A phylogenetic approach to cultural evolution

There has been a rapid increase in the use of phylogenetic methods to study the evolution of languages and culture. Languages fit a tree model of evolution well, at least in their basic vocabulary, challenging the view that blending, or admixture among neighbouring groups, was predominant in cultural history. Here, we argue that we can use language trees to test hypotheses about not only cultural history and diversification, but also bio-cultural adaptation. Phylogenetic comparative methods take account of the non-independence of cultures (Galton's problem), which can cause spurious statistical associations in comparative analyses. Advances in phylogenetic methods offer new possibilities for the analysis of cultural evolution, including estimating the rate of evolution and the direction of coevolutionary change of traits on the tree. They also enable phylogenetic uncertainty to be incorporated into the analyses, so that one does not have to treat phylogenetic trees as if they were known without error.     

On the origin of the treponematoses: a phylogenetic approach

Background

Since the first recorded epidemic of syphilis in 1495, controversy has surrounded the origins of the bacterium Treponema pallidum subsp. pallidum and its relationship to the pathogens responsible for the other treponemal diseases: yaws, endemic syphilis, and pinta. Some researchers have argued that the syphilis-causing bacterium, or its progenitor, was brought from the New World to Europe by Christopher Columbus and his men, while others maintain that the treponematoses, including syphilis, have a much longer history on the European continent.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We applied phylogenetics to this problem, using data from 21 genetic regions examined in 26 geographically disparate strains of pathogenic Treponema. Of all the strains examined, the venereal syphilis-causing strains originated most recently and were more closely related to yaws-causing strains from South America than to other non-venereal strains. Old World yaws-causing strains occupied a basal position on the tree, indicating that they arose first in human history, and a simian strain of T. pallidum was found to be indistinguishable from them.

Conclusions/Significance

Our results lend support to the Columbian theory of syphilis''s origin while suggesting that the non-sexually transmitted subspecies arose earlier in the Old World. This study represents the first attempt to address the problem of the origin of syphilis using molecular genetics, as well as the first source of information regarding the genetic make-up of non-venereal strains from the Western hemisphere.     

Definitions in phylogenetic taxonomy: critique and rationale

A general rationale for the formulation and placement of taxonomic definitions in phylogenetic taxonomy is proposed, and commonly used terms such as "crown taxon" or "node-based definition" are more precisely defined. In the formulation of phylogenetic definitions, nested reference taxa stabilize taxonomic content. A definitional configuration termed a node-stem triplet also stabilizes the relationship between the trio of taxa at a branchpoint, in the face of local change in phylogenetic relationships or addition/deletion of taxa. Crown-total taxonomies use survivorship as a criterion for placement of node-stem triplets within a taxonomic hierarchy. Diversity, morphology, and tradition also constitute heuristic criteria for placement of node-stem triplets.     

A phylogenetic approach to community assembly from a local species pool

Ecological theory provides two contrasting predictions about the characteristics of the species combining to form communities. Classical competition theory states that they will be less similar than expected by chance, whilst the environmental structuring hypothesis states that they will be more similar. We investigated these predictions by applying phylogenetic methods of analysis (PICs) to a grassland community, examining species on the basis of their traits. At the scale of investigation most useful in making predictions about the presence and abundance of species (the community level, the species forming the community were more similar than would be expected by chance. The use of PICs resulted in a more sensitive test than if phylogeny had been ignored, allowing the detection of effects that would otherwise have been overlooked or underestimated. Selected traits from the PICs analysis were used to develop a predictive model of community membership using discriminant analysis. This correctly identified species in the pool which were present in the community but failed to predict absences accurately, implying that dispersal limitation may operate in the community.     

On the repeat-annotated phylogenetic tree reconstruction problem.

A new problem in phylogenetic inference is presented, based on recent biological findings indicating a strong association between reversals (i.e., inversions) and repeats. These biological findings are formalized here in a new mathematical model, called repeat-annotated phylogenetic trees (RAPT). We show that, under RAPT, the evolutionary process--including both the tree-topology as well as internal node genome orders--is uniquely determined, a property that is of major significance both in theory and in practice. Furthermore, the repeats are employed to provide linear-time algorithms for reconstructing both the genomic orders and the phylogeny, which are NP-hard problems under the classical model of sorting by reversals (SBR).     

