The nature and significance of invertebrate cartilages revisited: distribution and histology of cartilage and cartilage-like tissues within the Metazoa

Tissues similar to vertebrate cartilage have been described throughout the Metazoa. Often the designation of tissues as cartilage within non-vertebrate lineages is based upon sparse supporting data. To be considered cartilage, a tissue should meet a number of histological criteria that include composition and organization of the extracellular matrix. To re-evaluate the distribution and structural properties of these tissues, we have re-investigated the histological properties of many of these tissues from fresh material, and review the existing literature on invertebrate cartilages. Chondroid connective tissue is common amongst invertebrates, and differs from invertebrate cartilage in the structure and organization of the cells that comprise it. Groups having extensive chondroid connective tissue include brachiopods, polychaetes, and urochordates. Cartilage is found within cephalopod mollusks, chelicerate arthropods and sabellid polychaetes. Skeletal tissues found within enteropneust hemichordates are unique in that the extracellular matrix shares many properties with vertebrate cartilage, yet these tissues are completely acellular. The possibility that this tissue may represent a new category of cartilage, acellular cartilage, is discussed. Immunoreactivity of some invertebrate cartilages with antibodies that recognize molecules specific to vertebrate bone suggests an intermediate phenotype between vertebrate cartilage and bone. Although cartilage is found within a number of invertebrate lineages, we find that not all tissues previously reported to be cartilage have the appropriate properties to merit their distinction as cartilage.     

Parallels between development of embryonic and matrix-induced endochondral bone

Endochondral bone formation can take place in the embryo, during fracture healing, or in postnatal animals after induction by implanted demineralized bone matrix. This matrix-induced bone formation recapitulates the embryonic sequence of bone formation morphologically and biochemically. The steps in bone formation in both systems include differentiation of cartilage from mesenchyme, cartilage maturation, invasion of the cartilage by blood vessels and marrow precursors, and formation of bone and bone marrow. Recently, bone inductive molecules from demineralized bone matrix have been purified, sequenced and produced as recombinant proteins. While there are similarities between bone development in the embryo and that after induction by these purified molecules, the molecules responsible for bone induction in the embryo have not yet been defined. Because of similarities between the two methods of bone formation, studies of bone induction by demineralized bone matrix may help to elucidate mechanisms of embryonic bone induction.     

Extracellular vesicles are integral and functional components of the extracellular matrix

Extracellular vesicles (EV) are small plasma membrane-derived particles released into the extracellular space by virtually all cell types. Recently, EV have received increased interest because of their capability to carry nucleic acids, proteins, lipids and signaling molecules and to transfer their cargo into the target cells. Less attention has been paid to their role in modifying the composition of the extracellular matrix (ECM), either directly or indirectly via regulating the ability of target cells to synthesize or degrade matrix molecules. Based on recent results, EV can be considered one of the structural and functional components of the ECM that participate in matrix organization, regulation of cells within it, and in determining the physical properties of soft connective tissues, bone, cartilage and dentin. This review addresses the relevance of EV as specific modulators of the ECM, such as during the assembly and disassembly of the molecular network, signaling through the ECM and formation of niches suitable for tissue regeneration, inflammation and tumor progression. Finally, we assess the potential of these aspects of EV biology to translational medicine.     

Persistence of cartilage proteoglycan and link protein during matrix-induced endochondral bone development: An immunofluorescent study

