between the partners.     

Factors affecting rumen methanogens and methane mitigation strategies

The rumen is a highly diverse ecosystem comprising different microbial groups including methanogens that consume a considerable part of the ruminant’s nutrient energy in methane production. The consequences of methanogenesis in the rumen may result in the low productivity and possibly will have a negative impact on the sustainability of the ruminant’s production. Since enteric fermentation emission is one of the major sources of methane and is influenced by a number of environmental factors, diet being the most significant one, a number of in vitro and in vivo trials have been conducted with different feed supplements (halogenated methane analogues, bacteriocins, propionate enhancers, acetogens, fats etc.) for mitigating methane emissions directly or indirectly, yet extensive research is required before reaching a realistic solution. Keeping this in view, the present article aimed to cover comprehensively the different aspects of rumen methanogenesis such as the phylogeny of methanogens, their microbial ecology, factors affecting methane emission, mitigation strategies and need for further study.     

A re-appraisal of the diversity of the methanogens associated with the rumen ciliates

The diversity of methanogenic archaea associated with different species of ciliated protozoa in the rumen was analysed. Partial fragments of archaeal SSU rRNA genes were amplified from DNA isolated from single cells from the rumen protozoal species Metadinium medium, Entodinium furca, Ophryoscolex caudatus and Diplodinium dentatum. Sequence analysis of these fragments indicated that although all of the new isolates clustered with sequences previously described for methanogens, there was a difference in the relative distribution of sequences detected here as compared to that of previous work. In addition, many of the novel sequences, although clearly of archaeal origin have relatively low identity to the sequences in database which are most closely related to them.     

The effect of rumen ciliates on chitinolytic activity,chitin content and the number of fungal zoospores in the rumen fluid of sheep

The objective of this study was to investigate the effect of selected protozoa on the degradation and concentration of chitin and the numbers of fungal zoospores in the rumen fluid of sheep. Three adult ewes were fed a hay-concentrate diet, defaunated, then monofaunated with Entodinium caudatum or Diploplastron affine alone and refaunated with natural rumen fauna. The average density of the protozoa population varied from 6.1 · 10⁴ (D. affine) to 42.2 · 10⁴ cells/ml rumen fluid (natural rumen fauna). The inoculation of protozoa in the rumen of defaunated sheep increased the total activity of chitinolytic enzymes from 2.9 to 3.6 μmol N-acetylglucosamine/g dry matter (DM) of rumen fluid per min, the chitin concentration from 6.3 to 7.2 mg/g DM of rumen fluid and the number of fungal zoospores from 8.1 to 10.9 · 10⁵ cells/ml rumen fluid. All examined indices showed diurnal variations. Ciliate population density was highest immediately prior to feeding and lowest at 4 h thereafter. The opposite effects were observed for the numbers of fungal zoospores, the chitin concentration and chitinolytic activity. Furthermore, it was found that chitin from zoospores may account for up to 95% of total microbial chitin in the rumen fluid of sheep. In summary, the examined ciliate species showed the ability of chitin degradation as well as a positive influence on the development of the ruminal fungal population.     

Effect of insulin on in vitro fermentation activity of microrganism community of rumen ciliate Entodinium caudatum culture

The influence of insulin (17.4 nmol l-1) on total gas and methane production, the concentration of total and individual fatty acids and dry matter degradability was investigated in the rumen ciliate culture of Entodinium caudatum. The experimental groups consisted of control group (without insulin) and two groups with insulin application--single shot and long-term application (over 30 days). Fermentation activity of each experimental group was observed on two subgroups: whole protozoan culture (protozoa plus bacteria) and bacterial fraction (bacteria without protozoa). Long-term application of insulin significantly increased methane production and DM degradability in the whole protozoan culture. Total VFA concentration was significantly increased by long-term as well as single-dose application of insulin (by 255% and 158%, respectively). The growth of the protozoa was not influenced by insulin treatments. It can be concluded that the fermentation activity of the community of the rumen ciliate Entodinium caudatum culture was marked stimulated by application of insulin.     

Anti-methanogenic effect of rhubarb (Rheum spp.) – An in silico docking studies on methyl-coenzyme M reductase (MCR)

The present study explored anti-methanogenic properties of rhubarb compounds using in silico analysis on methyl-coenzyme M reductase (MCR) for identifying its anti-methanogen mechanism. To identify pharmacokinetics of 35 compounds from rhubarb, molecular docking and ADME analysis were performed against MCR using AutoDockVina, FAFDrugs3 and PROTOX programs. Docking results successfully indicated three possible candidate compounds 9,10-anthracenedione, 1,8-dihydroxy-3-methyl (?6.92 kcal/mol); phthalic acid isobutyl octadecyl ester (?5.26 kcal/mol); and diisooctyl phthalate (?5.61 kcal/mol) showed minimum binding energy (kcal/mol) with the target protein MCR which catalyze the biosynthesis of rumen methane. In conclusion, the identified compounds showed the most docking fitness score against the target methyl-coenzyme M reductase and the decrease in ruminal methane emission by rhubarb might be a result of these compounds by inhibition of methanogenesis.     