A phylogenetic approach to the identification of phosphoglucomutase genes

The expanding molecular database provides unparalleled opportunities for characterizing genes and for studying groups of related genes. We use sequences drawn from the database to construct an evolutionary framework for examining the important glycolytic enzyme phosphoglucomutase (PGM). Phosphoglucomutase plays a pivotal role in the synthesis and utilization of glycogen and is present in all organisms. In humans, there are three well-described isozymes, PGMI, PGM2, and PGM3. PGM1 was cloned 5 years ago; however, repeated attempts using both immunological approaches and molecular probes designed from PGM1 have failed to isolate either PGM2 or PGM3. Using a phylogenetic strategy, we first identified 47 highly divergent prokaryotic and eukaryotic PGM-like sequences from the database. Although overall amino acid identity often fell below 20%, the relative order, position, and sequence of three structural motifs, the active site and the magnesium-- and sugar-binding sites, were conserved in all 47 sequences. The phylogenetic history of these sequences was complex and marked by duplications and translocations; two instances of transkingdom horizontal gene transfer were identified. Nonetheless, the sequences fell within six well-defined evolutionary lineages, three of which contained only prokaryotes. Of the two prokaryotic/eukaryotic lineages, one contained bacterial, yeast, slimemold, invertebrate, and vertebrate homologs to human PGM1 and the second contained likely homologs to human PGM2. Indeed, an amino acid sequence, derived from a partial human cDNA, that fell within the second cross-kingdom lineage bears several characteristics expected for PGM2. A third lineage may contain homologs to human PGM3. On a general level, our phylogenetic-based approach shows promise for the further utilization of the extensive molecular database.      

The nucleotide-sugar transporter family: a phylogenetic approach

Nucleotide sugar transporters (NST) establish the functional link of membrane transport between the nucleotide sugars synthesized in the cytoplasm and nucleus, and the glycosylation processes that take place in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and Golgi apparatus. The aim of the present work was to perform a phylogenetic analysis of 87 bank annotated protein sequences comprising all the NST so far characterized and their homologues retrieved by BLAST searches, as well as the closely related triose-phosphate translocator (TPT) plant family. NST were classified in three comprehensive families by linking them to the available experimental data. This enabled us to point out both the possible ER subcellular targeting of these transporters mediated by the dy-lysine motif and the substrate recognition mechanisms specific to each family as well as an important acceptor site motif, establishing the role of evolution in the functional properties of each NST family.     