Monospecific antibodies to cartilage proteoglycan monomer and link protein were employed with immunofluorescence microscopy to determine the tissue distribution of these constituents during matrix-induced endochondral bone development. Subcutaneous implantation of demineralized diaphyseal bone matrix resulted in new endochondral bone formation. On Day 3, the implant consisted of mesenchymal tissue which did not contain any demonstrable cartilage-related proteoglycan or link protein. With the onset of early chondrogenesis on Day 5, cartilage proteoglycan monomer and link protein were first localized together in the cartilage matrix, particularly around chondrocytes in territorial sites. Progressively more staining around cells was observed at Days 7 and 9. On Day 9, when mineralization was first observed, there was no evidence of a net loss of these molecules prior to mineralization of the cartilage matrix. On Day 11 and thereafter, bone formation was observed by appositional growth on calcified cartilage spicules. Whereas the osteoblasts and bone matrix were devoid of any staining for cartilage proteoglycan and link components, the residual, partly mineralized cartilage spicules still reacted with antibodies to cartilage proteoglycan monomer and link protein in territorial sites, but in reduced amounts, indicating a loss of these molecules associated with a loss of hypertrophic chondrocytes. Since mineral prevented the access of Fab' antibody subunits, demineralization after fixation was routinely employed. The results reveal that cartilage proteoglycan monomer and link protein are present around chondrocytes in hyaline cartilage during the early stages of endochondral bone formation and that there is no net loss of these molecules prior to mineralization of this cartilage matrix as was previously thought.     

Structural analysis of cartilage proteoglycans and glycoproteins using matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry

Cartilage extracellular matrix molecules synthesized and maintained by chondrocytes form a strong, elastic tissue functioning to cushion and protect the subchondral bone. Osteoarthritis is characterized by degradation of cartilage extracellular matrix molecules resulting in fibrillation, irreversible erosion, and eventual failure of the tissue. With recent interest in the degradation of cartilage extracellular matrix molecules, a need for more detailed structural information exists. Posttranslational modifications are believed to play a role in determining the susceptibility of these molecules to proteolytic degradation during the development of osteoarthritis. The purpose of this paper is to show how the application of matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight (MALDI-TOF) mass spectrometry to extracellular matrix protein and proteoglycan structure will help elucidate problems in extracellular matrix biochemistry. Methodological issues relating to the high molecular weight, polydispersity, and high degree of posttranslational modification of these molecules are discussed. MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry provides an improved level of detail for extracellular matrix protein and proteoglycan structure and is useful in addressing issues surrounding the causes of degradation during osteoarthritis.     

Perspectives in the biological function, the technical and therapeutic application of bone morphogenetic proteins

The bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) belong to the transforming growth factor beta superfamily of growth and differentiation factors and have been characterized by their ability to induce new bone formation in ectopic (non-skeletal) sites. BMPs are secreted molecules and are key regulators in early embryogenesis and organogenesis. One of the many functions of BMPs is to induce cartilage, bone, and connective tissue formation in vertebrates. This osteo-inductive capacity of BMPs has long been considered very promising for applications in bone repair, in the treatment of skeletal diseases, and in oral applications such as dentiogenesis and cementogenesis during regeneration of periodontal wounds. We discuss here biological roles of the BMPs in the organism and their signaling cascades leading to bone and cartilage formation in particular. It is also the aim of this review to evaluate the potential and the problems of BMPs in skeletal tissue engineering for the regeneration of bone damaged by disease or trauma and to serve as therapeutic agents for periodontal defects.     

In vitro induction of cartilage-specific macromolecules by a bone extract

An in vitro system has been developed to study the onset of chondrogenesis. Embryonic rat muscle mesenchymal cells, when treated in suspension culture with an extract of bovine bone matrix, synthesized cartilage-specific proteoglycan and type II collagen. The synthesis of these two macromolecules was assayed by the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay inhibition technique. Further evidence of chondrogenesis was demonstrated by morphological changes of treated cells when cultured in firm agarose and stained for metachromatic matrix. Even with crude bone matrix extracts, the assay was sensitive at the microgram level and significant differences in cartilage macromolecules compared with controls were observed in 2-3 d. In vivo the same extract induced first cartilage and then bone.     

