Enhanced microtubule binding and tubulin assembly properties of conformationally constrained paclitaxel derivatives

Microtubule binding and tubulin assembly promotion by a series of conformationally restricted paclitaxel (PTX) derivatives was investigated. In these derivatives, the C-4 acetate of the taxane is tethered to the C-3' phenyl at ortho and meta positions with different length linkers. The apparent affinity of these derivatives for GMPCPP-stabilized microtubules was assessed by a competition assay, and their influence on microtubule polymerization was evaluated by measuring the critical concentration of GDP-tubulin in the presence of the respective molecule. In general, taxane derivatives with higher apparent affinity for microtubules induced tubulin assembly more efficiently. Among the derivatives, molecules with the shortest tether display the strongest affinity for microtubules. These derivatives exhibited enhanced microtubule stabilization properties and efficiently induced GDP-tubulin assembly into microtubules at low temperature of 12 degrees C and in the absence of Mg2+ ions in 0.1 M PIPES. Based on molecular dynamics simulations, we propose that the enhanced ability to assemble microtubules by these taxane derivatives is linked to their ability to effectively shape the conformation of the M-loop of tubulin for cross-protofilament interaction.     

Taxanes with high potency inducing tubulin assembly overcome tumoural cell resistances

We have found that four taxanes with chemical modifications at positions C10 and C13 were active against all types of taxane resistant cell lines, resistant by P-gp overexpression, by mutations in the β-tubulin binding site or by overexpression of the highly dynamic βIII-tubulin isotype.We have characterized the interaction of taxanes with high activity on chemotherapy resistant tumoural cells with microtubules, and also studied their cellular effects. The biochemical property enhanced in comparison with other taxanes is their potency at inducing tubulin assembly, despite the fact that their interactions with the microtubule binding sites (pore and luminal) are similar as studied by NMR and SAXS. A differential interaction with the S7–S9 loop (M-loop) is responsible for their enhanced assembly induction properties. The chemical changes in the structure also induce changes in the thermodynamic properties of the interaction, indicating a higher hydrophilicity and also explaining their properties on P-gp and βIII overexpressing cells and on mutant cells.The effect of the compounds on the microtubular network is different from those observed with the classical (docetaxel and paclitaxel) taxanes, inducing different bundling in cells with microtubules being very short, indicating a very fast nucleation effect and reflecting their high assembly induction power.     

Hallmarks of molecular action of microtubule stabilizing agents: effects of epothilone B, ixabepilone, peloruside A, and laulimalide on microtubule conformation

Microtubule stabilizing agents (MSAs) comprise a class of drugs that bind to microtubule (MT) polymers and stabilize them against disassembly. Several of these agents are currently in clinical use as anticancer drugs, whereas others are in various stages of development. Nonetheless, there is insufficient knowledge about the molecular modes of their action. Recent studies from our laboratory utilizing hydrogen-deuterium exchange in combination with mass spectrometry (MS) provide new information on the conformational effects of Taxol and discodermolide on microtubules isolated from chicken erythrocytes (CET). We report here a comprehensive analysis of the effects of epothilone B, ixabepilone (IXEMPRA(TM)), laulimalide, and peloruside A on CET conformation. The results of our comparative hydrogen-deuterium exchange MS studies indicate that all MSAs have significant conformational effects on the C-terminal H12 helix of α-tubulin, which is a likely molecular mechanism for the previously observed modulations of MT interactions with microtubule-associated and motor proteins. More importantly, the major mode of MT stabilization by MSAs is the tightening of the longitudinal interactions between two adjacent αβ-tubulin heterodimers at the interdimer interface. In contrast to previous observations reported with bovine brain tubulin, the lateral interactions between the adjacent protofilaments in CET are particularly strongly stabilized by peloruside A and laulimalide, drugs that bind outside the taxane site. This not only highlights the significance of tubulin isotype composition in modulating drug effects on MT conformation and stability but also provides a potential explanation for the synergy observed when combinations of taxane and alternative site binding drugs are used.     

