Immune Response against Hamster Erythrocytes in the Low-Responder Mouse Strains

Enhancing and suppressing effects of microbial adjuvants were studied in female mice of the C3H/He, AKR and SL strains. Propionibacterium acnes, Bordetella pertussis, BCG and yeast cell wall (YCW) were chosen as adjuvants. As antigens, we chose hamster erythrocytes (HRBC) which proved to be a weak antigen for mice. Adjuvants were given on day —7, day 0 or day 3, and HRBC were injected on day 0. The results were as follows. 1) P. acnes facilitated IgM and IgG antibody production in AKR mice and suppressed IgM antibody production in SL mice, when given on day —7. When P. acnes was given on day 0, they suppressed IgM antibody production in all of the strains used. 2) When B. pertussis was given on day 0, it exhibited enhancing effects on IgG antibody production in all of the strains and a suppressing effect on IgM antibody production in SL mice. 3) BCG suppressed IgM antibody production in all strains when given on day 0. 4) YCW showed no influence on antibody production in any combination used in this work. 5) SL mice were very sensitive to suppressing effects by adjuvants. Strain differences in the expression of enhancing and suppressing effects by adjuvants appear to be under some control independent of antigen-specific immune response genes.     

Immune Response against Hamster Erythrocytes in the Low-Responder Mouse Strains

1) A subcutaneous injection of hamster erythrocytes (HRBC) in Freund's complete adjuvant (FCA) or an intravenous injection of hamster lymph node (HLN) cells suppressed antibody production against HRBC in the low-responder C57BL/6 and AKR mice, when HRBC in saline were given on the same day; 2) The suppressing effect of such treatments was neither detectable in the high-responder SL mice, nor in the C57BL/6 mice, which had been pre-sensitized with HRBC in FCA or hamster lymphoma cells; 3) Positive reactions of the peritoneal macrophage disappearance test and the enhanced antibody production were detected seven days after treatment with HRBC in FCA and HRBC in saline, or HLN cells and HRBC in saline; 4) The suppressing effect of such simultaneous treatments on anti-HRBC antibody production was eliminated by a transfer of normal syngeneic thymus cells to AKR mice or a transfer of thymus cells from SL to C57BL/6 mice. Suppression of the antibody production in the low-responder mice by the described simultaneous treatments may be due to a competitive involvement of HRBC-specific thymus-derived cells (T cells) in the developmental stages of delayed hypersensitivity and antibody production. High-responder SL mice appear to have enough T cells for development of the delayed hypersensitivity and as helper cells in antibody production. These results appear to support the concept that T cells for delayed hypersensitivity and antibody production to HRBC antigen are derived from the same original pool.     

Immunological properties of Propionibacterium acnes. I. Potentiation and Suppression on antibody response to sheep and hamster erythrocytes in mice.

Adjuvant activity of phenol-treated cells of Propionibacterium acnes C-7 in antibody response was investigated in ICR mice. Simultaneous administration (day 0) of P. acnes (i.p.) and sheep red blood cells (SRBC) (i.v.) enhanced the formation of direct plaque-forming cells (PFC) on days 2, and the formation of indirect PFC response on day 7 and thereafter. Conversely, pretreatment from 11 to 14 days before antigen injection suppressed markedly the antibody response. The potentiation and the suppression of immune response depended on doses of antigen and of P. acnes, the timing of adjuvant injection and the time of assay. The two opposite phenomena caused by P. acnes were also confirmed in antibody response against hamster red blood cells (HRBC). Pretreatment with P. acnes 1 to 14 days before antigen injection suppressed markedly anti-HRBC antibody response, whereas P. acnes injected simultaneously with HRBC or one day after injection of the antigen induced prolongation of antibody response and the production of 2-mercaptoethanol-resistant antibody.     