A phylogenetic approach to the evolution of fish behaviour

Summary WHAT HAVE WE LEARNED?As I indicated in the introduction, this is a non-traditional review. I have not asked What generalizations can we draw about the evolution of fish behaviour based upon information gleaned from phylogenetically based studies? Instead, I have presented detailed discussions of those studies. The reason for this approach is quite simple: if all studies in such a wide area of investigation can be discussed at length in one relatively short paper, then the database is not large enough to warrant the move from information collection to information synthesis. The purpose of this review, then, has been to capture the enthusiasm of the phylogenetically orientated fish ethologists and to highlight their discoveries, in the hopes that this will stimulate further research. If successful, the next review of phylogeny and the evolution of fish behaviour will follow a more familiar pathway.Although the database does not allow us to draw generalizations about the evolution of specific behavioural characters in fishes, the studies to date have uncovered a number of more general evolutionary insights. First, phylogenetic conservatism is evident at all levels of analysis, from the muscle activity patterns that underlie behavioural characters (Lauder 1986; Westneat and Wainwright, 1989; Westneat 1991; Wainwright and Lauder, 1992) through foraging preferences (Winterbottom and McLennan, 1993) and egg deposition strategies (Johnston and Page, 1992) to parental care (Stiassney and Gerstner, 1992). This conservatism forms the backbone against which the appearance of novel behaviours (apomorphies) can be highlighted. Each species' behavioural repertoire is thus a unique combination of very old (plesiomorphic), relatively old (synapomorphic) and recently derived (autapomorphic) characters. Second, phylogenetic analysis has allowed us to investigate models of behavioural evolution that were constructed from a variety of microevolutionary fitness parameters. The macroevolutionary patterns have corroborated some parts of those models (transition from biparental to female-only care: Gross and Sargent, 1985; Stiassney and Gerstner, 1992; transition from fresh water to anadromy: Gross et al., 1988; Stearley, 1992) and highlighted other parts of the models that would benefit from a re-examination of the basic assumptions (transition from biparental or female-only to male-only care: Gross and Sargent, 1985; Stiassney and Gerstner, 1992). Third, expanding our evolutionary perspective to include clades of organisms has allowed researchers to formulate new theories of behavioural evolution incroporating information about the patterns of character origin and diversification as well as information about character maintenance (Ryan, 1900a; Ryan and Rand, 1990; Ryan et al., 1990a). And finally, examination of macroevolutionary correlations between the origin and diversification of behavioural characters has allowed us to make predictions about the forces influencing the evolution of those characters that can then be tested experimentally (McLennan et al., 1988; Basolo, 1990a,b, 1991; McLennan, 1991). The studies presented in this paper have spanned a wide theoretical arena. They have revealed a number of interesting insights about the evolution of behaviour, and in so doing, have demonstrated the hybrid vigour of a research programme based upon integrating phylogeny and experimental ethology, phylogeny and functional morphology, and phylogeny and behavioural ecology. The question to be answered now is:WHERE DO WE GO FROM HERE?If this fledgling research programme is to remain vigorous, we need to do two things. First, channels of communication must be re-opened between systematists and ethologists. Specifically, we need to encourage systematists to construct robust phylogenetic trees for groups of fish that either have already been well studied behaviourally and ecologically, or would be of interest to ethologists if a phylogeny existed (the belontiids, poeciliids, and rivulines come to mind, to name just a few). In the absence of such critical information, behavioural ecologists are faced with the option of investigating their ethological data based upon trees reconstructed from old classification schemes or phenograms, neither of which produces a robust phylogenetic hypothesis of genealogy. Researchers who have opted for this approach preface their investigations with the caveat that the analysis and conclusions are only preliminary because of the unsatisfactory nature of the phylogenetic hypotheses available to them. The importance of a preliminary analysis cannot be understimated for researchers who are frustrated by their inability to apply the phylogenetic approach to their burgeoning data sets. It is, however, critical to remember that a preliminary analysis can, at best, produce only tentative results. If the data themselves are both incomplete and ambiguous, this will compound the problems arising from the absence of a rigorous phylogenetic framework, which will produce a confusing picture of behavioural evolution. It is also important to realize that even the most robust phylogenetic tree is still only a hypothesis of genealogical relationships, a hypothesis that may change with the discovery of new data.Second, links must be forged between comparative ethology and behavioural ecology. All of the examples discussed in this paper uncovered a phylogenetic component in patterns of behavioural origin and diversification. The discovery of this phylogenetic influence, however, is only the first step in developing a comprehensive evolutionary picture because phylogenetic patterns can tell us very little about the processes underlying those patterns. In order to explore questions of process, we must incorporate information about the fitness parameters of behavioural characters into our evolutionary picture. For example, optimizing such parameters onto a phylogenetic tree may allow us to investigate whether there are any macroevolutionary correlations between the origin and divergence of a behaviour and a change in one (or more) of the fitness components. We must also incorporate information about the genetic, developmental and physiological control of behaviour into our comparative framework (Brooks and McLennan, 1991; Willis et al., 1991; Lauder et al., 1993). This is perhaps the most neglected aspect of comparative ethology and will thus be the most difficult to remedy. Details of the genetic and developmental systems underlying behaviour are known for only a handful of taxa and for only a handful of behaviours within those taxa. The physiological control of behaviour is better studied, but has yet to be placed within a phylogenetic context (but see e.g. Stearley, 1992, for an example of the insights that can be gained from such a study). The results of such a multilevel approach will be a more robust estimate of the relative roles for the effects of both phylogenetic heritage and environmental factors in the evolution of behaviour in fishes.     