Taccalonolide microtubule stabilizers

This review focuses on a relatively new class of microtubule stabilizers, the taccalonolides. The taccalonolides are highly oxygenated pentacyclic steroids isolated from plants of the genus Tacca. Originally identified in a cell-based phenotypic screen, the taccalonolides have many properties similar to other microtubule stabilizers. They increase the density of interphase microtubules, causing microtubule bundling, and form abnormal multi-polar mitotic spindles leading to mitotic arrest and, ultimately, apoptosis. However, the taccalonolides differ from other microtubule stabilizers in that they retain efficacy in taxane resistant cell lines and in vivo models. Binding studies with the newly identified, potent taccalonolide AJ demonstrated covalent binding to β-tubulin at or near the luminal and/or pore taxane binding site(s) which stabilizes microtubule protofilaments in a unique manner as compared to other microtubule stabilizers. The isolation and semi-synthesis of 21 taccalonolides helped to identify key structure activity relationships and the importance of multiple regions across the taccalonolide skeleton for optimal biological potency.     

Studies on suppressors of <Emphasis Type="Italic">sav2/shade avoidance 2</Emphasis> revealed altered interaction at the interface of αβ-tubulin intradimer affects microtubule dynamics

Microtubules are highly dynamic cellular structures that are required for many biological processes. Cortical microtubules in plant play crucial roles during cell expansion. Its proper dynamics are required for plant growth and responses to environmental stimuli. Arabidopsis mutants, such as sav2/tub4 ^P287L , display a variety of growth defects, including short and twisting hypocotyls in dark and shade. Both microtubule organization and dynamics are altered in sav2. Here, we have identified a suppressor of sav2 (sus2), which surprisingly contains a missense mutation in another β tubulin gene, TUB6. The mutation results in a L246F substitution in TUB6. It locates at the interface of αβ-intradimer. This mutation partially suppressed the swirling microtubule arrangement in sav2 hypocotyl cells, leading to the partial rescue of sav2 phenotypes. As the mutant behaves as a semi-dominant mutation and the CFP-labeled tub6^L246F can incorporate into microtubules, we propose that the incorporation of tub6^L246F interferes with the normal function of microtubules. tub6 ^L246F single mutant is hypersensitive to drugs disrupting microtubule dynamics, such as colchicine, suggesting the mutation may affect microtubule dynamics. Moreover, we found the colchicine hypersensitivity of tub6^L246F can be suppressed by tub4^P287L, while tub6^L246F interferes with the rescuing effect of EB1 on sav2. As P287 locates around M-loop, which is involved in interactions between microtubule protofilaments, we propose that altered interactions at αβ-intradimer interface may affect microtubule dynamics through M-loop mediated interactions between microtubule protofilaments.     

Analysis of the Strength of Interfacial Hydrogen Bonds between Tubulin Dimers Using Quantum Theory of Atoms in Molecules

Microtubules are key structural elements that, among numerous biological functions, maintain the cytoskeleton of the cell and have a major role in cell division, which makes them important cancer chemotherapy targets. Understanding the energy balance that brings tubulin dimers, the building blocks of microtubules, together to form a microtubule is especially important for revealing the mechanism of their dynamic instability. Several studies have been conducted to estimate various contributions to the free energy of microtubule formation. However, the hydrogen-bond contribution was not studied before as a separate component. In this work, we use concepts such as the quantum theory of atoms in molecules to estimate the per-residue strength of hydrogen bonds contributing to the overall stability that brings subunits together in pair of tubulin heterodimers, across both the longitudinal and lateral interfaces. Our study shows that hydrogen bonding plays a major role in the stability of tubulin systems. Several residues that are crucial to the binding of vinca alkaloids are shown to be strongly involved in longitudinal microtubule stabilization. This indicates a direct relation between the binding of these agents and the effect on the interfacial hydrogen-bonding network, and explains the mechanism of their action. Lateral contacts showed much higher stability than longitudinal ones (–462 ± 70 vs. –392 ± 59 kJ/mol), which suggests a dramatic lateral stabilization effect of the GTP cap in the β-subunit. The role of the M-loop in lateral stability in absence of taxol was shown to be minor. The B-lattice lateral hydrogen bonds are shown to be comparable in strength to the A-lattice ones (−462 ± 70 vs. –472 ± 46 kJ/mol). These findings establish the importance of hydrogen bonds to the stability of tubulin systems.     