Immune Response against Hamster Erythrocytes in the Low-Responder Mouse Strains

Delayed hypersensitivity against hamster erythrocyte antigen was examined after sensitization with hamster erythrocytes (HRBC) in Freund's complete adjuvant (FCA). Extent of the delayed hypersensitivity was determined by the migration inhibition test, the peritoneal macrophage disappearance test and the skin test in the ear using solubilized HRBC as the test antigen. 1) Delayed hypersensitivity against HRBC developed earlier in high-responder SL mice than in low-responder C57BL/6 mice after sensitization. The period required for development of the delayed hypersensitivity in AKR mice was intermediate between periods in high-responder SL mice and low-responder C57BL/6 mice. 2) After sensitization with HRBC in FCA, a delayed hypersensitive state without detectable antibody production persisted until day 12 in high-responder SL mice and until day 16 or later in low-responder C57BL/6 mice. 3) Delayed hypersensitivity against HRBC antigen persisted even after the appearance of circulating antibody which occurred late after sensitization with HRBC in FCA or after intravenous injection of HRBC into sensitized mice.     

Effects of BCG (Bacillus Calmette–Guérin) Vaccines on Immune Responses in Mice

The effects of killed and living BCG on antibody production against hamster erythrocytes (HRBC) and the 2, 4, 6-trinitrophenyl (TNP) group were studied in SL mice. Killed and living BCG, each in doses of 0.008 mg, 0.08 mg, 0.8 mg and 8 mg per mouse, were intravenously inoculated 7 days prior to primary immunization with HRBC. Secondary immunization was carried out 28 days later with TNP-HRBC. Anti-HRBC and anti-TNP antibodies were estimated by a hemagglutination test. The results showed that pretreatment with killed or living BCG enhanced the antibody production against both HRBC and TNP. Comparing the effects of these two BCG preparations, it was noted that killed BCG augmented the anti-HRBC antibody production more effectively than living BCG. In regard to the anti-TNP antibody production, living BCG exhibited a greater augmenting effect than killed BCG. This difference in the modes of action of killed and living BCG was remarkable when two groups given 8 mg of killed and living BCG were compared. In addition, it was shown that living BCG at a dose as high as 8 mg was able to augment the anti-TNP antibody production, even in the absence of preceding immunization with HRBC.     

Effects of BCG (Bacillus Calmette-Guérin) vaccines on immune responses in mice. I. Possible effect of BCG on helper T cells.

The effects of killed and living BCG on antibody production against hamster erythrocytes (HRBC) and the 2, 4, 6-trinitrophenyl (TNP) group were studied in SL mice. Killed and living BCG, each in doses of 0.008 mg, 0.08 mg, 0.8 mg and 8 mg per mouse, were intravenously inoculated 7 days prior to primary immunization with HRBC. Secondary immunization was carried out 28 days later with TNP-HRBC. Anti-HRBC and anti-TNP antibodies were estimated by a hemagglutination test. The results showed that pretreatment with killed or living BCG enhanced the antibody production against both HRBC and TNP. Comparing the effects of these two BCG preparations, it was noted that killed BCG augmented the anti-HRBC antibody production more effectively than living BCG. In regard to the anti-TNP antibody production, living BCG exhibited a greater augmenting effect than killed BCG. This difference in the modes of action of killed and living BCG was remarkable when two groups given 8 mg of killed and living BCG were compared. In addition, it was shown that living BCG at a dose as high as 8 mg was able to augment the anti-TNP antibody production, even in the absence of preceding immunization with HRBC.     

Immune Response against Hamster Erythrocytes in the Low-Responder Mouse Strains

C57BL/6 and AKR mice were treated with hamster erythrocytes (HRBC) in complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA) or incomplete Freund's adjuvant (IFA) and the development of delayed hypersensitivity and antibody production were examined. 1) Delayed hypersensitivity against HRBC antigen, as determined by the peritoneal macrophage disappearance test, was detected in mice sensitized with HRBC in CFA but not in those sensitized with HRBC in IFA. 2) Antibody production against HRBC or hapten TNP after a booster injection of HRBC or trinitrophenylated HRBC (TNP-HRBC) in saline was enhanced by pretreatment with HRBC in CFA or IFA. 3) Delayed hypersensitivity was not detectable after a booster sensitization with HRBC in CFA in mice which had been pretreated with HRBC in IFA 2 weeks earlier. In the mice treated with both HRBC in IFA (day ?21) and in CFA (day ?7), however, an enhanced antibody production against HRBC or TNP was detected after an intravenous injection with HRBC or TNP-HRBC in saline (day 0). These results suggest that sensitized effector lymphocytes in delayed hypersensitivity and helper cells in antibody production may be derived from the same pool of unprimed T cells. The pool of unprimed T cells with a capacity to differentiate into either type of primed T cells may be exhausted after pretreatment with the antigen in IFA, and the primed helper T cells may not be able to differentiate into sensitized lymphocytes even after sensitization with the antigen in CFA, which favors development of delayed hypersensitivity in normal controls.     