The effects of chemokine, adhesion and extracellular matrix molecules on binding of mesenchymal stromal cells to poly(l-lactic acid)

Abstract Background aims. Mesenchymal stromal cells (MSC) are pluripotent adult stem cells capable of osteogenesis and chondrogenesis to form bone and cartilage. This characteristic gives them the potential for bone and cartilage regeneration. Synthetic polymers have been studied to examine whether they could be used as a scaffold for tissue engineering. In the current study a two-dimensional (2-D) poly(l-lactic acid) (PLLA) scaffold was treated with chemokine, adhesion and extracellular matrix molecules with the aim of using biologic molecules to improve the attachment of human MSC. Methods. MSC were isolated from human bone marrow and applied to a 2-D PLLA scaffold. Chemokines ligand (CXCL12 and CXCL13), adhesion molecules [P-selectin, vascular cell adhesion molecule (VCAM)-1 and heparin] and extracellular matrix molecules (fibronectin and type IV collagen) were coated on the scaffold and their effects on the number of MSC that adhered were recorded. Results. When used alone CXCL12 and CXCL13 enhanced MSC adhesion, as did VCAM-1, P-selectin, fibronectin and collagen, but not heparin. The effects of VCAM-1, P-selectin and heparin were enhanced by the addition of CXCL12. Incubation of MSC with antibodies to integrins α4 and α5β1 inhibited their adhesion to VCAM-1 and fibronectin-treated PLLA respectively, suggesting that these integrins were involved in the MSC interactions. Conclusions. The use of certain chemokines and adhesion and extracellular matrix molecules, alone or in combination, is beneficial for the attachment of MSC to PLLA, and may be helpful as natural molecules in scaffolds for regenerative medicine.     

Vinculin and α-catenin: shared and unique functions in adherens junctions

Vinculin and α-catenin are two functionally related proteins of adherens junctions, structures in which cells make contacts to neighboring cells or to the extracellular matrix. At these sites, the actin cytoskeleton of animal cells is anchored to the plasma membrane. Junction assembly and disassembly are coordinated in processes as different as mitosis, cell movement and tissue formation. Since adherens junctions are assembled from a large number of proteins, these molecules have to be coordinately activated and spatially regulated. Vinculin and α-catenin have been characterized as tumor suppressors, suggesting that they have a regulatory function in addition to their structural role. Several possible modes of vinculin and α-catenin regulation are discussed here, as the published data favor the concept that no single model fully explains the complexity of adherens junctions. Most probably, cells select from a variety of possibilities to solve the problem of making specific contacts. BioEssays 20 :733–740, 1998.© 1998 John Wiley and Sons, Inc.     

Peptide growth factors and their interactions during chondrogenesis

Peptide growth factors have been implicated in three aspects of cartilage growth and metabolism; the induction of mesoderm and differentiation of a cartilaginous skeleton in the early embryo, the growth and differentiation of chondrocytes within the epiphyseal growth plates leading to endochondral calcification, and the processes of articular cartilage damage and repair. Three peptide growth factor classes have been strongly implicated in these processes, the fibroblast growth factor family (FGF), the insulin-like growth factors (IGFs) including insulin, and transforming growth factor-β (TGF-β) and related molecules. Each of these peptide groups are expressed in the early embryo. Basic FGF, TGF-β and the related activin have been shown to induce the appearance of mesoderm from primitive neuroectoderm. TGF-β and related bone morphometric proteins can induce the differentiation of cartilage from primitive mesenchyme, and together with basic FGF and IGFs promote cartilage growth. Each class of growth factor is expressed within the epiphyseal growth plate where their autocrine/paracrine interactions regulate the rate of chondrocyte proliferation, matrix protein synthesis and terminal differentiation and mineralization. Basic FGF may prove useful in articular cartilage repair, while basic FGF, IGFs and TGF-β are among a number of growth factors and cytokines that have been implicated in cartilage disease.     