Structural investigations into the binding mode of novel neolignans Cmp10 and Cmp19 microtubule stabilizers by in silico molecular docking,molecular dynamics,and binding free energy calculations

Microtubule stabilizers provide an important mode of treatment via mitotic cell arrest of cancer cells. Recently, we reported two novel neolignans derivatives Cmp10 and Cmp19 showing anticancer activity and working as microtubule stabilizers at micromolar concentrations. In this study, we have explored the binding site, mode of binding, and stabilization by two novel microtubule stabilizers Cmp10 and Cmp19 using in silico molecular docking, molecular dynamics (MD) simulation, and binding free energy calculations. Molecular docking studies were performed to explore the β-tubulin binding site of Cmp10 and Cmp19. Further, MD simulations were used to probe the β-tubulin stabilization mechanism by Cmp10 and Cmp19. Binding affinity was also compared for Cmp10 and Cmp19 using binding free energy calculations. Our docking results revealed that both the compounds bind at Ptxl binding site in β-tubulin. MD simulation studies showed that Cmp10 and Cmp19 binding stabilizes M-loop (Phe272-Val288) residues of β-tubulin and prevent its dynamics, leading to a better packing between α and β subunits from adjacent tubulin dimers. In addition, His229, Ser280 and Gln281, and Arg278, Thr276, and Ser232 were found to be the key amino acid residues forming H-bonds with Cmp10 and Cmp19, respectively. Consequently, binding free energy calculations indicated that Cmp10 (?113.655 kJ/mol) had better binding compared to Cmp19 (?95.216 kJ/mol). This study provides useful insight for better understanding of the binding mechanism of Cmp10 and Cmp19 and will be helpful in designing novel microtubule stabilizers.     

The physical basis of microtubule structure and stability

Microtubules are cylindrical polymers found in every eukaryotic cell. They have a unique helical structure that has implications at both the cellular level, in terms of the functions they perform, and at the multicellular level, such as determining the left-right symmetry in plants. Through the combination of an atomically detailed model for a microtubule and large-scale computational techniques for computing electrostatic interactions, we are able to explain the observed microtubule structure. On the basis of the lateral interactions between protofilaments, we have determined that B lattice is the most favorable configuration. Further, we find that these lateral bonds are significantly weaker than the longitudinal bonds along protofilaments. This explains observations of microtubule disassembly and may serve as another step toward understanding the basis for dynamic instability.     

Analysis of the Strength of Interfacial Hydrogen Bonds between Tubulin Dimers Using Quantum Theory of Atoms in Molecules

Microtubules are key structural elements that, among numerous biological functions, maintain the cytoskeleton of the cell and have a major role in cell division, which makes them important cancer chemotherapy targets. Understanding the energy balance that brings tubulin dimers, the building blocks of microtubules, together to form a microtubule is especially important for revealing the mechanism of their dynamic instability. Several studies have been conducted to estimate various contributions to the free energy of microtubule formation. However, the hydrogen-bond contribution was not studied before as a separate component. In this work, we use concepts such as the quantum theory of atoms in molecules to estimate the per-residue strength of hydrogen bonds contributing to the overall stability that brings subunits together in pair of tubulin heterodimers, across both the longitudinal and lateral interfaces. Our study shows that hydrogen bonding plays a major role in the stability of tubulin systems. Several residues that are crucial to the binding of vinca alkaloids are shown to be strongly involved in longitudinal microtubule stabilization. This indicates a direct relation between the binding of these agents and the effect on the interfacial hydrogen-bonding network, and explains the mechanism of their action. Lateral contacts showed much higher stability than longitudinal ones (–462 ± 70 vs. –392 ± 59 kJ/mol), which suggests a dramatic lateral stabilization effect of the GTP cap in the β-subunit. The role of the M-loop in lateral stability in absence of taxol was shown to be minor. The B-lattice lateral hydrogen bonds are shown to be comparable in strength to the A-lattice ones (−462 ± 70 vs. –472 ± 46 kJ/mol). These findings establish the importance of hydrogen bonds to the stability of tubulin systems.     