Immune Response against Hamster Erythrocytes in the Low-Responder Mouse Strains

It was confirmed by passive transfer experiments that the function of thymus-derived cells specific for hamster erythrocytes (HRBC) was deficient in the low-responder mouse strains. 1) Antibody production against HRBC was enhanced by passive transfer of thymus cells from normal SL mice (high-responder) to normal C57BL/6 mice (low-responder). 2) The enhancing effect of passive transfer of thymus cells from SL mice was abrogated by pre-sensitization of the recipients (C57BL/6) with thymus cells from SL mice. 3) In C57BL/6 mice, antibody production against HRBC was enhanced by the transfer of lymph node or spleen cells from C57BL/6 mice which had been sensitized with HRBC in Freund's complete adjuvant or hamster lymphoma cells.     

Immune Response against Hamster Erythrocytes in the Low-Responder Mouse Strains

Antibody response against hamster red blood cells (H-RBC) was examined in inbred strains of C57BL/6, AKR, C3H/He, DDD and SL mice, and outbred CF1 mice. 1) There were strain differences in antibody response after a primary intravenous injection of H-RBC. DDD, SL and CF1 mice belonged to high-responder strains, while C57BL/6, AKR and C3H/He to low-responder strains. In the spleens of immunized CF1 and SL, 40 to 70 times as many plaque-forming cells (PFC) as those in C57BL/6 mice were detected. The magnitudes of the response were: CF1 ≒ SL>DDD>>C3H/He ? AKR>C57BL/6. 2) 2-mercaptoethanol resistant (MER) antibody was detected in neither low- nor high-responders after a primary intravenous antigen-injection. 3) After a secondary intravenous antigen-injection, MER antibody was detected in all the SL mice, but only in 30 to 50% of AKR and C57BL/6 mice. 4) A subcutaneous injection of H-RBC in Freund's complete adjuvant (FCA) did not elicit antibody production within 10 days. When mice pre-sensitized 7 days in advance w^Tith H-RBC in FCA were intravenously injected with H-RBC, enhanced antibody production of the primary type was observed in all the mouse strains. 5) In pre-sensitized mice, the extent of the enhancement of antibody production was the highest in low-responder C57BL/6 mice and the lowest in high-responder SL and CF1 strains. Thus, there was no strain difference in antibody titers or the numbers of PFC after the booster.     

Immune Response against Hamster Erythrocytes in the Low-Responder Mouse Strains

Patterns of proliferation of antibody-forming cells after an intravenous immunization with hamster erythrocytes (HRBC) were compared in groups of mice possessing different activities of thymus-derived lymphocytes (T cells). 1) Marked differences in the numbers of hemolysin plaque-forming cells (PFC) after HRBC injection were found among the low- and high-responder normal mice and those pretreated with HRBC in complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA) or incomplete adjuvant (IFA), and they appeared to depend primarily upon the different rates of proliferation of antibody-forming cells rather than on the numbers of antigen-specific lymphocytes initiating the antibody response. 2) The numbers of hemolytic foci were slightly larger in mice with large numbers of PFC (normal SL mice, the pretreated SL and C57BL/6 mice) than in those with small numbers of PFC (normal C57BL/6 mice). The numbers of hemolytic foci increased at almost the same rate from day 2 to day 3 in both groups, while the numbers of PFC increased more efficiently in mice with large numbers of PFC than in those with small numbers of PFC from day 2 to day 3. Individual hemolytic foci appeared to contain larger numbers of PFC in mice with large total numbers of PFC than in those with small total numbers of PFC. 3) The numbers of rosette-forming cells (RFC) were increased by pretreatment with HRBC in CFA and by pretreatment with HRBC in IFA to almost the same extent. Rates of increases in PFC were, however, larger by pretreatment with HRBC in CFA than with HRBC in IFA. These results suggested that the activity of the T cell determined not only the rates of proliferation of antibody-forming cells but also the antibody-producing capacity of each cell.     