Effects of mixtures of lauric and myristic acid on rumen methanogens and methanogenesis in vitro

AIMS: To identify the most effective mixture of non-esterified lauric (C12) and myristic (C14) acid in suppressing ruminal methanogenesis, and to investigate their effects on the methanogenic population. METHODS AND RESULTS: C12/C14 mixtures were incubated with rumen fluid using the Hohenheim gas test apparatus. Methane production and the numbers of Archaea declined with an increasing proportion of C12. With a 2 : 1 proportion of C12/C14, the maximum methane-suppressing effect (96%) was achieved similar to that with C12 alone. The proportions of the individual methanogenic orders of total methanogens were altered by varying the C12/C14 ratio. CONCLUSIONS: Although C14 alone had no effect on methanogenesis, C14 enhanced the methane-suppressing effect of C12 in certain mixtures. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: The results support strategies for an environment-friendly ruminant nutrition as it was demonstrated that part of the less palatable C12 could be replaced by C14 without losing its methane-suppressing potential.     

Effect of combined herbal feed additives on methane,total gas production and rumen fermentation

The present study was to evaluate effect of herbal feed additives on methane and total gas production during the rumen fermentation for environment and animal health concern. Different parts of the five medicinal plants were selected such as leaf and small stems of Ocimum sanctum (Tulsi), roots of Curcuma longa (Haldi), fruits of Emblica officinalis (Amla), leaves of Azadirachta indica (Neem) and leaves and small stem of Clerodendrum phlomidis (Arni) for our study. Addition of different herbal additive combinations did not influence IVDMD and total gas production however methane production (mg/g of substrate DM) was significantly (P<0.05) reduced in Amla: Neem and Neem: Arni combinations. Total nitrogen significantly (P<0.01) increased in the combinations of Tulsi: Haldi and Amla: Neem. TCA–ppt-N is significantly (P<0.01) increased in Tulsi: Haldi, Haldi: Amla, Amla: Neem and Neem: Arni however NH₃-N (mg/dl) significantly decreased in all treatments. We conclude that the screening of plant combinations, Amla: Neem and Neem: Arni have potential to decrease methane production and our herbal feed supplements have no side-effects on the ruminant in small amount.     

Xylanases and carboxymethylcellulases of the rumen protozoa Polyplastron multivesiculatum, Eudiplodinium maggii and Entodinium sp

Endoglucanase and xylanase activities of three rumen protozoa, Polyplastron multivesiculatum, Eudiplodinium maggii, and Entodinium sp. were compared qualitatively by zymograms and quantitatively by measuring specific activities against different polysaccharides. A set of carboxymethylcellulases and xylanases was produced by the large ciliates whereas no band of activity was observed for Entodinium sp. in zymograms. Specific activity of endoglucanases from P. multivesiculatum (1.3 micromol mg prot(-1) min(-1)) was twice that of E. maggii, whereas xylanase specific activity (4.5 micromol mg prot(-1) min(-1)) was only half. Very weak activities were observed for Entodinium sp. A new xylanase gene, xyn11D, from P. multivesiculatum was reported and its gene product compared to 33 other family 11 xylanases. Phylogenetic analysis showed that xylanase sequences from rumen protozoa are closely related to those of bacteria.     

16S rDNA directed PCR primers and detection of methanogens in the bovine rumen

AIMS: To assess the diversity of ruminal methanogens in a grazing cow, and develop PCR primers targeting the predominant methanogens. METHODS AND RESULTS: DNA was extracted from rumen contents collected from a cow grazing pasture. Archaeal 16S rRNA genes were amplified by PCR using two pairs of archaea-specific primers, and clone libraries prepared. Selected clones were sequenced. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that for one primer pair, most sequences clustered with Methanobrevibacter spp. whereas with the other primer pair most clustered with Methanosphaera stadtmanae. One sequence belonged to the Crenarcheota. PCR primers were designed to detect Msp. stadtmanae and differentiate between Mbb. ruminantium and Mbb. smithii and successfully tested. CONCLUSIONS: The ruminal methanogens included Mbb. ruminantium, Mbb. smithii, Mbb. thaueri and methanogens similar to Msp.stadtmanae. The study showed that apparent methanogen diversity can be affected by selectivity from the archaea-specific primers used to create clone libraries. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: This study revealed a greater diversity of ruminal methanogens in grazing cows than previously recognized. It also shows the need for care in interpreting methanogen diversity using PCR-based analyses. The new PCR primers will enable more information to be obtained on Msp. stadtmanae and Methanobrevibacter spp. in the rumen.     