Microtubules switch occasionally into unfavorable configurations during elongation

Tubulin assembles to form a range of structures that differ by their protofilament and monomer helix-start numbers. The microtubule lattice is believed to accommodate these different configurations by skewing the protofilaments so that the lateral interactions between tubulin subunits are maintained. Here, we present the characterization of 14 types of microtubules, including six novel ones, through an extensive analysis of microtubules assembled in vitro from pure tubulin. Although the six new types represented only 1 % of the total length of the population examined ( approximately 17 mm), they define the limits of microtubule structure and assembly. Protofilament skewing is restricted to within +/-2 degrees. Outside this range, the restoring force induced by the skewed protofilaments is compensated by a longitudinal shift (less than +/-0.2 nm) between adjacent protofilaments. Configurations with theoretical protofilament skew angles larger than +/-4 degrees or that necessitate larger modifications of the microtubule surface lattice were not observed. Analysis of the microtubule types distribution reveals that it is sharply peaked around the less skewed conformations. These results indicate that both the flexibility of the protofilaments and the strength of their lateral interactions restrict the range of structures assembled. They also demonstrate that growing microtubules can occasionally switch into energetically unfavorable configurations, a behavior that may account for the stochastic nature of catastrophes.     

C-Terminal Tail Polyglycylation and Polyglutamylation Alter Microtubule Mechanical Properties

Microtubules are biopolymers that perform diverse cellular functions. Microtubule behavior regulation occurs in part through post-translational modification of both the α- and β-subunits of tubulin. One class of modifications is the heterogeneous addition of glycine and/or glutamate residues to the disordered C-terminal tails (CTTs) of tubulin. Because of their prevalence in stable, high-stress cellular structures such as cilia, we sought to determine if these modifications alter microtubules’ intrinsic stiffness. Here, we describe the purification and characterization of differentially modified pools of tubulin from Tetrahymena thermophila. We found that post-translational modifications do affect microtubule stiffness but do not affect the number of protofilaments incorporated into microtubules. We measured the spin dynamics of nuclei in the CTT backbone by NMR spectroscopy to explore the mechanism of this change. Our results show that the α-tubulin CTT does not protrude out from the microtubule surface, as is commonly depicted in models, but instead interacts with the dimer’s surface. This suggests that the interactions of the α-tubulin CTT with the tubulin body contributes to the stiffness of the assembled microtubule, thus providing insight into the mechanism by which polyglycylation and polyglutamylation can alter microtubule mechanical properties.     

A unique mode of microtubule stabilization induced by peloruside A

Microtubules are significant therapeutic targets for the treatment of cancer, where suppression of microtubule dynamicity by drugs such as paclitaxel forms the basis of clinical efficacy. Peloruside A, a macrolide isolated from New Zealand marine sponge Mycale hentscheli, is a microtubule-stabilizing agent that synergizes with taxoid drugs through a unique site and is an attractive lead compound in the development of combination therapies. We report here unique allosteric properties of microtubule stabilization via peloruside A and present a structural model of the peloruside-binding site. Using a strategy involving comparative hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry of different microtubule-stabilizing agents, we suggest that taxoid-site ligands epothilone A and docetaxel stabilize microtubules primarily through improved longitudinal interactions centered on the interdimer interface, with no observable contributions from lateral interactions between protofilaments. The mode by which peloruside A achieves microtubule stabilization also involves the interdimer interface, but includes contributions from the α/β-tubulin intradimer interface and protofilament contacts, both in the form of destabilizations. Using data-directed molecular docking simulations, we propose that peloruside A binds within a pocket on the exterior of β-tubulin at a previously unknown ligand site, rather than on α-tubulin as suggested in earlier studies.     

Microtubule structure at improved resolution.