Immunoadjuvant treatment of primary grafted and spontaneous AKR-leukemia. I. Treatment efficiency correlated to autoimmune reactivity.

Young AKR mice grafted i.v. with 10(1) or 10(3) cells from spontaneous AKR thymomas were treated with repeated i.v. injections of BCG or subcutaneous injections of irradiated AKR thymoma cells. BCG often cured mice from graft leukemia, whereas the effect of irradiated thymoma cells was less effective. Mice that did not develop graft-leukemia after graft of 10(1) leukemia cells and BCG treatment showed a spontaneous leukemia in 30% of the cases later. Ninety percent of nongrafted mice developed spontaneous leukemia whether BCG-treated or not. General immune reactivity as assessed in individual mice by T and B lymphocyte mitogen tests as well as the hemolytic plaque-forming cell assay had no clear correlation to the effects of immune adjuvants in respect to survival. In contrast, occurrence of self-directed immune reactions were clearly correlated to survival and cure of grafted and BCG-treated mice as revealed by assays both in vitro and in vivo. However, 13 to 25% of the mice apparently cured of leukemia developed a wasting-like syndrome that sometimes terminated in death. The immplications of self-directed immune reactions as mediators of the anti-neoplastic effects of immunoadjuvants.     

Immune Response against Hamster Erythrocytes in the Low-Responder Mouse Strains

The production of anti-hapten antibody after immunization with trinitrophenylated (TNP) hamster erythrocytes (HRBC) or sheep erythrocytes (SRBC) was determined in high- and low-responder mouse strains against HRBC antigen. 1) Anti-TNP antibody was detected in sera of high-responder DDD and CF1 mice after primary immunization with TNP-HRBC, but not in those of low-responder C57BL/6 mice. 2) Anti-TNP antibody was detectable in sera of all the strains after primary immunization with TNP-SRBC. 3) Production of anti-TNP antibody was elicited after a booster injection of TNP-HRBC in low-responder C57BL/6 mice pre-sensitized with HRBC in Freund's complete adjuvant. These results suggest that functions of thymus-derived cells specific for HRBC antigen are deficient in low-responder mice.     

Immune Response against Hamster Erythrocytes in the Low-Responder Mouse Strains

In a previous paper we reported that an inbred strain of SL mice and an outbred strain of CF1 mice belonged to the high-responder strains in antibody production after primary immunization with hamster erythrocytes (H-RBC), while inbred strains of C57BL/6, AKR and C3H/He mice belonged to low-responder strains. In the present study we obtained the following results. 1) Pre-sensitization with hamster lymphoma enhanced antibody production after an intravenous injection of H-RBC. There was no strain difference in the pattern of antibody production against H-RBC among pre-sensitized mice. 2) The pattern of enhanced antibody production after an intravenous injection of H-RBC into pre-sensitized mice assumed the primary type in terms of time of appearance of hemolysin plaque-forming cells (PFC) in the spleens and the conversion from 2-mercaptoethanol sensitive to 2-mercaptoethanol resistant antibody production, when the intervals between both treatments were within 7 days. 3) Pre-sensitization with lymphoma induced not only an increase in numbers of PFC after an intravenous injection of H-RBC, but also an increase in the size of the hemolysin plaques. These results suggested that sensitization with hamster lymphoma stimulated some kinds of immuno-competent cells, which could contribute to antibody production against H-RBC after a booster injection of H-RBC.     

Studies on adjuvants for human prophylactics. III. Comparison of adjuvanticity in different animal species.

Activities of common adjuvants were compared in mice, rabbits and monkeys with tetanus toxoid as an antigen. Aluminium gel showed consistently high adjuvanticity for antitoxin production in all animal species examined when administered subcutaneously. Water-in-oil in water (w/o/w) showed high activity comparable to that of aluminium in mice and rabbits but no activity in monkeys. Endotoxin was considerably effective in rabbits and monkeys but not so in mice. Production of both IgM and IgG antitoxin was promoted by the effective adjuvants in rabbits and monkeys. In mice, however, the effects of adjuvants on the production of IgM antitoxin was less significant and inconsistent. Contrary to the case of guinea pigs, tetanus antitoxin was produced in mice by ip injection to a level comparable to that induced by sc injection. The effects of adjuvants in mice administered by ip and sc injection were not significantly different from each other.     