Relationship between rumen methanogens and methane production in dairy cows fed diets supplemented with a feed enzyme additive

Aims: To investigate the relationship between ruminal methanogen community and host enteric methane (CH₄) production in lactating dairy cows fed diets supplemented with an exogenous fibrolytic enzyme additive. Methods and Results: Ecology of ruminal methanogens from dairy cows fed with or without exogenous fibrolytic enzymes was examined using PCR–denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (PCR–DGGE) analyses and quantitative real‐time PCR (qRT‐PCR). The density of methanogens was not affected by the enzyme additive or sampling times, and no relationship was observed between the total methanogen population and CH₄ yield (as g per head per day or g kg^?1 DMI). The PCR–DGGE profiles consisted of 26 distinctive bands, with two bands similar to Methanogenic archaeon CH1270 negatively correlated, and one band similar to Methanobrevibacter gottschalkii strain HO positively correlated, with CH₄ yield. Three bands similar to Methanogenic archaeon CH1270 or Methanobrevibacter smithii ATCC 35061 appeared after enzyme was added. Conclusions: Supplementing a dairy cow diet with an exogenous fibrolytic enzyme additive increased CH₄ yield and altered the composition of the rumen methanogen community, but not the overall density of methanogens. Significance and Impact of the Study: This is the first study to identify the correlation between methanogen ecology and host CH₄ yield from lactating dairy cows.     

A 43 kDa protein inserted at the plasma membrane-cytoskeleton interface in rumen entodiniomorphid ciliates

Summary The P-43 ofEudiplodinium and homologous proteins in three other entodiniomorphid species, free-living ciliates, flagellates, and HeLa cells, were identified at the plasma membrane-cytoskeleton interface. Proteins cross-reacting with MAb B6 were also located at the ciliary inner surface of the plasma membrane. Due to the strong adhesion of the plasma membrane to the underlying cytoskeleton, classical extraction with detergents, urea, NaOH, and PTA, failed to separate the two components completely. However, the extraction properties of P-43, associated with its membrane-cytoskeleton interactive functions, suggest that this unglycosylated protein may present some analogies with proteins of the intermediate filaments. Their ubiquity and localization suggest that P-43 and MAb B6 crossreacting proteins may not be strictly epiplasmic but could be amphitropic proteins, strongly anchored to both the plasma membrane and the underlying microfilament framework, via protein-protein binding or by direct insertion in the lipid bilayer.Abbreviations BSA bovine serum albumin - Con A concanavalin A - EDTA ethylene diamine tetraacetic acid - EM electron microscopy - IF intermediate filaments - MAb monoclonal antibody - MET 2-mercaptoethanol - MW molecular weight - PAb polyclonal antibody - PBS phosphate buffered saline - PMSF phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride - PTA phosphotungstic acid - SDS sodiumdodecyl sulfate - TAME Na-p-tosyl-arginine methyl ester - TLCK Na-p-tosyl-lysine chloromethyl ketone     

Effects of protozoa on Methane production in rumen and hindgut of calves around time of weaning

Effects of the presence or absence of ciliate protozoa on methanogenesis in the rumen and hindgut were investigated in young calves during a 7-week period. Ten Holstein calves, aged 7 days, were divided in two groups (n = 5) and fed an increasing amount of a commercial milk replacer and small amounts of a calves starter. One group was inoculated with ciliate fauna on two occasions, week 5 and 6, while the second remained ciliate-free. The absence of protozoa in the rumen decreased rumen empty weight ( ? 23%, P < 0.01), and rumen pool size of N ( ? 36%, P < 0.01) and crude fat ( ? 37%, P < 0.05). Rumen bacteria of non-faunated calves contained a higher proportion of total amino acid-N per 16 g N ( + 3%, P < 0.01) and D-alanine-N per 16 g N ( + 13%, P < 0.05) compared to faunated calves. Further results contain a reference for a higher bacterial mass in the ciliate-free rumen with an increased number of bacteria adherent to rumen mucosa. The CH₄ production in the rumen increased exponentially with the increase in protozoa population size (R² = 0.68). In presence of 46 · 10⁴ protozoa per ml rumen fluid, the in vitro CH₄ production of rumen fluid per mol total VFA was about 34% higher in faunated than in non-faunated calves (P < 0.001). Hydrogen (2H) recovery of rumen fermentation was positively correlated (R² = 0.55) to the CH₄ production rate. Methanogens were attached on rumen mucosa. Methanogenesis, induced by rumen mucosa attached bacteria, was stimulated by ruminal protozoa. In the absence of protozoa in the rumen, the acetate - propionate ratio and butyrate proportion of VFA were reduced. In vivo in the absence of protozoa not only the whole animal CH₄ production ( ? 30%, P < 0.05) but also the digestibility of carbohydrates ( ? 4%, P < 0.05) was reduced. Thereby no difference was observed in the intake of ME per kg DM between the groups. In conclusion, the methanogenesis in the rumen, but not in hindgut, is associated with the development of the ruminal protozoa population. The level of methanogenesis (mol/mol VFA) in the hindgut amounts to 20% of the ruminal methanogenesis.     