Organic matrixlike macromolecules associated with the mineral phase of sea urchin skeletal plates and teeth

The skeletal plates and teeth of the echinoid Paracentrotus lividus contain a heterogeneous assemblage of macromolecules that are not part of the connective tissue, but are presumably intimately associated with the mineral phase. Upon dissolution of the Mg-calcite mineral phase, some of these molecules are insoluble. The insoluble fractions of the teeth and skeletal plates are quite different, the former being predominantly protein and the latter, primarily some unknown nonproteinaceous material. The soluble constituents are similar in both tissues. These hydrophilic macromolecules have been partially separated and characterized. In both hard parts, two distinct classes of macromolecules are present, as indicated by the amino acid compositions of their protein constituents. These two classes of macromolecules are also present in the shells of a foraminifer and in various mollusks, both of which are formed by the "organic matrix-mediated" biomineralization process. The locations of these macromolecules in the teeth and skeletal plates are not known, nor whether they form coherent structures. It is therefore premature to conclude that these macromolecules do function as an organic matrix, although the results presented are in agreement with such an interpretation.     

An Introduction to Proteoglycans and Their Localization

Proteoglycans comprise a core protein to which one or more glycosaminoglycan chains are covalently attached. Although a small number of proteins have the capacity to be glycanated and become proteoglycans, it is now realized that these macromolecules have a range of functions, dependent on type and in vivo location, and have important roles in invertebrate and vertebrate development, maintenance, and tissue repair. Many biologically potent small proteins can bind glycosaminoglycan chains as a key part of their function in the extracellular matrix, at the cell surface, and also in some intracellular locations. Therefore, the participation of proteoglycans in disease is receiving increased attention. In this short review, proteoglycan structure, function, and localizations are summarized, with reference to accompanying reviews in this issue as well as other recent literature. Included are some remarks on proteoglycan and glycosaminoglycan localization techniques, with reference to the special physicochemical properties of these complex molecules.     

Age-related changes in the intercellular substance of human hyalin and collagen-fiber cartilage tissue

The articular cartilage of the hip joint and the intervertebral disks (LIV and LV), obtained from 42 corpses without any signs of pathology in these tissues, have been investigated. Six age groups have been distinguished: 21-30, 31-40, 41-50, 51-60, 61-70, 71 years of age and older. After the topo-optic reactions have been get, double refraction of glycosamineglycans (GAG) and collagen is studied in the structure and orientational regularity is estimated in these macromolecules in the matrix. The peculiarities on distribution of the collagenous fiber fasciculi in the intercellular substance in the hyalin and collagen-fibrillar cartilaginous tissue are demonstrated at the areas and depending on the age. Correlations in qualitative and quantitative changes of the GAG and collagen with age are analysed; this gives certain possibilities to reveal signs of similarity and difference in morphogenesis of hyalin and collagen-fibrillar cartilage tissue. Basing on the comparative analysis performed concerning the GAG and collagen state in the age aspect, as well as taking into account the data of previously performed investigations, the collagenous carcass can be characterized as the most stable component of the intercellular substance of cartilages, possessing a great reserve of strength. Homokinesis of the cartilaginous tissue is performed at the expense of the GAG; this ensures a high ability of the cartilaginous tissue to adaptation. A hypothesis on the GAG role in realization of adaptive rearrangements of the cartilaginous matrix at the macromolecular level is put forward.     

Effects of compression on the loss of newly synthesized proteoglycans and proteins from cartilage explants

The effects of mechanical compression of calf cartilage explants on the catabolism and loss into the medium of proteoglycans and proteins radiolabeled with [35S]sulfate and [3H]proline were examined. A single 2- or 12-h compression of 3-mm diameter cartilage disks from a thickness of 1.25 to 0.50 mm, or slow cyclic compression (2 h on/2 h off) from 1.25 mm to 1.00, 0.75, or 0.50 mm for 24 h led to transient alterations and/or sustained increases in loss of radiolabeled macromolecules. The effects of imposing or removing loads were consistent with several compression-induced physical mediators including fluid flow, diffusion, and matrix disruption. Cyclic compression induced convective fluid flow and enhanced the loss of 35S- and 3H-labeled macromolecules from tissue into medium. In contrast, prolonged static compression induced matrix consolidation and appeared to hinder the diffusional transport and loss of 35S- and 3H-labeled macromolecules. Since high amplitude cyclic compression led to a sustained increase in the rate of loss of 3H- and 35S-labeled macromolecules that was accompanied by an increase in the rate of loss of [3H]hydroxyproline residues and an increase in tissue hydration, such compression may have caused disruption of the collagen meshwork. The 35S-labeled proteoglycans lost during such cyclic compression were of smaller average size than those from controls, but contained a similarly low proportion (approximately 15%) that could form aggregates with excess hyaluronate and link protein. The size distribution and aggregability of the remaining tissue proteoglycans and 35S-labeled proteoglycans were not markedly affected. The loss of tissue proteoglycan paralleled the loss of 35S-labeled macromolecules. This study provides a framework for elucidating the biophysical mechanisms involved in the redistribution, catabolism, and loss of macromolecules during cartilage compression.     