Difference in antibody production to hererologus erythrocytes in conventional, specific-pathogen-free (SPF), germfree and antigen-free mice.

The expression of antibody-producing capacities against hamster erythrocytes (HRBC), known to be weakly immunogenic in mice, was compared among conventional, SPF, germfree and antigen-free mice. ICR strain germfree and antigen-free mice showed antibody production to HRBC comparable to that in conventional or specific-pathogen-free (SPF) mice. In the NC strain, some of the conventional mice produced low titers of antibody after a single injection of HRBC, but none of the germfree mice showed such a transient antibody production. In the ICR-KIG strain, which was selected from the colony-bred ICR strain, antibodies with high titers were produced after a single injection of HRBC under both conventional and germfree conditions. The onset of conversion from 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME) sensitive to 2-ME resistant antibody after a single injection of HRBC was not delayed in the germfree mice when compared with the conventional or SPF mice. Antibody production to sheep erythrocytes (SRBC), known to be highly immunogenic in mice, was not influenced by exogeneous stimulation from microorganisms or diet. No differences in antibody production to SRBC were detected irrespective of the maintenance conditions of the mice. Stimulation with microorganisms or diet may not be required as essential elements for the maturation of antibody-producing capacities, but such a stimulation appears to modify the antibody response. The modifying effect was more prominent in the antibody response against weakly immunogenic antigens than against highly immunogenic ones.     

Immune Response against Hamster Erythrocytes in the Low-Responder Mouse Strains

Golden hamsters were used as hosts in this work, and mice of various strains as donors of antigens. 1) There were no strain differences in immunogenicity of erythrocytes from C57BL/6, AKR, SL and CF1 mice. 2) Primary intravenous immunization with mouse erythrocytes (MRBC) induced the production of hemolysin plaque-forming cells (PFC) in a large number, but elicited only in a negligible titer production of 2-mercaptoethanol-resistant antibody. 3) 2-Mercaptoethanol-resistant antibody was produced more efficiently in hamsters pre-sensitized with mouse lymph node (MLN) cells rather than those pre-immunized with MRBC after a booster with MRBC. 4) Numbers of PFC in pre-sensitized hamsters were three-times that of the non-sensitized hamsters after a booster with MRBC, when pre-sensitization was performed intradermally with a small number of MLN cells. 5) Average diameter of the hemolysin plaques in pre-sensitized hamsters was one and a half times larger than that in non-sensitized hamsters. Conclusions agree well with the results in our previous papers that the reversed combination of hosts and antigen donors employed support the concept that certain processes required for delayed hypersensitivity contributed to antibody production under a condition suitable for antibody response.     

The influence of adjuvant on induction of protective immunity by a non-living vaccine against schistosomiasis

Mice were protected against subsequent infection with Schistosoma mansoni by intradermal or s.c. vaccination with killed schistosomula or soluble parasite extracts and bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG). Treatment with i.p. immunization was somewhat less effective, whereas i.m. vaccination failed to elicit protective immunity. The level of resistance induced by intradermal immunization was influenced by the strain of BCG used, and isolated BCG cell walls did not reliably substitute for whole BCG organisms as adjuvant. Bordetella pertussis vaccine and saponin were also able to function as adjuvants for protective immunity in this model, whereas other immunopotentiators including Corynebacterium parvum and aluminum hydroxide were ineffective. No correlation between resistance to challenge infection and antibody levels was detected. Animals immunized intradermally using either protective or non-protective adjuvants all showed minimal humoral reactivity against schistosomulum surface Ag but strong IgG response to soluble parasite components including paramyosin, which is the major serologically recognized Ag in mice vaccinated intradermally with schistosome Ag plus BCG and is protective in this model. In contrast, a strong correlation was observed between resistance and Ag-specific cell-mediated reactivity, including IFN production by T lymphocytes in vitro and macrophage activation in vivo. These results further substantiate the hypothesis that protection in this model is based on cell-mediated immune effector mechanisms. Moreover, they may be of general relevance in the design of vaccination protocols using other Ag or against other infectious agents.     