A glimpse on the pattern of rodent diversication: a phylogenetic approach

ABSTRACT: BACKGROUND: Development of phylogenetic methods that do not rely on fossils for the study of evolutionary processes through time have revolutionized the eld of evolutionary biology and resulted in an unprecedented expansion of our knowledge about the tree of life. These methods have helped to shed light on the macroevolution of many taxonomic groups such as the placentals (Mammalia). However, despite the increase of studies addressing the diversication patterns of organisms, no synthesis has addressed the case of the most diversied mammalian clade: the Rodentia. RESULTS: Here we present a rodent maximum likelihood phylogeny inferred from a molecular supermatrix. It is based on 11 mitochondrial and nuclear genes that covers 1,265 species, i.e., respectively 56 % and 81 % of the known specic and generic rodent diversity. The inferred topology recovered all Rodentia clades proposed by recent molecular works. A relaxed molecular clock dating approach provided a time framework for speciation events. We found that the Myomorpha clade shows a greater degree of variation in diversication rates than Sciuroidea, Caviomorpha, Castorimorpha and Anomaluromorpha. We identied a number of shifts in diversication rates within the major clades: two in Castorimorpha, three in Ctenohystrica, 6 within the squirrel-related clade and 24 in the Myomorpha clade. The majority of these shifts occurred within the most recent familial rodent radiations: the Cricetidae and Muridae clades. Using the topological imbalances and the time line we discuss the potential role of different diversication factors that might have shaped the rodents radiation. CONCLUSIONS: The present glimpse on the diversication pattern of rodents can be used for further comparative meta-analyses. Muroid lineages have a greater degree of variation in their diversication rates than any other 1rodent group. Different topological signatures suggest distinct diversication processes among rodent lineages. In particular, Muroidea and Sciuroidea display widespread distribution and have undergone evolutionary and adaptive radiation on most of the continents. Our results show that rodents experienced shifts in diversication rate regularly through the Tertiary, but at different periods for each clade. A comparison between the rodent fossil record and our results suggest that extinction led to the loss of diversication signal for most of the Paleogene nodes.     

TreeMos: a high-throughput phylogenomic approach to find and visualize phylogenetic mosaicism

SUMMARY: TreeMos is a novel high-throughput graphical analysis application that allows the user to search for phylogenetic mosaicism among one or more DNA or protein sequence multiple alignments and additional unaligned sequences. TreeMos uses a sliding window and local alignment algorithm to identify the nearest neighbour of each sequence segment, and visualizes instances of sequence segments whose nearest neighbour is anomalous to that identified using the global alignment. Data sets can include whole genome sequences allowing phylogenomic analyses in which mosaicism may be attributed to recombination between any two points in the genome. TreeMos can be run from the command line, or within a web browser allowing the relationships between taxa to be explored by drill-through. AVAILABILITY: http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/sci/whri/research/archaeobotany.     

A phylogenetic approach to assessing the targets of microbial warfare

Bacteriocins are the most abundant and diverse defense systems in bacteria. As a result of the specific mechanisms of bacteriocin recognition and translocation into the target cell it is assumed that these toxins mediate intra-specific or population-level interactions. However, no published studies specifically address this question. We present here a survey of bacteriocin production in a collection of enteric bacteria isolated from wild mammals in Australia. A subset of the bacteriocin-producing strains was assayed for the ability to kill a broad range of enteric bacteria from the same bacterial collection. A novel method of estimating killing breadth was developed and used to compare the surveyed bacteriocins in terms of the phylogenetic range over which they kill. The most striking result is that although bacteriocin-producers kill members of their own species most frequently, some kill phylogenetically distant taxa more frequently than they kill closer relatives. This study calls into question the role these toxins play in natural populations. A significant number of bacteriocins are highly effective in killing inter-specific strains and thus bacteriocins may serve to mediate bacterial community interactions.     

A phylogenetic approach to total evaporative water loss in mammals

Abstract Maintaining appropriate water balance is a constant challenge for terrestrial mammals, and this problem can be exacerbated in desiccating environments. It has been proposed that natural selection has provided desert-dwelling mammals physiological mechanisms to reduce rates of total evaporative water loss. In this study, we evaluated the relationship between total evaporative water loss and body mass in mammals by using a recent phylogenetic hypothesis. We compared total evaporative water loss in 80 species of arid-zone mammals to that in 56 species that inhabit mesic regions, ranging in size from 4 g to 3,500 kg, to test the hypothesis that mammals from arid environments have lower rates of total evaporative water loss than mammals from mesic environments once phylogeny is taken into account. We found that arid species had lower rates of total evaporative water loss than mesic species when using a dichotomous variable to describe habitat (arid or mesic). We also found that total evaporative water loss was negatively correlated with the average maximum and minimum environmental temperature as well as the maximum vapor pressure deficit of the environment. Annual precipitation and the variable Q (a measure of habitat aridity) were positively correlated with total evaporative water loss. These results support the hypothesis that desert-dwelling mammals have lower rates of total evaporative water loss than mesic species after controlling for body mass and evolutionary relatedness regardless of whether categorical or continuous variables are used to describe habitat.     