The chondrocyte,architect of cartilage. Biomechanics,structure, function and molecular biology of cartilage matrix macromolecules

Chondrocytes are specialised cells which produce and maintain the extracellular matrix of cartilage, a tissue that is resilient and pliant. In vivo, it has to withstand very high compressive loads, and that is explicable in terms of the physico-chemical properties of cartilage-specific macromolecules and with the movement of water and ions within the matrix. The functions of the cartilage-specific collagens, aggrecan (a hydrophilic proteoglycan) and hyaluronan are discussed within this context. The structures of cartilage collagens and proteoglycans and their genes are known and a number of informative mutations have been identified. In particular, collagen fibrillogenesis is a complex process which can be altered by mutations whose effects fit what is known about collagen molecular structural functions. In other instances, mutations have indicated new functions for particular molecular domains. As cartilage provides the template for the developing skeleton, mutations in genes for cartilage-specific proteins often produce developmental abnormalities. The search for mutations amongst such genes in heritable disorders is being actively pursued by many groups, although mutation and phenotype are not always well correlated, probably because of compensatory mechanisms. The special nature of the chondrocyte is stressed in connection with its cell involvement in osteoarthritis, the most widespread disease of diarthrodial joints.     

Identification and partial characterization of two type XII-like collagen molecules

We have identified two distinct collagenous macromolecules in extracts of fetal bovine skin. Each of the molecules appears to contain three identical alpha-chains with short triple-helical domains of approximately 25 kD, and nontriple-helical domains of approximately 190 kD. Consistent with these observations, extracted molecules contain a relatively short triple-helical domain (75 nm) and a large globular domain comprised of three similar arms. Despite these similarities, the purified collagenase-resistant domains are distinguished by a number of criteria. The globular domains can be chromatographically separated on the basis of charge distribution. Peptide profiles generated by V8 protease digestion are dissimilar. These molecules are immunologically unique and have distinct distributions in tissue. Finally, rotary shadow analysis of purified domains identifies size and conformation differences. Structurally, the molecules are very similar to type XII collagen, but differ in tissue distribution, since both these molecules are present in cartilage, while type XII is reported to be absent from that tissue.     

Proteomic analysis of Col11a1-associated protein complexes

Cartilage plays an essential role during skeletal development within the growth plate and in articular joint function. Interactions between the collagen fibrils and other extracellular matrix molecules maintain structural integrity of cartilage, orchestrate complex dynamic events during embryonic development, and help to regulate fibrillogenesis. To increase our understanding of these events, affinity chromatography and liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry were used to identify proteins that interact with the collagen fibril surface via the amino terminal domain of collagen α1(XI) a protein domain that is displayed at the surface of heterotypic collagen fibrils of cartilage. Proteins extracted from fetal bovine cartilage using homogenization in high ionic strength buffer were selected based on affinity for the amino terminal noncollagenous domain of collagen α1(XI). MS was used to determine the amino acid sequence of tryptic fragments for protein identification. Extracellular matrix molecules and cellular proteins that were identified as interacting with the amino terminal domain of collagen α1(XI) directly or indirectly, included proteoglycans, collagens, and matricellular molecules, some of which also play a role in fibrillogenesis, while others are known to function in the maintenance of tissue integrity. Characterization of these molecular interactions will provide a more thorough understanding of how the extracellular matrix molecules of cartilage interact and what role collagen XI plays in the process of fibrillogenesis and maintenance of tissue integrity. Such information will aid tissue engineering and cartilage regeneration efforts to treat cartilage tissue damage and degeneration.     