Diversity and activity of enriched ruminal cultures of anaerobic fungi and methanogens grown together on lignocellulose in consecutive batch culture

Consecutive batch cultures (CBC), involving nine serial transfers at 3, 5 and 7 d intervals (21, 45 and 63 d, respectively) were established to enrich for plant fibre degrading co-cultures of anaerobic fungi and methanogens from rumen digesta. Microbial diversity and fermentation end-products were measured at appropriate intervals over each CBC time-course. While methanogenic populations remained diverse, anaerobic fungal diversity was related to transfer interval and appeared to decrease with increasing transfer number. Acetate was the principal aqueous fermentation end-product with minimal quantities of lactate and formate detected. Methane and carbon dioxide were detected in the gaseous head-space of all co-cultures and the total amounts of gas generated per transfer was greater with transfer intervals of 5 and 7 d compared with a 3 d interval, although the 3 d interval tended to be more efficient per unit time. In conclusion, rapidly growing, methane producing co-cultures of anaerobic fungi and methanogens from rumen digesta were easy to establish on lignocellulose (barley straw) and maintain over considerable time periods. These results suggest such co-cultures have potential in industrial scale anaerobic digestion (AD) of highly fibrous substrates, which are resistant to degradation in conventional AD plants.     

Bioconversion of carbon dioxide to methane using hydrogen and hydrogenotrophic methanogens

Biogas produced from organic wastes contains energetically usable methane and unavoidable amount of carbon dioxide. The exploitation of whole biogas energy is locally limited and utilization of the natural gas transport system requires CO₂ removal or its conversion to methane. The biological conversion of CO₂ and hydrogen to methane is well known reaction without the demand of high pressure and temperature and is carried out by hydrogenotrophic methanogens. Reducing equivalents to the biotransformation of carbon dioxide from biogas or other resources to biomethane can be supplied by external hydrogen. Discontinuous electricity production from wind and solar energy combined with fluctuating utilization cause serious storage problems that can be solved by power-to-gas strategy representing the production of storable hydrogen via the electrolysis of water. The possibility of subsequent repowering of the energy of hydrogen to the easily utilizable and transportable form is a biological conversion with CO₂ to biomethane. Biomethanization of CO₂ can take place directly in anaerobic digesters fed with organic substrates or in separate bioreactors. The major bottleneck in the process is gas-liquid mass transfer of H₂ and the method of the effective input of hydrogen into the system. There are many studies with different bioreactors arrangements and a way of enrichment of hydrogenotrophic methanogens, but the system still has to be optimized for a higher efficiency. The aim of the paper is to gather and critically assess the state of a research and experience from laboratory, pilot and operational applications of carbon dioxide bioconversion and highlight further perspective fields of research.     

Assessing the impact of rumen microbial communities on methane emissions and production traits in Holstein cows in a tropical climate

The evaluation of how the gut microbiota affects both methane emissions and animal production is necessary in order to achieve methane mitigation without production losses. Toward this goal, the aim of this study was to correlate the rumen microbial communities (bacteria, archaea, and fungi) of high (HP), medium (MP), and low milk producing (LP), as well as dry (DC), Holstein dairy cows in an actual tropical production system with methane emissions and animal production traits. Overall, DC cows emitted more methane, followed by MP, HP and LP cows, although HP and LP cow emissions were similar. Using next-generation sequencing, it was found that bacteria affiliated with Christensenellaceae, Mogibacteriaceae, S24-7, Butyrivibrio, Schwartzia, and Treponema were negatively correlated with methane emissions and showed positive correlations with digestible dry matter intake (dDMI) and digestible organic matter intake (dOMI). Similar findings were observed for archaea in the genus Methanosphaera. The bacterial groups Coriobacteriaceae, RFP12, and Clostridium were negatively correlated with methane, but did not correlate with dDMI and dOMI. For anaerobic fungal communities, no significant correlations with methane or animal production traits were found. Based on these findings, it is suggested that manipulation of the abundances of these microbial taxa may be useful for modulating methane emissions without negatively affecting animal production.