Social evolution in the genusHalictus: a phylogenetic approach

Summary Halictine bees exhibit an enormous diversity of solitary and social colony structures. To investigate social evolution in the genusHalictus, phylogenies of 15 species of the subgeneraH. (Halictus) andH. (Seladonia) were constructed based on protein electrophoretic data. Solitary, social, and socially polymorphic species were included.Halictus (Seladonia) apparently rendersH. (Halictus) paraphyletic. The common ancestor ofH. (Halictus) andH. (Seladonia) was probably social or socially polymorphic. This implies that some solitary and socially polymorphic species, such asH. confusus andH. tumulorum, represent evolutionary reversals from a completely eusocial condition to the solitary condition that is thought to be primitive for the subfamily as a whole.     

Detecting recombination in TT virus: a phylogenetic approach

TT virus (TTV) has a remarkable genetic heterogeneity. To study TTV evolution, phylogenetic analyses were performed on 739 DNA sequences mapping in the N22 region of ORF1. Analysis of neighbor-joining consensus trees shows significant differences between DNA and protein phylogeny. Median joining networks phylogenetic clustering indicates that DNA sequence analysis is biased by homoplasy (i.e., genetic variability not originated by descent), indicative of either hypermutation or recombination. Statistical analysis shows that the significant excess of homoplasy is due to frequent recombination among closely related strains. Recombination events imply that the transmission of TTV is not clonal and provide the necessary basis to explain (i) the high degree of genetic divergence between TTV isolates, (ii) the lack of population structure on a world scale, and (iii) the number of highly divergent strains that seems typical of this virus. We show that recombination phenomena can be detected by phylogenetic analyses in very short sequences when a sufficiently large data set is available.     

The adipokinetic hormones of Odonata: a phylogenetic approach

Adipokinetic neuropeptides from the corpora cardiaca of the major families of all three suborders of the Odonata were identified by one or more of the following methods: (1) Isolation of the peptides from a methanolic extract of the corpora cardiaca by liquid chromatography, peak monitoring by fluorescence of the Trp residue and comparison of the retention time with those of known synthetic peptides of Odonata. (2) Hyperlipaemic bioassays of the HPLC-generated fractions either in Locusta migratoria or, in a few cases, in Anax imperator or Orthetrum julia. (3) Sequencing of the isolated, bioactive HPLAC fraction by Edman degradation. (4) Mass spectrometric measurement of the isolated, bioactive fraction. Sequence assignment revealed that the investigated Odonata species always contain only one adipokinetic peptide. This is always an octapeptide. The suborder Zygoptera contains the peptide code-named Psein-AKH, the Anisozygoptera and the families Aeshnidae, Cordulegastridae and Macromiidae of the Anisoptera contain Anaim-AKH, whereas Gomphidae, Corduliidae (with the exception of Syncordulia gracilis) and Libellulidae contain Libau-AKH; one species of Libellulidae has Erysi-AKH, a very conservative modification of Libau-AKH (one point mutation). When these structural data are interpreted in conjunction with existing phylogenies of Odonata, they support the following: (1) Zygoptera are monophyletic and not paraphyletic. (2) Anisozygoptera and Anisoptera are sister groups and contain the ancestral Anaim-AKH which is independently and convergently mutated to Libau-AKH in Gomphidae and Libellulidae. (3) The Corduliidae are of special interest. Only Corduliidae sensu stricto appear to contain Libau-AKH, other species placed into this family by most authorities contain the ancestral Anaim-AKH. Possibly, assignments of AKHs can untangle the paraphyly of this family.     

On a naturalist theory of health: a critique

This paper examines the most influential naturalist theory of health, Christopher Boorse’s ‘biostatistical theory’ (BST). I argue that the BST is an unsuitable candidate for the rôle that Boorse has cast it to play, namely, to underpin medicine with a theoretical, value-free science of health and disease. Following the literature, I distinguish between “real” changes and “mere Cambridge changes” in terms of the difference between an individual’s intrinsic and relational properties and argue that the framework of the BST essentially implies a Cambridge-change criterion. The examination reveals that this implicit criterion commits the BST to the troubling view that an individual could go from being diseased to healthy, or vice versa, without any physiological change in that individual. Two problems follow: (1) the current framework of the BST is ill-equipped to formally embrace Cambridge changes and (2) it is theoretically dubious. The arguments advanced here are not limited to the BST; I suggest they extend to any naturalist claim to underpin medical practice with a value-free theory of health and disease defined in terms of an evolutionary view of biological fitness.