Evidence for differential induction of helper T cell subsets during Trichinella spiralis infection

The H-2-compatible mouse strains, AKR and B10.BR, exhibit disparate responses to infection with the parasitic nematode Trichinella spiralis. The resistant AKR mice expel intestinal adult worms faster than susceptible B10.BR mice. We tested antibody and lymphokine responses in these strains. With respect to antibody responses, the B10.BR mice had 3- to 10-fold more serum IgE and T. spiralis-specific IgG1 and IgA than AKR mice. The B10.BR mice also had greater numbers of IgG and IgA plaque-forming cells than AKR mice. In contrast, AKR mice produced T. spiralis-specific IgG2a, whereas the B10.BR mice did not. The antibody response kinetics of these strains were similar. We also analyzed lymphokine secretion after restimulating lymphocytes in vitro with T. spiralis Ag. The AKR mesenteric lymph node cells produced more IFN-gamma and less IL-4 than the B10.BR mesenteric lymph node cells. The B10.BR splenocytes produced more IL-4 than the AKR splenocytes, although splenocyte IFN-gamma production was not different. The kinetics of IL-4 production also differed between the two strains. In summary, resistant AKR mice produced more IFN-gamma and T. spiralis-specific IgG2a than susceptible B10.BR mice, which produced more IL-4, IgE, and T. spiralis-specific IgG1. Our results are consistent with differential activation of Th cell subsets in T. spiralis-infected AKR and B10.BR mice.     

Hapten-specific IgE antibody responses in mice. VII. Conversion of IgE "non-responder" strains to IgE "responders" by elimination of suppressor T cell activity.

Mice of the inbred strains SJL (H-2s) and AKR (H-2k) are "non-responders" and "low-responders," respectively, in terms of their capacity to develop antibody responses of the IgE class when immunized with conventional proteins and hapten-protein conjugates under conditions optimal for eliciting IgE responses in "high-responder" mice, such as BALB/c (H-2d), to these same antigens. For example, BALB/c mice preimmunized with ASC and then challenged 7 days later with DNP-ASC develop peak augmented primary IgE anti-DNP antibody responses of 320 PCA units, whereas SJL and AKR mice develop responses which are 16-fold and 4-fold lower, respectively. However, pretreatment of the latter two strains with appropriate doses of either x-irradiation (150 R), cyclophosphamide (100 mg/kg) or ALS (150 mul) before carrier-preimmunization strikingly enhances the magnitude of IgE antibody responses in such mice to levels as high as 64-fold above those of untreated control mice of the same strains. Evidence obtained in these experiments indicates that the capacity of such maneuvers to to convert poor IgE responders to high responder status reflects elimination of nonantigen-specific suppressor T lymphocytes which are naturally present and normally function to suppress or "dampen" the IgE antibody response in a relatively selective manner. It appears that these cells modulate IgE responses by acting at least at two distinct points: 1) The most effective activity seems to be at the level of induction of carrier-specific helper T cells; 2) A second locus of inhibitory activity is more distal in the response, either impeding helper T cell-B cell cooperative interactions or suppressing B cell differentiation and/or function directly. Taken collectively, these observations demonstrate that the state of poor responsiveness of the SJL and AKR strains for the IgE antibody class is not a reflection of a genetic inability to develop IgE responses but rather a manifestation of a genetic capability to actively inhibit IgE antibody synthesis.     

Regulation of the immune response by antibody. II. The effects of different classes of passive guinea pig antibody on humoral and cell-mediated immunity in rats

The ability of different classes of passively administered guinea pig antibody (γ1, γ2, and IgM) to regulate humoral and cell-mediated immunity to flagellin, polymerized flagellin (POL), and sheep red blood cells (SRBC) was investigated in rats. It was found that at high concentrations, all classes of antibody suppressed the primary antibody responses and usually enhanced the delayed-type hypersensitivity induced by the three antigens. With flagellin and SRBC, the different classes of passive antibody varied in their suppressing and enhancing properties, being in the order: γ2 > γ1 = IgM. At low concentrations, γ1 and IgM enhanced the primary antibody response and suppressed the delayed hypersensitivity induced by flagellin. Such an effect was not observed with either POL or SRBC. Priming for a secondary antibody response was less readily suppressed by all classes of passive antibody. The removal of macrophage cytophilic antibody from γ2 converted this antibody to a preparation (γ2 absorbed) which had effects on humoral and cell-mediated immunity approaching that of γ1 antibody.