Microtubule architecture can vary with eukaryotic species, with different cell types, and with the presence of stabilizing agents. For in vitro assembled microtubules, the average number of protofilaments is reduced by the presence of sarcodictyin A, epothilone B, and eleutherobin (similarly to taxol) but increased by taxotere. Assembly with a slowly hydrolyzable GTP analogue GMPCPP is known to give 96% 14 protofilament microtubules. We have used electron cryomicroscopy and helical reconstruction techniques to obtain three-dimensional maps of taxotere and GMPCPP microtubules incorporating data to 14 A resolution. The dimer packing within the microtubule wall is examined by docking the tubulin crystal structure into these improved microtubule maps. The docked tubulin and simulated images calculated from "atomic resolution" microtubule models show tubulin heterodimers are aligned head to tail along the protofilaments with the beta subunit capping the microtubule plus end. The relative positions of tubulin dimers in neighboring protofilaments are the same for both types of microtubule, confirming that conserved lateral interactions between tubulin subunits are responsible for the surface lattice accommodation observed for different microtubule architectures. Microtubules with unconventional protofilament numbers that exist in vivo are likely to have the same surface lattice organizations found in vitro. A curved "GDP" tubulin conformation induced by stathmin-like proteins appears to weaken lateral contacts between tubulin subunits and could block microtubule assembly or favor disassembly. We conclude that lateral contacts between tubulin subunits in neighboring protofilaments have a decisive role for microtubule stability, rigidity, and architecture.     

Different protofilament-dependence of the microtubule binding between MAP2 and MAP4

To see a molecular basis of the difference in the microtubule binding between MAP2 and MAP4, we compared the binding of them onto microtubule and Zinc-sheet in the presence of various concentrations of NaCl. The Zinc-sheet is the lateral association of protofilaments arranged in an antiparallel fashion with alternatively exposed opposite surfaces, so that binding requiring adjacent protofilaments is restricted. While the salt-dependence of the MAP2 desorption was not altered between these tubulin polymers, MAP4 dissociated from Zinc-sheet at lower concentrations of NaCl than from microtubule. These results suggest that single protofilament is sufficient for microtubule binding of MAP2 as observed by Al-Bassam et al. [J. Cell Biol. 157 (2002) 1187], but MAP4 appeared to interact with adjacent protofilaments during microtubule-binding. Weakened binding on Zinc-sheets was also observed in the projection domain-deletion mutants of MAP4, so that the difference in the protofilament-dependence would lie in the relatively conserved microtubule-binding domain.     

Diameters of microtubules change during rotation of the lipotubuloids of Ornithogalum umbellatum stipule epidermis as a result of varying protofilament monomers sizes and distance between them

Microtubules in lipotubuloids of the Ornithogalum umbellatum stipule epidermis cells change their diameters depending on the motion of the cytoplasmic domains rich in microtubules and lipid bodies. Microtubules fixed during rotary and progressive motion of the lipotubuloids composed of the same number of protofilaments fall into two populations – wide (43–58 nm) and narrow (24–39 nm) in size. Following blockage of the motion with 2,4-dinitrophenol (DNP), the range of this diversity is smaller, microtubules become a medium-sized population (34–48 nm). When DNP is removed and the motion reactivated, 2 populations of microtubules reappear. Analysis of the structure of the microtubule wall revealed that changes in the microtubule diameters resulted from varying distances between the adjacent protofilaments, and stretching and compression of tubulin subunits in the protofilaments.A supposition has been put forward that the changes in the sizes of O. umbellatum microtubule diameters: 1) are connected with the interactions between microtubules and actin microfilaments lying along these microtubules; 2) can be the driving force of the rotary motion of lipotubuloids.     

Microtubules with different diameter, protofilament number and protofilament spacing in Ornithogalum umbellatum ovary epidermis cells

Microtubules present in the epidermis of Ornithogalum umbellatum ovary in the area of lipotubuloids (i.e. aggregates of lipid bodies surrounded by microtubules) are 25-51 nm in diameter. They consist mainly of 10 and 11, sometimes 9 and 12 protofilaments. An average diameter of microtubule consisting of 9 subunits is about 32 nm, of 10-35 nm, of 11-38 nm and of 12-43 nm, however, individual microtubules in each category significantly vary in size. These differences result from varying distance between protofilaments in microtubule walls and diameters of protofilaments: in thin microtubules they are densely packed and smaller while in thicker ones they are loosely arranged and bigger. A hypothesis has been put forward that changes in microtubule diameter depend on structural changes associated with their functional status and are executed by modifications of protofilament arrangement density and their diameters in microtubule wall. The above hypothesis seems to be in agreement with the opinion formed on the basis of in vitro image of microtubules, that lateral contact between tubulin subunits in neighboring protofilaments indicates some flexibility and changeability during microtubule function.     