Growth factors in cartilage tissue engineering

Tissue engineering of cartilage consists of two steps. Firstly, the cells from a small biopsy of patient's own tissue have to be multiplied. During this multiplication process they lose their cartilage phenotype. In the second step, these cells have to be stimulated to re-express their cartilage phenotype and produce cartilage matrix. Growth factors can be used to improve cell multiplication, redifferentiation and production of matrix. The choice of growth factors should be made for each phase of the tissue engineering process separately, taking into account cell phenotype and the presence of extracellular matrix. This paper demonstrates some examples of the use of growth factors to increase the amount, the quality and the assembly of the matrix components produced for cartilage tissue engineering. In addition it shows that the "culture history" (e.g., addition of growth factors during cell multiplication or preculture period in a 3-dimensional environment) of the cells influences the effect of growth factor addition. The data demonstrate the potency as well as the limitations of the use of growth factors in cartilage tissue engineering.     

Unraveling the human bone microenvironment beyond the classical extracellular matrix proteins: a human bone protein library

A characteristic feature of bone, differentiating it from other connective tissues, is the mineralized extracellular matrix (ECM). Mineral accounts for the majority of the bone tissue volume, being the remainder organic material mostly derived from collagen. This, and the fact that only a limited number of noncollagenous ECM proteins are described, provides a limited view of the bone tissue composition and bone metabolism, the more so considering the increasing understanding of ECM significance for cellular form and function. For this reason, we set out to analyze and extensively characterize the human bone proteome using large-scale mass spectrometry-based methods. Bone samples of four individuals were analyzed identifying 3038 unique proteins. A total of 1213 of these were present in at least 3 out of 4 bone samples. For quantification purposes, we were limited to noncollagenous proteins (NCPs) and we could quantify 1051 NCPs. Most classical bone matrix proteins mentioned in literature were detected but were not among the highly abundant ones. Gene ontology analyses identified high-abundance groups of proteins with a functional link to mineralization and mineral metabolism such as transporters, pyrophosphatase activity, and Ca(2+)-dependent phospholipid binding proteins. ECM proteins were as well overrepresented together with nucleosome and antioxidant activity proteins, which have not been extensively characterized as being important for bone. In conclusion, our data clearly demonstrates that human bone tissue is a reservoir of a wide variety of proteins. In addition to the classical osteoblast-derived ECM, we have identified many proteins from different sources and of unknown function in bone. Thus, this study represents an informative library of bone proteins forming a source for novel bone formation modulators as well as biomarkers for bone diseases such as osteoporosis.     

Cellular and molecular interactions regulating skeletogenesis

Skeletal development involves complex coordination among multiple cell types and tissues. In long bones, a cartilage template surrounded by the perichondrium is first laid down and is subsequently replaced by bone marrow and bone, during a process named endochondral ossification. Cells in the cartilage template and the surrounding perichondrium are derived from mesenchymal cells, which condense locally. In contrast, many cell types that make up mature bone and in particular the bone marrow are brought in by the vasculature. Three tissues appear to be the main players in the initiation of endochondral ossification: the cartilage, the adjacent perichondrium, and the invading vasculature. Interactions among these tissues are synchronized by a large number of secreted and intracellular factors, many of which have been identified in the past 10 years. Some of these factors primarily control cartilage differentiation, while others regulate bone formation and/or angiogenesis. Understanding how these factors operate during skeletal development through the analyses of genetically altered mice depends on being able to distinguish the effect of these molecules on the different cell types that comprise the skeleton. This review will discuss the complexity of skeletal phenotypes, which arises from the tightly regulated, complex interactions among the three tissues involved in bone development. Specific examples illustrate how gene functions may be further assessed using new approaches including genetic and tissue manipulations.