The minimum GTP cap required to stabilize microtubules

Background: Microtubules polymerized from pure tubulin show the unusual property of dynamic instability, in which both growing and shrinking polymers coexist at steady state. Shortly after its addition to a microtubule end, a tubulin subunit hydrolyzes its bound GTP. Studies with non-hydrolyzable analogs have shown that GTP hydrolysis is not required for microtubule assembly, but is essential for generating a dynamic polymer, in which the subunits at the growing tip have bound GTP and those in the bulk of the polymer have bound GDP. It has been suggested that loss of the ‘GTP cap’ through dissociation or hydrolysis exposes the unstable GDP core, leading to rapid depolymerization. However, evidence for a stabilizing cap has been very difficult to obtain.Results We developed an assay to determine the minimum GTP cap necessary to stabilize a microtubule from shrinking. Assembly of a small number of subunits containing a slowly hydrolyzed GTP analog (GMPCPP) onto the end of dynamic microtubules stabilized the polymer to dilution. By labeling the subunits with rhodamine, we measured the size of the cap and found that as few as 40 subunits were sufficient to stabilize a microtubule.Conclusion On the basis of statistical arguments, in which the proportion of stabilized microtubules is compared to the probability that when 40 GMPCPP-tubulin subunits have polymerized onto a microtubule end, all protofilaments have added at least one GMPCPP-tubulin subunit, our measurements of cap size support a model in which a single GTP subunit at the end of each of the 13 protofilaments of a microtubule is sufficient for stabilization. Depolymerization of a microtubule may be initiated by an exposed tubulin–GDP subunit at even a single position. These results have implications for the structure of microtubules and their means of regulation.     

Taxol allosterically alters the dynamics of the tubulin dimer and increases the flexibility of microtubules

Taxol is a commonly used antitumor agent that hyperstabilizes microtubules and prevents cell division. The interaction of Taxol with tubulin and the microtubule has been studied through a wide array of experimental techniques; however, the exact molecular mechanism by which Taxol stabilizes microtubules has remained elusive. In this study, through the use of large-scale molecular simulations, we show that Taxol affects the interactions between the M and H1-S2 loops of adjacent tubulin dimers leading to more stable interprotofilament interactions. More importantly, we demonstrate that Taxol binding leads to a significant increase in the dynamics and flexibility of the portion of β-tubulin that surrounds the bound nucleotide and makes contact with the α-monomer of the next dimer in the protofilament. We conclude that this increase in flexibility allows the microtubule to counteract the conformational changes induced by nucleotide hydrolysis and keeps the protofilaments in a straight conformation, resulting in a stable microtubule.     

Effects of C7 substitutions in a high affinity microtubule-binding taxane on antitumor activity and drug transport

Some C-7 modified analogs of 3, a taxane with high affinity for binding to microtubules, were prepared through multistep transformations. Most of the analogs, bearing less lipophilic C-7 substituents than propionyl in 3, exhibited comparable binding affinities to microtubules but less cytotoxicity against drug-sensitive as well as multidrug-resistant tumor cells overexpressing P-glycoprotein. In addition, these C7 modifications increased P-glycoprotein-mediated drug transport in both directions in a Caco-2 cell assay.     

Tau protein binding forms a 1 nm thick layer along protofilaments without affecting the radial elasticity of microtubules

Tau is one of the most abundant microtubule-associated proteins involved in kinetic stabilization and bundling of axonal microtubules. Although intense research has revealed much about tau function and its involvement in Alzheimer's disease during the past years, it still remains unclear how exactly tau binds on microtubules and if the kinetic stabilization of microtubules by tau is accompanied, at least in part, by a mechanical reinforcement of microtubules. In this paper, we have used atomic force microscopy to address both aspects by visualizing and mechanically analyzing microtubules in the presence of native tau isoforms. We could show that tau at saturating concentrations forms a 1 nm thick layer around the microtubule, but leaves the protofilament structure well visible. The latter observation argues for tau binding mainly along and not across the protofilaments. The radial elasticity of microtubules was almost unaffected by tau, consistent with tau binding along the tops of the protofilaments. Tau did increase the resistance of microtubules against rupture. Finite-element calculations confirmed our findings.